« February 2010 | Main | April 2010 »

March 31, 2010

US lawyer wants to question pope on child sex cases

KENTUCKY
AFP

WASHINGTON — A US lawyer has filed a legal motion to have Pope Benedict XVI questioned over the child sex scandal that is rocking the Roman Catholic church, he told AFP Wednesday.

Lawyer William McMurry filed a motion in a Kentucky court Tuesday seeking to take sworn testimony from the pope on what the Vatican knew about the long-running scandal of predator priests.

The motion, a copy of which was sent to AFP, says Benedict was aware of clergy sex abuse in the United States and that he "discouraged prosecution of accused clergy and encouraged secrecy to protect the reputation of the Church" in the 24 years that he led the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:53 PM

The Catholic Church has forfeited its soul

Pique Newsmagazine

By Jesse Ferreras

Satan is taking names at Hell's VIP party. Next to pass the velvet rope is Pope Benedict XVI.

The New York Times reported last week that Joseph Ratzinger was once in a position to stop the sexual abuse of children at a Wisconsin school for the deaf. Evidence abounds that a case of abuse once came before him and he did nothing to address it.

Father Lawrence Murphy took up a position as chaplain at St. John's School for the Deaf in 1950. The first reports of his abuse came as early as 1955, when they were reported to David Walsh, chaplain of the deaf in Chicago from 1955 to 1963. They were reported to the Archbishop of Milwaukee, who said Murphy first denied, then admitted to the abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:48 PM

Levada takes on the Times

SAN FRANCISCO (CA)
San Francisco Bay Guardian

Cardinal William Levada, former archbishop of San Francisco Catholic Archdiocese of San Francisco, has penned a caustic response to recent New York Times articles and editorials that were critical of how the church and Pope Benedict XVI have handled sexual abuse cases involving priests over the years, calling the coverage “deficient by any reasonable standards of fairness that Americans have every right and expectation to find in their major media reporting.”

This bold, Spiro Agnew-like counterattack on the press during a time of mounting evidence of a covered-up pedophilia epidemic in the church is all the more notable given that Levada is the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, an office then-Cardinal Ratzinger held before becoming Pope Benedict XVI, helping to place that office in charge of all reports of pedophiliac priests, a move that critics have charged was made to shield the church from criticism.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:45 PM

How Vatican Tries to Dodge Legal Fallout of Sex Abuse

KENTUCKY
AOL News

Dana Kennedy

(March 31) -- Developments in a Kentucky court case suggest that the Vatican will seek to shield Pope Benedict XVI and the church from liability in the worldwide clerical sex abuse crisis by distancing itself from individual dioceses.

In legal documents filed in U.S. District Court in Louisville last week, the Vatican claims that as the head of a sovereign state, the Vatican City, the pope is immune from prosecution. The papers further assert that American bishops are not employed by the Holy See.

The Vatican will also likely deny that a 1962 church decree about clergy and the reporting of clerical pedophilia is a "smoking gun" that led to a worldwide cover-up of sexual crimes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:42 PM

Group Says McCann Should Have Prosecuted Priest

MILWAUKEE (WI)
WUWM

By Marti Mikkelson
March 31, 2010 | WUWM | Milwaukee, WI

An advocacy group for victims of clergy abuse says former Milwaukee District Attorney E. Michael McCann knew that a priest was molesting boys, and didn't file charges. Peter Isely, of the group Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, says the Rev. Lawrence Murphy admitted to the Archdiocese in 1958 that he was assaulting kids at the School for the Deaf in St. Francis. He says students brought their cases to McCann in 1974 and claims the district attorney helped the Archdiocese cover up the scandal.

"The church and him shared in my opinion a common understanding that priests don't get prosecuted," Isely says.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:36 PM

Catholics rue sex scandal, but hands off the pope

SOUTH AFRICA
Times LIVE

Mar 31, 2010

Fr Chris Townsend, Southern African Catholic Bishops Conference:

THE crisis facing the Roman Catholic Church around the world is grave. It points to two major failures: a failure to protect the vulnerable and a failure of leadership.

The Catholic Church in southern Africa has had a process in place for the past 15 years to deal with complaints of sexual abuse of minors by church personnel.

In all our efforts, particularly in the past five years, those responsible for dealing with such complaints have a clear process that ensures these two major failings are minimised.

I do not claim the process is perfect, but it is under constant review and revision to ensure accusations of cover-ups and the double abuse of victims doesn't happen.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:32 PM

Will the Pope Be Deposed? Not If the Vatican Can Help It

UNITED STATES
The Wall Street Journal

By Ashby Jones
On Monday, we blogged an Associated Press story on Jeff Anderson, the man behind many of the suits filed against members of the Catholic Church over allegations of sexual abuse by priests and other church leaders.

Today, it seems, it’s the Vatican’s turn. An AP story takes a look at the Holy See’s planned legal defense. The specific goal of the defense: to keep the pope from having to be deposed in a lawsuit going on in Kentucky.

According to the AP, Vatican lawyers plan to argue:

that the pope has immunity as a head of state;
that American bishops who oversaw abusive priests weren’t employees of the Vatican,
that a 1962 document is not the “smoking gun” that provides proof of a cover-up.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:27 PM

U.S. Bishops Quietly Reinstate Accused Priests

UNITED STATES
NPR

[with audio]

by Barbara Bradley Hagerty

While the Roman Catholic sexual abuse scandal unfolds in Europe, the Catholic Church in the U.S. is under renewed scrutiny.

In the wake of its own scandal almost a decade ago, the U.S. church says it has reformed its policies for handling sexual abuse allegations and will remove from ministry every priest who is credibly accused of abuse.

But some of those priests are now being quietly reinstated. ...

Swearingen's case is not an isolated one, says Anne Barrett Doyle, who works with the watchdog group BishopAccountability.org. She says that recently, bishops have started quietly returning to ministry priests who previously have been accused of abuse.

"I think they feel that the crisis has died down in the public mind," she says. "Therefore, they have some confidence that if they go ahead and reinstate these priests, that they'll get very little backlash."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:22 PM

Fairness for the Pope: Pontiff not at fault in Wisconsin pedophile priest case

NEW YORK
New York Daily News

Wednesday, March 31st 2010

It has become an increasingly prevailing belief that as a cardinal, before he ascended to the papacy, Pope Benedict enabled a pedophile priest to do enormous harm. This is false.

New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd took the accusations against the Pope, whose given name is Joseph Ratzinger, to their most extreme. She wrote:

"Now we learn the sickening news that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, nicknamed 'God's Rottweiler' when he was the church's enforcer on matters of faith and sin, ignored repeated warnings and looked away in the case of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, a Wisconsin priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:05 PM

New York Daily News urges ‘Fairness for the Pope’

NEW YORK
Catholic News Agency

New York City, N.Y., Mar 31, 2010 / 02:33 pm (CNA).- Reacting to the slew of articles from media outlets attempting to incriminate Pope Benedict in past clerical sex abuse cases, the New York Daily News published an editorial today calling for a fair analysis of the facts about the Pope’s involvement with such cases.

Using extremely direct diction, the Daily News’ editorial states that “with certainty,” the belief that Pope Benedict enabled a pedophile priest to inflict great harm is “false.”

The editorial then refers to a recent column by the New York Times’ Maureen Dowd, stating that she “took the accusations against the Pope, whose given name is Joseph Ratzinger, to their most extreme.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:00 PM

Pressure Mounts For Pope Amid Abuse Revelations

ITALY
WBUR (United States)

By Sylvia Poggioli
March 31, 2010

As the faithful fill churches during Holy Week, a wave of clerical sex abuse revelations is sweeping Europe. The latest allegations come from Italy, just outside Vatican walls.

As the scandal mounts, Pope Benedict XVI is under increasing pressure to give a more forceful response to the most serious crisis of his papacy.

Following weeks of media coverage of sex abuse by priests in the United States, Ireland and Germany, three deaf men from Italy appeared on national TV last week.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:57 PM

Sinead O’Connor Calls for Catholic Boycott

IRELAND
The New York Times

[with video]

By ROBERT MACKEY

Nearly two decades after the Irish singer Sinead O’Connor tore up a photograph of Pope John Paul II on “Saturday Night Live,” to protest what she said was the Vatican’s responsibility for child abuse, she has called on fellow Irish Catholics to boycott the church until Pope Benedict XVI makes “a full confession” and agrees to “a full criminal investigation” of the church’s role in concealing the sexual abuse of children by members of the clergy.

First in a statement on her Web site, then in an op-ed piece for The Washington Post and in interviews with The Los Angeles Times, the BBC and CNN, Ms. O’Connor rejected the pope’s pastoral letter to the Irish people as “an insult” and suggested that “the goodhearted, sweet Catholic people who go to Mass still despite all of this” could force the Vatican into giving a more complete account of its role by employing a tactic with Irish roots: a boycott.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:48 PM

Learning From the Vatican's Problems: What the U.S. Must Do to Protect Children Now

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Marci Hamilton

In the last several weeks, Germany and Brazil have been added to the already lengthy list of countries where there is irrefutable evidence of childhood sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clergy. The Pope, whose previous role in the Vatican made him the primary policymaker on this issue, has even been implicated in the persistent, global pattern of abuse -- most recently in a case involving hundreds of deaf boys in Wisconsin. Moreover, there now appears to be overwhelming evidence that Benedict, as the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, was aware of hundreds -- if not thousands -- of other especially heinous cases of abusive priests who were allowed to continue pastoring despite proof of their horrific actions and went on to victimize more children. And, in 2001, in what many are now calling nothing short of an obstruction of justice, he issued a definitive letter requiring that the handling of child sexual abuse issues be under the "pontifical secret."

Yet, the Pope's responses lag well behind the world's demands for accountability; last weekend, as the crisis continued to spiral across Europe, he offered a written apology in response to the months-long crisis in Ireland. Yet, he remains mute on Germany, his own home country, and on Brazil, where the evidence of abuse has been caught on tape. The Catholic system, though, does not permit the Pope to be removed from office without his assent. So if countries are to protect their children, they will have to take action on their own.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:43 PM

Denmark's Catholic Church to investigate abuse cases dating back decades

DENMARK
The Canadian Press

By Richard Steed (CP)

COPENHAGEN, Denmark — Denmark's Catholic Church will launch an investigation next week into claims of clerical abuse dating back several decades, a spokesman said Wednesday.

The move comes after the church came under pressure from media and human rights groups to revisit allegations of sexual abuse that had not been reported to police.

Claims that priests sexually abused children at Catholic institutions have swept across Europe, including in the small Catholic communities in the Nordic countries, which are predominantly Lutheran.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:40 PM

This 'Blame The Gays' Defense Of The Vatican Basically Makes No Sense At All

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Jason Linkins

In case you missed it, the novel defense of the Catholic Church being mounted by Bill Donohue of the Catholic League over the whole matter of Vatican officials covering up the crimes of a Wisconsin priest who molested upwards of 200 deaf boys is to blame the gays. Wow: first the gays get blamed for the massacre at Srebrenica, now this!

Here's the relevant quote from Donohue, from a full-page ad taken out in the New York Times:

The Times continues to editorialize about the "pedophilia crisis," when all along it's been a homosexual crisis. Eighty percent of the victims of priestly sexual abuse are male and most of them are post-pubescent. While homosexuality does not cause predatory behavior, and most gay priests are not molesters, most of the molesters have been gay.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:37 PM

Catholic League head: Abuse not pedophilia because boys were ‘post-pubescent’

UNITED STATES
Raw Story

By Daniel Tencer
Wednesday, March 31st, 2010

The head of the influential Catholic League says that the priest who allegedly sexually abused 200 deaf boys in Wisconsin did not engage in pedophilia because 'the vast majority of the victims [were] post-pubescent."

Bill Donohue made the argument during a raucous debate on Larry King Live Tuesday night, during which he repeatedly pointed the finger to homosexuality -- rather than pedophilia -- as the cause of the church's sex abuse problems.

"You've got to get your facts straight," Donohue said, addressing sex abuse victim Thomas Roberts. "I'm sorry. If I'm the only one that's going to deal with facts tonight then that'll be it. The vast majority of the victims are post-pubescent. That's not pedophilia, buddy. That's homosexuality."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:33 PM

Group: Milwaukee Ex-DA Should Have Charged Priest

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Channel 3000

MILWAUKEE -- The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests is renewing its claims that Milwaukee prosecutors should have charged a priest accused of sexually assaulting hundreds of deaf boys between 1950 and 1974.

The man who was the prosecutor at the time says he had no choice. E. Michael McCann said the crimes were reported after the six-year statute of limitations had lapsed.

But SNAP spokesman Peter Isely disagreed Wednesday. He said one victim found a letter he says he submitted to McCann's office in 1974. It details abuse from four years earlier.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:24 PM

Group: Milwaukee Ex-DA Should Have Charged Priest

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Channel 3000

MILWAUKEE -- The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests is renewing its claims that Milwaukee prosecutors should have charged a priest accused of sexually assaulting hundreds of deaf boys between 1950 and 1974.

The man who was the prosecutor at the time says he had no choice. E. Michael McCann said the crimes were reported after the six-year statute of limitations had lapsed.

But SNAP spokesman Peter Isely disagreed Wednesday. He said one victim found a letter he says he submitted to McCann's office in 1974. It details abuse from four years earlier.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:24 PM

Pope John Paul II's Path to Sainthood Now in Doubt

AOL News

Dana Kennedy

(March 30) -- To many, the charismatic Pope John Paul II represented much that is lacking in the dour, scholarly Pope Benedict XVI, who was once nicknamed "the Rottweiler" and is under worldwide siege for the child sex abuse scandals sweeping the Roman Catholic Church.

But even as more questions swirl around Benedict and his alleged role in the cover-ups of pedophile priests, John Paul's stellar reputation is suddenly taking a subtle beating.

A miracle ascribed to John Paul that is a prerequisite for his canonization has been questioned, and one of church's highest-ranking officials has said that John Paul ignored Benedict's pleas to mount a full investigation into sex abuse accusations against the archbishop of Vienna.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:21 PM

1963 letter shows former pope knew of abuse

LOS ANGELES (CA)
TBO

By GILLIAN FLACCUS
Associated Press Writer

LOS ANGELES (AP) -- A newly released letter to then-Pope Paul VI indicates the Vatican was aware of clergy abuse in the U.S. nearly five decades ago.

In the 1963 letter released Wednesday, the head of a Roman Catholic order that oversaw treatment of pedophile priests tells the pope he recommends removing pedophile priests from active ministry.

The letter is a summary of the Rev. Gerald M.C. Fitzgerald's thoughts on problem priests that appears to have been requested by the pope after Fitzgerald's 1963 visit to the Vatican. Fitzgerald headed the New Mexico-based Servants of the Holy Paracletes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:18 PM

THANK YOU, CARDINAL RATZINGER

LOS ANGELES (CA)
Cardinal Mahony Blogs LA

While I have no personal information on some of the specific allegations against our Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, when he served the Church of Munich in Germany, I am able to assert without hesitation the action steps which he undertook in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith when he served as Prefect of that Congregation.

Beginning in that dark year of 2002, the then Cardinal Ratzinger responded quickly and affirmatively to all of our requests for assistance here in the United States.

Recall that Canon 1324, par. 4, states that in Canon Law a minor is a person under the age of 16 years. However, in the civil laws of the United States, a minor is deemed to be a person under the age of 18 years. After we brought this gap to the attention of Cardinal Ratzinger, the canonical age was also raised to 18 years to accommodate civil law in our country and in other countries.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:10 PM

Pedophile Priests and the Challenge to Catholic Authority

UNITED STATES
KCRW

{with audio]

The worldwide scandal of pedophile priests has reached into the Vatican. Lay Catholics are asking the Pope himself to reveal what he knew, when he knew it and how he responded. We look at the details in the context of 2000 years of institutional history. Also, the Obama Administration clears way for expanded offshore drilling, and a committee of Parliament says the Special Relationship between Britain and the US is a thing of the past.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:07 PM

Former Upland priest leaves Airzona Air Force base after complaints

CALIFORNIA
Contra Costa Times

Sandra Emerson, Staff Writer

UPLAND - A priest formerly assigned to St. Anthony's Church in Upland recently started work at an Air Force base in Arizona, causing some to rehash complaints of the past.

He has been released within the past week due to contractual restrictions, according to an Air Force spokesman, not because of present or past complaints.

The Rev. Charles Schultz resigned from the Diocese of San Bernardino in June after parishioners filed complaints with the Upland Police Department and the diocese's human- resources department.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:01 PM

Brady meets clerical abuse survivors

IRELAND
The Irish Times

Gerry Moriarty, Northern Editor in Armagh

Cardinal Sean Brady has expressed support for the concept of a national inquiry into clerical child sex abuse, according to survivors of clerical abuse and their representatives who met him in Armagh City today.

The victims and the representatives variously said that the meetings were useful, frank, positive and at times "emotional" and "uncomfortable". Various views were expressed during and after the meetings at the Catholic primate's residence beside St Patrick's Cathedral with some maintaining he should resign and others saying he is now a "lame duck Cardinal".

Cardinal Brady requested the meetings following from the continuing disclosures about clerical abuse, the recent pastoral letter about the abuse from Pope Benedict XVI and from the criticism of the primate's failure to notify the Gardai of allegations of sex abuse against two children made to him when he was a priest in 1975.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:35 PM

US bishops back the Pope; SNAP responds

UNITED STATES
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by Peter Isely, Midwest Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (414-429-7259)

America's bishops have joined the "circle the wagons" chorus, more intent on protecting prelates' reputations than on protecting children's safety.

Instead of exposing predators and helping victims, America's bishops busy themselves with self-congratulations and public relations. They tout their plentiful but largely ineffective policies, panels and procedures which were adopted as public relations moves. Since 2002, they have done little but water down and increasingly ignore their pledges of greater openness, confident that 'the wave has crested' and they have little to fear from more victims, lawsuits, prosecutions or media exposes.

Once again, bishops still refuse to use the words "bishop" or "cover up" when talking about a crisis caused by bishops covering up. This statement, like so many others, tries to minimize this crisis, blaming only the predators and ignoring their corrupt supervisors.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:32 PM

Clergy sex victims release more church records

LOS ANGELES (CA)
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

What
Holding signs and child hood photos at a sidewalk news conference, clergy sex abuse victims will release a dozen pages of once secret church records proving that the Pope and other top Catholic officials – in Rome and here - knew much about pedophile priests even decades ago. ...

When
Wednesday, March 31 at 11:00 a.m.

Where
Outside Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels, 555 W. Temple St. (at N. Grand Ave.) in Los Angeles ...

Why
Newly released records, including letters to the Vatican in the 1960s, show a Catholic official admitting a “tremendous problem” of predator priests. The documents prove that almost 50 years ago, top church staff knew how widespread and incorrigible pedophiles are. They severely undercut recent claims by the Pope’s defenders that he and others in the church hierarchy mishandled cases because they were “on a learning curve.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:28 PM

The Pope’s pedophilic church

UNITED STATES
Bay Windows

by Rev. Irene Monroe
Bay Windows Contributor
Wednesday Mar 31, 2010

Who among us would not flinch at the thought of a "holy man" preying on children instead of praying with them?

What faith can anyone have in a Church that says it stands on the teachings of Jesus, yet violates his biblical mandate stated in Mark 10:14: "Let the children come to me; do not try to stop them; for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these."

When you have a pope more invested in doctrinal debates than personal suffering, and he’s more invested in exerting his ecclesiastical power and defrocking dissident theologians than his priestly flock of sex predators, then it’s easy to comprehend why the pleas and petitions for decades from Catholic parishioners -- worldwide -- to Pope Benedict XVI to do something never happened.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:25 PM

Pope Benedict's 'friend' accused of hitting children with carpet beater at Catholic orphanage

GERMANY
Mail (United Kingdom)

By Allan Hall
Last updated at 8:06 PM on 31st March 2010

The Catholic Church abuse scandal in Germany moved closer to the Vatican today with claims of violence against both boys and girls committed by a friend and ally of Pope Benedict XVI.

Bishop Walter Mixa of Augsburg - appointed by the pope in 2005 - is accused of the systematic beating of children in his care when he oversaw a Catholic orphanage 30 years ago.

The Bishop, a controversial figure who tried to explain away rampant paedophilia in the Church by claiming the sexual liberation movement must share a 'significant' part of the blame, is accused of using a carpet beater on the bare behinds of victims as he screamed: 'Satan is in you and I must drive him out.'

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:21 PM

Vatican to AP: Pope sees sex abuse crisis as test

VATICAN CITY
Washington Post

The Associated Press
Wednesday, March 31, 2010

VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican says Pope Benedict XVI sees the clerical abuse crisis as a "test for him and the church."

The Vatican spokseman, Rev. Federico Lombardi, told The Associated Press on Wednesday the pontiff is holding up well physically but is enduring a Holy Week of "penitence and humility."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:18 PM

Italian politicians rally to pope's defense

ITALY
Washington Post

By FRANCES D'EMILIO
The Associated Press
Wednesday, March 31, 2010

ROME -- Italy's foreign minister has rushed to Pope Benedict XVI's defense, while Italian newspapers labeled foreign media reports as "attacks" for questioning what the pontiff might have known about pedophile clergy.

Europe has been rocked in recent months by a flood of allegations of sexual abuse by Catholic priests, leading some rank-and-file Catholics to question the traditional chummy relationship between the Vatican and Italian institutions.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:15 PM

Vatican Official Defends Pope’s Handling of Case

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By RACHEL DONADIO
Published: March 31, 2010

ROME — The head of the Vatican’s doctrinal office sought Wednesday to rebut criticism that top Vatican officials, including the man who would become Pope Benedict XVI, had mishandled the case of a Wisconsin priest who sexually abused scores of deaf boys.

In a statement posted on the Vatican’s Web site, Cardinal William J. Levada, the prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, criticized an article in The New York Times that raised questions about why the Vatican had not defrocked the priest, Father Lawrence C. Murphy, despite calls for action on his case from American bishops.

“It seems to me, on the other hand, that we owe Pope Benedict a great debt of gratitude for introducing the procedures that have helped the Church to take action in the face of the scandal of priestly sexual abuse of minors,” Cardinal Levada wrote in the lengthy statement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:09 PM

The New York Times has seriously screwed up its coverage of the Pope and the child abus

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Damian Thompson

It’s pretty clear now that The New York Times has screwed up its coverage of Pope Benedict XVI and the child abuse scandals. In fact, I doubt it could have done a worse job if it had brought back Jayson Blair to report the story.

Cardinal William Levada, head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, this week laid into the NYT in Catholic San Francisco Online. I’m not a huge fan of Levada, and reckon he’ll be moving on shortly, but he’s spot on about the Old Gray Lady. So is Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York, who received a standing ovation in St Patrick’s Cathedral when, without mentioning the paper by name, he attacked it from the sanctuary on Sunday. Dolan long ago worked out that the NYT has an insidious anti-Catholic slant, and has not been afraid to say so in the past.

Meanwhile, I hope you’ve had a chance to read the devastating expose of the media’s methods by the canonical judge in charge of the Wisconsin case, which I reproduced in a blog post yesterday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:55 PM

Satan behind media attacks on the Pope, asserts Italian exorcist

ITALY
Catholic News Agency

Rome, Italy, Mar 31, 2010 / 11:47 am (CNA).- Noted Italian exorcist Father Gabriele Amorth, commented this week that the recent defamatory reporting on Pope Benedict XVI, especially by the New York Times, was “prompted by the devil.”

Speaking to News Mediaset in Italy, the 85-year-old exorcist noted that the devil is behind “the recent attacks on Pope Benedict XVI regarding some pedophilia cases.”

“There is no doubt about it. Because he is a marvelous Pope and worthy successor to John Paul II, it is clear that the devil wants to ‘grab hold’ of him.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:46 PM

Cardinal Levada to NY Times: Reconsider 'attack mode' against Pope Benedict

UNITED STATES
Catholic San Francisco

The New York Times and Pope Benedict XVI:
how it looks to an American in the Vatican

By Cardinal William J. Levada
Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

In our melting pot of peoples, languages and backgrounds, Americans are not noted as examples of “high” culture. But we can take pride as a rule in our passion for fairness. In the Vatican where I currently work, my colleagues – whether fellow cardinals at meetings or officials in my office – come from many different countries, continents and cultures. As I write this response today (March 26, 2010) I have had to admit to them that I am not proud of America’s newspaper of record, the New York Times, as a paragon of fairness.

I say this because today’s Times presents both a lengthy article by Laurie Goodstein, a senior columnist, headlined “Warned About Abuse, Vatican Failed to Defrock Priest,” and an accompanying editorial entitled “The Pope and the Pedophilia Scandal,” in which the editors call the Goodstein article a disturbing report (emphasis in original) as a basis for their own charges against the Pope. Both the article and the editorial are deficient by any reasonable standards of fairness that Americans have every right and expectation to find in their major media reporting.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:44 PM

Indonesian Catholics Prepare for Easter as Church Struggles with Scandal

INDONESIA
Jakarta Globe

More than seven million Indonesians are preparing to mark the Easter season, considered by many as the holiest period in the Catholic calendar.

Pope Benedict XVI opened Holy Week on Sunday amid a raging crisis facing not only the church but the pope himself over his handling of cases of pedophile priests when he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. ...

“The impact can be seen in the behavior of our priests. This has become a matter for reflection and a test of our commitment to serve,” he said.

“A lot of people from the communion have also asked us about this issue. This has seen the priests reflect on themselves, to make sure that they do not betray their people’s trust.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:41 PM

Says the judge: Priest was on trial the day he died

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Patrick McIlheran of the Journal Sentinel
March 31, 2010

Did the Vatican protect an old molesting priest? The canonical judge trying the priest says no.

The claim is that the man now Pope Benedict XVI in the 1990s "refused" to defrock the notorious Father Lawrence Murphy, who molested boys from the 1950s to 1974 at a school for the deaf in St. Francis.

This is the basis of the New York Times story of scandal over the past week. This is what made one protester in Milwaukee say the other day that "We're finally able to get it where we believe it belongs, and that's at the Vatican doorstep."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:38 PM

European bishops urge victims to go to the police

VATICAN CITY
Forbes

By NICOLE WINFIELD , 03.31.10

VATICAN CITY -- Swiss bishops urge victims of clerical abuse to file criminal complaints and are considering creating a national registry for pedophile priests. Danish bishops launch an investigation into decades-old claims. Austria's senior bishop celebrates a Holy Week Mass of repentance.

A week after Pope Benedict XVI excoriated Irish bishops for gross errors of judgment in handling cases of priests who sexually abuse children, European bishops are admitting to mistakes, reaching out to victims and promising to act quickly when they learn about abuse cases.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:35 PM

Cardinal Seán Brady meets with survivors of abuse in Armagh

IRELAND
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference

As part of an ongoing series of meetings between survivors of sexual abuse by clergy and Catholic Church representatives, Cardinal Seán Brady, Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland, today held meetings with survivors of abuse and with groups representing survivors.

The following meetings took place separately in Cardinal Brady’s home in Armagh:

9.30 am Mr John Kelly, Mr Patrick Walsh and Ms Marie Seo of Irish SOCA

11.30 am Mrs Marie and Mr Raymond Collins

3.00 pm Mr Michael O’Brien, Right to Peace and Mr Christopher Heaphy of Right of Place

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:32 PM

German bishop accused of hitting children with carpet beater

GERMANY
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

By Allan Hall in Berlin and Nick Pisa in Rome

Bishop Walter Mixa of Augsburg is facing claims he flogged and hit former pupils at a Catholic orphanage in Germany 30 years ago.

The Bishop, who was appointed by the Pope in 2005, is a controversial figure who has tried to explain paedophilia in the Church by claiming the sexual liberation movement must share a "significant" part of the blame.

He is accused of using a carpet beater on the bare skin of boys and girls as he screamed: "Satan is in you and I must drive him out."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:28 PM

The truth shall set us free: Responding to the sex abuse crisis

UNITED STATES
U.S. Catholic

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Anne M. Burke

In this excerpt of her March 23, 2010 talk at St. Xavier University in Chicago, Illinois Supreme Court Justice Anne M. Burke, who served on the National Review Board responding to the U.S. sex abuse scandal, lambasts those church officials who continue to betray the gospel by their untruthfulness in the clergy sex abuse scandals.

Forty years ago the Swiss theologian Hans Küng published his remarkable reflection on the future of the church called Truthfulness. Küng lamented that the exciting participation of the laity in the dialogue that was once so promising had come to be simply disregarded. He asked some pointed questions in light of the political maneuvering at the time by those opposed to artificial methods to prevent conception.

Truthfulness was Küng's look into the world that was yet to be, the one you and I are presently living in. He posited what was his deepest hope-an "unshakable hope," he called it-that the Catholic Church would emerge renewed even from the post-conciliar crisis.

I believe Küng and I appear to have come to the same point of conclusion, though largely from very different journeys. The conclusion is this: "Truthfulness is the future of the Church."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:23 PM

Abuse survivors tell Cardinal Brady to resign

IRELAND
The Times (United Kingdom)

Ruth Gledhill, Religion Correspondent

Survivors of sex abuse at the hands of Roman Catholic clergy told the head of the Church in Ireland today that he was a "lame duck cardinal" and should resign.

Overturning a centuries-old tradition of deference towards the Roman Catholic hierarchy in Ireland, victims confronted Cardinal Seán Brady with their stark judgment during a face-to-face meeting at his residence in Armagh.

They spared him most of the details of the torture they suffered at the hands of priests, including rape and beatings with metal straps that they had been forced to manufacture themselves in workshops.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:20 PM

Dissident Catholic Bishop Calls for Pope to Resign over Sex Abuse Scandal

AlterNet

March 31, 2010

Amy Goodman

Editor's Note: The Vatican has denied a series of media reports alleging that Pope Benedict, before being elected pontiff, may have looked the other way in cases of abuse in his native Germany and in the United States. Last week, the Vatican strongly defended its decision not to defrock the Wisconsin-based priest Father Lawrence Murphy, who abused some 200 deaf boys in the 1950s and ’60s. The National Catholic Reporter, perhaps the US's most influential Catholic publication, published a line-in-the-sand editorial saying the Pope must be ready to answer questions and called the scandal “the largest institutional crisis in centuries, possibly in church history":

The Holy Father needs to directly answer questions, in a credible forum, about his role -- as archbishop of Munich (1977-82), as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (1982-2005), and as pope (2005-present) -- in the mismanagement of the clergy sex abuse crisis.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:16 PM

Tyler Bishop Urges Congregation To Speak Out Against Sex Abuse

TYLER (TX)
Tyler Morning Telegraph

By MELISSA CROWE
Staff Writer

A Catholic Tyler bishop is urging his congregation to speak out against sexual abuse crimes.

Last week, Bishop Rev. Alvaro Corrada, of the Catholic Diocese of Tyler, issued a statement on his Web site concerning Cincinnati-based priest Father Robert Poandl's indictment on sexual abuse charges.

About a week ago, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) asked bishops, who are not Vatican employees, to use their diocesan Web sites, newspapers, employees, parish Web sites and parish bulletins to urge sexual abuse victims and witnesses to speak out against the crime.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:13 PM

POPE'S CRITICS LACK EVIDENCE

UNITED STATES
Catholic League

Catholic League president Bill Donohue comments on the latest falsehoods being told about the pope:

Much of the accusation against Pope Benedict XVI in the case of Wisconsin priest Fr. Lawrence Murphy rests on his alleged disinterest in pushing for Murphy to be defrocked. Contradicting this smear is the judge in the Murphy trial and the New York Times itself. ...

I challenge anyone to produce a single piece of evidence that the pope did anything wrong.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:10 PM

Enfant Terrible der katholischen Kirche

GERMANY
Spiegel

Von Carsten Volkery

Als konservative Reizfigur provoziert er seit Jahren, Mitschuld für den Kindesmissbrauch in der Kirche suchte er in der sexuellen Revolution. Nun erheben ehemalige Heimkinder Vorwürfe gegen den Augsburger Bischof Mixa - er soll sie als Pfarrer geprügelt haben.

In der katholischen Kirche spielt der Augsburger Bischof Walter Mixa seit Jahren die Rolle des Enfant Terrible. Er gefällt sich darin, gegen die Mehrheitsmeinung und liberale Tendenzen anzugehen. Es überraschte daher niemanden, als er kürzlich die Mitschuld für den Kindesmissbrauch in der Kirche ganz außerhalb des Klerus suchte.

Die "sogenannte sexuelle Revolution", verkündete Mixa, sei daran "sicher nicht unschuldig". Das klang so, als sei vor 1968 in der Kirche alles mit rechten Dingen zugegangen. Dabei zählen die fünfziger Jahre zu den dunkelsten Kapiteln in der Missbrauchssaga. Es war eine typische Mixa-Provokation, der gewünschte Proteststurm folgte auf dem Fuß. Selbst die "Bild"-Zeitung erklärte: "Murks, Herr Mixa".

[summary]

As a conservative figure, Bishop Walter Mixa of Augsburg has blamed child abuse in the church on the sexual revolution. Charges have now been brought against him by former children in care that he beat them when he was a pastor.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:00 PM

''Er hat mir mit voller Wucht ins Gesicht geschlagen''

GERMANY
Sueddeutsche

Von Stefan Mayr
Die Vorwürfe gegen Bischof Mixa reißen nicht ab. Eine weitere Betroffene meldet sich in der Süddeutschen Zeitung zu Wort und berichtet von brutalen Misshandlungen. Auch Klosterschwestern sollen daran beteiligt gewesen sein.

[summary]

A group of people who as children were in care have accused Augssburg Bishop Walter Mixa of corporal punishment. Jutta Stadler of Pfaffenhofen confirmed on Wednesday in the Sueddeutsche Zeitung that the accusation were included in an affivdavit. One person said the bishops gave full force in the face.

Six sworn statements say that Mixa had beaten them during his time as pastor in the Schrobenhausen children's home.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:48 PM

The Church's moral accountability

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

Terry McKiernan

[See also the original version of this column with links to dozens of key articles and documents.]

Last week was a remarkable time for victims of abuse by Catholic clergy and for the Vatican. The week will be remembered as the moment when a crisis that had gained notoriety in several countries, starting with the U.S. in 1985, suddenly emerged as a global issue and reached the Pope himself, with implications that I'll discuss below. By Saturday, March 27, Vatican spokesman Rev. Federico Lombardi, S.J., acknowledged that the way the church deals with sexual abuse "is crucial for her moral credibility." Lombardi was referring to these developments:

▪ March 21: Embattled Irish primate Cardinal Sean Brady released Benedict's letter to the Irish people, who gave it a mixed reception.

▪ March 24: The Munich and Freising archdiocese announced it had informed police that Rev. Peter Hullermann (welcomed to the archdiocese by then-Archbishop Ratzinger in 1980 after allegations, and convicted of child abuse in 1986) had been accused of sexually abusing a boy in 1998; the alleged abuse is recent enough to prosecute.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:41 PM

The Church versus the law . . it's been going on sin

UNITED KINGDOM
Bromley Times

ALL the scandals about paedophile priest cover-ups are nothing new and further endorse the extraordinary philosophy the church can uphold the myth its staff are somehow beyond the laws of the land.

This incredibly arrogant situation began, arguably, back in the 12th century in the reign of Henry II.

This monarch famously disagreed with the Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Becket, over this issue and quite rightly refused to accept why any priest committing a criminal act albeit child abuse (if such an act was deemed a crime in those days) stealing, or fornication, would only be tried by other fellows of the cassock. Oh? So no real punishment there then 'cos we're all mates together and it's just slapped wrists all around.

German bishop faces allegations of physical punishment

GERMANY
Deutsche Welle

According to allegations published Wednesday in a German newspaper, leading Catholic bishop Walter Mixa physically abused children in a church orphanage three decades ago. The bishop's office has denied the accusations.

The German daily Sueddeutsche Zeitung published a report on its website on Wednesday alleging that Bishop Walter Mixa had "slapped, punched or spanked the behinds of boys and girls who had misbehaved" at an orphanage in the southern town of Schrobenhausen in the 1970s.

The newspaper said three women and two men had given statements under oath that Mixa had beaten them repeatedly.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:28 PM

St. Louis area priest pleads guilty in child porn case

ST. LOUIS (MO)
KMOX

ST. LOUIS (KMOX) -- St. Louis Catholic priest could spend more than 6 years behind bars after being caught in federal sting operation last summer.

Father James Grady pleaded guilty this morning to possessing child porn.

Investigators say they found more than 100 images of girls between the ages of 7 and 17 on his computer, along with search terms consistent with child porn.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:24 PM

St. Louis area priest pleads guilty to child porn

ST. LOUIS (MO)
St. Louis Globe-Democrat

James Patrick Grady pleaded guilty to possession of child pornography Wednesday according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

Prosecutors gave the following account of the investigation:

•According to court documents, James Patrick Grady was employed as the pastor at St. Rafael’s Parish in St. Louis. Grady was provided with a computer by the Archdiocese of St. Louis, but requested that parish members obtain a laptop computer for his personal usage. The parish purchased him a Toshiba laptop computer.

•On July 29, 2009, law enforcement officers and agents were involved in an undercover operation investigating subjects who attempt to purchase children, or their services, for commercial sex in the Eastern District of Missouri. The same day, officers received an e-mail in response to an Internet advertisement that had been placed by law enforcement working in the undercover capacity. The advertisement indicated that young females of an indeterminate age were available. The e-mail was from James Patrick Grady, seeking more information regarding the ad, and was informed that there were two females. In the course of the e-mails, Grady received a digitally morphed photograph of a 16-year old female. Grady inquired about the cost of the child depicted and was given a price for a half hour and for one hour. Grady indicated that he wanted a half hour and was told that the girl was 16 years old. He indicated that was fine and set up a meeting. Upon arriving at the agreed upon location, Grady met an undercover officer, and asked to see the girls. Grady was subsequently arrested by the FBI, St. Louis County Police and the Maryland Heights Police. After his arrest, Grady admitted that he intended to have sex with the girl.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:20 PM

Father James Grady pleads guilty to child pornography

ST. LOUIS (MO)
KSDK

KSDK -- A St. Louis priest pled guilty to possessing child pornography on Wednesday morning, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office.

Father James Patrick Grady will be sentenced June 25.

According to court documents, while Father Grady was priest at St. Raphael Parish in St. Louis, the parish purchased him a laptop computer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:10 PM

Louisville Attorney Files Lawsuit Against Pope Benedict XVI

KENTUCKY
Louisville Mojo

A historic, if misguided, legal landmark is unfolding before our eyes: for the first time in history, a U.S. court will decide whether The Vatican and The Pope can be held liable for negligence in the growing nationwide priest abuse scandal.

The case against Pope Benedict XVI was filed in Louisville by William McMurry, with three men claiming to have been abused by priests in Kentucky. They also claim that the Pope and Vatican officials did nothing about it, and maintain this makes them legally liable.

Don't expect the case to go very far, however. The notion that a man sitting in Rome can be held personally responsible for the acts of men he's never met doing scurrilous things in Kentucky is pretty ridiculous, and not likely to hold up in court. The leader of a religion cannot keep in check his millions of followers any more than the CEO of a global corporation can keep tabs on the day-to-day doings of its blue-collar workers in plants around the world.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:08 PM

Alleged victim's lawyers: Vatican protected priest

MIAMI (FL)
Atlanta Journal-Constitution

By CHRISTINE ARMARIO
The Associated Press

MIAMI — Lawyers representing an alleged victim of sex abuse claim the Vatican instructed church officials in Florida to shelter a priest from Cuba who was later accused of pedophilia.

Attorney Jessica Arbour, who represents an alleged victim of the Rev. Ernesto Garcia-Rubio, released a 1968 letter from the Vatican to the Archdiocese of Miami, stating the cleric had been forced to leave Cuba "because of serious difficulties of a moral nature (homosexuality)."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:05 PM

German bishop accused of corporal punishment (Roundup)

GERMANY
Monsters and Critics

Augsburg, Germany - A German Catholic bishop was accused Wednesday of administering corporal punishment to children 30 years ago as a scandal over sex abuse and violence grew in the homeland of Pope Benedict XVI.

The office of Walter Mixa, bishop of Augsburg, vehemently denied the claims that he spanked and slapped children in an orphanage in the southern town of Schrobenhausen while he was a junior priest.

Many German Catholics have been embittered at revelations that Catholic clergy groped, fondled or thrashed children in hundreds of cases between the 1950s and the 1980s. In a few cases, it has emerged that priests were convicted of rape.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:02 PM

Benedict's failure and opportunity

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

This Catholic's View

By Thomas J. Reese, S.J.

Like most bishops, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who became Pope Benedict XVI, did not understand the sexual abuse crisis when it first appeared. He underestimated its extent and scope.

But over time, he grew in understanding as he watched what was happening in the United States and as he learned from reports from the American bishops. He got it faster than other Vatican officials, including Pope John Paul II. As head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, he was forced to read the files on these priests when bishops asked for their dismissal from the priesthood.

As a Vatican official, he supported the American bishops when in 2002 they adopted a zero tolerance rule so that no abusive priest could be returned to ministry. He also condemned the abuse and expressed sorrow when he visited the United States in 2008, the high point of which was his meeting with victims of abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:39 AM

Pope should abandon institutional self-protection, embrace transparency

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

Rajan Zed

Q:Should Pope Benedict XVI be held responsible for the escalating scandals over clerical sexual abuse in Europe? Should he be investigated for cases of abuse that occurred under his watch as archbishop of Munich or as the Vatican's chief doctrinal enforcer? Should the pope resign?

His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI should urgently come up with a White Paper on the reportedly mushrooming global sex scandal engulfing the Roman Catholic Church, which is unprecedented and shocking.

This authoritative Paper should honestly address the reported worldwide sexual abuse crisis the Church is facing; and then list the solutions, action program and implementation schedule. A monitoring body should also be established for future.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:20 AM

Pope's U.S. favorable rating drops

UNITED STATES
St. Louis Globe-Democrat

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

PRINCETON, N.J., March 31 (UPI) -- Pope Benedict's favorable rating has dropped sharply in the United States over his handling of clergy sex abuse cases in Europe, a poll suggested.

The pope's favorable rating dropped from 63 percent in a Gallup poll taken two years ago to 40 percent in a Gallup poll released Wednesday.

The pontiff's rating deteriorated about equally among Roman Catholics and non-Roman Catholics interviewed for the poll, Gallup said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:14 AM

Day of Repent for sexual abuse at Vienna cathedral

AUSTRIA
Austrian Independent

Vienna Archbishop Christoph Cardinal Schönborn will preside at a "day of repentance" service today (Weds) in the wake of revelations of numerous cases of violence and sexual abuse by members of the Catholic clergy.

His office said yesterday that the service at 7pm at Vienna’s St. Stephen’s Cathedral would constitute "an acknowledgement of guilt in the name of the Church."

The office added that members of some organisations critical of Schönborn, such as "We are the Church," had been invited to attend it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:10 AM

Employment Testing for the Priesthood Can Prevent Child Abuse

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Jerry Chautin

Do you have the propensity to molest young boys? What about girls? If you become a messenger of God, will you exploit your powers to fulfill your sexual fantasies? Can you handle celibacy without having affairs with your parishioners?

In a pre-employment test for the priesthood, these questions will need to be answered. The questions will be cloaked with ambiguities so that the applicant will not be sure what the questions mean. The tester will gain insight to personal characteristics of the job applicant applying to enter the clergy. Unsuitable candidates will be disqualified.

Abuse by Catholic priests is continuing to capture the headlines. Psychological testing is needed to screen out would-be priests and other candidates for religious or spiritual leadership, regardless of their faith.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:01 AM

Attorneys Want Pope To Answer Questions

UNITED STATES
WLWT

CINCINNATI -- Three men who claim they were abused by priests are asking for the pope to be held accountable for their ordeal.

The men filed a lawsuit in 2004, accusing the Vatican of negligence.

Attorneys want to question the pope under oath about the rampant sex abuse scandals plaguing the Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:58 AM

Statement by John Manly: Cardinal Mahony Defends the Pope and Sex Abuse Cover-up

CALIFORNIA
Manly & Stewart

March 31, 2010 | By John Manly
Incredibly, Cardinal Mahony of the Los Angeles Archdiocese issued a statement today lauding Pope Benedict for his work in allegedly protecting victims from sexually abusive priests.

It’s incredible that the Cardinal who presided over the largest known number of pedophile priests in the United States would be qualified to issue statements regarding proper behavior in preventing child molestation.

The Pope’s misdeeds and inaction - while a Bishop in Germany, and later as a Senior Vatican Official acting as the gate keeper for abusive priests - are well documented. The fact that the Pope must rely on a man so thoroughly discredited as Roger Mahony, acutely demonstrates the desperate position he finds himself in now that the Pope’s misdeeds and crimes have come to light.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:55 AM

Priests told to refocus on holy living

BOSTON (MA)
Boston Globe

By Lisa Wangsness
Globe Staff / March 31, 2010

Cardinal Sean O’Malley directly addressed the sex abuse scandal in Europe in his Holy Week homily to priests yesterday, telling local clergy that “the crisis that keeps coming back at us’’ underscores the need for priests to “live a life of holiness.’’ He thanked the priests for their sacrifice and service but urged them to work on living more balanced and prayerful lives.

O’Malley spoke to hundreds of priests gathered at the Cathedral of the Holy Cross in the South End in the midst of the most sacred week of the church year, and at a time when the worldwide church is confronting anew the crisis that first roiled the American church, beginning with the Boston Archdiocese, eight years ago.

In Europe, Pope Benedict XVI has been under harsh attack for his own role in a case involving an abusive priest in the early 1980s, when he was an archbishop in Germany, as well as for his recent handling of the sex abuse scandal in the Irish church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:51 AM

Catholics critical of abuse 'cover-up'

IRELAND
Leinster Express

By Staff Reporter
CATHOLICS from Parishes across the Diocese of Kildare and Leighlin gathered in Portarlington and Carlow last week to discuss the recent Papal Letter from Pope Benedict XVI on clerical sex abuse and to hear the views of Baroness Nuala O'Loan, former ombudsman for the Police Service of Northern Ireland.

The meeting at Mount St Annes, Portarlington was held alongside a gathering at the Carlow Cathedral Parish Centre. In Diocesan statement, there was discussion at the meetings of the Vatican and its role in the ongoing scandal but also criticism of the "cover up" mentality. Some questioned why the meetings had not been more widely advertised and there were calls for further meetings in every parish.

The Diocese said the people spoke of their own hurt and lack of trust, of their disappointment with aspects of the church's handling of child abuse, The statement said a number of speakers congratulated Bishop Jim Moriarty on the position he adopted when offering his resignation after the publication of the Murphy report. The bishop’s letter of resignation has yet to be accepted by the Pope.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:39 AM

Pope Benedict and the bishops: Who's to blame?

UNITED STATES
USA Today

Isn't nuance annoying? It's so pesky to say on the one hand/one the other or he did X but he also did Y, or the context of such-and-such is so-and-so, which might alter your perceptions. All that information has a way of messing up neat answers. And so it is with examining Pope Benedict XVI and the global sexual abuse crisis.

He faces unrelenting criticism for failing to rid the priest ranks of predators for decades, for choosing treatment, silence and respect for accused priests' reputations, and the Church's, over the safety and spiritual treasures of children and teens, and for failing to hold bishops' feet to the fire on the jobs they are appointed to do -- to preach teach and govern.

Reckless remarks are flying (see Sally Quinn equating the Pope to Nixon enmeshed in Watergate). Anger mounts as demonstrations are planned by victims (today in California aimed at Cardinal Roger Mahony). Also in Los Angeles, the LA. Times profiled Jeffrey Anderson, the victims advocate who has been trying for more than a decade to establish in U.S. courts that blame for the ongoing abuse epidemic goes all the way to the Vatican.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:36 AM

Brunch with Jaime, Elizabeth, and Virginia

PORTLAND (OR)
The Garden of Roses: Stories of Abuse and Healing

Date: May 1, 2010
Time: 10:30 AM to 1PM
Where: Elizabeth Goeke’s home
in Portland, Oregon (call for directions to get there)

Join us for brunch and an informal conversation on healing the wounds of abuse.

Brunch Panel:
Dr. Jaime Romo was sexually abused by a priest as a boy. He later studied to be a priest at St. John Seminary, dropping out before being ordained. He went on the be a teacher, a school administrator, and then a professor of education at a Catholic university. When his own sons reached the age he was when he was abused, memories of the his long buried abuse began to surface, throwing him into a personal and professional crisis. He became a member of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, leading leaflettings and press conferences about church policies relative to abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:17 AM

German bishop Mixa rejects corporal-punishment allegations

GERMANY
Earth Times

Augsburg, Germany - The office of a leading conservative Catholic bishop in Germany, Walter Mixa of Augsburg, denied on Wednesday allegations that he had slapped or spanked children in a church orphanage three decades ago.

A newspaper had earlier in the day quoted former residents with claims that the clergyman gave them corporal punishment for misbehaviour while he was parish priest of the southern town of Schrobenhausen.

Mixa is the first of Germany's 27 bishops to have to face an allegation that he personally abused children. Germany has already been rocked by allegations that priests sexually abused hundreds of children in their care.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:14 AM

Report: 5 allege priest beat them before becoming bishop

GERMANY
Toronto Sun

BERLIN — A German newspaper says three women and two men are claiming they were physically abused at a Roman Catholic orphanage by a priest who is now a bishop.

The Sueddeutsche Zeitung said Wednesday it has obtained affidavits the five self-described victims had prepared claiming that Walter Mixa struck them with his fists or instruments such as sticks, carpet beaters or wooden spoons in the 1970s and 1980s when he was a priest at the orphanage in Schrobenhausen.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:11 AM

How to Defend Without Being Defensive?

UNITED STATES
American Magazine

Posted at: 2010-03-31 08
Author: Michael Sean Winters

It is one of the most confounding conundrums faced by anyone in the public spotlight: How to defend without being defensive? How to correct critical details without the appearance of nitpicking? Finally, how to deal with the media – which is the only way most people will come to know of the controversy in question – when that media is in a feeding frenzy?

Let me start with this important caveat. I do not – and no one at the Vatican should – blame the media for the current controversy surrounding the sexual abuse of minors by clergy, and most especially, the role of Pope Benedict, in his earlier positions of authority, in perpetuating the culture that covered-up that sexual abuse. I will go further and say, thank God for the Boston Globe and National Catholic Reporter and other media outlets that covered the scandal. Otherwise, we might never have had the explosion in Boston which caused the U.S. bishops to get serious and crackdown on pedophilia and set about creating safe environment for children. The bishops had ignored earlier, internal warnings about the nature and extent of the crisis. Only when the Globe sunk its teeth into the story develop the kind of momentum that made it unstoppable. To be clear, the crisis in Catholicism did not begin when the Globe covered the story. The crisis was the on-going cover-up of serial child abusers. The reporting in NCR and the Globe were nothing more than the provocation needed to get the bishops to being the painful surgery of removing the cancer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:05 AM

German bishop accused of beating orphaned girls

GERMANY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Roger Boyes, Berlin
One of the Pope's closest conservative allies in Germany, Bishop Walter Mixa, has been accused of brutally beating and flogging children in his care.

The Bishop of Augsburg, 68, denies the claims by five former pupils at a Catholic-run orphanage and care facility. But they will be a source of deep embarrassment and concern in the Vatican: Bishop Mixa is part of a conservative axis in Pope Benedict XVI's native Bavaria that has always backed the pontiff in his most controversial decisions, from criticising the violence of Islam in Regensburg cathedral, to rehabilitating the Holocaust-sceptic Bishop Richard Williamson.

Although there are no accusations of sexual abuse at the home – where the bishop was a visiting priest in the 1970s and 1980s – it is clear that Mr Mixa is in trouble.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:02 AM

Setting the Record Straight: an interview with Murphy trial judge Fr. Thomas Brundage

UNITED STATES
Vatican Radio

(31 Mar 10 - RV) The judge who presided over the Church Court that was trying Fr. Lawrence Murphy on charges he abused deaf boys in the confessional, Fr. Thomas Brundage, has written an article in the archdiocesan newspaper of Anchorage, Alaska, where he is currently stationed. The article is critical of the New York Times’ reporting of the Fr Murphy case, and seeks to set the record straight. Chris Altieri reached Fr. Brundage by phone this (Wednesday) morning and asked him about the trial, which began in the mid 1990’s on the explicit authorization of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, of which the man who would become Pope Benedict XVI was head at the time.

Fr. Brundage: From 1996 until 1998, the trial lasted about eighteen (18) months, and concluded with Fr. Murphy’s death.

Chris Altieri: - And at any time during that trial, did you have any pressure whatsoever from Rome to abey the proceedings, to suspend them, to push this under the rug - anything like that?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:59 AM

A church adrift

AUSTRALIA
The Age

BARNEY ZWARTZ
April 1, 2010

IT'S only a quarter over, but mark down 2010 as a bad year for the Vatican. A steady drip of revelations of sexual abuse by clergy and cover-ups by bishops has become a flow, then a torrent.

Hundreds of new allegations are emerging in Germany, Austria and the Netherlands, and the stain is spreading right to the top, with serious accusations being levelled against Pope Benedict XVI himself.

Once dismissed as merely an Anglo-Saxon disease, or a hostile media campaign, the avalanche is catastrophic for the Roman Catholic hierarchy's already battered credibility and moral authority.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:56 AM

Swiss bishops 'underestimated' sexual abuse

SWITZERLAND
Taiwan News

Top Swiss Catholic clergymen say they underestimated the problem of sexual abuse and are now telling victims to consider criminal complaints.

The Swiss Bishops' Conference said Wednesday it was "ashamed" by the number of sexual abuses cases and apologized for "errors." They have previously cited about 60 people claiming to be victims and said they "underestimated the magnitude of the situation."

The bishops are split over the idea of a blacklist of pedophile priests.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:52 AM

Bishop says 'vast' tally of sexual abuse yet to emerge

AUSTRALIA
The Age

BARNEY ZWARTZ
April 1, 2010

THE Catholic Church has a turbulent future as probably a much smaller church in the West, with a ''vast amount'' of sexual abuse cases yet to emerge, according to a retired Australian bishop.

''The church is not going to fold up its tent and disappear, but there could be very dramatic changes'' as a result of the clergy abuse crisis, said Bishop Geoffrey Robinson.

The Archbishop of Melbourne, Denis Hart, blamed a failure of leadership and a lack of courage for the crisis and warned that while Australia had learnt its lessons, the difficulties for the church in many countries were still coming.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:49 AM

Pope Pressured To Address Church's Sex Abuse Crisis

ITALY
KPCC (United States)

Sylvia Poggioli | NPR

Allegations of child abuse by Catholic priests have emerged in Italy. Three men say they were abused as boys at a Catholic school for the deaf. They say no action has been taken against the priests - even though they reported the cases more than a year ago. Pope Benedict is under pressure to make a full response to abuse charges in Europe and the U.S.

As the faithful fill churches during Holy Week, a wave of clerical sex abuse revelations is sweeping Europe. The latest allegations come from Italy, just outside Vatican walls.

As the scandal mounts, Pope Benedict XVI is under increasing pressure to give a more forceful response to the most serious crisis of his papacy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 AM

O'CONNOR WILLING TO DEFEND POPE

IRELAND
Express (United Kingdom)

Wednesday March 31,2010
Outspoken singer SINEAD O'CONNOR has vowed to "stand up and defend" the Pope if allegations of sexual abuse within the Catholic church are proved false.

The Nothing Compares 2 U hitmaker was one of the first celebrities to address the issue of child abuse in the church, and has previously urged Pope Benedict XVI to resign over reports the Vatican covered up the scandal for decades.

O'Connor admits the reputation of church leaders has been destroyed by the allegations and insists she would support the pontiff if he's innocent.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:44 AM

The Vatican’s cross

PHILIPPINES
Inquirer

THIS MUST BE THE BLEAKEST HOLY THURSDAY at the Vatican in many decades. An unholy shroud of suspicion has enveloped the Holy See, threatening to suffocate even the papacy itself. An Associated Press story Wednesday drew a forbidding global picture: “As the faithful fill churches this Holy Week, many Roman Catholics around the world are finding their relationship to the church painfully tested by new revelations of clerical abuse and suggestions [that Pope] Benedict himself may have helped cover up cases in Germany and the US.”

We should point out that these new revelations about insufficient institutional responses to allegations of sexual abuse by predatory priests have had perhaps less impact on the Church in the Philippines (and, the AP story suggests, in Poland too, another staunchly Catholic country). Indeed, the AP story itself recognizes that many of the Catholic faithful who are aware of the latest iteration of a long-running scandal aren’t necessarily thinking of leaving the Church. It quotes Linda Faust, of Greendale, Wisconsin, as saying, rather pungently, “At this point in my life I wouldn’t leave the Church for somebody else’s sins.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 AM

Catholic Students Attack Media Over Abuse Charges

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - Conservative Catholic university students rushed to Pope Benedict's defense on Wednesday, attacking journalists who have written about the sexual abuse of children by priests as "sowers of mistrust."

The some 4,000 students from around the world, in Rome for a convention, handed the beleaguered pope a letter of support during his weekly general audience in St Peter's Square.

In his address, the pope made no direct reference to the scandal sweeping the church but said priests should always send a message of "hope, reconciliation and peace."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 AM

Bishop Mixa accused of abusing children

GERMANY
The Local

Published: 31 Mar 10
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/national/20100331-26229.html

Five people have accused Germany's controversial Catholic Bishop Walter Mixa of physically abusing them while they were at a children’s home north of Munich in the 1970s and 1980s.

Three women and two men claimed that Mixa hit them on multiple occasions while they were at the St. Josef children’s home in Schrobenhausen, daily Süddeutsche Zeitung reported on Wednesday, citing statements declared under oath by the alleged victims.

Their descriptions of the abuse include slaps to the face, punches to their upper arms, and spankings with a carpet beater, the paper said.

But the Augsburg diocese called the accusations “absurd, untrue, and obviously invented to defame the bishop.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:33 AM

German bishop accused of physical abuse of children

GERMANY
Catholic Culture

March 31, 2010
Three women and two men who were former residents of a Catholic children’s home have accused Bishop Walter Mixa of Augsburg of physically abusing them in the 1970s and 1980s. Calling the allegations “absurd, untrue, and obviously invented to defame the bishop,” a diocesan spokesman said that the diocese reserved the right to take press charges or file a civil suit against the accusers.

The nation’s justice minister criticized Bishop Mixa in February after he attributed the abuse scandal in part to the sexual revolution. Bishop Mixa also serves as the bishop of the nation’s military.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:28 AM

German bishop accused of physical abuse of children

GERMANY
Catholic Culture

March 31, 2010
Three women and two men who were former residents of a Catholic children’s home have accused Bishop Walter Mixa of Augsburg of physically abusing them in the 1970s and 1980s. Calling the allegations “absurd, untrue, and obviously invented to defame the bishop,” a diocesan spokesman said that the diocese reserved the right to take press charges or file a civil suit against the accusers.

The nation’s justice minister criticized Bishop Mixa in February after he attributed the abuse scandal in part to the sexual revolution. Bishop Mixa also serves as the bishop of the nation’s military.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:28 AM

Check, recheck and triple check

UNITED STATES
GetReligion

Posted by Mollie

It appears that ace Vatican reporter John Allen isn’t the only person who noted problems with the New York Times’ recent attempt to link Pope Benedict XVI to a particularly sickening story of priest abuse.

We looked at Allen’s critique already. The Times said the fact that only 20 percent of abuse cases went to trial was a mark of “inaction” by the office Benedict oversaw when he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. But Allen said that most Vatican observers would say that allowing bishops to handle cases instead of sending them all to trial was much more favorable to the victims. Allen summed up his take on the situation in a new op-ed for the Times:

After being elected pope, Benedict made the abuse cases a priority. One of his first acts was to discipline two high-profile clerics against whom sex abuse allegations had been hanging around for decades, but had previously been protected at the highest levels.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:26 AM

Cardinal Mahony praises Pope’s swift response to Los Angeles abuse cases

LOS ANGELES (CA)
Catholic News Agency

Los Angeles, Calif., Mar 31, 2010 / 06:27 am (CNA).- Responding to controversial media reports about Pope Benedict’s handling of abusive clergy, Cardinal Roger M. Mahony, the Archbishop of Los Angeles, has praised “without hesitation” the future Pope’s quick and helpful response to allegations in the California archdiocese.

As Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), the future pontiff responded “quickly and affirmatively” to all requests for assistance from prelates in the United States during the year 2002 with reports about the American sexual abuse scandal.

Cardinal Ratzinger and the CDF responded “swiftly” and advised how to proceed in cases of alleged sexual abuse by priests in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles, Cardinal Mahony wrote on his blog.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:23 AM

Law firm implicates Vatican, Pope in abuse case

MIAMI (FL)
Washington Post

By CHRISTINE ARMARIO
The Associated Press
Wednesday, March 31, 2010

MIAMI -- A South Florida law firm is implicating the Vatican and Pope Benedict XVI in its handling of a priest accused of sexually abusing children.

Jessica Arbour, an attorney representing one of the alleged victims, says documents show the Vatican was aware of Rev. Ernesto Garcia-Rubio's misconduct as early as 1968.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:19 AM

Dioceses in the U.S publish online document aimed to prevent abuse

UNITED STATES
Rome Reports

[with video]

Romereports.com March 31, 2010.

Some 80 dioceses in the United States have taken a simple step to prevent sexual abuse cases. They’ve published this document on their websites in an effort to prevent abuse.

Dioceses like the ones in New York City, Brooklyn, Iowa, Dallas and Philadelphia have made the ‘Model Code of Pastoral Conduct’, readily available. You can download it for free from the website www.virtus.org. The National Catholic Risk Retention Group created the website to prevent sexual abuse in the Church.

This 13-page document, outlines the code of conduct for the diocese to prevent abuse in parishes and schools. It refers to priests, deacons, pastoral ministers, administrators and volunteers who work there.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:15 AM

Pedophilia in the Catholic Church: Coverup Operation at the Vatican?

Center for Research on Globalization

by Mike Whitney

Pope Benedict should do everyone a favor and resign. By hanging on, he's just making matters worse. Who does he think he's fooling anyway? Everyone knows that he was involved in the sex-scandal cover up. Does he really think that a few papal apologies will make a difference? He was in charge and knew everything that was going on. That makes him responsible. His best option now is to "man up" and face the consequences. He needs to arrange a press conference, tell the truth, and resign. End of story.

It's clear that the problem isn't going to go away. In the last week, three more incidents have surfaced adding more fuel to the fire. In Wisconsin, Father Lawrence Murphy abused as many as 200 boys at a Milwaukee school for the deaf. One of the victims, Arthur Budzinski, has been all over TV telling his story and blaming the pope. It's pretty heart-wrenching stuff, too. According to Budzinski's daughter Gigi:

"The pope knew about this. He was the one who handled the sex abuse cases. So, I think he should be accountable, because he did nothing."


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:12 AM

Ky lawsuit seeks to question Pope under oath

KENTUCKY
FOX 41

[with video]

By Bennett Haeberle WDRB-TV Fox 41 News

Vatican attorneys are working to protect Pope Benedict XVI from being deposed in a Kentucky lawsuit that claims the Vatican and its clergy were responsible for covering up cases of priest sex abuse.

The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court in Louisville in 2004, claims the pontiff "has extensive knowledge" and was "intimately and uniquely tied to the issue of child sexual abuse by the clergy."

The class-action litigation has been ongoing for years, but stalled until recently.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:06 AM

Church at the crossroads

VERMONT
Bennington Banner

Tuesday March 30, 2010

It has been a long and, for Catholics, frequently excruciating eight years since the Roman Catholic sexual abuse scandal broke in the U.S. in early 2002.

A similar firestorm over the abuse of children by priests, and the hierarchy’s failure to stop it, is now engulfing the church in Ireland and in Germany. Moreover, Pope Benedict XVI himself is now under fire, the fact having emerged that when he was archbishop of Munich in 1980, a known pedophile priest came to his diocese and was assigned to parish work. Whether then-Archbishop Joseph Ratzinger knew about this decision or not, it happened while he was in charge.

However, a sense of the overall arc of the abuse scandal seems necessary to gain perspective. First, the Catholic Church has made great strides in its handling of abuse cases. The vast majority of cases at issue over the last eight years, both in the U.S., and now in Europe, took place before the 1990s. Church officials long ago discarded the misguided notions that pedophilia can be successfully "cured" with therapy and that Christian forgiveness means allowing abusive priests to continue in ministry.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:04 AM

Mumbai Catholics react to Vatican paedophilia scandals

INDIA
Mid-Day

By: Bobby Anthony Date: 2010-03-31

Even as Good Friday approaches, Catholics in Mumbai have begun reacting to Western media reports about allegations against Pope Benedict XVI and his brother, which accuse them of protecting priests involved in child
sex abuse.

"I don't deny that there are cases of paedophile priests. But there has been no attempt to shield any such priest. We live in the age of legal activism and openness, and it would be a generalisation to say that Catholics are asking the Pope to step down, which is not fair," said Fr Anthony Charanghat, director, Catholic Communication Centre.

"You must also understand that the global porn industry is responsible for blowing these reports out of proportion. They have been trying to demonise the Catholic clergy, since the Church has been fighting them," he added.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 AM

Milwaukee Archbishop Supports Victims, Defends Pope

WISCONSIN
WBAY

By Matt Smith

During the most holy week of the Christian year, a cloud of sin hangs over the Catholic Church. Tuesday night, Milwaukee's archbishop publicly addressed the alleged sex abuse cover-up extending from Wisconsin to the Vatican.

The late Father Lawrence Murphy is accused of molesting as many as 200 boys at a school for the deaf in Milwaukee in the 50s, 60s, and 70s.

Last week, a victims advocacy group called SNAP said it has documentation that Vatican leaders, including Pope Benedict when he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, stopped a church trial against Father Murphy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Full text of Listecki's remarks

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

The comments below were shared by Milwaukee Archbishop Jerome E. Listecki Tuesday night at the end of the Chrism Mass at the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist.

Dear Friends,

This Lent throughout the archdiocese, we celebrated a Season of Mercy, acknowledging our sinfulness and our need to reconcile with our God. This Season of Mercy is a stark recognition of the presence of sin in our world, in our Church, amongst our people, and, yes, within priests and bishops. That sin has never been more present to us as a Church than through the sin and crime of clergy sexual abuse.

As a bishop, a priest, and as a man of faith, I apologize to anyone who has been a victim of clergy sexual abuse. This crime, this sin, this horror, should never occur, especially by a priest. Those who committed these crimes and those, including some bishops, who didn’t do everything in their power to stop it, go against everything the Church and the priesthood represent. For those actions, I offer my sincere apology.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:57 AM

Editorial: What the pope should do

UNITED STATES
The Providence Journal

It has been nearly a decade since widespread allegations of sexual abuse by priests rocked the Roman Catholic Church in the U.S. Now similar allegations are sweeping Europe. And new evidence suggests that, before he became Pope Benedict XVI, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger shielded a U.S. priest from accusations that he molested some 200 deaf boys in Wisconsin.

So far, the pope has taken only modest steps to try to calm the mounting outrage. In Ireland, where last year two scathing government reports revealed decades of abuse, he issued a letter of apology. And last week, he accepted the resignation of one bishop, John Magee. Yet Bishop Magee will keep his title as head of the Diocese of Coyne, in southern Ireland, and is likely to continue with pastoral work. At least four other bishops have reportedly offered to resign, but the pope is resisting accepting their resignations.

Meanwhile, in Germany, hundreds of alleged victims have come forward since a news report centering on a Jesuit high school was published in January. In one 1980 case, an accused priest was ordered by Archbishop Ratzinger to undergo treatment. He returned to work and allegedly molested more children. The Vatican contends the pope was unaware of this development at the time.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:54 AM

The Vatican Hotline Outrage

The Daily Beast

by Barbie Latza Nadeau

The Catholic Church’s move to open a hotline to report sex abuse has infuriated victims who say it’s another ploy to keep the church’s darkest secrets under lock and key.

The Roman Catholic Church is the last place victims of predator priests should turn to. That, according to victims, is how the church got into this mess in the first place. And it’s why victims’ groups are outraged by a new church-sponsored hotline for victims to report alleged crimes.

“Victims should tell loved ones and police first,” said David Clohessy of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP. “Calling the church should be a last resort.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:51 AM

Child abuse allegations made against 45 Maltese priests in 11 years

MALTA
Times of Malta

Cynthia Busuttil

A total of 84 allegations of child abuse, involving forty-five Maltese priests, were reported to a Church response team over the last 11 years, The Times reports today.

The response team was set up in 1999 and receives reports from both the Maltese and Gozitan dioceses, a spokesman for the Curia said.

He would not divulge the nature of the cases, saying the response team's work was carried out in confidence.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:48 AM

Jerome Christenson: Why am I still Catholic? Read on, my friend

MINNESOTA
Winona Daily News

By Jerome Christenson | jchristenson@winonadailynews.com | Posted: Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Just when I thought it was safe to go to communion, my church is making me uncomfortable again.

Just in time for Easter the sorry legacy of pedophile priests has resurfaced. This time international attention is focused on Milwaukee and Munich, on what did the pope know and when did he know it?

Most people I know aren't so rude as to ask how I can be part of an organization that has harbored and protected predatory pedophiles. I don't have to be so polite with myself, especially after I learned, some years ago, that as I entered adolescence one such notorious priest was assigned to a parish and parish school just blocks from my home. My friends and schoolmates served him as altar boys. More than that, I can't know for sure, but there but for the grace of God ...

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:44 AM

Father Tim: Nobody buying what Catholic Church defenders selling

UNITED STATES
Irish Central

by Father TIm

My friends:

The Catholic Church's "defenders of the fake" have begun their expected counterattack to those pesky critics who still don't believe -- despite Pope Benedict sending them a letter -- that the Church's leadership (if that's the right word) is serious about putting pedophile priests behind bars along with the conspiratorial clergy who covered up their heinous crimes.

In my adopted hometown of New York City, the Church's defensive lineup was especially pathetic, and even comical.

Archbishop Timothy Dolan, leader of some of the city's Catholics, used his Palm Sunday performance to compare Benedict to Jesus Christ, a hysterical analogy that may in fact become blasphemous if the Pope is found to have been complicit in cover-ups himself.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

For critics of pope and Church, end justifies means

UNITED STATES
The Tribune-Democrat

Pedro Vega
For The Tribune-Democrat

— For the past several years now, I have sat back and waited during the Lent and Easter seasons for the inevitable eruptions of sensational reports, purported exposés and clever reinterpretations of traditional Christian teachings. This year, would it be a new documentary concerning the discovery of the corpse of Jesus? Would it be another shallow, runaway bestseller such as “The Da Vinci Code”?

Nope. This year’s Easter surprise has been the relentless attacks against the Catholic Church in general, and Pope Benedict XVI in particular, from critics both outside and inside the Church. Who they are and what they say reveal a lot of what they want.

But before we go into that, let’s reaffirm what is accepted by all: This injury is largely self-inflicted. Years of negligent handling of sexual abuse allegations have brought us here. As Pope Benedict recently told the Irish bishops:

“It cannot be denied that some of you and your predecessors failed, at times grievously, to apply the long-established norms of canon law to the crime of child abuse. Serious mistakes were made in responding to allegations … it must be admitted that grave errors of judgment were made and failures of leadership occurred. All this has seriously undermined your credibility and effectiveness.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 AM

Lubbock churches carry on as usual amid protests against Pope

LUBBOCK (TX)
Avalanche Journal

By Kellie Bramlet | AVALANCHE-JOURNAL
Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Protesters in London demanded the Pope's resignation and some in Switzerland called for a registry of pedophile priests, The Associated Press reported, but Catholic leaders in Lubbock are carrying on as usual.

"We are much bigger and much stronger and much more multidimensional than this one terrible problem that has plagued the Church," said Monsignor David Cruz, pastor of Our Lady of Grace Church. "We cannot let this one issue define who we are."

Cruz said he's spoken with individual members about the recent allegations that Pope Benedict XVI knew of some of the incidents of sexual abuse committed by clergy members while he served as the archbishop of Munich, but Cruz hasn't addressed the whole congregation regarding the issue.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:33 AM

Kathy Redig: Womenpriests support vicitims of clergy abuse

MINNESOTA
Winona Daily News

By Kathy Redig / Winona | Posted: Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Roman Catholic Womenpriests stand in solidarity with victims of clergy sex abuse throughout Europe and around the world who were sexually assaulted by Catholic clergy.

The growing number of allegations of sexual abuse in Ireland, Germany, Switzerland, Austria and the Netherlands indicate that the cover-up of crimes against children and youth in the Catholic Church goes all the way to the pope and the Vatican.

In the U.S., the sex abuse scandal has destroyed the lives of victims and their families, bankrupted some dioceses and cost the church more than $2 billion.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:28 AM

New garda unit will oversee sex-crime inquiries

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By TOM BRADY

Wednesday March 31 2010

A NEW sexual crime management unit is being set up within An Garda Siochana to oversee inquiries by members of the force into allegations and complaints of abuse.

The move was announced yesterday by Garda Commissioner Fachtna Murphy at the annual conference of the Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors in Galway. He said the unit would regularly evaluate investigations into child sexual abuse, child neglect and other sexual offences to ensure they were being dealt with properly and brought to a prompt conclusion.

The team, which is being established within the existing domestic violence and sexual assault investigation unit, will also focus on assisting and training gardai around the country in carrying out inquiries into abuse and promote international standards.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:25 AM

Abuse must never be dismissed: archbishop

CANADA
National Post

Charles Lewis, National Post
Published: Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Roman Catholics should not try to minimize the crisis facing the Church by making reference to the small percentage of abusive priests in their midst or by dismissing reports about the scandal as media exaggeration, Thomas Collins, the Archbishop of Toronto, said yesterday.

"We cannot escape the horror of this by pointing out that almost all priests serve faithfully -- though that fact is a grace that gives joy to the Catholic people," Archbishop Collins said in a homily.

"But even one priest gone wrong causes immense harm, and throughout the world priests have done unspeakable evil."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

Letter of apology unacceptable

CANADA
Windsor Star

By Sandy Cameron, Windsor Star

March 31, 2010 I would think most people might find the Pope's letter of apology absolutely unacceptable. Sorry, it just doesn't cut it. It can be a part of it but the major message should have been: "We take full responsibility and this will not be tolerated."

In his letter, the Pope didn't specifically insist that cases of child sexual abuse be reported to the police by the church. These crimes are decades past being left to the Catholic Church to police itself.

The Pope is the person with the ultimate power in his church. More than anyone, he could -- even at this very late stage -- start protecting children from these monsters.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:20 AM

A troubling order for the Catholic Church

UNTIED STATES
Los Angeles Times

By Tim Rutten

March 31, 2010

One of the decisions confronting Pope Benedict XVI as he struggles to contain an abuse scandal whose tendrils now appear to extend into the Vatican may have a particular resonance in the United States.

That decision involves what to do about a wealthy and influential order, the Legionaries of Christ, and the worldwide lay movement it operates, Regnum Christi. The former includes 800 priests and the latter as many as 75,000 members. Around the globe, the Legionaries operate 120 seminaries, universities, schools and Catholic newspapers. Their ability to recruit future priests in an era of declining vocations has impressed the Vatican; today 2,600 are preparing for ordination in their seminaries.

The Legionaries were founded in Mexico in 1941 by a seminarian, Marcial Maciel, who went on to lead what quickly became the church's fastest-growing religious order and one of its most powerful. That power came from the socially well-connected Maciel's ability to raise astonishing sums of money, and from his insistence on unquestioning loyalty to papal authority.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:17 AM

Sex scandals call for change

UNITED STATES
The Daily Bruin

By Jordan Manalastas

March 31, 2010

It is now Holy Week. In four days, hymns will harmonize, priests will pray, and congregations will congregate to commemorate the most glorious Sunday among the same old, same old: the yearly resurrection of their god. But Catholic churches from Los Angeles to the Vatican have more important things to worry about than Mass turnout or incense supplies. In light of a resurgence in sex scandals among the clergy, the Church must face the repercussions of her ignoble failure of accountability.

Regardless, parishioners across the globe continue to abide. As one Milwaukee Catholic told Wisconsin ABC News, the scandal “hasn’t shaken my faith in the whole institution.” But the institution, dear reader, is exactly the problem.

The Church’s habit of concealing molestation cases and reassigning guilty priests to other parishes – a trend implicating countless priests, bishops and even the Pope – reveals a profound flaw in the system itself. This goes beyond the actions of individual priests and the reckless bishops who enable them. The root of this evil is the Church’s insistence on private self-policing, an asinine opacity that completely disregards the law, the victims and the safety of their communities.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:12 AM

Guilty priests must step down

TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
Trinidad and Tobago's Newsday

By CECILY ASSON Wednesday, March 31 2010

Chairman of the Social Justice Commission Leela Ramdeen on Monday joined Roman Catholic priest Fr Kenneth Assing in mourning for a church that has been “disfigured” by mounting allegations of sex abuse made against several priests.

“The actions of a few have tarnished an entire church when in fact there are millions of Catholics around the world doing good work,” Ramdeen, an attorney, told Newsday.

“We have been betrayed by those who have been put in a position of trust.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:09 AM

An Unholy Holy Week ...

Religion Dispatches

By Anne Eggebroten
March 31, 2010

In the midst of the worst crisis to hit Roman Catholicism in centuries, it is clear that the all-male rule of the Church has failed.

A flock of newly-mitred Cardinals, 2007 This week is unprecedented in the two-thousand-year history of the Christian church. Instead of focusing on the last week of the earthly life of Jesus Christ, Christians are listening to horrific accounts of priestly sexual abuse of children and wondering whether Pope Benedict XVI will take decisive action to cleanse the church.

Probably he will not. After all, he will be 83 years old on April 16, and he just doesn’t get it. His focus has been purity of doctrine, not the purity of those who say Mass and administer the church.

In the US, he has approved an on-going investigation of nuns whose social activism ranges from anti-war activity to challenging the Roman Catholic ban on contraception, married priests, women priests, and acceptance of same-sex relationships. But there’s no investigation of the reasons why widespread sexual activity by priests persists, whether it be child sexual abuse, affairs with parishioners, or “marriages” surrounded by a conspiracy of silence.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:03 AM

The (Re)Reformation of the Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
The Cornell Daily Sun

March 31, 2010
By Mike Wacker

In the wake of the horrendous sex abuse scandal which has afflicted the Catholic Church, criticism of Catholicism in its current form has exploded. Certainly much of the criticism comes with good reason, but simultaneously, one can sense that some critics seem to have a few other motivating factors behind their critiques of the Catholic Church, factors unrelated to the scandal itself.

Sun columnist Peter Finocchiaro ‘10 and New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd have both written on this scandal. Given the topic of these columns, you would expect that if you removed any content not directly related to the sex abuse scandal from them, the columns would contain almost nothing. But instead of nothing, you would find a laundry list of complaints about Catholic doctrines or beliefs, complaints often made outside the context of a sex abuse scandal.

I myself am Lutheran, and for those of you vaguely familiar with the Reformation, you would know I have my own disagreements with Catholicism, including a few but not all of the items on that laundry list. Yet the sex abuse scandal should not become an excuse for any of us to renew our disagreements with Catholicism.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:00 AM

The Catholic Church's Dirty Little Secret

UNITED STATES
New America Media

New America Media, Commentary, Blase Bonpane, Posted: Mar 31, 2010

More than 40 years ago I, was automatically excommunicated from the Catholic Church for "attempting marriage." Our “attempted marriage” was conducted at my parents’ home with four priests presiding together with my bride, the former Sister Maura Killene of Maryknoll who had served in Southern Chile. We have now celebrated four decades together and now have two children and five grandchildren. There is nothing “attempted” about it. It is a wonderful marriage followed by a life of full-time work for justice and peace.

The excommunication has never upset me, mostly because of the guidance of my mother who had admonished me to “take it with a grain of salt.” This was her comment on many ecclesiastical directives, including celibacy. She was very disturbed that I went off to the seminary to become a priest in the first place.

Blase Bonpane”Why don’t they marry? It’s not normal,” she insisted. Both of her parents were born in Italy and they had a wonderful understanding of the irrationality of Canon Law. That’s right. They loved their church and were very comfortable criticizing it and even making fun of it. But as is becoming increasingly clear amid almost daily revelations of sexual abuse among the clergy, much of church behavior is really not funny.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:55 AM

Archbishop: Mistakes made in priest sex abuse case

MILWAUKEE (WI)
CNN

(CNN) -- The archbishop of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, apologized repeatedly Tuesday night for the way his archdiocese handled an abusive priest and he defended the Vatican which has come under fire for not disciplining or defrocking the man.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

Vatican: Three reasons why we are not liable for sexual abuse and cover-ups in the Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
Mail (United Kingdom)

Pope has immunity as head of state

Bishops who oversaw abusive priests were not employed by Vatican

1962 document does not provide proof of cover-up

The Vatican has revealed its three-point defence against an American lawsuit seeking to have the Pope deposed over claims of sexual abuse and cover-ups in the Catholic Church.

The Kentucky case is the first in the U.S. to reach the stage of determining whether victims actually have a claim against the Vatican itself for allegedly failing to alert police or the public about Roman Catholic priests who molested children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:49 AM

Archbishop Listecki: Milwaukee, not Rome at fault in Murphy abuse scandal

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Catholic Culture

Apologizing to victims of clerical abuse, Archbishop Jerome Listecki of Milwaukee said in his March 30 Chrism Mass homily that Milwaukee bishops-- implicitly Archbishop William Cousins (1958-77) and Archbishop Rembert Weakland (1977-2002)-- were at fault in the handling of Father Lawrence Murphy’s abuse of deaf children.

“As a bishop, a priest, and as a man of faith, I apologize to anyone who has been a victim of clergy sexual abuse,” Archbishop Listecki said. “This crime, this sin, this horror, should never occur, especially by a priest. Those who committed these crimes and those, including some bishops, who didn’t do everything in their power to stop it, go against everything the Church and the priesthood represent. For those actions, I offer my sincere apology.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:46 AM

Should There Be an Inquisition for the Pope?

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

By MAUREEN DOWD
Published: March 30, 2010
WASHINGTON

It doesn’t seem right that the Catholic Church is spending Holy Week practicing the unholy art of spin.

Complete with crown-of-thorns imagery, the church has started an Easter public relations blitz defending a pope who went along with the perverse culture of protecting molesters and the church’s reputation rather than abused — and sometimes disabled and disadvantaged — children.

The church gave up its credibility for Lent. Holy Thursday and Good Friday are now becoming Cover-Up Thursday and Blame-Others Friday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:43 AM

Pope has done nothing wrong, says Toronto archbishop

CANADA
Toronto Star

Raveena Aulakh
Staff reporter

Minutes after warning more than 200 priests that there will always be among them those who will betray the innocent, the archbishop of Toronto strongly defended the Pope’s actions during the most serious crisis facing the Roman Catholic Church in decades.

“This is the man who has done so much. He’s led the way,” Archbishop Thomas Collins told reporters in a courtyard of St. Michael’s Cathedral in Toronto. “Of all the people to become the target of attacks in this, the Pope ... good grief.”

Earlier, Collins addressed the congregation at a mass for priests where they renewed their commitment to the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:41 AM

Top speakers for Graigue Novena

IRELAND
Leinster Express

By Staff Reporter
A PRIEST who challenged the handling of child clerical abuse within the Catholic Church as far back the 1990s will be among a list of high profile speakers set to speak about their work and how their faith guides them at the Solemn Novena in Graiguecullen in the coming weeks.

The fourth Solemn Novena to Our Lady of Perpetual Help begins on Monday, April 12 and will run for nine consecutive Monday nights to June 7 at St Clare’s Parish Church Graiguecullen.

Perhaps the most challenging speaker will be Fr Kevin Hearty, a priest in Belmullet, Co Mayo who is a former editor of church’s pastoral and liturgical resource magazine Intercom. He will speak on April 26. Fr Hegarty was moved out of his job as editor after he raised questions over the handling of clerical child sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:38 AM

In Brazil, Catholic Church sees few scandals

BRAZIL
NRC Handelsblad (Netherlands)

Published: 31 March 2010

Brazil is the biggest Catholic country in the world, but accusations of sexual abuse by its clergy are few and don’t get much attention.

By Philip de Wit in Rio de Janeiro

In Arapiraca, a town in the Brazilian state of Alagoas, an unlikely DVD was a bestseller this month: a sex tape showing a 82-year-old priest, Luiz Marques Barbosa, in bed with a 19-year-old altar boy. The images are hard to bear for the people of Arapiraca, who worshiped the priest and even named a school after him.

On March 11, Brazilian TV first aired the sordid pictures of Barbosa. On the programme, former altar boys accused him and two other priests from Arapiraca of sexually abusing them from age 12 onward. Other altar boys from the same parish soon came forward with similar accusations.

The incident has led to great indignation in Arapiraca, where the suspected priests were known as extremely conservative and puritan. Congregants wept openly on TV. The local police has even put a special team on the case. But, contrary to many European countries, the revelations have not led to a stream of complaints over paedophilia within the Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:34 AM

Prosecute peadophile priests: Swiss bishops

SWITZERLAND
Times LIVE (South Africa)

Mar 31, 2010 11:54 AM | By Sapa

Swiss Roman Catholic bishops admit hat they underestimated the extent of sexual abuse by the clergy and called on any victims to seek prosecution.

"We humbly admit that we underestimated the extent of the situation," the Swiss bishop's conference said in a statement.

"Those in charge of the diocese and religious orders made mistakes."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:30 AM

Bishop William Lee issues statement

IRELAND
Waterford Today

Bishop William Lee issues statement regarding his handling of child sexual abuse complaints

Statement of Bishop William Lee issued by the Diocese of Waterford and Lismore Communications office, St. John's Pastoral Centre, John's Hill, Waterford:

"In December 1993, a few months after my ordination as Bishop of Waterford & Lismore, I received complaints of child sexual abuse against a priest of the Diocese. This was the first case of such a nature that I had ever dealt with.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:27 AM

The story of a 40-year cover-up

MILWAUKEE (WI)
News Buzz

By Marie Rohde
An international firestorm raged last week after lawyers released documents linking the cover up of sexual abuse of children in Wisconsin to Pope Benedict XVI. Yet, there is still far more to the story: an extraordinary tale of how countless officials failed to pursue legal charges against the abusive priest, Father Lawrence Murphy. Among these officials were Archbishop Rembert Weakland and his two predecessors as archbishop, former Milwaukee County District Attorney E. Michael McCann and his deputy prosecutor, William Gardner, and St. Francis Police.

All knew about the allegations that Murphy abused boys who were students at the St. John’s School for the Deaf in St. Francis, as NewsBuzz found in reviewing records released by St. Paul lawyer Jeffrey Anderson. Anderson has represented victims in this and other clergy abuse cases.

Some 200 men have by now accused Murphy of sexually abusing them. Critics have charged that church officials seemed more concerned about protecting the church and the priest from dishonor.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:23 AM

March 30, 2010

Edmonton bishop latest to defend Pope in abuse scandal

CANADA
CBC News

Edmonton's Roman Catholic archbishop held a rare news conference Tuesday to say Canada's bishops strongly support Pope Benedict XVI — who has come under fire lately over allegations he covered up sex abuse within the Roman Catholic Church.

Archbishop Richard Smith said he and his fellow Canadian bishops have sent a letter to the Vatican offering the "absolute support and confidence of ... all the bishops of Canada in the clear and decisive leadership of the Holy Father at this time."

Last Friday, Canada’s top Roman Catholic cardinal, Quebec City Archbishop Marc Ouellet, denounced allegations that Pope Benedict XVI covered up cases of sexual abuse committed by priests.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:37 PM

Vatican and Pope Stumble in Response to Abuse Crisis

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By RACHEL DONADIO and DANIEL J. WAKIN
Published: March 30, 2010

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican has been ramping up its defense of how Pope Benedict XVI and the church have handled a growing sexual abuse scandal. But deflecting criticism has proved challenging for this papacy, which has been defined by missteps and difficulties in conveying its message.

Even as the Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, has said that the crisis has threatened the “moral credibility” of the church, he acknowledged in an interview this week that he had not personally discussed the abuse crisis with the pope, a fact he attributed to the structure of the Vatican’s communications apparatus.

“The pope has never avoided the problems of the church,” Father Lombardi said of the sexual abuse issue in an interview on Monday. “He has always expressed his very deep pain and his very deep awareness of the seriousness of what has happened.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:34 PM

Papal Letter to Ireland Seen as Valid for Everyone

ROME
Zenit

ROME, MARCH 30, 2010 (Zenit.org).- Benedict XVI's letter to the Church in Ireland regarding sexual abuse of minors is a "real step forward" in combatting an abominable evil, according to the retired theologian of the pontifical household.

Cardinal Georges Cottier spoke to La Repubblica last week about the Pope's efforts to stop sexual abuse in the Church. He pointed to the Holy Father's "courage" and "firm condemnation."

Regarding the cases of abuse in Ireland, the cardinal contended that oftentimes things were handled too quickly.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:11 PM

Vatican, Catholic officials defend Pope Benedict XVI's record on child abuse cases

VATICAN CITY
Washington Post

By Anthony Faiola
Washington Post staff writer
Wednesday, March 31, 2010

VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican on Tuesday dismissed any notion that Pope Benedict XVI should take personal responsibility for the child sexual abuse scandal rocking the church, defending his management of such cases and vowing that the crisis would not interrupt what historians view as his conservative agenda for Catholics around the world.

The defense of the pope, outlined in an interview Tuesday by the Rev. Federico Lombardi, the Vatican's official spokesman, came as the church hierarchy is launching a public relations blitz in the United States and Europe to ease Catholic anger and bolster the pope's image in sermons and interviews ahead of Easter Sunday.

Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn of Vienna, for instance, this week publicly countered accusations that Benedict turned a blind eye to abuse scandals when, as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, he headed a powerful Vatican office in charge of disciplinary action of the clergy between 1981 and 2005. Schoenborn said that Ratzinger in 1995 pressed for a special investigation into the former archbishop of Vienna, Cardinal Hans Hermann Groer, for allegedly molesting young monks. That push, Schoenborn said, was blocked by aides to then-Pope John Paul II.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:07 PM

Archbishop of Edmonton speaks out after allegations against Catholic church

CANADA
iNews 880

The Archbishop of Edmonton is speaking out after new allegations of sexual abuse among the clergy of the Catholic church re-surfaced in Germany and Ireland.

Archbishop Richard Smith broached the subject last night with Edmonton leaders of the Catholic church, and met again with reporters this afternoon. "Somehow the Pope was involved in the culture of secrecy - all of these different things that you hear out there, that's the impression. I just want to state, categorically, that is not the case. That would be false information. This is a Pope that is addressing this with complete determination and resolution."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 PM

San Angelo Diocese passes annual audit

SAN ANGELO (TX)
Standard-Times

By Michael Kelly
Posted March 30, 2010

SAN ANGELO, Texas — The San Angelo Catholic diocese is in compliance with all directives of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, according to the 2009 annual report on the charter's implementation, the diocese said in an announcement Friday.

The audit was conducted by the Gavin Group of Boston in September, the diocese said. The diocese was commended in the report for conducting safe environment workshops for children, employees and parents and conducting background checks on personnel.

Bishop Michael Pfeifer organized task forces and supported community efforts to protect children throughout the diocese, the announcement said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:57 PM

Priest goes to ground after child concerns

NORTHERN IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Wednesday, 31 March 2010

A Co Tyrone parish priest who was stood down while child safety concerns are investigated has gone to ground.

Fr Sean McEvoy left the parochial house in Aughnacloy at the weekend, and attempts to contact him yesterday were unsuccessful.

Fr McEvoy has been parish priest of Aghaloo for the last six years, and yesterday people in the border community spoke of their shock at the news.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:51 PM

Vatican confirms report of sexual abuse and rape of nuns by priests in 23 countries

VATICAN CITY
The Indpendent (United Kingdom)

[This is a 2001 article but it pre-dates the Tracker and was not previously posted.]

By Frances Kennedy in Rome

Wednesday, 21 March 2001

The Catholic Church in Rome made the extraordinary admission yesterday that it is aware priests from at least 23 countries have been sexually abusing nuns.

Most of the abuse has occurred in Africa, where priests vowed to celibacy, who previously sought out prostitutes, have preyed on nuns to avoid contracting the Aids virus.

Confidential Vatican reports obtained by the National Catholic Reporter, a weekly magazine in the US, have revealed that members of the Catholic clergy have been exploiting their financial and spiritual authority to gain sexual favours from nuns, particularly those from the Third World who are more likely to be culturally conditioned to be subservient to men.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:44 PM

Diocese fights against sex crimes

ALBANY (NY)
CBS 6

March 30, 2010 7:21 PM
Alexandra Field
ALBANY -- As the latest sex scandal rocks the Catholic Church, the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany is fighting to put an end to sex crimes in the Church.

It's an initiative that started eight years ago under order of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. In 2002, the bishops signed the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People. Soon after, the Albany diocese developed a plan to meet the goals of the charter. It's a dual approach aimed at educating young people and training the adults who work for them.

Since the start of the program, the diocese's sexual assault education programs have reached about 35,000 kids a year both in their parishes and schools. John Soja, Assistant Superintendent for Administrative SErvices for Catholic schools says the program is helping the diocese meet goals. " The awareness level and the transperency that is more prevalent nowadays...makes it more comfortable for kids to raise these types of issues and seek help when needed," says Soja.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:41 PM

Catholic League Misleading Ad Smears Gays

NEW YORK
Outcome

NEW YORK CITY — Truth Wins Out today harshly condemned the Catholic League and its President Bill Donohue for its full-page New York Times ad in which the organization served as an enabler for sexual abuse in the Catholic Church and sought to deflect blame for the crisis by smearing the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community.

The offensive ad sought to exonerate the Pope and other priests of blame who are ensnared in a widening sexual abuse scandal that reaches across the globe. Instead of offering an apology for sinful behavior, the Catholic League served as apologists and used the ad to try to deflect the crisis by attacking gay priests.

"This was a disgraceful ad and an unconscionable attempt to smear gay and lesbian people," said Truth Wins Out's Executive Director Wayne Besen. "Clearly, the Catholic League is more interested in finding scapegoats than solutions."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 PM

Church abuse victim wants royal commission

AUSTRALIA
ABC News

Child sex abuse victims of New South Wales Hunter Valley Catholic priests say a full-scale probe into the church's handling of abuse cases will further help the healing process.

Dozens of boys claim to have been abused by members of the clergy in the Maitland-Newcastle diocese since the 1970s.

Several priests have been convicted and others are still before the courts.

A senior Hunter police office believes a wider investigation like a royal commission is warranted.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 PM

Standards for church should be different

WISCONSIN
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Nancy Ettenheim

Posted: March 30, 2010 6:39 p.m. |(0) Comments

As can be expected, the Child Victims Act has generated a lot of heat, both from sexual abuse survivors and from the church. (In this column, I refer to "the church" to mean all religious denominations.) I strongly support the bill and believe it is long overdue.

The church loudly complains that the legislation treats it unfairly, essentially holding it to a higher standard than others. My position is that religious organizations and individuals should and must be held to a higher standard of behavior as well as consequences because they already claim that position for themselves in many ways.

Why? My answer is threefold and resides in the nature of the victim, the perpetrator and the seriousness of child sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:30 PM

Denver Archdiocese responds not to papal scandal but to ‘media frenzy’

DENVER (CO)
The Colorado Independent

By John Tomasic 3/30/10

The Archdiocese of Denver has responded to international reports of sexual abuse and cover up by the Catholic Church in three countries by posting a paragraph on its website not about sexual abuse or coverup or administrative responsibility but about what it calls a “media frenzy.” Archbishop Chaput, the U.S. representative on a special team appointed to investigate a high-profile pedophile priest this year, has yet to address the scandals directly. His office failed to return messages yesterday.

If the comment threads at the Catholic websites he is sending readers to are any measure, though, Chaput’s or the archdiocese’s paragraph critiquing the media will fail to satisfy the restive flock, which seems to be looking for leaders to confront the issue instead of dodging it.

Chaput is not shy to speak in the public sphere on controversial issues. Indeed he has written a book arguing that it is a Catholic obligation to do so. Chaput was one of the loudest Catholic voices in opposing health reform. He went to Texas recently (Texas!) and critiqued Pres. John Kennedy’s reading of Catholicism as a non-controlling factor in his approach to public policy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:27 PM

A call for a Catholic reformation

Washington Post

By Henri Boulad
Egyptian Jesuit

Holy Father,
I dare to speak directly to you for my heart bleeds upon seeing the abyss into which our Church is falling. Hopefully, you will forgive the filial frankness, inspired by the liberty of the children of God to which St. Paul invites us and for my impassioned love for the Church.
I will be pleased also that you forgive the alarmist tone of this letter for I know that little time remains and that the situation remains dire. Let me first tell you a little about myself. I am an Egyptian Lebanese Jesuit of the Melkiterite. I will soon turn 78. For the last 3 years, I have been the rector of the Jesuit school in Cairo. I have also carried out the following responsibilities: superior of the Jesuits in Alexandria, regional superior of the Jesuits in Egypt, professor of theology in El Cairo, director of Caritas-Egypt, and vice president of Caritas International for the Middle East and North Africa.

I am well acquainted with the Catholic hierarchy of Egypt having participated over many years in meetings as president of superiors of the religious orders of Egypt. I have very close relations with each one of them, some of whom are my former students. I also personally know Pope Chenouda III, whom I saw frequently. As far as the Catholic hierarchy of Europe goes, I had the opportunity to meet personally with some of its members such as Cardinal Koening, Cardinal Schonborn, Cardinal Daneels, Cardinal Martini, Archbishop Kothgasser, Bishops Kapellari and Kung, other Austrian bishops and bishops of other European countries. These encounters occurred during my annual trips to give conferences throughout Europe, Austria, Germany, Switzerland, Hungary, France, Belgium, etc. During these visits, I spoke and engaged with diverse audiences and the media (newspapers, radio, television, etc.) I did the same in Egypt and the Near East.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:23 PM

The Vatican’s 3 reasons the Pope can’t be deposed

UNITED STATES
True/Slant

David Knowles

The inevitable has happened. A lawsuit in Kentucky is attempting to have Pope Benedict XVI deposed in a criminal proceeding looking into his role in the ever-widening pedophilia scandal currently rocking the Catholic Church.

The case was filed in 2004 in Kentucky by three men who claim they were abused by priests and claim negligence by the Vatican. Their attorney, William McMurry, is seeking class-action status for the case, saying there are thousands of victims across the country.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:20 PM

Local SNAP leader sets up new chapter in England

ST. LOUIS (MO)
KMOX

Fred Bodimer Reporting
flbodimer@cbs.com

ST. LOUIS (KMOX) -- St. Louisian Barbara Dorris, the National Outreach Director for the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, concluded her European tour Tuesday with a stop in London.

At a news conference outside Westminster Cathedral, Dorris and another SNAP leader Barbara Blaine announced the creation of a new permanent SNAP chapter titled "SNAP England."

"We also called on the Archbishop here to make a national registry of priests and clergy members who have been credibly accused of abuse," said Dorris. "And to open his files to law enforcement."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:01 PM

Petty gossip and unfair intimidation: A look at the real victims of the Vatican sex abuse scandal

Straight

By Mike Cowie

"Indifference is the essence of inhumanity"
—George Bernard Shaw

Hey, did you hear the news? The Vatican sex abuse scandal isn't really about the tens of thousands of little kids who've been raped and abused in all sorts of disturbing ways over the years by their friendly neighborhood clergymen. No, it seems the real issue, at least according to the Vatican and Pope Benedict himself, is the strength and resolve of the Church to not be intimidated by such "petty gossip".

And, yes, "petty gossip" is indeed the term the Pope used to refer to all of this. It's not clear whether he was referring to the Church's systemic worldwide sheltering and protection of habitual child rapists or just the allegations of his own personal involvement in at least two cases of coverups in the year's before he became Pope, but, either way, it's terrific to see him standing up for the true victims in all of this: the poor maligned leaders of the Catholic Church, himself included.

His exact words, reverberating with indignation for justice not yet achieved, referred to "the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:58 PM

Marquette Professor Calls For Pope’s Resignation

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Today's TMJ

By Tom Murray
MILWAUKEE – Marquette’s Daniel Maguire, a religious ethics professor, knows what he has to say goes against what leaders at his university want to hear.

"I met the Pope when he was a Cardinal and he made it clear he did not agree with me on everything,” Maguire told TODAY’S TMJ4 reporter Tom Murray.

Maguire, a former priest, is calling for Pope Benedict to step down.

"That is for two clear reasons,” he said. “Number one, the crime. Number two, the cover up."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:55 PM

Ahearn: A church scandal, a papal response

NEW JERSEY
Daily Record

By JAMES AHEARN
RECORD COLUMNIST

THE ESCALATING scandal in the Roman Catholic Church about sex abuses by rogue priests is rooted in two church doctrines.

The first is that sinners can obtain absolution in the confessional, with the admonition that they go forth and sin no more. Some mend their ways. Some don’t. The plight of a victim is treated as a separate matter.

The second tenet is that scandalous information about the church must be kept secret.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:49 PM

"Our church will no longer be the personal punching bag of the New York Times"

NEW YORK
Beliefnet

Deacon Greg Kandra

That's how Brooklyn's Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio describes the recent coverage of the pope, in his homily at tonight's Chrism Mass.

From the press release:
In his homily to the priests and people of the Diocese of Brooklyn, Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, called upon the priests and people of the Diocese of Brooklyn to stand up with him and "besiege The New York Times. Send a message loud and clear that the Pope, our Church, and bishops and our priests will no longer be the personal punching bag of The New York Times."

Bishop DiMarzio's spirited defense of the Holy Father was based on the decision of The New York Times editors to, "Omit significant facts," and ignore the reality that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which Cardinal Ratzinger headed up, did not have competency over Canonical Trials in 1996. Moreover, Bishop DiMarzio continued "...the priest in question, Father Murphy was in the midst of a Canonical Trial. He died before a verdict was rendered."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:46 PM

Spotlight on pope evokes local priest scandals

LOUISIANA
Daily Comet

John DeSantis
Senior Staff Writer

THIBODAUX — As the world follows allegations that the pope ignored alarms concerning priests accused of sex abuse, two cases with local ties continue creeping through the courts.

Attorneys representing accusers in the local cases say their clients met a “conspiracy of silence” similar to allegations now leveled against Pope Benedict XVI and other high-ranking church officials concerning cases in Germany, Ireland and the U.S.

“Failure to take appropriate action against these priests, failure to weed them out of the ministry, it’s all part of that conspiracy,” said Roger Stetter, one of the attorneys for 24-year-old Jared Ribardi, who accuses the Rev. Etienne LeBlanc, former pastor of Annunziata Catholic Church in Houma, of molesting him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:43 PM

What did Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger know and when?

UGANDA
The New Vision

Tuesday, 30th March, 2010

Opiyo Oloya

AS Christians around the world prepare to celebrate Easter, trouble is brewing about the Vatican’s handling of allegations of sex abuses involving Catholic priests.

At the heart of the scandal is the Catholic Church’s unwillingness to confront the issues of sexual abuse in a forthright manner as Jesus would have. Now, because of that failure, there are growing calls for Pope Benedict XVI to resign.

That is not going to happen. But the Vatican needs to come clean about what Pope Benedict XVI knew and when. The questions surround several cases of alleged sex abuses that the pope handled when he was still known as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. While not all alleged sexual abuses by priests happened under Cardinal Ratzinger’s watch, those raising the most hackles happened during his tenure as the archbishop of Munich, and later as the head of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith.


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:39 PM

Not Throwing Stones: A Protestant Remembers The Best Of The Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Serene Jones

As a Protestant, and as the President of a seminary known for its commitment to progressive theology, my reaction is deeply divided about the sexual abuse crisis that is currently shaking the Roman Catholic Church in Europe and the United States. Watching the disturbing details of cover-ups by clergy -- even those at the highest levels -- unfold during Holy Week, of all times, I can't decide whether to cry out in despair or be ever-so-slightly optimistic that real changes may result from this tragedy. Most days, I feel both.

Tears come easily when I think of the abuse and the horrifying realization that some within the church clearly believe that protecting priests is more important than safeguarding children. When I think of Jesus suffering during Holy Week, it is the broken bodies of children, betrayed by their own religious leaders, that come to mind. They bear the crosses of the church's abuses of power.

That said, I also weep because this latest sex scandal adds to our distrust of religious leadership in general and keeps us from remembering all the good work the Roman Catholic church does for the poor, hungry, and homeless, and has done for many decades. I am personally indebted to countless nuns and priests I've encountered over the years, who patiently taught me what it means to "stand with the least of these." In the twentieth century, especially, it was Roman Catholics rather than liberal, so-called "Main Line" Protestants who more often found spiritual grounds for social justice.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:37 PM

The Pattern of Priestly Sex Abuse

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

Ross Douthot

Reproduced below is a chart from the John Jay Report on sexual abuse in the Catholic priesthood, commissioned by the U.S. Council of Catholic Bishops, showing the number of credible accusations of abuse across the last half-century. It’s part of the basis for my column’s claim that something in the moral/cultural/theological climate of the 1960s and 1970s encouraged a spike in sexual abuse, and also for my assertion that we’ve since seen the church come to grips with the problem, at least in the United States.

It’s important to note that most of these incidents were reported in the 1990s and 2000s, years after they took place. This raises the question of whether the low numbers for the 1950s reflect a real difference between the rate of abuse in the Eisenhower era and the rate in the decades that followed, or whether it’s just that fewer of the victims from the ’50s have come forward with their stories, because of advanced age, greater shame, etc.

There’s no way to be completely certain about this, and clearly there was abuse in the church, and horrid cover-ups as well, going back decades and centuries and more. But the John Jay data suggest that something significant really did shift, and escalate, in the years around the sexual revolution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:33 PM

Reports blaming Pope for mishandled sex abuse case are inaccurate, Church judge reveals

UNITED STATES
Catholic News Agency

Anchorage, Alaska, Mar 30, 2010 / 04:43 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- Reports in the New York Times and other media about a Wisconsin priest who sexually abused deaf children have been “sloppy and inaccurate,” the then-judicial vicar of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee has said. Correcting the public record, he said the claim Pope Benedict XVI was involved in the case is “a huge leap of logic.”

Fr. Thomas Brundage, JLC, former judicial vicar of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, wrote in Anchorage, Alaska’s Catholic Anchor about the case of Fr. Lawrence Murphy, a principal of St. John’s School for the Deaf in Milwaukee.

About 200 former students have said they were molested by Fr. Murphy, sometimes even in the confessional. Outlets such as the Associated Press claim that the priest was “spared a defrocking in the mid-1990s” because he was allegedly “protected by the Vatican office led by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger,” who is now Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:31 PM

How To Prosecute Your Local Priest

Slate

By Juliet Lapidos
Posted Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Pope Benedict XVI continues to face criticism over a 2001 letter he sent advising bishops to forward cases of sexual abuse to the Vatican, rather than suggesting they call the police. Meanwhile, allegations of Catholic priests molesting children have surfaced by the hundreds in Germany, the Netherlands, Ireland, Italy, and the United States. Do the legal systems in those countries allow people to keep mum if they know about a crime?

Sometimes. Generally speaking, the rules are more strict in the United States than in Europe. All states plus the District of Columbia have statutes identifying "mandated reporters" with a "duty to report" suspected child abuse; usually these are professionals who come in frequent contact with kids, including social workers, teachers, physicians, mental health professionals, and law enforcement officers. More than 20 states specifically mention that members of the clergy count as "mandated reporters." Reporting laws often recognize clergy-penitent confidentiality, yet this privilege is interpreted narrowly in a child-abuse context—so if a priest learns of abuse outside the context of confession or counseling, he can be held liable for keeping that information to himself. Canada (which had its own pedophile priest scandal in the 1980s) has laws very comparable to ours. And according to the U.S. Embassy in Italy, Italian law requires any citizen who suspects child abuse to notify law enforcement. But Germany, the Netherlands, and Ireland do not mandate reporting.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:27 PM

Rollback Rollback

UNITED STATES
Newsweek

By The Rev. Richard P. McBrien | Newsweek Web Exclusive

The child sex-abuse scandal in the Catholic priesthood—and the worldwide cover-up that seems, at least indirectly, to have involved Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger before he was elevated to the papacy—has embarrassed the Catholic Church and angered parishioners. It's a good bet Pope Benedict XVI won't resign under pressure; it's not his style and, more importantly, nobody can compel him. But that doesn't mean the scandal will simply go away. Benedict brought a clearly conservative moral agenda to the Vatican, and he has gone about implementing it slowly. Yet until he comes clean on what he knew—and fires bishops who mishandled abuse cases—his changes are likely to stall or fail altogether.

The pope's ideas about the church include his belief that interpreters of Vatican II overly weakened the church's teachings on salvation outside the church (that is, they relaxed the message that only Catholic dogma can lead to salvation), ecumenical relations with other Christian communities, abortion, homosexuality, and contraception, for example. There is already an air of widespread indifference, if not outright opposition, to some of Benedict's objections, such as those related to human sexuality and reproduction.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:23 PM

Listecki To Speak Out On Sex Abuse Crisis

WISCONSIN
WISN

MILWAUKEE -- Milwaukee Archbishop Jerome Listecki is set to publicly address the recent allegations of a cover-up of priest sex abuse in the archdiocese.

The speech comes at a tough time for the Catholic faith, as allegations of abuse cross the globe and enflame even the pope.

Listecki will speak following Mass Tuesday night at St. John's Cathedral.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:19 PM

Vatican offers 3 reasons it's not liable for abuse

VATICAN CITY
Houston Chronicle

By NICOLE WINFIELD Associated Press Writer
March 30, 2010

VATICAN CITY — Dragged deeper than ever into the clerical sex abuse scandal, the Vatican is launching a legal defense that the church hopes will shield the pope from a lawsuit in Kentucky seeking to have him deposed.

Court documents obtained Tuesday by The Associated Press show that Vatican lawyers plan to argue that the pope has immunity as head of state, that American bishops who oversaw abusive priests weren't employees of the Vatican, and that a 1962 document is not the "smoking gun" that provides proof of a cover-up.

The Holy See is trying to fend off the first U.S. case to reach the stage of determining whether victims actually have a claim against the Vatican itself for negligence for allegedly failing to alert police or the public about Roman Catholic priests who molested children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:13 PM

Pope accused in new U.S. predator priest case

UNITED STATES
Canada.com

Agence France-Presse
March 30, 2010 5:03 PM

WASHINGTON - The Vatican and Pope Benedict XVI came under fire in the United States Tuesday for allegedly covering up for another predator priest and doing nothing to remove him from ministry.

Documents sent to AFP by lawyers representing a man who claims he was sexually abused as a teen by Father Ernesto Garcia Rubio claim the Papal Nuncio — the Vatican ambassador to the U.S. — asked the church in Miami to protect Garcia after he moved there from Cuba in 1968 after "serious difficulties of a moral nature."

"He was in ministry here in Miami for about 30 years and during that time we know of about a dozen victims that he abused," said Jessica Arbour, an attorney for the unnamed victim and five others who are suing the archdiocese of Miami for alleged abuse between 1977 and 1987.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:08 PM

Group urges Catholic church to out sex abusers

UNITED KINGDOM
Reuters

The diocese of Westminster could not immediately be reached for comment.

SNAP says it has already been contacted by 45 victims in England looking for help and expects many more to come forward once proper support is in place.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:58 PM

Catholic League says Church crisis is homosexual problem, not child abuse

UNITED STATES
Irish Central

By ANTOINETTE KELLY, IrishCentral.com

The Catholic League says the ongoing Church abuse scandal is a homosexual crisis.

President Bill Donohoe singles out The New York Times for allegedly getting the story wrong saying, "The Times continues to editorialize about the pedophilia crisis while all along it's been a homosexual crisis."

Donohoe took out an ad in the op-ed section of The New York Times Tuesday to broadcast his anti-gay message.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:56 PM

Catholic League Stands by Pope, Catholic Church via NYT Ad

UNITED STATES
Media Bistro

By Kiran Aditham on Mar 30, 2010

In light of the global shitstorm that's surrounded the Vatican, Pope Benedict and the Catholic Church following sexual abuse allegations from Wisconsin to Miami to Germany, Catholic League president Bill Donohue (left) is rushing to the defense of his religious brethren with a quarter-page ad in today's New York Times (below).

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:50 PM

Criticism makes no distinction between the past and what is happening now

NEW ZEALAND
The Dominion Post

Bishop Peter J Cullinane responds to claims the Catholic Church has lost its moral authority over sex-abuse scandals.

New Zealand's Catholic bishops make no excuse whatever for sexual crimes or for errors of judgment in dealing with them. Wrong is wrong.

Like other bishops around the world, the New Zealand bishops feel nothing but shame that such crimes have been committed here or anywhere, and sadness at the slowness of the Church, everywhere, to appreciate the irremediable nature of some not all kinds of sexual offending.

The claim that the Church has lost its moral authority in your editorial refers especially to recent allegations of mismanagement by the Pope. Unfortunately, some media are still disseminating inaccuracies and misleading reports.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:46 PM

Catholic Bishops Praise Pope for Handling of Sex Abuse Crisis

UNITED STATES
NBC Chicago

By MARY ANN AHERN

Chicago's Francis Cardinal George and other U.S. Bishops on Tuesday praised Pope Benedict for his leadership as others question the pontiff's moral credibility in the midst of the current priest sex abuse crisis.

"We know from our experience how Pope Benedict is deeply concerned for those who have been harmed by sexual abuse and how he has strengthened the Church’s response to victims and supported our efforts to deal with perpetrators," George, as the President of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, said in a statement.

"We continue to intensify our efforts to provide safe environments for children in our parishes and schools. Further, we work with others in our communities to address the prevalence of sexual abuse in the larger society."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:43 PM

Judicial Vicar in Fr. Murphy Case: Pope Not Involved, Case Moved "Slow"

WISCONSIN
WTMJ

By Jay Sorgi
MILWAUKEE - Another major player has come forward to give his perspective in a church sex abuse scandal that has linked the case of an abusive priest from Milwaukee to the man who is now Pope.

Fr. Thomas Brundage, who was judicial vicar for the Milwaukee Archdiocese at the time of the case (1996-98), explains that a number of complications extended the length of the case to a point where it could not be completed before the priest accused of child sex abuse, Fr. Lawrence Murphy, passed away.

He also contends that current Pope Benedict XVI had no role in the case, despite recent media reports to the contrary.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:41 PM

NYT’s Ross Douthat Gains Voice as He Reacts to the Pope Scandal Coverage

UNITED STATES
Mediaite

by Michael Triplett | 4:27 pm, March 30th, 2010

Professional angry-Catholic Bill Donohue at the Catholic League is convinced that the New York Times is harassing the Pope and Catholics and he took out an ad in the paper to underscore the point. But it is likely conservative columnist Ross Douthat the folks churning out the reporting on the new scandals that allegedly implicate Pope Benedict XVI are probably more concerned about.

Donahue’s quarter-page ad says the paper is refusing to properly cover what he calls a “homosexual crisis” and that the paper is trying to undermine the church “[b]ecause of issues like abortion, gay marriage and women’s ordination. That’s what’s really driving them mad, and that’s why they are on the hunt.”

The paper’s new revelations about the Pope’s alleged involvement in not moving forward with charges against a pedophile priest in Wisconsin and reinstating a pedophile priest in Munich have been fodder for the paper’s editorial pages, with more than five editorial, op-eds, and columns over the past week.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:38 PM

Vatican supporters strike back

UNITED STATES
Dallas Voice

March 30th, 2010
Below is a scan of an ad that ran in today’s issue of The New York Times. The ad was paid for by the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights, and it ran on the Times’ op-ed page.

Apparently, the Catholic League is unhappy with the Times’ recent coverage of yet another sex scandal in the Catholic Church, this was reaching as high, possibly, as Pope Benedict, with some charging that the pope — back when he was Cardinal Ratzinger — participated in a cover-up of at least one instance of a priest being accused of molesting a child. So the Catholic League ran this ad that, in essence, blames the gays.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:51 PM

Lawyers: Vatican knew of abusive priest

MIAMI (FL)
United Press International

MIAMI, March 30 (UPI) -- The Archdiocese of Miami and the Vatican knew a South Florida priest had "serious difficulties of a moral nature," lawyers for alleged abuse victims say.

Jessica Arbour and Stuart Mermelstein are representing men who say they were abused as children by the Rev. Ernesto Garcia-Rubio, The Miami Herald reports. They say Luigi Raimondi, then the apostolic delegate to Washington, warned Archbishop Coleman Carroll in a secret letter in 1968 that Garcia-Rubio had been "forced to leave Cuba because of serious difficulties of a moral nature," or homosexuality.

"It was a longstanding and well-known secret that the Vatican and Archdiocese of Miami knew exactly what Ernesto Garcia-Rubio was capable of," Arbour said Monday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:47 PM

Bill Donohue shifts goalposts on Church scandals

UNITED STATES
Irish Central

by Cahir O'Doherty

Bill Donohue is at it again. Today he took out a quarter page ad in The New York Times to defend the Church and Pope Benedict from the seemingly endless glut of sexual abuse stories rocking the Church around the world.

For Donohue, the real scandal doesn't appear to be the abuse; it seems to be what he calls a sustained press campaign against the church. If that's true then the abuse was not the problem, the rape, the shaming, the enforced silence; only the revelation of it.

Donohue, the leader of the Catholic League, an organization fellow Irish American Kathy Griffin called “one man in a room in front of a computer,” is switching the goalposts in his effort to defend the Catholic Church from the international, decades long sex abuse crisis it did little or nothing to prevent.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:42 PM

Tracking the Papal Paper Trail on Sex Abuse

UNITED STATES
ProPublica

by Marian Wang, ProPublica - March 30, 2010

Earlier this month, the Vatican denounced what it viewed as a campaign against the pope:

“It’s rather clear that in recent days there have been people who have searched—with notable tenacity in Regensberg and Munich—for elements to personally involve the Holy Father in the question of the abuses,” Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi told Vatican Radio. “To any objective observer, it’s clear that these attempts have failed.”

Observers, in addition to taking in the Vatican’s statement, may want to take a look at what documents are out there, especially since documents—more than statements, accusations or denials—have historically proven useful for revealing the awareness of abuses up the institutional hierarchy. So we’ve compiled a list of documents that have so far been cited in reporting on ties between Cardinal Ratzinger—now Pope Benedict XVI—on the subject of sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:36 PM

Support Benedict XVI from Secular Journalist Terrorism!

Blogger News Network

Posted on March 30th, 2010 by Hugh McNichol

Perhaps it is the right time for all Catholics worldwide to garner support for the bashing the secular press is giving to Pope Benedict XVI. As the visible head of the Catholic Church, Pope Benedict is an easy target for the secular press and collective media that has any type of anti-Catholic grudge that offers at opportunity at sensationalism. Some secular journalists are waging a ad hominem attack against the Pope as a larger delivery method of anti-Catholic rhetoric.

The personal attacks aimed at Benedict XVI are not justified and reflect a growing and pervasive attempt to discredit the activities of good priests, bishops and religious of both sexes that faithfully serve the world’s Catholic faithful without any involvement in scandals. While there are quite a few examples of sexual abuse that are surfacing throughout the Catholic world, most of the reported cases are extremely dated and quite frankly old. When these cases are considered, Catholics and indeed all observers need to ask why the allegations of abuse were unreported for decades by scores of allegedly abused victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:36 PM

Pope under the spotlight

MALTA
Times of Malta

As Malta prepares for Pope Benedict XVI's visit on April 17 and 18, he faces increasing scrutiny over cases of sexual abuse by priests. Could this taint the Pope's image in the eyes of Maltese Catholics? Will it affect the enthusiastic welcome he is expected to receive from the people? By Cynthia Busuttil and Claudia Calleja.

The sex abuse scandal rocking the Roman Catholic Church is not expected to overshadow the visit of Pope Benedict XVI to Malta next month.

The Vatican last week attacked what it called an "ignoble attempt" to smear the Pope himself with allegations that, while still a cardinal, he had some part in covering up sexual abuse of children by priests. Protestors in London have gone so far as to demand his resignation.

Sociologist Rev. Joe Inguanez is one of those who believe the impact of the allegations will not be widespread in Malta, an overwhelmingly Catholic country.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:32 PM

Catholicism in turmoil

MSNBC

[with video]

WARSAW, Poland - An Austrian priest avoids mention of Pope Benedict XVI in his Masses. A Philadelphia woman stops going to confession, saying she now sees priests as more flawed than herself. British protesters call for the pontiff to resign.

As the faithful fill churches this Holy Week, many Roman Catholics around the world are finding their relationship to the church painfully tested by new revelations of clerical abuse and suggestions Benedict himself may have helped cover up cases in Germany and the U.S.

There are fears that for those whose commitment is already wavering, the scandal could be the final blow, and a growing chorus is clamoring for the church to embrace full transparency, take a hard line against pedophiles, and reconsider the rule of priestly celibacy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:17 PM

The Demons of Pope Benedict XVI

VATICAN CITY
Spiegel (Germany)

By Alexander Smoltczyk

The case of an American priest who abused deaf children for years has shaken the Vatican. Detailed information about the sexual misconduct of the Rev. Lawrence Murphy went across the desk of Cardinal Ratzinger prior to his papacy. Abuse allegations in Italy are also putting the Catholic Church in an increasingly tough spot.

It is late on a Thursday evening at the Vatican and it is already beginning to look like Easter. St. Peter's Square is brightly lit, and groups attending a world youth forum are in high spirits as they sing and clap to celebrate their pope, clad in immaculate white, who has just spoken about the "Feast of the Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin," behaving "as if nothing at all had happened."

These are the words of Peter Isely. Standing on a street corner one block away from the spectacle, he is determined to spoil the pope's festival of redemption. Isely has come to Rome all the way from Milwaukee, in the US state of Wisconsin. He is a 49-year-old psychotherapist with a buzz cut and a question that has been on his mind since he was 13: "Why is my church the only institution where pedophiles continue to be employed?"

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:09 PM

Pope Faces a 'Scourging by Words', says Former Student and Publisher

UNITED STATES
Earned Media

SAN FRANCISCO, March 30 /Christian Newswire/ -- As nearly one billion Catholics enter Holy Week, their chief shepherd faces attacks in newspapers, blogs, twitter posts, and television and radio news. Unfortunately, the primary news sources repeatedly fail to report accurate timelines and crucial details. The impression is left that Pope Benedict XVI is part of the problem, rather than leading the way to solving it. Consequently, concerned Catholics and others are agitated and confused.

Pope Benedict's former student speaks out in support of the Pope and responds to the lack of responsible journalism on this story.

"Benedict the XVI is only infallible as an authoritative teacher of the Faith, not as an administrator. He certainly may have made some mistakes, even serious ones, in the 33 years since he was first made a bishop. But there is no evidence for the ones he's being blamed for in the media; for those who know the facts, the evidence leads to just the opposite conclusion. Like the Master he serves, he's also, after 33 years, being publically scourged, this time with words," Jesuit Father Joseph Fessio says.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:37 PM

U.S. Bishops Voice Concern for Victims of Clergy Sexual Abuse, Thank Pope Benedict for Leadershi

UNITED STATES
PRNewswire

WASHINGTON, March 30 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The U.S. bishops March 30 voiced concern for victims of child sexual abuse by clerics and praised Pope Benedict XVI for leadership in dealing with the sin and crime of child sexual abuse.

"We know from our experience how Pope Benedict is deeply concerned for those who have been harmed by sexual abuse and how he has strengthened the Church's response to victims and supported our efforts to deal with perpetrators," the bishops said. "We continue to intensify our efforts to provide safe environments for children in our parishes and schools. Further, we work with others in our communities to address the prevalence of sexual abuse in the larger society."

The bishops' comments came in a statement issued by the Executive Committee of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops: Cardinal Francis George, OMI, of Chicago, president; Bishop Gerald Kicanas of Tucson, Arizona, vice-president; Archbishop Joseph Kurtz of Louisville, treasurer; Bishop George Murry, SJ of Youngstown, Ohio, secretary; and Bishop Arthur Serratelli of Paterson, New Jersey, elected member.

A Personal Issue, The Catholic Church Scandal

Reader Supported News

By John Cory, Reader Supported News
28 March 2010

My views on child abuse and child molestation are harsh and unforgiving and forged by the fires of my own childhood. I give no quarter on this issue.

I have no kind words or forgiving thoughts for the Catholic hierarchy or their enablers, which brings me to Bill Donohue's article on the CNN Opinion web site. You can read what he says here but I'll give you my version:

Child abuse and molestation is bad but this stuff happened a long time ago and times were different then and besides everyone does it including churches, schools, businesses and even the Jews. This is all about picking on the Catholic Church for headlines.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:17 PM

Going for the Vatican Jugular

UNITED STATES
Bishop.Accountability.org

By Bill Donohue
Catholic League
Advertisement in the New York Times
March 30, 2010

[This ad was scanned from the print edition of the New York Times by BishopAccountability.org. See also an image of the ad with a PDF. Donohue is discussing Vatican Declined to Defrock U.S. Priest Who Abused Boys, by Laurie Goodstein, New York Times, March 24, 2010, with the documents posted on the web to accompany the article. See also For Years, Deaf Boys Tried to Tell of Priest’s Abuse, by Laurie Goodstein and David Callender, New York Times, March 26, 2010.]

Recent accusations against the Vatican deserve a response.

• Fr. Lawrence Murphy apparently began his predatory behavior in Wisconsin in the 1950s, yet the victims' families never contacted the police until the mid-1970s. After an investigation, the case was dropped.

• The Vatican did not learn of the case until 1996.

• Cardinal Ratzinger, now the pope, was the head of the office that was contacted. There is no evidence that he knew of it. But even if he did, he would have had to allow for an investigation. While the inquiry was proceeding, Murphy died.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:12 PM

Going for the Vatican Jugular

UNITED STATES
BishopAccountability.org

This links to a copy of the advertisement from the Catholic League.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:07 PM

A Response to the New York Times

National Review

[Fr. Raymond J. de Souza]

The New York Times on March 25 accused Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, of intervening to prevent a priest, Fr. Lawrence Murphy, from facing penalties for cases of sexual abuse of minors.

The story is false. It is unsupported by its own documentation. Indeed, it gives every indication of being part of a coordinated campaign against Pope Benedict, rather than responsible journalism.

Before addressing the false substance of the story, the following circumstances are worthy of note:

• The New York Times story had two sources. First, lawyers who currently have a civil suit pending against the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. One of the lawyers, Jeffrey Anderson, also has cases in the United States Supreme Court pending against the Holy See. He has a direct financial interest in the matter being reported.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:03 PM

Indian holy man calls sex tape 'false campaign'

INDIA
BBC News

A Hindu holy man in India has denied any wrongdoing, days after video emerged apparently showing him engaging in sexual acts with two women.

A spokesman for Nithyananda Swami said he was at the Kumbh Mela festival and would soon "clear the air".

In a video released on Sunday, the guru said he had done nothing illegal and the scandal was "a false campaign".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:07 AM

Schönborn, Ratzinger, and Groër

UNITED STATES
Leon J. Podles: Dialogue

Now that he has made a public statement, I feel I can now reveal what Cardinal Schönborn told me two years ago.

I know him a little, and I sent him my book Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church. We met in San Diego, and I asked him what he thought of the book, especially the section on his predecessor, Cardinal Groër. I wondered whether I had understood all the German sources correctly.

Schönborn said the situation was worse than I knew. Groër had molested almost every student he had come into contact with for decades. After Groër was accused of this abuse, John Paul II continued to receive Groër socially in the Vatican, and tens of thousands of Austrians were resigning from the Church in protest.

Schönborn in person pleaded with John Paul to make a statement about Groër. John Paul replied that he would like to, but “they won’t let me.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:57 AM

Bishop Duffy says he has no questions to answer in Fermanagh abuse case

IRELAND
Donegal Democrat

A spokesperson for the Bishop of Clogher said this week he had not been made aware of any allegations against de-frocked priest Jeremiah McGrath.

The spokesperson told a reporter from The Irish News that the Bishop, whose diocese includes parts of south Donegal, that once the PSNI informed the bishop of claims against McGrath, he co-operated fully with the investigations.

McGrath, who was born in Kerry, served as parish priest in the Fermanagh town of Roslea. He was convicted at Liverpool Crown Court in 2007 for assisting and facilitating the rape of a 12-year-old schoolgirl by his lover, convicted rapist Billy Adams

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:53 AM

Listecki To Address Clergy Abuse From Pulpit

MILWAUKEE (WI)
WTMJ

By Tom Murray

MILWAUKEE - Archbishop Jerome Listecki plans to address the latest developments in the clergy abuse scandal during the Tuesday evening Chrism Mass at the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist. Representatives from every parish in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee are expected to be in attendance.

Listecki defends the Pope's handling of clergy abuse cases.

"This Pope really did recognize that response and was on the forefront of reparation," Listecki told TODAY'S TMJ4 reporter Tom Murray.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:49 AM

Papalgate: The Pope's Nixon Problem

UNITED STATES
The Atlantic

The ever-widening scandal over Pope Benedict XVI’s handling of Church sex abuse cases has an eerily familiar ring: it's unfolding in much the same way that Watergate played out for Richard Nixon. Each day brings new revelations, to which the Pope and his supporters respond with carefully crafted explanations and pointed counterattacks.

Is this Watergate with holy water? Here’s a look at some of the ways in which Pope Benedict XVI has found himself caught up in a scandal of Nixonian proportions…

What Did He Know and When Did He Know It?

During the Watergate hearings, Senator Howard Baker famously posed the question that came to define the case against Richard Nixon: "What did the President know and when did he know it?" There’s ample evidence that Nixon had no prior knowledge of the Watergate break-in. So the crucial question became, What did Nixon do once he found out about White House involvement in the crime?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:43 AM

Hundreds of cases of clerical abuse reported

AUSTRIA
Austrian Independent

There have been 566 reports of various kinds of abuse by clergy at the Catholic Church’s ombudsman’s offices this year, it was reported today (Tues).

Vienna archdiocese has had the highest number, 174, followed by Innsbruck diocese with 115. More than half of them can no longer be prosecuted because of the statute of limitations.

Cases of sexual abuse constitute 27 per cent of these, cases of violence 26 per cent. More than half of them require further investigation, according to the media.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:39 AM

Church judge in Wisconsin priest’s trial speaks out

UNITED STATES
San Francisco Examiner

Online Opinion Editor
03/30/10

Over at Catholic Anchor, the ecclesiastical judge in the case of the Wisconsin priest who molested hundreds of deaf children is speaking out. His long piece on what really happened there suggests that there has been much sloppy reporting attempting to establish a tenuous link between the horrific case of Father Lawrence Murphy and Pope Benedict, decades after Murphy sexually abused scores of deaf children.

This short excerpt won’t be enough to catch you up on the case if you haven’t been following it, but if you have, then I think it’s worth reading:

[I]n a letter from [Milwaukee] Archbishop Weakland to then-secretary of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone on August 19, 1998, Archbishop Weakland stated that he had instructed me to abate the proceedings against Father Murphy. Father Murphy, however, died two days later and the fact is that on the day that Father Murphy died, he was still the defendant in a church criminal trial. No one seems to be aware of this. Had I been asked to abate this trial, I most certainly would have insisted that an appeal be made to the supreme court of the church, or Pope John Paul II if necessary. That process would have taken months if not longer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:35 AM

Jerbal Infallibility

ORANGE COUNTY (CA)
Orange Juice

Within Roman Catholic theology there is a dogma of Papal infallibility under which the faithful believe that the Pope is protected from the possibility of error when “making a statement on faith or morals”. Well appearently if we are to believe the ever increasingly pious Matt Cunningham he has “Jerbal infallibility”.

Cunningham who is best know for his outing the names of Catholic Church sexual abuse victims in order to intimidate them and scare other victims from coming forward continues to tell anyone that will listen it was just a simple mistake on his part. In “Jerbal’s” sick mind it was “no harm, no foul”. Unfortunately the victims feel much differently about his actions.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:27 AM

Sex Abuse Statute Limitations Move Closer To Elimination

CONNECTICUT
NBC Connecticut

By a vote of 23 to 20, the state's Judiciary Committee voted on Monday to eliminate the statute of limitations in civil cases involving child sexual abuse.

The committee sent the bill, on a 23-20 vote, to the House of Representatives for further action.

The proposal is a direct result of the case involving the late Dr. George Reardon. He died in 1998, but in 2007 a worker renovating his former West Hartford home found thousands of slides and hundreds of movie reels of child pornography. Nearly 150 lawsuits have been filed against St. Francis Hospital in Hartford, where Reardon worked.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:24 AM

Healing Survivors, Ending Abuse

UNITED STATES
Healing and Spirituality

Dr. Jaime Romo

Mar 29th, 2010

An ancient Vedic text says, “You are your deepest driving desire. As is your desire, so is your will as is your will, so is your deed. As is your deed, so is your destiny. Therefore, your desires can become your destiny.”

If we really want healing and an end to sexual abuse, it requires us to shift, in some small and big ways: different words, thoughts, actions to connect us to what we really really want.

When I was finishing my doctoral studies, people asked me what I wanted to accomplish with my dissertation. I answered as many in the same position answered, after having gone through a six year process of learning and then applying my own ideas; after working with sometimes challenging or harsh feedback about whether I really knew what I was talking about. I said that I wanted my dissertation to change the world.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:17 AM

The Pope's message

CANADA
Toronto Star

As Roman Catholics reel from the latest child abuse scandals, Pope Benedict's every word is being scrutinized for a sign that he gets it. That the Vatican truly grasps how appalled Catholics are by the victims' anguish and the cover-ups. And that Rome will do better.

By that standard, Benedict's Palm Sunday homily was a missed opportunity. Rather than face the latest crisis head on, and the pain and the need for reform, he came across as defensive. He said faith provides "the courage that does not let itself be intimidated by the gossip of dominant opinions." He also extolled "the loyalty that stands with the other even when the situation makes it difficult."

Surely the abuse scandal is more than "gossip," to be stifled by the church reflexively closing ranks. That is how this crisis grew.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:12 AM

Group says abuse victims under attack by pope

MILWAUKEE (WI)
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Annysa Johnson of the Journal Sentinel

Posted: March 30, 2010

Milwaukee advocates for victims of clergy sex abuse called on Pope Benedict XVI and Catholic Church officials Monday to curtail what they see as verbal attacks on victims in the wake of the abuse scandal enveloping the Vatican.

In a protest organized by the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, victims stood on the steps of the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist holding handmade signs saying "stop attacking us" and "I'm not 'petty gossip' " - references to quotes by Benedict and others since last week's revelation that the Vatican failed to remove a Wisconsin priest who is believed to have molested as many as 200 deaf boys over decades.

"Hundreds and hundreds of wounded victims are finding the courage to speak up," said victim Mary Guentner.

"They should be praised  . . .  and instead they're being vilified."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:09 AM

The Pope Should Step Down...For Now

UNITED STATES
NPR

by Kenneth Briggs

Kenneth Briggs writes for the National Catholic Reporter. He's a professor at Lafayette College professor and a former New York Times religion editor.

The predicament that surrounds Pope Benedict XVI has cast suspicion on his behavior without yet delivering a clear-cut verdict. The unanswered questions related to whether he covered up priests who were child abusers are troubling enough to paralyze his papacy, even though the power of his office cannot be diminished. But he has been convicted of nothing. Fairness dictates that he remain pope until or unless he is judged guilty.

My proposal, therefore, is that Benedict take a leave of absence until his case is cleared one way or another. He should ask for a full investigation by both secular and church agencies and step aside until the results are in. If he fails to clear his name, he would be honor bound to resign. A refusal to invite such tough scrutiny would be widely seen as admission of wrongdoing. Otherwise, he could return with a clean slate.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:06 AM

Italian Church to help courts on child abuse

ITALY
RTE News

Italy's Roman Catholic Church says it will help to bring paedophile priests to justice after the country's bishops ruled that it was right to do so under Canon law.

The Italian conference of bishops stressed concern for the victims of sexual abuse and their families as they met in Rome to address the widening scandal embroiling the Church in Europe and the US.

'The key to searching for the truth is to enforce the procedures and penal rules of Canon law with rigour and transparency,' the episcopal conference said in a statement after the talks.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:04 AM

“Many guilty priests would still be considered priests”

LOS ANGELES (CA)
California Catholic Daily

(Editor’s Note: The following is from a Sunday, March 28, entry from the website “Cardinal Roger Mahony Blogs L.A.” under the heading, “Thank you, Cardinal Ratzinger.”)

While I have no personal information on some of the specific allegations against our Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, when he served the Church of Munich in Germany, I am able to assert without hesitation the action steps which he undertook in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith when he served as Prefect of that Congregation.

Beginning in that dark year of 2002, the then Cardinal Ratzinger responded quickly and affirmatively to all of our requests for assistance here in the United States.

Recall that Canon 1324, par. 4, states that in Canon Law a minor is a person under the age of 16 years. However, in the civil laws of the United States, a minor is deemed to be a person under the age of 18 years. After we brought this gap to the attention of Cardinal Ratzinger, the canonical age was also raised to 18 years to accommodate civil law in our country and in other countries.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:01 AM

Ex-Christ the King boys basketball coach Bob Oliva to be arraigned on sex abuse charges April 12

BOSTON (MA)
New York Daily News

By Michael O'Keeffe
Daily News Sports Writer

Tuesday, March 30th 2010

Bob Oliva, the former Christ the King Regional High School boys basketball coach, will be arraigned April 12 in Suffolk (Mass.) Superior Court in Boston on sex abuse charges.

Oliva, the influential former coach who won four CHSAA Class AA intersectional titles and coached Lamar Odom and Jayson Williams before they became NBA stars, was indicted last week by a Massachusetts grand jury on two counts of rape of a child. He could be sentenced to life in prison if convicted.

Prosecutors say Oliva raped a 14-year-old boy at the Boston Sheraton during a visit to Massachusetts in 1976 to attend a Red Sox-Yankees doubleheader at Fenway Park.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:54 AM

The Pope Should Stay ... For Now

UNITED STATES
NPR

by David Clohessy

David Clohessy is the director of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests

If the Pope were to resign (highly unlikely), it would no doubt bring short-term comfort to tens of thousands of deeply wounded and still suffering clergy-sex-abuse victims across the globe. It would also provide some hope for millions of Catholics who desperately want to believe that their church hierarchy is capable of reform. It might temporarily scare and deter others who have, are or might be reckless, callous or deceitful regarding child safety.

But there's plenty it would not do. It wouldn't end centuries of secrecy in an ancient, rigid, self-perpetuating, all-male monarchy. It wouldn't unearth volumes of carefully-concealed church records that contain names of predator priests and complicit bishops, some or many of whom are still in parishes and chanceries across the globe. It wouldn't strengthen efforts to reform archaic, predator-friendly laws that enable corrupt employers to hire and shield offenders while jeopardizing kids.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:51 AM

The Pope, the judge, the paedophile priest and The New York Times

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Damian Thompson

Fr Thomas Brundage, the former Archdiocese of Milwaukee Judicial Vicar who presided over the canonical criminal case of the Wisconsin child abuser Fr Lawrence Murphy, has broken his silence to give a devastating account of the scandal – and of the behaviour of The New York Times, which resurrected the story.

It looks as if the media were in such a hurry to to blame the Pope for this wretched business that not one news organisation contacted Fr Brundage. As a result, crucial details were unreported.

Moreover, Fr Brundage – who seems to have shown admirable tenacity in pursuing the loathsome Fr Murphy – claims that a document of questionable provenance was quoted authoritatively by the media as a source for his own opinions. At the very least, The New York Times and many other organisations have some explaining to do. They must be held to account for the way they pursued this story, which led to hysterical attacks on Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 AM

Setting the record straight in the case of abusive Milwaukee priest Father Lawrence Murphy

UNITED STATES
Catholic Anchor

By Fr. THOMAS BRUNDAGE, JLC
For CatholicAnchor.org

To provide context to this article, I was the Judicial Vicar for the Archdiocese of Milwaukee from 1995-2003. During those years, I presided over four canonical criminal cases, one of which involved Father Lawrence Murphy. Two of the four men died during the process. God alone will judge these men.

To put some parameters on the following remarks, I am writing this article with the express knowledge and consent of Archbishop Roger Schwietz, OMI, the Archbishop of Anchorage, where I currently serve. Archbishop Schwietz is also the publisher of the Catholic Anchor newspaper.

I will limit my comments, because of judicial oaths I have taken as a canon lawyer and as an ecclesiastical judge. However, since my name and comments in the matter of the Father Murphy case have been liberally and often inaccurately quoted in the New York Times and in more than 100 other newspapers and on-line periodicals, I feel a freedom to tell part of the story of Father Murphy’s trial from ground zero.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:43 AM

The idea that the Vatican helped Nazi leader Adolf Eichmann escape ...

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

Guy Walters

With the Roman Catholic Church now supposedly responsible for every evil on the planet, it came as no surprise to read in the Jerusalem Post that the Vatican “aided” Adolf Eichmann’s escape to Argentina. This accusation is made annually by hacks eager to do their bit of pontiff-baiting, but unfortunately for them, it is complete tosh. Yes, members of the Catholic Church certainly helped Eichmann escape, but there is no evidence that suggests that the Vatican as an institution helped Nazis on their way to South America and the Middle East (an often overlooked retirement destination for pensioned fascists). This distinction between individuals and an institution is an important one to make – one bent copper does not make a corrupt police force.

Like all institutions, the Catholic Church has its share of rotten apples, and historians are fairly knowledgeable about the ones who helped Eichmann. These include the members of the St Raphael Community in Bavaria, and a Franciscan called Edoardo Dömöter in Genoa. Some, such as Simon Wiesenthal, supposed that Eichmann went to Rome to receive the assistance of Bishop Alois Hudal, but this is nonsense. I’ve looked through Hudal’s archives in Rome, and although names such as Franz Stangl and Erich Priebke pop up, there is no mention of Eichmann or of his alias, Riccardo Klement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:35 AM

Judiciary Committee Passes Proposal To Change Statute Of Limitations On Sexual Abuse Civil Lawsuits

CONNECTICUT
The Hartford Courant

By ARIELLE LEVIN BECKER

March 30, 2010

HARTFORD — - A proposal to change the statute of limitations for civil lawsuits in child sexual abuse cases cleared the judiciary committee by a 23-20 vote Monday but only after lawmakers revised it to maintain some restrictions on those currently barred from suing.

Under current law, victims of child sexual abuse have until they turn 48 — 30 years after they turn 18 — to file lawsuits. The original proposal, inspired in part by pending sexual abuse lawsuits involving St. Francis Hospital and Medical Center, would have eliminated the statute of limitations for civil cases involving child sexual abuse, assault or exploitation.

But after a public hearing during which victims of sexual abuse supported the change and representatives of the Roman Catholic Church opposed it, lawmakers changed the proposal, allowing victims 48 and older to sue only if they can clear certain hurdles.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:32 AM

Group calling for change in Catholic church to hold vigil

CANADA
Telegraph-Journal

BRUCE BARTLETT
Telegraph-Journal

SAINT JOHN - While officials in the Catholic church are fighting allegations that the cover-up of sexual abuse of children by priests leads to the very highest levels, a grassroots group remains committed to fighting for changes from within.

This evening, members of the Catholic Network for Women's Equality will gather for a purple stole vigil outside the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception on Waterloo Street. Inside, the annual mass of the holy chrism, a celebration of the institution of the priesthood, will be taking place as part of the week leading up to Easter. The vigil begins at 6 p.m.

"We've had a purple stole vigil since 2003," said Cathy Holtmann, a spokeswoman for the network in New Brunswick.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:28 AM

More Sources of the Scandal

UNITED STATES
America Magazine

At its deepest level, the sexual abuse crisis, and most especially the manner in which the hierarchy has responded to it, entails profound cultural issues. Yesterday, I looked at two issues that were proximate to the crisis, but today I would like to look at a couple of issues that are more deeply ingrained in the culture of the Church and the habits of its leaders.

In his book The Difference God Makes, Cardinal Francis George writes of our contemporary American culture: "Everything is possible, but nothing can be forgiven." He contrasts this with what a faithful, Catholic culture would demand. "Faith, by contrast, says that many things cannot be done," Cardinal George writes. "But, in the end, everything can be forgiven." This profound difference between the ecclesiastical culture and the mainstream culture informed the sexual abuse crisis from start to finish. And, I should add, the Church owes no one an apology for believing that God’s mercy can reach to all man’s sins, even the sins of the pedophiles. But, the promise of God’s mercy became something to hide behind, instead of an invitation to repentance. The bishops imagined themselves in the role of the father in the story of the Prodigal, welcoming back their errant priests, getting them counseling and therapy, and returning them to their prior status, as if what the priests had done was only a sin and not also a crime.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:24 AM

Sex abuse files surface in Boy Scout, Mormon case

OREGON
Oregon Faith Report

March 30, 2010

Faith Report News Note:

An Oregon sex abuse case could uncover a secret Boy Scout file of Scout leader sexual abusers. Some have labeled the records as the “Perversion Files”. A Portland lawyer, Kelly Clark, has obtained over 1,000 of these records. Because the Mormon Church was a charter organization, they are also named in the case.

KVAL reports more on the story,“At the start of the Oregon trial, attorney Kelly Clark recited the Boy Scout oath and the promise to obey Scout law to be “trustworthy.” Then he presented six boxes of documents that he said will show “how the Boy Scouts of America broke that oath.” He held up file folder after file folder he said contained reports of abuse from around the country, telling the jury the efforts to keep them secret may have actually set back efforts to prevent child abuse nationally. “The Boy Scouts of America ignored clear warning signs that Boy Scouts were being abused,” Clark said

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:21 AM

A pope with a problem

UNITED STATES
Sacramento Bee

By TIM RUTTEN
Los Angeles Times
Published: Tuesday, Mar. 30, 2010

This has been a tough Lent for the Roman Catholic Church. Its seemingly endless sexual abuse scandal finally has seeped into the papal apartments, and the Vatican's response to this week's revelations suggests that far too little has been learned from this squalid affair.

Until now, Pope Benedict XVI had seemed to be taking a far more forthright approach to the problem than his predecessor, John Paul II, most recently in a blistering "pastoral letter" to the entire Irish church.

Last week, however, the New York Times published a pair of stories suggesting that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger - the future Pope Benedict - participated in precisely the sort of secrecy and administrative negligence that has been at the root of this scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:03 AM

Hindus ask Pope to issue “white paper” on global Church sex scandal

The 300 News Daily

Hindus want Pope to urgently come up with a white paper on reportedly mushrooming global sex scandal engulfing the Roman Catholic Church, which they called “unprecedented and shocking”.

Acclaimed Hindu statesman Rajan Zed, in a statement in Nevada (USA) today, said that this authoritative paper should truthfully address the reported worldwide sexual abuse crisis the Church was facing; and then list the solutions, action program and implementation schedule. A monitoring body should also be established for future.

Zed, who is president of Universal Society of Hinduism, further said that instead of church officials pointing fingers at the “hostile media”, consumerism, and secularism; His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI should publicly acknowledge the reported past mistakes of the Church on this issue, apologize, and clarify his personal role in the crisis.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:00 AM

Nothing but the truth

UNITED STATES
U.S. Catholic

A U.S. Catholic interview
Judge Anne M. Burke reviewed her years monitoring the U.S. church's response to the clergy sex abuse crisis.

As the wife of a veteran Chicago alderman, Judge Anne M. Burke has seen her share of political intrigue up close. But not even Chicago politics, she says, adequately prepared her for the "medieval, certainly Byzantine machinations" she encountered during the two and a half years she served on the National Review Board.

The U.S. bishops appointed this 13-member board of lay Catholics at the height of the clergy sex abuse crisis to oversee their compliance with the reforms they had pledged to institute. But many of the bishops, it seems, were surprised when the board took its job seriously and went to work. Accustomed to having laypeople only give them advice they could choose to follow or ignore, some bishops were taken aback when the board publicly called them to task for foot-dragging or for efforts to obstruct or circumvent agreed-upon processes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 AM

Destiny pastors accused of abuse leave church

NEW ZEALAND
3 News

Destiny Church Taranaki pastors Lee and Robyn Edmonds have quit their roles amid allegations of sexual misconduct against two family members.

In a statement issued by the church today, spokesman Richard Lewis said "management" had accepted the couple's offer to stand down and would be looking into the circumstances of both cases.

One of the matters, against a 29-year-old man, is already before the courts. He is next due to appear in New Plymouth District Court in May. The other allegation is against a woman.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:54 AM

Pillar of Truth

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Wayne Trujillo

Earlier this month, a Boulder Catholic school created a stir when it expelled a student whose parents are lesbians because, according to the Denver Archdiocese, the parents are "living in open discord with Catholic teaching." After reading the recent New York Times report about the latest set of revelations involving Catholic priests, children and cover-ups that allegedly extend to the top tiers of the Vatican, which drew a quick and indignant response from Rome, it seems to me that the Catholic hierarchy should be quicker to kick out wayward priests rather than children. Or is the operative word "open"? Those errant priests, while not exactly conducting themselves in exactly a saintly manner, were living in "closed" discord with Catholic teaching. The whole affair seems like a canonical refrain of the military's "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." Much of the anger directed toward the Catholic Church over these scandals, aside from travesty of the pedophilia within its midst on an international scale, are its largely static and secretive responses when informed by its members of the problems.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:51 AM

Archbishop criticised on handling of abuse issue

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY Religious Affairs Correspondent

ARCHBISHOP DIARMUID Martin has been strongly criticised by a former spokesman for his predecessor as Archbishop of Dublin, Cardinal Desmond Connell, over his handling of the clerical sex abuse issue.

The criticism by Eddie Shaw, who was spokesman for Cardinal Connell from September 2002 to October 2003, is contained in a book, The Dublin/Murphy Report: A Watershed for Irish Catholicism?, launched yesterday.

In the book Mr Shaw criticises what he claims is Archbishop Martin’s failure to support the auxiliary bishops of his diocese in the fall-out from the Murphy report.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:48 AM

Bishop says he met up to 80 victims of sexual abuse

IRELAND
The Irish Times

GORDON DEEGAN

THE BISHOP of Killaloe, Dr Willie Walsh has confirmed that he has met 70-80 victims of sex abuse during his time as bishop.

Dr Walsh said the victims were abused by the religious and clergy and also lay people, inside and outside the diocese.

“I do believe that I tried every time to treat every victim with respect and kindness and sympathy and I do have a sense of their dreadful pain,” he said in an interview.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:45 AM

Judiciary Committee Approves Extending Statute Of Limitations; Related To Case Of Dr. Reardon At St. Francis

CONNECTICUT
The Hartford Courant

By Christopher Keating on March 29, 2010

The judiciary committee narrowly approved a controversial bill Monday that would eliminate the statute of limitations for civil lawsuits in cases of sexual abuse.

The measure was approved, 23 to 20, on a topic that divided both Republicans and Democrats.

Currently, the law allows lawsuits by those up to the age of 48, which is 30 years after reaching the age of 18. If adopted into law, Connecticut would become the fourth state in the nation to eliminate the statute.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Catholics concerned about abuse, not surprised

CALIFORNIA
The Desert Sun

Nicole C. Brambila • The Desert Sun • March 30, 2010

In the wake of reports Pope Benedict XVI once shuffled a priest accused of child sex abuse while archbishop in Germany, local diocesan officials offer papal support while victims say the latest scandal to rock the Catholic Church is “the tip of the iceberg.”

“It's always painful for us as Catholics to reflect on this issue,” said John Andrews, spokesman for the San Bernardino Diocese that also includes Riverside County.

“Our prayers go out to the victims of this terrible crime. And, of course, we're also praying for the pope,” he said Monday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:37 AM

Faith will survive - Archbishop Moras

INDIA
Mangalorean

By Fr Adolf Washington

Bangalore March 30, 2010: Faith has been under attack after recent reports of child abuse by priests of the Roman Catholic Church. Jeff Anderson, a US-based lawyer, filed thousands of suits against the Church since 1983, following up cases of sexual abuse.

The New York Times has started a series of investigative articles into the abuses, even claiming that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who was then Archbishop of Munich, and became Pope Benedict XVI in April 2005, failed to act in time against priests accused of sexually abusing children in their care.

Archbishop Dr. Bernard Moras of the Archdiocese of Bangalore answers a volley of questions from the media (DNA) on the impact of these developments on the local Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:34 AM

Authority on Catholic Sex Abuse Crisis Defends and Criticizes Pope

UNITED STATES
Christian Newswire

Contact: Dr. Leon Podles, 443-824-4550, leepodles@gmail.com; http://podles.org

BALTIMORE, March 30 /Christian Newswire/ -- Dr. Leon J. Podles, author of Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church, ended that book with the election of Joseph Ratzinger as Pope Benedict XVI and his promise to clean up the filth in the Church. In his book, which explored the deep roots of the Catholic Church's sex abuse scandal, Podles pulled no punches in describing the horrors of that abuse. He traced the enabling of abuse back to the failures of the clergy and its narcissistic culture of clericalism.

As president of Crossland Foundation Podles has collected and reviewed tens of thousands of pages that document sexual abuse in every diocese in the United States and numerous cases throughout the world. His background as a retired federal investigator has given him the ability to skillfully analyze these cases. On his website http://podles.org, he documents numerous case studies of abusers and murderers who were protected by the hierarchy and provides frequent blog commentary on the crisis.

As a major Catholic donor, Podles endowed the Chair of Catholic Studies at McGill University in Canada and has watched $3 billion paid in settlements to victims and unknown hundreds of millions paid out to attorneys defending the hierarchy. As a board member of the pontifical International Theological Institute in Austria he has continued his support of Catholic education.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:31 AM

MSM, liberal Catholics exploiting scandal for political gain

UNITED STATES
The Daily Caller

By John Rossomando 03/30/10

Few things have been more disgusting than the countless priestly sex abuse cases that have been publicized around the globe in recent weeks or the Catholic Church’s mishandling of these crimes.

But the bid by liberal Catholics and their allies in the establishment press to exploit these scandals for political gain has been just as outrageous.

Instead of merely expressing righteous anger with the apparent cover-ups, the establishment press has returned to lecturing the Church on how it could have prevented these scandals had it ordained married men or women to the priesthood.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:27 AM

SBS Dateline

AUSTRALIA
Insights

Easter Sunday night on Dateline, 8.30 pm on SBS ONE, host George Negus will be interviewing Father Tom Doyle about the sex scandal involving the Catholic Church.

Father Doyle is a Washington DC priest who, since 1984, has been trying to get the Church to face up to its faults in regard to sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:24 AM

Pope’s reaction to allegations is a nail in the body of the church

WALES
Western Mail

Mar 30 2010 by Steve Dube, Western Mail

“PETTY gossip” will not intimidate His Holiness, who urges all of us to resist such a temptation. He even claims that it needs “courage” to resist the siren call that he and others covered up sexual shenanigans by men in cassocks. Alas, Pope Benedict’s reaction is the opposite of courage, and another nail in the body of the church he leads.

Some of us with an intimate past relationship of a wholly innocent nature with the Roman Catholic Church can confess that we have been taken in by such gossip, and it didn’t seem petty at the time.

As for intimidation, that definitely came from elsewhere, and it invariably ensured silence. To be precise, it came from many “brothers” in the religious order that made up most of the staff at my school more than 40 years ago.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

Column - Greg Sagan: Church endures agony of secrecy

TEXAS
Amarillo.com

This must be a time of agony for the Catholic church.

Locally, we endure the loss of Bishop Emeritus L.T. Matthiesen, who passed away last week. I was privileged to have been acquainted with Bishop Matt for the past dozen years, and I have even received mail from him about my writing.

Every once in a while he agreed with me, and when he didn't he was articulate, knowledgeable, sincere and reasonable. He was what I'm sure many would call an elitist, being as he was intelligent, educated and wise, but to me he was a force of God from the moment we met.

I miss him.

In point of fact, Bishop Matthiesen was to me a persuasive argument in favor of a married clergy. He was, in every sense of the word, a father. The world is less for not having more children raised by him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:19 AM

Temptation to cover-up

CANADA
The Globe and Mail

A mistaken application of the Christian theological concept of scandal has tended to tempt the Roman Catholic Church into cover-ups, which have compounded the abundantly justified outrage over the sexual abuse of children by priests.

The Catholic Church is not like a business corporation or a government department that happens to be inept in its public-relations strategy. Its purposes and principles are different, and its seriously held ideas are complex enough that its leaders can become entangled and misapply them.

Whether Pope Benedict XVI, in his previous or present functions, has been at fault in these matters is a question of fact that may or may not be sorted out in due course.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:16 AM

Pope unlikely to alter course

The Vancouver Sun

By Tom Heneghan, Reuters

The sex abuse scandals lashing the Vatican have led to calls for an end to priestly celibacy, a cleanout of the Catholic Church hierarchy and the resignation of Pope Benedict, but the pope seems unlikely to alter his approach.

The demands, widely aired in the media, are so far removed from the way Benedict works that abuse victims and other critics who raise them seem bound to be disappointed.

The sex abuse saga, while shameful enough to make Benedict issue several apologies to victims, has many aspects that apparently convince him he can continue to tackle the problem quietly but firmly, without undue fanfare.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:14 AM

The Year of the Abusive Priest

Religion Dispatches

By Anthea Butler
March 30, 2010

When Pope Benedict refers to the ever-growing scandal threatening the Church as "petty gossip of dominant opinion" he shows, for all his theological learning, a shocking disregard for both his flock and for the moral standing of the institution he heads. Is it curtains for the Church as we know it?

In June of 2009, Pope Benedict XVI declared “The Year of the Priest,” and in his homily at the vespers marking the opening day, he spoke the following words:

How can we forget, in this regard, that nothing causes more suffering for the Church, the Body of Christ, than the sins of her pastors, especially the sins of those who become “thieves and robbers” of the sheep (cf. Jn 10:1 ff.), lead them astray by their own private teachings, or ensnare them in the toils of sin and death? Dear priests, the summons to conversion and to trust in God’s mercy also applies to us; we too must humbly, sincerely and unceasingly implore the heart of Jesus to preserve us from the terrifying risk of endangering the very people we are obliged to save.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:11 AM

Overture To Catholics, From an Episcopal Priest

Religion Dispatches

By Randall Balmer
March 30, 2010

In the midst of new developments in the Catholic sex abuse scandal and in light of last year’s surprise invitation from the Pope to conservative Episcopalians, a new invitation is extended to disheartened Catholics.

I have no authority whatsoever to speak for my Church, nor would I presume to do so. But as an Episcopal priest, I call on my ecclesiastical superiors to make a special overture to Roman Catholics who are disgruntled by the pedophilia scandals in the Catholic Church; scandals that increasingly point to the complicity of the man in charge of the Vatican, Benedict XVI.

My reference here, of course, is to the declaration last fall by the very same Benedict seeking to lure conservative Anglicans and Episcopalians to the Roman Catholic Church. The Vatican sensed an opening, especially with those Episcopalians (and former Episcopalians) who were still fuming over the consecration of V. Gene Robinson, an openly gay man, as bishop of New Hampshire, the refusal of the Episcopal Church to foreswear same-sex marriages, and the ordination of gays and lesbians and even (still!) the ordination of women.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:07 AM

It's wrong to point finger at Pope in sex abuse scandals

CANADA
Calgary Herald

By Bishop Fred Henry, For The Calgary Herald

March 30, 2010

(This is a pastoral letter that was sent to all of Calgary's Catholic parishes).

In the Liturgy of the Hours for Passion (Palm) Sunday, part of a Sermon by St. Andrew of Crete reads: "Let us go together to meet Christ on the Mount of Olives ... In his humility Christ entered the dark regions of our fallen world ... his love for humanity will never rest until he has restored our earthbound nature from glory to glory, and made it one with his own in heaven."

These are not easy times. Priests and people feel battered and scattered by the seemingly relentless media campaign about child sexual abuse in the Church. We, too, have entered into the dark regions of our fallen world. This is a painful, emptying and humbling experience.

Pope Benedict XVI, in his Pastoral Letter to Catholics in Ireland, has expressed his dismay at the sexual abuse of young people by Church representatives and the way this was addressed by local bishops and religious superiors. He speaks of his closeness in prayer to the whole Irish Catholic community at this painful time and he proposes a path of healing, renewal and reparation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:05 AM

Celibacy not to blame for pedophilia: cardinal

VATICAN CITY
Edmonton Journal (Canada)

A leading Vatican prelate on Monday rejected any link between the requirement of celibacy for priests and the spate of pedophilia scandals rocking the Roman Catholic Church.

"Celibacy has nothing to do with the sexual abuse of minors," Cardinal Walter Kasper said, as calls for the church to rethink the tradition grow.

"Pedophilia has no connection with the very old tradition that prevents priests from marrying," the German cardinal said in an interview with the Italian daily La Stampa published Monday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:02 AM

Catholic Church launches sex abuse telephone hotline

GERMANY
Deutsche Welle

After a torrent of sex abuse allegations, Germany's Catholic Church is opening a nationwide hotline to deal with the clerical sex abuse scandal.

In response to a growing number of sex abuse allegations, the Catholic Church in Germany is launching a nationwide telephone hotline this Tuesday to offer support and counseling to those impacted by the scandal.

The hotline is the church's response to a spate of revelations of sexual abuse and physical cruelty by clerics and parochial school teachers in recent months. So far more than 150 cases of sexual abuse in Catholic institutions in Germany have been reported.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:57 AM

What Pope Benedict Must Do

UNITED STATES
Politics Daily

Jason Berry
Contributor

Pope Benedict faces an epic scandal as victims of clerical sex abuse in Ireland, Western Europe and America raise the issue of justice denied by secret tribunals that allowed predators to remain priests. Yet an editorial in the Vatican newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, scored the media for "an ignoble attempt to strike at Pope Benedict and his closest aides at any cost."

Benedict is grappling with an unfinished crisis that drew media coverage in America in 1992; victims' lawsuits revealed bishops who had sheltered predators from prosecution. By 1994 the coverage had ebbed. Then, in 2002, The Boston Globe gained access to voluminous documents, exposing a vast clergy sexual underground. Pope John Paul II called the American cardinals to Rome for an emergency conference. In June, the U.S. bishops enacted a youth protection charter. Lay review boards would comb clergy files and probe new accusations. Bishops began weeding out sex offenders.

The Vatican drew the line, however, at giving these review boards the authority to investigate bishops. That decision has come back to haunt the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

Germany's Catholic Church launches sex abuse hotline

GERMANY
BBC News

[with video]

The Roman Catholic Church in Germany is launching a telephone hotline for victims of sexual abuse.

The helpline will be run from the western city of Trier.

Its bishop has been appointed to handle any allegations made against clergy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:50 AM

Weighing Weigel’s case against The Times

UNITED STATES
dotCommonweal

March 29, 2010

Posted by Paul Moses

George Weigel’s column on the First Things blog summarizes the case being made in many quarters that The New York Times has been biased in its recent coverage of Pope Benedict’s handling of cases of clergy sexual abuse. He writes:

“… the sexual abuse story in the global media is almost entirely a Catholic story, in which the Catholic Church is portrayed as the epicenter of the sexual abuse of the young, with hints of an ecclesiastical criminal conspiracy involving sexual predators whose predations continue today. That the vast majority of the abuse cases in the United States took place decades ago is of no consequence to this story line.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:47 AM

Scoundrel Time(s)

UNITED STATES
First Things

Mar 29, 2010
George Weigel
The sexual and physical abuse of children and young people is a global plague; its manifestations run the gamut from fondling by teachers to rape by uncles to kidnapping-and-sex-trafficking. In the United States alone, there are reportedly some 39 million victims of childhood sexual abuse. Forty to sixty percent were abused by family members, including stepfathers and live-in boyfriends of a child’s mother—thus suggesting that abused children are the principal victims of the sexual revolution, the breakdown of marriage, and the hook-up culture. Hofstra University professor Charol Shakeshaft reports that 6-10 percent of public school students have been molested in recent years—some 290,000 between 1991 and 2000. According to other recent studies, 2 percent of sex abuse offenders were Catholic priests—a phenomenon that spiked between the mid-1960s and the mid-1980s but seems to have virtually disappeared (six credible cases of clerical sexual abuse in 2009 were reported in the U.S. bishops’ annual audit, in a Church of some 65,000,000 members).

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:45 AM

Catholics find ties to the church tested by crisis

Belleville News-Democrat

By VANESSA GERA - Associated Press Writer

WARSAW, Poland -- An Austrian priest avoids mention of Pope Benedict XVI in his Masses. A Philadelphia woman stops going to confession, saying she now sees priests as more flawed than herself. British protesters call for the pontiff to resign.

As the faithful fill churches this Holy Week, many Roman Catholics around the world are finding their relationship to the church painfully tested by new revelations of clerical abuse and suggestions Benedict himself may have helped cover up cases in Germany and the U.S.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:42 AM

Catholic Church's Klasnic pick causes a stir

AUSTRIA
Austrian Independent

Christoph Cardinal Schönborn’s announcement that Waltraud Klasnic will head a commission dealing with victims of Catholic Church abuse and violence has been met with harsh criticism.

Schönborn said in a TV interview on Sunday that the former Styrian People’s Party (ÖVP) governor will head a special commission checking on all claims and reports of sexual abuse and violence by Catholic Church clergy.

Parish priest Rudolf Schermann, who published Catholic magazine Kirche In, said yesterday (Mon): "I would have preferred an objective atheist."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:39 AM

Germany's Catholic church sex abuse hotline goes live

GERMANY
Earth Times

Berlin - Germany's Catholic church set up a telephone hotline for sexual abuse victims on Tuesday, after several hundred reports of widespread mistreatment by priests emerged in recent months, dating back to the 1950s.

Three days a week, trained advisors and therapists will now be available to answer calls to the free telephone number, set up by the Catholic church.

"With this offer we want to encourage victims to contact us, irrespective of whether these are old or current cases," said the bishop of Trier, Stephan Ackermann, who has been appointed by the church to investigate sex abuse complaints.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:34 AM

March 29, 2010

Lawyers claim Vatican knew about troubled past' of former Miami priest

MIAMI (FL)
News & Observer

By JAY WEAVER - McClatchy Newspapers
MIAMI -- The Archdiocese of Miami, along with top Vatican authorities, knew as far back as 1968 that the Rev. Ernesto Garcia-Rubio, a priest later defrocked amid child sex-abuse allegations, had a troubled past in Cuba before transferring to South Florida, lawyers representing victims claimed Monday.

The lawyers say the Vatican's role is similar to what is alleged in the scandal now unfolding in Wisconsin, where top Catholic officials are accused of failing to defrock a priest accused of molesting some 200 deaf boys in a long career that paralleled the Miami cleric's. Pope Benedict XVI was in charge of the Vatican office that reviewed such cases when he served as Cardinal Ratzinger.

"It was a longstanding and well-known secret that the Vatican and Archdiocese of Miami knew exactly what Ernesto Garcia-Rubio was capable of," said attorney Jessica Arbour, who with lawyer Stuart Mermelstein, has filed several suits against the archdiocese involving Garcia-Rubio

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:25 PM

Vatican goes on offensive after ‘difficult and frustrating week’

VATICAN CITY
The Globe and Mail (Canada)

Eric Reguly

The nightmare day for the Vatican press office came last Thursday, when a report alleged that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who would become Pope Benedict XVI in 2005, declined to defrock a priest who had been one of the American church’s most aggressive and perverted pedophiles – he went after deaf boys.

Published in The New York Times, the report left Father Ciro Benedettini, the Vatican’s amiable deputy press secretary, and chief spokesman Father Frederico Lombardi frazzled. “It’s been a difficult and frustrating week,” Father Benedettini said from his cluttered office within metres of St. Peter’s Square and the papal apartments that overlook it.

The report, coming only days after the Pope's apology to the victims of abuse in Ireland, triggered a genuine credibility crisis within the Catholic Church and left the Vatican press office struggling to salvage the Pope’s reputation. Father Benedettini, 64, can’t remember having been so busy. To prove the point, he clicked onto the electronic service used by the Vatican to monitor Vatican- and Pope-related stories. There were more than 2,200 new stories yesterday morning alone. Most, probably, were about the scandals.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:19 PM

Weigel: NY Times trying to discredit Church using sex abuse

UNITED STATES
Catholic News Agency

Washington D.C., Mar 29, 2010 / 02:46 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- In an article published on Monday, noted Catholic scholar George Weigel condemned the recent media treatment of Pope Benedict XVI, particularly by the New York Times, as part of a larger agenda to take “the Church down” and discredit its moral authority. Weigel also praised the Holy Father's “determination to root out” what the Pontiff previously called “filth in the Church.”

Weigel began his First Things article by arguing that the media has recently portrayed the Catholic Church as “the epicenter of the sexual abuse of the young,” when in fact, it is “by empirical measure, the safest environment for young people in America today.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:16 PM

The reasons for targeting Ratzinger

WISCONSIN
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Patrick McIlheran of the Journal Sentinel
March 29, 2010

Father Raymond d'Souza pointed out a little oddity at National Review the other day:

American demonstrators were in Rome on exactly the day the New York Times published its story claiming that then-Cardinal Josef Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, helped shield a pervert who'd been a priest in Milwaukee. "One might ask," writes d'Souza, "how American activists would happen to be in Rome distributing the very documents referred to that day in the New York Times. The appearance here is one of a coordinated campaign, rather than disinterested reporting."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:11 PM

The absolute wrong response to sex abuse

UNITED STATES
U.S. Catholic

Monday, March 29, 2010
By Bryan Cones
Every day brings another headline on the sex abuse crisis unfolding in Europe and echoing again stateside. And every time the hierarchy is responding in the absolute worst way possible.

Consider this from Archbishop Timothy Dolan's Palm Sunday homily, according to the New York Post: The pope is suffering "the same unjust accusations, shouts of the mob and scourging at the pillar" and is "now being daily crowned with thorns by groundless innuendo." Dolan goes ot credit the pope with the progress the U.S. church has made on its own crisis--credit that should be going to the National Lay Review Board, which struggled mightily, at times against the bishops' opposition, to enforce compliance with the Dallas Charter. (You can read our January 2005 interview with Justice Anne Burke, who once chaired the review board, for some background.)

The Vatican's defense in its conduct in the case of a Milwaukee priest who abused between 100 and 200 children is no more helpful, in effect amounting to an argument that the Holy See didn't know about the case until long after the abuse took place. And a homily by the preacher of the papal household, Raniero Cantalamessa, ends up sounding almost deranged in its narcissistic lamentation about "the present moment of serious hardship we priests of the Catholic Church are experiencing."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:08 PM

Uncovering the cover-up by the Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
The Salt Lake Tribuen

Cal Thomas

God knows -- and He does -- Protestants shouldn't be throwing stones at the Roman Catholic Church for the scandals involving the abuse of children by some priests. Protestants have a blemished history of how they have handled their own scandals involving extramarital sex, misappropriated funds and arrogant behavior.

The hall of shame in the last century includes Aimee Semple McPherson (an alleged affair with her radio engineer, Kenneth Ormiston), Garner Ted Armstrong ( Hustler magazine carried a story in September of 1978 called "In Bed with Garner Ted Armstrong -- America's Promiscuous Preacher," which detailed gambling, adultery and the alleged rape of a young stewardess who worked on his private jet), Jim Bakker (sex with his secretary), Jimmy Swaggart (sex with a prostitute) and Ted Haggard (sex with a man), among too many others.

The difference between them and what is happening in the Catholic Church is that the sex -- though still sinful -- was (with the exception of Armstrong's alleged crime) between consenting adults. Those swindled or otherwise deprived of their money were old enough to have known better.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:02 PM

Protesters call on Pope Benedict to confront abuse scandal

SAN FRANCISCO (CA)
KGO

SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- Protesters in San Francisco on Monday called on Pope Benedict XVI to confront the sexual abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Church.

Members of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, demonstrated outside the offices of the Archdiocese of San Francisco.

SNAP's protest comes as Benedict faces calls to resign over his handling of abuse cases while the pope served as a bishop in his native Germany.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:56 PM

SNAP - Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests

GERMANY
YouTube

[video presentation]

SNAP = Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests Schutzgemeinschaft für die Opfer von geilen Pfaffen Frauenfeindlich = kinderfeindlich!

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:53 PM

What a difference a week makes

Mar. 29, 2010
By Sr. Maureen Paul Turlish

I had been out of the loop, as it were, since Monday, March 22, when I left for Alabama to attend the 26th annual symposium on child abuse sponsored by the National Children's Advocacy Center headquartered in Huntsville. I made the mistake of not taking my laptop, thinking that I could check my e-mail on the hotel's computer. That did not work out.

As a result, I couldn't open my e-mail, couldn't read The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Tablet of London, or even National Catholic Reporter.

I was in the dark until early afternoon Thursday while I waited for my connecting flight from Washington to Philadelphia. That was when I caught some news from CNN and I realized that that sexual abuse of minors by Catholic clergy was all over the news..

What a difference a week makes!

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:49 PM

Clergy sex victims blast NY Archbishop Dolan

NEW YORK
Voice from the Desert

Statement by David Clohessy, Executive Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (314-566-9790)

Dolan’s comments yesterday hurt the church he loves, hurt abuse victims, and hurt himself. He showed a callousness and narrowness that ill-befits the head of a religious institution. His intent may be to “circle the wagons.” The effect, however, will be to harm the children, because by demeaning, insulting and ignoring wounded victims and suffering children, Dolan perpetuates the culture of sexual secrecy and clerical entitlement that leads to more devastation.

The Pope isn’t a victim here. He’s the most powerful monarch in the world’s largest monarchy. His distressing track record on clergy sex crimes and cover ups is finally being examined with some rigor. To compare his situation now to the suffering of Christ is over the top. And it suggests that victims who find the courage to speak up and report unspeakable crimes are somehow hurting the pontiff. (The truth is that these brave victims are helping the church, not hurting it.)

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:45 PM

SAINTHOOD NOW? NO – NEVER!

Voice from the Desert

By James A. Turcotte, U.E.

Foreword

Let me make it clear, right from the start, that I am an 83-year-old Roman Catholic, dedicated to the Faith. I am one of eleven children raised by honest, sincere parents who taught us to be people of integrity.

My concern is that the Vatican hierarchy appears to be pushing the effort to canonize the late John Paul II. In fact, there is insufficient evidence to warrant this honour.

The claims of a potential cure of a nun from Parkinson’s Disease through John Paul’s intercession as well as other minor claims, has raised many questions by the laity about the one-sidedness of the evidence. The lure to sainthood is based on the former pope’s display of charisma and holiness during his world tours. However, there is no sign of an investigation into his behind-the-scenes activities that would further support or deny the claim for this very serious matter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 PM

Jeff Anderson: One Man's Crusade Against The Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Patrick Condon

ST. PAUL, Minn. — Jeff Anderson has filed thousands of lawsuits alleging sex abuse by priests and won tens of millions of dollars for his clients, but he has had a bigger goal in mind for nearly two decades. He wants to bring his career-long legal crusade against misconduct in the Roman Catholic Church right to the top.

He would love to question Pope Benedict XVI himself under oath. Though that is extremely unlikely given that the pope is a head of state, documents Anderson has unearthed have the potential to take a scandal that has plagued dozens of dioceses around the world and place it at the doorstep of Vatican leadership.

The documents, which became publicly known in the past week after Anderson shared them with The New York Times, show that a Vatican office led by the pope, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, halted a church trial against a Wisconsin priest accused of molesting some 200 boys at a school for the deaf.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:46 PM

Holy Week and the suffering Church

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

By Sister Mary Ann Walsh
Director of Media Relations, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops

Holy Week is time when Catholics worldwide feel the pain of dying in Christ.

It comes this year as media reports bring up heartrending, often previously published, stories with a new twist - how the Vatican handled the cases. Efforts to link stories to culpable inaction by Pope Benedict XVI cause reasonable people anguish given all that the pope has tried to do to address this crisis.

Since 2002, the church in the United States has had a policy of zero tolerance, which means a priest or deacon who has admitted to or been found guilty of sexually abusing a minor can no longer engage in public ministry. Likewise, the church has developed screenings and processes to ensure that the children in its schools and religious formation programs today are not subject to abusive behavior, whether by a cleric or lay person. This has solved one problem by excising child abusers from parishes and dioceses.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:41 PM

Tom Sutcliffe: This papal tone of petulance is shameful

UNITED KINGDOM
The Independent

Tuesday, 30 March 2010

I've been trying to resist the temptation to take satisfaction in the current embarrassments of the Catholic Church. Why? Well, one obvious reason would be that those embarrassments arise out of the suffering of children – and it would be far better if the occasions for the Catholic hierarchy's current confusion and disgrace had never occurred in the first place.

Another reason would be that I can't quite share the zeal in opposition of some of my fellow-atheists – whose sincere indignation on behalf of abused children has sometimes appeared to be mixed with an opportunistic loathing of clerics in general. And though I share their distaste for the institutional Church – and for the real-world effects of some of its dogmas – it seemed to me unseemly to crow, to say "we told you so", when there was real sorrow in this story – both for the victims of abusing priests and for disillusioned believers.

This self-denying ordinance got a lot harder over the weekend though, after an address from the Pope in which he appeared to dismiss recent criticism of him and his church as the "petty gossip of dominant opinion". I still find myself murmuring those first two words in tones of incredulity. Petty gossip. At a time when the Church is being found guilty of covering up real crimes and facilitating fresh ones, at a time when contrition would seem to be the only morally decent tone to adopt, he talks of how religious faith gives one the courage not to be intimidated by "petty gossip".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:38 PM

Let the children come to me...

MALTA
Malta Today

As Malta prepares to welcome Pope Benedict XVI next week, revelations of child abuse cover-ups have plunged the Vatican into its deepest crisis in centuries. RAPHAEL VASSALLO on the scandal that dare not speak its name

With the Church now facing unprecedented levels of hostility over child abuse allegations, it is difficult to remember a time when priests and bishops were still accorded the respect we now reserve for visiting royalty.

And yet it was only a few years ago that public genuflection before the Archbishop was deemed an almost compulsory obeisance – as was the custom of kneeling to kiss a Monsignor’s ring.
Today, those who remember a time when it was ‘sinful’ to eat meat on a Friday – among countless other insignificant trivialities – find themselves having to digest the news that the same Catholic Church, having exacted such high moral standards from others, had all along been aware of far more immoral and reprehensible activities conducted by members of its own clergy... and not only did it fail abjectly to curb the abuse itself, but in some respects, it appears to have even abetted it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:35 PM

Vatican ripped for its handling of Wisconsin abuse scandal

WISCONSIN
Green Bay Press-Gazette

By Carrie Antlfinger • The Associated Press • March 29, 2010

MILWAUKEE — A man who says he was among some 200 deaf boys allegedly molested by a priest in Wisconsin said Monday the Vatican’s defensive responses to revelations about the case make him feel like he did when he was 12, when no one would listen to him about the abuse.

Arthur Budzinski, 61, said at a news conference outside the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist that Pope Benedict XVI is trying to protect himself against criticism of his handling of the Wisconsin case against the Rev. Lawrence Murphy. Murphy was accused of molesting some 200 boys at the St. John’s School for the Deaf outside Milwaukee from 1950 to 1975. He never was defrocked.

“It’s 2010. I’m not trying to hurt the pope,” Budzinski said. “The pope should do something. I’m just telling my story. That’s all I’m doing,” said his 26-year-old daughter Gigi Budzinski, who interpreted his sign language.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:31 PM

VOTF National Vigil of Sorrow Good Friday, April 2, 2010

UNITED STATES
Voice of the Faithful

Good Friday is a day of sorrow for the Catholic Church. On this solemn day, we stand in solidarity with victims of clergy abuse and, as Pope Benedict requested of the faithful in Ireland, we too devote our penances for the healing and renewal of the Church. We call on our pastoral leaders to say “Stop the Hiding; Start the Healing.”

• The revelations emerging from Europe these past weeks demonstrate that all the cases have not been resolved, that some priest offenders are still serving. It is long past time to open the files on sex abuse.
• An apology is not enough. The secrecy and oaths of silence must end. The structures that favor deceptions and cover-ups must fall away in favor of the transparency and accountability essential for healing and rebuilding our Church.

WHEN AND WHERE

New York City
- St. Patrick's Cathedral, 12pm - 3pm

Boston
- Cathedral of the Holy Cross, 12pm - 3pm

Chicago
- Holy Name Cathedral, 3pm

Washington, D.C.
- Cathedral of St. Matthew, 12pm – 1pm

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:28 PM

The storm buffeting God's Rottweiler

EUROPE
BBC News

Gavin Hewitt | 13:07 UK time, Monday, 29 March 2010

I was in Ghent at the weekend and dropped in on Saint Bavo's monumental cathedral. It was Palm Sunday. The place bursts with Gothic extravagance; its soaring brick roof testifying to another era and the muscular confidence of the Catholic Church. By the time I was there the service was over and people, clutching fronds or sprigs of green, were embracing each other.

It was a peaceful ritual that belies the storm battering the Church. Across Europe, there is now a torrent of allegations against predatory priests and the abuse of children. In Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Ireland, Italy and the Netherlands people are emerging, with their often buried stories, and pointing their fingers at priests and bishops. One Catholic paper opined that this scandal was the "largest in centuries" to trouble the Church.

The questions facing the Vatican are these: Was its priority protecting vulnerable children or guarding the reputation of the Church? Were children systematically abused at Catholic schools and were paedophile priests shipped out to other parishes rather than being prosecuted?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:25 PM

Lori on Pope Benedict

BRIDGEPORT (CT)
YouTube

[video presentation]

(WTNH) -- The beginning of Holy Week for Catholics has been marred by fresh allegations against Pope Benedict. Bridgeport Bishop William Lori is speaking out in his defense.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:23 PM

Sex abuse scandal drives down Pope Benedict's U.S. approval ratings

UNITED STATES
USA Today

Pope Benedict XVI's ratings with Americans in general and U.S. Catholics in particular have fallen sharply in the wake of daily news stories on the global clerical sexual abuse epidemic.

Those with a favorable view of him fell from 63% of adults -- his personal best in the USA in April 2008, when he visited New York and Washington D.C. -- to 40%, according to a new USA TODAY/Gallup survey of 1,033 adults conducted March 26-28. Among Catholics surveyed, the drop was also steep -- from 81% favorable to 61%.

In parallel, his unfavorable ratings climbed from 15% in 2009 to 35% last weekend overall. Catholics in particular also viewed him more critically, with unfavorable rating rising from 12% two years ago to 25% now.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:20 PM

Opinion: The churches and sexual abuse

UNITED STATES
Associated Baptist Press

By David Gushee
Monday, March 29, 2010

(ABP) -- The child-sexual-abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Church has resurfaced with a vengeance, with events in Ireland, Germany, and the United States having been the subjects of recent reporting. A particularly nauseating case involves a Wisconsin priest who is accused of molesting at least one young boy in the confessional, perhaps the holiest and most trusted space in Catholic life. As one who grew up Catholic, I know exactly what that sacred space is supposed to mean.

Today I write as a Baptist ethicist and minister with no desire to condemn the Catholic Church. Indeed, I want to suggest in this column that three of the four main factors that have fueled this scandal are just as relevant in Baptist or other Protestant settings.

First, this scandal has been fueled by imbalances of power between laity and clergy, and especially between children and adults. When a child is sexually abused by the most-trusted authority figure in a church, he or she begins from a position of total powerlessness. He or she starts off with the voicelessness of every child in a world where the rules are set by adults. He or she lives in a context in which adults are far more likely to be believed than children. And if he or she does somehow develop the capacity to articulate the abuse, the complaint must eventually be made to the very institution led by the child’s abuser. The victim will need a significant infusion of power arrayed in solidarity with him or her from other adults -- such as parents, lay leaders in the congregation, lawyers, or the civil authorities -- to start leveling the imbalance of power.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:16 PM

Media attacks on Pope Benedict, and responses (Roundup)

Catholic Culture

With a media assault on Pope Benedict XVI reaching a frenzied level, reporters for dozens of major newspapers and wire services placed responsibility for sex-abuse cases at the Vatican, despite the clear evidence that diocesan bishops have been responsible for disciplinary failures.

An AP story claimed that only 20% of reported abuse cases result in full canonical trials. The truth is that in most cases, disciplinary measures are imposed without a full trial. As prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), then-Cardinal Ratzinger pressed for vigorous action and authorized diocesan bishops to proceed with their own disciplinary action.

A Reuters story rehearsed the now-familiar charges against the Pope, and only after 18 paragraphs did the reporter mention a vigorous defense by Vienna's Cardinal Christoph Schönborn. During his years at CDF, the Austrian cardinal said, Cardinal Ratzinger pushed Pope John Paul II to conduct a full inquiry into charges against another Austrian prelate, the late Cardinal Hans Hermann Groer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:13 PM

Pope seen undeterred by abuse scandal, reform calls

VATICAN CITY
Reuters

(Reuters) - The sex abuse scandals lashing the Vatican have led to calls for an end to priestly celibacy, a cleanout of the Catholic Church hierarchy and the resignation of Pope Benedict, but the pope seems unlikely to alter his approach.

The demands, widely aired in the media, are so far removed from the way Benedict works that abuse victims and other critics who raise them seem bound to be disappointed.

The sex abuse saga, while shameful enough to make Benedict issue several apologies to victims, has many aspects that apparently convince him he can continue to tackle the problem quietly but firmly, without undue fanfare.

"He will plod along undeterred," said Rev. Vincent Twomey, an Irish theologian who has known the pope for 37 years. "He takes note of things, but he's not a magician. He works steadily ... I think he'll weather the storm."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:06 PM

Up to the Pope: Stop the Pandemic of Pedophilia

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Rev. Debra Haffner

The latest revelations about sexual abuse against children by Roman Catholic priests are nothing short of revolting. The story of Father Lawrence Murphy, who abused more than 200 deaf boys in Milwaukee over decades, despite the boys' speaking out and calling for help, should outrage us all. The new revelations from Germany and other European countries add to the understanding that the prevalence of pedophile priests are, in the words of my colleague, Dan Maguire, "a global Catholic Church pandemic."

"It went up to the Pope," a formerly Roman Catholic friend said to me yesterday, with tears in her eyes. "How is it possible that people knew and didn't stop it?" Unfortunately, the answer is that the Catholic hierarchy did know, and chose to transfer the priests rather than address the crimes they were committing against children.

Yes, crimes. In the secular world, the offending priests and their superiors would be held criminally accountable for their behavior. It is not enough for the Pope to apologize, as he did to victims last week. It is unconscionable when Catholic apologists try to explain away the church's inaction as a relic of another time, when people didn't talk as much about sexual abuse. We are talking now - and learning, to our dismay, how widespread sexual abuse in faith communities really is.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:01 PM

Proposed NY Child Abuse Bill Being Fought by Religious Leaders

NEW YORK
News Inferno

Religious leaders in New York State continue to fight a proposed child abuse law that would temporarily lift the statute of limitations for lawsuits alleging the sexual abuse of children. According to The New York Times, opposition to the law, known as the Child Victims Act, is being led by the Catholic Church, and a loose coalition that includes leaders of the Hasidic and Sephardic Jewish institutions in Brooklyn.

The impetus for the Child Victims Act was the Roman Catholic Church child sexual abuse scandal that has rocked New York, as well as much of the country, over the past decade. Because of the current statute of limitations, hundreds of claims filed in recent years against Catholic priests and dioceses in New York have been dismissed.

Currently, the deadline for bringing such a lawsuit in New York is 5 years after a victim turns 18. The Child Victims Act would give victims a one-year exemption from the statute of limitations. Regardless of how long ago the alleged abuse occurred, they could file suit in civil court. At the year’s end, time limits on such claims would be restored, but with a wider window: Instead of a five-year period after turning 18, victims would have 10 years to file claims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:57 PM

Papers Reveal Cover Up Priest's Sexual Misconduct

FLORIDA
CBS 4

John MacLauchlan

MIAMI (CBS4)
An investigation into a defrocked priest who ministered here in South Florida and allegedly preyed on young children from the Mariel boat lift, Nicaragua and El Salvador has reportedly uncovered documents that indicate his actions were acknowledged and covered up by the Vatican.

The documents concern the former Father Ernesto Garcia-Rubio who was pastor of "Our Lady of Divine Providence" in Sweetwater in the 1980s. Garcia-Rubio was defrocked in the late 1990s after he was accused of raping four young boys from Central America.

According to child sexual abuse attorneys Stuart Mermelstein and Jessica Arbour the documents reveal an international cover up of Garcia-Rubios' pattern of sexual misconduct. The Vatican, Archdiocese of Miami, and Garcia-Rubio's Cuban diocese all reportedly knew he posed a threat to children early in his ministry, yet did each entity did nothing to warn the parishioners.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:54 PM

Is the Vatican scandal really about the abuse of power?

Foreign Policy

David Rothkopf

This weekend the Pope took a hard stand on behalf of the power of faith to provide "the courage" to not allow "oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion." This revealed more about the Pontiff's misunderstanding of the current crisis in the Church than intended. Because, of course, the problem is not the petty gossip. The problem is the hard and awful fact of decades of abuse of thousands upon thousands of innocent children at the hands of priests in whom they and their families had placed the ultimate trust.

The problem is not petty gossip. The problem is what would be considered in any other organization to be a criminal conspiracy to cover up grievous crimes and to recklessly endanger innocents. The problem is a culture not of compassion but of one that placed the interests of a rich and powerful organization above those of the individuals it was supposed to be serving. The Church doesn't need to be protected. The children need to be protected.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:50 PM

Pope Remains Silent On Abuse Case In Germany

GERMANY
WBUR

[with audio]

By Eric Westervelt

March 29, 2010 :

Pope Benedict XVI has apologized to abuse victims in Ireland, but has yet to speak out about the growing church abuse scandal in his native Germany.

In particular, he has been silent about the case of a priest who was treated for molesting boys in Munich in the 1980s, when the current pope was archbishop of Munich.

The doctor who treated the abusive priest says his warnings went unheeded.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:48 PM

The Priestly Pedophilia Program (PPP)

True/Slant

Michael Shermer

By now everyone is painfully aware of the latest scandal to hit the Catholic Church over the matter of the Priestly Pedophilia Program (PPP). As the circle of justice slowly tightens around the Vatican and the Pope himself, who apparently not only knew about extensive priest-on-boy molestation but directly and actively helped bury the story and possibly even moved the offending priest to a perish that would grant him greater access to even more boys, the one-liner of the eminently quotable Christopher Hitchens comes to mind here about the PPP: No Child’s Behind Left.

If it were revealed that any other organization but the Catholic Church had not only engaged in but protected and sometimes even encouraged child molestation, rest assured that any government worthy of the name would swoop down upon them and shut them down cold, stopping all further activities until a full and legal investigation and proper prosecution of all offenders were undertaken.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:40 PM

Vocal Archbishop Chaput so far silent on Church sex scandal

COLORADO
The Colorado Independent

By John Tomasic 3/29/10
The latest chapter in a widening scandal of Catholic Church pedophelia and cover-up that counts thousands of victims on two continents unfolded spectacularly last week, implicating the Pope directly as a key player even before he was pope in a culture of power and secrecy that flouted secular law. The escalating stories of hushed-up child abuse in Ireland, Germany and Wisconsin were augmented Saturday by the long-delayed official admission that the revered head of the powerful Legionaries of Christ Catholic order was also a pedophile and a thief.

Denver Archbishop Charles Chaput was the U.S. member of a five-man investigative team appointed by the Vatican last July to look into the allegations of abuse conducted by Rev. Marcial Maciel Degollado, the deceased leader of the Legionaries. What the team found, by all accounts, isn’t good news for the Church. Chaput, who has spoken out repeatedly on the moral failings of the health care bill and members of Congress and who recently expelled the children of a lesbian couple from a Catholic school in Boulder, has remained publicly silent on the abuse scandals and the Church’s willful failure to follow criminal and civil legal codes.

Although representatives of the Legionaries have admitted the guilt of Degollado– who reportedly molested at least a dozen underlings and fathered and surreptitiously supported a number of children– the official report of the Vatican investigative team has yet to be made public.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:36 PM

NYT UNFAIRLY CITES POPE'S ROLE

UNITED STATES
Catholic League

March 29, 2010

Catholic League president Bill Donohue criticizes an op-ed article and a news story in the New York Times about Pope Benedict XVI's role in the case of Fr. Lawrence Murphy:

In yesterday's Times, columnist Maureen Dowd said that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now the pope, "ignored repeated warnings and looked away in the case of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, a Wisconsin priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys." Wrong. Her own newspaper said it has no evidence that he even knew of letters that reached his office in 1996 about this matter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:33 PM

PopeWatch: Palm Sunday Edition

UNITED STATES
Beliefnet

Nicole Neroulias

Given the daily -- sometimes hourly -- influx of Catholic news lately, I'm introducing PopeWatch, my daily digest of the Vatican's response to the global clergy sex abuse scandal, including the New York Times' ongoing investigative coverage and commentary, and other headlines.

Yesterday was Palm Sunday (the same day for all Christians this year, including the Eastern Orthodox branch), the start of Holy Week, leading up to Easter. The Associated Press reported that Pope Benedict made no direct reference to the scandal in his homily, though one of the prayers during Mass was "for the young and for those charged with educating them and protecting them." Some sex abuse victims took offense at something else he said, however: "From God comes the courage not to be intimidated by petty gossip."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:44 PM

The Theocons Dig In

UNITED STATES
The Daily Dish

George Weigel, once a staunch defender of cultist and multiple child-rapist Marcial Maciel, a man protected by both Woytila and Ratzinger for years, now blames gay former archbishop, Rembert Weakland, and Laurie Goodstein of the New York Times for airing the hideous story of how a Catholic priest was able to rape countless deaf children in Milwaukee for decades. All of it is now a liberal media conspiracy against the church:

[T]he crisis of sexual abuse and episcopal malfeasance has been seized upon by the Church’s enemies to cripple it, morally and financially, and to cripple its leaders. That was the subtext in Boston in 2002 (where the effort was aided by Catholics who want to turn Catholicism into high-church Congregationalism, preferably with themselves in charge). And that is what has happened in recent weeks, as a global media attack has swirled around Pope Benedict XVI, following the revelation of odious abuse cases throughout Europe. In his native Germany, Der Spiegel has called for the pope’s resignation; similar cries for papal blood have been raised in Ireland, a once-Catholic country now home to the most aggressively secularist press in Europe.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:41 PM

Press Claims and Document Trails Miss Point in Abuse Scandal

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Radio

[with audio]

(29 Mar 10 - RV) 3,000 cases of sex abuse against minors by priests or religious have been dealt with by the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith since 2001.

According to Raymond de Souza, a priest and columnist with Canada’s National Post newspaper, this is the quiet revolution taking place in the Vatican when it comes to investigating cases and ensuring those responsible are brought to justice.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:39 PM

The Position of the Church

NEW YORK
The New York Times

Ross Douthat

New York’s Archbishop Timothy Dolan, blogging on the sex abuse scandal:

What causes us Catholics to bristle is not only the latest revelations of sickening sexual abuse by priests, and blindness on the part of some who wrongly reassigned them — such stories, unending though they appear to be, are fair enough, — but also that the sexual abuse of minors is presented as a tragedy unique to the Church alone.

That, of course, is malarkey. Because, as we now sadly realize, nobody, nowhere, no time, no way, no how knew the extent, depth, or horror of this scourge, nor how to adequately address it.

There is truth to this. The Catholic Church is not unique among large institutions in having a problem with sexual abuse. The American public school system is rife with sexual misconduct, and the same is presumably true of most religious denominations, Boy Scout-type groups and so forth. Any organization devoted to the care and education of the young is going to attract would-be abusers, and provide settings for misconduct and criminality. Nor was the Catholic Church unique in misunderstanding the scope of the crisis it faced from the early 1960s through the 1980s: Catholicism’s abuse problem wouldn’t have spiraled so far out of control if a host of American professions — psychiatrists, policemen, lawyers, judges, etc. — hadn’t been similarly inclined to downplay the risks of abuse and overstate the ease with which the problem could be managed. Nor, finally, is the archbishop wrong to see a certain amount of anti-Catholic and anti-religious animus motivating the media’s often-obsessive coverage of the priest-abuse scandals, and the level of scrutiny that the church receives relative to other institutions.

But I wish that he and others would think twice before complaining so vociferously about it. Call out bad reporting, by all means; defend yourself against unjustified allegations, definitely. But don’t spend too much time complaining about a double standard, or griping about being unfairly targeted. Because, after all, the church is the church — not the public school bureaucracy, not the Boy Scouts or Girl Scouts, not the American juvenile detention system or the Scientologists or any other organization that you might not be surprised to discover has a problem with sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:33 PM

Monday, March 29, 2010

UNITED STATES
outpatient clinic

Skip Shea

Archbishop Dolan of New York's assertion that Pope Benedict is like Jesus should be considered miraculous. What else could possibly explain the transformation of one person from Hitler Youth to the King of the Jews?

Alright, that's an unfair joke. He was only 16 years old when he went into military service for the Nazi's. Clearly that doesn't count. Just like my Uncle Vinny who lied about his age and joined the US Navy at the age of 16. He was there when they captured the only German submarine in WWII, the U-505. That doesn't count either.

I can understand the Church's unease with discussions around Nazi's as Pope Pius XII reputation and record during that period is a little suspect. In particular, letting the likes of Dr. Josef Mengele to escape justice by fleeing Europe down the ratline, which went through the Vatican.

That's not good for PR. Although all of this bad press does keep the likes of Catholic League President Bill Donohue employed. As silly as he sometimes may be. Like his response that Cardinal Ratzinger may have seen a memo about the transfer of pedophile priest Peter Hullermann.

Donohue said "So what? Wasn't that what he expected to happen?” Yes, but he wasn't supposed to get caught transferring him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:23 PM

Stance on perverted priests still problematic

UNITED STATES
Western Courier

Cody Boland

It doesn't take a discerning eye to realize that the Catholic religion, which was based on the teachings of Jesus Christ, seems to have missed the point about such messages as "blessed are the meek."

The sovereign city-state known as Vatican City, a theocratic state run by the pope, delights in elaborate ceremony and expensive architecture, something that their favorite Nazareth resident may have had a few words against.

The economy, funded by tourism, is another interesting irony that seems to be a bit of a contrast to what the charitable, robed desert walker had in mind.

But those are just minor nuances that rub me the wrong way. While the concept of the pope, the spiritual leader who represents the closest connection between Catholics' and their god, needing a bulletproof dome to travel in implies an amusing lack of "faith," this easy comedic paradox that creates a good stand-up routine is largely insignificant. It is the words of the man himself which move my Vatican stance from a joke to strong disdain.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:12 PM

German bishops beg forgiveness for sex abuse by priests

GERMANY
Earth Times

Berlin - Several Catholic bishops in Germany begged for forgiveness Monday for past sex abuse by paedophile priests, saying the hundreds of cases were a "shocking" judgement on the church.

For days, as the scandal has widened in Germany and the United States, bishops have been issuing previously unpublished tallies of molestation in the period from 1950 to 1990, and reporting more recent cases to police.

As hundreds of priests listened in his cathedral in Muenster, bishop Felix Genn asked victims for forgiveness for these "appalling attacks" and said the church had suffered major damage and lost face.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:09 PM

Spreading the Big Lie

UNITED STATES
National Review

George Weigel & Rev. Jay Scott Newman

If Irish singer Sinead O’Connor wishes to denounce her mother publicly as an abusive parent, that is her privilege. If Ms. O’Connor wishes to shred a photograph of Pope John Paul II on stage, as she did almost two decades ago, she is, one supposes, within the boundaries of “performance art.” If Ms. O’Connor wishes to “separate” the God she believes in from the Catholic Church in which she was raised, as she put it in a March 28 article in the “Outlook” section of the Washington Post, she is free to do so.

What Sinead O’Connor is not free to do is to misrepresent the teaching and law of the Catholic Church in the Post in order to buttress her claim that the Church is an “abusive organization” and that the Church threatens with excommunication those who would blow the whistle on clerical sexual abusers. That is utterly false. If Ms. O’Connor is aware of that falsehood, she has lied. What is more likely is that she picked up this arrant nonsense from those who are attempting to portray the Catholic Church as a global criminal conspiracy of sexual predators, in order to cripple the Church morally and financially and to drive it from the public square in shame.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:06 PM

Controversial Priest moves out of Strabane

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Ulster Herald

By Alan Rodgers

THE priest at the centre of sex abuse allegations who had been living in Strabane Parochial House for over nine years, is moving out of the residence.

Parishioners in the town were told of the decision on Fr John McCullagh at weekend Masses by Parish Priest, Fr Declan Boland. He had previously accused the Derry Diocese of 'stitching him up' amid fears that the parish would be tainted by the controversy.

In a statement read to congregations Fr Boland said the decision was taken following consultations with the Parish Pastoral Council and Bishop Seamus Hegarty.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:02 PM

Can faith in the Pope, and the church, be saved?

CANADA
The Globe and Mail

Michael Valpy

.Benedict XVI risks history’s lasting stain as the pope of a sexually abusive church unless he takes bold steps to steer Roman Catholicism onto a fresh path such as summoning a global council to deal with the problem, says a Canadian scholar who is one of the world’s leading experts on the faith.

Michael Higgins’s issued his warning as Catholic leaders around the world – including members of the Canadian church hierarchy – defended Benedict against what they called unfair attacks and smears against a man they say has been the Vatican’s driving force behind ridding the church of priestly sex predators.

“I just find it so ironic that he who has really belled the cat in these cases, and has actually confronted and dealt with and changed things and made things happen for the whole church, that of all people he should be attacked,” said Archbishop Thomas Collins of Toronto, head of the Canadian church’s largest archdiocese. “Of course if you can attack the Pope, you can hit a home run. But it’s so unfair, so unfair, the Holy Father has done so much.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:58 PM

When Priests and Rabbis Commit Sexual Abuse

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Brad Hirschfield

The words used by Pope Benedict and others in responding to the Church's ever-deepening sexual abuse crises reflect a sickness that is not unique to the Catholic community. In fact, that sickness creeps into all religious communities of which I know, and leaves a trail of victims in its wake every time. I refer to the way in which religious leaders and the communities which they lead wear the mantle of victimhood to cover their naked moral failings.

In the past days I have heard Catholics tell me again and again that "the Church is under assault." Under assault by whom? Is this "assault" the real problem? Or is it a deflection from the horrors of child abuse committed by the religious?

In his Palm Sunday address, Pope Benedict spoke about allowing neither himself nor the Church to be "intimidated by petty gossip". "Petty gossip"? Is that how the Holy Father understands the outcry against the evil acts which members of the Church have committed? Is it really his view that the Church is a victim of gossip mongers more than the thousands of children have been victims of the Church?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:51 PM

20 Trier diocese priests accused of sex abuse

GERMANY
The Local

Trier's Roman Catholic diocese said Monday that 20 of its current and former priests had been accused "in recent weeks" of sexual abuse as part of an ever widening scandal embroiling the Church in Germany.

The Trier bishopric in the western part of the country said the "shocking" allegations involved crimes committed from the 1950s to 1990.

"For my part, I would like to encourage those victims who have not yet found the courage to come forward to do so," Bishop Stephan Ackermann told reporters, saying he was "stunned" by the cases that had come to light.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:48 PM

Editorial: The church needs to be true to itself

NEW ZEALAND
New Zealand Herald

A Vatican newspaper claims the hailstorm of allegations of priestly sexual abuse is a conspiracy aimed at the present Pope and the Catholic Church.

Ironically, it targets the "media" as leading or cheerleading this conspiracy, the New York Times being the latest to publish a historical claim, from up to 70 young, deaf boys who allege abuse by an American priest now dead.

It is unfortunate the messenger is being criticised rather than the message heeded. There is much still to be done for the church to put this sin behind it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:49 AM

SNAP Criticizes Vatican Handling of Scandal

UNITED STATES
KSAX

MILWAUKEE (AP) - The group called Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests is criticizing the Vatican for its handling of the recent scandal involving Wisconsin abuse victims.

The group claims in a news release that top Catholic officials in Rome have publicly insulted abuse victims in the last few days.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:46 AM

Cravatts: Is clergy abuse inevitable?

MASSACHUSETTS
MetroWest Daily News

By Richard Cravatts/Guest columnist
The MetroWest Daily News

The recent revelations of yet another history of rampant sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests in Ireland, not to mention Pope Benedict XVI's own complicity in covering up instances of such abuse when he was an archbishop in Germany in the 1980s, still leaves unanswered and troubling questions about the psychology of the perpetrators and the motivation of Church leaders who ignored these morally-defective, criminal actions and allowed them to continue.

What is it about the Catholic Church that attracted the many priests who would go on to sexually abuse hundreds of pre- and post-pubescent children, both in Europe and the United States?

Answering those questions gives clues about why the Church's scandal happened, and, more importantly, how Church leadership and lay professionals can begin to unravel the psychosocial trap into which many troubled priests have seemingly fallen.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:42 AM

The sins of the Fathers...are crimes

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite

The sexual abuse of children is a crime; in Wisconsin, where as many as 200 deaf boys may have been sexually abused by Father Murphy at St. Johns' School for the Deaf in St. Francis, clergy are now among those legally mandated to report child sexual abuse to authorities. The failure of clergy to report child sexual abuse in WI is now against the law. Unfortunately, this law was only adopted nearly a decade after the alleged abuse by Father Murphy.

From Wisconsin to Ireland to Rome, and everywhere in between, the Catholic church must not only be held morally accountable for the crimes of sexual assault by priests against children, it must be held legally accountable. Until Catholic priests are everywhere held legally accountable for the crimes of sexual abuse they commit, and Catholic authorities are held legally responsible for the crimes they cover-up, the abuse will not stop.

A fundamental question that often gets overlooked in the horrible pattern of child sexual abuse in the Catholic Church, is who is the church? Are children part of the church, and the beloved of God, and their safety the condition for being able to say the church is holy? Or is it only the church hierarchy that is the church, and the protection of the hierarchy the most important issue? Are children part of the church or not?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:37 AM

Maciel Disowned By His Own Cult

UNITED STATES
The Daily Dish

[with video]

A serial child-rapist, cult-leader and secretly married confidant of John Paul II and Benedict XVI is finally disowned by his own cult. John Paul II called this multiple child-rapist "an efficacious guide to youth". Of course, he was never subjected to any criminal sanctions, was protected by Woytila and Ratzinger for years, even as they knew full well what was going on, and the euphemized statement just released is what the Catholic hierarchy believes is contrition. In 2006, the Vatican decided not even to subject him to canonical hearing because of his advanced age. So if you live long enough, and bring enough cash into the church, you can be allowed to molest countless children and your only punishment is an invitation to spend the rest of your life, supported by the church, in "prayer and penance, renouncing to any public ministry”.

The person who approved of this non-punishment is now the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the American Cardinal Levada. Punishing Maciel for decades of child-rape with a paid retirement and invitation to prayer was also approved directly by Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:35 AM

"Bad" popes and bishops

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

By Anthony Stevens-Arroyo

What do Alexander VI, the Renaissance Borgia pope, and today's Benedict XVI have in common? No, it's not a sex scandal - even though different kinds of sex scandals abound in both cases. Rather, like Alexander in his time, Benedict is trying to protect the Church's political power at a time when secularism is replacing respect for religious institutions.

Papal history is filled with scandal. Alexander VI (1492-1503) was notorious for his mistresses and illegitimate children. Renaissance pope Julius II (1503-1513) led mercenary armies in Italy as a field general. Paul III (1534-1549) convoked the Council of Trent, but not before he appointed his two teenage grandsons as Cardinals first. Most of Catholic America considers prelates like these to be "bad" popes and bishops. From today's moral standards, they certainly were. But others disagreed; Machiavelli, for example, wrote that Alexander VI was a brilliant politician who was good for the Church. So there is a difference between "morally bad" and "politically bad."

I do not subscribe to the idea, common in Protestant circles, that the Holy Spirit abandoned the Renaissance Church. Catholics at that time accepted the goal of institutional power calculating that it outweighed scandal. I suspect that four centuries from now, the Catholic faithful will look back on the Pope John Paul II (1978-2005) and his successors with the same criteria used for the Renaissance popes: despite mistakes, they fought to preserve institutional power.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:52 AM

Listecki "Cannot Believe" Attemped Cover-Up Happened at Vatican

MILWAUKEE (WI)
WTMJ

By Jay Sorgi

MILWAUKEE - It's Holy Week, the week including Good Friday and Easter Sunday, but Milwaukee Archbishop Jerome Listecki has to give his Holy Week message amidst claims of a Vatican cover-up of sex abuse of children by a priest here.

"It's a shame."

So said Listecki on 620WTMJ's "Wisconsin's Morning News."

He mentioned that he doesn't believe the Vatican had involvement of a cover-up in the case.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:48 AM

Vatican Documents Showing Coverup of Miami Priest to be Released

FLORIDA
Mermelstein & Horowitz

New Documents Released Show Vatican Involvement in Coverup of Miami Priest Accused of Sexually Abusing Children

Child sexual abuse attorneys Stuart Mermelstein and Jessica Arbour will release never-before seen documents obtained in litigation that reveal an international coverup of Fr. Ernesto Garcia-Rubio’s pattern of sexual misconduct. Garcia-Rubio has been accused of sexually abusing multiple boys he came to know through his work in Miami’s immigrant and refugee communities. Documents reveal that officials in the Vatican, Archdiocese of Miami, and Garcia-Rubio’s Cuban diocese knew he posed a threat to children early in his ministry, yet did nothing to warn parishioners.

The documents reveal that Garcia-Rubio was personally known to several Vatican officials, and began his career in Miami at the request of the Holy See. Less than 5 years after he was ordained, the Vatican warned Miami officials that he had been forced to leave Cuba because of sexual misconduct, and it sought assurance that Garcia-Rubio would be “protected” in Miami. Garcia-Rubio was so well known that Vatican officials even called on him to assist with special projects.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:45 AM

Ex-Powys vicar Richard Hart faces child sex offences

WALES
BBC News

A former vicar has appeared in court accused of a series of sexual offences against children.

Richard Hart, 60, of Beguildy, near Knighton, Powys, has been charged with gross indecency and indecent assault offences.

Dyfed-Powys Police said he appeared before magistrates in Llandrindod Wells last Thursday. No plea was entered.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:32 AM

Pope talks today of "petty gossip;" Clergy sex victims are hurt & insulted

VATICAN CITY
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by Barbara Blaine, SNAP President, 312 299 4747

Contrary to what a few in Rome are saying, we are not "ignoble," "despicable" or engaging in "petty gossip." We are men, women and children who are in deep pain, having been raped, sodomized and assaulted by Catholic clergy and often betrayed by Catholic officials. Our trauma - past and present - should never be trivialized by anyone, much less by those who profess to be caring shepherds.

That last description - "petty gossip" - hurts the worst, because it comes from the Pope himself. The mean-spirited comments by some loyal church bureaucrats in defense of the pontiff are wrong but understandable, given the intense scrutiny their leader now faces. But when the Pope himself responds to hundreds of suffering clergy sex abuse victims and thousands of aching Catholic parishioners with dismissive rhetoric, it's particularly disturbing.

Tens of thousands of us are doing a public service. By our courage, we are making the church, and society, safer for children. By our actions, we are exposing predators, warning parents, protecting families and deterring future recklessness and deceit in child sex cases, secular and religious. We are shining a sorely-needed light on long-hidden secrets and corruption, so that horrific wounds can be healed and so that vulnerable youngsters can be safeguarded. That's no "conspiracy," that's decency and bravery.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:21 AM

Clergy sex abuse victims announce new group forming in England

UNITED KINGDOM
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

WHAT
Holding signs and childhood photos at a sidewalk news conference, two prominent US clergy sex abuse victims and 2 or 3 victims from the UK will
-- express their concern for vulnerable children and wounded adults in England,
-- announce the formation of a confidential self help group for British victims, and
-- beg anyone who saw, suspected or suffer clergy sex crimes to speak up, call police, get help, expose predators, protect others and start healing.

When:
Tuesday, 30th of March, 11:00 a.m.

WHO
Two US women who lead the world’s largest & most highly visible support group for clergy sex abuse victims, called SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAPnetwork.org) and 2 or 3 victims from England

Where
In front of the Westminster Cathedral at Ambroseden Avenue, Westminster, London SW1P 1QJ

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:15 AM

Maciel’s men.

ROME
dotCommonweal

March 29, 2010, 8:07 am Posted by Grant Gallicho

In her thread on the Legion of Christ’s disavowal of Maciel, Mollie linked to an important piece by Sandro Magister, “Legionaries: The ‘Nomenklatura’ that Must Disappear.” Next month, the five bishops who led investigations of the the Legion–Archbishop Chaput in the United States–will present their findings to Vatican officials. Magister details the maneuverings of Legion leadership in advance of those meetings. Rome will likely place the Legionaries under the authority of an “external commissioner endowed with full powers,” yet, according to Magister, the group’s leaders–all with close ties to Maciel, several of whom alleged to have knowledge of Maciel’s double life–are “anything but resigned to giving way.”

Freed from the annoyance of the visitors, and not yet subjected to the command of the commissioner, during this interim period which they are hoping will last for “several months” they are doing everything they can to consolidate their power and win the support of the majority of the 800 priests of the Legion, and of the other religious and lay members.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:12 AM

FR. LOMBARDI: CHURCH COMMITMENT AGAINST CHILD ABUSE

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

VATICAN CITY, 27 MAR 2010 (VIS) - Given below is the text of a note released by Holy See Press Office Director Fr. Federico Lombardi S.J., entitled "Vigil of Holy Week".

"The question of the sexual abuse of minors by members of the Catholic clergy has continued to receive wide coverage in the communications media of many countries, especially in Europe and North America, coverage which has continued over recent days following the publication of the Pope's Letter to the Catholics of Ireland.

"This is no surprise. The nature of the question is such as to attract the attention of the media, and the way in which the Church deals with it is crucial for her moral credibility.

"The truth is that the cases that have come to public attention generally took place some time ago, even decades ago, although recognising them and making amends with the victims is the best way to restore justice and to achieve that 'purification of memory' which enables us to look to the future with renewed commitment, with humility and trust.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:52 AM

Is he a hard hat or a prophet?

SOUTH AFRICA
Mail & Guardian

JOHN HOOPER - Mar 29 2010

On the opening evening of the Second Vatican Council in 1962, thousands of Romans poured into St Peter's Square in a torchlight procession. Called to the window of his study by the multitude, John XXIII said: "Returning home, you'll find the children. Give them a caress and say: 'This is the caress of the pope.'"

Forty-three years later, on the night Benedict XVI was elected, a text message hurtled between cellphones as the crowds dispersed from the same square. "Returning home, you'll find the children," it read. "Give them a belt round the ear and say: 'That's from the pope.'"

In the five years since it has become clear that the daunting reputation the former Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger brought into office as "God's rottweiler" was, in many respects, misleading.

A man less likely to cuff a child would be hard to imagine -- although, as the latest and biggest scandal to rock his papacy has revealed, his choirmaster brother was not above cuffing choristers.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:37 AM

Three Catholic Church reformers reflect on latest sexual abuse reports

UNITED STATES
The Star-Ledger

By Jeff Diamant/The Star-Ledger
March 28, 2010

To many advocates of reform in the Catholic Church, the papal election of conservative Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in April 2005 was a blow to hopes the Vatican would change positions on gender, sexuality, divorce, and the church hierarchy.

Yet the result encouraged three prominent reformers who were appointees to a U.S. bishops' advisory panel. The three American Catholics — a judge, an attorney and a newspaper publisher — were concerned mainly with the clergy sex scandal.

They had met with Ratzinger in his Vatican office in 2004 for an extensive discussion on the cover-ups of clergy sex abuse of children and came to view Ratzinger as the best churchman anywhere on the issue. A year later, when he became Pope Benedict XVI, they were often quoted praising him in American news articles.

But that was then. This month's clamor over revelations in a German newspaper and the New York Times about two priests whose abuse cases were adjudicated under Ratzinger's watch have led two of the three panel members who met with Ratzinger to reconsider their views.

The Star-Ledger interviewed all three late last week: Illinois Supreme Court Justice Anne Burke, Washington attorney Robert Bennett, and retired publishing executive William Burleigh

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:30 AM

Bishop's apology is not enough -- survivor

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Ralph Riegel

Monday March 29 2010

ONE of the alleged victims of clerical abuse in the Diocese of Cloyne has welcomed the resignation of Bishop Dr John Magee.

However, the victim said the resignation of the 73-year old bishop would not draw a line under the hurt caused by the diocese's mishandling of abuse allegations.

A special letter from Dr Magee was read out at all Masses in the diocese yesterday. He thanked people for their support over his 23 years as their bishop and said victims would remain in his prayers.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:24 AM

Brady under fire over new allegations against priest

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney and Paul Melia

Monday March 29 2010

The embattled head of the Catholic Church in Ireland has found himself at the centre of another child-abuse scandal involving allegations against one of his senior priests.

Cardinal Sean Brady announced yesterday that a parish priest in his archdiocese of Armagh had agreed to step aside from his official duties pending a police investigation.

On Saturday night the 70-year-old cardinal travelled from Armagh to the unidentified parish to concelebrate Mass and tell shocked parishioners about the sudden departure of their parish priest.

Last night, the cardinal's spokesman refused to respond to questions from the Irish Independent about details of the complaint against the cleric, and about when it was first made known to Cardinal Brady.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:21 AM

Just outrageous

UNITED STATES
A Passionate Engagement

Ken Harvey

I keep thinking that the response of the Roman Catholic Church to the sex abuse crisis can't shock me any longer, but, unfortunately, it still does. The latest outrage was Pope Benedict XVI's Palm Sunday missive to the faithful. One line sums up everything that is wrong with the Church.

In a not-so-subtle reference to the recent investigations into further sexual abuse, the pontiff said faith in God helps lead one “towards the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion.”

Okay. A few points here.

1. The sexual abuse of thousands of children is not "petty gossip." It is real and painful. It could have been stopped. It has left lasting scars on its victims. Petty gossip? You insult every victim of clergy abuse with these two outrageous words.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:09 AM

Sources of the Scandal

UNITED STATES
America Magazine

Father Martin, below, usefully recommends that everyone look back at the incredible resource which is the report of the National Review Board, set up by the USCCB, to monitor their own compliance with the provisions adopted at Dallas in 2002 to address the clergy sex abuse crisis. Last week, the Review Board issued its annual update, which is also useful reading.

There are two "causes" of the crisis that the Review Board did not mention, however, that merit mentioning. One applies to the actual issue of clerical sexual abuse and the other to the pattern of Episcopal cover-ups of the abuse. A priest told me that he believes most dioceses and most seminaries still throw out anyone who admits to having had sexual relations with a woman within the past five years or anyone who admits to being homosexual. The priest predicted, and I have every reason to think he is right, that for most applicants this is simply an invitation to lie. I recall an article in a newspaper in which a seminary rector said there were no homosexuals in his seminary. Having visited many seminaries over the years, I am quite certain that this statement is false. I am also certain that such naivete about sexual matters is an instance of clerical malpractice. Note to the Board of Trustees at all seminaries: Fire any rector or seminary staffer who says something that dumb. I would also call attention to the much more nuanced approach taken by Archbishop Timothy Dolan during a recent interview when asked about his tenure as rector of the North American College. Dolan gets it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 AM

Catholic Church still silent on SNAP allegations

GUAM
KUAM

by Mindy Aguon

Guam - The Catholic Church continues to remain silent on allegations made by the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. The head of the group's Southwest Division was on island last week and talked with victims, some including high ranking government officials.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:53 AM

OC Catholic Sex-Abuse Survivor Visits Guam to Give its Pedo-Priests Hell

ORANGE COUNTY (CA)
Orange County Weekly

By Gustavo Arellano, Monday, Mar. 29 2010

This past Saturday, after traveling for nearly 24 hours nonstop, Joelle Casteix finally returned home after a week of giving pedophile priests and their apologists hell. The setting wasn't her usual stomping grounds outside any Diocese of Orange facility but a place much, much prettier but no less demonic: Guam.

Casteix--one of the eight or so graduates of Mater Dei High who ever turned out to become a decent person--went in her capacity as the Southwest Regional Director for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) after sex-abuse victims in the American territory contacted her seeking to tell their stories. She spent a week meeting with victims, but none showed up for a public session she organized. Unfazed, Casteix will return in a couple of months, telling a Guam newspaper "Our goal is two-fold. Number one: To begin healing for survivors of sexual abuse, and that is through them talking. ... Number two is making sure what happened to us never happens to another child."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:50 AM

A Time for Contrition

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

By ROSS DOUTHAT
Published: March 28, 2010

During a frustrating argument with a Roman Catholic cardinal, Napoleon Bonaparte supposedly burst out: “Your eminence, are you not aware that I have the power to destroy the Catholic Church?” The cardinal, the anecdote goes, responded ruefully: “Your majesty, we, the Catholic clergy, have done our best to destroy the church for the last 1,800 years. We have not succeeded, and neither will you.”

Two centuries later, the clergy has taken another shot at it. What the American and Irish churches have endured in the last decade and what German Catholics find themselves enduring today is all part of the same grim story: the exposure, years after the fact, of an appalling period in which the Catholic hierarchy responded to an explosion of priestly sex abuse with cover-ups, evasions and criminal negligence.

Now the scandal has touched the pope himself. There are two charges against Benedict XVI: first, that he allowed a pedophile priest to return to ministry while archbishop of Munich in 1980; and second, that as head of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in the 1990s, he failed to defrock a Wisconsin priest who had abused deaf children 30 years before.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:47 AM

CONSERVATIVE MEXICAN PRIEST SEXUALLY ABUSED SONS HE FATHERED - MARCIAL MACIEL, Founder of $2 BILLION, 75,000-Member Order Of The Legion Of Christ

UNITED STATES
San Francisco Sentinel

By Tracy Wilkinson
The Los Angeles Times

He hobnobbed with Mexico’s rich and famous, cut lucrative real estate deals and was rumored to travel on occasion with a briefcase full of cash. He fathered at least one child, molested seminarians and boys and is said to have boasted that he had the pope’s permission to get massages from young nuns.

And all the while the conservative priest was building one of the most influential organizations in the Roman Catholic Church.

Two years after the death of the Rev. Marcial Maciel, a Mexico native, scandals continue to unfold: Just the other day in Mexico City, two brothers came forward, claiming tearfully that not only was Maciel their father, he had also sexually abused them.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:44 AM

Petty Gossip

VATICAN CITY
Democratic Underground

Posted by NanceGreggs

Faced with yet another resurgence of outrage over the Catholic Church’s systematic cover-up of the sexual abuse of children at the hands of its priests – this time triggered by allegations that the current pontiff himself participated in this heinous exercise – Pope Benedict XVI today chose to respond not by reassuring the faithful that such a serious matter would be investigated and addressed, but instead by adding insult to injury.

In his address to the crowd assembled in St. Peter’s Square to observe Palm Sunday, His Holier-Than-Thouness stated that faith in God leads one "towards the courage of not allowing one’s self to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion".

One cannot help but note the use of the words “one’s self” – because, as this particular pontiff has demonstrated time and again, it’s his world, and it’s all about him, and the children who were stripped of the innocence of their childhood be damned – literally and figuratively – for suggesting otherwise.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:40 AM

Pope's prayer for sex-abuse victims fails to pacify critics

ROME
The Globe and Mail (Canada)

Eric Reguly

.Parishioners at Santa Susanna, a baroque gem of a Catholic church that has served as the American national church in Rome since the 1920s, were surprised by a prayer said at Palm Sunday mass. Mixed in with invocations for the victims of earthquakes in Haiti and Chile, came a prayer “for all the victims of child abuse.”

“This is the first time I heard a prayer for the abused at the church,” said Jack Zaleweski, an American security consultant who lives in Rome and regularly attends services at Santa Susanna, which opened 1603.

There was no other acknowledgment during the mass of the abuse scandal shaking the Roman Catholic Church around the world.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 AM

Abuse crisis weighs on area's Catholics

CHARLOTTE (NC)
Charlotte Observer

Charlotte Catholics heading into Holy Week are thinking not only about the approach of Easter but also about troubling new questions swirling around the leader of their ancient church.

On Saturday and Sunday, Catholics leaving Palm Sunday Masses at three Charlotte parishes indicated that they have long been concerned, even "heartbroken," as one put it, about a child sex abuse crisis that has rocked dioceses in the United States, Ireland - and now Germany, where Pope Benedict XVI previously served as archbishop of Munich.

Recent news reports allege that, in 1980, he approved the transfer of an abusive priest to another jurisdiction. Then in the 1990s, when he was the Vatican's top doctrinal official, he was allegedly made aware of a Wisconsin case in which the church failed to defrock a priest accused of molesting 200 deaf children from the 1950s to the 1970s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:32 AM

Lawsuits affect area dioceses

NORTH DAKOTA
Grand Forks Herald

By: Stephen J. Lee, Grand Forks Herald

The St. Paul attorney who is suing the Vatican also has filed lawsuits recently against the Catholic dioceses of Fargo and Crookston, alleging sexual abuse by priests.

Jeffrey Anderson’s law firm has filed four suits against the Fargo diocese alleging that Raimond Rose, who as a Christian Brother taught at Shanley High School in Fargo from 1976-80, sexually molested students and that diocesan officials knew Rose had been accused of molesting students at Catholic schools in the Twin Cities before he was hired at Shanley.

A spokeswoman for the diocese said recently that no one had come forward to the diocese to report abuse by Rose.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:29 AM

Ireland deserves better than this papal apology

IRELAND
Guelph Mercury

March 29, 2010

By Sinead O’Connor

When I was a child, Ireland was a Catholic theocracy. If a bishop came walking down the street, people would move to make a path for him. If a bishop attended a national sporting event, the team would kneel to kiss his ring. If someone made a mistake, instead of saying, “Nobody’s perfect,” we said, “Ah sure, it could happen to a bishop.”

The expression was more accurate than we knew. This month, Pope Benedict XVI wrote a pastoral letter of apology — of sorts — to Ireland to atone for decades of sexual abuse of minors by priests whom those children were supposed to trust. To many people in my homeland, the pope’s letter is an insult not only to our intelligence, but to our faith and to our country. To understand why, one must realize that we Irish endured a brutal brand of Catholicism that revolved around the humiliation of children.

I experienced this personally. When I was a young girl, my mother — an abusive, less-than-perfect parent — encouraged me to shoplift. After being caught once too often, I spent 18 months in An Grianán Training Centre, an institution in Dublin for girls with behavioral problems, at the recommendation of a social worker. An Grianán was one of the now-infamous church-sponsored “Magdalene laundries,” which housed pregnant teenagers and uncooperative young women. We worked in the basement, washing priests’ clothes in sinks with cold water and bars of soap. We studied math and typing. We had limited contact with our families. We earned no wages. One of the nuns, at least, was kind to me and gave me my first guitar.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:25 AM

Ormond man wants Catholic penance week

FLORIDA
The Daytona Beach News-Journal

By MARK HARPER, STAFF WRITER

The latest revelations in the pedophile priest scandal that have damaged the Catholic Church have sparked debate within the Diocese of Orlando about the days leading up to Easter Sunday.

Volusia Voice of the Faithful -- headed by Ormond Beach resident Robert Keane -- is calling on Bishop Thomas Wenski to proclaim this, Holy Week, a period of "recollection and remorse." The group is asking than all pastors wear sack cloth and ashes, lead penance services and "admit the extent of this, our greatest crisis since the flagrant conduct of the Renaissance Church."

Wenski, through a church spokeswoman, issued a statement to The News-Journal on Friday. The purpose of Holy Week is to remember the passion of Christ, who Catholics believe died in order to redeem the sins of all men and women, according to the statement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

World waits for pope's reaction to sexual abuse claims

VATICAN CITY
WFIE

Posted by Sarah Harlan

VATICAN CITY (NBC) - The Catholic church began this holy week under a cloud of suspicion with more claims of sexual abuse by priests and more accusations that the leaders of the church ignored those claims.

The accusations reach all the way to Pope Benedict.

The majesty of the Catholic church was on display in St. Peter's Square Sunday morning, with the Palm Sunday mass commemorating Jesus Christ's triumphant arrival into Jerusalem, the first in a week of events focused on Christ's death and resurrection.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:19 AM

For Rwandans, the pope's apology must be unbearable

RWANDA
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Martin Kimani The Guardian, Monday 29 March 2010

If you are an Irish Catholic, and have suffered sexual abuse at the hands of a priest, you were recently read a letter from Pope Benedict that tells you: "You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. I know that nothing can undo the wrong you have endured. Your trust has been betrayed and your dignity has been violated."

For any practising Catholic in Rwanda, this letter must be unbearable. For it tells you how little you mean to the Vatican. Fifteen years ago, tens of thousands of Catholics were hacked to death inside churches. Sometimes priests and nuns led the slaughter. Sometimes they did nothing while it progressed. The incidents were not isolated. Nyamata, Ntarama, Nyarubuye, Cyahinda, Nyange, and Saint Famille were just a few of the churches that were sites of massacres.

To you, Catholic survivor of genocide in Rwanda, the Vatican says that those priests, those bishops, those nuns, those archbishops who planned and killed were not acting under the instruction of the church. But moral responsibility changes dramatically if you are a European or US Catholic. To the priests of the Irish church who abused children, the pope has this to say: "You must answer for it before almighty God and before properly constituted tribunals. You have forfeited the esteem of the people of Ireland and brought shame and dishonour upon your confreres."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:15 AM

Kenyan rebel Catholics challenge church

KENYA
Capital FM

BY EVELYN NJOROGE

NAIROBI, Kenya, Mar 29 - The Roman Catholic Church has been challenged to embrace reforms as one way of reducing the sexual abuse scandals that have rocked the church in recent months.

Reverend Godfrey Shiundu, who leads a break-away faction of catholic priests who have broken the celibacy vow, said on Sunday that the Church needs to be honest with itself and allow change that would see members shun immorality and accept the married state of priests and other religious people.

“This is the right time for Rome to go back to its consciousness and say yes we goofed and bring this change,” said the Ecumenical Catholic Church of Christ Principal Consecrator adding that a priest who had a family ‘would respect himself and preach in fear.’

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:12 AM

Church's shame

JAMAICA
The Gleaner

André Wright, Night Editor

While condemning the cover-up of child sex-abuse cases involving Roman Catholic clergy globally, Archbishop of Kingston, the Most Reverend Donald Reece, says paedophilia should be treated as an irreversible psychological problem and not necessarily a moral or spiritual failing.

Reece, who is the head of Jamaica's Roman Catholic community, acknowledges that the church's system of dealing with child sex abuse - by sending priests on 30- or 40-day therapeutic retreats - was short-sighted and wrong, leading to the development of institutional secrecy.

The church leader argued that paedophilia has a psychological imprint which can never be cured.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:10 AM

Church in crisis

SOUTH AFRICA
Leadership

“Pope Benedict XVI’s latest apology for the emerging global scandal of child abuse by predatory priests – an issue that the Roman Catholic Church (RCC) should have engaged years ago – is strong on forgiveness, but far short of the full accountability that Catholics need for repairing,” The New York Times wrote last week. As the now-adult victims of molestation by priests increasingly are coming to the fore, it is clear that the RCC is far from out of the woods on perhaps the greatest threat in its long history.

One of the most spellbinding responses can be found in the comments section of a recent report on the OpenDemocracy website. A victim who identifies himself as Gerry Stafford writes an open letter to the Pope.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:07 AM

Majority want pedophile priest registry

SWITZERLAND
World Radio Switzerland

Swiss President Doris Leuthard is calling for a national list of pedophile priests—and a strong majority of the Swiss people would support such a move according to a nationwide poll.

It’s the first time that the head of the government has spoken about the widening scandal of sexual abuse in the Catholic church. She said in a position paper yesterday that it’s “particularly despicable for priests, teachers and other who supervise children.”

Leuthard said a list of teachers who have abused children already exists and that one should now be developed for priests to prevent them from having any more contact with children. She added that the church must accept its share of responsibility, and that “everyone is subject to the Swiss Penal Code, without exception.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:05 AM

CATHOLIC CHURCH 'DISFIGURED'

Trinidad and Tobago
Triniday and Tobago's Newsday

By Janelle de Souza Monday, March 29 2010

As protestors in Europe clamour for Pope Benedict XVI to resign over a clerical sex abuse scandal, a local Roman Catholic priest yesterday urged his congregation to mourn not only for the victims, most of them children, but also for the “disfigured church”.

“Mourn for the victims who have felt betrayed by the priests who have perpetrated the crime, not understanding the reason why these priests have done what they did,” Father Kenneth Assing, declared in his Palm Sunday homily at the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception in Port-of- Spain yesterday.

Assing said the scandal, which intensified yesterday into a protest at Westminster Cathedral, London, England, where protestors demanded that the Pope step down, has shown that the Catholic Church has been betrayed by its own priests.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:02 AM

The Vatican apologists carry on

True/Slant

Allison Kilkenny

Now is the time the Vatican apologists will:

A) Continue their disgusting tradition of acting as apologists for child torturers and rapists, or

B) Revise their history of acting as Vatican apologists, and claim none of these accusations are surprising — and gee! — can’t Catholics clean house, and send the kid-toucher priests to an island, or something?

Then there’s Douthat, who heroically attempts to do both.

He half-scolds the Pope for allowing a pedophile priest to return to ministry while Benedict XVI served as archbishop of Munich in 1980. But Douthat then claims a second charge — that the Pope failed to report a Wisconsin priest who had abused 200 deaf children — is “unfair.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:58 AM

Boston Catholics decry Pope's handling of abuse scandal

MASSACHUSETTS
The Daily Free Press

By Meaghan Beatley

As reported cases of child sexual abuse committed by priests explode across the globe, Catholics in the Boston area are condemning what they see as a lack of inadequacy and lack of accountability in dealing with the crisis by the Vatican.

On March 20, Pope Benedict XVI publicly released an 18-page pastoral letter to the Catholic Church in Ireland in which he formally apologized for the wave of sexual abuses committed by priests in the traditionally deeply Catholic country.

Many Catholics, including a large number in Boston, have voiced their concern that the pope has failed to take responsibility for the issue or action to address it.

“What he did was quell the crisis and the outrage but keep the focus away from the Vatican and its role in creating this culture in the Catholic Church. He did not address his own role, and he did not administer any real punishment,” said Anne Barrett Doyle, a co-director of BishopAccountability.org, a Massachusetts nonprofit organization dedicated to gathering documents, reports and news items related to clergy abuse in the Roman Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:56 AM

Archbishop Dolan compares pope abuse flap to torment of Jesus

NEW YORK
New York Post

By LACHLAN CARTWRIGHT and LEONARD GREENE
Post Wire Services

The pope is being crucified over untrue allegations that he condoned the acts of pedophile priests, Archbishop Timothy Dolan told worshippers in St. Patrick's Cathedral yesterday.

The charges being hurled at Pope Benedict XVI are the "the same unjust accusations, shouts of the mob and scourging at the pillar" suffered by Christ, Dolan said in his first Palm Sunday Mass as New York archbishop.

Discussing child abuse by clergy, he added, "The dramatic progress that the Catholic Church in the United States has made . . . could never have happened without the insistence and support of the very man now being daily crowned with thorns by groundless innuendo.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

Chilean Priest Speaks Out As Revelations Sweep the Catholic Church

CHILE
The Santiago Times

Written by Aaron Cantu
Monday, 29 March 2010 05:43

Members of Chile’s Legion of Christ express sorrow for the actions of its founder

The recent accusations of pedophilic abuse and fatherhood involving Marcial Maciel - the founder of the Legion of Christ, an international Roman Catholic congregation - have moved leaders in Chile’s chapter to publicly comment on the matter and express regret.

The Legion, founded in 1941 and brought to Chile in 1980, released a statement on March 26 acknowledging that its founder and former leader, the late Marcial Maciel, engaged in a drug-addled double life of pubescent molestation and sexual affairs at unspecified moments throughout his 64-year post.

“[Maciel] can no longer serve as a role model for us,” said Father John O’Reilly, chaplain of El Colegio Cumbres in Chile. “Right now, it is necessary to distinguish between the Legion and the deplorable actions of its founder… We have a lot of respect for our superiors, so this has been very painful for us.”

Readers wonder whether the pope should step down

Deutsche Welle

As the clergy abuse scandal has crept closer to the Vatican, some have called for the resignation of Pope Benedict. We asked our readers what they thought.

The following comments reflect the views of DW-WORLD.DE readers. Not all reader comments have been published. DW-WORLD.DE reserves the right to edit for length and appropriateness of content.

Vatican stands by pope amid calls for resignation
We asked: Should the pope step down?

No the pope should not step down. This is a time for the pope to grow in authority and take action against the rebellious bishops and priests who are teaching false doctrines and who want to see the pope removed. Hang tough Pope Benedict. -- Evelyn, Canada

Yes! -- Robin McGinty, US

As a loyal Catholic, I say he should certainly consider doing it, especially if more and more complaints implicate him in a cover up of sexual abuse in the church. Maybe he should step down now for the good of the church. Maybe some one from a new generation with a far better record on this issue could do a much more effective job. -- Anne Rice, US

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:47 AM

DiManno: A church sex scandal where the truth is crucified

VATICAN CITY
Toronto Star

By Rosie DiManno
Columnist
TURIN, ITALY

The doctrinarian-in-chief, disciplinarian of even picayune transgressions when it came to canon law, has no excuse for ignoring the mortal sins of the priests.

Before he succeeded to the white beanie, Pope Benedict XVI, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, headed the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which received information about virtually every priest in the world who'd been accused of sexual abuse.

If, as his defenders claim, Benedict was so distressed by the extent of the problem and the Church's historical tendency to shelter predators from exposure that he altered practice so that direct action would be taken in a majority of cases, this epiphany came rather late in his administrative career.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 AM

UK protestors tell Pope: You’re not welcome here

UNITED KINGDOM
Digital Journal

Fifty protesters from humanist, secular, women’s and gay organizations have accused Pope Benedict of “covering up child sex abuse by Catholic clergy”.

At a protest rally in London yesterday (Sunday), they also called him a “protector of paedophile priests” and “an accomplice to sex crimes”. They demanded: “The Pope must resign” and “Prosecute the Pope for collusion with sex abusers”.

The protest took place noon on what was Palm Sunday in the Christian calendar, outside London’s Westminster Cathedral, the main Catholic church in Britain.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:40 AM

March 28, 2010

Justice Interrupted Radio

UNITED STATES
blogtalkradio

[audio presentation]

As Passover begins this week, Vicki Polin from the Awareness Center will be discussing how there is still an overwhelming rate of abuse in the Jewish Community.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:23 PM

Rugman in Rome: victims refuse to shake priest’s hand

ITALY
Channel 4

Author: Jonathan Rugman

Just after 9pm on Friday night I found a myself in a television studio in Rome as a member of the audience of an Italian television programme called “Brought to You by Rai Three”.

The show was broadcast live, with between 3 and 4 million Italians watching at home. I was briefly distracted when a television camera fell on the head of an audience member, obliging the TV staff to bundle the victim off the stage; but that was a surreal moment in an otherwise gripping show.

Three gentlemen from Verona were in the presenter’s hotseat, being interviewed about how they were abused by Italian priests when they were children. A Monsignor from the Verona diocese called Bruno Fasani had been sent down to put the church’s point of view. During a break for advertisements, Mgr. Bruno leapt out of his chair to shake the victims’ hands. But they refused to take it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:18 PM

Local Bishop responds to abuse scandal

NEW YORK
WIVB

[with video]

Mylous Hairston
Posted by: Kate McGowan
BUFFALO, N.Y. (WIVB) - Catholics are being asked to give what they can to help charity, and this comes as the Pope faces world wide criticism in a church scandal.

The 82-year-old says he will not be intimidated by critics or media reports, claiming he played a role in covering up sex abuse of children by priests.

Bishop Edward Kmiec of the Catholic Diocese of Western New York expressed, "I think the Pope has answered his critics. He gives an answer. And I think he's a man of honor, of integrity, of honesty. I think if he felt he had done something wrong, I think he'd admit to it."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:09 PM

Matthew Norman: Ye of little faith, hark the voice of the Vatican

UNITED KINGDOM
The Independent

If there's a finer and more fearless organ than L'Osservatore Romano anywhere on the planet today, I'd love to know what it is.

Mischievously described as the "semi-official" newspaper of the Vatican – a slur similar to slandering the Daily Mirror (see below) as the semi-official newspaper of No 10 – it flourishes under editor-in-chief Giovanni Maria Vian. His leader dismissing as malevolent conspiracy theorising the current nonsense about Hitler Youth pontiff Benedict XVI – real name: Joseph Ratzinger – is a classic.

As his leader makes plain, the charge of cover up has been all got up by the press, and is "clearly an ignoble attempt to strike at Pope Benedict at any cost". Yet the masterstroke here lay in Signor Vian's skilful pre-emption last June of any criticism now that his paper trivialises allegations of the kind. "No accusation, however serious or shameful," L'Osservatore's Michael Jackson eulogy put it, "is enough to tarnish his myth among his millions of fans ..." What cleverness to seize that chance, in the midst of an unending but ever worsening scandal, to ridicule the notion that the Vatican takes an atypically liberal approach to paedophilia.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:07 PM

Leading article: The Pope at bay

UNITED KINGDOM
The Independent

For Roman Catholics, Holy Week is the most important time of the year: a period of deep contemplation, when believers recall and in a sense re-enact the last days of Christ's life, from Palm Sunday to the crucifixion and resurrection. Traditionally this is also a time when millions of otherwise nominal Catholics return, if only briefly, to the Church's embrace.

But not this year, perhaps, with Easter overshadowed by fresh damaging revelations about the abuse of children entrusted to clerical care. This year, the likelihood is that many cradle Catholics will just stay away, and never return.

As concern with the Church's handling of child-abuse cases gives way to anger, and as demands grow for the Church to end its culture of secrecy, the Pope's Easter message is likely to be drowned out. Still sounding a defiant note, he is starting to resemble some ancien régime monarch, immured in his palace and dangerously out of touch with the world outside.

Some writers – Catholic writers, not members of the increasingly confident movement of militant atheists – liken this restive atmosphere within the Church to the mood on the eve of the Reformation, when disgust with the venality of the Renaissance popes resulted in large chunks of Catholic Europe denouncing their authority.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:04 PM

Scandal Tests Catholics’ Trust in Leadership

The New York Times

This article is by John F. Burns, Rachel Donadio and Nicholas Kulish.

ARMAGH, Northern Ireland — As the sexual abuse scandal sweeps through the Roman Catholic Church in Europe and the United States, there are few places where dismay and confusion among worshipers strikes as deep a chord as here in Armagh, seat of the embattled cardinal whose fate has become closely entangled with the widening controversy facing Pope Benedict XVI.

As they have for centuries, townspeople turned out in the hundreds this weekend for Palm Sunday Masses in the twin-spired cathedral that looks down on the city, where St. Patrick established his first church in Ireland more than 1,500 years ago.

But judging by the responses of those leaving the Masses, trust in church leaders has been profoundly battered by a succession of revelations that the church hierarchy often failed to take strong action against the abuse in its ranks, and sometimes sought to cover up the problem.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 PM

Local faithful react to church abuse scandal

PHILADELPHIA (PA)
6 ABC

[with video]

Dann Cuellar

At the Basilica of Saints Peter and Paul in Center City Philadelphia, Archbishop Cardinal Justin Rigali performed the blessing of the palms. It's a symbolic emblem of the palms used by Christians commemorating Jesus Christ's triumphant entry into Jerusalem. It's also the start of the Church's Holy Week which includes the Good Friday re-enactment of Christ's crucifixion and death, and his resurrection on Easter Sunday.

But this year, the most solemn week on the Catholic Calendar has been stained by questions about the Pope Benedict's own handling on pedophile priests and the Vatican acknowledging it's moral credibility was on the line.

For some people the topic was too sensitive to comment on. Others, however, were clearly disturbed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 PM

Pope Remains Silent On Abuse Case In Germany

UNITED STATES
NPR

[with audio]

March 29, 2010

Pope Benedict XVI has apologized to abuse victims in Ireland, but has yet to speak out about the growing church abuse scandal in his native Germany.

In particular, he has been silent about the case of a priest who was treated for molesting boys in Munich in the 1980s, when the current pope was archbishop of Munich.

The doctor who treated the abusive priest says his warnings went unheeded.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:52 PM

Pope John Paul II ignored Ratzinger's pleas to pursue sex abuse cardinal

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Damian Thompson

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger tried to persuade Pope John Paul II to mount a full investigation into a cardinal who abused boys and young monks, one of the Church’s most senior figures revealed yesterday. But Ratzinger’s opponents in the Vatican managed to block the inquiry. As the future Benedict XVI put it: “The other side won.”

The pervert cardinal was the late Hans Hermann Groer, removed as Archbishop of Vienna in 1995 following sex allegations. The source for the story is Groer’s successor in Vienna, Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn, an intellectual whom some commentators have tipped as a possible future Pope.

That’s quite a revelation, in my book – but it doesn’t fit the script that the Benedict-hating media have written, so we’re not hearing too much about it. Also, I suspect that former advisers to John Paul would rather not remind us that the late Pope didn’t do enough to curb sex abuse and cover-ups. Safer to blame Benedict, eh?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:50 PM

Pope's Holy Week crisis

VATICAN CITY
Sunday Star-Times (New Zealand)

[with video]

Pope Benedict XVI has opened Holy Week amid one of the most serious crises facing the church in decades, with protesters in London demanding he resign and calls in Switzerland for a central registry for paedophile priests.

Benedict made no direct mention of the scandal in his Palm Sunday homily. But one of the prayers, recited in Portuguese during Mass, was "for the young and for those charged with educating them and protecting them."

Jesus Christ, Benedict said in his homily, guides the faithful "toward the courage that doesn't let us be intimidated by the chatting of dominant opinions, towards patience that supports others."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:03 PM

Pope mass hints at fightback against abuse critics

VATICAN CITY
BBC News

The Pope has spoken of the need not to be intimidated by critics, in a veiled reference to anger at the Catholic Church over past sex abuse scandals.

At a mass in Rome's St Peter's Square, he said his faith would help give him the courage to deflect "petty gossip".

The Pope has been accused of failing to act over the case of a US priest alleged to have abused 200 deaf boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:59 PM

Many Catholics unwilling to address sex-abuse allegations

CANADA
CTV

Sonia Sunger, ctvedmonton.ca

The Catholic Church is facing some of the harshest criticism in years following allegations of sex abuse and supposed cover-ups to protect priests, and while the issues have captured global attention, many Catholics here in Edmonton were unwilling to address the matter.

CTV News tried to speak to parishioners as they were leaving St. Joseph's Basilica this Palm Sunday, but many walked away stating they had no comment on the allegations of abuse in the church.

CTV's Deborah Shiry approached nine people outside the downtown church and only got a response from one woman.

"I think it's upsetting," said parishioner Shastina Tessier. "There's a lot of things that are upsetting that I see, but God is love and forgiveness and that's the best we can do."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:55 PM

Bishop Magee latest senior casualty of Church crisis

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

In Rome, John Magee stood at the right hand of three Popes, but his career went no further after his surprise appointment as bishop of a small diocese in Ireland. Kieron Wood reports.

Seldom has a bishop generated so much expectation as John Magee - and seldom has a bishop fallen so far short of the mark.

Secretary to three popes, a Vatican high-flier in the 1960s, Magee returned from Rome to his native Ireland as bishop of the Cork diocese of Cloyne in 1987. The appointment was seen as a stepping stone, and Vatican-watchers predicted that the native of the diocese of Dromore would eventually return to his home province to succeed Cardinal Tomás Ó Fiaich as head of the Catholic Church in Ireland.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:51 PM

Column: Church sex-abuse crisis sparks a haunting déjà vu

WISCONSIN
Duluth News Tribune

By: Robin Washington, Duluth News Tribune

Verne Wagner gets to live a normal life most of the time. But then, as he told News Tribune reporter Jana Hollingsworth in Saturday’s paper, a new wrinkle in the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal erupts, and he’s reliving the horror of his childhood, lost at the hands of a Proctor priest.

I know something of what he’s talking about. Not, thank God, the terror of abuse, but the lulls and flash points of an incessant wrong that never seems to go away.

For most of 2002 and 2003, the scandal consumed my life; reporting — mostly on the victims, and later, the accused priests — for the Boston Herald. It was a fantastic story that encompassed every aspect of journalism; shoe-leather and investigative skills, empathy and skepticism, of victims and clergy and bishops alike; and tears. Journalists (and even archbishops, as the disgraced Cardinal Bernard Law told me in a fleeting moment of compassion) do cry. But you turn your head away from the person you’re interviewing, hide it and go on.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:48 PM

Legionaries. The "Nomenklatura" That Must Disappear

ROME
Chiesa

Name by name, all the top leaders of the congregation. Their extremely close connection with the founder and with his scandal. The impossibility of any real renewal, as long as they remain in power

by Sandro Magister

ROME, March 29, 2010 – At the end of April, the five bishops who have completed the apostolic visit among the Legionaries of Christ as ordered by the Holy See will present to the Vatican authorities the contents of their reports, delivered in mid-March.

A previous, long-ago apostolic visit among the Legionaries, between 1956 and 1959, ended with absolution.

This time, however, everything gives the impression that will not be the case again.

It is likely that the Vatican authorities will put the Legion under the command of an external commissioner endowed with full powers.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:41 PM

Apologies aren’t enough

UNITED STATES
Boston Herald

By Boston Herald Editorial Staff

The stories out of Europe - first Ireland, now Germany - of pedophile priests and a church in denial come all too close to home for us here.

The pattern is one we have become sadly familiar with. A troubled priest caught molesting boys in his parish is sent for therapy and then transferred to another unsuspecting parish by those who should have known better, who should have put the welfare of children above all else - but didn’t. So then more children are subject to abuse and the question becomes who knew what and when. And why was nothing ever done.

The scandal has now reached the Vatican itself. The New York Times [NYT] reported yesterday that then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, presided over a meeting of his diocesan council on Jan. 15, 1980, at which a priest accused of molesting three boys in the Essen Diocese less than a month earlier is transferred to Munich and returned to pastoral duties by Feb. 1 that year

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:37 PM

N. Ireland priest on leave over child safety concern

NORTHERN IRELAND
Reuters

(Reuters) - A parish priest in Northern Ireland has been asked to take a period of leave following concerns over child safety, the head of the Irish Church Cardinal Sean Brady said.

A statement published on Sunday on the website of a local archdiocese said that Brady told a congregation in Armagh on Saturday that their priest's absence from his ministry was to allow an investigation by civil authorities.

"The policy of the Archdiocese of Armagh is that in all matters relating to child safeguarding, the safety and welfare of the child must be our paramount concern," Brady said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:33 PM

Protesters call for Pope to quit

UNITED KINGDOM
Mercury

Protesters have gathered outside the main Catholic church in the UK to call for the Pope's resignation over clerical sex abuse.

Carrying placards stating "Pope Protects Paedophile Priests - Resign!" and "Sex Abuse Cover Up - Pope Must Resign", demonstrators confronted the congregation as it left Westminster Cathedral in central London.

They claim that Pope Benedict XVI was complicit in protecting priests accused of child sex abuse from prosecution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:28 PM

Pope opens solemn Holy Week amid sex abuse crisis

VATICAN CITY
The Associated Press

By NICOLE WINFIELD (AP)

VATICAN CITY — Pope Benedict XVI opened Holy Week on Sunday amid one of the most serious crises facing the church in decades, with protesters in London demanding he resign and calls in Switzerland for a central registry for pedophile priests.

Benedict made no direct mention of the scandal in his Palm Sunday homily. But one of the prayers, recited in Portuguese during Mass, was "for the young and for those charged with educating them and protecting them."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:26 PM

Pope Benedict All But Says “I Am Not A Crook”- Refuses To Resign

Lez Get Real

03/28/10-by Bridgette P. LaVictoire
Pope Benedict has signaled that he plans on hunkering down and refuses to be pushed out of the Papacy despite growing evidence that people are reluctant to stay in the Church because of the child molestation scandal. Pope Benedict stated in his sermon opening Holy Week, which began today with Palm Sunday, that God can lead one “towards the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion.” What Pope Benedict seems to miss is any actual taking of responsibility for his own actions, or lack there of.

Pope Benedict is a man who is stuck somewhere around the 15th Century, when the Roman Catholic Church was the dominant power in Europe and any deviation from doctrine would be met with, if necessary, force. During this time, heretics were burned en masse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:23 PM

Father Lawrence Murphy Plays The Catholic Church Like a Fiddle

WISCONSIN
News Blaze

By John Kays

I heard of the unbelievable case of Father Lawrence Murphy many years ago, but didn't think that much about it until an article was published in the New York Times last week. No stone was left unturned. Finally people can awaken to the gravity of this unresolved case. It's been known since 1955 that this priest at St. John's School for the Deaf in Wisconsin was a sexual predator, but it's been hushed up for all these years. Why is this so?

The ice was broken by a New York Times article, Vatican Declined to Defrock U.S. Priest Who Abused Boys by Laurie Goodstein, published last Wednesday, March 24th. Along with the article The Times published 24 documents associated with the Father Murphy case. Now for the first time the public can see for themselves primary evidence of how one of the most heinous cases of child abuse was covered up by the Catholic Church.

These documents are a revealing gut-shot of the slowly grinding bureaucratic wheels of the Catholic Church. The Times obtained these crucial documents from attorneys for five men who were abused by Father Murphy. It was 1996 before Archbishop Weakland petitioned the Vatican to consider this serious case. Matters of abuse by priests were handled by a department at the Vatican called the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. The Doctrine of the Faith was headed up by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, our future Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:20 PM

Chicago cardinal mum on sex abuse in Catholic Church

CHICAGO (IL)
The State Journal-Register

CHICAGO — Pope Benedict XVI has opened the church’s solemn Holy Week amid increasing questions about his own handling of cases of sexual abuse of children by priests.

In Chicago, thousands attended Palm Sunday services at downtown’s Holy Name Cathedral.

Cardinal Francis George made no mention of the ongoing controversy during his homily at a morning mass. He instead focused on a message of forgiveness and strength.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:17 PM

NY Archbishop Defends Pope In Sex Abuse Scandal

NEW YORK
Fox 4

(NewsCore) - New York’s Archbishop Timothy Dolan came to the Vatican’s defense Sunday, saying embattled Pope Benedict XVI -- recently under fire for a decades-old sex abuse scandal -- is suffering the same slings and arrows as Jesus did before his crucifixion.

In a Palm Sunday service at a packed St. Patrick’s Cathedral, Dolan gave a spirited defense of the pontiff’s leadership and received a standing ovation.

“Sunday Mass is hardly the place to document the inaccuracy, bias and hyperbole of such aspersions,” Dolan told parishioners.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:13 PM

Report: Poland's top church leader defends pope

POLAND
The Oklahoman

WARSAW, Poland (AP) — A news agency says Poland's top Roman Catholic leader is defending Pope Benedict XVI's handing of church abuse cases.

The PAP news agency quotes the Primate of Poland, Henryk Muszynski, as saying that criticism of Benedict amounts to a personal attack on the pontiff and an attempt to discredit the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:07 PM

Archbishop Defends Pope's Handling Of Sex Abuse Claims

NEW YORK
NY1

[with video]

Archbishop Timothy Dolan defended the Pope's handling of the recent sex-abuse scandal, which has rocked the Catholic Church.

At the end of Palm Sunday Mass at Saint Patrick's Cathedral, the archbishop condemned the alleged abuse of minors by priests in Ireland and Germany, saying it intensified the somber nature of Holy Week.

Dolan also criticized suggestions that Pope Benedict did not come out more strongly against the abuse or somehow aided in coverups.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:04 PM

GUESTVIEW: Are Catholics masochists?

Ethopian Review

The following is a guest contribution. Reuters is not responsible for the content and the views expressed are the authors’ alone. Isabelle de Gaulmyn is Religion Editor of the Paris Catholic daily newspaper La Croix and author of Benoît XVI, Le pape incompris (Benedict XVI, The Misunderstood Pope). She blogs in French at Une foi par semaine, where this first appeared.

Are Catholics masochists? After all that’s been happening these days, this looks like the question to ask. There were probably more than 3 million Catholics in France who went to church to celebrate Palm Sunday today. And during this Holy Week, millions more will to prepare for Easter. If the news we hear is anything to go by, these Catholics must be either mad or masochistic.

Why not take advantage of this Sunday to go fishing or play tennis rather than frequent a place full of pedophile priests and leaders who lie and hush up the truth? How can there still be people in the pews, on pilgrimages, in monasteries or volunteering in one of many charities?

And what about the adults who will be baptised as Catholics on Saturday evening?* Are they thoughtless, suicidal or stupid? In short, are Catholics “the blind being led to slaughter,” as was written in a militant secularist pamphlet dropped into my mail box?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:55 PM

Minn. attorney who found documents implicating pope in abuse scandal has long pursued Vatican

ST. PAUL (MN)
Los Angeles Times

PATRICK CONDON
Associated Press Writer

March 28, 2010

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Jeff Anderson has filed thousands of lawsuits alleging sex abuse by priests and won tens of millions of dollars for his clients, but he has had a bigger goal in mind for nearly two decades. He wants to bring his career-long legal crusade against misconduct in the Roman Catholic Church right to the top.

He would love to question Pope Benedict XVI himself under oath. Though that is extremely unlikely given that the pope is a head of state, documents Anderson has unearthed have the potential to take a scandal that has plagued dozens of dioceses around the world and place it at the doorstep of Vatican leadership.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:52 PM

Protesters decry papal visit to Britain

UNITED KINGDOM
CNN

About 50 protesters gathered near Westminster Cathedral Sunday to protest the pope's announced state visit to Britain later this year, as well as the Catholic Church's most recent sex abuse scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:48 PM

The Catholic Church: Why Have Anything To Do With These People?

UNITED STATES
The Huffington Post

Richard Greener

Two questions jump right out at you about the sexual abuse scandals in the Catholic Church. They scream so loudly your ears echo until someone answers.

#1. What if the grown men accused of these perverted acts were not priests, but rather employees such as janitors, security guards, maintenance workers or any other kind of men who might happen to be around a Catholic church - like deliverymen, mail carriers, plumbers, carpenters, construction workers, painters, electricians? How would these kinds of sexual criminals be treated by the Church and by the local law enforcement agencies?

#2. What does it take to make someone walk away from the Catholic Church?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:45 PM

NY archbishop defends pope against sex abuse furor

NEW YORK
The Associated Press

By LARRY NEUMEISTER (AP)

NEW YORK — Archbishop Timothy Dolan was greeted with applause after finishing Palm Sunday Mass by defending Pope Benedict XVI against suggestions he aided cover-ups of reports of child abuse.

The standing-room-only crowd at St. Patrick's Cathedral applauded for 20 seconds after Dolan read a statement calling the pope the "leader in purification, reform and renewal that the church so very much needs."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:42 PM

German priest defrocked over sex offence

GERMANY
Sydney Morning Herald

AFP

A German diocese says it has defrocked a priest over an unspecified sex crime, as the Roman Catholic Church struggles to cope with a widening abuse scandal.

Officials from the bishopric of Osnabrueck in western Germany said on Sunday the priest has been stripped of his functions with immediate effect "following an allegation of a sexual offence".

"The clergyman admitted misconduct on Friday in a conversation with Bishop Franz-Josef Boden," the diocese said in a statement and added that the priest, who was not named, has turned himself in to prosecutors.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:40 PM

Pope dismisses 'petty gossip' of sexual abuse allegations

VATICAN CITY
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Tom Kington in Rome guardian.co.uk, Sunday 28 March 2010

Pope Benedict, facing the worst crisis of his papacy as a sexual abuse scandal sweeps the Catholic church, declared today he would not be "intimidated" by "petty gossip", angering activists who say he has done too little to stamp out paedophilia.

Addressing crowds in St Peter's square during a Palm Sunday service, the pope did not directly mention the scandal spreading though Europe and engulfing the Vatican, but alluded to it during his sermon. Faith in God, he said, led "towards the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion".

As Benedict spoke, the president of Switzerland, Doris Leuthard, called for a central register of paedophile priests to keep them away from children. In Austria, the archbishop of Vienna announced the creation of a commission funded by the church, but without church representatives, to look into Austrian abuse claims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:37 PM

Daylight upon Magic

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

The English constitutionalist Walter Bagehot once said of the monarchy something that applies to religious hierarchies too. It does not do to let in daylight upon magic. The mystique of the institution, in other words, is the secret of its power. So, the preservation of a certain distance by the Vatican from the rules of temporal life is to be expected. That said, the inadequate response from Rome to the scandal of clerical abuse is not mitigated by its defensible requirement for mystery.

In his Palm Sunday address yesterday, marking the start of Holy Week, Pope Benedict XVI struck a defiant note. He would not be “intimidated”, he said, by the “chatter of dominant opinions”. Coming immediately after the Vatican unwisely criticised the media for its coverage of the allegations, there is a sense that the gravity of the issue has not yet been fully grasped.

If a more emollient tone is not found, then the critics demonstrating outside Westminster Cathedral yesterday, demanding the resignation of the Pope himself, will find a voice. There are lots of unanswered questions about the role of Cardinal Ratzinger — as he was then — and, specifically, his handling of cases of paedophile priests, first as Archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982 and then later as the head of doctrine at the Vatican.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:32 PM

Abused deaf children, the Pope & Boulder Junction, Wisconsin

WISCONSIN
YouTube

[video presentation]

Clergy sexual abuse by Fr. Lawrence Murphy of deaf children in Milwaukee and Boulder Junction, Wisconsin was known by the Archbishops' of Milwaukee and the Bishops of Superior and Joseph Ratzinder who is now Pope Benedict XVI. These videos are about March 25, 2010 press conferences in Superior and Boulder Junction, Wisconsin.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:29 PM

Abused deaf children, the Pope & Superior Diocese

UNITED STATES
YouTube

[video presentation]

Clergy sexual abuse by Fr. Lawrence Murphy of deaf children in Milwaukee and Boulder Junction, Wisconsin was known by the Archibishops of Milwaukee and the Bishops of Superior and Joseph Ratzinger

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:26 PM

Resignation is not an option for the Pope

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

William Rees-Mogg

The paedophile abuse cases have become a big crisis for the Roman Catholic Church. A crisis for the laity, a crisis for the clergy, a crisis for the bishops and, increasingly, a crisis for the Pope himself.

It has caused great damage to the victims, who need to be considered first. In some cases the psychological damage will last a lifetime. The crisis has damaged the image that the Church has of itself; it has damaged the authority of the Pope.

Priests see themselves as men of spiritual values, disciplined in their personal lives and requiring considerable personal sacrifices, including the sacrifice involved in a life of celibacy. They usually have the respect of their own communities.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:24 PM

Holy Week's unholy question: What could end sex abuse crisis?

UNITED STATES
USA Today

This is Palm Sunday for Christians, the beginning of Holy Week leading up to Easter Sunday. But news coverage of the Catholic Church right now is distracted from the ways believers celebrate the "good news" -- the gospel of Christ -- to coverage of the pope and the sexual abuse crisis now raging.

So why am I thinking about the aftermath of Enron?

Something about reaction to the news coverage reminds me of how the American public just loved seeing the alleged bad boys of that financial scandal arrested and led off in handcuffs.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:17 PM

British protesters demand Pope quit over abuse

UNITED KINGDOM
The Associated Press

LONDON — British protesters called on Pope Benedict XVI to resign Sunday as they staged a demonstration over the Catholic Church's handling of clerical sex abuse cases.

Demonstrators gathered outside Westminster Cathedral to call for action over the scandal, carrying placards displaying messages including "Pope? Nope!" and "Don't Turn a Blind Eye," though fewer than 50 people joined the rally.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:47 PM

Man accused of Haiti school abuse in court

NEW HAVEN (CT)
The Hartford Courant

NEW HAVEN, Conn. - A Colorado man charged with sexually abusing boys at a school he founded for street children in Haiti is due in court for a hearing on his motion to dismiss the charges.

Douglas Perlitz is scheduled to return Thursday to federal court in New Haven.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:31 PM

Today, Sunday, March 28, NBC nightly news will have a story on SNAP leaders in Rome

ROME
Voice from the Desert

Today, Sunday, March 28, NBC nightly news will have a story on SNAP leaders in Rome and the rest of the fast-breaking news about the Church’s response, and non-response, to the widening worldwide scandal of 1) clerical sex abuse of children and 2) cover up by many bishops and religious superiors of this widespread abuse .

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:27 PM

Helping accused (innocent and guilty) priests

UNITED STATES
Renew America

By Matt C. Abbott

In response to my March 18 column featuring Opus Bono Sacerdotii, a Detroit-based organization founded to assist Catholic priests in difficult situations, a reader sent me a link to a 2008 article posted on AveWatch.com, excerpted and edited below (click here to see the full article).

'According to Ave Maria University's Web site, the AMU Founder's Club hosted a visit from the president of Opus Bono Sacerdotii (OBS), Joseph Maher, one year ago this past Friday. IRS records show that the self-described exempt purpose of OBS is to offer 'outplacement services for Roman Catholic priests and religious men and women for the purpose of providing a transition from one position to another.'

'The University's Founders Club, which was established by Tom Monaghan, advertised that the purpose of OBS was 'to find solutions to sensitive situations confronting priests and religious in accordance with the authentic teaching of the Church.'

''Outplacement services' for 'sensitive situations'? Translation: OBS helps to quietly shuffle around pederast priests....

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:23 PM

Protesters call for Pope's resignation over alleged sex abuse cover up

UNITED KINGDOM
Ekklesia

By staff writers
28 Mar 2010
Palm Sunday worshippers were startled to face strong protests against the Pope and calls for his resignation as "an accomplice in sex crimes" outside London's Westminster Cathedral.

The demonstration by 50 members of secularist, women's and gay organisations accused the Pope of "covering up child sex abuse by Catholic clergy" and called him a "protector of paedophile priests".

Some congegants had sympathy with the protest, but others were angry at what they accused of being an attempt to create generalised anti-Catholic sentiment out of the current child abuse crisis - which has been growing in scale and strength in recent days.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:36 PM

Statement from Cardinal Seán Brady, Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland, concerning a priest of the diocese

IRELAND
Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Armagh

After celebrating Vigil Mass in a parish in the Archdiocese of Armagh, Cardinal Seán Brady spoke to the congregation about a decision he has made concerning their Parish Priest.

Cardinal Brady said “The policy of the Archdiocese of Armagh is that in all matters relating to child safeguarding, the safety and welfare of the child must be our paramount concern.”

Cardinal Brady said that in the light of information relating to child safeguarding issues, he has asked the priest concerned to take a period of leave from his ministry which he has agreed to do. “This is to allow the civil authorities, who have been informed, to investigate this matter” he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:30 PM

Child concerns see priest 'take leave'

IRELAND
BBC News

A parish priest in the Diocese of Armagh has been asked to take a period of leave from his ministry due to concerns over child safety.

Cardinal Sean Brady told the undisclosed congregation about his decision after vigil mass on Saturday.

"This is to allow the civil authorities, who have been informed, to investigate this matter," he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:27 PM

Emotionally - Can I Do Pesach This Year?

UNITED STATES
The Awareness Center

(2010) by Vicki Polin, MA, LCPC
With Pesach (Passover) less then a week away many Jewish incest survivors are faced with the dilemma of trying to figure out what they are going to do for the holiday. For many survivors it’s much too dangerous to go home because they fear the risk of emotional and or physical harm. The truth is that other incest survivors may not even be invited home after confronting family members with their childhood abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:26 PM

Baruch Lebovits Sentencing Put Off Until Monday, April 12

NEW YORK
Frum Follies

by Yerachmiel Lopin on 03/27/2010
Sentencing of Baruch (Mordechai) Lebovits for eight Class D Felonies of child sexual assault was originally scheduled for Monday, March 29, Erev Pesach. Supporters of both the defendant and the victim requested a postponement because this is a very difficult day to get to a court house with all the necessary work preceding Passover.

I have urged all of you concerned about molesting in our community to write letters to the judge and to show up in the courtroom. If you are sympathetic but have not yet committed to either of these courses of action you have another chance to act.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:23 PM

OK, yes, the Times is piling on Benedict

UNITED STATES
Beliefnet

Rod Dreher

This morning's NYTimes brings us the shocking news that as Archbishop of Munich, Joseph Ratzinger was preoccupied with theological matters. Clutch the pearls! Here's the story. Excerpt:

When Pope Benedict XVI was archbishop of Munich and Freising, he was broadly described as a theologian more concerned with doctrinal debates than personnel matters. That, say his defenders, helps explain why he did not keep close tabs on a pedophile priest sent to his archdiocese in 1980 and allowed to work in a parish.

Yet in 1979, the year before Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, approved the Rev. Peter Hullermann's move to Munich, the cardinal blocked the assignment to the local university of a prominent theology professor recommended by the university senate. And in 1981, he punished a priest for holding a Mass at a peace demonstration, leading the man to ultimately leave the priesthood.

The construal of these facts advances the line put forward by some liberal Catholics, namely that while Benedict focused on punishing theological deviants within the Church, he left the field open to sexual deviants. The conclusion one is meant to draw is that Ratzinger focused on the unimportant things to the exclusion of important things.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:12 PM

Archbishop of Westminster: 'secrecy vows should never have happened'

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ruth Gledhill, Religion Correspondent

The Archbishop of Westminster has said children should not have been made to swear life-long vows of secrecy as more details of legal cases in which the head of the Irish Catholic Church Cardinal Seán Brady is named as a defendant emerged in Ireland.

Responding to the reports that Cardinal Brady was present when abused children were sworn to secrecy, Archbishop Vincent Nichols said it was wrong for victims to swear secrecy for a lifetime but told the BBC's Andrew Marr show that it was comparable to the secrecy imposed for the purposes of a trial.

"It is like giving victims anonymity in the course of a trial," he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:08 PM

Bishop Patrick Dunn: Local perspective on child abuse within the church

NEW ZEALAND
New Zealand Herald

By Bishop Patrick Dunn

Catholics in New Zealand have had to deal with outrage and betrayal says Bishop Patrick Dunn.

Much public comment has been made in this country in the wake of Pope Benedict's letter to the Catholic people of Ireland.

The Pope has strongly criticised the Irish bishops and other church authorities for their mishandling of accusations of sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:06 PM

Cardinal Brady confirms parish priest investigation

IRELAND
The Irish Times

CHARLIE TAYLOR

A parish priest serving in the Diocese of Armagh has been asked to take a period of leave from his ministry due to concerns over child safety.

After celebrating vigil mass in a parish in the Archdiocese of Armagh yesterday, the cardinal spoke to the congregation about a decision he has made concerning their parish priest.

Cardinal Brady said that in the light of information relating to child safeguarding issues, he has asked the priest to take a period of leave, which he has agreed to do.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:58 AM

Pope Benedict: don't be intimidated by 'petty gossip'

VATICAN CITY
National Post (Canada)

Philip Pullella, Reuters Published: Sunday, March 28, 2010

VATICAN CITY -- Pope Benedict, facing one of the gravest crises of his pontificate as a sexual abuse scandal sweeps the Church, indicated on Sunday that his faith would give him the courage not to be intimidated by critics.

The 82-year-old pontiff led tens of thousands of people in a sunny St. Peter's Square in a Palm Sunday service at the start of Holy Week events commemorating the last days in Jesus's life.

While he did not directly mention the scandal involving sexual abuse of children by priests, parts of his sermon could be applicable to the crisis he and the Roman Catholic Church are facing.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:55 AM

Pope Benedict More Interested In Pursuing Heretics Than Pedophile Priests

Lez Get Real

03/28/10-by Bridgette P. LaVictoire
As revelations of what Pope Benedict did in his previous incarnation as Cardinal and Archbishop Ratzinger begin to surface, one has to wondering if he is channeling Tomas de Torquemada who is most famous as the head of the Spanish Inquisition. Perhaps Pope Benedict has decided to model himself after Torquemada, after all, no one expects the Spanish Inquisition.

All laughter and Monty Python references aside, Pope Benedict’s tenure as head of the diocese of Munich is one of the least examined portions of his life. Somewhere between his tenure there and his role as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and his time as a professor, it should have become clear that Pope Benedict’s interests were certainly not in the pursuit of pedophiles nor the protection of the children taken under wing by the Church.

At a time when the Catholic Church was and still is facing major sex abuse scandals, Archbishop Ratzinger was more interested in pursuit of heretics and maintaining doctrine than in the pursuit of child molesters inside the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:08 AM

Westminster Cathedral protest calls for Pope's resignation over child sex scandal

UNITED KINGDOM
Mail

Protesters gathered outside the main Catholic church in the UK today to call for the Pope's resignation over clerical sex abuse.

Carrying placards stating 'Pope Protects Paedophile Priests - Resign!' and 'Sex Abuse Cover Up - Pope Must Resign' demonstrators confronted the congregation as it left Westminster Cathedral in central London.

They claim that Pope Benedict XVI was complicit in protecting priests accused of child sex abuse from prosecution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:04 AM

Pope will 'not be intimidated by petty gossip' over sex abuse scandals

VATICAN CITY
Telegraph

By Nick Pisa in Rome

Pope Benedict XVI began Holy Week on Sunday by suggesting in his Palm Sunday address that the Catholic Church would "not be intimidated" by the sex abuse scandals sweeping it.

Pope Benedict XVI Leads Palm Sunday At St. Peter's Square Photo: GETTY In a clear indication that the Vatican continues to insist the continual abuse revelations are part of a conspiracy the Pope said: "From God comes the courage not to be intimidated by petty gossip."

Although he did not directly mention the crisis that has seen claims of abuse from Ireland, Germany, Austria, Holland and Brazil the 82 year old Pontiff's message was evidently clear.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:00 AM

Avvenire: New York Times Contradicts Itself

VATICAN CITY
Zenit

VATICAN CITY, MARCH 26, 2010 (Zenit.org).- The documentation published by The New York Times contradicts its own thesis, which accuses Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger of not being sufficiently energetic in the case of an American priest who the Church punished for acts of pederasty.

This is the conclusion of an analysis by Riccardo Cascioli that appeared in today's edition of Avvenire, the newspaper of the Italian episcopal conference.

According to The New York Times, "top Vatican officials -- including the future Pope Benedict XVI -- did not laicize a priest who had molested some 200 deaf boys, despite the fact that several American bishops repeatedly warned that the lack of decisive action in the matter could embarrass the Church."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:57 AM

Ratzinger is the Perfect Pope

Washington Post

Richard Dawkins

"Should Pope Benedict XVI be held responsible for the escalating scandals over clerical sexual abuse in Europe?" Yes he should, and it's going to escalate a lot further, as more and more victims break through the guilt of their childhood indoctrination and come forward.

"Should he be investigated for how cases of abuse were handled under his watch as archbishop of Munich or as the Vatican's chief doctrinal enforcer?" Yes, of course he should. This former head of the Inquisition should be arrested the moment he dares to set foot outside his tinpot fiefdom of the Vatican, and he should be tried in an appropriate civil - not ecclesiastical - court. That's what should happen. Sadly, we all know our faith-befuddled governments will be too craven to do it.

"Should the pope resign?" No. As the College of Cardinals must have recognized when they elected him, he is perfectly - ideally - qualified to lead the Roman Catholic Church. A leering old villain in a frock, who spent decades conspiring behind closed doors for the position he now holds; a man who believes he is infallible and acts the part; a man whose preaching of scientific falsehood is responsible for the deaths of countless AIDS victims in Africa; a man whose first instinct when his priests are caught with their pants down is to cover up the scandal and damn the young victims to silence: in short, exactly the right man for the job. He should not resign, moreover, because he is perfectly positioned to accelerate the downfall of the evil, corrupt organization whose character he fits like a glove, and of which he is the absolute and historically appropriate monarch.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:48 AM

Archbishop Nichols says sex abuse anger 'justifiable'

UNITED KINGDOM
BBC News

[with video]

The leader of Catholics in England and Wales has said just one case of child abuse was enough to create "justifiable anger" but the issue could be tackled.

The Archbishop of Westminster, Vincent Nichols, said the "anger and dismay" over the alleged cover up of sex abuse by some Catholic clergy was "proper".

But he said allegations about the Pope's involvement were unfounded.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:31 AM

Why can't the media treat the Pope fairly?

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

Andrew M. Brown

I read the coverage of the Pope every day in the newspapers and listen to the BBC news and as a Catholic and a journalist I feel like crying out pathetically: “This is not fair!” And it isn’t fair, or reasonable. Intelligent journalists who are normally capable of mental subtlety and of coping with complexities have abandoned their critical faculties. There is an atmosphere of unreason.

I cannot help feeling that a lot of it is down to sheer, blind hatred. It amounts to the demonisation of a whole institution and its leader. We have come to a stage where nothing good whatever, no good faith can be assumed of anybody involved in the Church – however senior, however greatly respected, loved, admired, including the Pope.

In this hysteria, everybody is tainted. Here Andrew Sullivan, a Catholic, writes as though the entire priesthood is corrupted by sexual repression and they’re all, every single one of them, covering up for each other.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:27 AM

Pope condemns critics over abuse scandal 'gossip'

VATICAN CITY
The Independent (United Kingdom)

By Jerome Taylor, Religious Affairs Correspondent

Sunday, 28 March 2010

In his Palm Sunday address the Pope reminded worshippers that belief in Jesus Christ helped lead Christians 'towards the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion.'

In a characteristically cryptic but illuminating speech to mark the start of the Christian Holy Week, Pope Benedict XVI made it clear today that he would not intimidated by his critics over the ongoing sexual abuse scandal enveloping his church.

Speaking at a Palm Sunday service in Rome in front of tens of thousands of worshippers, the 82-year-old pontiff made no official mention of global clerical sex abuse scandals that have thrown the church into its worst crisis in recent decades.

But he did launch a clear broadside against those who have called on him to do more to explain his previous role as the Vatican’s head investigator of child abuse claims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:23 AM

Abuse protesters call on Pope to resign

UNITED KINGDOM
UTV

Protesters gathered outside the main Catholic Church in London on Sunday to call for the Pope's resignation over clerical sex abuse.

Carrying placards stating "Pope Protects Paedophile Priests - Resign!" and "Sex Abuse Cover Up - Pope Must Resign" demonstrators confronted the congregation as it left Westminster Cathedral.

They claim that Pope Benedict XVI was complicit in protecting priests accused of child sex abuse from prosecution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:20 AM

Pope Benedict condemns 'petty gossip' over child sexual abuse scandal

VATICAN CITY
Guardian

Mark Tran and agencies guardian.co.uk, Sunday 28 March 2010

Pope Benedict today risked inflaming opinion as he appeared to round on critics of the Catholic church over the widening sexual abuse scandal, saying he would not "be intimidated by ... petty gossip".

The 82-year-old pontiff led tens of thousands of people in a Palm Sunday service in St Peter's square. He did not mention the scandal engulfing the church directly, but parts of his sermon alluded to it.

The pope said that faith in God helped lead one "towards the courage of not allowing oneself to be intimidated by the petty gossip of dominant opinion".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:17 AM

Clergy sex abuse victims to pass out leaflets to parishioners as they leave Mass

NETHERLANDS
The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests

What:
Holding childhood photos at a sidewalk news conference, three clergy sex abuse victims will
--will pass out leaflets after the 11:00 Mass, begging victims and witnesses to come forward ...

When:
Sunday, March 28 at 11:45 am

Where:
Outside the Cathedral of St. Lawrence and St. Elisabeth, Mathenesseriaan 305, Rotterdam

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:04 AM

Friday, March 26, 2010

UNITED STATES
WPTF

[audio presentation]

Discussing sexual abuse in the Catholic church and dangerous dogs.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Some liberal Catholics are thinking: It's payback time, Ratzinger!

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Damian Thompson

There is still no good evidence that Pope Benedict XVI is seriously implicated in the atrocious child abuse scandals that are – rightly – blackening the reputation of the institutions of the Catholic Church. But still the attempts to join the dots continue. To put it bluntly, there is an increasingly frantic media campaign against the Pope in which headlines are being written first and then facts shaved to fit them.

It is also clear that many prominent liberal Catholics are turning a blind eye to this media vendetta because they don’t like Pope Benedict. They are happy for him to take the rap for diocesan cover-ups initiated, in some cases, by liberal prelates. Those relates are grateful for the opportunity to pass the buck to the one man who, though his record on this matter is certainly not beyond criticism, has done more than any other to rectify the Church’s lax procedures – Joseph Ratzinger.

Some Catholics, such as our blogger Cristina Odone, have protested against the unjust treatment of the Pope. God bless her, for I know that Cristina is not sympathetic to some of the Pope’s views; yet she can spot the hidden agenda here.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 AM

Why Pope Benedict’s got to go!

UNITED STATES
Boston Herald

By Margery Eagan

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Boston Herald Columnist

The Pope should resign. He should offer himself up to authorities for prosecution, like the sacrificial lamb he’s supposed to represent here on earth.

Long ago he should have opened the secret church books on priestly abuse. He hasn’t. Courts finally forced that in Boston almost a decade ago and, oh, what horrors we found. Remember? The Vatican hierarchy then blamed our scandal on a decadent American culture. Now the same priestly disease has swept Ireland, Germany, the Netherlands, on and on across Europe and beyond. So was all the world, from the 1950s on, just one huge, decadent Gomorrah? Or was the Catholic hierarchy, from the ’50s on, run like an international crime organization aiding and abetting child abuse, then covering up its cover-up?

A few years back, former Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating caused an uproar by comparing secret-keeping American bishops to La Cosa Nostra.

He was but ahead of his time

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:53 AM

Pope: I 'will not be intimidated' by sex abuse accusations

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome

Pope Benedict XVI has opened Holy Week indicating that he would "not be intimidated" by accusations against the Vatican over the clerical sex abuse crisis.

In his Palm Sunday address the Pope said that Jesus Christ "leads us towards courage which does not allow us to be intimidated by the chatter of dominant opinions, towards patience which supports and sustains others".

The pontiff did not refer to accusations over his handling of cases of paedophile priests, both as Archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982 and subsequently as head of doctrine at the Vatican. However, Vatican watchers said his meaning today was clear "in the current context".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:49 AM

Ex-pastor is guilty of child porn

LUBBOCK (TX)
Avalanche Journal

By Logan G. Carver | AVALANCHE-JOURNAL
Friday, March 26, 2010

A former Lubbock pastor faces up to 10 years in prison, a lifetime of supervised release and a hefty fine after pleading guilty Thursday to attempted possession of child pornography.

Dean Richard Tarkington admitted to engaging in online sexual activity both at his home and at his office at the Word of Faith Christian Center, according to court documents.

Judge Sam Cummings ordered a pre-sentence investigation. Tarkington will be sentenced at a later date.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:37 AM

Words are not enough

AUSTRALIA
Herald Sun

Alan Howe From: Herald Sun March 29, 2010

PURGATORY would be a busy place. Cosmopolitan, too. It's where Catholics, and many others, believe you are warehoused after you die, possibly with some punishment, before facing God in heaven.

That's presupposing you have not already passed "go" on your way to warmer climes.

I am sure we all test God's mercy - none so much, you'd reckon, as the likes of Middle Eastern suicide bombers and paedophile Catholic priests.

While they might rub shoulders in purgatory, God only knows how their various punishments are measured by He Who Must Be Obeyed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:32 AM

Brady is fighting five legal cases from Smyth victims

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By JIM CUSACK

Sunday March 28 2010

Cardinal Sean Brady is fighting five victims of the paedophile priest rapist Brendan Smyth in legal cases, three of which have been before the High Court for more than a decade.

And it has also been learnt that senior clergy who knew about clerical abusers and did nothing could now be facing prosecution after the appointment of the former heard of the Criminal Assets Bureau to investigate whether offences were committed by failure to report to gardai or to take steps to stop the rape and abuse of children.

Assistant Commissioner John O'Mahony has been brought back to Dublin from his position as head of the garda western region based in Galway.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:25 AM

More paid to lawyers than victims

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By MAEVE SHEEHAN

Sunday March 28 2010

CARDINAL Sean Brady's archdiocese has spent more on legal fees than on compensating victims of sex abuse by priests.

More than €600,000 has been paid to lawyers defending the Archdiocese of Armagh in 10 civil actions while victims shared compensation payouts totalling €562,000.

The disproportionate legal bill will further anger victims of clerical abuse as public opinion towards the cardinal hardens.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:19 AM

Friends leap to defense of priest

WASHINGTON
The Wenatchee World

By Michelle McNiel
World staff writer

Saturday, March 27, 2010

WENATCHEE — The accusation that a former Waterville priest sexually abused a child in the 1970s has shocked people who were close to the priest, including a family who lived with him at one time.

“It’s just not true, it can’t be true,” said June Norman, now of Wenatchee, who worked as a housekeeper and cook for the Rev. Joseph “Joe” Graaff during part of the time he served in Waterville.

“It surprised me — shocked me in fact,” said Mary Ann Sprauer, Graaff’s bookkeeper at the church during the nine years he served in the rural Douglas County community. “This man that I knew professionally was a perfectly decent, honorable man.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:14 AM

Scandal draws mixed response to pontiff

NEW BEDFORD (MA)
South Coast Today

By Steve Urbon
surbon@s-t.com
March 28, 2010

NEW BEDFORD — While the Roman Catholic Church's latest abuse scandal spreads across Europe, SouthCoast reactions are decidedly split as Pope Benedict XVI finds himself at the vortex of a storm of questions about his own possible involvement in handling cases.

Benedict has one of his biggest defenders in the Rev. Roger Landry, pastor of St.. Anthony's of Padua Church in New Bedford and editor of the diocesan newspaper, The Anchor.

Landry had a casual acquaintance with Benedict, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, when he was in Rome as a young priest in the late 1990s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:11 AM

OUR VIEW: Heartbreak for Catholics

MASSACHUSETTS
South Coast Today

March 28, 2010

Through the long agony of the clergy abuse scandal, Roman Catholics have known that some bishops and cardinals in the American church allowed priests who were known pedophiles to continue to prey on children.

The cover-up of crimes committed by a small minority of priests reached the office of Cardinal Bernard Law and other high-ranking bishops in dioceses across the United States.

It has now been alleged, however, that the policy of protecting the institution and its clergy instead of victims of child rape and molestation reached the highest levels of the Vatican, which has responded as it often has — by issuing unsupported denials, deflecting blame and accusing news organizations of waging an attack on the Roman Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:09 AM

Pope Benedict XVI under fire amid fresh scandal

BOSTON (MA)
Boston Herald

By Marie Szaniszlo
Sunday, March 28, 2010

The clergy sex-abuse scandal that has landed on Pope Benedict XVI’s doorstep in recent weeks has yet to produce a smoking gun implicating the pontiff, a theologian said yesterday, making the Pope’s departure very unlikely.

But the distance between Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the Pope’s name when he headed the Archdiocese of Munich, and Cardinal Bernard F. Law, the Boston cleric who quit after revelations that he moved a pedophile priest from one parish to another, is narrowing, said Stephen Pope, professor of moral theology at Boston College.

“Both men tended to treat sexual abuse as a sin rather than as a crime,” Pope said. Still, the mushrooming sex-abuse scandal is “extremely” unlikely to result in Benedict’s resignation or ouster. At the end of the day, the Pope himself calls the Vatican shots.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:02 AM

Catholic Church is getting sex education the hard way

IRELAND
Irish Central

by Father TIm

My friends:

A great deal of the rage and shock felt by the public about the Catholic Church's self-inflicted child sex abuse scandal centers on a simple question: WHY didn't those in authority DO SOMETHING right away when they heard about THE PROBLEM?

Of course, many of those in authority DID do something right away: They either ignored it, blamed the victims and swore them to silence after wrenching, blame-switching interrogations, or transferred the offending priest to another parish or even another country where he was free to renew his evil acts. A few sought to send the priest, or the victims, or all of them, to a Church psychiatrist (a responsibility I know well) -- hopefully to both sort out the truth, arrive at a just solution consistent with canon and civil law, and to help begin the process of emotional and spiritual healing needed by all.

Sadly but honestly though, this latter path was the exception rather than the rule. And an even less-followed path was simply calling the police, although in Ireland particularly, the Church had built itself a very high pedestal from which to "rule" its flock -- which the police were part of. They were not in the business of arresting priests on the word of a couple of young, probably "misbehaving" boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:58 AM

Cravatts: Is the sexual abuse of children by priests inevitable?

MASSACHUSETTS
MetroWest Daily News

By Richard Cravatts/Guest columnist
The MetroWest Daily News
Posted Mar 28, 2010

The recent revelations of yet another history of rampant sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests in Ireland, not to mention Pope Benedict XVI's own complicity in covering up instances of such abuse when he was an archbishop in Germany in the 1980s, still leaves unanswered and troubling questions about the psychology of the perpetrators and the motivation of Church leaders who ignored these morally-defective, criminal actions and allowed them to continue.

What is it about the Catholic Church that attracted the many priests who would go on to sexually abuse hundreds of pre- and post-pubescent children, both in Europe and the United States?

Answering those questions gives clues about why the Church's scandal happened, and, more importantly, how Church leadership and lay professionals can begin to unravel the psychosocial trap into which many troubled priests have seemingly fallen.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:54 AM

Ruben Rosario: He spoke truth to power, but Vatican wouldn't listen

UNITED STATES
Pioneer Press

By Rubén Rosario

Updated: 03/28/2010

Last Sunday, I went to a suburban east metro Catholic church I sometimes attend. The elderly priest gave a traditional Lenten homily based on the biblical tale of the adulterous woman and Jesus' words, 'Let ye who have not sinned cast the first stone.'

It was all well and good until, right before the benediction, the priest implored the congregation to pray that the health care reform bill be defeated by Congress because it contained federal funding for abortion. I will wager a week's pay the guy did not read the entire bill.

There was also no mention of how the Catholic Church's priest abuse scandal has spread across Europe and into Pope Benedict XVI's native Germany in recent months. ...

I confess all this now as a backhanded way of introducing Father Tom Doyle, 65. Four decades ago, the Sheboygan, Wis., native went through "priesthood boot camp" in Winona, Minn., and ultimately became a top official in the hierarchy of the Roman Catholic Church.

As a canon lawyer for the Vatican's embassy in Washington, Doyle seemed on a smooth ascension up the diplomatic and legal ladders of a church he believed with all his heart and soul was the paragon of morality.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:50 AM

Time to heal: After 30 years, local woman speaks about clergy abuse

NORTH ANDOVER (MA)
The Eagle-Tribune

By Brian Messenger
bmessenger@eagletribune.com

NORTH ANDOVER — It came without warning, a subconscious flash flood washing up images from a forgotten childhood. Painful details Kristen Merrill unwittingly suppressed for decades made their return. She thought she was dreaming.

The distinct wallpaper in the rectory kitchen. The green linoleum counter top and a red tin filled with cookies her grandmother made. Her yellow blouse.

And there stood the man she knew simply then as Father Paul, a popular priest at St. Michael Church who years later would marry her to a young Coast Guardsman.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:43 AM

Valley native who took down Geoghan still fighting for victims

METHUEN (MA)
The Eagle-Tribune

By Brian Messenger
bmessenger@eagletribune.com

METHUEN — He is the Hampshire Street farm boy best known for taking down former priest and pedophile John J. Geoghan.

Mitchell Garabedian had been an attorney for 15 years when a woman walked into his Boston law office in the mid-1990s with her three children in tow.

The story they shared with him would change all their lives, not to mention those of countless other victims with similar tales of sexual abuse at the hands of Geoghan and other clergy members.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:41 AM

Does Pope Benedict XVI Lack Moral Authority to Sanctimony?

New Liberian

By Paul I. Adujie, New York

Pope Benedict XVI and the hierarchy of the Catholic Church deserve worldwide condemnations for the failure and wanton neglect to action.

They failed to act, again, and again and again in connection with this pandemic of sex abuses and molestations of children which is now revealed. Data, evidences, facts which are thoroughly documented have revealed wide ranging sex abuse of children in America, Germany, Ireland, Italy and quite likely, these sexual exploitation of innocent hapless children occurred worldwide.

This pandemic of sexual abuse and exploitation of children by the hierarchy of the Catholic Church is evidently still unfolding. The length and breadth of sex abuse of children by Catholic Church priests is clearly predominant a practice in many nations across the world. The unfolding torrid tales of lewd criminal sex abuse of children by these priests are just mind boggling depravity.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:38 AM

Vatican says pope's authority still strong despite sex abuse scandal

VATICAN CITY
Los Angeles Times

March 28, 2010

Vatican City - The Vatican said Saturday that recent attacks on the church over its handling of clerical sex abuse cases have been harmful but that the pope's authority had not been weakened.

Instead, the Vatican spokesman said, Pope Benedict XVI's authority and the commitment of the Vatican doctrinal and disciplinary office "have been confirmed in their support and guidance to bishops to combat and root out the blight of abuse wherever it appears."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:36 AM

Pope Benedict Should Resign In Wake Of Catholic Church Paedophile Scandals

Voxy

Chris Ford

Pope Benedict XVI should consider resigning the papacy after revelations of his involvement in possible cover ups of paedophile sex offending by priests.

This past week has witnessed a new round of revelations surrounding the abuse of Deaf schoolboys in the United States by a now deceased former priest during the 1960s. The most alarming revelations, however, have surfaced from within Benedict's former German archdiocese where it is alleged that he took part in the cover up of child sex abuse by priests there during the 1980s. Furthermore, it has been reported that when Benedict (as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger) was head of the Vatican's doctrinal office under Pope John Paul II, he was very slow to act on cases of child sex abuse that were reported to him in that capacity.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:33 AM

Catholics keep the faith

CANADA
Montreal Gazette

By IRWIN BLOCK, The Gazette

The scandal of child sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clergy and the suggestion of a cover-up by Pope Benedict XVI while still a cardinal have done nothing to shake the faith of Montreal believers in the church and its precepts.

That's what a parent, a seminarian, a priest, and two students said in random interviews yesterday as several hundred Catholics gathered in Chinatown to celebrate World Youth Day, founded 25 years ago by Pope John Paul II.

At the Chinese Catholic Community Centre, young women prepared palm leaves for an afternoon procession - a head start for today's Palm Sunday and the beginning of Holy Week, which precedes Easter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:29 AM

Abuse, denial

PENNSYLVANIA
The Times-Tribune

The Vatican newspaper last week characterized a mounting sexual abuse scandal as a global media conspiracy against the Catholic Church "as if," L'Osservatore Romano said, "it were the only one responsible for sexual abuse."

Sexual abuse of children actually is a common feature of secular news coverage just about everywhere. The problem for the Catholic Church, and the reason for the media focus, is the Vatican's failure to decisively deal with it.

When the epidemic of abuse in the United States first was revealed about a decade ago, the Vatican called it an "American problem," that is, an element of the decadent American culture rather than a problem within the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:26 AM

Swiss president calls for blacklist of 'paedophile' priests

SWITZERLAND
Expatica

Swiss President Doris Leuthard called in remarks published Sunday for paedophile priests to be put on a blacklist to ensure they have no contact with children.

"It is important that paedophiles, whether they are priests, teachers or if they have one form or other dealings with children, should no longer be able to have contact with children," she said on the website of Swiss newspaper Le Matin Dimanche.

"Maintaining a centralised register as it currently exists for teachers should also be discussed for paedophile priests," she said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:23 AM

Vatican knew of allegations against Ontario priest: Victim

CANADA
Toronto Star

Sandro Contenta
Feature Writer

An Ontario victim of a pedophile priest who later became a top Vatican official says the Vatican knew of allegations against the priest years before he was convicted.

The priest, former Monsignor Bernard Prince, was convicted in 2008 of molesting 13 young boys between 1964 and 1984. Most of the incidents occurred in the Killaloe area, near Pembroke in eastern Ontario. He was defrocked last year.

Prince was appointed to a top Vatican job in Rome in 1991 – the year after the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pembroke learned of sex abuse allegations – says the victim, who can't be identified because of a court publication ban on identifying him. The victim says in 1993 the Apostolic Nunciature in Ottawa – the Vatican's embassy – was notified of the allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:19 AM

Pope is setting the right example

MALTA
Times of Malta

Fr Joe Borg

During the pontificate of John Paul II, the Church got accustomed to apologising for mistakes committed decades and centuries ago.

Pope Benedict took the process a step further. He did not find it difficult to apologise for mishandling the Bishop Williamson case due to incomplete information given to him. Moreover, on March 20, Pope Benedict personally apologised to victims of priestly sexual abuse in Ireland and announced new steps to heal the wounds of the scandal, including a Vatican investigation and a year of penitential reparation.

The letter proved how unjust and untruthful are the attempts of those trying to link the Pope to cases of abusing priests or to the culture of silence which, unfortunately, was common in the Church for a very long period of time.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:17 AM

Archbishop: Pope will not resign

UNITED KINGDOM
BBC News

[with video]

The Archbishop of Westminster Vincent Nichols says the Pope will not resign over the paedophile priests scandal.

The Most Reverend Vincent Nichols told Andrew Marr that child abuse was "the most-hidden crime" following a slew of reports of sexual misconduct with minors by members of the Roman Catholic church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:14 AM

As It Stands: If the truth sets you free, the Catholic Church is in captivity

UNITED STATES
Times-Standard

Dave Stancliff/For the Times-Standard
Posted: 03/28/2010

Facts can fracture foundations, but once they are exposed they can also be repaired. The current scandals involving the Roman Catholic pedophile priests in Ireland, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, the United States, the Netherlands and Italy are rocking the church's credibility and stability to the core.

When Pope Benedict XVI recently sent a letter to Ireland apologizing for the chronic child abuse within the Catholic Church, after offering no help to three official Irish investigations that revealed 100 years of abuse in the Dublin Archdiocese and the rural Ferns diocese, he followed the road paved by his predecessors. Over 15,000 victims of sexual abuse by priests have been discovered thus far.

In his letter, the Pope urged priests to confess if they're child molesters, but didn't say what he'd do with them when they did. He mentioned facing the law. But whose law? The Vatican's track record with the church's pedophiles is not very reassuring. The church outright refused to help in the 2001-2009 probes that revealed the scale and longevity of the abuse suffered by Irish children throughout the 20th century.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:11 AM

Pope opens Holy Week amid abuse crisis

VATICAN CITY
Cape Cod Times (United States)

By The Associated Press
March 28, 2010

VATICAN CITY — Pope Benedict XVI has opened the church's solemn Holy Week amid increasing questions about his own handling of cases of sexual abuse of children by priests.

Benedict's procession entered St. Peter's Square on Sunday at the start of Palm Sunday Mass. The pontiff, in crimson and golden vestments, waved to the throngs of faithful waving palm fronds and olive branches.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:07 AM

March 27, 2010

What Vatican secrets does disgraced Bishop John Magee take with him ?

IRELAND
Irish Central

by Niall O'Dowd

The disgraced Bishop of Cloyne John Magee will bring at least two dark secrets to his grave with him. He resigned this week after a tribunal found he had blatantly failed to implement church regulations on abuse of children.

The Newry-both Magee was Secretary to three popes, Pope Paul VI, Pope John Paul I and Pope John Paul II, the only cleric in history to achieve such an incredible honor. In the picture above he is with John Paul II.

John Cooney, an Irish journalist covering religious affairs, wrote how Magee proudly boasted that Pope Paul VI treated him as a son, and that John Paul II treated him like a brother.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:30 PM

Protesters urge Pope to quit over sex abuse 'cover up'

UNITED KINGDOM
BBC News

Campaigners are to urge Pope Benedict XVI to resign over the alleged cover up of sex abuse by some Catholic clergy.

They will protest outside Westminster Cathedral from 1200 GMT over claims he failed to ensure priests who abused young people were reported to police.

The Protest the Pope coalition says he has personal responsibility for letting many paedophile priests escape justice.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:03 PM

Vatican Attacks Americans, White House Does Nothing

UNITED STATES/VATICAN CITY
News Junkie Post

By Liam Fox
NEWS JUNKIE POST

Mar 27, 2010

Dr. Miguel Humberto Diaz is the American Ambassador to the the Holy See, the State of the Vatican City(1). As yet, there has been no official reaction from Dr. Diaz, on behalf of the United States Government, demanding official accountability by the State of the Holy See to the citizens of the United States of America for crimes committed by its officials against American citizens.

There is a great deal of reaction regarding the silence of the Holy See government, and its head of state Pope Benedict XVI, regarding these atrocities. The silence of the American Government, charged with the protection of its citizens, against all enemies foreign and domestic, is somewhat more puzzling. Thousands of America’s most vulnerable citizens have been terrorized by agents directly under the supervision of a foreign power. Where is the official action from the American government?

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has also refrained from exercising the duties of her office despite the many thousand attacks and assaults against American citizens aided by this foreign Power. Diplomatic relations and status must be reviewed immediately, and appropriate limitations and suspensions applied as a result of the Holly See’s official complicity to these heinous crimes. The American government must not remain inactive when its people have been so egregiously violated.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:56 PM

The Pope says pray for these priests. I say prosecute them

UNITED KINGDOM
Mail

By Suzanne Moore

Sometimes it is necessary to be graphic. To spell things out however upsetting it may be. Pope Benedict XVI’s letter to the people of Ireland emphasised the spiritual rebuilding that must take place following the child-abuse scandals that have engulfed the Catholic church there. It talks a lot about priests but not much about the actual abuse.

So let’s be clear: we are not talking about a little inappropriate behaviour, a clumsy pass, standing too close to a teenager. We are talking about the rape of children. We are talking about systematic beatings, torture and humiliation. Many of those abused by priests and monks are now elderly but they weep and tremble when recounting what those who were meant to care for them did.

Last year in Ireland, the ten-year Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, that had heard evidence from 2,000 people aged between 50 and 80 who grew up in Catholic institutions, concluded that abuse was ‘endemic’.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:52 PM

Hitchens: Pope Benedict wants 'wiggle room' for 'rape and torture of children'

PageOneQ

by Stephen C. Webster, Raw Story

The Catholic Church is in serious trouble and may have nowhere to run, depending on who you ask.

"I warned them about all of this," declared author Christopher Hitchens, appearing on HBO's Real Time with Bill Maher on Friday night. "Nothing good can come of a church that has as its' slogan, 'Leave no child's behind.' And then they went and chose as pope the man who was personally responsible, in his dioceses, and institutionally responsible for the cover-up. So now, there's no escape."

The child rape scandals that have savaged Catholic ranks for years starting in the United States, then flaring up in Ireland, Germany, Italy and other locations around the world, have finally come to implicate Pope Benedict XVI, according to recent reports.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:50 PM

Vatican defensive as pope targeted in child abuse scandal

VATICAN CITY
Sydney Morning Herald

MICHELE LERIDON
March 28, 2010

Pope Benedict XVI will not be weakened by abuse scandals rocking the Roman Catholic Church, the Vatican said Saturday, amid mounting criticism of his handling of predator priests.

The Vatican, which dismissed a New York Times report Friday that Benedict had failed in 1980 to stop a priest accused of sexually abusing children, put up a brave front amid mounting criticism in newspapers and magazines.

"The recent media attacks have without doubt caused damage," Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi told Italy's ANSA news agency.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:45 PM

No sermon needed on church sex abuse, says bishop

CANADA
Calgary Sun

By DAVE DORMER, Calgary Sun

Last Updated: March 27, 2010

The clerical sex abuse scandal hanging over the Catholic church won’t be addressed by Bishop Fred Henry during Palm Sunday services.

Instead, the leader of the Calgary Catholic diocese said he will be focusing his message on preparing for the Easter holiday

“I’m going to speaking about the entry of Jesus into Jerusalem and setting up holy week,” he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:43 PM

NZ Catholics doubt Pope knew of abuse

NEW ZEALAND
New Zealand City

28 March 2010
A leading figure amongst New Zealand Catholics says the ongoing bad publicity is bringing sadness to the church.

Questions have been raised about how much the Pope and the Vatican knew about cases of sexual abuse by clergy and whether the Pope did enough to address the issue of pedophile priests before he was appointed to the church's top position.

Pat Dunn, the Catholic Bishop of Auckland, says the allegations have brought sadness to the church in New Zealand, but he doubts the Pontiff would have knowingly done anything to protect an offender. He says the letter Pope Benedict sent to Irish Catholics last week demonstrated his understanding of their of hurt and outrage over abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:40 PM

Celibacy, sexual abuse and other stories

NIGERIA
Punch

By Casmir Igbokwe, Published: Sunday, 28 Mar 2010

PENULTIMATE Sunday, worshippers at Saint Francis Catholic Church, Idimu, Lagos, heard what many considered a funny story. According to the story, a parishioner took another man‘s wife to a hotel to catch some fun. No sooner had they settled down at their rendezvous than some kidnappers struck. They took the man away and demanded N5m ransom.

The culprit‘s wife does not have this kind of money. Though shocked, she still summoned courage to meet and plead with the husband of her man‘s concubine to release her husband. Obviously, she thought the man engineered her hubby‘s abduction. That one denied any knowledge of the incident. Not knowing where else to go, this woman decided to approach the church for help.

Hence, a church official made an important announcement. Those who wished to help the woman, he reportedly said, should come forward with their freewill donation. Some hissed. Some giggled.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:37 PM

Chilean Priest Under Investigation for Sexual Abuse of Minors

CHILE
Latin American Herald Tribune

VALPARAISO, Chile – A Chilean priest is being investigated for suspected sexual abuse of minors and for aiding prostitution.

Judicial sources said that Fr. Juan Henriquez Zapata, 64, a parish priest in the city of Limache, located at some 100 kilometers (62 miles) northwest of Santiago, is suspected of having paid in 2008 the sum of 25,000 pesos (about $48), to practice oral sex on two minors aged 15 and 16.

According to accusations by local prosecutors at a hearing, the incidents occurred in April of that year at the priest’s home behind the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:34 PM

Irish Cardinal refuses to quit over abuse cover-up despite Vatican outrage

IRELAND
Scotman

Published Date: 28 March 2010
By Michael McHugh
REPORTS that the Vatican intends to force the head of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland to quit over the paedophile priests scandal have been dismissed by his spokesman.

Cardinal Sean Brady has apologised for his role in the handling of sex abuse cases. But he insists he wants to work towards a just resolution of a case being raised against him by an abuse victim. The man claims he was abused by Father Brendan Smyth and alleges the Church failed to do enough to stop Smyth.

The Northern Ireland Assembly is preparing to order an official investigation into child abuse after details emerged of more attacks on children by the clergy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:32 PM

Pope faces fresh wave of child abuse scandals in Italy

UNITED KINGDOM
The Observer

Tom Kington in Rome and Henry McDonald in Dublin
The Observer, Sunday 28 March 2010

Pope Benedict XVI is facing growing pressure over his handling of paedophile priests as new cover-ups come to light in Italy, the country with the greatest concentration of Roman Catholic clerics.

After the latest allegations – that Benedict took no action in the US when he was head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican's enforcer – the church is now "terrified" as more victims stand up to be counted in Italy, according to Roberto Mirabile, head of La Caramella Buona, an Italian anti-abuse group. "With the scandals erupting abroad, we will see a huge growth in victims' groups in Italy in coming weeks," said Mirabile yesterday. As Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Benedict handled abuse cases at the Vatican for 24 years before he became pope in 2005.

"We are likely to discover that the Vatican worked even harder in Italy with bishops than elsewhere to hide cases, simply because the contact was closer and the church is so powerful in Italy," Mirabile added.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:28 PM

Pope deserves better credit

CANADA
The Ottawa Citizen

By David Warren, The Ottawa Citizen

March 27, 2010

Palm Sunday is as good a day as any to be defending the Catholic Church against the latest onslaught of media smears, and the tireless efforts to tarnish Pope Benedict personally.

I desisted from writing this column for St. Patrick’s Day, when the issue was whether in 1979, Joseph Ratzinger, then Archbishop of Munich and Freising, had knowingly transferred a pedophile priest to another assignment where he could abuse more children.

The truth was that he had removed the offending priest from his station promptly, and sent him into therapy; and that without Ratzinger’s knowledge, that priest’s parochial vicar, no doubt falsely believing he was “cured,” later put him back in a parochial setting. To suggest that Ratzinger had knowingly put other children at risk was a calumny. But I notice the journalists are still combing old cc’d memos to find mud that will stick.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:25 PM

Victims of sex abuse to sue Vatican

The Times (United Kingdom)

Tony Allen-Mills in New York and John Follain in Rome

NEW revelations about Pope Benedict XVI’s alleged role in covering up accusations of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy have exposed the Vatican to the risk of lawsuits brought by victims around the world.

Mounting anger at the Catholic Church’s failure to act on predatory priests in the US, Europe and Mexico has plunged the papacy into an institutional crisis described by an American Catholic newspaper last week as “the largest in centuries”.

Yesterday the Vatican denounced the “aggressive persistence” of critics who were attempting to “involve the Holy Father personally in the matter of abuse”. A spokesman told Vatican Radio that the Pope’s record was “above discussion”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:21 PM

Beyond the church: Most child sex abuse never sees the light

UNITED STATES
The Oregonian

By Susan Nielsen, The Oregonian
March 27, 2010

Is it hard for survivors of child sex abuse to speak out?

Is the pope Catholic?

Victims worldwide continue to pour forward with stories of abuse as children at the hands of clergy. Many of the allegations have been substantiated by priests who've confessed. Even the pope himself was drawn into the scandal last week with questions about his past role in protecting an abusive priest from earthly consequences.

The surprising part here isn't the sheer number of victims, from the deaf children in Wisconsin to the altar boys in Ireland. The real shocker is remembering that most child sex abuse victims aren't connected to churches, don't file lawsuits and never speak publicly at all.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:16 PM

Pope defended over sex abuse row

VATICAN CITY
Herald (Ireland)

Sunday March 28 2010

The Vatican said recent attacks on the church over its handling of clerical sex abuse cases have been harmful, but insisted the pope's authority had not been weakened.

Instead, the Vatican spokesman said, Pope Benedict XVI's authority and the commitment of the Vatican doctrinal and disciplinary office "have been confirmed in their support and guidance to bishops to combat and root out the blight of abuse wherever it appears."

"The way in which the church deals with it is crucial for her moral credibility," said the spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, on Vatican Radio.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:13 PM

Holy Father, I can stay no longer in this Church of Disgust

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

India Knight

My daughter was baptised into the Roman Catholic faith when she was two months old. She is now six, and should really be gearing up for her first communion. The fact that she isn’t is down to one factor: the parish priest at the local church was suspended, pending investigations into allegations of child abuse.

He was eventually cleared of all charges, which was nice for him but didn’t really work for me because I don’t want any of my children left alone with adult men in any context where the words “child abuse” are hovering in the air. In recent years that context has, sadly, broadened to include the entire church.

To be blunt about it, my daughter was baptised because we feared she might die — she had complicated open-heart surgery a few weeks after she was born, and for some reason I found the sacrament intensely comforting. Beautiful, too.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:10 PM

A Nope for Pope

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

By MAUREEN DOWD
Published: March 27, 2010

WASHINGTON

Yup, we need a Nope.

A nun who is pope.

The Catholic Church can never recover as long as its Holy Shepherd is seen as a black sheep in the ever-darkening sex abuse scandal.

Now we learn the sickening news that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, nicknamed “God’s Rottweiler” when he was the church’s enforcer on matters of faith and sin, ignored repeated warnings and looked away in the case of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, a Wisconsin priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys.

The church has been tone deaf and dumb on the scandal for so long that it’s shocking, but not surprising, to learn from The Times’s Laurie Goodstein that a group of deaf former students spent 30 years trying to get church leaders to pay attention.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:07 PM

Pope considers emergency 'abuse summit'

VATICAN CITY
The Independent (United Kingdom)

By John Phillips in Rome

Sunday, 28 March 2010

As pilgrims, tourists and the faithful congregate in St Peter's Square today to collect olive branches during a solemn Palm Sunday Mass, an embattled Pope Benedict XVI is coming under mounting pressure to call an emergency synod of bishops from around the world to hammer out a new strategy to deal with the worsening child abuse scandal, Vatican sources say.

A number of Roman Catholic prelates have strongly urged the Holy See that such an extraordinary synod, or conference, be held on the grounds that the German pontiff and the Vatican evidently cannot cope effectively on their own with the spiralling image crisis.

"There is a deep feeling of unease in the Vatican at the moment," said one well-placed source in the Holy See. "Senior people in the Curia feel under siege from parts of the international media as they see it trying to nail the Pope for allegedly covering up or mishandling abuse cases.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:03 PM

Bad Popes

UNITED STATES
The Fifth Column

Bonnie Erbe of US News and World Report is in high dudgeon. The Pope was remiss in handling a sexually abuse priest! Hang the Pope! yada, yada, yada.

Now, as a Catholic, I want to personally thank Bonnie and company for their close attention to the Catholic Church's trials and tribulations. After all, Bonnie is very concerned for Catholic welfare. She cares about Catholics in a way that she obviously doesn't when it comes to any other group of people.

When Carol Shakeshaft reported on the level of sexual abuse in the American public school system, Bonnie was silent as a lamb. When Yemen found it impossible to outlaw child marriage, Bonnie saw no news. There is nothing wrong with Muslims who insist that child marriage is not only legal, but laudable, because they are Muslims, after all, and we can't expect them to be decent people. And we won't even discuss how the ritual of Jewish circumcision passes on HIV to infants, or the rates of sexual abuse in Jewish or Protestant communities.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:33 PM

Canadian Cardinal jumps to the defence of Pope

CANADA
Montreal Gazette

By Amy Husser, Canwest News Service

One of Canada’s highest-ranking Roman Catholic officials has joined the ranks of those coming to the defence of Pope Benedict XVI, as the pontiff faces allegations he turned a blind eye to priests who were sexually abusing children.

The scandal has led to some calls for Benedict to resign, and on Saturday one Swiss newspaper reportedly called him “the biggest sinner in the whole Catholic Church."

Cardinal Marc Ouellet — who is the Primate of the Catholic Church in Canada — posted a statement on the website of his archdiocese in Quebec City that denounced the reports from “several media” this week.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:20 PM

Church abuse victims dissect '08 pope meeting anew

BOSTON (MA)
San Francisco Chronicle

By JAY LINDSAY, Associated Press Writer

Saturday, March 27, 2010

(03-27) 09:53 PDT BOSTON, (AP) --

Two years ago, Bernie McDaid stepped out of a police escort and into a Washington, D.C., chapel for a secret meeting with Pope Benedict XVI and a handful of clergy sex-abuse victims like him.

McDaid left afterward believing Benedict was beginning to understand the scope of his church's corruption. He doesn't believe that today.

"Was it a PR move? Looking back at that now, I have to say it was," McDaid said of the meeting. "Everything they do is not about the children. It's about the church. It's always the church first."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:15 PM

At the Vatican, Up Against the World

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By FRANK BRUNI
Published: March 26, 2010

Of the many heartbreaking details in the latest round of outrage over child sexual abuse in the Catholic Church, one stands out as particularly emblematic: a tidy window into Church leaders’ mindsets; a bracing glimpse of what went wrong.

It traces back to 1975, when the Rev. Sean Brady, now a cardinal at the head of the Catholic Church in Ireland, was tending to two boys who had been molested by a priest. By Cardinal Brady’s own admission, he did not report what had happened to the authorities. It was his understanding, he said, that the church would not want that. Instead, the boys — one 14, one just 10, both surely reeling — were forced to sign an oath that such notification would never be made.

It is doubtful that pledge helped them heal, or that he or anyone else in the church thought it might. It certainly did not safeguard other children, many of whom the priest went on to molest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:06 PM

Vatican Calls Scandal Test of 'Moral Credibility'

VATICAN CITY
The Wall Street Journal

By STACY MEICHTRY
ROME—The Vatican said Saturday that the Roman Catholic Church faces a test of "moral credibility" in confronting a global sexual-abuse crisis, which has shaken the papacy of Pope Benedict XVI.

In an address on Vatican Radio, Vatican spokesman the Rev. Federico Lombardi highlighted the recent media scrutiny of the church's handling of sexual-abuse cases.

His remarks come in the wake of reports in the New York Times focusing on how the pope handled cases of alleged sex abusers when he was Archbishop of Munich and subsequently as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican department in charge of disciplining priests.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:03 PM

Vatican pressured to reveal more about Pope Benedict connection to sex abuse cases

VATICAN CITY
The Christian Science Monitor

By Brad Knickerbocker, Staff writer / March 27, 2010

Pressure is building on the Vatican to reveal more information about a priest accused of sexually molesting boys – specifically the extent to which Pope Benedict XVI, then an archbishop in Munich, may have known about the sex abuse.

.“The future Pope Benedict XVI was kept more closely apprised of a sexual abuse case in Germany than previous church statements have suggested, raising fresh questions about his handling of a scandal unfolding under his direct supervision before he rose to the top of the church’s hierarchy,” the New York Times reported Friday.

“Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope and archbishop in Munich at the time, was copied on a memo that informed him that a priest, whom he had approved sending to therapy in 1980 to overcome pedophilia, would be returned to pastoral work within days of beginning psychiatric treatment,” the Times report states. “The priest was later convicted of molesting boys in another parish.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:00 PM

Clerical Paedophilia in the Catholic Church – are economic migrants into the priesthood to blame?

UNITED KINGDOM
Asian Tribune

Hemantha Abeywardena writes from London…
London, 28 March, (Asiantribune.com): At the moment, the Catholic Church wants to be seen as an institute, metaphorically speaking, under siege in the wake of serious allegations about sexual abuse of children and the subsequent systematic cover-up, both in America and Europe. The burgeoning scandal in the two continents has started knocking on the central core of the powerful establishment; even its head, the Pontiff, is no longer immune from accusations. Nor is he above criticism any more.

The Vatican was compelled to issue a statement through its printed media condemning what it called ‘ignoble’ attacks to smear the Holy Father, following a report in the New York Times which said that the then Cardinal Ratzinger, the present Pope Benedict, failed to take action against a priest who abused 200 deaf boys in the US in the eighties.

It was only last week that the pope wrote to the Irish Catholics while apologising for what some of them suffered at the hand of a section of the Catholic clergy. It came in the form of an open letter to be distributed among the church-goers. Unfortunately, the letter didn’t go far enough for the victims and the debate reignited on both sides of the Atlantic pool and then spread like wild fire; the pontiff has been forced to moonlight as a fire-fighter too, in addition to his demanding daily spiritual duties, with the long hose of Vatican’s media unit at full stretch.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:54 PM

A Papal Conversion

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

By JOHN L. ALLEN Jr.
Published: March 27, 2010

Denver

IN light of recent revelations, Pope Benedict XVI now seems to symbolize the tremendous failure by the Catholic Church to crack down on the sexual abuse of children. Both the pope’s brief stint as a bishop in Germany 30 years ago and his quarter-century as a top Vatican official are being scoured for records of abusive priests whom he failed to stop, and each case seems to strengthen the indictment.

For example, considerable skepticism surrounds the Vatican’s insistence that in 1980 the pope, then Archbishop Joseph Ratzinger of Munich, was unaware of a decision to transfer a known pedophile priest to his diocese and give him duties in a parish. In some ways, the question of what he knew at the time is almost secondary, since it happened on his watch and ultimately he has to bear the responsibility. However, all the criticism is obscuring something equally important: For anyone who knows the Vatican’s history on this issue, Benedict XVI isn’t just part of the problem. He’s also a major chapter in the solution.

To understand that, it’s necessary to wind the clock back a decade. Before then, no Vatican office had clear responsibility for cases of priests accused of sexual abuse, which instead were usually handled — and often ignored — at the diocesan level. In 2001, however, Pope John Paul II assigned responsibility to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican’s all-important doctrinal office, which was headed by Joseph Ratzinger, then a cardinal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:50 PM

Northern Ireland plans child abuse investigation

NORTHERN IRELAND
Channel 4 News

Updated on 27 March 2010

[with video]

The Northern Ireland Executive is set to launch a major investigation into child abuse, after allegations that it was rife in the Catholic Church in Northern Ireland and beyond have rocked the community. Kylie Morris reports.

Stormont and Northern Ireland's politicians have finally found their voices over the scandal that has hit the Catholic Church, and Channel 4 News understands that an investigation will take place.

Early indications of the parameters for any Stormont inquiry into abuse suggests it shouldn't concentrate on the church alone, but also on abuse across state institutions.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:47 PM

New Book Release Tells the Heartbreaking True Story of a Survivor of Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
PR-USA

"Altar Boy Altered Life" (ISBN 978-159858-724-1, Dog Ear Publishing) is a new book released by author David Price. When he becomes depressed and suicidal in 1993 at age 28, David Price decides to seek therapy. During his sessions David begins to uncover repressed memories of being sexually abused as a teen (1979-1984) by a trusted and well-loved Catholic priest.

Father Michael Harris, an attractive and athletic young priest and headmaster of David's school, was an extremely popular figure in the community. David Price, one of fourteen children and orphaned by the age of eight, had led a difficult life and was an innocent teenager when he met the man who would change his life forever.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:39 PM

As Archbishop, Benedict Focused on Doctrine

GERMANY
The New York Times

By KATRIN BENNHOLD and NICHOLAS KULISH
Published: March 27, 2010

MUNICH — When Pope Benedict XVI was archbishop of Munich and Freising, he was broadly described as a theologian more concerned with doctrinal debates than personnel matters. That, say his defenders, helps explain why he did not keep close tabs on a pedophile priest sent to his archdiocese in 1980 and allowed to work in a parish.

Yet in 1979, the year before Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, approved the Rev. Peter Hullermann’s move to Munich, the cardinal blocked the assignment to the local university of a prominent theology professor recommended by the university senate. And in 1981, he punished a priest for holding a Mass at a peace demonstration, leading the man to ultimately leave the priesthood.

Pope Benedict’s four-and-a-half-year tenure as archbishop is among the least-examined periods of his life, but his time presiding over 1,713 priests and 2.2 million Catholics was in many ways a dress rehearsal for his present job tending to the Roman Catholic Church’s more than one billion members worldwide.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:33 PM

Vatican say abuse response crucial for credibility

VATICAN CITY
Reuters

(Reuters) - The Catholic Church's response to cases of sexual abuse by priests is crucial to its credibility and it must "acknowledge and make amends for" even decades-old cases, a Vatican spokesman said on Saturday.

The church is reeling from a series of media reports this week that Pope Benedict, before being elected pontiff, may have looked the other way in the case of the abuse of hundreds of boys by a priest at an American school for the deaf.

The Vatican has denied any cover-up in the abuse of 200 deaf boys by Reverend Lawrence Murphy from the 1950s to the 1960s, after the New York Times reported he was not defrocked despite warnings sent to the Vatican and to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, then the church's top doctrinal official, now Pope Benedict.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:32 PM

Ordinary Catholics 'ashamed and broken-hearted'

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ruth Gledhill

Tablet editor Catherine Pepinster's Thought for the Day today was so profoundly moving that I am delighted she has granted permission for me to reproduce it on Articles of Faith, below. A BBC source tells me that normally, the staff in the Today programme office use the brief Thought slot to have a quick coffee break. But today, they all sat and listened. Alone at home, I also had a sense also of the nation stopping what it was doing, to listen closely to what this leading lay Catholic woman would say. Another moving article, this one by lay Catholic Mike McCarthy, appears in today's Independent. 'The crisis affecting the Catholic Church is currently being treated as the failure of an arrogant institution, a sort of colossal religious Watergate, and indeed it is that, but we are starting to see that the trouble runs even deeper, right into the church's spiritual heart. Some sort of terrible worm has got into the bud of Catholicism; its crisis is only beginning,' he writes.

Catherine Pepinster said on BBC Radio 4's Thought for the Day:

'Earlier this week I was fortunate to be able to visit St Walburge’s, one of the most magnificent Catholic churches in the country. These days St Walburge’s is open infrequently for most of the houses that once surrounded it have been demolished and the population has moved elsewhere. But as I looked around this stunning grade one listed church in Preston, I was aware of what I can only describe as its prayerful silence and the thousands upon thousands of ordinary people who’d prayed there over the years.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:04 PM

Local Catholics on sex abuse scandal

HOUSTON (TX)
KTRK

[video presentation]

People from Houston discuss the latest controversy involving allegations of cover-ups of abuse of children within the Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:52 PM

Tréadlitir an Phápa Rónaofa Beinidict XVI Chuig Caitlicigh na hÉireann

IRELAND
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference

The Irish language translation of the Pastoral Letter of the Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI to the Catholics of Ireland is now available on the Irish Catholic Bishops’ website www.catholicbishops.ie as part of a special web feature.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:39 PM

COMMUNIQUÉ regarding the current circumstances of the Legion of Christ and the Regnum Christi Movement

Legion of Christ

March 25, 2010
Solemnity of the Annunciation of the Lord

Introduction

As we are gathered for the annual meeting of the territorial directors with our general director, we wish to write to our brothers in the Legion of Christ, to the consecrated and all the members of Regnum Christi, our families and friends who accompany us at this juncture in our history, and also to all those who have been affected, wounded, or scandalized by the reprehensible actions of our founder, Fr Marcial Maciel, LC.

It has taken us time to come to terms with these facts regarding his life. For many, especially the victims, this time has been too long and very painful.

We have not always been able, or found the way to reach out to everyone in the way we should have, and in fact wanted to. Hence the need we feel to make this communiqué.

1. Regarding some facts in the life of our founder, Fr Marcial Maciel, LC (1920-2008)

We had thought and hoped that the accusations brought against our founder were false and unfounded, since they conflicted with our experience of him personally and his work. However, on May 19, 2006, the Holy See’s Press Office issued a communiqué as the conclusion of a canonical investigation that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) had begun in 2004. At that time, the CDF reached sufficient moral certainty to impose serious canonical sanctions related to the accusations made against Fr Maciel, which included the sexual abuse of minor seminarians. Therefore, though it causes us consternation, we have to say that these acts did take place.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:34 PM

Grinding the Faces of the Oppressed

UNITED STATES
Leon J. Podles: Dialogue

The NYT has the story of how everyone: bishops, priests. Pope, police, failed the deaf children who were molested by Father Murphy. Some critics have asked why victims sometimes take so long to come forward. As the experience of the deaf children showed, even going directly to the police, even leafleting in front of the cathedral did no good. No one would listen to them, no one would help them.

They told other priests. They told three archbishops of Milwaukee. They told two police departments and the district attorney. They used sign language, written affidavits and graphic gestures to show what exactly Father Murphy had done to them. But their reports fell on the deaf ears of hearing people.

Throughout history, the poor, the disadvantaged, the weak, have suffered for the convenience of the important, the wealthy, the powerful. It has been no different in the Church or the state.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:36 PM

Vatican Corruption

UNITED STATES
Leon J. Podles: Dialogue

March 27th, 2010

John Paul II and Paul VI did not listen to the cries of violated children. Why?

I have a few sources with Vatican connections and have received fairly reliable second-hand information, and my guess at the scenario is this.

John Paul, for reasons he refused to explain even to a cardinal who questioned him, would not act against abusers. John Paul was a lousy judge of character. His priest–“friends” in the Krakow chancery were all in the pay of the Communist secret police, and gave them detailed information about the precise location of Wojtyla’s bed, which medicines he took, who his pharmacist was, etc. The priests were supplying information potential assassins in return for permission to study aboard for career advancement. When this was finally discovered after the fall of communism, John Paul’s secretary kept it from him - why disturb an old man, he explained.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:30 PM

Former priest gets 20 years for sexually assaulting 2 teens in Elm Grove

WISCONSIN
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Gina Barton of the Journal Sentinel

Posted: March 27, 2010

A former Catholic priest was sentenced to 20 years in prison Friday for sexually assaulting two teenage boys in Elm Grove in the late 1970s and early 1980s, according to his attorney.

James R. Blume, 64, who first served as a Brother of the Holy Cross, became a priest in 1980. He was removed from the priesthood in June 2007. Blume most recently lived in Florida, where he worked as a prison counselor and social worker, said his attorney, Jonathan LaVoy of Brookfield.

In January, Blume pleaded guilty in Waukesha County Circuit Court to two counts of sexual assault of a child.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:36 PM

The Sources of the Catholic Crisis

William Pfaff

Paris, March 23, 2010 -- I would think one judgement history will make on the Catholic Church’s Second Vatican Council (1962-65), under Pope John XXIII, will be a reproach for its failure to lift the rule of celibacy for secular priests. This has not been a moral failure. It was and remains a monumental failure of human courage and prudence in a matter wholly under the responsibility of the clergy themselves.

The rule of celibacy was ceasing to work and was damaging the Church at the very moment of the Council. The result was an exodus of many of the best priests the Church had, followed by a severe drop in the number of American and European candidates for the priesthood. The
moral spell of the rule of celibacy had broken.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:25 PM

Catholics Need to Save the Church, Hold Bishops and Pope Benedict Accountable in Sexual Abuse Crisis

Bridget Mary's Blog

By Bridget Mary Meehan

“Cry out as if you had a million voices, it is silence that kills the world,” said St. Catherine of Siena, a courageous reformer who lived from 1347-1380, at a time of grave scandal when three men, each claiming to be the pope, shook the church to its foundation. Today Catholics live in a time when the institutional church has lost credibility because of the cover-up of a global sex abuse scandal that, like a rapidly spreading cancer, is destroying the moral fiber of our church. Like St. Catherine, we, the people, need to speak truth to our church leaders including our bishops and our pope. Silence is compliance. It was silence on the part of many good people that allowed world-wide atrocities such as the Holocaust and the rape and murder of hundreds of thousands of women and children in tribal warfare in Africa to continue without world intervention.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:07 AM

Three allegations overseen by Pontiff during church career

Irish Independent

Saturday March 27 2010

In his time as an archbishop in Germany, a cardinal at the Vatican and after becoming Pope Benedict XVI, Joseph Ratzinger has overseen at least three cases involving allegations of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy and church workers. A glance at the cases.

Wisconsin, US

Allegations: About 200 deaf boys at St John's School for the Deaf near Milwaukee, Wisconsin, alleged they were molested by Fr Lawrence Murphy, including in the confessional, in dormitories, in closets and during field trips during his years at the institution from the 1950s through to 1974.

Handling: Church and Vatican documents show that in the mid-1990s, two Wisconsin bishops urged the Vatican office handling abuse cases to let them hold a church trial against Fr Murphy. The office, the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, was led by then-Cardinal Ratzinger.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:58 AM

Stunning flood of claims held in secret diocesan archive

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney and Ralph Riegel

Saturday March 27 2010

A METICULOUSLY maintained secret archive on abuse allegations against clerics in the Diocese of Cloyne has shocked both victim representatives and church investigators.

The revelation came as the Irish Independent has learnt that the same archive will be used to support a flood of civil damages claims once a state-ordered probe into alleged clerical abuses in Dublin and Cloyne is published.

The archive contains stunning data -- recorded in meticulous detail -- on abuse allegations dating over several years, related correspondence, clerical responses and the diocesan handling of the individual complaints. Gardai were, at the time, unaware of significant data in the file.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:55 AM

Pope will force Brady to resign

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney, Ruth Gledhill and Jill Sherman

Saturday March 27 2010

THE Vatican will force the head of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, to quit if he refuses to resign over the growing child abuse scandal.

Sources in Rome signalled that nothing less than Dr Brady's resignation will diminish fury at the highest levels in Rome over his role in paedophile priest cover-ups.

Dr Brady apologised last week for his role in a Catholic Church tribunal on allegations made by a 14-year-old boy against Brendan Smyth, the priest whose case brought down the Government in 1994.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:52 AM

Bruce Arnold: Church must respect State law ahead of its own rules

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Bruce Arnold

Saturday March 27 2010

Politicians, including party leaders, are ignoring their role in putting right deeply flawed social structures that have failed

We have reached a point of surfeit over abuse. The story spreads worldwide, now involving Germany, South America, the United States again with the Milwaukee revelations. We can always trump what happens elsewhere with worse here. If it is deaf children, we had worse in Ireland where boys were sexually abused over decades, and the girls suffered mindless cruelty.

Disabled children? The same. We allowed a massive culture of abuse to develop, the church part of it, but by no means the whole, since the people, together with their guardians -- the State, the law and the police -- simply allowed it to happen. Even today, politicians, including party leaders, are ignoring their role in putting right deeply flawed social structures that have failed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:46 AM

John Cooney: The secret scandal-hit Magee will take to grave

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney

Saturday March 27 2010

ON February 17, 1987, Pope John Paul II announced he was appointing the Master of Pontifical Ceremonies Fr John Magee to the vacant bishopric of Cloyne in Co Cork.

But the story of why the most handsome man in the Vatican became the Bishop of Cloyne has never been told before today.

For the first time, the high drama of ecclesiastical intrigue and ruthless church politics that has been kept under the wraps of pontifical secrecy can now be unveiled.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:38 AM

Pope may seek Brady's resignation - report

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

Saturday, March 27, 2010

It is being reported that the Pope may force the head of the Catholic Church in Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, to resign.

Pope Benedict the Sixteenth is considering asking the Cardinal to step down over his role in a Catholic Church tribunal on abuse allegations by a teenage boy against Fr Brendan Smyth, according to today's Irish Independent .

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:35 AM

Mexican cleric led double life, Vatican inquiry finds

VATICAN CITY
National Post (Canada)

By Philip Pullella

VATICAN CITY -- An influential Roman Catholic priestly order — whose Mexican founder was discovered to have been a sexual molester and to have fathered at least one child — apologized yesterday to the priest’s victims, whose accusations were ignored.

Last week, the Vatican announced the completion of a one-year inquiry of the conservative order, which involved visits by papal inspectors to its more than 120 seminaries, 200 schools and 600 centres for lay Catholics around the world.

Father Marcial Maciel, who died in 2008 at age 87, was a cult figure in the order and for years had the ear of pope John Paul II despite allegations he had abused young male seminarians.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:26 AM

Cardinal Brady Downplays Resignation Claims

IRELAND
98 FM

Reports that the Vatican intends to force Cardinal Sean Brady to resign have been dismissed by his spokesman today.

This morning’s papers claimed that the Pope is to seek the Cardinal’s resignation over his role in the cover-up of child sex abuse cases.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:23 AM

Cardinal Brady denies Vatican wants him to resign

IRELAND
BBC News

Reports that the Vatican want the head of the Catholic Church in Ireland to resign over a child abuse scandal have been denied.

As a priest in 1975 Cardinal Sean Brady was at meetings where children signed vows of silence over complaints against paedophile priest Fr Brendan Smyth.

A number of newspapers reported that the Vatican hierarchy want the cardinal to stand aside.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:19 AM

Vatican stands by pope amid calls for resignation

VATICAN CITY
Deutsche Welle

The Vatican has once again dismissed media allegations that Pope Benedict XVI helped cover up sex abuse as mounting criticism from lay reform movements resulted in a call for the pontiff to step down.

The New York Times reported that during his tenure as archbishop in Germany, Pope Benedict didn't prevent a known pedophile priest, Reverend Peter Hullerman, from being transferred to a new parish.

"The then archbishop had no knowledge of the decision to reassign (Hullerman) to pastoral activities in a parish," the Vatican said in a statement on Friday, March 26, adding that it "rejects any other version of events as mere speculation."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:15 AM

Dutch cardinal apologises for Nazi reference

NETHERLANDS
Radio Netherlands

The former head of the Catholic Church in the Netherlands, Cardinal Ad Simonis, has apologised for his recent remark, in German, "Wir haben es nicht gewusst".

Speaking on television on Tuesday evening, Cardinal Simonis used the notorious German phrase to say Dutch church leaders had not known of any child sex abuse taking place between 1950 and 1980.

The cardinal says his remark has been misinterpreted. He says he feared a plain denial would prompt sneers and so used one himself to preempt them. On Tuesday, he had already added: "I know that is a very dangerous remark and a very loaded one, but it's true."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:11 AM

143 Years of Papal Documents in One Click

VATICAN CITY
Chiesa

[Italian]

[French]

[Spanish]

The Vatican has put on the web the records of the Holy See from the past century and a half, including those on the second world war and on Pius XII and the Jews. A user's guide

by Sandro Magister

ROME, March 27, 2010 – For two days now, all the official records of the Holy See from 1865 to 2007 have been freely available on the internet, in pdf format, on the Vatican website:

> Acta Sanctae Sedis, 1865-1908

> Acta Apostolicae Sedis, 1909-2007

Also available online are the twelve large volumes of the records and documents of the Holy See relative to the period of the second world war, from 1939 to 1945, the collection requested by Paul VI in 1964 and compiled between 1965 and 1981 by the Jesuit historians Pierre Blet, Angelo Martini, Burkhart Schneider and Robert A. Graham:

> Actes et documents du Saint Siège relatifs à la Seconde Guerre Mondiale

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:55 AM

Archbishop Nichols Praises Pope Benedict's Reforms of Vatican Procedures in Clerical Abuse Allegations

UNITED KINGDOM
Vatican Radio

[with audio]

(27 Mar 10 - RV) Archbishop Vincent Nichols of Westminster has explained how extensive the then Cardinal Ratzinger’s reforms of Vatican procedures were after he took over responsibility for dealing with clerical sex abuse allegations in 2001.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:51 AM

Church abuse in Delaware: Diocese bankruptcy judge waits to appoint mediator

WILMINGTON (DE)
The News Journal

From staff and wire reports • March 27, 2010

A judge was expected to sign an order Friday in the Diocese of Wilmington bankruptcy approving a global mediator to help resolve the case outside the courtroom, but it did not happen.

Instead, a proposed order to appoint Thomas Rutter, a retired judge from Philadelphia who has mediated in earlier, individual church abuse cases, was entered on the docket.

According to attorneys, Bankruptcy Judge Christopher S. Sontchi is expected to sign off on Rutter as the mediator early next month at a previously scheduled hearing in the case involving the diocese, the official unsecured creditors committee and abuse victims who are suing the diocese.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:48 AM

Can a pope resign from office?

VATICAN CITY
BBC News

The possibility has been raised that Pope Benedict XVI should resign over the snowballing paedophile priest scandal in the Catholic Church. The BBC's Vatican correspondent, David Willey, examines the question.

In theory, there is nothing to stop Pope Benedict taking a piece of paper out of his writing desk and drafting a letter of resignation to hand to the College of Cardinals, the supreme electoral body of the Catholic Church.

Under Canon Law, the only conditions for the validity of such a resignation are that it be made freely and be properly published.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:45 AM

Top Vatican cardinal defends pope amid scandal

VATICAN CITY
The Associated Press

VATICAN CITY — A top Vatican cardinal is calling for "housecleaning" and urging the Roman Catholic Church to be more alert and brave in dealing with cases of clerical sex abuse.

Cardinal Walter Kasper has also defended the pope, saying he was the first to recognize the need for a harsher stance against offenders. He says attacks on Pope Benedict XVI go "beyond any limit of justice and loyalty."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 AM

Scandal's Stain Spreads Through Vatican

UNITED STATES
NPR

March 27, 2010 The Vatican is facing renewed pressure amid charges that Pope Benedict XVI mishandled priest sex abuse cases while serving as archbishop of Munich in the 1980s. Host Scott Simon talks with John Allen, who reports on the Roman Catholic Church as a senior correspondent for the National Catholic Reporter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:40 AM

Secrecy on child abuse stalks Pope

AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald

AS POPE Benedict XVI struggles to stay above the paedophilia priest scandals engulfing the Catholic Church, the Vatican is facing growing calls for an end to its ''culture of secrecy''.

The Pope is at a ''crossroads'', said Vatican expert Marco Politi the day after the pontiff was implicated for a second time in a snowballing scandal. Pope Benedict has been accused of helping to keep the lid on the case of a US serial abuser - a priest who abused children at a school for the deaf in Wisconsin in the 1960s.

''Either he proceeds on the path of greater transparency'' or he hunkers down with defenders who claim he is being unfairly targeted, said Mr Politi of the left-wing Italian newspaper Il Fatto Quotidiano.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:38 AM

Christ the King keeps eye on state Federation championship, tries to ignore Bob Oliva case

NEW YORK
New York Daily News

BY Mark Lelinwalla and Mitch Abramson
DAILY NEWS SPORTS WRITERS

Saturday, March 27th 2010, 4:00 AM

lThe Christ the King boys basketball team says it is focused on winning a state Federation championship, refusing to let the news of Bob Oliva get in the way.

Oliva, the former legendary basketball coach of CK, was indicted by a Massachussets grand jury Thursday on two counts of child rape.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:33 AM

Vindicating the Victims

UNITED STATES
Leon J. Podles: Dialogue

We are witnessing a cruel irony of history: Joseph Ratzinger, one of the few ecclesiastics to evidence genuine horror at the sexual abuse of children by priests and the one pope since perhaps Pius V to act against corruption in the Church, is receiving a massive international attack for his failures in handling abuse cases.

It is not entirely undeserved. Ratzinger worked within the system and accepted how it handled sexual abusers: treatment and secrecy, and no regard for the victims. He seems to have come to a genuine awakening and determined to change the Church once he became pope, and he did immediately act against abusers, such as Maciel, whom John Paul had protected.

But Ratzinger too had failed to protect children, chiefly through negligence. At the very least, he did not monitor Peter Hullermann, he did not forbid Hullermann to work in a parish, he did not read the memo (perhaps) that Hullermann has been assigned to parish work within days of arriving in Munich for therapy for the “disease” of pedophilia.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:24 AM

Cardinal 'will not be forced to resign'

IRELAND
The Independent (United Kingdom)

By Michael McHugh, Press Association

Saturday, 27 March 2010

Reports that the Vatican intends to force the resignation of the head of the Catholic Church in Ireland over the paedophile priests scandal have been dismissed by his spokesman today.

Cardinal Sean Brady has apologised for his role in the handling of sex abuse cases. He has said he wants to work towards a just resolution of a case being taken against him by a man who claims he was abused by Father Brendan Smyth but not enough was done to stop his attacker.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:20 AM

London protest planned over Pope’s alleged child-abuse cover-up

UNITED KINGDOM
Digital Journal

Protesters in London will on Sunday accuse Pope Benedict XVI of covering up child sex abuse by Catholic clergy and demand his resignation.

“In a 2001 edict to Catholic Bishops worldwide, the Pope ordered a cover-up of child sex abuse by Catholic clergy,” says the Australian-born British human-rights activist Peter Tatchell.

“He failed to ensure that priests who raped and sexually abused young people were reported to the police. This is why he is not welcome in the UK and why we object to his being honoured with a State Visit in September, especially a State Visit that is being funded by the taxpayer,” said Tatchell, who also represents the gay human-rights group OutRage!.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:16 AM

Sisters of Mercy bring insights into addiction to seminary students and faculty

CANADA
The B.C. Catholic

By Laureen McMahon

“Sex” is the number one search topic on the internet, according to U.S. psychiatrist Sister Marysia Weber, a Religious Sister of Mercy. Browsers can now access close to 400 million pornographic websites, up from 1.3 million in 2003.

The Seminary of Christ the King at Westminster Abbey in Mission is among the religious institutions in North America turning to Sister Weber and Sister Esther Mary Nickel, a member of the same order, to help students and faculty understand how the explosion of Internet pornography, the sexual abuse of minors, and homosexual activity affect seminarians and priestly and religious vocations, said Abbot John Braganza, OSB.

“Our concern is the good formation of healthy and mature religious vocations,” the abbot told The B.C. Catholic. “The Church must be in tune with the signs of the times. We are all struggling to deal with this phenomenon of the Internet in a reasonably healthy and spiritual fashion and how to integrate this gift (and the Internet is a gift) in a balanced way into our lives as people faithful to the Gospel.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:13 AM

Church teacher charged with molestation

SUMMERFIELD (FL)
Ocala.com

By Austin L. Miller
Staff writer

SUMMERFIELD - A music teacher at a church school was charged Friday with four counts of lewd and lascivious molestation, one count of lewd and lascivious conduct, 12 counts of lewd and lascivious exhibition and one count of child abuse.

Lanham David Solomon Lanham, 29, turned himself in at the Marion County Jail at 1:50 p.m. He remained behind bars Friday night. He declined to comment for this article.

He is a teacher at Royal Child Academy in Summerfield, and is a member of the Open Door Community Church, where the school is located, at 5200 S.E. 145th St. According to the church Web site, Lanham is listed as a worship leader/design coordinator.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:10 AM

Vatican fights to protect Pope's image

VATICAN CITY
Jamaica Observer

AFP

Saturday, March 27, 2010

VATICAN CITY, Italy (AFP) -- The Vatican fought on yesterday to limit the damage from a report alleging Pope Benedict XVI failed to bar the transfer of a known paedophile priest.

The fresh allegation added fuel to the fire after child abuse scandals sweeping Catholic churches around the world have encouraged more and more victims to speak out.

The New York Times reported on yesterday that Pope Benedict failed to act in 1980 to stop Reverend Peter Hullerman, accused of sexually abusing children, from taking up new duties in a different parish in Germany.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:08 AM

Differing papal perspectives

GetReligion

We’ve discussed a bit of the European media’s coverage of various Roman Catholic sex scandals. The German press has been working on stories dealing with Pope Benedict XVI’s time there as a diocesan bishop, during which one child-molesting priest was transferred. The news has been terribly sad to read. And the New York Times has also gotten into the fray with some hard-hitting coverage. Here’s Laurie Goodstein’s recent story questioning whether then-Cardinal Ratzinger failed to act with one troublesome case involving untold numbers of deaf children in the scandal-plagued Milwaukee diocese.

I haven’t really highlighted the coverage from the New York Times because I didn’t really have much to say. The piece was well researched and written and I thought that Goodstein was careful to not overhype the links — as some of the press across the pond have been doing and as some folks have been doing in response to her reporting.

Still, some folks have gotten a bit carried away. And it doesn’t seem to be calming down much. Religion News Service’s lead story right now is “Will the Pope resign?” What can I say about it other than Andrew Sullivan is actually quoted in the piece?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:05 AM

For Years, Deaf Boys Tried to Tell of Priest’s Abuse

WISCONSIN
The New York Times

[Documents: The Case of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy]

By LAURIE GOODSTEIN and DAVID CALLENDER
Published: March 26, 2010

They were deaf, but they were not silent. For decades, a group of men who were sexually abused as children by the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy at a school for the deaf in Wisconsin reported to every type of official they could think of that he was a danger, according to the victims and church documents.

Mr. Geier reported the abuse to three priests, including the Rev. Tom Schroeder
They told other priests. They told three archbishops of Milwaukee. They told two police departments and the district attorney. They used sign language, written affidavits and graphic gestures to show what exactly Father Murphy had done to them. But their reports fell on the deaf ears of hearing people.

This week, they learned that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, received letters about Father Murphy in 1996 from Archbishop Rembert G. Weakland of Milwaukee, who said that the deaf community needed “a healing response from the Church.” The Vatican sat on the case, then equivocated, and when Father Murphy died in 1998, he died a priest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 AM

NYTimes vs. Pope Benedict: Paper Seeks to Implicate Pope in Abuse Cases

LifeSite

By John Jalsevac

March 26, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The NYTimes has set its sights firmly on Pope Benedict in its front page coverage of the fallout of the sex abuse crisis in the Catholic Church, which has been reignited in recent weeks and months after revelations of abuse by priests and religious in Ireland and Germany.

In recent days the U.S. paper has published a series of articles claiming to have unearthed information personally implicating the pope and/or "top Vatican officials" of having allowed a known child abuser to be put back into pastoral service, and having ignored requests to defrock a known child sex abuser.

The Vatican in turn has blasted the NYTimes coverage - claiming in one case that the coverage included no new information that has not already been soundly refuted, and, in another, that the paper had unfairly targeted the pope and the Vatican for having declined to defrock a priest whose alleged crimes had occurred over two decades previous, and who was dying at the time the Vatican was informed about his misdeeds.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Canada's top cardinal defends Pope

CANADA
CBC News

Canada’s top Roman Catholic cardinal, Quebec City Archbishop Marc Ouellet, is denouncing allegations Pope Benedict XVI covered up cases of sexual abuse by priests.

In a statement released Friday, Ouellet, who is primate of the Roman Catholic Church in Canada, accused members of the media of having ulterior motives for their attempts to link the Pope to cases of sexual abuse.

The Pope has always shown a "zero tolerance" attitude towards sexual assaults committed by members of the clergy at each step of his career in the church, said Ouellet.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 AM

The Words of a Victim

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

Steven Geier, 59, is among the former students of St. John’s School for the Deaf who has accused the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy of sexual abuse. He spoke Thursday to David Callender, a reporter covering the story for The Times, in Madison, Wis. The following is a transcript of their conversation. It has been edited and condensed, and it contains mature language.

The interview began with a question to Mr. Geier asking how he felt about his treatment by the Roman Catholic Church.

A. I feel my church has been very mean to me. When I attended St. John’s, the priests and the nuns were always mean and never nice to any of the children. I’ve never forgotten that the nuns and the priests told us that we were deaf because that was God’s way of punishing our parents. When I saw my mom, I told her that and she said that was not true. She told me that I became deaf because of a high fever.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:52 AM

The Bad Shepherd

UNITED STATES
Newsweek

By Lisa Miller | NEWSWEEK

Two years ago Pope Benedict XVI—once known as "God's Rottweiler"—displayed his gentler side on a pilgrimage to America. Television pundits spoke of his soft white hair, his smile, "his great warmth and his sense of humor," says Thomas Noble, head of the history department at Notre Dame. On the trip Benedict confronted head-on the American church's sexual-abuse crisis, a catastrophe that first came to light in Boston in the 1990s and unfolded over the years, involving more than 10,000 children and 4,400 priests. The pope even met firsthand with a small group of abuse victims in Washington.

But those victims aren't sure he heard what they were saying. One of them was Bernie McDaid, 11 years old when his parish priest started fondling him during car rides in his Boston neighborhood. McDaid, now 54, says that during the meeting, Benedict read a 10-minute speech offering an apology on behalf of the church. Then each victim had a private five-minute audience with the pontiff, who stood, unmoving, before an altar. McDaid says he told the pope what happened to him in detail and warned the Holy Father that sex abuse was "a cancer" in the church. Benedict just listened and nodded. "He would only speak to me when I pushed him for words," says McDaid.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:50 AM

U.S. courts allow sex abuse cases against Vatican to proceed in rare legal move

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

By Michelle Boorstein
Washington Post Staff Writer
Saturday, March 27, 2010

Since the Catholic clergy sexual abuse scandal exploded in the United States almost a decade ago, advocates have been trying to find a way to learn the role the Vatican played. Now they have gotten further than ever in their efforts to holding the Holy See accountable in a U.S. courtroom.

Two federal appeals courts in recent months have allowed sexual abuse lawsuits against the Vatican to proceed in Oregon and Kentucky. Vatican attorneys have asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal of the Oregon case. Attorneys for both sides in the Oregon proceeding were in Washington two weeks ago making their arguments before a roomful of U.S. government officials, who could wind up weighing in if the Vatican -- considered a foreign country with immunity to lawsuits -- is found a liable party in an American case.

If the Supreme Court declines to take up the case this summer and lets the federal appeals ruling stand, attorneys could begin subpoenaing decades of documents and calling Vatican officials under oath.

Correspondence between the Vatican and U.S. clergy has always been subject to subpoena if the documents are located in the United States, attorneys say.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:46 AM

What will the good men of the church do now?

UNITED STATES
Belleville News-Democrat

By MARY SANCHEZ - McClatchy Newspapers

Once upon a time, my hair would be pulled taut each morning into pigtails, I'd don my plaid pleated skirt, and happily trot off to my parochial school, where dedicated nuns impressed upon me and my peers the basics of right and wrong.

Things were simple in my world of Catholicism. Mind your mother. Don't fight with your brothers. Say your prayers. And if you do find yourself in error, fess up quickly. Correct the situation. This was the path God wanted of his children.

Years later, this ex-Catholic school pupil is having a hard time reconciling these basic moral teachings with the behavior of a lot of high prelates of the church, including the pope himself.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:43 AM

Drane: Catholic Church reaches crisis point

UNITED STATES
GoErie

By JAMES F. DRANE
Contributing writerScandals have an amazing durability. They never seem to go away. They affect ever larger groups of people.

The latest news about the priest pedophile scandal is an effort to link Pope Benedict to immoral priest behavior. Vatican officials have responded forcefully to protect the Pope against what they describe as an unfair campaign to smear him.

According to his critics, while Benedict was archbishop of Munich, a pedophile priest was permitted to practice rather than being suspended and reported to civil authorities. After being sent for therapy, the priest was returned to pastoral work. When the accusations were made against the pope, the priest was still doing parish work in Bavaria.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Pope Benedict deserves more for his apology

CANADA
London Free Press

By RORY LEISHMAN, Special to QMI Agency

While Pope Benedict XVI is not without fault in his dealings with the sex-abuse crisis afflicting the worldwide Catholic Church, his shrillest critics in the media are not offering any legitimate criticism or constructive advice. Instead, they are exploiting the occasion to serve up the vilest anti-Catholic prejudice and abuse.

Benedict deserves much better. In a pastoral letter read out in every Catholic church in Ireland on Sunday, he made an unqualified apology to the hundreds of victims of child-abuse by members of the Catholic Church in Ireland. "It is understandable that you find it hard to forgive or be reconciled with the Church," he said. "In her name, I openly express the shame and remorse that we all feel."

George Weigel, author of Witness to Hope, much the best biography of Pope John Paul 11, has welcomed this statement. In an article entitled The End of Euphemism: Benedict XVI and the corruptions of Catholic Ireland published in National Review Online, Weigel observed: "The letter breaks ground for the Vatican by acknowledging, with admirable candour, that parents and entire families have suffered grievously because of the abuse of their loved ones, and that these families trust has been betrayed and your dignity has been violated."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:35 AM

Pittsburgh Diocese Taking Proactive Approach As Catholic Scandal Grows

PITTSBURGH (PA)
WTAE

[with video]

PITTSBURGH --
As a swirling global sex abuse scandal inches closer to Pope Benedict XVI, the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh said it's already taken proactive steps to prevent any further problems.

"The problem with abuse, sexual abuse with minors is a national problem. It's a national epidemic," said Ronald Regan, of the Pittsburgh diocese.

Archbishop Donald Wuerl initiated a zero-tolerance policy while serving as bishop in Pittsburgh in the 1990s that called for the immediate removal of any priest caught in allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:30 AM

Commentary on March 26 News

LifeSite

Pope Benedict is under sustained assault by the enemies of the moral principles of the Catholic Church. Yes, many bishops have been severely negligent about past sexual abuse incidents and need to be held personally accountable. Nothing wrong with that public campaign. However, the Holy Father is not one of those.

It cannot be a coincidence that this is occurring so soon after the health care battle when the Catholic Church stood against the Democrat anti-life factions and Catholic Church dissidents who are becoming very emboldened in their opposition to the authority of the Pope and those bishops in union with him.

They are enraged over the Church's unwillingness to bend on life and homosexuality and enraged over the new, more faithful translation of the liturgy, the Pope's welcoming into the Church of traditional and morally conservative Anglicans, his encouragement of the more traditional liturgies, the intensified questioning of the Catholicity of Catholic universities and his increasingly strong actions against dissent and moral corruption among the clergy and religious nuns and brothers. They fear that all their gains from the fraudulent "Spirit of Vatican II" revolution within the Church may be lost.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:28 AM

Bankruptcy judge blasts attorneys for Del. diocese

WILMINGTON (DE)
The Capital

By RANDALL CHASE, Associated Press Writer
Published 03/27/10
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) — An irate Delaware judge on Friday blasted attorneys in the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington's bankruptcy for agreeing to a mediation process involving the diocese and alleged victims of priest sex abuse behind his back.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Christopher Sontchi ordered a telephone status conference with attorneys Friday afternoon after reading in a local newspaper that lawyers for the diocese and its unsecured creditors committee had agreed that a Philadelphia mediator would oversee talks aimed at resolving claims by alleged abuse victims.

"You may not remember me, but I am the judge in the case," Sontchi icily told lawyers representing the diocese and the alleged abuse victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:24 AM

Old wounds resurface with each new priest scandal

WISCONSIN
Duluth News Tribune

By: Jana Hollingsworth, Duluth News Tribune

Every time a new Catholic Church scandal surfaces in the media, Duluthian Verne Wagner is brought back to his own horrible experience.

Wagner, an altar boy at St. Rose Parish in Proctor in the 1960s, was sexually abused by a priest beginning when he was 11 and continuing for a year. Although he sued the Catholic Diocese of Duluth in the 1990s and settled, the pain from that time remains.

“There’s so much anger that goes with this, so much negative energy,” he said. “There’s a public shame. But part of getting rid of that is to stand up and take your power back.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:18 AM

Step down, Benedict XVI

CANADA
The McGill Daily

By Riva Gold

The 1917 Code of Canon Law guarantees him the security of his office regardless of health, psychological state, or performance record. No one can impeach him or call for his resignation. Oh, and he has sovereign immunity – under canon law, he’s immune from prosecution for any crime. Talk about job security. So while firing him is next to impossible, Pope Benedict XVI should consider stepping down from the papacy if the post is to retain any legitimacy.

To be sure, I do appreciate the Pope’s revival of the red cappello romano, a highly fashionable outdoor hat with a wide brim. This hat has been neglected by unfashionable popes since the early ’60s. But there are also many things I find distasteful about Pope Benedict’s policies. His refusal to overturn the Vatican’s prohibition on condoms to combat the spread of HIV strikes me as grossly negligent. His motu proprio Summorum Pontificum allows the use of a prayer that asks God to “take the veil from [Jewish people’s] hearts” so they will convert to Catholicism, which creeps me out just a little bit.

But while his hard-line conservative and theological positions on divorce, Jewish people, homosexuality, and abortion don’t resonate with a lot of liberal sensibilities, this is hardly unique to Pope Benedict. It would be nonsensical to ask a leader to resign for simply carrying on the policies of his predecessors. Rather, it is Pope Benedict’s direct and increasingly public involvement in a series of church-wide sexual abuse scandals that demand his resignation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:15 AM

Sadness but little shock over latest church allegations

SANTA ROSA (CA)
The Press Democrat

By GUY KOVNER
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Retired Judge John Gallagher of Santa Rosa is among the Catholics wondering if the head of their church, Pope Benedict XVI, is guilty of covering up the crimes of child-abusing priests.

“I don’t know,” Gallagher said. “It wouldn’t surprise me if he is.”

The pontiff, who previously served as archbishop in Munich and as enforcer of church doctrine in Rome, is “part of the old church,” Gallagher said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:12 AM

Trial set for retired priest accused of child sex abuse

MARYLAND
News-Post

By Kate Leckie
News-Post Staff

A Sept. 28 trial date has been set for a retired priest removed from his position in the Catholic Church after allegations of child sexual abuse in the mid-1970s surfaced.

During a pretrial conference Friday in Frederick County Circuit Court, Thomas Roy Bevan, 73, of Cascade, waived his right to a trial within 180 days of being charged.

On Jan. 22, a Frederick County grand jury indicted Bevan on two counts of child abuse by a custodian.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:07 AM

Ratzinger unaware of transfer: Church

GERMANY
National Post (Canada)

Christopher Lawton, Reuters
Published: Saturday, March 27, 2010

Pope Benedict's former archdiocese of Munich insisted yesterday he had no knowledge of a 1980 decision to reassign a priest undergoing therapy there for suspected pedophilia to a post with access to children.

Archdiocesan spokesman Bernhard Kellner dismissed as speculation a New York Times article, which suggests the fact then-cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was copied on a memo of the transfer meant he was informed of what went on.

"We stand by our account that Cardinal Ratzinger didn't know about this decision," he said. "I cannot confirm he knew about this, and we don't have any evidence to that effect."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:04 AM

Pope Benedict at crossroads

CANADA
National Post

Charles Lewis, National Post Published: Saturday, March 27, 2010

The Roman Catholic Church has been defending its handling of the pedophile priests in its midst for several decades -- but at least up until a few months ago the murky waters of this scandal were at a safe distance from its popes.

Now with unproven media allegations that then-cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope who was head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, failed to remove clerics in both Germany and Wisconsin who were known as dangerous to children, the Vatican is facing a new level of crisis management.

Marco Politi, a veteran Vatican journalist, told The New York Times that Pope Benedict is now at a crossroads. "What's extraordinary is that the scandal has reached the heart of the centre of the Church. Up to now it was far way -- in the States, in Canada, in Brazil, in Australia. Then it came to Europe, to Ireland.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:01 AM

A pope with a problem

UNITED STATES
Los Angeles Times

By Tim Rutten

March 27, 2010

This has been a tough Lent for the Roman Catholic Church. Its seemingly endless sexual abuse scandal finally has seeped into the papal apartments, and the Vatican's response to this week's revelations suggests that far too little has been learned from this squalid affair.

Until now, Pope Benedict XVI had seemed to be taking a far more forthright approach to the problem than his predecessor, John Paul II, most recently in a blistering "pastoral letter" to the entire Irish church.

This week, however, the New York Times published a pair of stories suggesting that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger -- the future Pope Benedict -- participated in precisely the sort of secrecy and administrative negligence that has been at the root of this scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:58 AM

Local Catholics outraged by recurrent pedophile priest scandals

CALIFORNIA
Sacramento Bee

By Jennifer Garza
jgarza@sacbee.com
Published: Saturday, Mar. 27, 2010

New allegations about old molestation cases in the Catholic Church – and reports that top Vatican officials were more interested in protecting the church than abused children – have worried and enraged local parishioners who now watch church leaders again defend themselves.

Catholics from throughout the Sacramento diocese said Friday that the continuing sex scandal and reports that Vatican officials ignored repeated warnings about a Wisconsin priest who may have molested 200 deaf boys have shaken their confidence in church leadership.

"I am absolutely outraged," said Rita Mize, vice president of the Sacramento-area Call to Action, a group of Catholics that describes itself as working for equality and justice in the church. "The church has not taken responsibility for this. They really don't get it."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:56 AM

Papacy under fire

UNITED STATES
The Courier-Journal

The scandal of sexual abuse of children by Roman Catholic priests, which led to the dismissal of 700 priests in the United States alone in a single three-year period, now threatens to engulf the papacy.

If that assessment sounds extreme, consider the Nixon-era echoes in a National Catholic Reporter editorial about Pope Benedict XVI: “The focus now is on Benedict. What did he know? When did he know it? How did he act once he knew?”

At the moment, neither Catholics nor the larger public know the answers to those questions. What is clear is that for 33 years — as archbishop of Munich, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and, since 2005, as pope — Benedict has been in a position to be involved in the handling of sex abuse by the clergy. The record is deeply troubling.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

Mistakes were made. Boys were abused

CANADA
National Post

Robert Fulford, National Post
Published: Saturday, March 27, 2010

In his recent letter to Irish Catholics, Pope Benedict XVI remarked that one cause of the sexual-abuse scandal was a fear of scandal itself. "A misplaced concern for the reputation of the Church" apparently caused bishops to hide the monstrous crimes of priests and leave them unpunished.

That was last weekend. On Thursday, The New York Times reported that court papers filed in a suit against the diocese of Milwaukee indicate that the Pope himself committed precisely that error. In 1996, as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, heading the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, he declined to challenge a priest who had molested perhaps 200 deaf boys in his care. The priest died in 1998 without official stain on his record. He was buried in his priestly vestments--a scandal in itself.

In writing to Ireland, the Pope expressed a generalized "shame and remorse that we all feel" in response to sexual crimes against children. He said nothing about his connection to the Milwaukee case or a German case that has thrown another shadow across his record.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:50 AM

The Church's challenge

CANADA
Ottawa Citizen

If Catholicism is under threat, as some Church officials fear, it is not just the result of secularism, consumerism and a hostile media. The Church itself has behaved in such a way as to erode faith and breed cynicism.

The institution of the Roman Catholic Church -- centred in the Vatican -- is not the same thing as the Catholic religion. There are one billion Catholics in the world, and membership in the church is steadily climbing, particularly in Asia and Africa. It is a glorious and important religious tradition, filled with ceremony, mysticism and a legacy of good works.

But many committed Catholics are despondent over the Church's inadequate response to the historic sexual abuse of children by priests, a response that has not only left perpetrators unpunished but has resulted in the victimization of children who could, and should, have been protected.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:47 AM

Deaf men confront Italian church

ITALY
Philadelphia Inquirer

By Nicole Winfield
Associated Press

ROME - Three deaf men who say they were repeatedly sodomized and abused by priests as children confronted the church diocese yesterday about why it had not punished their abusers, saying they wanted justice.

The three men, first interviewed last year by the Associated Press, appeared on a prime-time talk show on Italy's state-run RAI television, squaring off with the spokesman of the Verona Diocese amid a global sex-abuse scandal that has inched closer to Pope Benedict XVI.

The former students have not gone to the police because the 10-year statute of limitations expired. They have asked the priests in question to waive the statute of limitations so a case can be opened.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 AM

Editorial: The scandal continues

UNITED STATES
Philadelphia Inquirer

The leaders of the Roman Catholic Church still do not seem to get it.

Despite a long and ugly list of sexual-abuse scandals that have cast the church in a harsh light, top officials continue to defend their actions to protect scores of pedophile priests. Two recent cases have made international news because they have raised questions about the role of Pope Benedict XVI.

One case involves a priest in Wisconsin accused of molesting more than 200 deaf boys in confessionals, dormitories, closets, and on field trips.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:42 AM

Don't blame pope, Vatican says

VATICAN CITY
Boston Globe

By Rachel Donadio
New York Times / March 27, 2010

ROME — The Vatican yesterday reaffirmed its position that the future Pope Benedict XVI “had no knowledge’’ of a decision to allow a known pedophile priest to resume pastoral duties when the pope was archbishop in Munich in 1980.

In a statement, the Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said that an article that appeared in The New York Times yesterday, which said that the future pope had been sent a memorandum relating to the reassignment of the priest, “contained no new information.’’ The Vatican rejected as “speculation’’ any version of events other than the one it originally put forward to explain what it called the pope’s “nonresponsibility’’ in the matter.

The Archdiocese of Munich and Freising has said that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, had approved a decision to transfer the troubled priest, the Rev. Peter Hullermann, into his diocese for therapy to overcome pedophilia. But the diocese said that Ratzinger’s deputy at the time, the Rev. Gerhard Gruber, took full responsibility for the decision to reassign the priest to pastoral duties a few days after his therapy began.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:39 AM

Church's defensive posture misses point

UNITED STATES
The Day

In defending the church's handling of former child sexual abuse scandals, the Vatican once again appears to be putting protection of the church's image above concern for victims.

The growing scandal in Europe has raised questions about how Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger - now Pope Benedict XVI - handled a sex abuse case in his own Munich diocese in 1980 and oversaw such cases when he was the Vatican's chief doctrinal official from 1982 until his election as pope in 2005.

Most recently, The New York Times reported that Cardinal Ratzinger received a memo in 1980 alerting him that a pedophile priest was being assigned to a new parish in Munich just days after the priest's therapy for pedophilia began. The priest later molested more boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:34 AM

European bishops see no coverup by Vatican

EUROPE
Toronto Star

Reuters News Agency
PARIS–Catholic churches in Europe rallied behind Pope Benedict Friday, rejecting claims that he covered up child sex abuse by priests.

France's bishops conference, Archbishop Vincent Nichols of London and the Munich archdiocese Benedict once led all rejected new allegations in the media.

But the National Catholic Reporter in the United States called on Benedict in an editorial Friday to answer questions about his role "in the mismanagement" of sex abuse cases, dating back to his tenure in the 1980s as archbishop of Munich and while head of the Vatican's doctrinal and disciplinary office.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:31 AM

Even Dan Brown wouldn't invent this papal conspiracy

VATICAN CITY
Guardian

Marina Hyde The Guardian, Saturday 27 March 2010

At last, one of Pope Benedict's closest aides uses the word "conspiracy" in relation to the systematic global cover-up of child abuse by paedophile Catholic priests. Unfortunately, Cardinal José Saraiva Martins believes the conspiracy is against the Catholic church, which is its victim.

"We should not be too scandalised if some bishops knew about it but kept it secret," he this week told reporters of the sexual abuse, on the same day the Vatican newspaper opted to blame the media for "ignoring the facts". "This is what happens in every family, you don't wash your dirty laundry in public." Though Saraiva Martins declined to spell out who was behind the conspiracy, he informed his listeners darkly: "There is a well-organised plan, with a clear aim."

For those who imagined church-related conspiracies as involving psychotic albino monks, easily decipherable holy grail puzzles, and some guff about the sacred feminine, this all comes as something of a shock. I suppose a cryptex that falls open if you align the letters N, O, N, C and E may yet surface, and x-ray analysis might discover the words "perhaps he could teach at a girls' school next time?" concealed in the rural backdrop of the Mona Lisa.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:29 AM

Will the Pope Resign? It Wouldn't Be Easy, And May Not Be Possible

UNITED STATES
Politics Daily

Continuing revelations about cases of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy are raising more questions about what Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, did -- or did not do -- about them, both as Archbishop of Munich (1977-1982) and for nearly 24 years as the Vatican's chief guardian of doctrine.

That has left many wondering if this is the Catholic Church's version of Watergate -- and if it could end the same way. (Richard Nixon, raised a Quaker, once mused that he'd have made a good pope, and as things worked out for him, you could understand that wish.) As things stand now, and under almost any imaginable scenario, Benedict is not about to resign. Some say he can't.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:26 AM

Wisconsin Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy accused of molesting boys at St. John's School for the Deaf just outside Milwaukee

ST. FRANCIS (WI)
Post-Crescent

By Dinesh Ramde and Gretchen Ehlke • Associated Press writers • March 27, 2010

ST. FRANCIS — Arthur Budzinski says the first time the priest molested him, he was 12 years old, alone and away from home at a school for the deaf.

He says he asked the Rev. Lawrence Murphy to hear his confession, and instead the priest took him into a closet under the stairs and sexually assaulted him.

Budzinski, now 61, was one of about 200 deaf boys at the St. John's School for the Deaf just outside Milwaukee who say they were molested by the priest decades ago in a case now creating a scandal for the Vatican and threatening to ensnare Pope Benedict XVI.
Some of the allegations became public years ago. But they got renewed attention this week after documents obtained by The New York Times showed that Murphy was spared a defrocking in the mid-1990s because he was protected by the Vatican office led by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now the pope.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:23 AM

Storm over paedophile priest now threatens Italy

EUROPE
The Times of Malta

Paedophile priest scandals sweeping the Catholic Church around Europe have encouraged more and more victims to speak out, fuelling a storm that now threatens to break over Italy.

"Victims' groups will grow exponentially in the next few weeks," predicted Italian anti-paedophilia activist Roberto Mirabile.

Fresh Catholic Church investigations in the northern cities of Bolzano and Verona could expose new cases of predatory clergy in Italy, which counts more than 50,000 priests, the highest concentration in the world.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:20 AM

Priest describes abusing boys: ‘I went too far’

GERMANY
NBC New York

A German priest accused of sexually abusing teenage boys has said the church should have had supervisors in homes.

The priest, writing in The Times of London, said the allegations against him were made four weeks ago and he was forced to leave his church. He is now living in a monastery and said he did not "dare show my face."

He wrote that he had gone "too far" while looking after about 30 boys, aged 13 to 16, during the early to mid-1980s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:10 AM

March 26, 2010

Pope should do more to end shielding of abusive priests

Boston Globe

March 27, 2010

THE BUCK stops with Pope Benedict XVI. He should stop apologizing and start confronting the root issue behind the latest revelations about clergy sexual abuse in the Roman Catholic Church: the Vatican’s complicity in protecting pedophile priests and their enablers from criminal prosecution.

For Benedict, that means tearing down a wall of secrecy that he helped construct and ending the church’s history of providing sanctuary to predator priests and the higher-ups who shielded them.

The pope’s involvement is personal. In 2001, he was in charge of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, which decides whether accused priests should be defrocked. In that capacity, then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger sent a letter instructing bishops to refer allegations of certain offenses by the clergy, including sexual conduct with minors, to the congregation. While the Vatican maintains that Ratzinger did not discourage cooperation with government authorities, the letter has been interpreted as telling bishops to keep accusations secret.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:05 PM

Bishop Hegarty fails to give answers as Catholic Church faces ‘tsunami’

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Saturday, 27 March 2010

A prominent former Catholic priest has urged the church in Derry to take “radical action” to restore public faith following revelations that a priest in the diocese paid £12,000 in a secret deal with a victim of abuse.

Denis Bradley has also said that the current “tsunami” facing the church has caught up with Bishop of Derry Dr Seamus Hegarty, who knew about the out-of-court settlement.

Mr Bradley said he was “sickened” when he learnt of the allegations against Fr John McCullagh.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:01 PM

Legionaries of Christ bishops ask forgiveness for founder's behaviour

ROME
The Irish Times

PADDY AGNEW

DOUBLE LIFE: ANOTHER TIDAL wave in the ongoing tsunami of clerical sex abuse allegations sweeping over the Catholic Church hit the Holy See yesterday when top officials of the Legionaries of Christ order asked forgiveness for the behaviour of their founder, the late Fr Marcial Maciel Degollado.

Expressing their “consternation”, Legionary bishops confirmed that allegations against Fr Maciel, claiming that he had led a sexually dissolute life, had been substantiated. For some years, media reports have suggested that Fr Maciel, rather than being the founder of an ultra-orthodox, ascetical, devout and vibrant religious congregation, had in fact lived a second life which involved a whole series of sexual affairs with men, women and boys in many different parts of the world.

In May 2006, after investigating allegations that Fr Maciel had sexually abused young seminarians, Pope Benedict ordered him to stop practising his ministry and sentenced him to a “retired life of prayer and penitence”. Two years later, he ordered an Apostolic visitation to the Legionaries following Fr Maciel’s death in January 2008.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:58 PM

Bishop of Galway downgrades 'service of reparation' to parish event

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY Religious Affairs Correspondent

PRAYER SERVICE: THE “SERVICE of reparation” scheduled to take place in Galway Cathedral at 3pm tomorrow has been downgraded from a diocesan to parish event by Bishop of Galway Martin Drennan.

In a letter to priests of the diocese on March 9th, he said each parish was invited to send representatives to the service which would take the form of “readings, prayers of intercession and hymns”.

He continued: “We’ll be asking God’s forgiveness for crimes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse that have brought shame on all of us. In our prayer we’ll remember all who are survivors of abuse, all in need of healing, in need of the peace that only God can give.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:56 PM

Prelate honoured with civic reception

IRELAND
The Irish Times

GORDON DEEGAN

BISHOP WILLIE WALSH: THE POSITION of Irish bishops is now hazardous for sad reasons and at risk from possibly some mistake made 20 to 50 years ago, Bishop Willie Walsh said yesterday.

Bishop Walsh was speaking to an audience at a civic reception held in his honour in Ennis to mark his 16 years as Bishop of Killaloe. In January, the bishop formally handed in his resignation letter to Pope Benedict on turning 75 and the process to choose his successor is continuing with the diocese’s 100 priests recently voting on who should succeed him.

At the reception, where he received a standing ovation, Bishop Walsh said for all of Irish bishops, “it is a very difficult time, and all of us are at risk from possibly some mistake made anything from 20 to 50 years ago”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:53 PM

'New York Times' report dismissed as 'speculation'

The Irish Times

DEREK SCALLY in Berlin and PATSY MCGARRY

ARCHBISHOPï'S ROLE: THE CATHOLIC diocese of Munich has dismissed as “pure speculation” a New York Times report yesterday that Pope Benedict, as Archbishop Ratzinger of Munich in 1980, was aware that a convicted paedophile priest had been returned to pastoral work in his diocese.

The newspaper reported that documents relating to Fr Peter Hullermann’s arrival in Munich for therapy were copied to Archbishop Ratzinger. The priest’s transfer took place after discussion with Essen diocese, where he had been accused of molesting boys and was removed from work.

The New York Times quoted yesterday from a letter sent by Essen to Munich in early January 1980 and extracts of minutes from a meeting of the Munich diocesan council two weeks later, chaired by Archbishop Ratzinger, which approved the transfer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 PM

Cardinal wants 'just resolution' to abuse lawsuit

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY and CHARLIE TAYLOR

CARDINAL SEÁN Brady has said he wants a “just resolution” to a legal case involving an alleged victim of paedophile priest Fr Brendan Smyth.

- In a statement yesterday afternoon he said he had asked his legal representatives to engage with the complainant’s legal team “with a view to progressing the case” and that, as court proceedings were ongoing, it was not appropriate for him to comment further.

The complainant referred to is suing Cardinal Brady as Archbishop of Armagh and as the Catholic Church representative in Ireland, in a High Court legal action which began in 1997. The man claims he was sexually assaulted on a number of occasions by Smyth in Dundalk in the early 1970s, as well as in Dublin and on a trip to Cork.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:44 PM

Vatican daily newspaper mounts vigorous defence of pope

VATICAN CITY
The Irish Times

PADDY AGNEW

MEDIA: THE VATICAN daily, L’Osservatore Romano , yesterday issued a vigorous defence of Pope Benedict XVI, arguing that he is the victim of an anti-clerical, anti-Catholic media lobby.

Responding to reports in the New York Times of the alleged mishandling in 1996 of US paedophile priest Larry C. Murphy by the then Cardinal Ratzinger, at the time Prefect For the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, L’Osservatore comments: “The prevalent media tendency is to ignore the facts and to twist the interpretation of what happened in order to present an image of the Catholic Church in which it seems to be almost the only organisation responsible for sex abuse crimes, an image which simply does not correspond with reality. But this is an image which serves well in the all too evident and ignoble attempt to, at all costs, besmirch the figure of Benedict and his closest collaborators.”

In its editorial, the paper argues that “transparency, severity and a firm line” with a view to throwing light on clerical sex abuse has always been the criteria indicated by Benedict to the entire church, adding: “Clearly, this modus operandi – which is entirely coherent with his own record and with his more than 20-year long period as Prefect of the Congregation For the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) – frightens those who do not want the truth to emerge but would rather prefer to manipulate, with no basis in facts, horrible and painful episodes that go back many years. The most recent example of this comes from an article in today’s New York Times . . . . about the serious case involving priest Lawrence C. Murphy”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 PM

Rome puts pressure on Catholic leader to quit

IRELAND
The Times (United Kingdom)

Ruth Gledhill and Jill Sherman

The head of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland will be pressed to quit if he refuses to resign over the growing child abuse scandal, The Times has learnt.

Nothing less than Cardinal Sean Brady’s resignation will diminish fury at the highest levels in Rome over his role in paedophile priest cover-ups.

The Northern Ireland Assembly prepared last night to order an official investigation into child abuse in the Province after details emerged of more attacks on children by members of the clergy.

Dr Brady is spending the days before Easter considering his position as Archbishop of Armagh. Although there is no canonical procedure to remove him, if he refuses to go voluntarily pressure from the Holy See will make his departure inevitable. “Ireland needs a fresh start,” a source in Rome said. “By clinging on, he is putting his own interests before the Church’s.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:11 PM

The Catholic Church's Waterloo: Why The Pope Should Step Down

The Huffington Post

Keli Goff

It's a sad state of affairs when new allegations of Catholic priests accused of sexual abuse are greeted with the same measure of surprise as another Tiger Woods porn star: none at all.

At this point the story has to take a particularly egregious and shocking turn to warrant front-page news coverage. This week it did. The Vatican -- not a local parish, or a local papal leader, but the Vatican itself -- stands accused of halting an investigation into a Wisconsin priest believed to have molested 200 deaf boys over a 20-year period. (Yes, you read that correctly.)

As reported by the Associated Press, the case bears disturbing similarities to a case in Italy in which a group of priests is also accused of preying on a group of deaf children, and on that matter the Vatican is also accused of dragging its feet. But even more shocking, the New York Times reports that during his tenure as Cardinal, Pope Benedict was cc'd on a 1980 memo that notified him and others of the return of a known pedophile to a parish. The priest was eventually convicted of molesting boys there. But I'm sure that came as no surprise to the people who helped put him there, which, no matter how you dress it up, includes the current Pope. And that's what makes these stories a turning point.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:40 PM

The Pope & the New York Times

UNITED STATES
National Review

[Kathryn Jean Lopez]

Yes, I've been reading the New York Times the last two days, and it strikes me that the biggest scandal here is not the hot story the media wants to run with — that then Cardinal Ratzinger was involved — but that after these horrendous crimes were committed, it took three decades for something to be done about it and four decades before Rome heard about it. This priest probably should have been laicized — in the 1950s.

This case was clearly mishandled, but all blame does not lead to Rome. The fact that the Milwaukee archdiocese has a mess of a history (including Archbishop Rembert Weakland stepping down in scandal) is not breaking news so much as a shameful reality.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:37 PM

Bankruptcy Judge Blasts Attorneys For Del. Diocese

WILMINGTON (DE)
WJZ

RANDALL CHASE, Associated Press Writer
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) ― An irate Delaware judge on Friday blasted attorneys in the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington's bankruptcy for agreeing to a mediation process involving the diocese and alleged victims of priest sex abuse behind his back.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Christopher Sontchi ordered a telephone status conference with attorneys Friday afternoon after reading in a local newspaper that lawyers for the diocese and its unsecured creditors committee had agreed that a Philadelphia mediator would oversee talks aimed at resolving claims by alleged abuse victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:34 PM

Italian police anticipate Vatican unrest

ROME
GlobalPost

By Alessandro Speciale — Special to GlobalPost
Published: March 26, 2010 16:57 ET

ROME, Italy — As Catholics around the world prepare to celebrate Palm Sunday, a drumbeat of scandal in the church seems incessant and increasingly focused on the pope himself.

Consider that just this week Pope Benedict XVI issued an unprecedented apology to Irish Catholics for the church's handling of past allegations of sexual abuse; The New York Times carried a front-page story that the pope, when he served as cardinal, allowed a priest who had molested 200 deaf children to be reassigned to another post with more access to children; and the very powerful congregation of pontifical right known as the Legion of Christ essentially disowned its founder in the wake of yet another sexual abuse scandal.

While a growing number of Catholics demand that the pope accept responsibility for abuse cases unfolding from Germany to the United States, the Vatican launched a public relations campaign to blame the media for smearing the pope.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:32 PM

Catholic Sexual Abuse Scandals

UNITED STATES
Religion and Ethics Newsweekly

BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: New evidence came to light this week that raises questions about Pope Benedict XVI’s response to the abuse scandal. Documents surfaced that suggest the Benedict, before he became pope, may have been involved in protecting abusive priests. Meanwhile, Benedict issued a letter of apology to Irish Catholics that was read at Sunday Masses. He also accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop. But many lay people criticized the Pope for not taking stronger actions.

Joining us is Father Tom Reese, Senior Fellow at the Woodstock Theological Center at Georgetown University. Father Reese, welcome.

FATHER THOMAS REESE, SJ: Thank you.

ABERNETHY: The allegations just keep coming about sex abuse by some priests, about cover-ups by some bishops—in the US, now in Europe, all over Europe, reaching into the Vatican, maybe, too. You’ve served the church all your life. How do you react to all that?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:29 PM

Wisconsin Law Revisited Amid Catholic Church's Latest Troubles

WISCONSIN
WBAY

By Matt Smith

Pope Benedict is under fire again for what he did or did not know about another priest accused of molesting several boys.

Internal correspondence released Thursday shows before he became pope, then-Cardinal Ratzinger refused to punish Father Lawrence Murphy, a Milwaukee priest who was accused of molesting 200 students at a school for the deaf.

Now the New York Times reports Father Peter Hullerman of Germany was allowed to return to active ministry as he began therapy after molesting three boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:25 PM

Impact Of Milwaukee-Based Catholic Scandal Felt Globally

UNITED STATES
NPR

[with audio]

March 26, 2010 A decades-old sex abuse scandal at the St. John’s School for the Deaf outside Milwaukee, where 200 boys say they were molested is creating a scandal for the Vatican and threatening to ensnare Pope Benedict XVI. Guest host Allison Keyes speaks about the fallout with Michael Sean Winters of America, the national Catholic weekly, and Hjamil Martínez-Vázquez, assistant professor of Religion at Texas Christian University.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:19 PM

Profile: The Vatican's watchdog

VATICAN CITY
BBC News

By Patrick Jackson
BBC News

As the Vatican watchdog responsible for tackling sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clerics, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) faces serious questions about its work, particularly during the years when it was headed by the current Pope.

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, as he was known before being elected Pope Benedict XVI, came to the office in 1981 and led it for nearly a quarter of a century.

Just weeks before his elevation to the papacy in 2005, he wrote of his outrage at corrupt clerics who had soiled the "garments and face" of the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:17 PM

The Catholic Church: A Crisis Of Trust

The Huffington Post

Vinnie Rotondaro

The Catholic Church is collapsing into a state of moral bankruptcy.

In America, the Church has been the leading advocate for universal health care and other social justice issues for generations. But Church leaders put that history aside in the weeks leading up to the House vote on health care reform, on the specious grounds that maybe, just maybe, federal funds might be used for abortions per the health care bill.

Meanwhile, new revelations in the sexual abuse scandal have reached the Pope himself. This Thursday the New York Times reported on the case of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, a Wisconsin priest who molested nearly 200 deaf boys between 1950 to 1974. The future Pope may have turned a blind eye to multiple warnings about the abusing priest. On Friday the Times reported that Ratzinger was cc'd on a memo concerning the relocation of Rev. Peter Hullermann, the offending German priest whose outing kicked off the latest rounds in the sexual abuse scandal. Somebody, if not the Pope, should have blown the whistle.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:14 PM

Church, deaf students square off on Italian TV

ROME
Mercury News (United States)

By NICOLE WINFIELD Associated Press Writer

ROME—Three deaf men who say they were repeatedly sodomized and abused by priests as children confronted the church diocese Friday about why it hadn't punished their abusers, saying they want justice.

The three men, first interviewed last year by The Associated Press, appeared on a prime-time talk show on Italy's state-run RAI television, squaring off with the spokesman of the Verona diocese amid a swirling global sex abuse scandal that has inched closer to Pope Benedict XVI.

The former students haven't gone to the police because the 10-year statute of limitations expired. They have asked the priests in question to waive the statute of limitations so a case can be opened, but to date none of them have.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:10 PM

Vatican dismisses fresh New York Times allegation

VATICAN CITY
Sydney Morning Herald

The Vatican fought on Friday to limit the damage from a report alleging Pope Benedict XVI failed to bar the transfer of a known paedophile priest.

The fresh allegation added fuel to the fire after child abuse scandals sweeping Catholic churches around the world have encouraged more and more victims to speak out.

The New York Times reported on Friday that Pope Benedict failed to act in 1980 to stop Reverend Peter Hullerman, accused of sexually abusing children, from taking up new duties in a different parish in Germany.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:07 PM

Clergy abuse threatens to tarnish pope's legacy

VATICAN CITY
The Associated Press

By VICTOR L. SIMPSON (AP)

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican is facing one of its gravest crises of modern times as sex abuse scandals move ever closer to Pope Benedict XVI — threatening not only his own legacy but also that of his revered predecessor.

Benedict took a much harder stance on sex abuse than John Paul II when he assumed the papacy five years ago, disciplining a senior cleric championed by the Polish pontiff and defrocking others under a new policy of zero tolerance.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:04 PM

Police Chief again calls for policy change within La Crosse Diocese

WISCONSIN
WEAU

Eau Claire's Police Chief is once again urging the Diocese of La Crosse to change its policy regarding how child sexual abuse is reported, and a scandal that may involve the pope factors into the argument.

Several deaf men are now claiming a priest, who has since died, molested them decades ago. The church apparently received fair warning about it, but never took the priest to task. Now Chief Jerry Matysik says it's time for the La Crosse Diocese to learn from all that.

Victims say Reverend Lawrence Murphy molested 200 boys at Saint John's School for the Deaf near Milwaukee from 1950 until 1974. He died in 1998.

A letter from the Archbishop of Milwaukee to then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger warned of true scandal in the near future. Ratzinger is now Pope Benedict the 16th. According to documents obtained by NBC News, he never took Murphy to task for the alleged abuse. The Vatican later refused to hold a church trial against Murphy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:02 PM

Verona deaf school ex-pupils tell Italian TV of sex abuse by priests

ITALY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome

The sex abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Church came to the Pope’s doorstep last night as a group of victims appeared on Italian television to claim that two dozen priests had for decades abused children at a school for the deaf in Verona.

Three former pupils of the Antonio Provolo school who spoke on RAI, the state broadcaster, confirmed allegations made in a signed statement last year by 67 ex-students who described a regime of sexual abuse, paedophilia and corporal punishment from the 1950s to the 1980s. They said that 24 priests and lay brothers from the Company of Mary order were involved.

The three said that the priests had “fondled and masturbated” them as well as sodomising them in dormitories, bathrooms and the priests’ quarters.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:59 PM

Child Abuse and the Church

Newsweek

By Bishop Kieran Conry | Newsweek Web Exclusive
Mar 26, 2010

When I went to work for the Catholic Church's media office in London in 1993, the three most common news stories about the church had to do with contraception, celibacy, and condoms. When I left seven years later, the topic of contraception had been displaced by the issue of the abuse of children.

In the mid-'70s the church in Ireland had been rocked by the case of Father Brendan Smyth, and the case of Father Michael Hill in England came back spectacularly to haunt Bishop Cormac-Murphy O’Connor when he was made archbishop of Westminster (and cardinal) in 2000. Since then, the church has never been able to move far from the question of child sexual abuse, and recent developments in Ireland and continental Europe—especially Germany—have seen more damaging revelations.

How much damage has been done is difficult to measure. The reputation of the church in the eyes of the secular world has undoubtedly suffered, but the church has never been greatly concerned with "image" in and of itself. But as an organization fundamentally dedicated to encouraging new members, it can't entirely ignore the image question.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:56 PM

How Could It Happen? Tracing the Causes of Sexual Abuse by the Clergy

The Huffington Post

Rev. James Martin, S.J.

The terrible revelations of sexual abuse in Ireland and Germany have confirmed the reality that the abuse of children by clergy is not a phenomenon confined to the United States. Nor, as Kieran Conroy, the bishop of Arundel and Brighton in the U.K., stated recently, is the crisis a media creation. "It is real," he said. "It is a reality." Outrage among the Irish and German public is the predominant, natural and justified response. But buried beneath the shock and anger, especially for Catholics, however, is a searing question: How could this happen?

There is an important resource that may begin to answer this question: the detailed analysis of the roots of clerical abuse in this country, which was conducted by The National Review Board, the group of lay people who researched and reported to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in 2003. Some questioned the independence of the board, but I think that their situational analysis, carried out by committed and highly qualified lay Catholics, is accurate.

Looking at what the National Review Board viewed as the root causes of the crisis in this country may shed light on what happened in Ireland and Germany and elsewhere. On the whole, the board's analysis is about the most accurate and insightful that we have about the American situation. Of course, these are presented by the board as reasons, not excuses. There are no excuses for these crimes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:53 PM

Catholic Publications' Response to the Abuse Crisis

UNITED STATES
The Atlantic Wire

By Heather Horn on March 26, 2010

The New York Times' twin stories yesterday on papal involvement in abuse coverups in Wisconsin and Munich have marked a turning point in general opinion on the Catholic abuse crisis. But what about specifically Catholic opinion? Here, the Wire summarizes four American Catholic publications' opinion coverage of the abuse scandal throughout March. Some have been harsh on the Vatican from the very beginning, while others have been skeptical of anti-Catholic media spin. In general, however, it looks like writers for all four of the publications are getting increasingly critical of the Church as more abuse cases and coverup stories emerge.

•National Catholic Reporter: Time for a Full Account The independent publication has covered the abuse scandal extensively, beginning the month with some mostly opinion-less analysis on the subject from John Allen and Tom Roberts. Then on March 17 John Allen took a look at the pope's twin responses to priestly abuse, arguing that Benedict has been extremely strict with the abusers themselves but perhaps not as strict with those covering for abusers. A much harsher op-ed from David Clohessy, head of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, followed two days later.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:47 PM

Rücktritt des Papstes gefordert

AUSTRIA
Main Post

Österreichische Kirchenvolksbewegung geht weiter als die deutschen Reformkatholiken
Schwere Vorwürfe gegen Papst Benedikt XVI. hat die Kirchenvolksbewegung „Wir sind Kirche“ im Vorfeld ihrer Bundesversammlung in Würzburg erhoben. Ihr Sprecher Edgar Büttner aus dem Erzbistum München und Freising forderte mit Blick auf die zahlreichen Missbrauchsfälle, Papst Benedikt XVI. solle die Arbeit von Kardinal Joseph Ratzinger „kritisch anschauen“.

[summary]

Edgar Buettner, spokesman for We Are Church, has demanded a review of the numerous cases of abuse. He asked where there was a confession of guilt. Popes and bishops were responsible for years of repression of crime. Hans Peter Hurka, chairman of the Austrian reform movement, has called for resignation of the pope.

We Are Church set up an emergency telephone in 2002 and had heard from about 300 victims between then and early 2010. Another 90 victims have called since. Buettner criticized church leadership for not realizing extent of the abuse and for not taking it seriously.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:33 PM

Pope Benedict infallible? So the Vatican would like us to believe

UNITED KINGDOM
Guardian

John Cornwell
guardian.co.uk, Friday 26 March 2010

At my Catholic primary school, our RE teacher drummed into us the meaning of papal infallibility. "It does not mean," she used to say, "that the pope can predict the weather, tell a lie, or get his sums wrong." She was explaining that papal infallibility is restricted to doctrinal matters, and only in exceptional circumstances.

And yet, in the matter of the proliferating paedophile priest scandal, the Vatican gives the impression that no scintilla of responsibility, still less fallibility, in fact or in principle, could possibly attach to His Holiness. It is widely assumed even by seasoned Vatican commentators that the least discovery, or admission, of a cover-up could lead to his resignation. Popes, according to canon law, can indeed resign with a stroke of the papal pen, but it has only happened once, in 1296. But no foreseeable, proven accusation is likely to prompt Benedict's abdication.

The complex paper trails are measured now in many tens of thousands of cases spread over half a century and across five continents. It would be astonishing if there were not at least a handful of documents leading back to the powerful orthodoxy watchdog, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, as Benedict once was. From 1982 until 2005 he was responsible in large measure for the disciplining of the clergy. His failure to answer two letters in the late 1990s from Archbishop Rembert Weakland of Milwaukee relating to an abusive priest 20 years after his crimes appears substantive enough. But the Vatican has responded with impressive casuistry as to the facts, and vehement indignation as to the insinuations, and will continue to do so with this or any other allegation brought against Benedict.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:07 PM

Short SNAP statement re NY Times disclosure

UNITED STATES
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by David Clohessy 314 566 9790, SNAP executive director

"These records prove that the world's two top Catholic officials did nothing about a serial predator despite repeated pleas from three US bishops. The reason was because then-Cardinal Ratzinger and then-Cardinal Bertone were afraid of publicity. The year was 1998. The obvious result was that more kids were molested. The likely result was that more kids were molested. And now, the likely result will be that any papal words about getting tough with predators or being open about abuse will be meaningless, because church staff will see that the Pope himself, just a dozen years ago, opted for secrecy and inaction with an admitted predator."

Let's be clear about Ratzinger and Bertone: They did nothing. They didn't call police, warn citizens, contact parents, defrock the predator, or insist that Wisconsin bishops do anything other than keep quiet.

If they refuse to act against a pedophile who admits molesting 34 kids, imagine their indifference and inaction with pedophiles who admit nothing and molest fewer. If they rebuff three bishops, imagine how they respond to lay Catholics and victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:03 PM

Warned About Abuse, Vatican Failed to Defrock Priest; SNAP responds

UNITED STATES
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by Peter Isely of Milwaukee, Wisconsin - SNAP Midwest Director (in Rome today)

Newly-disclosed church records prove that the world’s two most powerful Catholic prelates refused to rein in a serial predator even though three US bishops begged them to act. Because these documents are relatively recent, the crimes so egregious, the victims so vulnerable and the Vatican inaction so clear, this disclosure is particularly damaging to Benedict and Bertone.

Benedict has told bishops to "recognize the extent and complexity of the (abuse) problem" and "admit grave errors of judgment were made and failures of leadership occurred." He’s said "All this has seriously undermined your credibility and effectiveness."

"It cannot be denied that some of you (bishops) and your predecessors failed, at times grievously, to apply the long-established norms of canon law to the crime of child abuse,” Benedict has written. “Serious mistakes were made in responding to allegations." He’s said that bishops should “remedy past mistakes” and “guarantee that they do not happen again.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:00 PM

Pope Was Told Pedophile Priest Would Get Transfer; Sex abuse victims respond

GERMANY
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by Peter Isely, Midwest Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (414-429-7259)

Like Bill Clinton’s claim that he smoked marijuana but didn’t inhale, the Vatican’s claim that the Pope knew about a German predator priest’s abuse but not his re-assignment is increasingly discredited.

Regarding convicted and controversial Munich predator priest Peter Hullerman, the New York Times reports today on its front page that “the future pope not only led a meeting approving the transfer of the (predator) priest, but was also kept informed about the priest’s reassignment,” which directly contradicts earlier claims that Ratzinger knew nothing of the priest’s later whereabouts.

The Pope allegedly wants greater transparency in the church on abuse. (He could, of course, mandate openness, instead of just talking about it.) Here’s the place to start: He should make himself, Fr. Peter Hullerman, Vicar General Gerhard Gruber, Fr. Friedrich Fahr, and others with knowledge of this reckless case available for interviews. He should voluntarily turn over all files relating to this situation. That would clear things up considerably.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:58 PM

Abuse victims call for universal norms to deal with clergy sex abuse

VATICAN CITY
The Catholic Review

By Carol Glatz
Catholic News Service

ROME – Four victims of clergy sex abuse came from the United States to Rome to call on the Vatican and Pope Benedict XVI to “break down the walls of secrecy” and to seek harsher, universal measures in dealing with clergy accused of the sexual abuse of minors.

Included in those rules, they said, should be that any priest or religious who has been found guilty of rape, molestation or abuse of children be removed immediately from the priesthood and that bishops in every country should cooperate with civil authorities and turn over all information they have concerning crimes by priests to police.

The Vatican needs to establish stricter measures that would be put into immediate effect for churches around the world so that “no parish, no community, no boarding school on this planet has to ever be concerned that the priest in their parish ... has raped or assaulted a child,” said Peter Isley of the Survivors’ Network of those Abused by Priests.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:55 PM

Vatican defends Pope: Victims' voices

BBC News

The Vatican has come under increased pressure in the face of charges that the Pope failed to act against a US priest accused of abusing up to 200 deaf boys two decades ago.

The leadership of the Catholic Church has responded by attacking the media, saying the claims were an "ignoble" attack on the Pope and that there was no "cover-up".

Here, three alleged victims of sexual abuse by priests, who contacted the BBC, tell their stories and give their opinions on the latest allegations surrounding the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:50 PM

French priest under investigation in sex case

FRANCE
The Associated Press

PARIS — A prosecutor says that preliminary charges have been filed against a priest in a small town southeast of Paris accused of sexual assault and possession of pornographic photos of a child parishioner.

The prosecutor of Troyes, Alex Perrin, says police detained the priest, who lives in Marcilly-le-Hayer, following a complaint of sexual assault by a 22-year-old. Perrin stressed that the priest contests the assault allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:48 PM

How the Catholic Church could end its sex scandal

Washington Post

By E.J. Dionne Jr.
Friday, March 26, 2010

How in the name of God can the Roman Catholic Church put the pedophilia scandal behind it?

I do not invoke God's name lightly. The church's problem is, above all, theological and religious. Its core difficulty is that rather than drawing on its Christian resources, the church has acted almost entirely on the basis of this world's imperatives and standards.

It has worried about lawsuits. It has worried about its image. It has worried about itself as an institution and about protecting its leaders from public scandal. In so doing, it has made millions of Catholics righteously furious and aggravated every one of its problems.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:42 PM

Keeping the record straight on Benedict and the crisis

National Catholic Reporter

by John L Allen Jr on Mar. 26, 2010 All Things Catholic

Intense scrutiny is being devoted these days to Pope Benedict XVI's history on the sex abuse crisis. Revelations from Germany have put his five years as a diocesan bishop under a spotlight, and a piece on Thursday in The New York Times, on the case of Fr. Lawrence Murphy of Milwaukee, also called into question his Vatican years as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Despite complaints in some quarters that all this is about wounding the pope and/or the church, raising these questions is entirely legitimate. Anyone involved in church leadership at the most senior levels for as long as Benedict XVI inevitably bears some responsibility for the present mess. My newspaper, the National Catholic Reporter, today called editorially for full disclosure about the pope's record on the sexual abuse crisis, and it now seems abundantly clear that only such transparency can resolve the hard questions facing Benedict.

Yet as always, the first casualty of any crisis is perspective. There are at least three aspects of Benedict's record on the sexual abuse crisis which are being misconstrued, or at least sloppily characterized, in today's discussion. Bringing clarity to these points is not a matter of excusing the pope, but rather of trying to understand accurately how we got where we are.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:38 PM

Only God Can Fire Pope Benedict After Scandals

UNITED STATES
ABC News

[with video]

By SUSAN DONALDSON JAMES
March 26, 2010

As outrage mounted over the latest Catholic Church sex scandal, writer Christopher Hitchens called for the arrest of Pope Benedict XVI, and singer Sinead O'Connor said the pope should face a criminal investigation.

"As a priest, it's like seeing my home and family disintegrate before my eyes."Protesters rallied outside the Vatican, angry that an office under his command had stopped the prosecution in 1996 of Wisconsin priest Lawrence Murphy, who admitted molesting 200 boys at a school for the deaf where he worked for 20 years.

The secret church trial was halted after Murphy made a personal appeal to the future pope asking for mercy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:35 PM

Glance at church abuse cases handled by pope

The Associated Press

In his time as an archbishop in Germany, a cardinal at the Vatican and then after becoming Pope Benedict XVI, Joseph Ratzinger has overseen at least four cases involving allegations of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy and church workers. A glance at the cases.

WISCONSIN:

Allegations: About 200 deaf boys at St. John's School for the Deaf near Milwaukee, Wisconsin, alleged they were molested by the Rev. Lawrence Murphy, including in the confessional, in dormitories, in closets and during field trips during his years at the institution from the 1950s through 1974.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:32 PM

Hush Little Boys

The Garden of Roses: Stories of Abuse and Healing

[with video]

Virginia Jones

Mr. Eric Gudmunsen sent this song to me last night, and I got his permission to share it with all of you. Mr. Gudmunsen is a Comedian-Singer/Songwriter-Musician from Dundee, Scotland, who currently lives in the Canary Islands with his Irish wife. He wrote this song as a protest against clergy abuse. He said that when he performs it, people laugh for a couple lines and then stop and listen. My daughter described the song as both depressing and funny.

Sometimes things are so bad all we can do is laugh at how bad they are. Many years ago I met a Peace Corp volunteer who had returned from Africa. She told me that Peace Corp volunteers who come back from South America, come back politically active. Those who come back from Asia, come back spiritually oriented. Those who come back from Africa, come back laughing.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:26 PM

Listen: Milwaukee Scandal Latest Abuse Crisis For Vatican

BOSTON (MA)
WBUR

[with audio]

By BOB OAKES

Published March 26, 2010

BOSTON — The clergy abuse scandal in Europe now includes — for the first time — documents that appear to show top Vatican officials mishandled allegations against a priest.

It is alleged that when he was Cardinal Ratzinger in the 1990s, Pope Benedict chose not to discipline Lawrence Murphy, a Wisconsin priest who allegedly molested up to 200 children at a school for the deaf, which he ran in Milwaukee from 1950 through 1974. Murphy died in 1998.

Related documents from the case appear on the Web site of a Boston-area group that tracks clergy abuse cases in the United States. The group, BishopAccountability.org, is now doing the same thing for claims in Europe.

WBUR spoke with the group’s president, Terry McKiernan, and asked him about the significance of the Milwaukee case.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:29 PM

Pope aide claims under-fire Vatican is victim of ‘conspiracy’

SCOTLAND
Caledonian Mercury

March 26, 2010 by Andrew McLeod

The Vatican has rejected fresh allegations linking Pope Benedict XVI to a cover-up of paedophile priests, even as international media reports accused the Church of moral bankruptcy and questioned the pontiff’s authority to continue to lead it.

The New York Times has alleged that the Pope, when Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, failed to defrock an American priest, the Rev Lawrence Murphy, for the abuse of 200 pupils in a school for deaf boys in Milwaukee. The allegations were the latest in a series of scandals to hit the Church this year.

L’Osservatore Romano, the Vatican newspaper, said in an editorial that Pope Benedict had always handled such cases with “transparency, purpose and severity.” It accused the international media of acting “with the clear and ignoble intent of trying to strike Benedict and his closest collaborators at any cost”. One of the Pope’s top aides, Cardinal José Saraiva Martins, said there was “a conspiracy” against the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:23 PM

Alone With Father Tom

UNITED STATES
CounterPunch

By DAVID YEARSLEY

The photo – this one in the New York Times, above the fold -- had an uncanny vintage look to it: there on the front page was a black-and-white photograph from 1960—the first black-and-white that I can remember in a long since the Times went to color—of the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, his hands folded in prayer and standing alongside two other priests. From out of the shadows covering his eyes like a mask, Murphy looks down at a row of kneeling deaf boys in starched shirts and crew cuts. Murphy molested as many as 200 student at the St. John’s School for the Deaf in Wisconsin. Warnings from several American bishops to Rome were ignored. According to the Times, letters to then Cardinal Ratzinger in his capacity as head of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which remains the office charged with pursing canonical trials for the defrocking of priests, went unheeded. This was only one of thousands of cases of which the Vatican was informed and did not act upon.

This kind of publicity will not only shake the Church’s already creaking foundations; so evocative and troubling is the photo that it will have many revisiting their own memories.

I began to play the organ when I was fourteen, studying for a summer in Washington, D.C. I took to it very quickly, and when I returned to Bainbridge Island in Puget Sound at summer’s end, I needed a place to continue my practice. A few miles away was an Episcopal Church with a mediocre organ but one that would serve the purposes of my improvement as an organist. My involvement with the Episcopal Church had purely to do with the convenience of the organ, but I soon became interested in the elaborations of liturgy, the relationship of religious text to music, and the mysteries of religion.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:20 PM

The Pope: Drowning, Not Waving, Ctd

The Daily Dish (United States)

26 Mar 2010

"An important question is whether the Church should investigate and discipline severe ethical transgressions of its leaders as do other major organizations, including corporations. It appears that when it comes to ethical and leadership failures, Pope Benedict believes the answer is "no," that the Church—which serves God—should not be held even to the same standards as responsible corporations—servants of Mammon," - former GE executive Ben Heineman in Business Week.

And this is the case Benedict is making: because we are the church, we need not observe the same moral standards as secular institutions. Even child rape must be dealt with entirely internally and secretly - and even then, no actual firings in any way commensurate with the offense. And now that we know that Ratzinger chaired an actual meeting that agreed to transfer a pedophile priest to therapy and another parish, rather than fire him immediately and report him to the authorities, we know how far up that attitude goes.

That's why there really is no solution apart from a mass resignation at the top of the Church and some attempt to start over.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:17 PM

New allegations say pope failed to stop abusive German priest

GERMANY
National Post (Canada)

Agence France-Presse
Published: Friday, March 26, 2010

WASHINGTON -- Pope Benedict XVI failed to act in 1980 to stop a priest accused of sexually abusing children from taking up new duties in a different parish in Germany, the New York Times alleged on Friday.

Before Benedict became pontiff, the then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was kept closely apprised of the case of Reverend Peter Hullerman, who was suspended from his duties in the northern German town of Essen in late 1979 after several parents accused him of pedophilia.

A few weeks later in January 1980, Pope Ratzinger, then archbishop of Munich, led a meeting approving Father Hullerman's transfer as a priest in the southern Bavarian city, the Times said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:14 PM

Paedophile priests scandal seen with the eyes of the Thailand of sex tourism

THAILAND
AsiaNews

Bangkok (AsiaNews) - "The accusations against paedophile priests shames and embarrasses me, but I also have great compassion for the victims and perpetrators of abuses. So it is important not to reduce everything to the act of reporting abuse. It is far better to be discreet and help those who are guilty – who are certainly wounded people - and the victims who have been abused. Only in this way can something positive come out of these bitter experiences. "

These are the remarks of Fr. Adriano Pelosin, 64, PIME missionary in Thailand for 29 years, and more than 12 years engaged in the recovery of street children abused by their parents, used as instruments of pleasure for sex tourism, abandoned by their families.

The scandal of paedophile priests even if reported in newspapers in Thailand, has no great impact on people. "Here - continues the priest - there is a law that prohibits people speaking about scandals involving the monks and the royal household. The pope and priests are associated with the Buddhist religious world and so little mention is made. Among Catholics, there is a certain degree of shame over the way some ministers have stained their sacred service and betrayed the trust of children or young men and women”. For this, he says, the culprits must be prosecuted and there should be no cover ups or silences. "But - he adds – the time has come to take a deep look at ourselves, priests and laity, believers and non believers: if priests could have done so much wrong, who knows how much wrong has been done by others! Jesus' would say: Who is without sin cast the first stone. And if God has called an army of journalists to accuse the Church - as he once called the Assyrian army to destroy Jerusalem – we must be careful not to go beyond the limits that God puts on all punishment."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:11 PM

Jeff Anderson, crusading lawyer on clergy sex abuse, finding new ways to get around legal roadblo

ST. PAUL (MN)
MinnPost

By Beth Hawkins | Friday, March 26, 2010
In many of the thousands of lawsuits he has filed over the years against the Roman Catholic Church and its clergy, St. Paul's Jeff Anderson ran up against the same seemingly impenetrable legal wall.

Because sex-abuse victims frequently endure years of misery before coming forward, by the time Anderson's clients were ready to go public with their stories, statutes of limitation — legal deadlines for filing suit — had elapsed.

But now, after 27 years of looking for alternative legal avenues, it seems Anderson has found a couple of chinks in the wall.

Parish wants sex abuse priest back

AUSTRIA
Austrian Independent

Parishioners have called for the return of a priest, suspended for sexually abusing a 17-year-old boy.

Ernest Theußl, chairman of the town council in the priest’s parish of Deutschlandsberg, Styria said no one could complain about the priest, who was punished 12 years ago for sexual abuse of the boy but had admitted his guilt.

Theußl said: "We knew about his offence from the beginning, but we have had a good experience with him and want it to continue. We believe that forgiveness is appropriate in non-violent cases like his."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:06 PM

Memo to Pope Described Transfer of Pedophile Priest

GERMANY
The New York Times

By NICHOLAS KULISH and KATRIN BENNHOLD
Published: March 25, 2010

MUNICH — The future Pope Benedict XVI was kept more closely apprised of a sexual abuse case in Germany than previous church statements have suggested, raising fresh questions about his handling of a scandal unfolding under his direct supervision before he rose to the top of the church’s hierarchy.

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope and archbishop in Munich at the time, was copied on a memo that informed him that a priest, whom he had approved sending to therapy in 1980 to overcome pedophilia, would be returned to pastoral work within days of beginning psychiatric treatment. The priest was later convicted of molesting boys in another parish.

An initial statement on the matter issued earlier this month by the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising placed full responsibility for the decision to allow the priest to resume his duties on Cardinal Ratzinger’s deputy, the Rev. Gerhard Gruber. But the memo, whose existence was confirmed by two church officials, shows that the future pope not only led a meeting on Jan. 15, 1980, approving the transfer of the priest, but was also kept informed about the priest’s reassignment.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:03 PM

Cardinal wants 'just resolution'

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Friday, 26 March 2010

The head of the Catholic Church in Ireland said he wanted to work towards a just resolution in a court case being taken against him by an alleged victim of clerical abuse.

Cardinal Sean Brady has been called to withdraw his defence in a legal battle with a man who claims he was abused by notorious paedophile priest Fr Brendan Smyth.

It is understood the man is suing Dr Brady at the High Court in his capacity as Archbishop of Armagh. In a statement the Cardinal said he wanted to "work towards a just resolution of the case.. conscious of the rights of all concerned." He said he had asked his legal representatives to engage the legal representatives of the complainant with a view to progressing the case.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:00 PM

Vatican Denies Pope Knew of Priest’s Transfer

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By RACHEL DONADIO
Published: March 26, 2010

ROME — The Vatican on Friday denied that the future pope Benedict XVI knew about a decision to transfer a known pedophile priest to his diocese when he was archbishop in Munich in 1980.

In a statement Friday, the Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said that Benedict “had no knowledge of the decision” to reassign the priest “to pastoral activities in a parish.”

The Vatican issued the statement in response to an article in The New York Times on Friday reporting that Benedict, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, archbishop of the diocese of Munich and Freising, had been copied on a memo informing him that a priest he had sent for therapy to overcome pedophilia would return to pastoral work in the Munich diocese only days after beginning the treatment.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:57 PM

Archbishop Asks Accountability of Colleagues

IRELAND
America Magazine

Archbishop Diarmuid Martin of Dublin called on his episcopal colleagues to take responsibility for the Irish Catholic Church’s failures in dealing with child sexual abuse by priests. “Without accountability for the past there will be no healing and no trust for the future,” Archbishop Martin told reporters on March 20 following Mass at St. Mary’s Pro-Cathedral in Dublin after Pope Benedict XVI’s pastoral letter to Irish Catholics on the abuse crisis was released.

Just a few days later, on March 24, the Vatican announced that the pope had accepted the resignation offered on March 9 by Bishop John Magee of Cloyne. Magee, 73, had served as personal secretary to three popes. He was accused in a 2009 investigation of mishandling reports of sexual abuse in his diocese. Four other Irish bishops had offered their resignations to the pope in December because of their mishandling of sexual abuse of children by clerics. The pope has accepted only one of these resignations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:54 PM

Pope faces claims he covered up German sex abuse case

GERMANY
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

By Rob Crilly
Published: 4:41PM GMT 26 Mar 2010

The Pope faced fresh accusations of covering up child abuse yesterday as it emerged he was present at a meeting where Church officials decided to allow a paedophile priest to continue working.

The allegations dating to his time as Archbishop of Munich came a day after he was accused of covering up attacks on up to 200 boys at a deaf school in the American state of Wisconsin.

The latest claims centred on how much he knew about a decision to allow a priest to resume pastoral duties in Germany in the 1980s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:51 PM

No sex abuse inquiry against priest because complaint was not made

NORTHERN IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

By Donna Deeney
Friday, 26 March 2010

Police confirmed they would not have investigated claims of sex abuse against a priest because they didn’t receive a complaint from the victim.

Disgraced priest Fr John McCullagh made an out-of-court settlement in 2000 when he paid £12,000 of his own money and wrote a letter of apology to a woman from the Derry Diocese, who accused him of abusing her between 1979 and 1989.

Questions have been asked as to why police did not pursue McCullagh after the Bishop of Derry, Dr Seamus Hegarty, said he met with the RUC to discuss allegations against the priest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:49 PM

Does sex abuse crisis threaten pope's moral clout?

USA Today

The Catholic clergy sex abuse crisis that exploded across the USA in 2002 is now detonating across Ireland and Germany and up to the doorstep of the Vatican where abuse victims demonstrated on Thursday, demanding full accountability by the Church.

Pope Benedict XVI himself is under attack for failing to defrock predatory priests or to toss out bishops who put the image of the church ahead of the safety of child and teen victims.

Vatican defenders are punching back, calling the spate of stories a concerted attack on the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:46 PM

Vatican Spokesman Refutes Murphy Case Accusations

VATICAN CITY
Catholic.net

By Genevieve Pollock

VATICAN CITY, MARCH 25, 2010 (Zenit.org).- There were no cover-ups, the Vatican is confirming in response to media accusations that tried to implicate Benedict XVI in the case of a priest accused of abusing deaf children.

Today, several media sources followed the New York Times in reporting a story about Father Lawrence Murphy, a priest from the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, who was accused of molesting up to 200 children.

The Holy See published the statement that Father Federico Lombardi, director of the Vatican press office, gave to the Times, in which he deplored this "tragic case" that "involved particularly vulnerable victims who suffered terribly."


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:42 PM

New York Times highlights Vatican inaction on abusive Milwaukee priest

VATICAN CITY
Catholic Culture

March 25, 2010
In a front-page headline story, the New York Times has called attention to a sex-abuse case in which the Vatican failed to act promptly on a request to defrock a Wisconsin priest who was accused of molesting up to 200 boys at a school for the deaf.

In an extraordinary public statement directly responding to the Times story, the Vatican pointed out that the Vatican was unaware of the accusations against Father Lawrence Murphy until more than 20 years after they arose. In his statement Father Federico Lombardi, the director of the Vatican press office, also took pains to debunk the popular misconception that the 1962 Vatican document Crimen Sollicitationis and/or the Code of Canon Law required diocesan officials to maintain absolute confidentiality about abuse reports. He said:

Indeed, contrary to some statements that have circulated in the press, neither 'Crimen' nor the Code of Canon Law ever prohibited the reporting of child abuse to law enforcement authorities.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:39 PM

NEW YORK TIMES TRIES TO KEEP FLAME ALIVE

UNITED STATES
Catholic League

March 26, 2010

Catholic League president Bill Donohue addresses today's New York Times news story on the pope:

"Pope Was Told Pedophile Priest Would Get Transfer." That's the headline in today's New York Times piece on the pope. Yet the Times offers absolutely no evidence to support this charge.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:32 PM

Child sex abuse: Catholic church leader admits he knew

NETHERLANDS
Radio Netherlands

[with audio]

The child sex abuse scandal within the Dutch Catholic Church is deepening with the admission for the first time from the country's most senior church figure that he was aware of abuse in the 1970s and 80s.

Bishop of Rotterdam Ad van Luyn, who now chairs the Netherlands Synod of Bishops, knew of concrete cases of sexual abuse during his time as head of the Salesian order between 1975 and 1981.

The revelation has been confirmed to Radio Netherlands Worldwide by the Bishop's spokesman.

This is the first time that Van Luyn has admitted knowing about abuse during the period that he was in charge of the order. The Bishop says he will only say more about this when an independent investigation, called by the church, is completed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:29 PM

Rotterdam bishop knew about abuse

NETHERLANDS
Dutch News

Friday 26 March 2010

Rotterdam bishop Ad van Luyn knew about several cases of sexual abuse of children at Catholic boarding schools run by the Salesian order, a spokesman for the bishop told the NRC and Dutch world service radio RNW.

Van Luyn was head of the Salesian order from 1975 to 1981. The bishop was aware of 'several concrete cases' and 'had to take action', the spokesman said.

It is the first time the bishop has admitted knowing about the abuse. He declined to make any further comment pending the outcome of an independent inquiry into abuse at Catholic schools and seminaries nationwide.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:26 PM

Granite Falls church finds unexpected connection to Catholic scandal

MINNESOTA
KARE

By Scott Goldberg

GRANITE FALLS, Minn. -- The scandal that started in Ireland and spread across the globe has come knocking on the door of a Catholic church in this small city 120 miles west of Minneapolis.

"I was very shocked and disgusted," said the Rev. Jim Devorak, the pastor at St. Andrew, who learned about the connection the same way as most in his parish.

Last week, CNN reported 82-year-old priest Francis Markey, who is in an Indiana jail awaiting extradition to Ireland on charges he raped a 15-year-old boy 40 years ago, once spent three months as the interim pastor at St. Andrew.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:19 PM

Former interim Granite Falls pastor charged with rape

GRANITE FALLS (MN)
Advocate Tribune

By Scott Tedrick, Editor
Advocate Tribune
Fri Mar 26, 2010

A recent CNN: Special Investigation report uses Granite Falls as the setting for a story involving 82 year old priest Francis Markey who is facing charges of raping a 15-year-old boy in Ireland 40 years ago.

According to a statement issued by the New Ulm diocese, Markey filled in at the Granite Falls parish during an approximately three month period during the spring of 1982. Following the death of Fr. Henry LeMay, pastor James Moran was lined up to take on the post at St. Andrew’s. However, Moran was on a sabbatical in Rome at the time and unable arrive in Granite Falls immediately. Markey was brought in to fill in during the interim.

The CNN report states that, as a priest, Markey was first suspended for unidentified reasons in 1964 and sent for psychiatric treatment in Dublin. Throughout the 60s and 70s he underwent suspension and subsequent treatment a total of three times. Eventually, he was sent to New Mexico where it was reported that the Catholic church ran a treatment facility for priests with “various addictions or sexual problems.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:15 PM

Delaware courts: Wilmington diocese, victims close to mediation

WILMINGTON (DE)
The News Journal

By MAUREEN MILFORD • The News Journal • March 26, 2010

In a move that could foretell a quick resolution of the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington's bankruptcy, the diocese and victims of clergy sexual abuse are close to a deal to work on settling their conflicts outside the courtroom.

An agreement to mediate disputed issues -- the equivalent of legal peace talks -- could be struck and papers filed as early as today in U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, according to lawyers for the diocese, the official unsecured creditors' committee and abuse victims suing in state court.

The goal of mediation is to more quickly and cost-effectively reach agreement on a plan of reorganization, avoiding protracted courtroom battles before the judge, lawyers said. During the mediation process, the case would remain in bankruptcy court and the judge would have to approve any settlement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:09 PM

Clerics regret church abuse as Vatican denounces report

EUROPE
CNN

(CNN) -- Top Catholic clerics from France and Britain expressed shame, anger and regret Friday over a widening abuse scandal in the church that has reached Pope Benedict XVI's doorstep.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:05 PM

What the pope should have known

UNITED KINGDOM
Guardian

John Hooper guardian.co.uk, Friday 26 March 2010

Confused? It would be more than forgivable.

Such is the multiplicity and complexity of the accusations being levelled at pope Benedict and the Vatican in the sex abuse scandal assailing the Catholic church that it is not easy to make out the wheat amid the chaff.

But no one should be in any doubt that today's report in the New York Times, if true, is wheat (though that wholesome analogy may be rather misplaced in the circumstances since we are talking here about particles of information that could prove lethal to the current leadership of the Catholic church).

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:13 AM

Alleged victim of Wisconsin priest says he's shocked to learn of pope's role in case

MINNESOTA
News Observer

By RANDY FURST AND JEFF STRICKLER - Star Tribune (Minneapolis)
MINNEAPOLIS -- Donald Marshall, 45, says he still remembers when the late Rev. Lawrence Murphy entered his cell at the Lincoln Hills School for Boys reformatory near Wausau, Wis., when Marshall was 13.

"We were studying the Bible together," Marshall said. "It started out with him putting his hand on my knee. I didn't think nothing of it. ... He moved over closer and started kissing me, started fondling me."

Two years ago, Marshall and three other alleged victims of Murphy's sued the Catholic Church.

That suit became an international news story Thursday, when their attorneys, Jeff Anderson and Mike Finnegan of St. Paul, released internal church documents they'd obtained.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:08 AM

The Butler Did It

NEW YORK
New York Post

DYLAN BUTLER

In Middle Village, Queens this afternoon, Father John Savage Gymnasium was packed for a pep rally as the Christ the King community wished its boys and girls basketball teams luck as they trekked to upstate Glens Falls for the New York State Federation tournament this weekend.

At around the same time in Boston, the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office was preparing a press release detailing an indictment against longtime boys coach Bob Oliva on two charges of child rape and one of disseminating pornography to a minor.

A Boston grand jury handed down the indictment after hearing testimony from a number of former Oliva associates as well as from two alleged victims. They spoke about horrific and despicable acts by a man who was lauded for his coaching ability by some.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:05 AM

Pope linked to cover-up in Superior Diocese priest case

WISCONSIN
Duluth News Tribune

By: Robin Washington and Jana Hollingsworth, Duluth News Tribune

Pope Benedict XVI — or at least his immediate subordinate in his previous role as a cardinal — was made aware of an attempt to cover up the record of a Milwaukee priest reassigned to the Diocese of Superior after sexually molesting as many as 200 boys at a school for the deaf over 20 years, church records reviewed by the News Tribune show.

The Reverend Lawrence Murphy, who died in 1998, was reassigned to the Superior church in 1974 after allegations of abuse going back to 1950 at St. John’s School for the Deaf in St. Francis, Wis.

Church records reviewed by the News Tribune show he then spent time working in the Superior Diocese at St. Anne’s in Boulder Junction, Wis., and other parishes until 1994. ...

“There’s a letter on July 17, 1996, from Weakland to Ratzinger — two years before Murphy dies,” Terry McKiernan, president of Bishop Accountability, told the News Tribune from suburban Boston.

“He’s informing Ratizinger because he’s assuming Ratzinger will want to be made aware of these kinds of cases.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:48 AM

Renowned NYC prep coach indicted on rape charges

BOSTON (MA)
philly.com

A legendary New York City high school basketball coach is accused in an indictment of raping a 14-year-old player during a trip they took to Boston decades ago.

Bob Oliva was indicted by a grand jury yesterday on charges including two counts of rape.

The assault allegedly took place in 1976 at a Boston hotel. Prosecutors at the Suffolk District Attorney's office said they were able to charge Oliva in the case because the statute of limitations was frozen while Oliva lived out of state.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:44 AM

STATEMENT BY HOLY SEE PRESS OFFICE DIRECTOR

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

VATICAN CITY, 26 MAR 2010 (VIS) - The following communique was released late this morning by the Holy See Press Office:

"Holy See Press Office Director Fr. Federico Lombardi S.J., questioned by journalists concerning a new 'New York Times' article which appeared on 26 March and concerns the period in which Cardinal Ratzinger was archbishop of Munich, referred them to this morning's public denial in a communique published by the archdiocese of Munich, which reads:

"'The article in the New York Times contains no new information beyond that which the archdiocese has already communicated concerning the then archbishop's knowledge of the situation of Father H.'

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:44 AM

STATEMENT BY HOLY SEE PRESS OFFICE DIRECTOR

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

VATICAN CITY, 26 MAR 2010 (VIS) - The following communique was released late this morning by the Holy See Press Office:

"Holy See Press Office Director Fr. Federico Lombardi S.J., questioned by journalists concerning a new 'New York Times' article which appeared on 26 March and concerns the period in which Cardinal Ratzinger was archbishop of Munich, referred them to this morning's public denial in a communique published by the archdiocese of Munich, which reads:

"'The article in the New York Times contains no new information beyond that which the archdiocese has already communicated concerning the then archbishop's knowledge of the situation of Father H.'

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:41 AM

Pope Was Told Pedophile Priest Would Get Transfer

GERMANY
The New York Times

By NICHOLAS KULISH and KATRIN BENNHOLD
Published: March 25, 2010

MUNICH — The future Pope Benedict XVI was kept more closely apprised of a sexual abuse case in Germany than previous church statements have suggested, raising fresh questions about his handling of a scandal unfolding under his direct supervision before he rose to the top of the church’s hierarchy.

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope and archbishop in Munich at the time, was copied on a memo that informed him that a priest, whom he had approved sending to therapy in 1980 to overcome pedophilia, would be returned to pastoral work within days of beginning psychiatric treatment. The priest was later convicted of molesting boys in another parish.

An initial statement on the matter issued earlier this month by the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising placed full responsibility for the decision to allow the priest to resume his duties on Cardinal Ratzinger’s deputy, the Rev. Gerhard Gruber. But the memo, whose existence was confirmed by two church officials, shows that the future pope not only led a meeting on Jan. 15, 1980, approving the transfer of the priest, but was also kept informed about the priest’s reassignment.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:37 AM

Teacher/ pastor abused teen girl

WEST VIRGINIA
Appalachian News-Express

By Audrey Carter-Lee Staff Writer

WILLIAMSON, W.Va. — A former teacher and pastor pleaded guilty to incest Wednesday in Mingo County Circuit Court.

In exchange for the guilty plea, another charge of sexual abuse was dismissed against 36-year-old Johnny Ray Dempsey of Delbarton, W.Va. The defendant was represented by Attorney Mark Hobbs.

The incident is said to have occurred in June 2009.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:07 AM

Cardinal errors

Guardian (United Kingdom)

[poll]

With reports implicating the former Cardinal Ratzinger in cases of Catholic priests accused of abusing children, does Pope Benedict XVI have the moral authority to make reparation and restore the church's reputation?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:03 AM

MUST SEE: Videos on the pope, clergy abuse, and SNAP leaders in Rome

UNITED STATES
Voice from the Desert

Frank Douglas

My New York pal Dick Regan pointed me to the following Internet link to the Washington Post website which has four videos on the pope, clergy abuse of children, and SNAP in Rome.

Thanks, Dick.

When you link to the site, make sure you hit the “WORLD” button on the right. Then click on the title to see each video.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:57 AM

Can PR Save the Church and Joseph Ratzinger?

UNITED STATES
Newser

by Michael Wolff

A source I have used before from the high media stratosphere, who asks to remain anonymous, offers the following: “I am not for a second suggesting there is a parallel between Toyota/Goldman Sachs/Big Banks behavior and the Vatican but ... there is a curious similarity to the way each/both handles bad PR. Specifically there is the weak ‘we are all for transparency’ suggestion, the semi-apology, the vow to do better, etc. But there is also the ‘We are ______ (fill in the blank), we don't have to talk if we don't want to, this too shall pass, it always does’ mentality. Tiger Woods in his grudging ‘statement’ and then controlled ‘interview’ epitomizes this. Getting back to business in the face of outrage is the new black.”

I suppose it makes sense for the Catholic Church to regard itself on the level of mighty industrial companies or Wall Street powerhouses, or, even, an incomparable sports star. I suppose, too, that PR is PR—you do what worked for the last guy who got in trouble.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:53 AM

Scandal-plagued Catholic order apologizes to victims

ROME
Reuters

(Reuters) - An influential Catholic priestly order whose late founder was discovered to have been a sexual molester and to have had at least one child apologized on Friday to victims whose accusations were ignored for years.

The apology from the leaders of the Legion of Christ "to all those who have been affected, wounded, or scandalized by the reprehensible actions of our founder" came as the Catholic Church is being convulsed over reports of abuse of children.

Last week, the Vatican announced the completion of a one year inquiry of the conservative order, which involved visits by papal inspectors to its more than 120 seminaries, 200 schools and 600 centres for lay Catholics around the world.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:50 AM

Legionaries acknowledge founder abused seminarians, ask forgiveness

ROME
Catholic News Service

By John Thavis
Catholic News Service

ROME (CNS) -- Top officials of the Legionaries of Christ acknowledged that the order's founder, the late Father Marcial Maciel Degollado, sexually abused young seminarians, and they asked forgiveness for failing to listen to his accusers.

A statement released March 26 by the Legionaries and its lay branch, Regnum Christi, said that any members of the order who were guilty of cooperation in Father Maciel's crimes would be held accountable.

The statement said the Legionaries were looking to the future with the hope of continuing to serve the church, but with a greater emphasis on reconciling with those who suffered from Father Maciel's actions and greater cooperation with local pastors and other church officials.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:48 AM

Pope Allegedly Knew About Wis. Pedophile Priest

AOL News

Dana Kennedy

(March 25) -- Just days after Pope Benedict XVI chastised Irish bishops for covering up clerical sexual abuse in Ireland, new documents suggest he did nothing to discipline a Wisconsin priest he knew had molested scores of deaf boys -- and may have blocked a church trial in the case.

In 1996, when then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was serving in one of the Vatican's most important positions, he received written warnings from several bishops about the Rev. Lawrence Murphy, a priest at St. John's School for the Deaf in St. Francis, Wis., The New York Times reported. The Times obtained the internal church documents from lawyers of five victims of Murphy, who are suing the Archdiocese of Milwaukee.

"This shows a direct line from the victims through the bishops and directly to the man who is now pope," Jeff Anderson, one of the lawyers, told AOL News reporter Lisa Holewa in Milwaukee. "The only difference [from the 1950s] is now we have the documents that are open to secular eyes."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:45 AM

Credibility gap: Pope needs to answer questions

UNITED STATES
National Catholic Reporter

An NCR Editorial

PDF versionThe Holy Father needs to directly answer questions, in a credible forum, about his role -- as archbishop of Munich (1977-82), as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (1982-2005), and as pope (2005-present) -- in the mismanagement of the clergy sex abuse crisis.

We urge this not primarily as journalists seeking a story, but as Catholics who appreciate that extraordinary circumstances require an extraordinary response. Nothing less than a full, personal and public accounting will begin to address the crisis that is engulfing the worldwide church. It is that serious.

To date, as revelations about administrative actions resulting in the shifting of clergy abusers from parish to parish emerge throughout Europe, Pope Benedict XVI's personal response has been limited to a letter to the Irish church. Such epistles are customary and necessary, but insufficient.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 AM

Vicar faces sex charges

WALES
Shropshire Star

Friday 26th March 2010

A former Church in Wales vicar from Powys has appeared before a court charged with serious sexual offences.

Richard Hart, formerly parish priest at Beguildy near Knighton, appeared via video link from Park Prison in Bridgend before Brecon Combined Court yesterday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:37 AM

Deaf school students say Wis. priest abused them

ST. FRANCIS (WI)
TBO

By DINESH RAMDE and TODD RICHMOND
Associated Press Writers

ST. FRANCIS, Wis. (AP) -- Steven Geier says that four times in the mid-1960s, the Rev. Lawrence Murphy coaxed the then-14-year-old student into a closet at St. John's School for the Deaf just outside Milwaukee and molested him, using God to justify his actions.

Geier said when he told Murphy what was happening was wrong, the priest replied, "Oh, yes. God sent me. This is confession."

Geier, now 59 and living in Madison, was one of about 200 deaf boys at the school who say they were molested by the late priest decades ago in a case now creating a scandal for the Vatican and threatening to ensnare Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:34 AM

Pope Benedict XVI is part of the solution not the problem

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

Cristina Odone

It’s a bad time to be a Catholic. Everywhere you look, Church bashers are crowing about the left-footers caught kiddy-fiddling. Sensationalist stories of horriffic child abuse keep coming out like rats in a ramshackle house. Reports of cover-ups make you want to spit at any one wearing a bishop’s mitre, or a cardinal’s red hat: if they weren’t at it, they were probably covering up for one of their own who was.

So when it comes to the Bishop of Rome, Pope Benedict, the instinct is to spit all the more. But to do so would be wrong. This Pope has done more than any other Churchman to address the issue of priestly child abuse. He has stopped the practice of turning over priests accused of abuse to therapists, as we now know that therapy seldom helps a paedophile. He has fast-tracked the defrocking of priests found guilty of abuse. He has promoted co-operation, at a diocesan level, between church authorities responsible for canon law and police.

He can point to some real success in the protection of children: in England and Wales, for instance, child protection officers monitor every encounter between children and clergy. The result, is that, ironically, there is no safer place for a child today to be than with a Catholic priest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:23 AM

Pope Benedict XVI 'knew child abuser allowed back to work'

GERMANY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome, and Nico Hines

The Roman Catholic Church’s account of Pope Benedict XVI’s handing of a serial paedophile was called into question today when new documents emerged suggesting that his office was kept informed of the offender’s rapid return to working with children.

Contrary to statements released by the Church in Germany, a memorandum uncovered by The New York Times suggests that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was told that a priest had gone back to pastoral duties in Munich a few days after he started psychiatric treatment. The priest went on to commit further offences.

The latest child abuse scandal to hit the Catholic Church involves a German priest, Father Peter Hullermann, who was convicted of molesting boys in 1986. Victims have complained that repeated warnings were ignored by the Church over decades of abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:14 AM

Pope Benedict’s record

UNITED STATES
The Pilot

Dwight G. Duncan

On Saturday, March 20, Pope Benedict XVI released his long-awaited Letter to the Catholics of Ireland in response to the scandal of Church members there, particularly priests and religious, sexually abusing children and vulnerable young people. This is something we know about here in Massachusetts, as we were Ground Zero in the clerical sexual abuse scandal that shook the Catholic Church in this country beginning in 2002.

Recently, the crisis has spread to Australia and Ireland, and more recently to Germany, Pope Benedict’s homeland, as well as Austria, Switzerland and Holland. It seems clear that this is a world-wide problem which needs to be addressed. There are now allegations that while archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982, Cardinal Ratzinger himself let an abusive priest be transferred, though his vicar general has assumed responsibility for the decision.

Let the facts come out: Pope Benedict has stood for transparency, penance, and accountability in the Church, themes picked up by his recent Pastoral Letter. He reversed his own position (and that of venerable Pope John Paul II) in not hesitating to discipline Fr. Marcial Maciel in 2006, the founder of the Legionaries of Christ and an influential and well-connected figure in the Church, when allegations of sexual relations with minors were substantiated. He did the same with Fr. Gino Burresi, a famous Italian priest reputed to have the stigmata, in 2005. The wheels of justice may grind slow, but they grind exceedingly fine.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:12 AM

Brady wants 'just resolution' of abuse case

IRELAND
RTE News

[with audio]

Friday, 26 March 2010 12:45
Cardinal Seán Brady has responded to a news report that he has been urged to withdraw his defence in a legal battle with one of Fr Brendan Smyth's alleged victims.

High Court documents show that the solicitor for the alleged victim says he was incredulous at recent expressions of remorse by the Primate and other church leaders when those statements were compared to Dr Brady's defence in the proceedings.

In a statement, Cardinal Brady said he wanted to work towards a just resolution of the case, conscious of the rights of all concerned.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:09 AM

Shame on the NYTimes

UNITED STATES
America Magazine

Posted at: 2010-03-26
Author: Michael Sean Winters

Usually, we can all turn to the New York Times and the Washington Post with a reasonable degree of assurance that their writers and editors are top-notch journalists, who ferret out facts, put those facts in a proper context, and truly enlighten a reader’s understanding of whatever event is being reported on in the pages of their newspapers. Yesterday, not so much.

The New York Times’ article, by the usually reliable Laurie Goodstein, was not only unsupported by the documentation the paper cited, it seemed unrelated. From the documents the Times provided it seems abundantly clear that there was a monster priest, Father Murphy, in Milwaukee who abused dozens and dozens of deaf children, and that when this came to light in 1974, he was retired from ministry. Twenty years later, in 1996, a different charge was made against the priest, that he had granted absolution for sexual sins in which he was complicit. This was referred to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith which was headed at the time by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. To be clear – and this is important because the Times’ article seems to elide the charges – Cardinal Ratzinger and the CDF had no jurisdiction over abuse claims in 1996. Charges of sexual abuse only became the CDF’s responsibility in 2001. To suggest that Cardinal Raztinger was not taking the charge of sexual abuse seriously is not just interpretatively wrong in this case but factually wrong: The charge of sexual abuse was not in front of him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:06 AM

French Bishops ''ashamed'' of Priest Sexual Abuse

FRANCE
The New York Times

PARIS (AP) -- France's Roman Catholic bishops say in a letter to Pope Benedict XVI that they are ashamed of priests who committed ''abominable acts'' by molesting and raping children.

The French bishops have written in a letter to the pope ''those who carried out these acts have disfigured the church, wounded Christian communities and cast suspicion on all the members of the clergy.''

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:02 AM

Sexual abuse scandal linked to the northwoods

WISCONSIN
WAOW

[with video]

by Elizabeth Fay

BOULDER JUNCTION (WAOW)--SNAP, an advocacy group for those who have been abused by priests, held several press conferences throughout the world, including northern Wisconsin.

The group members say Father Murphy, the priest accused of molesting about 200 deaf boys mostly at St. John's in Milwaukee, continued working with the Catholic church, even after allegations of sexual abuse surfaced. That's why the SNAP Director of Minnesota, Bob Schwiderski, spoke out at St. Anne's Church, in Boulder Junction.

According to church documents, in 1974, church officials sent Murphy to Boulder Junction on what they called "sick leave."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Alleged abuse continued in Superior Diocese

WISCONSIN
Duluth News Tribune

By: Jana Hollingsworth, Duluth News Tribune

The Rev. Lawrence Murphy’s sexual assaults of boys didn’t stop after the Catholic Church moved him to the Diocese of Superior in the 1970s, according to two men who claim they were victims of the priest in northern Wisconsin.

Murphy’s acts of sexual assault against as many as 200 deaf boys in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee from 1950 to 1974 have been confirmed by the church, according to documents reviewed by the News Tribune. But allegations of similar crimes in the Diocese of Superior later in Murphy’s career have not been widely known.

Donald Marshall, now 45, said he was 13 or 14 when Murphy assaulted him at a reform school in the north-central Wisconsin town of Irma at the eastern end of the Superior Diocese. Murphy was serving as an unofficial assistant pastor in the area.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:57 AM

The Vatican wakes up

VATICAN CITY
UTV (Northern Ireland)

Madeleine Bunting: The wave of child abuse allegations has forced the Vatican, finally, to respond, apologise and investigate

Friday, 26 March 2010

The last few weeks have been an astonishing period in the history of the Vatican. Usually the institution likes to claim that it thinks in centuries. It has taken pride in its stubborn refusal to march to the tempo of daily news headlines. But all that is changing.

The papal spokesman, Federico Lombardi, has been rarely out of the news. He has been fighting on a near daily basis to defend the pope's reputation from allegations which have come closer and closer to drawing the papacy and Pope Benedict himself directly into the fast-spreading child abuse scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:54 AM

Pope Benedict XVI and the tarnished Catholic Church

UNITED STATES
Charlotte Observer

Posted: Friday, Mar. 26, 2010

The systematic coverup of many Catholic priests' decades-long sexual abuse of thousands of children now appears to have reached all the way to the top and Pope Benedict XVI.

The New York Times on Thursday broke the story of how the pope, who was then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, and other top Vatican officials looked the other way or worse when informed of a particularly egregious case of an abusive priest in Wisconsin. American bishops directly contacted Ratzinger in 1996 about the Rev. Lawrence Murphy, who had molested as many as 200 deaf boys while working at a school in Milwaukee from 1950 to 1974.

As Wisconsin bishops prepared a secret canonical trial against him, Murphy wrote to Ratzinger, who led the Vatican office that decides how to handle cases of accused priests. Murphy said he was in poor health and "I have repented of any of my past transgressions, and ... simply want to live out the time that I have left in the dignity of my priesthood. ... I ask your kind assistance in this matter."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:51 AM

Pope implicated in allegations over sex abuse by second Catholic priest

GERMANY
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Stephen Bates guardian.co.uk, Friday 26 March 2010

Fresh revelations have been made directly implicating Pope Benedict XVI in mishandling the case of a paedophile priest in his former archdiocese of Munich. The allegations come a day after the Vatican responded angrily to the allegation that the former Cardinal Ratzinger had ignored an American diocese's request that another predatory priest should be defrocked.

According to the New York Times, the former cardinal, as Archbishop of Munich, attended a meeting in January 1980 at which the transfer of Father Peter Hullermann from the diocese of Essen, where his parishioners had accused him of abusing boys, to Munich was agreed.

The move was meant to allow him to undergo therapy, but instead he was immediately posted to a parish in Bavaria, where he continued to abuse children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:47 AM

Vatican, Pope Benedict linked to case of WI priest abuse

ST. PAUL (MN)
KARE

By Jana Shortal

ST. PAUL, Minn. -- Lawyers from Saint Paul are representing five people who claim they were victims of abuse by a priest at a deaf school in Wisconsin between 1950 and 1974.

It's a case that's getting international attention Thursday because it allegedly involves action by the Pope.

In 1996 Milwaukee Archbisop Rembert Weakland wrote a letter to then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now the Pope to let them hold a church trial against Father Lawrence Murphy who was accused of molesting some 200 boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:44 AM

Weakland: Sex Abuse Case Took Too Long in Vatican

MILWAUKEE (WI)
TMJ4

By Jay Sorgi
MILWAUKEE - We're finally hearing from retired Milwaukee Archbishop Rembert Weakland about the abusive priest case that is now connected to Rome.

"They certainly delayed a lot more than I would have liked," Weakland told the BBC regarding the two-year time between the point he wrote Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now-Pope Benedict XVI in 1996, and Fr. Lawrence Murphy's death in 1998.

Murphy admitted to committing sexual abuse against children, and allegedly did so up to 200 times while working at a deaf school in Milwaukee during the 1950's, 60's and 70's.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:42 AM

The pope comes up short

UNITED STATES
Merced Sun-Star

McClatchy-Tribune News Service
The following editorial appeared in the Los Angeles Times on Thursday, March 25:

Confronted by a cascade of new sexual abuse revelations, Pope Benedict XVI has issued a pastoral letter expressing "shame and remorse" for "sinful and criminal acts." Addressing Catholics in Ireland, where the hierarchy has been embarrassed by a government commission's report on widespread abuse, Benedict wrote that the bishops' response was "often inadequate" and that the crisis was aggravated by "a misplaced concern for the reputation of the church and the avoidance of scandal." Bishops, he said, should cooperate with "civil authorities in their areas of competence" - apparently a reference to law enforcement.

The pope's condemnation is completely appropriate. But just as important is what he left unsaid - and undone. He failed to say, for instance, that bishops in Ireland and elsewhere who have been found to have covered up abuse should leave their posts. It's bizarre that his letter was presented in St. Patrick's Cathedral in Armagh by Cardinal Sean Brady, the head of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland. Brady was present in 1975 when two children who had been abused by a priest were pressured to remain silent, supposedly so they wouldn't influence each other's accounts. Brady did not report the abuse to law enforcement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Report: Agreement Reached In Wilmington Diocese Bankruptcy Case

WILMINGTON (DE)
WBAL

Steve Fermier and Associated Press

Attorneys involved in the bankruptcy case of the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington say they are close to an agreement to mediate disputed issues.

Lawyers for the diocese, the official unsecured creditors' committee and abuse victims suing in state court say papers could be filed as early as Friday in U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.

The diocese, which serves about 230,000 Catholics in Delaware and the Eastern Shore of Maryland, filed for bankruptcy in October after settlement negotiations failed with about a dozen alleged victims of clergy sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:37 AM

John Fidler: Child abuse a moral problem that reaches around world

UNITED STATES
Reading Eagle

Recent world and national events remind us yet again of the horrendous way grown-ups treat children.

On Sunday, ABC News reported on the sex trafficking of children in Cambodia and the American evangelical Christians who are protecting them, not just from tourists but from their own mothers, who regularly sell their daughters into the maw of sexual degradation.

Cambodia endured a devastating genocide in the 1970s that claimed the lives of one-fifth of the population, about 1.7 million people. One pastor who runs a shelter for rescued kids said Cambodia suffers from a moral vacuum that makes it easy for mothers to sell their daughters, ABC News reported.

From Europe, yet another round of the sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests, this time in Germany, is generating headlines and outrage.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:33 AM

Victims accuse Pope of keeping abuser's secret

VATICAN CITY
Irish Independent

By Jerome Taylor

Friday March 26 2010

The Vatican was under renewed pressure last night to explain its handling of historical child abuse scandals after documents emerged showing that an office which was once headed up by Pope Benedict XVI decided not to defrock an American priest who been accused of abusing more than 200 deaf children.

Lawyers acting on behalf of victims in the United States released a series of letters yesterday from two Wisconsin bishops asking the Vatican for permission to press ahead with a church trial against Reverend Lawrence Murphy.

Many of the letters detailed correspondence between the bishops and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the influential Vatican body tasked with investigating abuse cases that was run by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger until he became pontiff in 2005.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:30 AM

Pope committed to eradication of abuse -- cardinal

VATICAN CITY
Irish Independent

By Nick Pisa

Friday March 26 2010

AN AUSTRALIAN cardinal who is tipped to lead the Vatican's "root and branch internal audit" of the Irish Catholic Church has defended the pope, saying: "No one should doubt Pope Benedict XVI's resolve to seeing abuse eradicated."

The comments of Cardinal George Pell, archbishop of Sydney, were reported in the Vatican's official newspaper, 'L'Osservatore Romano'.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:28 AM

'Victims' give details of priest's alleged abuse

WISCONSIN
Ireland Online

Former students of a US priest suspected of molesting up to 200 deaf boys have given details of his alleged offences against them.

Arthur Budzinski, now 61, was one of about 200 deaf boys at the St John’s School for the Deaf just outside Milwaukee.

The Vatican yesterday strongly defended its decision not to defrock Fr Lawrence Murphy and denounced what it called a campaign to smear Pope Benedict XVI and his aides.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

Cardinal Ratzinger acted powerfully against abusers, says Archbishop Vincent Nichols

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

Damian Thompson

At last – Archbishop Vincent Nichols, writing in The Times, has explained how far-reaching the former Cardinal Ratzinger’s reforms of Vatican procedures were after he took over responsibility for dealing with abuse allegations in 2001. More should have been done, and much earlier. But, although his record was not perfect, Ratzinger was part of the solution, not the problem. And we need to bear that in mind when we listen to commentators like the monumentally pompous ex-Jesuit Michael Walsh scoring points against their old enemy. Oh, and if anyone is under the impression that veteran BBC Rome correspondent David Willey doesn’t have an axe to grind, let me put you right on that one.

Here’s the quote from Archbishop Nichols. He may not be on quite the same liturgical wavelength as the Pope, but he can recognise a hit job when he sees one:

What of the role of Pope Benedict? When he was in charge of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith he led important changes made in church law: the inclusion in canon law of internet offences against children, the extension of child abuse offences to include the sexual abuse of all under 18, the case by case waiving of the statue of limitation and the establishment of a fast-track dismissal from the clerical state for offenders. He is not an idle observer. His actions speak as well as his words.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:20 AM

Sex-abuse scandal increases pressure on Vatican for more transparency

VATICAN CITY
The Denver Post

By Anthony Faiola and William Wan
The Washington Post

ROME — An escalating scandal over clerical sexual abuse in Europe is heightening calls for greater transparency in the Vatican and a zero-tolerance policy toward abusive priests that would mirror the approach already adopted by the U.S. Catholic Church.

The Vatican is confronting what observers describe as its gravest test in years, with officials fending off allegations that Pope Benedict XVI mismanaged abuse cases that occurred years before his ascension to the papacy in 2005.

No leading Catholic authority or organization has called on Benedict to take personal responsibility for the scandals, and Vatican watchers in Rome strongly maintained Thursday that there is no serious threat to the pope's position.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:16 AM

Pope May Be at Crossroads on Abuse, Forced to Reconcile Policy and Words

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By RACHEL DONADIO
Published: March 26, 2010

ROME — Even as Pope Benedict XVI, faced with a sexual abuse scandal spreading across Europe, has called on victims to come forward and urged clerics to cooperate with civil justice, those strong words are running up against the complexities of his past.

“He is at a crossroads,” said Marco Politi, a veteran Italian Vatican journalist. “What’s extraordinary is that the scandal has reached the heart of the center of the church. Up to now it was far away — in the States, in Canada, in Brazil, in Australia. Then it came to Europe, to Ireland.

“Then it came to his motherland,” Mr. Politi added of Benedict’s native Germany. “Then it came to his diocese, and now it’s coming to the heart of the government of the church — and he has to give an answer.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:13 AM

Wisconsin's Catholic child abuse anguish

WISCONSIN
BBC News

By Matthew Price
BBC News, Milwaukee

What must it feel like to have lost 50 years of your life? For that is what 61-year old Arthur Budzinski has endured.

Five long decades of personal pain.

And he has to rely on others to speak of his anguish.

It is made worse by the fact that no-one has been held to account for the sexual abuse he allegedly suffered as a child while at the Roman Catholic St John's School for the Deaf in St Francis, Wisconsin.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:10 AM

Inquiry into clerical child abuse 'almost inevitable'

NORTHERN IRELAND
UTV

A state inquiry into institutional and clerical child abuse in Northern Ireland is almost inevitable, government sources have said.

A major probe similar to those which uncovered a shocking litany of historic crimes in the Republic of Ireland was considered by ministers in Stormont's power-sharing cabinet yesterday afternoon.

Afterwards one senior source said ministers agreed that decisive action was required.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:07 AM

Father Shay on Pope's Pastoral Letter to Irish Catholics

IRELAND
Independent Catholic News

By: Fr Shay Cullen

Posted: Friday, March 26, 2010

Pope Benedict XVI has signed a letter to address child sex abuse in the Catholic church in Ireland. However, the document comes months after the initial cases were reported.

Pope Benedict, in a Pastoral Letter to the Irish church last 21 March, expressing deep compassion for victims of clerical sexual abuse of children said that he was 'truly sorry', and, expressing shame and remorse, gave a sincere apology to the victims. He castigated clerical child abusers, reprimanded bishops, gave words of comfort to parents, youth and the innocent religious and clergy and revealed a great weakness in the fabric of the institutional church namely a mistaken belief among some authority figures that power and privilege puts them above the law and gives them impunity.

The Holy Father wrote to the victims: "You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. I know that nothing can undo the wrong you have endured. Your trust has been betrayed and your dignity has been violated. Many of you found that, when you were courageous enough to speak of what happened to you, no one would listen. Those of you who were abused in residential institutions must have felt that there was no escape from your sufferings. It is understandable that you find it hard to forgive or be reconciled with the Church. In her name, I openly express the shame and remorse that we all feel..."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:04 AM

Church Withholds Comment On SNAP Visit

GUAM
Pacific News Center

[with video]

Guam - With a firestorm of controversy surrounding the Catholic Church on the international stage, little has been said by Guam's Archdiocese since the arrival of a SNAP representative here, who has been calling for some sort of acknowledgment that some clergy members here have committed acts of sexual abuse against island youth. Snap was established to aide victims of abuse at the hands of clergy members.

There has been no comment from the Arch Diocese of Agana on the visit by members of the support network for those abused by priest.

Southwest Regional Director Joelle Casteix arrived on Tuesday to establish a network system on Guam. During her visit also held a group meeting, and private one on one sessions. And while the turn out was not as she expected, Casteix did meet with mental health and other support organizations to set up venues for victims who need help.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:00 AM

Vatican Defends Pope Over U.S. Abuse Case as Protesters Are Detained

VATICAN CITY
The Wall Street Journal

By STACY MEICHTRY And JOE BARRETT
VATICAN CITY—The Vatican on Thursday defended Pope Benedict XVI’s handling of a sexual-abuse case involving a priest who allegedly molested hundreds of students decades ago at a Milwaukee school for the deaf.

In an unusually swift response to a New York Times article, the Vatican’s official newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano, published a front-page editorial, denouncing “the evident and ignoble intent to wound Benedict XVI and his closest advisers at any cost.”

Meanwhile, a group of Americans who say they were sexually abused by clerics staged a news conference outside St. Peter’s Square in Rome to denounce the pope’s handling of the case and gave reporters what they said were church and Vatican documents on the case, the Associated Press reported.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:57 AM

O'CONNOR ATTACKS POPE BENEDICT OVER CHURCH CHILD ABUSE APOLOGY

IRELAND
Express (United Kingdom)

Friday March 26,2010
Outspoken Irish star SINEAD O'CONNOR has taken aim at the POPE again over his recent apology to the people of Ireland for the child abuse they have been subjected to at the hands of Catholic priests.

The Nothing Compares 2 U singer, who famously ripped up a photo of the last Pope, John Paul II, during an appearance on U.S. TV show Saturday Night Live in 1992, is on the attack again, insisting Pope Benedict XVI's 'pastoral apology' on behalf of the Roman Catholic Church is too little, too late.

In an exclusive interview with the Los Angeles Times newspaper, the angry mother-of-four, who was among the first celebrities to tackle the issue of abuse within the church, rages, "He (Pope) starts by saying that he's writing with great concern for the people of Ireland. If he was that concerned, why has it taken him 23 years to write a letter, and why did he or the last pope never get on an airplane and come to meet the victims... and apologise?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:55 AM

Sex Abuse Scandals Threaten to Taint Papacy

VATICAN CITY
Fox News

VATICAN CITY -- Revelations that the Vatican halted the investigation of a Wisconsin priest accused of molesting some 200 deaf boys have eerie echoes in Italy, where 67 deaf men and women accused two dozen priests of raping and molesting children for years.

Only now -- a year after the Italian case became public -- is the Vatican directing the diocese to interview the victims to hear their testimony about the accusations, The Associated Press learned Thursday.

The two cases are the latest in a burgeoning abuse scandal on both sides of the Atlantic that now threatens to tarnish the papacy itself. The office charged with disciplining clergy was long led by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, and a church prosecution in the Wisconsin case was stopped after an appeal to Ratzinger.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:52 AM

New Clergy Scandal Raises Questions In Old Cases

BOSTON (MA)
WBUR

By DEBORAH BECKER

Published March 25, 2010

BOSTON — The Catholic clergy abuse scandal erupting across Europe is focusing new attention on the abuse crisis that broke open in Boston in 2002. There are many viewpoints about what may have changed since then, but one recent case raises questions about the legal handling of abuse complaints.

Since the scandal exploded here, an estimated 207 priests from the Boston Archdiocese have been accused of abusing children. More than 95 percent of the cases ended in a civil settlement.

Attorney Mitchell Garabedian has represented hundreds of victims and says the way the church handles abuse cases hasn’t really changed.

“They’re following canon law, they’ve circled the wagons, and as far as they’re concerned, attorneys are a bunch of ambulance chasers,” Garabedian said. “And so what if the church has few pedophile priests in their ranks? All corporations do.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:49 AM

Bishop Walsh was involved in two Dublin diocese investigations

IRELAND
The Nenagh Guardian

By Gerry Slevin
Welcoming the Pastoral Letter which Pope Benedict XVI addressed to the people of Ireland at the weekend, Killaloe diocesan prelate Bishop Willie Walsh reveals this week that on two occasions prior to his appointment as bishop in 1994, he was asked by the then Archbishop of Dublin to act as one of three judges in a canonical process involving allegations of sexual abuse against two priests of that diocese.

He states that in response to the request of the Pope “to establish the truth of what has happened in the past” and the many requests he has received from journalists in recent days he wishes to “clarify my own story in relation to some of these issues”.

In the first case, the bishop states, that of William Carney, their judgement was that the most severe penalty in Church law namely laicization or expulsion from priesthood be applied.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:46 AM

Victims demand files be opened

VATICAN CITY
The Daily Observer (Canada)

Posted By PHILIP PULLELLA, REUTERS

Victims of sexual abuse by priests demonstrated at the Vatican on Thursday, demanding that Pope Benedict open up files on pedophile Catholic clerics worldwide and immediately defrock all "predator priests".

The demonstration came as a leading cardinal denounced what he called a "conspiracy" to discredit the Catholic Church and said he could understand why some bishops hushed up cases of pedophilia so as not to harm the Church's good name.

Four leaders of the U.S.-based Survivor Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), all of whom were sexually abused by priests, including being raped, held up photos of themselves as children and signs reading "Stop the Secrecy Now".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:42 AM

Cardinal Seán Brady urged to withdraw evidence in abuse court case

IRELAND
The Times (United Kingdom)

David Sharrock, Ireland Correspondent

The leader of Ireland’s Catholics, Cardinal Seán Brady, has been urged to withdraw his defence in a legal battle with one of the alleged victims of a paedophile priest.

The solicitor for the alleged victim of Father Brendan Smyth, a man who was 14 in 1975, said that he was “incredulous” at Cardinal Brady’s recent expressions of remorse given the primate’s defence in the legal proceedings.

The man is suing Cardinal Brady in the cardinal’s capacity as Archbishop of Armagh. He says he was an altar boy in Dundalk in the early 70s when Smyth sexually assaulted him in church, on a children’s holiday in County Cork and during a trip to Dublin for a Wombles concert.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:39 AM

Archbishop comes to pope’s defense

VATICAN CITY
MSBNC

[with video]

VATICAN CITY - A leading archbishop and Vatican officials defended the pope on Friday, amid increasing allegations that top members of the church hierarchy protected pedophile priests at the expense of those they abused.

While acknowledging that past child abuse and its concealment by the church was "deeply shocking and totally unacceptable," the Archbishop of Westminster Vincent Nichols defended Pope Benedict XVI in an article in London's Times newspaper.

"He is not an idle observer. His actions speak as well as his words," wrote Nichols, who is head of the Catholic church in England and Wales.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:36 AM

'Fresh Questions' About Future Pope's Handling Of Abuse Case, 'NYT' Says

NPR (United States)

By Mark Memmott

"The future Pope Benedict XVI was kept more closely apprised of a sexual abuse case in Germany than previous church statements have suggested," The New York Times reports this morning, "raising fresh questions about his handling of a scandal unfolding under his direct supervision before he rose to the top of the church's hierarchy."

According to the Times, then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (now the pope) "was copied on a memo that informed him that a priest, whom he had approved sending to therapy in 1980 to overcome pedophilia, would be returned to pastoral work within days of beginning psychiatric treatment. The priest was later convicted of molesting boys in another parish." Previously, the church had said a deputy to Ratzinger had made the decision to return the priest to his duties.

Church officials question whether the memo actually made it to Ratzinger's desk.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:32 AM

March 25, 2010

Vatican chooses pragmatism over principle

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

Mathew N. Schmalz

The recent revelations of documents related to the case of the late Father Lawrence Murphy have brought the sexual abuse crisis to a new level of urgency. According to the documents, as reported by The New York Times, Father Murphy abused hundreds of children and adolescents entrusted to his care. In correspondence relating to the case, Bishop Raphael Fliss of Superior, Wisc., described the situation as "tragic." "Tragic" is an adjective originally reserved for literary and dramatic works that offer deep reflections on the sorrowful aspects of human existence. While the Murphy case does have its tragic dimensions for Catholicism as a whole, its specifics hardly lend themselves to lofty, abstract considerations. Instead, the case is about the calculated efforts of a sexual predator to use his position of priestly authority to continue a pattern of sexual abuse. The case also reveals an ecclesiastic calculus that valued pragmatism over principle.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:53 PM

Executive likely to set up inquiry

IRELAND
The Irish Times

GERRY MORIARTY Northern Editor

THE NORTH: THE NORTHERN Executive is almost certain to set up an inquiry into institutional and clerical child abuse, according to Stormont sources.

Stormont Ministers are primed to establish an inquiry to examine the extent of child abuse in Northern Ireland following the disclosures about sex abuse by Catholic clergy on both sides of the Border, the sources said last night.

Minister of Health Michael McGimpsey has prepared for the Executive a range of options on how the issue of child abuse might be addressed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 PM

Priest asks bishop to move cleric accused of sex abuse

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Irish Times

GEORGE JACKSON

STRABANE CASE: A PARISH priest said yesterday that the continued presence of another priest in his parochial house was “inappropriate”.

Fr Declan Boland, parish priest of Strabane, Co Tyrone, said he wants Fr John McCullagh removed from the Church of the Immaculate Conception parochial house after child sex abuse allegations made against Fr McCullagh.

Fr McCullagh, who was neither charged nor convicted of any sex abuse offence, was relieved of all clerical duties after he paid a private settlement of £12,000 to a woman who alleged he had sexually abused her over a 10-year period starting in 1979. In paying the woman, Fr McCullagh did so without admitting liability and he has always denied the allegation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:44 PM

Request for Magdalene records to be released

IRELAND
The Irish Times

EITHNE DONNELLAN

VICTIMS: THE RELIGIOUS congregations which operated Magdalene laundries will be asked by the Government at a forthcoming meeting to consider releasing records for all women and children who entered their laundries after January 1900.

Minister for Health Mary Harney assured the Justice for Magdalenes (JFM) group yesterday that the matter would be raised with the religious orders, which are due to meet the Government again soon to discuss their financial contribution to victims in the aftermath of the Ryan report.

The JFM group, which is seeking an apology for the way women were treated in the laundries as well as a redress scheme, said its meeting with Ms Harney yesterday was a positive one.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:41 PM

Gardaí to resubmit altar boy abuse file

IRELAND
The Irish Times

BARRY ROCHE Southern Correspondent

CLOYNE: GARDAÍ ARE to resubmit a file to the DPP after re-interviewing an elderly priest in the Diocese of Cloyne concerning a complaint he sexually assaulted another priest when the younger man was an altar boy more than 20 years ago.

Detectives met the elderly priest earlier this week and interviewed him at length after they obtained further information from diocesan files which had been handed over by Bishop John Magee to the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church (NBSCC).

The priest, identified as Fr A in the report prepared by Ian Elliot, chief executive of the NBSCC, had previously been interviewed by gardaí in 2006 and a file had been sent to the DPP but the DPP had directed there be no prosecution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 PM

Statement Of Bishop William Lee

IRELAND
The Irish Times

‘i Satisfied Myself With Regard To The Supports Then Available To The Complainants’

In December 1993, a few months after my ordination as Bishop of Waterford Lismore, I received complaints of child sexual abuse against a priest of the Diocese. This was the first case of such a nature that I had ever dealt with.

Between December 1993 and 1994, I met personally with the complainants. I heard their complaints, without the administration of any form of oath, about events years earlier from their childhoods. I satisfied myself with regard to the supports then available to the complainants.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:36 PM

Bishop took two years to tell Garda of sex claim

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY Religious Affairs Correspondent

BISHOP OF WATERFORD AND LISMORE: CATHOLIC BISHOP of Waterford and Lismore William Lee said yesterday the Garda was not contacted by him for two years after he became aware of allegations of child sex abuse against a priest in the diocese, and that the priest was not removed from ministry for three years after he became aware of those complaints.

Last December he said that child protection policies in the diocese were “based on the practice of full co-operation with the statutory authorities”.

Yesterday, he described his own handling of the allegations of clerical child sex abuse in the diocese between 1993 and 1996 as “seriously inadequate”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:33 PM

Former priest cleared of child porn charges

FLORIDA
WPTV

[with video]

INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FL -- It's a Spartan existence for Gerry Lamothe.

A friend has given him a small space in an unmarked office under renovation. But it's a start for this 61 year-old father of eleven.

"It was a pretty big hit going from a child advocate, to being accused of child pornography," said Lamothe.

On Valentine's Day 2009, Lamothe was called to his office by police in the middle of the night after pornographic images were found on his computer monitor.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:03 PM

Ex-S.F. Arhcbishop Given 10-1 Odds Becoming Next Pope

CALIFORNIA
SF Weekly

By Matt Smith, Thursday, Mar. 25 2010

What are the odds?

​The Irish bookie site Paddypower is laying down 3-to-1 odds Pope Benedict XVI will be ousted over accusations that he was behind misdeeds such as helping shield a priest who purportedly raped hundreds of deaf boys. But when God shuts a door, he opens a window -- and if a Pope is canned over a molestation scandal, he's got to be replaced. And Paddypower is giving former San Francisco archbishop William Levada a decent enough 10-1 shot of becoming the next pontiff.

And if protecting priests accused of child rape is an attribute befitting the vicar of Christ, Levada would seem like a natural for the papal gig.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:01 PM

New Evidence Paints Horrific Picture Of Vatican!

UNITED STATES
Perez Hilton

New files pertaining to the Vatican were unveiled yesterday exposing certain members of the Catholic Church as two-faced hypocrites. Apparently, there is documentation revealing the Vatican's decision to allow a priest to remain at his post after it was confirmed he molested as many as 200 deaf boys!

In 1996, Milwaukee's archbishop contacted the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which decides the fate of accused priests, about Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy, who was working at a renowned school for deaf children and was being charged with molesting his students. A secret canonical trial was in the midst of being set up when the good Reverend personally wrote to the Cardinal in charge, insisting that he should not be put on trial because "he had already repented and was in poor health and that the case was beyond the church’s own statute of limitations."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:57 PM

Rev Lawrence Murphy’s paedophilia ‘as widely known, but ignored’

UNITED STATES
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome

The emotional scars remain years later for victims of Father Lawrence Murphy, a priest who molested generations of youngsters in the US Midwest state of Wisconsin. Donald Marshall, who was abused by Murphy when he was a teenager at a juvenile detention centre, said: “I haven’t stepped in a church for some 20 years. I lost all faith in the Church.”

Arthur Budzinski was abused at a school for the deaf in the city of St Francis, in the Milwaukee Diocese. Murphy taught at the school from 1950 to 1974, and even became director , despite the allegations.

Mr Budzinski said the priest would come to their dormitory at night and molest the deaf pupils. He was first molested by Murphy when he was 12, and was deceived by his “friendliness”. “If he was a real mean guy, I would have stayed away,” said Mr Budzinski, using sign language interpreted by his daughter. “But he was so friendly, and so nice ... I knew he was wrong, but I couldn’t really believe it.” One of the lawyers involved in the case said: “Instead of removing him from the priesthood, they just gave him a free pass.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:54 PM

Pope Benedict XVI must declare his own guilt in sex abuse cover-up

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen: commentary

To the outside world, it may look as if it is only a matter of time before the scandal engulfing the Church brings the pontificate of Benedict XVI crashing down.

But that is not how it looks in the Vatican, which marks time in centuries, not mere weeks, months or even years. The last Pope to step down voluntarily was Celestine V, in 1294 — and he was a mountain hermit who agreed only reluctantly to be Pope in the first place.

The Vatican view is that Pope Benedict is tackling the crisis vigorously, courageously and effectively. His pastoral letter to the Irish bishops was “unprecedented” and only issued after long reflection following his meeting with the bishops in Rome last month.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:51 PM

The Church is not trying to cover anything up

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Vincent Nichols

The child abuse committed within the Roman Catholic Church and its concealment is deeply shocking and totally unacceptable. I am ashamed of what happened, and understand the outrage and anger it has provoked.

That shame and anger centres on the damage done to every single abused child. Abuse damages, often irrevocably, a child’s ability to trust another, to fashion stable relationships, to sustain self-esteem. When it is inflicted within a religious context, it damages that child’s relationship to God. Today, not for the first time, I express my unreserved shame and sorrow for what has happened to many in the Church.

My shame is compounded, as is the anger of many, at the mistaken judgments made within the Church: that reassurance from a suspect could be believed; that credible allegations were deemed to be “unbelievable”; that the reputation of the Church mattered more than safeguarding children. These wrong reactions arise whenever and wherever allegations of abuse are made, whether within a family or a Church. We have to insist that the safety of the child comes first because the child is powerless.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:48 PM

Shame, shock and suffering ‘that will last for generations’

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ruth Gledhill, Religion Correspondent

The Archbishop of Westminster has described the child abuse committed within the Roman Catholic Church and its concealment as “deeply shocking and totally unacceptable”.

Writing in The Times today , the Most Rev Vincent Nichols admits serious mistakes have been made within the Church. “I am ashamed of what happened, and understand the outrage and anger it has provoked,” he said.

His comments come as some of the country’s leading lay Catholics predicted it would take generations for the Church to recover from the scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 PM

PEDOFILIA: VITTIME A S.PIETRO,2 ORE ALLA POLIZIA MA NON SAPEVAMO PERCHE'

ROME
ASCA

(ASCA) - Citta' del Vaticano, 25 mar - Sono state trattenute per due ore nel Commissariato di polizia di Borgo, vicino al Vaticano, le quattro vittime di abusi sessuali da parte di preti dell'associazione Snap (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests) che questa mattina hanno improvvisato una conferenza stampa a Piazza Pio XII, di fronte Piazza San Pietro. ''Alla fine - ha spiegato Barbara Dorris - ci hanno detto che siamo stati fermati perche' avevamo fatto una 'conferenza stampa non autorizzata''' ma ''per due ore non siamo riusciti a sapere perche' ci trattenessero''. ''Ci hanno confiscato le foto e i cartelli che avevamo e non ci lasciavano telefonare'', aggiunge, ''finche' non siamo riusciti a mandare un messaggio e qualcuno ha avvertito l'ambasciata'' Usa a Roma.

[summary]

Four American victims of sexual abuse by priests who are members of the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, were detained two hours in the Borgo police station, located near the Vatican. They held an impromptu press conference at Piazza Pio XII in front of Piazza San Pietro. Barbara Dorris said they were stopped because they held an unauthorized press conference.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:35 PM

Preti pedofili, polizia al presidio vittime Usa in quattro portati via per accertamenti

ROME
la Repubblica

La polizia ha intererotto una piccola manifestazione dell'Associazione di vittime americane di preti pedofili Snap che si stava svolgendo in piazza Pio XII a Roma di fronte al Colonnato di Piazza San Pietro.

I quattro rappresentanti dell'Associazione, due donne e due uomini, che stavano parlando con i giornalisti dopo le rivelazioni del New York Times sui silenzi dell'allora cardinale Joseph Ratzinger su un caso di abusi su centinaia di bambini nel Wisconsin, sono stati portati via nelle auto della polizia per accertamenti. Subito prima gli agenti avevano chiesto loro i passaporti. La presidente di Snap, Barbara Blaine, ha chiesto più volte in inglese: "Ho fatto qualcosa di male?". E' andata via visibilmente turbata chiedendo ai fotografi presenti di riprendere le immagini di quanto stava accadendo.

[summary]

Police interrupted a small demonstration held by American victims of pedophile priests that was taking place in Piazza Pio XII in Rome in front of the Colonnade of St. Peter's Square.

The four representives, two women and two men, were speaking to reporters after revelations in the New York Times on the silence of then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger on the case of abuse of hundreds of children in Wisconsin. They were taken away in the police car for questioning and just before police asked for their passports. President of SNAP, Barbara Blaine, asked repeatedly in English, "I've done something wrong?" Visibly disturbed, she asked photographers present to take pictures of what was happening.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:24 PM

Sexual abuse lawsuit against diocese continues

BROWNSVILLE (TX)
The Monitor

March 24, 2010
Allen Essex
Valley Morning Star
BROWNSVILLE — A judge on Wednesday denied a motion by plaintiffs seeking summary judgment in a long-running lawsuit against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brownsville over allegations of sexual abuse of parochial school students.

Manuel Ortiz Muñoz has been accused of molesting three boys from one family and one boy from another family in 2004 at St. Anthony School, where Ortiz was a janitor.

The motion denied Wednesday claimed the diocese does not have enough insurance to pay claims by the two families.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:18 PM

Another bishop 'sorry' over claims

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Thursday March 25 2010

Another Irish bishop has apologised for failing to properly deal with allegations of child abuse against a priest.

Bishop of Waterford and Lismore Dr William Lee, who waited two years in the mid-1990s before telling gardai about complaints from two people, said his handling of accusations was seriously inadequate.

"I sincerely apologise and am deeply sorry for the inadequacies of my earlier actions in this case," the bishop said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:16 PM

Blow for Brady as Vatican accepts Magee resignation

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney and Ralph Riegel

Thursday March 25 2010

EMBATTLED Cardinal Sean Brady's battle to survive as head of the Catholic Church in Ireland has received a major blow after the Pope accepted the resignation of the disgraced Bishop of Cloyne.

Bishop John Magee yesterday became the first victim of Pope Benedict's clampdown on the Irish hierarchy since his scathing criticism of how they mishandled abuse by paedophile clerics.

Dr Magee (73), a former private secretary to three popes and the most prominent casualty so far of the church abuse scandals, stepped down in March last year after an independent report found that his diocese put children at risk.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:13 PM

Genesis of a Crime. The Revolution of the 1960's

VATICAN CITY
Chiesa

by Sandro Magister

ROME, March 25, 2010 – Law and grace. Where earthly justice does not reach, the hand of God can. With his letter dated March 19, Benedict XVI has given the Catholics of Ireland an order never before given by a pope of the modern era to an entire national Church.

He told them not only to bring the guilty before the canonical and civil courts, but to put themselves collectively in a state of penance and purification. And not in the privacy of their consciences, but in a public form, before the eyes of all, even of their most implacable and mocking adversaries. Fasting, prayer, reading the Bible, and works of charity on all the Fridays from now until Easter of next year. Frequent sacramental confession. Continual adoration of Jesus – " himself a victim of injustice and sin" – present in the sacred host, exposed on the altars of the churches. And for all the bishops, priests, and religious, without exception, a special period of "mission," a long and strict course of spiritual exercises for a radical review of life.

It's a daring step, this one taken by Pope Benedict. Because not even the prophet Jonah believed any longer that God would forgive Nineveh its sins, in spite of the penitential ashes and sackcloth worn by all, from the king to the lowliest beast of burden.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:10 PM

The Fallibility of the Infallible Pope

Spiegel (Germany)

By Peter Wensierski

Allegations that Pope Benedict XVI may have had detailed knowledge about instances of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church continue to mount. In 1996, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which he then led, decided not to punish the pedophile priest Father Lawrence Murphy. With his authority eroded, why does he even remain in office?

When is it time for a pope to resign? Margaret Kässmann, the former head of the Protestant Church in Germany, stepped down in February upon deciding that she no longer had the necessary moral authority for her office after being caught driving drunk. But how much authority does Pope Benedict XVI still enjoy?

These days, what is left is disappearing almost daily. Each new detail about the role he played in his church's handling of instances of sexual abuse erodes it further. But a pope doesn't just resign. He is not the CEO of a company, not the head of a political party -- he is the direct spiritual descendent of the Apostle Peter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:05 PM

Don't bet on abuse scandal toppling the pope

UNITED STATES
Salon

By Mary Ann Sorrentino

A quarter-century ago -- at a time when about 10 priests in Rhode Island had already been accused of sexually abusing children -- the Roman Catholic Diocese of Providence tried to stop my then-14-year-old daughter from making her confirmation because of her mother's work with Planned Parenthood. When that conversation took place in our pastor's office (and was taped by me), I was also told not to come to the rail, since I'd been excommunicated for that work.

My reply?

"Let me understand this, Father. Because of my work with women at Planned Parenthood, you don't want me to come to the rail and take communion from the hands of a man who sexually abuses children? Is that what you're telling me, Father?"

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:02 PM

After Milwaukee Abuse Revelation, the Vatican Fires Back

VATICAN CITY
TIME

By Jeff Israely

The news has been relentlessly bad for the Pope. Two weeks ago, Germany was scandalized by revelations that a pedophile priest was allowed to work again with children after being transferred in 1980 to the Archdiocese of Munich, which was then headed by the future Pontiff. Over the weekend, an apology the Pope issued for sexual abuse by Irish priests was deemed insufficient by many of the victims. Now the New York Times has run an article accusing Pope Benedict XVI, who as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was head of the Vatican's doctrinal office, of not responding to requests in 1996 from the Archbishop of Milwaukee to have a priest stripped of his clerical status for alleged sexual abuse of some 200 deaf boys decades before.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:58 PM

Former New York coach indicted on charges he raped boy during '76 Boston visit

MASSACHUSETTS
Boston Globe

March 25, 2010
By Shelley Murphy, Globe Staff

A former standout New York City high school basketball coach was indicted today on charges that he raped a 14-year-old boy twice during a visit to Boston in the summer of 1976 to attend a Red Sox-Yankees double-header at Fenway Park.

Bob Oliva, the longtime coach for the powerhouse basketball team at Christ the King Regional High School in Queens, was indicted by a Suffolk County grand jury on two counts of rape of a child, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison, and one count of disseminating pornography to a minor. The incidents allegedly occurred at a Boston hotel, where Oliva and the boy were staying between July 31 and Aug. 1, 1976, according to the Suffolk district attorney's office.

Oliva, 65, who retired from coaching last year and lives in New York, has not been arrested. He is expected to be summonsed to court to face the charges, according to his Boston attorney, Michael J. Doolin.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:56 PM

Former Christ the King coach Bob Oliva indicted on two counts of child rape by Mass. grand jury

MASSACHUSETTS
New York Daily News

By Michael O'Keeffe
DAILY NEWS SPORTS WRITER

Bob Oliva, the legendary Christ the King Regional High School boy's basketball coach who resigned last year amid sex abuse allegations, was indicted on Thursday by a Massachusetts grand jury on two counts of rape of a child.

If convicted, Oliva could spend the rest of his life in prison.

The grand jury also indicted Oliva on one count of disseminating pornography to a minor, said Jake Wark, a spokesman for Suffolk County (Mass.) District Attorney Daniel F. Conley. The maximum penalty for that charge is five years in prison.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:52 PM

NSAC: NEW YORK TIMES STORY REVELATIONS STUNNING

UNITED STATES
Voice from the Desert

“Stunning,” the National Survivor Advocates Coalition (NSAC) called the revelations in today’s New York Times story regaridng the involvement and attitude of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger now Pope Benedict in the case of Wisconsin priest, Father Lawrence Murphy.

“We join our voice with the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests (SNAP) and call for a total and complete release of the documents of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith from 2001-2005 showing the involvement and attitude of Pope Benedict (then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger) in clergy sexual abuse cases, ” the coalition said.

“It is now clear,” the coalition said, ‘” the Church, directly in the person of Cardinal Joseph Ratizinger who rose to the position of Pope, cared more for the Church’s reputation and its clergy than the innocent and vulnerable entrusted to its care.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:49 PM

Pope accused of sparing priest suspected of sex abuse attacks

VATICAN CITY
Guardian (United Kingdom)

John Hooper in Rome guardian.co.uk, Thursday 25 March 2010

The growing sex abuse storm buffeting the Catholic church todaymoved closer to the figure of the pope himself, after allegations emerged that as a cardinal he had chosen not to discipline a dying American priest accused of molesting as many as 200 deaf boys.

In a report that for the first time pointed the finger directly at the pope's own conduct, the New York Times said that while he was cardinal, Joseph Ratzinger was twice informed about a notorious case involving Father Lawrence Murphy, who ran a school for deaf children in Wisconsin between 1950 and 1974. Though instructions were giving for a canonical trial to be held into Murphy's misdeeds, proceedings were dropped after the priest wrote to Ratzinger begging not to be indicted.

The Vatican angrily denounced the latest accusation in what it sees as a campaign to smear the pope, and said the church was being unfairly portrayed as the only institution with such a sinister history.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:46 PM

Clerical child abuse inquiry in North 'almost inevitable'

NORTHERN IRELAND
Ireland Online

A state inquiry into institutional and clerical child abuse in the North is almost inevitable, government sources said tonight.

A major probe similar to those which uncovered a shocking litany of historic crimes in the Republic was considered by ministers in Stormont’s power-sharing Cabinet this afternoon.

Afterwards one senior source said ministers agreed that decisive action was required.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:42 PM

Stormont signals abuse inquiry

NORTHERN IRELAND
RTE News

Thursday, 25 March 2010
Northern Ireland's power-sharing administration has moved a step closer to setting up an inquiry into child sex abuse.

The issue was discussed at today's meeting of the Stormont executive. Northern Health Minister Michael Mc Gimpsey and his colleagues were unanimous in their view that decisive action is required to address public concerns.


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:40 PM

Assembly calls for abuse inquiry

NORTHERN IRELAND
BBC News

The Stormont Health Committee has agreed the only way forward in pursuing the full extent of child sex abuse in NI is a public inquiry.

It was responding to the Health Minister's options paper, issued last week, which discussed various ways of examining crimes against children.

Health committee chair, Jim Wells, said nothing less than a public inquiry would do.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:37 PM

Irish priest awaiting extradition on abuse charge was removed from Minn. pulpit in '82

MINNESOTA
Fox 59

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — An official in the New Ulm Roman Catholic diocese says an Irish priest facing extradition over sexual abuse allegations was removed from a Granite Falls church in 1982 after parents complained he was "overly affectionate" with boys.

The Rev. Douglas Grams is vicar general in New Ulm. He said Thursday that the Rev. Francis Markey filled in at St. Andrew in Granite Falls for about three months ending in June 1982. Grams says after the complaints, the diocese sent Markey to a church-run treatment center in New Mexico and did not deal with him again.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:34 PM

Latest priest sex abuse scandal heats up responsibility debate

Deutsche Welle

As the latest sexual abuse scandal in the Catholic Church gets uncomfortably close to the pope, questions of punishment versus apology in dealing with pedophile priests have once again emerged.

The Church says the only way to face the burgeoning numbers of accusations is with complete honesty - and by urging victims to take legal action. Meanwhile, activists say the Church should take more responsibility for its wayward leaders.

Either way, the situation surrounding sexual abuse scandals in the Catholic Church is like a modern-day Hydra myth - no sooner is one scandal addressed than another rises up to take its place. With Europe's Catholics still reeling from a series of alleged child-molestation cover-ups, news broke in the US of a 1996 case that touches the upper echelons of Church power.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:31 PM

Basketball coach indicted on sexual abuse from 1976

BOSTON (MA)
My Fox Boston

BOSTON - It was announced today that a former New York school basketball coach has been indicted for sexually assaulting a young player on a trip more than 30 years ago.

Robert Oliva, 65, was indicted on two counts of rape of a child and one count of disseminating pornography to a minor.

The assault occurred on a trip to Boston in 1976 at the Sheraton Boston Hotel. Prosecutors allege that Oliva sexually assaulted the boy and showed him pornography.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:29 PM

From Hurting, to Healing, to Helping: An Interview with Elaina Kroll, Founder of The Innocence Mission

UNITED STATES
Healing and Spirituality

Dr. Jaime Romo

JR: You’re the founder of an organization called, The Innocence Mission. What is the Innocence Mission and how did you develop its focus?

EK: The Innocence Mission is an organization that is dedicated to the eradication of child sexual abuse (CSA) throughout our society. I became committed to this cause after my own perpetrator pled guilty for his crime, and I realized just how rare of an opportunity this is for victims. I also became abhorred at the many instances of abuse and other’s stories I regularly found being shared with me. The pervasiveness of the problem is what ultimately made me decide that something needed to be done to start to address these issues.

JR: You were a lifetime Catholic, and very involved in parish life. When you reported your abuse, what reactions did you get from others?

EK: Wow… well, it definitely wasn’t the pastoral reaction I would have expected from the many that I knew through parish life. In fact, I really didn’t get much reaction at all. They seemed to be handling it almost in a state of denial, which is another reason I feel so passionately about making sure that The Innocence Mission becomes an organization that reaches out to and supports survivors of CSA.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:27 PM

What has the abuse scandal done to you as a Catholic?

Connect the World

The Catholic Church is continuing to deal with allegations that members of its clergy were involved in child abuse cases stretching back nearly 20 years.

Hundreds of allegations of abuse of children by Catholic clergy have come to light in places like Germany, Austria and the Netherlands so far this year.

Ireland has also been badly shaken by widespread reports of child abuse, physical and sexual, by Catholic clergy going back at least seven decades.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:22 PM

Victims of Abuse by Clergy Demand Answers from Vatican

WISCONSIN
Milwaukee Public Radio

By Ann-Elise Henzl
March 25, 2010 | WUWM | Milwaukee, WI

A Catholic priest, Lawrence Murphy, taught at a school for deaf boys in St. Francis from the 1950s to the 1970s. He's accused of molesting as many as 200 children.

According to newly released documents, Wisconsin bishops urged the Vatican to permit a church trial against the priest in the 1990s. However, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict, prevented a trial from moving forward. He was head of the Vatican office that investigates abuse cases.

Mark Salmon is with the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. He says he wants answers from the Vatican.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:20 PM

U.S. Victims Protesting Outside Of Vatican Taken Away By Police

VATICAN CITY
digtriad

Kelly Heffernan-Tabor

Vatican City, Vatican -- American victims of abuse by clergy were taken away by police as they protested outside the Vatican about the handling of sexual abuse cases.

Peter Isely, of SNAP, the Survivors Network of Abuse by Priests was giving an emotional statement on how the Vatican had sought to move criminal evidence relating to abuse cases in diplomatic pouches, affectively hiding information from local authorities.

Isely cited the most recent case of pedophilia to explode into the media, that of Father Murphy, head of a school in Milwaukee, Wisconsin and accused of assaulting some 200 children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:14 PM

Pope accused of covering up US priest's abuse of 200 deaf boys

VATICAN CITY
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

By Nick Squires in Rome

The Pope is facing accusations he was personally involved in covering up child sex abuse by failing to take act against an American priest who molested up to 200 boys at a deaf school.

The allegations centre on the Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy who has been accused of abusing children in Wisconsin, where he worked from 1950 to 1974.

The Pope was alerted to the claims in 1996, when as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger he was the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican's department for dealing with particularly grave sins.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:10 PM

Protest at priests’ abuse reaches Vatican steps

ROME
Financial Times

By Guy Dinmore in Rome

The spreading scandal of sexual abuse by Roman Catholic priests reached the doorsteps of the Vatican on Thursday when four US victims held a demonstration to demand that Pope Benedict XVI take action against paedophile clerics and reveal the role he had played in the Church’s alleged cover-up.

Two men and two women representing the US-based Survivor Network of those Abused by Priests handed out leaflets near St Peter’s Square before being detained by Italian police. They were later released.

Barbara Blaine, president of SNAP, called on Pope Benedict to open up the files of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican department that handles cases of child abuse and was headed by the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger from 1981 until he became pontiff in 2005.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:08 PM

Pope knew about US deaf school predator priest, victim says

WISCONSIN
AFP

ST FRANCIS, Milwaukee — A US man claiming he was abused by a predator priest accused of molesting scores of deaf boys said Thursday Pope Benedict XVI knew about the latest sex scandal to rock the church and should be held accountable for it.

"The pope knew about this. He should be held accountable," Arthur Budzinski said outside the Archdiocese of Milwaukee after a New York Times report said Vatican officials, including the future pope, failed to act on warnings that Father Lawrence Murphy was abusing boys at a school for the deaf here.

Murphy is believed to have molested as many as 200 boys at St John's School for the Deaf in Wisconsin between 1950 and 1974.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:05 PM

The Pope and the Murphy case: what the New York Times story didn't tell you

UNITED STATES
Catholic Culture

By Phil Lawler | March 25, 2010

Today's front-page story in the New York Times suggests that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), under the direction of then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, failed to act against a Wisconsin priest who was accused of molesting scores of boys at a school for the deaf.

Is the story damaging? Yes. Should the Vatican have acted faster? Yes. Should the accused priest have been laicized? In all probability, Yes again.

Nevertheless, before assigning all blame to the Vatican, consider these factors:

1. The allegations of abuse by Father Lawrence Murphy began in 1955 and continued in 1974, according to the Times account. The Vatican was first notified in 1996: 40 years after Church officials in Wisconsin were first made aware of the problem. Local Church leaders could have taken action in the 1950s. They didn't.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:02 PM

Vatican abuse protesters arrested

ROME
The Press Association

Four victims of Catholic priest sex abuse have been held by Italian police after demonstrating outside the Vatican.

The group of Americans had demanded the pope release all files on paedophile clergy worldwide and sack the guilty.

The four, leaders of the Survivor Network of those Abused by Priests, held up pictures of themselves as children and signs reading "Stop the Secrecy Now".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:59 PM

The Pope and the Wisconsin sex abuse scandal: I smell a stitch-up

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Damian Thompson

In the early 1990s, when I was religious affairs correspondent of The Daily Telegraph, I reported on the American Catholic Church’s terrible failure to address allegations of child abuse. I think I was one of the first journalists in Britain to write about the way pervert priests were being shuffled around US parishes by bishops. So don’t accuse me of being an apologist for the culture of secrecy and cowardice that enabled wicked men to go unpunished.

But something smells fishy about today’s New York Times story implying that Pope Benedict XVI was complicit in the cover-up surrounding the crimes of a Wisconsin priest, Fr Lawrence Murphy, who abused children at a school for the deaf between 1950 and 1974.

Murphy? Guilty as hell. Various bishops? Likewise. But the fact that in 1996 Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger may have approved the decision not to pursue complex canonical procedures against Murphy on the grounds that the guy was dying anyway doesn’t strike me as much of a smoking gun.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:56 PM

'Scandal hidden in secret vaults'

UNITED STATES
Al Jazeera

By Kathleen McCaul

Jeff Anderson is one of two lawyers representing five men in the US who have brought lawsuits against the Archdiocese of Milwaukee for failing to take action over cases of alleged child abuse in the church.

The case involves a number of documents including internal correspondence between bishops and the Vatican that claim to show Pope Benedict XVI, then a cardinal, failed to respond to letters warning him about a priest who may have molested 200 deaf boys.

According to media reports, an eventual church trial of the priest, Lawrence Murphy, was stopped due to his poor health.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:52 PM

Vatican says media in "ignoble attempt" to smear pope

VATICAN CITY
Reuters

(Reuters) - The Vatican on Thursday angrily attacked the media over its reporting of sexual abuse of children by priests, saying there was an "ignoble attempt" to smear Pope Benedict "at any cost."

The editorial in a Vatican newspaper came on a day abuse victims protested near St Peter's Square to demand the pope open files on pedophile clerics and defrock "predator priests," and a cardinal spoke of a "conspiracy" against the church.

"The prevalent tendency in the media is to ignore the facts and stretch interpretations with the aim of spreading the picture of the Catholic Church as the only one responsible for sexual abuse, something which does not correspond to reality," the Vatican newspaper said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:49 PM

NY Times goes all tabloid on the Pope

UNITED STATES/VATICAN CITY
Irish Central

by The Yank

Okay, hold on. I was going to write about the Pope's recent letter to Ireland's Catholics, but instead I want to talk about the story on the front page of today's NY Times. Just because so many of the Bishops have made some grotesque errors in judgment doesn't mean that the NY Times should take leave of its editorial senses and adopt the sensationalist policies of a British tabloid.

The story the Times tells is another one about a priest who violated his vows, the innocence of children and the trust of their parents. Fr. Lawrence Murphy was an Assistant Director, Director and eventually Principal at St. John's School for the Deaf, a residential school in Milwaukee, from 1950 – 1974.

During that time Fr. Murphy sexually molested dozens of boys, perhaps even as many as 200. It's an horrific tale, made worse by the fact that Fr. Murphy preyed on deaf children for whom communicating what was happening to them was that much more difficult.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:46 PM

NYC Hoops Coach Indicted In Alleged Boston Assault

BOSTON (MA)
WBZ

BOSTON (AP) ― A legendary New York City high school basketball coach is accused in an indictment of raping a 14-year-old player during a trip to Boston decades ago.

Bob Oliva was indicted by a grand jury Thursday on charges including two counts of rape.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:43 PM

Ex-N.Y. coach indicted in ’76 rape of teen in Hub

MASSACHUSETTS
Boston Herald

By Laurel J. Sweet
Thursday, March 25, 2010

A former New York Catholic high school coach has been indicted by a Suffolk grand jury on charges he raped one of his 14-year-old basketball players at a Back Bay hotel in 1976 while the two were in town to see the Red Sox [team stats] play the Yankees.

Bob Oliva, 65, of Lynbrook, N.Y., accused of two counts of rape of a child and one count of disseminating pornography to a minor, will be summoned to Boston to answer to the charges, said Jake Wark, spokesman for Suffolk District Attorney Daniel Conley.

Oliva’s alleged victim, now 48, was a student at Archbishop Molloy High School in Jamaica, N.Y., and Oliva, a basketball coach for the Catholic Youth Organization, when he invited the boy to accompany him to Boston on July 31 and Aug. 1, 1976, a law enforcement source told the Herald

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:41 PM

Vatican slams Pope news story

VATICAN CITY
News 24

2010-03-25 22:02

Vatican City - The Vatican newspaper on Thursday denounced what it called an "ignoble attempt" to smear the pope after a New York Times article accused the pontiff of inaction over a decades-old paedophile priest scandal.

The report said the Vatican body headed at the time by Pope Benedict XVI, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, was alerted twice by the archbishop of Wisconsin to the accusations against Reverend Lawrence Murphy but did not respond.

In an editorial, L'Osservatore Romano denounced what it called "an ignoble attempt to strike at Benedict XVI and his closest aides at all costs".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:38 PM

Vatican denies hiding molestation case

VATICAN CITY
CBC News (Canada)

The Vatican denies there was a coverup in the church's handling of a priest accused of molesting as many as 200 deaf boys in Milwaukee.

The New York Times reported Thursday that two Wisconsin bishops urged the Vatican office led by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger — now Pope Benedict XVI — to let them conduct a church trial against accused priest Rev. Lawrence Murphy, but the Vatican ordered the process halted.

The Vatican newspaper L'Osservatore Romano dismissed the story, saying there was a "clear and despicable intention" to smear Benedict "at any cost."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:36 PM

Milwaukee Versus Vatican In Latest Alleged Sex Scandal

MILWAUKEE (WI)
WTAQ

MILWAUKEE, Wis. (WTAQ) - Lawyers for men alleging sexual abuse by a Catholic priest say all trails lead to Rome and the Pope. The attorneys' remarks stem from accusations by 5 men who claim they were molested while students at a school for the deaf by the late Father Lawrence Murphy. 4 lawsuits have been filed, arguing the Archdiocese of Milwaukee knew of the abuse, yet took no civil or criminal action against Murphy.

Attorneys Jeff Anderson and Mike Finnegan say they have uncovered documents that leave no question Vatican officials, including now Pope Benedict, were aware of the sexual abuse and that it was covered up. Anderson and Finnegan are representing the group in their case.

But the Vatican says it's the media's fault. An editorial in the official Vatican newspaper claims global media are engaged in what it calls an "ignoble attempt to strike at Pope Benedict and his closest aides at any cost." The defense was mounted in reaction to fresh allegations that an American priest in Wisconsin abused more than 200 deaf boys for 24 years.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:33 PM

In light of the pope's role in the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal, should he resign?

UNITED STATES
CNN

FROM CNN's Jack Cafferty:

Here we go again. Time now for another chapter in the tawdry tale titled: The Pope and the Pedophile Priests.

The New York Times reports that top Vatican officials - including the future Pope Benedict XVI - refused to defrock a Wisconsin priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:28 PM

Vatican axed trial for priest accused by deaf boys

VATICAN CITY
Austin American-Statesman

By NICOLE WINFIELD The Associated Press

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican on Thursday strongly defended its decision not to defrock an American priest accused of molesting some 200 deaf boys in Wisconsin and denounced what it called a campaign to smear Pope Benedict XVI and his aides.

Church and Vatican documents showed that in the mid-1990s, two Wisconsin bishops urged the Vatican office led by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger — now the pope — to let them hold a church trial against the Rev. Lawrence Murphy. The bishops admitted the trial was coming years after the alleged abuse, but argued that the deaf community in Milwaukee was demanding justice from the church.

An American protester in Rome on Thursday called the Murphy case an "incontrovertible case of pedophilia."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:24 PM

Vatican reacts on Pope inaction claims

VATICAN CITY
Sydney Morning Herald

MICHELE LERIDON
March 26, 2010 - 7:54AM

AFP

The Vatican has hit back at new paedophilia revelations, defending Pope Benedict XVI against an allegation that he failed to act over a US priest accused of molesting up to 200 deaf children in the 1970s.

The Roman Catholic Church's morals watchdog then headed by the future pope was reportedly alerted twice by the archbishop of Wisconsin of the accusations against Reverend Lawrence Murphy.

Benedict, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, did not respond to the letters, and a secret canonical trial authorised by his deputy was halted after Murphy wrote a pleading letter to the future pope, the New York Times said, citing documents provided by victims' lawyers.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:17 PM

Mother of Sex Abuse Victim Says Pope Is 'Lying'

WISCONSIN
ABC News

By RUSSELL GOLDMAN and CLARK BENTSON
March 25, 2010

Senior Vatican officials, including the current pope, refused to punish a priest who sexually assaulted as many as 200 deaf boys over the course of three decades, despite calls for disciplinary measures from two American bishops.

Documents from a lawsuit brought by the priest's now adult victims against the Milwaukee Diocese, and initially obtained by the New York Times, record the Rev. Lawrence Murphy admitting to diocese officials in the 1990s that he molested dozens of boys while working at St. John's School for the Deaf in St. Francis, Wisc., for 25 years from 1950 to 1975.

The documents also include letters during the 1990s from two Wisconsin bishops to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, asking for permission to prosecute Murphy in a church trial. Ratzinger at the time headed the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, the church's disciplinary office.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:12 PM

Statement from Diocese of Cloyne

IRELAND
The Irish Times

LATE LAST night the Diocese of Cloyne’s office issued a statement, following a series of questions sent by The Irish Times yesterday evening regarding Bishop Magee’s handling of a complaint of sex abuse in 2005.

A Diocese of Cloyne spokesman said that it was not possible to forward the queries to Bishop Magee in the time afforded but the administrator of the diocese, Archbishop Dermot Clifford had issued a statement in response.

The following is the statement in full:

“The Diocese of Cloyne operates its child protection system in full conformity with State and church guidelines. It engages very actively with the gardaí and HSE in ensuring the highest level of inter-agency co-operation and sharing of information.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:09 PM

Questions of Pope in Catholic sex abuse scandals

VATICAN CITY/UNITED STATES
euronews

The Murphy affair comes only a day after a top Irish Clergyman stepped down and is just the latest wave in the child sex abuse saga to hit the catholic church. Personal secretary to three of the Pope’s predecessors, Bishop John Magee of Cloyne in Ireland offered his resignation yesterday following a probe last year that accused him of mis-handling reports into sexual abuse in his diocese.

In attempt to quell growing calls for the head of the Irish church, Cardinal Sean Brady, to also resign over his involvement in covering up a sex abuse case in 1975, the Pontiff recently sent a letter to the faithful in Ireland.

But the storm clouds engulfing the church are increasingly beginning to circle the Vatican itself. The question being raised is did the Pope have knowledge of such crimes, notably during his tenure as archbishop of Munich. In 1980, a priest accused of paedophilia, was transferred to Benedict’s diocese, where he was previously known as cardinal Joseph Ratzinger.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:01 PM

US campaigners for sex abuse victims held after Vatican protest

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome

Four American campaigners for the victims of clerical sex abuse were this morning detained by police after holding an "unauthorised" demonstration on the edge of St Peter's Square to protest against decades of Church "silence".

Barbara Blaine, Peter Isely, John Pilmaier and Barbara Dorris from the Chicago-based Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) were talking to reporters about sex abuse cases, including revelations by the New York Times about the alleged role of Pope Benedict XVI in covering up the case of the late Father Lawrence Murphy in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, when they were approached by police and asked for their passports.

They were then taken away in a police car. Barbara Blaine, the leader of SNAP, was heard several times asking the police what they had done wrong. Before being detained the group held up banners reading "Stop the secrecy now" and "Expose the truth", and accused Pope Benedict of having imposed secrecy on clerical sex abuse cases when he was head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith before being elected Pope five years ago.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:18 PM

Man recounts abuse by priest, says pope should be held accountable

WISCONSIN
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

By Annysa Johnson of the Journal Sentinel

Posted: March 25, 2010 10:52 a.m.

St. Francis — A victim of molestation perpetrated by Father Lawrence C. Murphy recounted his abuse Thursday in a news conference outside the headquarters of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee.

SNAP, The Survivors' Network of those Abused by Priests, called the news conference in the wake of revelations that top Vatican officials, including the future Pope Benedict XVI, did not defrock Murphy, despite warnings about him.

"The pope knew about this. He's the one who knew about this," Arthur Budzinski said. "He should be held accountable. I believe somebody should be punished."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:33 PM

Former student tells of abuse at school for deaf

WISCONSIN
WQOW

ST. FRANCIS, Wis. (AP) - A Wisconsin man who claims he was molested by a Catholic priest at the center of a scandal about the way the Vatican has handled reports of abuse by clergy says he's happy the church is finally being held accountable.

Sixty-1-year-old Arthur Budzinski says he was repeatedly molested at St. John's School for the Deaf in suburban Milwaukee from age 12 to 14 by Rev. Lawrence Murphy. Speaking in sign language translated by his daughter, Budzinski says he told diocese officials about the abuse, but they did nothing. He says that as an adult, he went to police who investigated his claims, but made no arrest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:26 PM

Letters place Pope at centre of child abuse scandal

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Jenny Booth

Secret documents today placed Pope Benedict XVI at the centre of allegations of cover-up by the Catholic church of a priest sex abuse scandal in the United States.

Letters from the Vatican show that the enforcement department headed by the pontiff, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, took control of the efforts to bring paedophile priest Father Lawrence Murphy to justice, first ordering in 1997 that a church trial could only go ahead in conditions of total secrecy and then changing tack in 1998 and quashing it.

The change of heart came after Fr Murphy, who had sexually abused 200 vulnerable youths at a school for the deaf in Milwaukee between 1950 and 1974, wrote directly to the future Pope begging for mercy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:21 PM

Chicago SNAP leaders seized by police in Rome

ROME
ABC 7 (Chicago)

Chuck Goudie

March 25, 2010 (ROME) (WLS) -- As Pope Benedict XVI pleaded his own public innocence in the latest allegations of a Vatican sex scandal cover-up, four top leaders of a Chicago-based group for the victims of clerical sex abuse were detained by police.

Barbara Blaine, Peter Isely, John Pilmaier and Barbara Dorris from the Chicago-based Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) were detained by Vatican City police after holding an "unauthorized" demonstration on the edge of St Peter's Square.

They were mid-conversation with news reporters during a protest against decades of Church "silence" when uniformed officers took them away in a police car. Before being detained the group hoisted banners and placards reading "Stop the secrecy now" and "Expose the truth."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:18 PM

Zen in the art of covering up sexual abuse, Pope now involved

Digital Journal

R. C. Camphausen

US and German abuse inquiries are inching ever closer to the pope himself, with new documents obtained by the New York Times showing that Joseph Ratzinger, then cardinal and now pope, knew of 200 abuses by a single priest - yet did nothing.

Next week Easter, when the Pope will give his usual and multilingual Urbi et Orbi blessings from the balcony of St. Peter's Basilica on Sunday, many or most in the assembled crowd will know that the hands blessing them are the very same hands that have protected the Reverend Lawrence C. Murphy in 1996 when it was clearly known that he had molested up to 200 deaf boys between 1950 and 1974.

These are new facts in the ongoing series of scandals, and perhaps criminal investigations, that keep throwing light into what is going on in the Roman Catholic church - although all if it was always meant to remain a secret.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:15 PM

Pressure grows on Pope over handling of abuse cases

VATICAN CITY
BBC News

David Willey
BBC Vatican correspondent

Allegations have surfaced in the US that Pope Benedict failed to take action before his election as pontiff in yet another serious case of clerical paedophilia which has just come to light, this time at a school for deaf children in the state of Wisconsin.

The case has been confirmed by the Vatican. The Pope's spokesman, however, defended the pontiff's silence on the grounds that the Vatican department responsible for disciplining errant priests, formerly headed by the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, had not been informed until 1996 - 20 years after the priest's victims first informed the police.

Hardly a day goes by without new cases of sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests somewhere in the world being reported in the media.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:12 PM

Pope accused of failing to act on sex abuse case

VATICAN CITY
BBC News

Pope Benedict XVI has been accused of failing to act on complaints from two archbishops in the US about a priest who allegedly abused 200 deaf boys.

As a cardinal heading the Vatican office that dealt with sex abuse cases, the future pontiff allegedly failed to respond to letters about the case.

US media reports say a church trial of the priest, Lawrence Murphy, was halted when he pleaded ill health.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:08 PM

NEW YORK TIMES AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH

UNITED STATES
Catholic League

March 25, 2010

Catholic League president Bill Donohue comments today on the front-page article in today's New York Times about priestly sexual abuse:

Media requests to deal with this subject make it difficult to provide an adequate response to today's article by Laurie Goodstein. But the time has come to ask some serious questions about why the Times is working overtime with wholly discredited lawyers to uncover dirt in the Catholic Church that occurred a half-century ago. Those questions will be raised in an ad I am writing that will be published in next Tuesday's New York Times; a rejoinder to the article will also be made. All I can say now is that this is the last straw.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:55 PM

Fr. Lombardi explains Vatican response to sexual abuse by Wisconsin priest

VATICAN CITY
Catholic News Agency

Vatican City, Mar 25, 2010 / 10:10 am (CNA/EWTN News).- The New York Times printed an article on Wednesday in which they alleged that in the 1990s the prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), then Cardinal Ratzinger, did not respond to letters of a Wisconsin bishop on the matter of a sexually abusive priest. In an official response to the Times for the article, Fr. Federico Lombardi addressed the specific case and the CDF response.

According to the Times' article, Fr. Lawrence C. Murphy started working at the St John’s School for the Deaf in 1950. During his time there, civil and Church authorities were allegedly aware that he molested boys in the school.

He was moved from the Diocese of Milwaukee to the northern Wisconsin Diocese of Superior in 1974, where he continued working with children in parishes and even a juvenile detention hall.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:55 AM

The Predator Priest Who Got Away

UNITED STATES/VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

[link to the timeline]

The Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy admitted he sexually abused deaf boys at his boarding school for 22 years. Victims tried for more than three decades to bring him to justice, but documents show that the church neither defrocked him nor referred him for prosecution.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:48 AM

Vatican Declined to Defrock U.S. Priest Who Abused Boys

UNITED STATES/VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By LAURIE GOODSTEIN
Published: March 24, 2010

Top Vatican officials — including the future Pope Benedict XVI — did not defrock a priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, even though several American bishops repeatedly warned them that failure to act on the matter could embarrass the church, according to church files newly unearthed as part of a lawsuit.

The internal correspondence from bishops in Wisconsin directly to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, shows that while church officials tussled over whether the priest should be dismissed, their highest priority was protecting the church from scandal.

The documents emerge as Pope Benedict is facing other accusations that he and direct subordinates often did not alert civilian authorities or discipline priests involved in sexual abuse when he served as an archbishop in Germany and as the Vatican’s chief doctrinal enforcer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:43 AM

The Document Trail: The Predator Priest Who Got Away

UNITED STATES/VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

The Rev. Lawrence C. Murphy admitted he sexually abused deaf boys at his boarding school for 22 years. Victims tried for more than three decades to bring him to justice, but documents show that the church neither defrocked him nor referred him for prosecution. This links to a series of documents about this priest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:37 AM

Pope 'is at centre of Vatican abuse cover-up', says Hans Küng

EUROPE
The Times (United Kingdom)

Roger Boyes, Berlin

One of Europe’s leading theological thinkers has accused the Pope of being complicit in a Vatican cover-up of child abuse scandals in the Roman Catholic Church.

“No one in the whole of the Catholic Church knows as much about abuse cases – knowledge that is ex officio, derived from his office,” Hans Küng said in an interview with Swiss television.

Professor Küng – a long-standing critic of the Vatican – said that the Pope’s involvement in hiding clerical molestation of children dated back at least to his 24 years as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in Rome .

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:34 AM

Pope faces claims of covering up Milwaukee abuse

WISCONSIN
Wisconsin Public Radio

Newly released records show that the future Pope Benedict and other Vatican leaders failed to defrock a late Wisconsin priest accused of molesting up to 200 deaf boys. The records showed that several US bishops repeatedly warned the Vatican that the church could be embarrassed if it did not punish Father Lawrence Murphy.

The New York Times obtained those records and others as a part of four pending lawsuits against the Milwaukee Catholic Archdiocese. They come as Benedict faces similar accusations when he served as the Vatican’s chief doctrinal enforcer. Murphy allegedly molested the boys at Saint John’s School for the Deaf in Saint Francis.

Earlier reports said the church knew about the allegations since the 1950’s. Then in 1974, former Archbishop William Cousins quietly moved Murphy to the Diocese of Superior, where he taught Sunday school and presided at masses for the deaf for two decades. He died in 1998.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:31 AM

Rome police detain 4 US church abuse victims

ROME
Washington Post

Thursday, March 25, 2010; 11:08 AM

ROME -- Four American victims of clergy sexual abuse say they were detained and questioned by Italian police in Rome after showing photos of the pope during a news conference outside St. Peter's Square.

Barbara Blaine, one of the victims, said Thursday after emerging from a police station near the Vatican that officers told them a judge will decide if they will be charged. She says they were detained because they didn't have a permit for the outdoor news conference.

Blaine said police seemed most concerned because they displayed photos of Pope Benedict XVI and his top aide, Italian Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone. She says police also confiscated posters with slogans like "Stop the secrecy."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:25 AM

SNAP Response to Weakland/Pope Benedict/Fr. Murphy Story

WISCONSIN
TMJ4

By Jay Sorgi
The following is a statement from SNAP (Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests) on the report that former Milwaukee Archbishop Rembert Weakland warned now-Pope Benedict XVI about a priest based in Milwaukee who abused deaf children:

"Newly-disclosed church records prove that the world’s two most powerful Catholic prelates refused to rein in a serial predator even though three US bishops begged them to act. Because these documents are relatively recent, the crimes so egregious, the victims so vulnerable and the Vatican inaction so clear, this disclosure is particularly damaging to Benedict and Bertone.

"Benedict has told bishops to "recognize the extent and complexity of the (abuse) problem" and "admit grave errors of judgment were made and failures of leadership occurred." He’s said "All this has seriously undermined your credibility and effectiveness."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:17 AM

Vatican defends decision not to defrock U.S. priest

VATICAN CITY
Reuters

(Reuters) - The Vatican did not discipline a Catholic priest accused of sexually abusing up to 200 deaf boys in the United States from the 1950s to the 1970s as Church laws do not require

The New York Times reported on Thursday that the Vatican did not defrock Rev. Lawrence Murphy in the late 1990s despite receiving clear warnings from his bishops that his case was serious and could embarrass the Church.

The report came amid mounting allegations of sexual abuse by priests in Europe and pressure on bishops, mostly in Ireland, to resign for failing to report cases to civil authorities.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:09 AM

DECLARATION ON "MURPHY CASE", STATEMENT OF BISHOP MAGEE

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

VATICAN CITY, 25 MAR 2010 (VIS) - Given below is the complete text of the English-language declaration made yesterday, 24 March, by Holy See Press Office Director Fr. Federico Lombardi S.J. to the New York Times:

"The tragic case of Fr. Lawrence Murphy, a priest of the archdiocese of Milwaukee, involved particularly vulnerable victims who suffered terribly from what he did. By sexually abusing children who were hearing-impaired, Fr. Murphy violated the law and, more importantly, the sacred trust that his victims had placed in him.

"During the mid-1970s, some of Fr. Murphy's victims reported his abuse to civil authorities, who investigated him at that time; however, according to news reports, that investigation was dropped. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith was not informed of the matter until some twenty years later.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:07 AM

RC child abuse was made subject to the 'pontifical secret'

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Ruth Gledhill

Laurie Goodstein at the New York Times reports today: 'Top Vatican officials — including the future Pope Benedict XVI — did not defrock a priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, even though several American bishops repeatedly warned them that failure to act on the matter could embarrass the church, according to church files newly unearthed as part of a lawsuit.' The 1962 Vatican norms under which this case was dealt with, Crimen Sollicitationis, were superseded by Canon Law of 1983 and by new norms on 'delicts' against faith and morals published in a letter in 2001 from the future Pope, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. The Latin is here. The website Bishop Accountability, which is documenting the abuse crisis in the US, has the full text in English, reproduced below. Breach of pontifical secrecy can result in excommunication.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:03 AM

Vatican office led by future Pope Benedict XVI was warned about American pedophile priest: repor

UNITED STATES
New York Daily News

BY Stephanie Gaskell
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER

The growing sex scandal in the Catholic church reached the Vatican on Thursday, with new claims that Pope Benedict protected a Wisconsin priest accused of molesting up to 200 deaf boys.

Court documents show then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was alerted twice in writing by the Wisconsin archbishop in 1996 about the accusations against the Rev. Lawrence Murphy.

Murphy also wrote to Ratzinger, who headed up the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith from 1981 to 2005 before becoming Pope, and begged for leniency.

Abuse Victims Demand Pope Open Files on Paedophiles

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - Victims of sexual abuse by priests demonstrated at the Vatican on Thursday demanding that Pope Benedict open up files on paedophile Catholic clerics worldwide and immediately defrock all "predator priests."

The demonstration came as a leading cardinal denounced what he called a "conspiracy" to discredit the Catholic Church and said he could understand why some bishops hushed up cases of paedophilia so as not to harm the Church's good name.

Four leaders of the U.S.-based Survivor Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), all of whom were sexually abused by priests, including being raped and sodomised, held up photos of themselves as children and signs reading "Stop the Secrecy Now."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:56 AM

Joubert to take his case before a jury

NORWALK (CT)
The Hour

By STEVE KOBAK
Hour Staff Writer

The attorney for a Norwalk minister who is accused of rape in New York and faces domestic charges in Norwalk said that his client intends to take the domestic violence charges that he faces to trial.

Phillip Joubert, 48, is expected to plead not guilty to charges of risk of injury to a minor and third-degree assault, according to defense attorney Philip Russell, who respresents him on the Norwalk charges. He appeared Wednesday at Norwalk Superior Court and a protective order against him was adjusted so he could retrieve belongings from his former Norwalk residence.

He is scheduled for a supervised pre-trial conference on April 1 at Norwalk Superior Court. In a supervised pretrial conference, the defense meets with the state and the court judge to see if there is any possibility of resolving the matter without going to trial.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:54 AM

Diocesan chief says Gardai have details of all sex abuse allegations

IRELAND
Limerick Leader

By Eugene Phelan
THE Limerick diocesan administrator, Fr Tony Mullins, this week confirmed that all allegations of child sexual abuse by priests in Limerick have been reported to the civil authorities.

Fr Mullins, the parish priest in Athlacca, who is in charge of the diocese while the process continues to appoint a new bishop to replace Dr Donal Murray, said he wished to "encourage anyone who has concerns about child sexual abuse to contact the Gardai at Henry Street Garda station on 061-212400; the HSE West on 061-482792, or the diocesan designated person at 087-3233564".

Fr Mullins this Wednesday indicated his hope that a wide ongoing process of engagement with the content and theme of the Pope's pastoral letter will take place among parishioners, parish pastoral councils, pastoral area teams, child protection committee and other diocesan groups in the coming weeks and months.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:51 AM

Responses to Pope’s letter reflect how Irish attitudes have changed

IRELAND
The Southern Star

JUST how hugely Irish society in general has changed from what it used to be is illustrated by the public reaction to the historic Pastoral Letter of the Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, to the Catholics of Ireland last weekend. For a millennium and a half, since St Patrick brought Christianity to Ireland, the Pope was considered infallible and all edicts from Rome were dutifully accepted by the Church faithful, that is until the institution’s reputation was severely tarnished by revelations of unspeakable abuse of innocent children perpretrated by a small minority of its clerics.

This was compounded by shameful cover-ups of these evil deeds by those in authority in the Roman Catholic Church and the trail of responsibility for the culture of secrecy that surrounded such deliberate actions leads right back to the Vatican. These are the bare facts of the matter and were what the Pope needed to address comprehensively in his Pastoral Letter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:48 AM

Ireland’s Catholics should think long and hard on what exactly they want

IRELAND
The Southern Star

IS there a Martin Luther in the house? Someone to nail Ninety-Five Theses to the door of Armagh Cathedral and usher in a reformation of the Irish Catholic and Apostolic Church?

If there is, hopefully he or she is someone who does not possess the malevolence of the 16th century Augustinian monk. That guy’s abhorrence of the Pope had as much to do with the painful hemorrhoids he picked up in the Eternal City as with the desire to reform Christianity!

In the meantime, Irish Catholics faced with a dysfunctional Church, “shameful mismanagement” by church leaders and the cover-up of clerical sexual abuse may yet act in a way that will horrify Rome: by holding a national synod or a national assembly.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 AM

Ratzinger's reckoning

The Prague Post

By Hans Küng

After Archbishop Robert Zollitsch's recent papal audience, he spoke of Pope Benedict XVI's "great shock" and "profound agitation" over the many cases of abuse coming to light. Zollitsch, archbishop of Freiburg, Germany, and the chairman of the German Bishops' Conference, asked pardon of the victims and spoke again about measures that have already been taken or will soon be taken. But neither he nor the pope addressed the real question that can no longer be put aside.

According to the German polling agency Enmid, only 10 percent of those interviewed in Germany believe the church is doing enough in dealing with this scandal, and 86 percent say the church's leadership shows insufficient willingness to come to grips with the sex abuse problem. The bishops' denial that there is any connection between mandatory celibacy for priests and the abuse problem only confirms these criticisms.

This recent series of events raises four key questions.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:41 AM

Czech church responds to abuse scandal

CZECH REPUBLIC
The Prague Post

By Benjamin Cunningham - Staff Writer

As the Catholic Church's top officials in Rome struggle to cope with the ongoing sex abuse scandal in Europe, church leadership in the Czech Republic is proving equally inept at responding to growing public outrage.

Dominik Duka, who will take over as the archbishop of Prague in April, asserted the Irish end of the scandal is being driven by militant atheism that aims to harm the financial solvency of the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:38 AM

Pope 'failed to act' over abuse

VATICAN CITY
Al Jazeera

Senior Vatican officials, including Pope Benedict XVI, have been accused of not doing enough to stop sexual abuse by Catholic priests in the US, the New York Times newspaper has reported.

The pope, then a cardinal leading a Vatican office charged with protecting the moral authority of the church, was repeatedly warned about a priest who might have molested 200 deaf boys, according to church files released as part of a lawsuit.

Internal correspondence from bishops in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, directly to Pope Benedict VXI - then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger - showed that while church officials tussled over whether the priest should be dismissed, their highest priority was protecting the church from scandal, the US newspaper reported.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:33 AM

The Pope and the Pedophilia Scandal

The New York Times

Published: March 24, 2010
Pope Benedict XVI’s latest apology for the emerging global scandal of child abuse by predatory priests — an issue that the Roman Catholic Church should have engaged years ago — is strong on forgiveness but far short of the full accountability that Catholics need for repairing their damaged church.

With the scandal spreading across Europe, Benedict apologized to Irish Catholics last week for the “sinful and criminal” sexual abuse of thousands of children across decades. But he made no mention of the need to discipline diocesan leaders most responsible for shielding hundreds of priests from criminal penalties by moving them from parish to parish to continue their crimes.

The pope’s apology fell short not only for Catholics in Ireland, but for those in Germany, Austria and the Netherlands, where hundreds of new allegations are emerging to be investigated by a Vatican office that has but 10 workers to do the job. Benedict’s promise of a special Vatican inquiry into the Irish scandal came across as too little, too late, considering it took two scathing investigations by the Irish government to prod the Vatican into action. One of these found church officials were able to convince Dublin police to join in their cover-up.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:30 AM

Drop in clerical sex abuse reports – but 400 new cases in US last year

UNITED STATES
Irish Examiner

By Karin Zeitvogel and Christopher Lawton

Thursday, March 25, 2010

THE number of new child sex abuse allegations against Roman Catholic clergy in the US and Church payouts for clerical sex abuse cases fell sharply last year, a report commissioned by US bishops said Tuesday.

Some 400 new allegations of clerical sex abuse were reported in the United States in 2009, down from 620 cases in 2008 and 889 in 2004, when the first report tracking child predators in the US Catholic Church was issued.

In 2008, the US Catholic Church paid out $376m, and in 2007, costs related to abuse allegations against priests peaked at $499m.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:28 AM

Pope accused of covering up sexual abuse

SWITZERLAND
The Star (South Africa)

[the 2001 document]

[in Latin]

March 25, 2010 Edition 2

GENEVA: Hans Kueng, the dissident Catholic theologian from Switzerland, has accused Pope Benedict XVI of playing a role since 2001 in keeping sex-abuse claims against priests out of the public eye.

Kueng's office yesterday confirmed remarks made in a Swiss television interview on Sunday in which Kueng referred to a letter sent in May, 2001, by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger to the world's bishops.

The letter, De Delictis Gravioribus (about serious crimes), instructs bishops to report every case to the Vatican, but to keep such allegations confidential.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:18 AM

Pope faces fresh abuse cover-up claims

VATICAN CITY
Sydney Morning Herald

AFP

Fresh pedophilia cover-up claims hit Pope Benedict XVI late Wednesday in the case of a US priest who allegedly molested up to 200 deaf boys, according to church files obtained by The New York Times.

The documents, which emerged as part of a lawsuit surrounding a school for deaf children in the US state of Wisconsin, show direct correspondence from the accused priest to the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in 1996, the Times said.

A trial against Murphy was halted after he wrote Ratzinger directly to protest possible punishment for the abuse, the Times said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:15 AM

Irish Church set for shake up

IRELAND
BigPond News

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Cardinal Sean Brady, the self-effacing head of the Catholic Church in Ireland, could yet become the biggest scalp of the country's clerical child abuse scandal, critics and commentators say.

The Vatican accepted the resignation Wednesday of bishop John Magee, the second senior cleric to quit in recent months, after two major inquiries into the abuse of children by Catholic priests.

But groups representing the victims of decades of sexual and physical abuse of children by priests, religious brothers and nuns say Brady himself has lost all credibility at the helm of a church reeling from the extent of the abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:12 AM

Pope 'failed to act' on US sex abuse claims

VATICAN CITY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Anne Barrowclough

The sex abuse scandal enveloping the Catholic Church moved closer to Pope Benedict XVI today with revelations that in the 1990s the then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger failed to defrock an American priest who molested hundreds of deaf boys, despite receiving letters from a number of American bishops pleading with him to act.

Internal correspondence from bishops in Wisconsin directly to Cardinal Ratzinger, warning him and other top Vatican officials that failure to act could embarrass the church, have been unearthed as part of a lawsuit, according to The New York Times.

The case, against the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, involves the Reverend Lawrence Murphy, who worked at the St John's School for the Deaf in St Francis, Wisconsin, from 1950 to 1974, starting as a teacher and rising to director.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:09 AM

'My faith helped me to stay sane after abuse'

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

The Pope's pastoral letter was a velvet sledgehammer - and its message came as a catastrophic own-goal for the Irish Catholic Church, argues Fr Patrick McCafferty

Thursday, 25 March 2010

The recent pastoral letter of Pope Benedict XVI to Irish Catholics is without precedent. It addresses the reality of a tragic problem: the scandals of clerical sexual abuse and the massive failure of bishops to respond as true Christian leaders.

I would like to respond to the Holy Father's letter as a priest who is a survivor of abuse. I was badly hurt by sexual abuse when I was a young child. It was perpetrated by a babysitter and a local male. These persons had no connections with the Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:06 AM

Culture change in the Church

CANADA
National Post

Father Raymond J. de Souza, National Post
Published: Thursday, March 25, 2010

There has been much advice given to the Catholic Church in regard to the sexual abuse scandals. There are, though, only two real options. The Church can become more Catholic, or less Catholic.

Much commentary favours the latter approach. If the Catholic Church were to become less distinctively Catholic -- begin to teach as false what she now teaches as true, modify her traditional practices, adopt democratic modes of governance -- she would fix the problem. Though rarely put so bluntly, the advice to Catholics is to become more like Protestants.

The alternative is for the Church to become more fully who she already is--a preacher, a teacher, a mother, a mediator, a ruler. The sexual abuse scandals are a result of the Church's infidelity to her own identity and mission. That demands the response of being more Catholic, not less.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:04 AM

Germany sets up talks on child sex abuse

GERMANY
euronews

[with video]

The German government has set up round table talks to tackle a wave of child sex abuse cases that have shocked the country.

Some 250 separate allegations have been made in recent weeks, including a number involving Catholic Church officials.

The talks open on April 23 and will examine past cases and explore ways to prevent abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:00 AM

'Inadequate' handling of abuse case

IRELAND
The Irish Times

The Bishop of Waterford and Lismore Dr William Lee has described as "seriously inadequate" his handling of abuse allegations against a priest in his diocese during the mid-nineties.

It was reported this morning that Dr Lee apologised for delaying for two years before reporting the priest in question to the authorities.

In a statement issued to RTÉ, the Bishop said he particularly regretted that he had not sought the 'immediate' withdrawal fo the priest from all ministry.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:56 AM

Bishop apologises for abuse complaints delay

IRELAND
RTE News

[with audio]

Thursday, 25 March 2010
Bishop of Waterford and Lismore Dr William Lee has described as 'seriously inadequate' his handling of child sexual abuse allegations against one of his priests in the mid-1990s.

Dr Lee apologised for delaying two years before telling gardaí about the complaints.

In a statement to RTÉ News, he says he particularly regretted that he had not sought the immediate withdrawal of the priest from ministry.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:53 AM

Archdiocese reviewing sexual abuse allegations

GUAM
KUAM

by Mindy Aguon

Guam - The Archdiocese of Agana is reviewing allegations of sexual abuse that have been made by the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. No one showed up to SNAP's confidential support group meeting last night, but an official from the organization says she's not discouraged as more and more victims are coming forward about sexual abuse that occurred by members of clergy on Guam.

People are coming out of the woodworks to talk about abuse," noted Joelle Casteix. Even though SNAP's southwest regional director sat alone at a ballroom inside the Guam Hilton on Wednesday night, she's not discouraged. Yesterday and today she received several phone calls from survivors of sexual abuse.

"These are high-ranking government officials, people who have a lot at stake by coming forward and saying they were abused," she stated. "And a gentleman who was abused by Andy Mannetta right here on Guam." Manetta, as we reported, had been working on Guam for about a decade before working in Catholic churches in Hawaii. He was accused of sexually abusing a male minor for four years, for which the Catholic Diocese of Honolulu gave the victim $375,000 to avoid a sex abuse trial.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:49 AM

Report: Vatican was warned about priest in Wis.

UNITED STATES
The Associated Press

NEW YORK — Milwaukee's Roman Catholic archbishop warned a top Vatican office led by future Pope Benedict XVI about a priest who may have molested as many as 200 deaf boys, according to documents obtained by The New York Times, but the priest never was defrocked.

The documents were provided by two lawyers who have filed lawsuits alleging the Archdiocese of Milwaukee didn't take sufficient action against the Rev. Lawrence Murphy. The priest, who died in 1998, worked at the former St. John's School for the Deaf in St. Francis from 1950 to 1975.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:45 AM

Abuse Scandal’s Ripples Spread Across Europe

EUROPE
The New York Times

By KATRIN BENNHOLD, NICHOLAS KULISH and RACHEL DONADIO
Published: March 24, 2010

MUNICH — The fallout from the sexual abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Church settled across Europe on Wednesday, as prosecutors said they were weighing criminal charges against a priest suspected of molesting children in Germany, and Pope Benedict XVI accepted the resignation of a bishop accused of mishandling allegations of abuse in Ireland.

The possibility of criminal charges emerged from new accusations against a priest at the center of the child-molesting scandal rocking the church in Germany. On Wednesday, church officials in Munich said the priest, the Rev. Peter Hullermann — whose transfer in 1980 to an archdiocese led at the time by Benedict, then Archbishop Joseph Ratzinger, has drawn the pope himself into the nation’s child abuse controversy — had been accused of molesting a minor as recently as 1998.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:42 AM

Church is sullied by the failings of bishops

SCOTLAND
Herald Scotland

Published on 25 Mar 2010

There was applause last Sunday in our parish church.

Clapping isn’t part of our usual liturgy. We are more a middle-of-the-road congregation than a charismatic assembly. Yet we wanted to stand with our good priest who, commenting on the unfolding child abuse scandals rocking Catholicism, said we had been done an uncomfortable service by the media. It would be easy to dismiss the shocking revelations as yet more anti-Catholic reporting, were it not that the stories were true. Our priest paid tribute to the key role of lay people who have pushed the church hierarchy to address an issue it would much rather have ignored or covered up. It was our children who were put most at risk by those we had thought our shepherds.

It would be easy also to claim the Scottish church has mainly escaped this Calvary. The lack of a church/state accord might have been a blessing: the reticence of civil authorities to “interfere” might be markedly less than in Poland, Ireland or Spain some years ago. Our hierarchy should not get too puffed up too soon. Scots Catholics, never blessed with the most intellectually top-drawer of hierarchies, know that, had our Episcopal Conference faced Ireland’s troubles, it most likely would have responded in the same way. Let there be no doubt what most lay Catholics believe: any bishop who shielded or aided an abusing priest should heed the Pope and resign now.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:40 AM

Et tu, Benedict?

UNITED STATES/VATICAN
The Daily Maverick (South Africa)

The continuous stream of sex scandals assailing the Roman Catholic Church just refuse to die down. Still, this one is different. It involves inaction by no-one else than, shock, horror - Pontifex Maximus.

Internal Vatican correspondence shows that key Vatican officials — including then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI — failed to deal severely with an American priest in Wisconsin, Lawrence Murphy, who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, despite the fact that American bishops warned that failing to act could severely embarrass the church. This correspondence has now become public as part of an ongoing lawsuit being pursued by some of the priest’s victims. This is the latest in a series of grave public embarrassments for the Roman Catholic Church as a result of major sexual misbehaviour by its priests around the world.

In this latest case, newly public correspondence from bishops in Wisconsin, sent directly to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger shows that while church officials struggled with whether or not the Wisconsin-based priest should be dismissed, the church’s highest priority apparently was to protect itself from public scandal. This latest case has emerged even as other charges have been made in public that, while he was archbishop in Germany and the church’s chief doctrinal enforcer, Ratzinger did not alert civilian authorities or act firmly against priests involved in sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:33 AM

March 24, 2010

A preacher speaks as spin doctor from the pulpit

IRELAND
The Irish Times

DAVID ADAMS

Cardinal Seán Brady’s recent homily was self-serving and afforded only passing reference to the abused

THE AMERICAN author and journalist Hunter S Thompson wrote in 1972 about Richard Nixon’s presidential campaign: “Jesus where will it end? How low do you have to stoop in this country to be president?”

I’ve been wondering something similar about the child sex abuse scandals enveloping the Catholic Church. Where on earth will it all end? Is there anyone in the upper reaches of the church who hasn’t been involved in a cover-up of one kind or another? And how low will some of these people stoop to hang on to their positions? If Cardinal Seán Brady is anything to go by, the answer to my last question would appear to be this: just as low as it takes.

The recent television footage of Brady being confronted over his role in imposing a vow of silence on two young victims of the monstrous paedophile priest, Brendan Smyth, was so embarrassing to watch, I felt sorry for him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:08 PM

Faithful asked to repent for sins of the fathers

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY

OPINION: Why are churchgoers in Galway being asked to seek forgiveness for crimes they did not commit or cover up?

NEXT SUNDAY is Palm Sunday and Bishop of Galway Martin Drennan has planned a service of reparation in the city’s cathedral at which all will seek forgiveness for clerical child sex abuse.

Twelve years ago, on May 18th, 1998, there was a similar service at St Andrew’s Church on Dublin’s Westland Row. The then archbishop Desmond Connell led that special “service of prayer and healing for those who had suffered abuse in parishes and institutions run by the church”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:05 PM

Gardaí spoke to Magee in recent weeks about abuse file

IRELAND
The Irish Times

BARRY ROCHE Southern Correspondent

GARDAÍ SPOKE to the Bishop of Cloyne Dr John Magee who resigned yesterday, in recent weeks about a complaint that he had withheld information from officers investigating allegations of child sex abuse.

Gardaí launched the investigation last year after a retired schoolteacher from north Cork made a formal complaint that he believed Bishop Magee had endangered children by failing to disclose certain information regarding a particular priest in the diocese.

The man made the complaint in January 2009 after examining a National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church in Ireland (NBSC) report which examined Cloyne’s handling of complaints of alleged sexual abuse by two priests, Fr A and Fr B. It was compiled by Ian Elliott, the chief executive of the NBSC which is the Catholic Church’s own watchdog on child protection.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:02 PM

Cardinal's faith in his fellow bishop proved sorely misplaced

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY and PADDY AGNEW

ANALYSIS: Prelate who was secretary to three popes won the support of three archbishops, even in the face of mounting revelations as to how he mishandled allegations of clerical abuse

THE CATHOLIC primate Cardinal Seán Brady must be wondering now at the wisdom of that question he posed at the end of his St Patrick’s Day sermon in Armagh last week.

“The Lord is calling us to a new beginning. None of us knows where that new beginning will lead. Does it allow for wounded healers, those who have made mistakes in their past to have a part in shaping the future?” he asked.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:00 PM

Priests seek 'atonement' at Lough Derg

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PADDY CLANCY

PILGRIMAGE: ALMOST AN entire diocese of priests yesterday went on to the Lough Derg pilgrimage island to seek atonement and gain strength in a difficult time for the Catholic Church in Ireland.

More than 70 of the 80 priests in the diocese of Clogher joined their bishop, Dr Joseph Duffy, for a pre-pilgrimage day on the island, known as St Patrick’s Purgatory.

The trip came three days after they read out the pope’s message on clerical child sex-abuse in Ireland at Masses on Sunday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:58 PM

Abuse victims demonstrate in Dublin

IRELAND
The Irish Times

FIONA GARTLAND

SOME 147 pairs of children’s shoes were tied to the railings outside St Mary’s Pro-Cathedral in Dublin yesterday, a pair for every child known to have died in St Joseph’s Industrial School, Letterfrack, Co Galway.

The demonstration was organised by Fire and Ice, an abuse victims’ support group which aims to empower survivors of industrial schools through achieving compensation and justice for all who experienced abuse.

They have called for the Residential Institutions Redress Act, 2002, to be deemed unconstitutional, adversarial and unjust. And they have called for all victims to have a say in how trust funds or compensation funds are dispersed. They have also called for pensions to be provided to all victims and emergency funding for extreme cases.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 PM

Pope sanctions Bishop of Cloyne's departure

IRELAND
The Irish Times

BARRY ROCHE Southern Correspondent

POPE BENEDICT XVI yesterday accepted the resignation of former papal secretary John Magee as Bishop of Cloyne, Co Cork.

Dr Magee apologised to anyone who may have been abused by any priest while he was in charge of the diocese.

In a statement Bishop Magee (73) said he had tendered his resignation to the pope on March 9th and yesterday he had been informed that the pontiff had accepted it. “As I depart, I want to offer once again my sincere apologies to any person who has been abused by any priest of the diocese of Cloyne during my time as bishop or at any time,” said Bishop Magee, who was ordained bishop of Cloyne on March 17th, 1987.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:53 PM

Standing down 'farcical' and apology outrageous

IRELAND
The Irish Times

BARRY ROCHE

VICTIM REACTION: THE ANNOUNCEMENT of Bishop John Magee’s resignation as Bishop of Cloyne was yesterday described as unsatisfactory by three women who had made complaints to him and to gardaí that they had been abused as children by a priest of the diocese.

All three have made complaints to gardaí that they were sexually abused in the 1970s when they were girls by a priest identified as Fr B in a report by Ian Elliott, chief executive of the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church.

The women agreed that Bishop Magee’s resignation was “too little, too late” and they said they could draw no comfort or solace from his apology for any abuse suffered by children at the hands of priests in the diocese of Cloyne.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:51 PM

Child Abuse by Irish Priests Leaves Churches Scouring for Money

IRELAND
Business Week

March 24, 2010

By Colm Heatley and Louisa Fahy

March 25 (Bloomberg) -- It’s been almost three decades since Pat Jackman was sexually abused by his priest, a trusted family friend who ran a youth group.

Now the leader of their church in southeast Ireland is asking parishioners to help meet the bill for compensation.

“It was just the sheer arrogance of it,” said Jackman, 44, a sound producer and father of two who lives in the diocese of Ferns, whose bishop requested contributions from churchgoers in the area last month. “For the moral bastions of the community to be so insensitive was a disgrace.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:48 PM

Carlton Rae acted for a man abused by Roman Catholic priest in 1976

UNITED KINGDOM
Law Society Gazette

25 March 2010 by Jonathan Rayner

Who? Carlton Rae, 49, senior associate litigator at Reading firm Clifton Ingram.

Why is he in the news? Won £32,500 damages for a man abused by a Roman Catholic priest more than 30 years ago.

The 46-year-old, known only as Maga, was employed in 1976 by Father Christopher Clonan at the Church of Christ the King, Coventry, to do odd jobs. Clonan sexually abused Maga, who has learning difficulties, over several months. Maga reported the crime in 2006 when he learned that another man, also a victim of Clonan, had obtained compensation. Last year, the High Court upheld Maga’s claim of sexual abuse, but held that the Catholic Church was not liable because the abuse happened outside Clonan’s priestly duties. Last week in the Court of Appeal, master of the rolls Lord Neuberger reversed this decision, saying: ‘The abuse started in the presbytery and continued there, albeit not exclusively.’ Lord Justice Longmore added that it was Clonan’s ‘priestly status and authority’ that stopped people questioning his being alone with Maga and allowed sexual intimacy to occur. The Church was refused permission to appeal to the Supreme Court. Clonan’s whereabouts are unknown.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:45 PM

Vatican Did Not Defrock Abusive Priest, Files Show

UNITED STATES
The New York Times

By LAURIE GOODSTEIN
Published: March 24, 2010

Top Vatican officials — including the future Pope Benedict XVI — did not defrock a priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, even though several American bishops repeatedly warned them that failure to act on the matter could embarrass the church, according to church files newly unearthed as part of a lawsuit.

The internal correspondence from bishops in Wisconsin directly to Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope, shows that while church officials tussled over whether the priest should be dismissed, their highest priority was protecting the church from scandal.

The documents emerge as Pope Benedict is facing other accusations that he and direct subordinates often did not discipline or alert civilian authorities about priests involved in sexual abuse when he served as an archbishop in Germany and as the Vatican’s chief doctrinal enforcer.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:41 PM

MEDIA MOSTLY IGNORE SEX ABUSE DATA

UNITED STATES
Catholic League

March 24, 2010

Catholic League president Bill Donohue comments on the way the media are reacting to the 2009 annual report on priestly sexual abuse that was just released by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops:

There was a 36 percent decline in allegations of clergy sexual abuse between 2008 and 2009. As usual, most of the alleged offenders are either dead and buried, have already been thrown out of the priesthood, or are missing. There were six allegations made in 2009 involving minors. Six. As always, males are the preferred target. The report gave an age breakdown but did not mention the significant role played by homosexuals. Media reports never mentioned it either.

Here's how the media responded. AP ran a story of 864 words, but most newspapers ignored it: only two—the Asbury Park Press and the News Journal (Wilmington)—decided to run it. The Washington Post did a responsible job by covering it in 505 words. The St. Paul Pioneer Press also offered a decent summary. By contrast, the New York Times ran a 92-word article. The Chicago Tribune did much the same. None of the other big dailies—from the Catholic-bashing Boston Globe to the reliably anti-Catholic Los Angeles Times—even bothered to mention it. NPR gave it short mention, but the broadcast and cable stations ignored it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:37 PM

The pope comes up short

Los Angeles Times

Confronted by a cascade of new sexual abuse revelations, Pope Benedict XVI has issued a pastoral letter expressing "shame and remorse" for "sinful and criminal acts." Addressing Catholics in Ireland, where the hierarchy has been embarrassed by a government commission's report on widespread abuse, Benedict wrote that the bishops' response was "often inadequate" and that the crisis was aggravated by "a misplaced concern for the reputation of the church and the avoidance of scandal." Bishops, he said, should cooperate with "civil authorities in their areas of competence" -- apparently a reference to law enforcement.

The pope's condemnation is completely appropriate. But just as important is what he left unsaid -- and undone. He failed to say, for instance, that bishops in Ireland and elsewhere who have been found to have covered up abuse should leave their posts. It's bizarre that his letter was presented in St. Patrick's Cathedral in Armagh by Cardinal Sean Brady, the head of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland. Brady was present in 1975 when two children who had been abused by a priest were pressured to remain silent, supposedly so they wouldn't influence each other's accounts. Brady did not report the abuse to law enforcement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:34 PM

Milwaukee Sexual Abuse Victims Protest At Vatican

MILWAUKEE (WI)
WISN

MILWAUKEE -- Members of a Wisconsin organization will join protesters from around the world for a demonstration outside the Vatican Thursday.

Milwaukee's SNAP (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests) members were scheduled to arrive in Europe Wednesday to offer support to victims of sexual abuse.

Only recently have victims come forward in countries like Ireland and Germany.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:39 PM

Vatican reacts to Irish Bishop’s resignation

VATICAN CITY
euronews

[with video]

Bishop John Magee was well known in the Vatican where he served for years as a papal aide.

Authorities there deny they sought to cover up paedophilia by Roman Catholic clergymen around Europe. Today’s events prove concrete action is being taken, according to Vatican journalist Iacopo Scaramuzzi.

He stresses that this is the second resignation of an Irish Bishop to be accepted by the Pontiff since the abuse scandal broke, saying this “confirms the fact that Pope Benedict XVI is taking this whole affair seriously.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:36 PM

Gilbert Rabbi Arrested in Decade-Old Rape Case of 7-Year-Old Girl

GILBERT (AZ)
Phoenix New Times

By James King, Tuesday, Mar. 23 2010

​A Gilbert Rabbi was arrested today in the 2000 rape of a 7-year-old girl in New York City.

The U.S. Marshals Service tells New Times that its Child Predator Apprehension Team and detectives with the New York Police Department picked up 45-year-old Bryan Bramley outside of the Temple Beth Shalom Synagogue in Chandler, where he is the lead rabbi.

At the time of the incident, Bramley was living in his family's New York City home while he was studying to be a rabbi. According to the U.S. Marshals Service, the 7-year-old victim was sleeping over at the Bramley house when the rape occurred.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:33 PM

Arizona rabbi arrested on rape allegation

UNITED STATES
YNet News (Israel)

A rabbi accused of raping a seven-year-old girl in New York a decade ago was arrested Tuesday outside his Arizona synagogue.

Authorities say 45-year-old Bryan Bramly was taken into custody in the parking lot of the Temple Beth Sholom Synagogue in Chandler by the members of the US Marshals Child Predator Apprehension Team and detectives with the New York Police Department's Manhattan Child Abuse Unit.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:30 PM

Alleged Rabbi-Rapist Tracked Down in AZ

NEW YORK
Gothamist

An Arizona rabbi was cuffed in the parking lot of his synagogue, accused of raping a 7-year-old girl a decade ago in NYC. According to the victim, now 17, 45-year-old Bryan Bramly sexually assaulted her when she was spending the night at his family's home in 2000. At the time Bramly was finishing up his rabbinical studies, says the AP. She didn't report the incident until August 2009, but officials says they jumped on the case.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:28 PM

U.S. Marshals Launch G8 Wanted Child Sex Offender Website

UNITED STATES
U.S. Marshals Service.

Washington – The Department of Justice via the U.S. Marshals Service has launched a Web site, www.usmarshals.gov/investigations/g8/index.html, highlighting the 10 most wanted sex offenders in the United States. Seven other countries have also launched similar sites.

The U.S. G8-affiliated Wanted Child Sex Offender initiative, in collaboration with INTERPOL, aims to identify and apprehend wanted child sex offenders from the G8 countries – United States, United Kingdom, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan and Russia – by bringing together initiatives relating to child sex offenders.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:25 PM

Germany sets up talks to tackle child sex abuse

GERMANY
Reuters

By Christopher Lawton
BERLIN (Reuters) - The German government agreed on Wednesday to set up round table talks to tackle a wave of child sexual abuse cases, including numerous allegations of abuse in the Roman Catholic Church that have shocked the country.

The talks will also investigate alleged abuse cases in Protestant and secular schools and be led by four women -- three current government ministers and a former minister.

More than 250 abuse cases have been alleged in recent weeks, most of them at Catholic schools and dating from several decades ago. The scandals brought calls for an official inquiry into the Catholic Church, as Ireland had last year, but Berlin opted for round table talks among all groups concerned with the issue.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:22 PM

Sinead O'Connor: 'There should be a full criminal investigation of the pope'

IRELAND
Los Angeles Times

By Henry Chu

March 24, 2010

Reporting from Bray, Ireland - She shot to fame 20 years ago with her shaved head, chiseled cheeks and haunting rendition of the song "Nothing Compares 2 U." Then she gained notoriety when she tore up a photo of Pope John Paul II on American TV, calling him "the enemy" and urging people to fight child abuse.

Sinead O'Connor is still singing. And she's still speaking out against abuse -- only now her 1992 stunt on "Saturday Night Live" almost seems prescient as the Roman Catholic Church faces a growing catalog of complaints about child sexual and physical assault by priests in her Irish homeland and across Europe.

Such mistreatment was rampant here in Ireland, going back decades. By 1987, the Irish church was alarmed enough that it took out an insurance policy against future lawsuits and claims for compensation stemming from sexual-abuse allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:20 PM

Irish bishops deny ‘omerta’ code as senior churchmen face questions over a repeated gagging pattern

IRELAND
Forth

Wed 24 Mar, 2010

As an avalanche of fresh allegations of cover-ups of child abuse emerge one senior Irish clergyman says he was not party to oaths of secrecy, despite media reports to the contrary – but there is strong evidence of a culture of silence as more cases emerge forth editor JASON WALSH reports

TIMES ARE so tough for the Catholic church in Ireland that deputy heads have started to roll.

Today saw the resignation of Bishop of Cloyne John Magee. Speculation that Magee was pushed is immense: his resignation was accepted by Pope Benedict XVI after a full year of refusing to stand down. Magee had been criticised by church-appointed inquiry found that child protection practices in his Diocese were ‘inadequate and in some respects dangerous’.

Magee is far from being the only senior Irish cleric to face pressure to quit.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:17 PM

Hell yes, we will go!

MILWAUKEE (WI)
News Buzz

Two of Milwaukee’s leading activists against sex abuse by Catholic clergy are heading to Rome to protest at the Vatican and help European victims.

Amidst a growing European scandal over the issue – similar to the one that has rocked American parishes – Peter Isely and John Pilmaier, director and co-director of the Wisconsin chapter of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, flew into Atlanta Tuesday before crossing the Atlantic.

The group – which has butted heads with church officials in Milwaukee, where new Archbishop Jerome Listecki has refused to meet with its members – is responding to a new wave of victims speaking out on the sexual abuse they suffered at the hands of Catholic clergy, according to David Clohessy, SNAP’s national director.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:57 PM

Father Joe Quinn breaks his silence

NORTHERN IRELAND
Tyrone Times

COALISLAND priest Father Joe Quinn has broken his silence to reveal his seven year fight to clear his name.

Father Quinn was suspended from his religious duties in 2003 after accusations that he sexually abused two schoolgirls, who at the time of the alleged offences were over 16.
After one case was brought to Court, Rev Fr Quinn, former curate in Dungannon Parish, was cleared of any wrong-doing.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:38 PM

Q&A: A Reporter’s Insight Into the International Clergy Abuse Flare-Up

UNITED STATES
ProPublica

by Marian Wang, ProPublica - March 24, 2010

It’s a subject that has gotten limited play in the American press, but has held the attention of the international press for weeks, even months: In Germany, news of sexual abuse and negligent oversight in the very archdiocese once headed by Pope Benedict XVI has been a developing story, while in Ireland, sexual abuse by the clergy has been in the news for months. The pope wrote a letter to the Irish Catholic Church last week. The letter, while apologizing to abuse victims and urging greater accountability within the church, notably neglected to mention the investigation into what was once his own diocese in Germany. It also failed to quell growing demands for the resignation of leaders in the Irish church who knew sexual abuse was being covered up. Several bishops have offered their resignations to the pope; today, he accepted the resignation of one.

Interested—both as a journalist and a bystander—I called up Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Walter Robinson for some context on the recent flare-up involving clergy scandals in Europe. For seven years, Robinson led The Boston Globe’s investigative unit, which in 2002 and 2003 documented sexual abuse within the Boston Archdiocese. The coverage won the 2003 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service]. Robinson is now a professor of journalism at Northeastern University.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:32 PM

Veteran Editor of Church Scandal Coverage Weighs in On Latest in Europe

UNITED STATES
Media Matters for America

March 24, 2010 1:22 pm ET by Erich Streckfuss & Joe Strupp

ProPublica's new blogger, Marian Wang, has a good take on the recent coverage of the Catholic Church sex scandal in Europe.

She interviewed Walter Robinson, a former editor at The Boston Globe who helped oversee their Pulitzer Prize-winning coverage of the scandal at local Boston churches years ago.

"I don't know of any archdiocese where the archbishop or the cardinal archbishop was not kept fully informed and in most cases was not heavily involved in decision-making involving any priest who was accused of abusing minors," Robinson says in the Q&A

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:29 PM

Local cleric backs call for female priests

IRELAND
The Westmeath Independent

by Karen Downey

Athlone priest Fr Shay Casey has said this week that it does his head in thinking about the abuse of children by Catholic priests and the fact that more wasn't done about it.

And he said the introduction of women priests would help to usher in a new era for the church.

Speaking about the case where Cardinal Seán Brady oversaw two children signing a vow of silence about their abuse, Fr Shay said: "It was a horrendous case. I'm trying to get my head around why there weren't alarm bells ringing at the time."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:25 PM

More clerical resignations expected

IRELAND
Ireland Online

A second bishop was dramatically removed from the Catholic hierarchy over child sex abuse scandals tonight, with another three senior clerics expected to face the same fall from grace.

Scandal-hit former bishop of Cloyne John Magee, a one-time Vatican aide and the only cleric to serve as personal secretary to three popes, quit the day-to-day running of parishes across rural Cork in March last year.

The 73-year-old, from Newry, Co Down, faced scathing criticism after the church’s own watchdog found he took minimal action on accusations against two of his priests and branded his child protection inadequate and dangerous.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:21 PM

Bishop Duffy regrets not reporting paedophile priest

IRELAND
The Fermanagh Herald

THE Bishop of Clogher, Dr Joseph Duffy has admitted that he withheld from the police information about a paedophile priest, then on the staff of St Michael's College, to protect the church and in keeping with the prevailing culture at the time.

Now over 75, and after 30 years as bishop, Dr Duffy applied to Rome last year to be allowed to retire. However, in the course of a candid interview with a local radio station, he said he saw no reason to resign.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:19 PM

Mass-goers have mixed reaction to Pope's letter to the faithful

IRELAND
The Fermanagh Herald

THERE has been mixed reaction to the Pope's letter in Enniskillen. People coming out of Mass in Enniskillen were asked for their reaction. Some women suggested their husbands would be a better choice, others wanted to think more before commenting, but others were prepared to give an opinion, provided their identity was witheld.

'Saddened'

One woman told us: 'I think it (the letter) was a good start. I feel saddened for the good priest. That's the way I feel about it. I would feel very sad for the victims as well but I thing for the very good priest it's a very difficult and hard time for them.

'No, it (clerical child abuse) would not deter my faith in the church. I would be 100 per cent behind a good priest. I feel for the good priest, and I would not have any doubts in that regard and I would still be a good Catholic in
supporting the priest."


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 2:14 PM

CNA and EWTN launch joint news service

UNITED STATES
Catholic News Agency

Denver, Colo., Mar 24, 2010 / 06:23 am (CNA).- Catholic News Agency is pleased to announce it has entered into an agreement with the Eternal Word Television Network (EWTN). The new cooperation involves the sharing of news and resources to bring readers more Catholic news from around the world.

The new venture will be evident on both CNA's website and in the launch of a news website for EWTN, which can be found at www.ewtnnews.com.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:12 PM

CONGREGATIO PRO DOCTRINA FIDEI

VATICAN CITY
www.vatican.va

[English version]

EPISTULA
a Congregatione pro Doctrina Fidei missa
ad totius Catholicae Ecclesiae Episcopos
aliosque Ordinarios et Hierarchas interesse habentes:
DE DELICTIS GRAVIORIBUS
eidem Congregationi pro Doctrina Fidei reservatis

Ad exsequendam ecclesiasticam legem, quae in articulo 52 Constitutionis Apostolicae de Romana Curia enuntiat: «Delicta contra fidem necnon graviora delicta tum contra mores tum in sacramentorum celebratione commissa, quae ipsi delata fuerint, [Congregatio pro Doctrina Fidei] cognoscit atque, ubi opus fuerit, ad canonicas sanctiones declarandas aut irrogandas ad normam iuris, sive communis sive proprii, procedit»,[1] necesse erat in primis definire procedendi modum de delictis contra fidem: quod peractum fuit per normas, quarum inscriptio est Agendi ratio in doctrinarum examine, a Summo Pontifice Ioanne Paulo PP. II ratas atque confirmatas, simul articulis 28-29 in forma specifica approbatis.[2

Eodem fere tempore Congregatio pro Doctrina Fidei per Commissionem ad hoc ipsum institutam operam dabat diligenti canonum de delictis studio, sive Codicis Iuris Canonici, sive Codicis Canonum Ecclesiarum Orientalium, ad determinanda «graviora delicta tum contra mores tum in sacramentorum celebratione», ad perficiendas quoque normas processuales speciales «ad canonicas sanctiones declarandas aut irrogandas», quia Instructio Crimen sollicitationis hucusque vigens, a Suprema Sacra Congregatione Sancti Officii edita die 16 mensis martii anno 1962,[3] recognoscenda erat novis Codicibus canonicis promulgatis.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:07 PM

Feeling a bit sorry for the Irish bishops

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ruth Gledhill

The Pope has accepted the resignation of Bishop of Cloyne John Magee, the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland said today. Magee stepped down earlier after a Church investigation criticised the way he complaints against two paedophile priests in the diocese of Cloyne in southern Ireland. I am desperately sorry for and, like so many, angry on behalf of the victims, but also starting feel some compassion for the Irish bishops. Read on to find out why.

Richard Owen writes in The Times today that 'Georg Ratzinger, the Pope's brother, was drawn further into the paedophile scandal embroiling the Catholic Church.' One of the priests concerned is Father Sturmius W, whose case was highlighted on this blog last week. Georg Ratzinger is not implicated in the scandals.

And also in today's Times there is a truly courageous and extraordinary testimony by the former Director of Public Prosecutions, Sir Ken Macdonald, of Matrix chambers. Sir Ken was a cradle Catholic. On the Pope's letter of apology at the weekend, he writes that child rape was not invented in the 1960s and it was not the result of a changing moral climate.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:05 PM

Reform group urges Church to examine its structures

Independent Catholic News

Following the Pope's recent Letter to Irish Catholics, Raquel Mallavibarrena, Coordinator of the International Movement We are Church has issued a statement urging the Church leaders to examine its structures. She said: "Rather than look for external causes of this very serious problem, the Church should urgently take a deep look at its own structures, without any prejudice or fear. Its credibility is very much in question at this moment.”

It is deplorable that the Pope is not willing to hold ecclesiastical structures accountable for "the disturbing issue of sexual abuse of children”, but rather shifts the guilt to social trends such as “fast-paced social change” and “ways of thinking and assessment of secular realities”. To cite a "false reading" of the Second Vatican Council and its "program of renewal” as one of the causes, is outrageous.

The Pope accuses society of expecting too much from members of the clergy, in ethical terms, yet summons "the mystery of the priesthood" as a superior calling, effectively establishing that priests are to be considered as a special kind of human being.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:02 PM

Child porn charges dropped against counselor

VERO BEACH (FL)
WPTV

VERO BEACH, FL – The state has dropped all 33 charges of possession of child pornography filed against Vero Beach pastoral counselor Gerald Lamothe, who formerly was a Catholic priest, according to court files.

Vero Beach Police arrested Lamothe in April 2009 following an investigation in allegations that child pornography was on his office computer in Vero Beach.

Prosecutors and police officials were not immediately available for comment about the decision to not prosecute Lamothe.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:52 PM

Germany sets up child abuse panel amid church scandals

GERMANY
Expatica

The German government set up a panel of victims, experts and advocates Wednesday to shed light on child abuse in the wake of dozens of allegations against the Catholic Church and other institutions.

Chancellor Angela Merkel's cabinet named former family minister Christine Bergmann head of an "independent body charged with working on the subject and on financial and non-financial aid to victims," a government spokesman said.

Bergmann would also act as "the first port of call for the victims," spokesman Christoph Steegmans told a regular briefing here.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:48 PM

Catholic climbdown

GERMANY
German Herald

Trust in the Catholic Church ín Germany has fallen off the cliff in the wake of the child sex abuse scandal.

Barely one in six Germans say they now have confidence in the Church. This is accompanied by government statistics showing that people in dioceses affected by paedophile priests are now leaving in disgust in record numbers.

There is also anger directed against German-born Pope Benedict XVI - fewer than one in four people now say they trust him. These are the results of a poll carried out by Stern Magazine to be published today.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:46 PM

Six important points you don't hear about regarding clergy sexual abuse in the Catholic Church

Psychology Today

by Thomas Plante, PhD

There are a lot more myths than facts bantered around about clergy sexual abuse in the Catholic Church. Here are 6 important points that you should know if you are interested in this topic.

1. Catholic clergy aren't more likely to abuse children than other clergy or men in general.

According to the best available data (which is pretty good mostly coming from a comprehensive report by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice in 2004 as well as several other studies), 4% of Catholic priests in the USA sexually victimized minors during the past half century. No evidence has been published that states that this number is higher than clergy from other religious traditions. The 4% figure is lower than school teachers (at 5%) during the same time frame and perhaps as much as half of the numbers of the general population of men.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:44 PM

Irish bishop present at death of three popes resigns in Irish sex abuse scandal

IRELAND
Irish Central

by Niall O'Dowd

Another day another Irish Bishop resigns. The Vatican has now forced the resignation of the Bishop of Cloyne, John Magee.

Magee, a Down native, was already in deep trouble over victim abuse in his Cork diocese and had stepped aside temporarily while his actions were examined.

Magee is a controversial figure. He was personal secretary to three popes Paul VI, John Paul I and John Paul II and was present at each of their deaths.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:41 PM

Bishop's fall from grace

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Wednesday March 24 2010

Renowned for his links to three popes and last-ditch efforts to end the IRA's 1981 hunger strike, John Magee's tarnished legacy is now indelibly tied to the darker history of the Catholic Church.

Up until the Cloyne scandal was made public in late 2008, his climb through the clerical ranks was swift and widely regarded as colourful rather than controversial.

But after two damning child sex abuse allegations and by the 73-year-old's own admission, inadequate attempts to deal with them, the good natured perception of his bishopric has been all but destroyed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:31 PM

Irish bishop apologizes to abuse victims and retires from post

VATICAN CITY
Catholic News Agency

Rome, Italy, Mar 24, 2010 / 10:02 am (CNA/EWTN News).- The Holy Father officially accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee of the Diocese of Cloyne, Ireland on Wednesday. The Irish Bishops’ Conference had already reassigned his powers and duties in March of last year. Official news of the Pope’s acceptance of the bishops resignation request came at noon local time in Rome.

Following the announcement, Bishop Magee released a message through the communications office of the Irish bishops’ conference.

He expressed his “sincere apologies to any person who has been abused by any priest of the Diocese of Cloyne” during his time there or “at any time.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:25 PM

New abuse claim hits suspended German priest; sex abuse victims respond

GERMANY
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by David Clohessy, Executive Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (314-566-9790)

Our worst fears have been realized: a credibly accused predator priest, put back with kids while under the supervision of now-Pope Benedict, has apparently molested again.

(CNN reports that another victim of Fr. Peter Hullermann has come forward, who was assaulted AFTER Hullermann was ousted, sent to therapy and then re-assigned around children in the Munich archdiocese then headed by Archbishop Josef Ratzinger, who has since become the Pope.)

Catholic officials will no doubt try again to blame the reckless, callous and quiet re-assignment of this pedophile on one of then-Archbishop Ratzinger’s underlings. That is ludicrous.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:23 PM

Pope Accepts Irish Bishop’s Resignation in Abuse Scandal; Victims respond

IRELAND
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by Barbara Dorris, Outreach Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (314-503-0003)

We should neither exaggerate nor minimize the importance of complicit Catholic bishops stepping down.

We hope that Magee's resignation will provide some relief and consolation for the thousands of deeply wounded abuse victims and hundreds of thousands of betrayed parishioners in Ireland. By itself, however, this resignation doesn't signify any fundamental change in the corrupt church hierarchy or hurtful church practices regarding predator priests, nuns, seminarians, bishops, brothers or other employees.

It's preventive, not punitive, when a corrupt bishop resigns. It helps deter future recklessness, deceit and callousness. It helps, in a small way, to begin to change the church's centuries-old culture of silence and complicity surrounding child sex crimes and cover ups.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:13 PM

New Sexual Abuse Claims Against Former Local Priests

SANTA BARBARA (CA)
KEYT

[with video]

Three more men have stepped forward claiming they were sexually abused while attending the now defunct St. Anthony's Seminary in Santa Barbara during the 1970's and 80's.

Each of the men have filed a public complaint against the Franciscan Friars of California and Old Mission Santa Barbara.

A total of 27 Franciscan perpetrators are named in the complaints combined and the allegations against some of them are graphic in nature.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:10 PM

Statement from Bishop John Magee on his resignation

IRELAND
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference

On March 9th 2010 I tendered my resignation as Bishop of Cloyne to the Holy Father. I have been informed today that it has been accepted, and as I depart, I want to offer once again my sincere apologies to any person who has been abused by any priest of the Diocese of Cloyne during my time as bishop or at any time. To those whom I have failed in any way, or through any omission of mine have made suffer, I beg forgiveness and pardon. As I said on Christmas Eve 2008 after the publication report of the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church in Ireland, I take full responsibility for the criticism of our management of issues contained in that report.

On March 7th 2009 the Holy See appointed Most Rev. Dermot Clifford as Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Cloyne. This was in response to a request I had made to be relieved of the burden of administering the Diocese so that I could concentrate on co-operating with the Government Commission of Investigation into child protection procedures in the Diocese in my capacity as Bishop of Cloyne. I will of course continue to be available to the Commission of Investigation at any time.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:03 AM

Statement by Archbishop Clifford on the resignation of Bishop Magee

IRELAND
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference

In response to the announcement today that the Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, has accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee as Bishop of Cloyne, the following statement has been issued by Archbishop Dermot Clifford, Archbishop of Cashel and Emly and Apostolic Administrator to the Diocese of Cloyne:

I would like to thank Bishop John Magee for the cooperation he has given me since my appointment as Apostolic Administrator to the Diocese of Cloyne on 7 March 2009. I wish him all God’s blessings in his retirement. I ask for the continued prayers and support of the lay faithful, priests and religious of the Diocese of Cloyne for all those who have suffered abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:01 AM

Statement by Cardinal Seán Brady on the resignation of Bishop John Magee

IRELAND
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference

In response to the announcement today that Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee as Bishop of Cloyne, the following statement was issued by Cardinal Seán Brady, Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland:

“I wish to acknowledge the long and varied ministry of Bishop John Magee in the Church. I thank him for his contribution to the work of the Irish Bishops’ Conference over the past twenty years, particularly in the area of liturgy. I assure him of my prayers at this time and wish him good health in his retirement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:59 AM

Bishop's resignation accepted

IRELAND
The Irish Times

ÉANNA Ó CAOLLAÍ

Pope Benedict has accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee of Cloyne, it was announced today.

Dr Magee stood aside last March over his handling of abuse allegations in his diocese. The announcement was made at 11am in the form of a press release issued through the Irish Bishops’ Conference, St Patrick’s College, Maynooth, Co Kildare.

The short statement read: "His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of the Most Reverend John Magee, Bishop of Cloyne. This announcement was made today in Rome at 12:00 local time."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:56 AM

Trust in Catholic Church plummets amid abuse scandal

GERMANY
The Local

Trust in the Catholic Church has taken a heavy blow, a poll released Wednesday revealed, with barely one in six Germans saying they had confidence in the Church in the wake of the child sex abuse scandal.

German-born Pope Benedict XVI has also suffered a crippling blow to his authority, with fewer than one in four people saying they trusted him personally, the poll published by Stern news magazine found.

Just 17 percent said they trusted the Church and 24 percent the Pope. That compares with 29 percent and 38 percent respectively in a similar poll taken at the end of January.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:53 AM

Pope accepts Bishop John Magee's resignation. Will Cardinal Sean Brady be next?

IRELAND
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

By Damian Thompson

Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee, who stepped aside as Bishop of Cloyne a year ago after an independent report found he had failed to respond adequately to child abuse claims in Country Cork.

It’s a miserable end to the career of a man who was once private secretary to Popes Paul VI, John Paul I and John Paul II. It was Magee who was supposed to have discovered the body of John Paul I in 1978, though it later emerged that a nun had found the pontiff dead in his bedroom. The Vatican, in its wisdom, thought it was more “appropriate” that a priest should be named as the discoverer. As Magee has since put it: “I did find the body of His Holiness. I just didn’t find it first.” All theories that John Paul I were murdered are, incidentally, the most utter nonsense.

Anyway, all eyes now should be on Cardinal Sean Brady, Archbishop of Armagh. I would be surprised if the Pope did not accept his resignation, too – though it looks as if we shall have to wait until after Easter for a decision.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:49 AM

Vatican accepts resignation of Irish Catholic bishop John Magee

IRELAND
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Henry McDonald, Ireland correspondent guardian.co.uk, Wednesday 24 March 2010

The Vatican has accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop who was once the personal secretary to three popes, it was announced today.

The papacy said Bishop John Magee was stepping down over his mishandling of allegations of clerical sex abuse in his Irish diocese.

Although Magee quit the day-to-day running of parishes across rural Cork last March, it has taken the Vatican bureaucracy a year to formally confirm his resignation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:46 AM

OTHER PONTIFICAL ACTS

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

VATICAN CITY, 24 MAR 2010 (VIS) - The Holy Father:

Accepted the resignation from the pastoral care of the diocese of Cloyne, Ireland presented by Bishop John Magee, in accordance with canon 401 para. 2 of the Code of Canon Law.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:42 AM

Germany appoints ombudsman on sex abuse in church - Summary

GERMANY
Earth Times

Berlin- Germany on Wednesday appointed a special ombudsman to receive and investigate allegations of sex abuse dating from the 1950s in Catholic and other private schools.

Christine Bergmann, 70, was German minister of family affairs from 1998-2002. As ombudsman, she is to study cases that happened too long ago to be investigated by police. Germany does not prosecute child sex abuse after the victim turns 28.

In a related development, the Catholic archdiocese of Munich said it had reported to police a complaint that one of its priests had sex with a child in 1998. The priest was transferred to the archdiocese in 1980, at the time when Pope Benedict XVI was Munich's archbishop.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:39 AM

Annual audit shows decline in sexual abuse reports

UNITED STATES
Catholic News Service

By Patricia Zapor
Catholic News Service

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Reported cases of child sexual abuse in U.S. dioceses and religious institutes declined between the 2008 and 2009 audits to evaluate how church institutions are complying with the U.S. bishops' 2002 "Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People."

The 2009 annual report also showed that costs to dioceses and religious orders for lawsuits and other allegation-related expenses also decreased. In addition, it reported on how dioceses and religious orders are complying with provisions calling for education about sexual abuse for children and all who work with them, and for handling all allegations of sexual abuse, among other obligations included in the charter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:36 AM

Abuse scandal affects Pope's popularity

GERMANY
Radio Netherlands

The child sex abuse scandal rocking the Roman Catholic Church has led to a serious drop in the popularity of Pope Benedict XVI.

Opinion polls conducted by the German magazine Stern show that the pontiff's popularity with a cross-section of Germans has dropped from 38 to 24 percent since the end of January. His popularity with members of the Roman Catholic Church in Germany has fallen from 62 to 39 percent.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:32 AM

Pope Accepts Irish Bishop’s Resignation in Abuse Scandal

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

By RACHEL DONADIO and JACK HEALY
Published: March 24, 2010

VATICAN CITY — Pope Benedict XVI on Wednesday accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop accused of mishandling allegations of sexual abuse by priests, adding to the fallout of a scandal that has rocked the Catholic church in Ireland and throughout Europe.

The bishop, John Magee, who served as private secretary to three popes, stepped down last year from his daily duties as the head of the diocese of Cloyne, in southern Ireland, but had retained his title. In a statement posted on the diocese’s Web site, Bishop Magee said he had tendered his resignation on March 9, and that he received word on Wednesday that the pope had accepted it.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:30 AM

German Prosecutor Weighs Charges Against Priest

GERMANY
The New York Times

By KATRIN BENNHOLD and NICHOLAS KULISH
Published: March 24, 2010

MUNICH, Germany — As new accusations of sexual abuse emerged, the Munich prosecutor’s office said on Wednesday that it was weighing criminal charges against a priest at the center of the child-molestation scandal rocking the Roman Catholic Church in Germany.

Father Peter Hullermann, whose transfer in 1980 to an archdiocese led at the time by Pope Benedict XVI has drawn the pope himself into the child abuse controversy, is accused of molesting an additional minor in 1998 — the most recent accusation to date.

The latest revelation, made public by the archdiocese in Munich Wednesday, comes as church officials in northern Germany say they have “credible evidence” of at least two other cases of sexual abuse committed by Father Hullermann in the 1970s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:27 AM

Irish bishop begs pardon from abuse victims

IRELAND
AFP

By Andrew Bushe (AFP)

DUBLIN — An Irish bishop who was private secretary to three popes begged forgiveness from victims of child sex abuse in his diocese on Wednesday, as his resignation was accepted by the Vatican.

Bishop John Magee, who stepped aside a year ago pending an investigation into abuse claims, said he hoped that the probe's findings would help "towards healing for those who have been abused."

"As I depart, I want to offer once again my sincere apologies to any person who has been abused by any priest of the diocese of Cloyne during my time as bishop or at any time," he said in a statement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:24 AM

State drops all charges of child pornography possession filed against Vero Beach pastoral counselor

VERO BEACH (FL)
TC Palm

VERO BEACH – The state has dropped all 33 charges of possession of child pornography filed against Vero Beach pastoral counselor Gerald Lamothe, who formerly was a Catholic priest, according to court files.

Vero Beach Police arrested Lamothe in April 2009 following an investigation in allegations that child pornography was on his office computer in Vero Beach.

Prosecutors and police officials were not immediately available for comment about the decision to not prosecute Lamothe.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:22 AM

New abuse claim hits suspended German priest

GERMANY
CNN

Berlin, Germany (CNN) -- The German Cabinet met Wednesday to discuss ways of tackling child abuse in the Catholic church and other institutions as a new allegation surfaced against a suspended priest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:20 AM

Neuer Missbrauchsvorwurf gegen Priester H.

GERMANY
Erzbistum Munchen und Freising

Ordinariat meldet den Verdacht an Staatsanwaltschaft

München, 24. März 2010. Gegen den bereits suspendierten Priester H. liegt ein neuer Missbrauchsvorwurf vor. Nach einem Gespräch des Missbrauchsbeauftragten der Erzdiözese München und Freising, Monsignore Siegfried Kneißl, mit dem möglichen Opfer hat das Erzbischöfliche Ordinariat den Fall an die Staatsanwaltschaft weitergeleitet.

[summary]

A new abuse allegation has been made against the already suspended priest H. Monsignor Siegfried Kniessl met recently with the possible victims. The archdiocese has forwarded the case to the prosecutor. The abuse in question is said to have taken place in 1998. He was working at the time in the Garching/Alz parish. The case is not barred. The potential victim was a minor at the time. For further information, this case is reserved by the prosecutor.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:14 AM

Pfarrverband Bad Tölz setzt Ombudsmann ein

GERMANY
Erzbistum Munchen und Freising
(Archdiocese of Munich and Freising)

Informationsveranstaltungen zum Thema sexueller Missbrauch
Ordinariat unterstützt Pfarrei bei Aufarbeitung

Bad Tölz, 24. März 2010. Im Fall des suspendierten Kur- und Tourismusseelsorgers in Bad Tölz liegt der Schwerpunkt des weiteren Vorgehens für die Verantwortlichen in der Pfarrseelsorge und im Erzbischöflichen Ordinariat in den nächsten Tagen und Wochen neben der fortgesetzten Aufklärung aller Fakten vor allem auf der Information und der Beratung. Im Mittelpunkt stehen die Menschen vor Ort, insbesondere Kinder, Jugendliche und Eltern im Pfarrverband Bad Tölz.

[summary]

In the case of a suspended spa and tourism counselor in Bad Tolz, the focus in coming days and weeks will be on a broader approach to leaders of parish ministry. In addition to continuing education on all the facts, including information and advice, the focus will be on people in the town, especially children and adolescents.

Local people must act together to find out exactly what happened in the past in Bad Tolz in connection with the suspended priest. At the same time all possible support will be given to enable children, adolescents and their parents to deal appropriately with the abuse issue, according to the archbishop. Monsignor Peter Beer spoke Wednesday with with pastors of the parish community and representatives of the parish pastoral council.

The Bad Tolz independent ombudsman has appointed lawyer Henrich von Stackelberg/Gertsried. People can contact him to report possible abuse cases in Bad Tolz parish.

Pastor Rupert Frania, head of Bad Tolz parish, the following group sessions are to be held.

-- Children up to 13 years: Thursday 25 March, 17-18 o'clock, Franzmuhle
-- Young people aged 14 and over: Thursday 25 March, 17-18 o'cock, Franzmuhle
-- Parents: Thursday 25 March, 19.30 o'clock, Franzmuhle
-- Employees of the Church Foundation, Bad Tolz, including religion: Friday 26 March, 13.30-15 o'clock, parish hall / educational divide.

Please note: The press is not admitted to all events.

Note: The ombudsman for the Pfarrverband Bad Tolz, lawyer, Heinrich von Stackelberg, is contacted as follows: Heinrich von Stackelberg, Prießnitzerweg 2 / I, Geretsried, Tel 08171/93993, info@luithlen-stackelberg.de.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:00 AM

Baker's former attorneys subpoenaed for hearing

WACO (TX)
KXXV

by Bruce Gietzen

WACO - Matt Baker's former attorneys are being subpoenaed to testify in his hearing April 1st to try to get his murder conviction overturned.

Baker's court-appointed attorney, Stan Schwieger, filed a motion just an hour before the deadline February 22nd asking for a new trial.

The motion cites ineffective counsel by Guy James Gray and Harold Danford of Kerrville, where Matt Baker lived with his parents and daughters before he was arrested for murdering his wife Kari in 2006.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:50 AM

Heber charity founder Lon Kennard Sr. charged with years of sexual abuse

HEBERT CITY (UT)
Deseret News

By Geoff Liesik
Deseret News

HEBER CITY — The nonprofit organization he founded is aimed at helping kids in the world's poorest countries. But six women now say a Heber City man subjected them to years of sexual abuse in their youth.

Lon Harvey Kennard Sr. was charged Tuesday in 4th District Court with 24 counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, a first-degree felony; 21 counts of sexual exploitation of a minor, a second-degree felony; one count of forcible sodomy, a second-degree felony; and one count of witness tampering, a third-degree felony. ...

The sexual abuse outlined in court records allegedly began in 1995, around the time Kennard was serving as bishop of his LDS Church ward and one year after he and his wife founded Village of Hope. The nonprofit organization provides "development programs for destitute villages focusing on water and sanitation, agriculture and nutrition, high-risk children protection, women and girl empowerment, health care, family income and economic development," according to its Web site.The villages served are located in Mexico, Central America, Ethiopia and the Caribbean.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:47 AM

Guam pedophile priests identified

GUAM
Marianas Variety

THE reign of secrecy and apparent conspiracy of silence that have stigmatized the Roman Catholic Church, which has been facing accusations of abuses by pedophile priests, will no longer be tolerated around the world, not even on Guam, according to national advocates who are currently on Guam to help abuse victims.

Guam is predominantly Catholic and because of the high regard and respect for its priests and the Archdiocese of Agana, alleged sexual abuses by priests are a well-kept secret, only whispered around, but never actually reported, said one victim who has yet to come out and name his abuser.

Records and copies of email exchanges obtained by Variety revealed details of abuses, confessions made by priests based on Guam, as well as settlements made off-island.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:44 AM

Bishops welcome Papal letter concerning clerical abuse in Ireland

IRELAND
Offaly Express

Published Date: 24 March 2010
By grace o'dea
THE Bishop of Meath, Dr Michael Smith and the Bishop of Kildare and Leighlin, Dr Jim Moriarty have welcomed Pope Benedict XIII's letter concerning clerical abuse in Ireland.

The letter, which was read out at all masses over the weekend, was met with mixed reactions with members of the congregation in Dublin getting up and leaving the church.

However Bishop Smith 'warmly welcomed' the letter and asked people to read it for themselves 'with an open heart'.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:34 AM

Principal in Court on Sexual Assault Charge

SHERWOOD (AR)
KATV

Sherwood - The suspended principal and coach charged with first-degree sexual assault of a former student makes his first court appearance.

Police paint a disturbing picture of Timothy Ballard, 39, a man charged with sexually assaulting at least one of the children he was entrusted to care for at Abundant Life School in Sherwood. The arrest affidavit read at Tuesday's hearing said the former female student told police Coach Ballard started showing her a lot of extra attention when she was in the 7th grade. She says things then progressed to kissing, groping, fondling and other inappropriate sexual contact until she graduated in 2009.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:27 AM

Pope accepts Bishop Magee's resignation

IRELAND
Ireland Online

24/03/2010

Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of a senior Irish bishop who stood down over his mishandling of clerical child sex abuse allegations, it was confirmed today.

This announcement was made today in Rome at 12 noon local time (11am Irish time).

Scandal-hit former bishop of Cloyne John Magee, a one-time Vatican aide, quit the day-to-day running of parishes across rural Cork in March last year.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:14 AM

Pope accepts Bishop John Magee's resignation

IRELAND
TV 3

The Vatican has confirmed that it has accepted the Bishop's resignation.

A year ago Bishop Magee stepped aside from his diocesan duties following criticism over his handling of child abuse cases in the diocese.

In 2008 the Cloyne Report found that child protection practices in Cloyne were "inadequate and in some respects dangerous".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:01 AM

Bishop's resignation accepted

IRELAND
The Irish Times

ÉANNA Ó CAOLLAÍ

Pope Benedict has accepted the resignation of Bishop John Magee of Cloyne, it was announced today.

Dr Magee stood aside last March over his handling of abuse allegations in his diocese. The announcement was made at 11am in the form of a press release issued through the Irish Bishops’ Conference, St Patrick’s College, Maynooth, Co Kildare.

The short statement read: "His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of the Most Reverend John Magee, Bishop of Cloyne. This announcement was made today in Rome at 12:00 local time."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Irish bishop quits over abuse case

VATICAN CITY
Al Jazeera

Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop accused of mishandling child sex abuse allegations in his diocese, the Vatican has said.

John Magee, aged 73, had previously served as a private secretary to three successive Roman Catholic popes before being assigned to Cloyne in Ireland.

The Vatican said on Wednesday that Pope Benedict had accepted Magee's resignation, but did not elaborate.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:57 AM

Irish bishop quits over church sex abuse

IRELAND
USA Today

Bishop John Magee of the diocese of Cloyne, Ireland, said today he had resigned his position and he apologized for any abuse that occurred in his diocese.

CNN says the bishop offered his resignation to Pope Benedict XVI on March 9.

"To those whom I have failed in any way, or through any omission of mine have made suffer, I beg forgiveness and pardon."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:52 AM

Church sex abuse: Holocaust denial echoed

NETHERLANDS
Radio Netherlands

The former head of the Roman Catholic Church in the Netherlands, Cardinal Ad Simonis, says the church leaders were not aware of child sex abuse in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s.

Speaking on the TV programme Pauw & Witteman on Tuesday evening, he said - in German - "wir haben es nicht gewusst" and added "I know that is a very dangerous remark and heavily loaded, but it's true."

The remark in question, meaning "we didn't know about it" and referring to the Holocaust, was repeatedly used by Nazi defendants at the Nuremberg trials after World War II.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:47 AM

Too little, too late, Pope Benedict

IRELAND
Irish Central

by John Spain

The Pope's letter to Catholics in Ireland, a short version of which was read out at all Masses in the country last Saturday night and Sunday morning, is too little, too late. It has been dismissed with something approaching contempt not just by the victims of clerical abuse, but by people in general here.

All the newspapers and TV did vox pops -- street interviews -- in the wake of the letter, and reporters had a real problem finding anyone to say it was an adequate response to the abuse and cover-up scandal here.

People are right to be dismissive. I didn't go to church at the weekend myself. I don't go that often anyway, but I might have gone because I was curious.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:45 AM

Priest who served in Granite Falls is accused of sex crime

GRANITE FALLS (MN)
Pioneer Press

By Linda Vanderwerf
West Central Tribune

A priest accused of raping a teenage boy in Ireland is also alleged to have sexually abused at least one boy during the short time he served in Granite Falls in 1982.

The allegations against the Rev. Francis Markey were raised in a Cable News Network report last weekend.

Markey, 82, is fighting extradition to Ireland, where he is charged with raping a 15-year-old boy in 1968.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:41 AM

Pope accepts Irish bishop's resignation

VATICAN CITY
CBC News (Canada)

Last Updated: Wednesday, March 24, 2010
CBC News
Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of Irish Bishop John Magee, who has been accused of mishandling complaints of sex abuse in his diocese, the Vatican confirmed Wednesday.

Magee, 73, was appointed bishop of the diocese of Cloyne in southern Ireland in 1987. He tendered his resignation earlier in March, according to a statement published on the diocese's website.

Three Irish government-ordered investigations published from 2005 to 2009 have documented how thousands of Irish children suffered rape, molestation and other abuse by priests in their parishes and by nuns and brothers in boarding schools and orphanages.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Priest's abuse victims didn't want to be ID'd

FRANKFORT (KY)
Lexington Herald-Leader

By Jim Warren - jwarren@herald-leader.com

FRANKFORT — Franklin County Commonwealth's Attorney Larry Cleveland said Monday that he elected to accept a former Lexington pastor's plea on reduced charges in a sex-abuse case mainly because of the trauma for the victims if they had been required to testify at a trial.

The Rev. Joseph Muench, 59, once pastor at Lexington's Mary Queen of the Holy Rosary parish, could spend as little as a year in prison under a plea agreement reached last week.

Muench was accused of "subjecting another person to sexual contact by forcible compulsion," according to an indictment returned in October. One victim in the case was older than 18 and another was 16 when the incidents occurred, according to court filings.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 AM

Can the Pope get rid of problem bishops?

UNITED STATES
Beliefnet

Rod Dreher

Mark Shea says no, he can't. Interesting, his explanation for why not:

The irony, particularly in Dreher's case, is that in his frustration and sense of crisis about the Roman Church, he chose to be jump to the ecclesial camp which would be most irate if the Pope did was Dreher demands. They, better than I, can explain why the Pope is about a thousand years to late to go all Innocent III on us and imagine that it is his role to effectively take over the management of every diocese in the world and expel a huge number of bishops from their sees, not only for being fools when it came to the culture of secrecy in the abuse scandals, but for all sorts of other reasons as well.

T'aint gonna happen. (Not that I don't wish it would some days. I long for the expulsion of toads like Mahony from their sees.) But the reality is that this Pope appears to be pursuing almost exactly the same course as JPII when it comes to dealing with idiot bishops. To be sure, he is far more zealous in seeing to it that pervert priests get the bum's rush. But as far as bishops go, he is as reluctant as JPII to treat them like middle management who work for him. He appears to take the same, very eastern, view of the papacy that JPII articulated in Ut Unum Sint. If I'm right, then the best place to turn for an understanding of why these Popes act that way they do toward bishops who were idiots is... to ask Rod Dreher's Orthodox bishop. He, along with the rest of the eastern Churches, will be happy to explain that the Pope is not the Supreme Maximum Leader who can run about treating brother bishops as mere underlings who work for him. If I'm right (and I'm pretty certain I am), the Pope feels himself very hindered by the Church's teaching on collegiality. So, for that matter, do the Orthodox, who have their own troubles with pervy priests and the bishops who love them.

Well, for one thing, I don't think the Pope should "expel a huge number of bishops from their sees." How about just one or two of the worst ones?

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:32 AM

Pope accepts resignation of Irish bishop

VATICAN CITY
The Associated Press

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican says Pope Benedict XVI has accepted the resignation of Irish Bishop John Magee in the country's sex abuse scandal.

The 73-year-old Magee has been accused of mishandling complaints against priests in his diocese of Cloyne. The Vatican said Wednesday without elaboration that the pope had accepted his resignation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:30 AM

Pope accepts Irish bishop's resignation

IRELAND
BBC News

The Pope has accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop found to have mishandled allegations of clerical sex abuse in his County Cork diocese.

Bishop John Magee stepped aside in March 2009 after an independent report found his Cloyne Diocese had put children at risk of harm.

"I take full responsibility for the criticism of our management of issues in that report," he said on Wednesday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:28 AM

Audit Shows Fewest Reports of Sexual Abuse by Clerics since 2004; Most Incidents from Decades Ago

UNITED STATES
Metro Catholic

March 24, 2010
WASHINGTON DC (MetroCatholic) – The 2009 annual report on compliance with the U.S. bishops’ Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People shows the fewest number of victims, allegations and offenders in dioceses since 2004. Most cases reported to dioceses were from decades ago.

The data show that in 2009 there were 398 allegations and 286 offenders reported to dioceses, most from earlier decades. Of the allegations reported in 2009, six allegations (2 percent) involved children under the age of 18 in 2009. About an eighth of the allegations in 2009 (48) were unsubstantiated or determined to be false by the end of the year.

Similar declines were found in data from religious orders of men.

Data for the 2009 calendar year were collected by the Georgetown University-based Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA). It began gathering data on sexual abuse of minors by clerics in 2004 as part of the bishops’ annual report on compliance with the Charter. The audit report can be found at http://www.usccb.org/ocyp/annual_report2009.shtml

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:25 AM

Archdiocese calls accusations credible of sex abuse by pastor

LOUISVILLE (KY)
WHAS

[with video]

The Archdiocese of Louisville says accusations of sexual abuse by a long-time priest are credible.

James Schook was most recently Pastor at Saint Ignatius Martyr Parish on Rangeland Road.

He was placed on leave after one accusation last summer and then 4 more men came forward and said Schook had abused them when they were young.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

Priest accused of abuse removed from duties

LOUISVILLE (KY)
WAVE

Posted by Charles Gazaway

LOUISVILLE, KY (WAVE) – The Archdiocese of Louisville has removed a Kentuckiana priest from all ministerial duties after a sexual review board determined there was enough credible evidence of improper conduct.

The abuse allegations against Fr. James Schook date back to the mid 1980's. The Sexual Abuse Board recommended to Archbishop Joseph Kurtz that Schook lead a life of prayer and penance.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:15 AM

STEPHEN MULHOLLAND: Time for a rethink on celibacy

SOUTH AFRICA
Daily Dispatch

2010/03/24
WE ROMAN Catholics are, to the best of my religious knowledge, which is not vast, the only denomination in which celibacy is a requirement for those wishing to serve as officers of the church.

Some, such as Islam, reserve such offices for males but do not impose a vow of celibacy on them. In Catholicism here is one approach: “Clerics are obliged to observe perfect and perpetual continence for the sake of the kingdom of heaven and therefore are bound to celibacy which is a special gift of God by which sacred ministers can adhere more easily to Christ with an undivided heart and are able to dedicate themselves more freely to the service of God and humanity.”

Some will quite reasonably argue that this is in conflict with the reality of the nature of man. St Thomas Aquinas, the greatest of Catholic scholars, himself has written in Summa Theologia: “It is in man’s nature, like that of other animals, both before and after sin, to reproduce by intercourse, and nature has provided him with the organs needed for the purpose.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:13 AM

Priestly celibacy defended

VATICAN CITY
The Catholic Leader (Australia)

Published: 28 March 2010

VATICAN CITY (CNS): As the Year for Priests moves into its final phase, a chorus of Vatican officials and experts has defended priestly celibacy and rejected the idea that celibacy has anything to do with sexual abuse by priests.

The latest to take on critics of celibacy was Manfred Lutz, chief of psychiatry at a German hospital and a consultant to the Congregation for Clergy.

Speaking at a theological convention on the priesthood in Rome on March 12, Mr Lutz said people who viewed celibacy as "unnatural" failed to understand the positive value of self-control in human sexuality.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:09 AM

Priest removed from ministry

LOUISVILLE (KY)
The Courier-Journal

By Peter Smith • psmith@courier-journal.com • March 23, 2010

The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Louisville has permanently removed a longtime priest from ministry, saying it determined that past accusations of sexual abuse against him are credible.

The Rev. James R. Schook, 62, has been instructed by Archbishop Joseph E. Kurtz to live a life of “prayer and penance,” in which he will remain a priest but no longer minister publicly.

Under church policy, Schook “may not celebrate Mass publicly or administer the sacraments,” according to a statement from archdiocesan spokeswoman Cecelia Price. “He may not wear clerical garb or present himself publicly as a priest, and he will be directed not to have any unsupervised contact with minors.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:06 AM

Opinion: Catholic Church and its Clergy sex scandal

MAYLAYSIA
Catholic Online

By Dr.Chris Anthony
3/23/2010
Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

BUTTERWORTH, MALAYSIA (Catholic Online) - It looks like the Catholic Church seems to be perpetually stuck with sex scandals involving its clergy. Child sex abuse appears to be so widespread and entrenched among the Church hierarchy that it finds difficult to get out of the scandal let alone redeem itself from the grievous sin.

First it was the sex scandal that rocked the Church in the US in 2007 where a huge sum of money, in the region of US$2 billion, was paid as compensation to the victims. Not only such a huge sum was wasted but the scandal itself dealt a serious blow to the credibility of the Catholic Church as a moral leader in the world. The secular international media left no stone unturned to inflict the greatest degree of insult on the Catholic Church.

Before the Church could recover from the effects of the clergy sex scandal in the US we are again hit by similar scandals in Ireland, Netherlands and now in Germany. It looks that such sex abuses among the clergy may be much more widespread than we imagined. It has placed the greatest challenge to the Church today.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:03 AM

Catholics should demand justice -- and answers

CANADA
The Vancouver Sun

The Calgary Herald

March 24, 2010

The Vatican needs to do two things to respond to the scandal of sexual abuse, including pedophilia, in the Catholic Church -- and neither of those things involves spin.

First, Pope Benedict needs to come clean on just what he knew, and when he knew it, about sexual abuse in the churches of his archdiocese when he was archbishop of Munich during the 1970s and first part of the 1980s. Second, the Pope should put in place throughout the entire Roman Catholic Church, a rule requiring priests to report any incidents of sexual abuse of minors which they learn about, to the police. For too many years, the Church has shielded pedophile priests, speaking solemnly of forgiveness and healing, and moving those priests to other dioceses where, supposedly, they were not in a position to harm anyone further -- but they ended up doing so.

Benedict, as Archbishop Joseph Ratzinger of Munich, in 1979 transferred a pedophile priest who molested a 13-year-old boy out of his parish and sent him for therapy. However, the priest was returned in due time to pastoral duties by Vicar General Gerhard Gruber, who served as deputy to Ratzinger. The priest then went on to commit further sexual offences. Other priests in Ratzinger's archdiocese were also embroiled in sexual abuse accusations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:01 AM

Pope accepts bishop's resignation

IRELAND
UTV

The Pope has accepted the resignation of an Irish bishop criticised over his handling of allegations of clerical sex abuse in his County Cork diocese.

Newry-born Bishop John Magee, 72, indicated earlier this month he was to step down. He had faced a series of calls for his resignation since an independent report was published just before Christmas.

That report found Cloyne Diocese had put children at risk of harm due to an inability to respond appropriately to abuse allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:59 AM

Editorial - The Cardinal Brady Affair

IRELAND
Waterford Today

It would seem that hardly a month goes by without some new controversy surrounding the Catholic Church in Ireland and child sexual abuse. This time however the scandal goes all the way to the very top and involves the Primate of Ireland Cardinal Sean Brady. It would appear that in 1975 he was asked by his superior to investigate claims by two children into allegations of sexual abuse against the notorious priest Fr. Brendan Smyth. Fr. Smyth is perhaps the most notorious of serial child abusers in the annals of not only the church but also of the state. For decades he sexually abused children that were in his care and it was only at the end of his life that he was finally stopped. It was into these set of circumstances that Cardinal Brady, then a lowly priest, was dropped. What has outraged so many commentators and campaigners against child sexual abuse is the fact that not only was Fr. Smyth not reported but that apparently the two children making the allegations were made to sign a document saying that they would keep everything about the affair secret.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:56 AM

Church is not above the law

CANADA
Winnipeg Free Press

By: Gwynne Dyer

24/03/2010

The Biblical formula "Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's, and unto God the things that are God's" is generally taken to mean that people should recognize the authority of the state in secular matters, but that is not necessarily what Jesus meant by it. It is certainly not the current practice of the Roman Catholic Church, although the rule in modern democracies is very clear: The law applies equally to everyone, even priests.

It's more than two decades since evidence of widespread sexual abuse of children by Roman Catholic clergy began to surface in the United States, Canada and Ireland, and still the revelations continue. A "tsunami" of allegations of child abuse in Catholic schools and orphanages is spreading from Ireland across the rest of Europe, and at the same time the extent of the cover-up is becoming clearer. Even the Pope may have been involved.

The priests who abused and raped the children were individuals, and such people exist in other walks of life too. But the decision to cover up their crimes was a greater crime, for it was made by men whose main concern was protecting the reputation of the large organization which they served, the Catholic Church. They were able to act as they did only because they genuinely believed, and still believe, that the Church is above the law.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

Pope should come here to apologise, says Limerick abuse victim

IRELAND
Limerick Leader

Published Date: 24 March 2010
By Anne Sheridan
A LIMERICK victim of sexual, physical and emotional abuse at the hands of the Christian Brothers wants the Pope to come to Ireland and apologise to victims in person.

Following Pope Benedict's apology to victims of abuse in Ireland, Eddie Bermingham, from Weston, believes the gesture would be more meaningful for victims here if he apologised in person.

Mr Bermingham was sent to Letterfrack Industrial School in Connemara for five years at the age of ten in 1959 for stealing cigarettes from a local shop.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:50 AM

Clerical abuse reports being exploited to discredit Catholics, Elizabeth Lev charges

UNITED STATES
Catholic News Agency

Washington D.C., Mar 24, 2010 / 03:03 am (CNA).- A prominent Catholic writer says “selective” and “salacious” reporting of Catholic clergy in the aftermath of clerical sexual abuse scandals is being used to discredit a “powerful moral voice” in public debate. Acknowledging genuine abuse, she says present day anti-clericalism echoes the slanders of pre-Revolutionary France.

That view comes from Elizabeth Lev, an art historian who has written for Inside the Vatican, Sacerdos and First Things magazine. A regular columnist for Zenit, she is also the daughter of former U.S. Ambassador to the Vatican Mary Ann Glendon.

“While no one denies the wrongdoing and the harm caused by a small minority of priests, their misconduct has been used to undermine the reputations of the overwhelming majority of clergy who live holy quiet lives in their parishes,” Lev writes at Politics Daily.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:46 AM

US: Abuse scandal’s total cost approaches $2.2 billion; most victims male

UNITED STATES
Catholic Culture

March 24, 2010
The clerical abuse scandal cost American dioceses $104,439,629 in 2009, according to an annual report released on March 23 by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB). Only 59% of those funds were allotted to settlements ($55.0 million) and therapy for abuse victims ($6.5 million); the rest was spent on attorneys’ fees ($28.7 million), support for offenders ($10.9 million), and other costs ($3.3 million).

The clerical abuse scandal cost religious institutes an additional $15,648,367 in 2009. These expenses brought the total cost of the clerical abuse scandal to American dioceses and religious institutes between 2004 and 2009 to $2,194,729,859: $1,897,599,482 for dioceses and eparchies, and $297,130,377 for religious institutes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 AM

SNAP Holding Meetings ...

GUAM
Pacific News Center

Guam-They are here to set up a support network for victims of sexual abuse by Guam priest and this week meetings are being held to offer help to those victims who otherwise have not been given any. SNAP believes sexual abuse is rampant within Guam's Catholic Church and while trying to force the church to acknowledge such cases exists, the group also wants the church to provide care to the victims.

The New York Times reports that Catholic sexual abuse cases have declined since 2004, and the local church also reports there have not been any Catholic priest charged or convicted of sexual abuse, but still the survivors network for those abused by Catholic priests is certain there have been cases of sexual abuse by Catholic priests- but believes many of those cases have gone unreported.

But snap hopes to provide an avenue for victims to come forward and seek the support they need.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:41 AM

Germany to establish panel on abuse

GERMANY
CBC News (Canada)

German Chancellor Angela Merkel's cabinet is meeting Wednesday to establish an expert panel to deal with a recent spate of allegations of sexual abuse in the Roman Catholic church and other institutions.

The panel will be headed by the ministries of justice, family and education and is expected to meet for the first time on April 23. The panel will include 40 representatives from the church, the government, charities and educational institutions.

Merkel has said before that the panel should examine past abuses and take a second look at Germany's existing statute of limitations on sex crimes as well as possible compensation for victims of abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:38 AM

The Future of the Catholic Church in Ireland

IRELAND
Beliefnet

Scot McKnight

Wednesday March 24, 2010
This from our friend in Ireland, Patrick Mitchel, a professor and leader. He has no desire to bash the Catholic Church, but he's as grim as many. Let me say that this is a serious, serious issue, and while I want the proper procedures to be followed in the Vatican and beyond, the focus here must, must, must be on the victims of abuse and proper justice for the perpetrators of sexual violence.

Here are Patrick's words:

So what is the future of Catholicism in Ireland?

And this raises the question of 'How can reform come to any church?'

[and again let me say here I am not wanting to 'bash' the Catholic Church when it is 'down'. Nor am I implying that evangelical or Protestant churches have everything right - far from it. I believe the gospel is good news and that churches need to be good news - whatever brand they are]

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:36 AM

They did know, and ignored it

NETHERLANDS
Dutch News

Wednesday 24 March 2010

Cardinal Ad Simonis´s use of a Second World War catch phrase to comment on the sexual abuse of children is indeed loaded, writes Hanneke Sanou.

So the pope has written a letter of apology covering all sexual abuse cases in Ireland, without opening the door to action against the priests involved.

And now Dutch Cardinal Ad Simonis comes out with ‘Wir haben es nicht gewüsst’, ‘a loaded term perhaps’, he says.

A loaded term indeed, and mostly because we know that a large percentage of those who used the phrase did know and chose to turn a blind eye.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:32 AM

March 23, 2010

Gilbert rabbi arrested for allegedly raping 7-year-old girl

GILBERT (AZ)
AZ Family

by Natalie Rivers

GILBERT - U.S. Marshals arrested a rabbi outside of his synagogue in Gilbert for his involvement in a rape case that occurred 10-years ago.

Rabbi Bryan Bramley, 45, was arrested at Temple Beth Shalom Synagogue Tuesday morning by the Child Predator Apprehension Team of the U.S. Marshals and detectives with the New York Police Department.

Rabbi Bramley is accused of raping a 7-year-old girl in March 2000 in New York City.

The alleged rape occurred at the home of Bramley's family while the victim was spending the night. The Bramley's lived in New York during his rabbi studies.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:52 PM

Report: Valley rabbi arrested for sexually assaulting child

ARIZONA
ABC 15

Reported by: Katie Fisher
Email: kfisher@abc15.com

CHANDLER, AZ -- An east Valley rabbi was arrested Tuesday for sexually assaulting a child in New York 10 years ago, according to authorities.

Bryan Bramly, 45, was taken into custody in the parking lot of the Temple Beth Sholom Synagogue in Chandler by members of the U.S. Marshals and detectives with the New York Police Department.

Supervisory Deputy U.S. Marshal Thomas Henman said Rabbi Bramly is accused of raping a 7-year-old girl in March 2000 in New York City.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:47 PM

Arizona Rabbi Arrested for Allegedly Raping Child Ten Years Ago

GILBERT (AZ)
Fox News

A rabbi was arrested outside his synagogue in Gilbert, Arizona, over his alleged involvement in a child rape that occurred ten years ago in New York, according to information released Tuesday by the U.S. Marshals Service.

Bryan Bramley, 45, was arrested in the parking lot of the Temple Beth Sholom Synagogue in Gilbert by members of the U.S. Marshals' Child Predator Apprehension Team and New York detectives.

Rabbi Bramley is accused of raping a seven-year-old girl in March 2000 in New York City.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:44 PM

Rabbi arrested in Arizona for decade-old child rape in New York

ARIZONA
New York Post

A rabbi has been arrested outside of his synagogue in Gilbert, Arizona for his alleged involvement in a child rape that occurred ten years ago in New York, according to information released tonight by the U.S. Marshals Service.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 PM

Italy prelate sees campaign against church over abuse; sex abuse victims respond

ITALY
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Catholic officials are the culprits here, not the victims. To suggest that hundreds of deeply wounded European men and women are somehow conspiring with unethical journalists hurts the very individuals the Pope says he cares about and who are acting responsibly.

The brave victims who are coming forward are helping, not hurting, the Catholic church. They are doing what the Pope, Bagnasco and their colleagues should have done decades ago: exposing predators, warning parents, protecting kids and disclosing truth. They are to be commended and well supported, not vilified and further demeaned.

Bagnasco’s remarks contradict the Pope’s professed sympathy for abuse victims and contribute to the centuries-old and still-prevalent culture of secrecy in the church surrounding child sex crimes and cover ups. Sometimes Catholics wonder why victims can’t speak up sooner. This is one reason- because of the hostility of so-called spiritual figures who profess to be compassionate shepherds but act like cold-hearted CEOs.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:25 PM

Sex abuse victims respond to self-reported numbers from US bishops

UNITED STATES
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests

Statement by David Clohessy, Executive Director of SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (314-566-9790)

We must keep in mind two facts. First, these numbers come from most of the same bishops who concealed and enabled clergy child sex crimes for decades. They are inherently suspect, to say the least.

Second, very few child victims are able to disclose the crimes as they happen, so there always has been and will be decades between the actual offense and the reporting of it.

Given these facts, there are two options. We can either be reckless, assuming that clergy sex crimes are somehow magically being reduced, or we can be prudent, assuming that clergy sex crimes are essentially happening at the same rate, or a higher rate, than before.

Caution, not complacency, is the responsible choice.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 PM

The latest on clergy sex abuse

UNITED STATES
The Washington Times

By Julia Duin on March 23, 2010
SubscribeHow times have changed. Seven years ago, when the US Conference of Catholic Bishops were releasing statistics on how many clergy were sexually abusing children, you could barely push your way into their packed press conference. Today, with their latest statement, there was not even a presser - just a release sent out to media.

In it, which is here, they said that out of the 398 allegations reported in 2009, six (2 percent) occurred last year and 71 percent occurred between 1950-1984. Which supports their claim that abuse stats are essentially a clean-up operation from decades past with 1975-1979 being the high point.

Most of the abuse reported in 2009 was against pre-teen or teen-age males, we should note.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:19 PM

Call the police: that is what the Pope should have said

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ken Macdonald

When I was a child, my mother took me every Wednesday evening to Benediction where, we believed, the body of Christ was revealed. On Saturdays, my family went to confession and every Sunday morning, without fail, we attended Mass. If you asked my mother who and what she was, she would say “a Catholic” before she said “Scottish” or, even less likely, “British”. She believed that the Church of Rome was God’s own glory on Earth.

When I was 11, my parents sent me to a Christian Brothers boarding school. The Brothers were not priests but, even without the significant compensations of priestly rites and privileges, they had dedicated themselves to a life of celibacy, 30 or 40 years without the comfort of touch. We boys knew which of them couldn’t handle it, and we all knew why, from time to time, one or another moved stealthily on to a different school. It wasn’t a secret to us, even if it was to their Church.

The rituals of cleansing were no more worthy. In the past, when a priest raped a young Catholic, the child could expect to be offered absolution for the sin. If this seems a little shocking, we shouldn’t be too surprised. It’s a common enough trick of authoritarian religions to blame the victims of sexual violence for participating in their own abuse, particularly if the violator occupies the pulpit rather than a pew. Surely, such a terrible sin could only occur in the face of the most devilish temptation, presented without any shame.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:15 PM

Former chorister makes sex abuse claim against Georg Ratzinger's choir

GERMANY
The Times (United Kingdom)

Richard Owen, Rome

Georg Ratzinger, the Pope's brother, was drawn further into the paedophile scandal embroiling the Catholic Church yesterday after a former member of the school choir that he ran claimed to have been sexually abused.

Although Monsignor Ratzinger, 86, recently admitted slapping choirboys while running the renowned Domspatzen choir in Bavaria, he also said that was never aware of any sex abuse during his tenure as choirmaster from 1964 to 1994. He is not implicated in the allegations.

However, Clemens Neck, a spokesman for Regensburg diocese, which includes the school, said that sex abuse allegations against four priests and two nuns were being investigated and that one inquiry related to claims made by a former Domspatzen choirboy that a teacher abused him for months in 1971.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:12 PM

Claims aim to tarnish church: Vatican

VATICAN CITY
Montreal Gazette

By DANIEL FLYNN, Reuters

March 23, 2010 2:03 PM The Vatican criticized yesterday what it said was a bid to undermine the Roman Catholic Church, which is facing a deepening scandal over child abuse by priests in Europe.

As fresh allegations mounted against clergy in Austria, adding to hundreds of cases in Germany and the Netherlands, Vatican Secretary of State Tarcisio Bertone acknowledged that confidence in the church had declined.

"There has been a reduction in faith in all institutions, including the church," said Bertone, second in the Vatican hierarchy, after meeting Italian business leaders.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:21 PM

‘The Confession’ tackles priest abuse

GERMANY
MSNBC

By Andy Eckardt, NBC News Producer
MAINZ, Germany – "The Confession," a play that recently opened in the German city of Regensburg, could not be more timely or its location more symbolic.

The play tells the story of an orphaned choir boy who was abused by his priest, and later, as an adult, abuses his own child. In order to protect his son from the same destiny, the main character is determined to kill himself and his boy. But first, he confronts the priest, his former guardian and tormentor, in a confession that culminates in a disturbing dispute between the two men.

"When we planned this small production a year ago, we could not have imagined that it would be such a fitting sign of the times, and we have been overwhelmed by the attention it has received recently," said Friederike Bernau, a spokesperson for the Regensburg theater.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:17 PM

Survey reports decline in number of U.S. victims of clergy abuse

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

By Michelle Boorstein

Even as new clergy sex abuse scandals are unfolding across Catholic Europe, the American church today released its annual survey on the subject, showing -- as the survey has for years -- a drop in number of victims, allegations and perpetrators.

The annual survey-- funded by the bishops but done by independent researchers--relies primarily on data supplied by dioceses themselves. It said 398 new victims came forward last year with "credible allegations of sexual abuse" of a minor, down each year from 889 in 2004. They named 286 priests and deacons, 45 percent of whom had never been named before.

The U.S. church last year paid out $104 million, including $6.5 million for victims' therapy, $10.9 million for offenders (including therapy and living expenses) and $28.7 million in attorneys' fees.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:11 PM

SNAP gives abuse victims a voice

GUAM
Pacific Daily News

By Brett Kelman • Pacific Daily News • March 24, 2010

Childhood sexual abuse left Joelle Casteix on a path to suicide, but a public bond with other victims ended her "shameful little secret" and let her blossom through the most enriching time of her life.

Casteix was sexually abused by a Catholic school choir teacher as a teenager, but she didn't take her abuser to a court until 2003.

She left that California court with a settlement, a signed confession and a connection with other abuse victims who had been haunted since they were children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:56 PM

The enraged anti-Catholic mob

IRELAND
Trinity News

Written by Eamonn Hynes

The angry mob that has sprung up in response to Church paedophila needs to calm down, according to Eamonn Hynes.

There’s nothing like a good paedophile story to drum up the outraged, liberal-media-reading masses; most of whom have never experienced the horrors of child abuse, nor are they charged with cleaning up the mess left behind by a bunch of sick perverts. Cribbing and moaning from the sidelines and making snipes at the Catholic Church are the tactics of a coward and symptoms of their ignorance. It is in an air of calm that I write this piece in support of the Irish Catholic Church and in support of the Irish clergy in their mission to cleanse the institution and continue on the path of repentance, healing and renewal.

First off, we should calm down. Is one really that interested in the kind of slippery implication that one reads about in the holier-than-thou Irish media who bandy about terms such as “misprision of felony” and the 1937 Offences Against the State Act like bullies in a school yard.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:53 PM

Audit Shows Fewest Reports of Sexual Abuse by Clerics since 2004; Most Incidents from Decades Ago

UNITED STATES
United States Conference of Catholic Bishops

WASHINGTON—The 2009 annual report on compliance with the U.S. bishops’ Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People shows the fewest number of victims, allegations and offenders in dioceses since 2004. Most cases reported to dioceses were from decades ago.

The data show that in 2009 there were 398 allegations and 286 offenders reported to dioceses, most from earlier decades. Of the allegations reported in 2009, six allegations (2 percent) involved children under the age of 18 in 2009. About an eighth of the allegations in 2009 (48) were unsubstantiated or determined to be false by the end of the year.

Similar declines were found in data from religious orders of men.

Data for the 2009 calendar year were collected by the Georgetown University-based Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA). It began gathering data on sexual abuse of minors by clerics in 2004 as part of the bishops’ annual report on compliance with the Charter. The audit report can be found at http://www.usccb.org/ocyp/annual_report2009.shtml

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:48 PM

Child sex abuse by US Catholic clergy down sharply: study

UNITED STATES
AFP

WASHINGTON — Pay-outs by the US Roman Catholic church for child abuse cases involving clergy members fell to a six-year low last year but remained in the nine-figure range, an annual US report tracking clergy sex abuse of minors said Tuesday.

Nearly 400 new, credible allegations of clergy sex abuse were reported in 2009, said the report, which comes as the Roman Catholic church struggles to deal with thousands of alleged sex offenses by clerics against children in Europe and South America.

In the United States, the Roman Catholic church paid out 104,439,629 dollars last year in costs related to sex abuse cases, more than half of the money -- 55 million dollars -- in settlements for victims, the report showed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:46 PM

Sex abuse suit names former Waterville priest

WASHINGTON
The Wenatchee World

By Michelle McNiel
World staff writer

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

WATERVILLE — A former Waterville priest who died nearly 20 years ago has been accused of child sexual abuse in the early 1970s.

A lawsuit filed Thursday in Yakima County Superior Court accused the Rev. Joseph Graaff of abusing a child several times in the rectory of St. Joseph’s Catholic Church of Waterville.

It is apparently the first lawsuit over alleged child sexual abuse against a Catholic priest in North Central Washington.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:39 PM

Milwaukee SNAP Representatives Head To Rome

UNITED STATES
WISN

Two Milwaukee members of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests will be going to Europe and the Vatican to offer help to adults who were sexually abused by Catholic priests.

SNAP’s Midwest Director Peter Isely and Wisconsin Co-Director John Pilmaier will join SNAP's national director from Chicago and SNAP's outreach director from St. Louis.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:36 PM

The Catholic Church and the Child Sexual Abuse Scandal

UNITED STATES
WAMU

[audio presentation]

Guests
Joseph Bottum Editor of First Things, the nation’s largest magazine of religion and public life. He is a commentator on Catholic Affairs.

Rev. Thomas Doyle Canon lawyer, addiction therapist and advisory to abuse victims. He worked in the Vatican's U.S. embassy from 1981-1986.

David Gibson Covers religion for Politics Daily. He is the author of "The Rule of Benedict: Pope Benedict XVI and His Battle with the Modern World."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 3:32 PM

St. Galler Bischof will Schwarze Liste

SWITZERLAND
Blick

ST. GALLEN - Markus Büchel, Bischoff von St. Gallen, widerspicht im Kampf gegen sexuelle Ausbeutung in der Kirche dem oberste Bischof der Schweiz.

[summary]

Bishop Markus Buchel deviates from the line of the President of the Swiss bishops, Norbert Brunner. The St. Gallen bishop is committed to a blacklist for church people involved in sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:43 PM

Benedict's record on abuse: all talk and no action

UNITED STATES
National Catholic Reporter

Mar. 19, 2010
By David Clohessy

As disclosures of carefully concealed clergy sex crimes surface by the hundreds across Europe, even in Pope Benedict's native Germany, defenders of the pontiff are working overtime.

"As pope, he has been unusually and laudably aggressive in dealing with abusers," says David Gibson, author of a Benedict biography.

"[On abuse] Pope Benedict XVI has made it clear that no one, however well-connected, gets a free pass," writes John Allen of National Catholic Reporter.

Well, let's look clearly at Benedict's track record, as pope, on clergy sex crimes and cover ups. He has done three things.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:37 PM

Abuse case priest living in Strabane

IRELAND
Derry Journal

Published Date: 23 March 2010
The priest at the centre of a child sex abuse controversy in the Derry diocese is living in Strabane Parochial House, the 'Journal' can confirm.

Derry's dioscesan hierarchy was alerted to serious allegations against Fr John J McCullagh in 1994 and a settlement of £12,000 was paid to the alleged victim by the disgraced priest, who denied the allegations.

Diocesan spokesman Fr Michael Canny, said that Fr McCullagh was subject to strict rules imposed by the Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:34 PM

Austria: Priest resigns after admitting abuse

AUSTRIA
The Associated Press

VIENNA — An Austrian diocese says a priest has resigned after admitting he abused a 17-year-old boy.

The Graz-Seckau diocese says the priest stepped down of his own accord and that the abuse happened more than 20 years ago on a vacation.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:31 PM

“Pope’s letter is a pointer to the future”

IRELAND
Ocean FM

A survivor of clerical sex abuse said the Pope’s letter apologising to victims is not a magic wand which will wave away the pain suffered at the hands of priests and the religious.

Fr.John O’Brien, who was abused when he was in the seminary in 1979, accepted Pope Benedict the sixteenth’s sentiments that he was ”truly sorry”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:28 PM

Mass walk-out in Duiske Abbey

IRELAND
Kilkenny People

Published Date: 23 March 2010
By Staff Reporter

A NUMBER of parishioners stormed out of Mass in Duiske Abbey, Graignamanagh last week following a confrontation between the local parish priest and a member of the congregation.

In the middle of his sermon at Duiske Abbey on Tuesday, March 16, Fr Gerald Byrne asked where were the parents of the two child abuse victims at the centre of the Cardinal Brady row over his part in interviewing them as victims of notorious paedophile, Fr Brendan Smyth in 1975

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:16 PM

El Vaticano investiga 14 casos de pederastia en España

SPAIN
EcoDiario

El escándalo de los casos de pederastia por parte de la Iglesia salpica a España. "España es uno de los países con menos casos denunciados", señalaba Charles J. Scicluna, promotor de Justicia del Vaticano y máximo responsable de las investigaciones de curas y religiosos sospechosos de abusos sexuales a menores en la Iglesia católica.

[summary]

The scandal of sexual abuse cases from the church has splashed Spain. Charles J. Scicluna, promoter for Vatican justice and chief of investigations for priests suspected of child sexual abuse, said Spain has fewer reported cases. From January 2001 to March 2010 there were 14 cases sent to the Vatican which is less than one case per year-and-a-half, he said. The church assumes there are at least 25 Spanish priests and religious involved in sexual abuse cases in the past 20 years.

Leire Pajin, secretary of the Organization of the PSOE, said everyone -- citizens and governments -- has the legal and moral obligation to cooperate in the investigations and to shed light on all cases of abuse with the Catholic Church. The socialist leader also stressed that the Catholic community wants clarification on these cases and Catholics are demanding investigation and for the full weight of the law to fall on the guilty. Pajin said the crime of pedophilia is one of the most disgusting that there is. When asked by reporters, he avoided assessing the statement made this past weekend by Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:45 AM

Vatican investigating 14 sex abuse cases in Spain

SPAIN
The Times (United Kingdom)

Graham Keeley, Madrid

The Vatican is investigating 14 cases of alleged child sex abuse committed within the Spanish Catholic Church over the past nine years it emerged today.

The incidents of abuse are alleged to take have taken place between January 2001 and March 2010. Charles Scicluna, the promoter of justice in the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, said today they amounted to "less than one case every year".

Monsignor Scicluna stressed that Spain was one of the countries with the “lowest number of alleged abuse investigations” and said no convictions had been made.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:58 AM

Did Archbishop Ratzinger Help Shield Perpetrator from Prosecution?

GERMANY
Spiegel

By Dietmar Hipp, Frank Hornig, Conny Neumann, Sven Röbel and Peter Wensierski

After long delays, the Catholic Church finally appears to be taking responsibility for sexual abuse cases. But it is an uncomfortable process. The pope even failed to take the problem of child abuse seriously when he was the archbishop of Munich.

Peter H. simply cannot understand why allegations are being made against him now -- especially after all these years. "Why me of all people?" the priest asked during a phone conversation with his friend, the mayor of Garching, a town near his own, Bad Tölz, in Bavaria.

Yes, why him of all people? Especially when there are so many priests who have committed sins against children, and so many who have been treated leniently by the church. Back in 1980, even Joseph Ratzinger -- then the archbishop of Munich, and now Pope Benedict XVI -- had played a role in the decision to handle Peter H.'s pedophiliac infractions internally. No police, no state prosecutor, no trial. Therapy and brotherly love would bring this sinner back to the fold. ...

The Diocesan Council, chaired by Archbishop Ratzinger, dealt with the case in Munich on Jan. 15, 1980. According to the minutes of the meeting, "Point 5d" on the agenda saw the council discussing Peter H., who had requested "accommodation and support in a Munich parsonage for a while." The request also stated that "Chaplain H. will undergo psychological therapeutic treatment."

Ratzinger Knew Police Hadn't Been Informed

A policeman's son, Ratzinger was well aware that no one had notified the police and that everything had been handled by the Church internally. Neither he nor his diocese reported the case to the authorities. Instead, a brief, succinct statement concerning the chaplain's application was entered into the minutes: "The request is granted."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:53 AM

Missbrauch: 64-jähriger Pfarrer in Ruhestand versetzt

GERMANY
Zeit

Essen/Duisburg (dpa) - Das Bistum Fulda hat nach Angaben des Bistums Essen einen in Duisburg tätigen Pfarrer in den einstweiligen Ruhestand versetzt. Zuvor war bekannt geworden, dass der 64-Jährige vor mehreren Jahren wegen sexuellen Missbrauchs im Bereich des Bistums Fulda verurteilt worden war.

[summary]

The Fulda diocese had a priest on active duty before it became known that the 64-year-old priest was sentenced for sexual abuse in the diocese. He was later moved to Duisburg and was used in Altenseelsorge. There have been no further complaints. He is alleged to have abused minors during the 1980s and 1990s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:36 AM

Diözese Graz-Seckau greift gegen Missbrauchs-Priester durch

AUSTRIA
GGG

Die Diözese Graz-Seckau greift in der Missbrauchs-Causa hart durch: Die Priester der Gemeinden Graz-Puntigam, Gußwerk und des Pfarrverbandes Deutschlandsberg wurden dienstfrei gestellt.

[summary]

The Graz-Seckau diocese in cracking down on abuse. Three priests have been removed from duty. One of the three is said to have abused a teenager 20 years ago on a vacation trip. He was questioned upon notification of the ombudsman's office and admitted the deed. Two other priests have been convicted.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:30 AM

Pope failed to address the 'culture of secrecy'

IRELAND
Derry Journal

Published Date: 23 March 2010
By Staff reporter
Voice of the Faithful (VOTF), a group that was formed in response to the clerical sex abuse scandal in the Catholic Church, has hit out at Pope Benedict XVI's failure to address a "culture of secrecy" that compounded the suffering of victims - in his pastoral letter.

At weekend Masses Pope Benedict’s letter was read out to congregations in parishes across the North West. The Pope issued a heartfelt personal apology to the people of Ireland and to thousands of victims of sexual abuse by Catholic priests.

A number of Derry priests were said to be visibly upset while reading the letter, telling the people they shared in their “anger” about the abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:24 AM

New Victim of Eleuterio Ramos Comes Forward, Plans to Sue Orange Diocese

ORANGE COUNTY (CA)
Orange County Weekly

By Gustavo Arellano, Tuesday, Mar. 23 2010

​Even from the depths of Hell, the legacy of Eleuterio Ramos--the most prolific pedophile priest in the history of the Catholic Diocese of Orange, a man shielded from the authorities by every bishop Orange ever hosted--continues to torment the county's Catholic hierarchy. Ramos alone cost Bishop Tod D. Brown millions of dollars in civil settlements, and His Excellency better get ready to pass around the collection plate once more: a new Ramos victim has stepped forward and is planning to sue for their abuse.

The victim (whose name the Weekly is withholding--we're not the Orange County Register, after all) says they were molested by Ramos during the 1970s but only recently was motivated to come forward after reading my 2005 piece, "King of the County Pedophiles," online. The victim has already hired an attorney, San Pedro-based Werner Meissner, and are planning to file a lawsuit against the Orange diocese soon.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:20 AM

Pope's critics must get their facts straight

AUSTRALIA
The Australian

George Pell

THE evil of sexual abuse has no place in the Catholic Church and no one should doubt Benedict XVI's resolve to see it eradicated. His unprecedented pastoral letter to the Catholics of Ireland reflects his deep compassion for the victims of sexual abuse and his strong commitment to seeing that justice is done.

The Pope has met victims of sexual abuse in Australia and elsewhere. He has heard first-hand what they have suffered.

He is a man of immense compassion and goodness, and is personally committed to doing all he can to bring justice and healing to the victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:59 AM

Readers respond regarding clergy abuse, false accusations

UNITED STATES
Renew America

By Matt C. Abbott

The following are several (slightly edited) e-mails I received in response to my March 18 column "Was priest falsely accused?" Many thanks to those who provided me with insightful comments on this sensitive matter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:35 AM

Papal letter is ‘completely and utterly inadequate’

IRELAND
The Mayo News

Áine Ryan

‘COMPLETELY and utterly inadequate’. That was the reaction last night of the Director of the Mayo Rape Crisis Centre (MRCC), Ms Ruth McNeely, to the Pope’s pastoral letter, to the Catholics of Ireland, about clerical sexual abuse.

Also responding, Mayo News columnist, and leading commentator on the scandal, Father Kevin Hegarty (pictured below) said ‘it was only the victims themselves that can judge whether Pope Benedict’s letter meets their pain in any way’.

Published at the weekend, details of Pope Benedict XVI’s pastoral letter were read at all Masses throughout the country. In it he apologised for the deep hurt caused to abuse victims and their families. “You have suffered grievously, and I am truly sorry,” the Pope said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:31 AM

Sexual abuse admission by Dutch ex-priest

NETHERLANDS
Expatica

For the second time in a week a former priest in the Netherlands has confessed he sexually assaulted children at a monastery boarding school.

The man 68 admitted to Radio Netherlands Worldwide that he had indecently fondled three boys, but emphasised that he did not go beyond that. The abuse occurred at the Don Rua monastery in the town of 's-Heerenberg in the eastern Netherlands.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:27 AM

Healing Legislation

UNITED STATES
Healing and Spirituality

Dr. Jaime Romo

I spent last weekend at the International Male Survivor conference. It was counter-intuitive to go somewhere with such a focus on the complexities and impact of sexual abuse on males to find so much wisdom and healing people and positive energy.

It was a gathering of survivors of sexual abuse and supporters, including members of the therapeutic community as survivors and supporters. I attended workshops about incest, clergy abuse, multiple personalities, international healing efforts, and the current struggle to help the NY Senate to pass a bill that has been passed three times by the House and rejected by the Senate to change the statute of limitations (SOL). Some people think that SOL means ‘simply out of luck.’ I prefer to think that the repeal of the SOL in New York would represent a new Statute of Liberty.

I’ll paraphrase a presentation by Harvard law professor, Larry Lessig, who discussed blame and responsibility for ending sexual abuse. He was the attorney who took up the John Hardwicke case in New Jersey, which overturned a law that gave immunity to charitable organizations (e.g., churches), even when sexual abuse of minors was well documented and rampant at the American Boychoir School.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:21 AM

Abuse victim calls for Catholic Church files to be handed to authorities

NORTHERN IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Tuesday, 23 March 2010

A victim of clerical abuse in Londonderry has called for all files concerning the abuse held by the Catholic Church to be given to the civil authorities.

John McCourt was one of five victims who met with Bishop Seamus Hegarty last week at St Eugene's Cathedral.

The group received an apology for the abuse they suffered at the hands of the Sisters of Nazareth.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:07 AM

Church fails to tap into depth of feeling on abuse scandals

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

By Laurence White
Monday, 22 March 2010

The Catholic Church — and I suppose most organised denominations — finds it difficult to communicate with its followers.

Listen to any sermon on any Sunday as the priest tries to make a theological message relevant to today’s society. After a few minutes and you will notice that the attention of many in the congregation has begun to wander.

Pastoral letters from Bishops are even harder going. Read out at Masses on occasions like Easter or Christmas their message is often even more impenetrable. The church hierarchy does not talk the language of the ordinary person.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Police arrest church leader for alleged molestation

JASPER (TX)
Beaumont Enterprise

By JASPER NEWSBOY
March 22, 2010

Jasper Police arrested a local youth minister Friday and charged him with possession of marijuana and one count of aggravated sexual assault of a child.

Dwight L. Bullock was arrested Friday by Jasper police while conducting an investigation into multiple child molestation allegations. Bullock is a youth leader at Moore Chapel CME Church, located on South Bowie.

"We were investigating a call from parents alleging their children had made outcries of sexual abuse," said Jasper Police Chief Todd Hunter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:56 AM

Prague Archbishop: Irish campaign to push church from education

CZECH REPUBLIC
Prague Daily Monitor

ČTK | 23 March 2010
March 22 (CTK) - New Prague Archbishop Dominik Duka said the developments around sexual abuse of children in Irish Catholic schools is a campaign aimed to push the church from education and cut it off financial resources, in his reaction to Pope Benedict XVI's pastoral letter he gave to CTK Monday.

The Pope rebuked the Irish bishops for their unsuitable stand on the abuse of children by Catholic clergy.

Duka said, however, the church must take resolute steps against such failures.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:52 AM

Doing my Vatican rag

AUSTRALIA
Star Observer

Doug Pollard

I had one of those moments this week, where I quite literally could not believe my ears.
At the end of yet another report of child abuse by Roman Catholic priests, Anton Enus added, in an almost throwaway fashion, “Victim advocates estimate that up to half a million children have been abused at the hands of the Catholic Church over the last 50 years.”

Pope Benedict, in his former role as the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (formerly called the Inquisition), banned anyone from speaking about the abuse outside the church. The criminals were protected and the victims silenced in order to safeguard the church’s image.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:50 AM

Where was the real cover up?

VATICAN CITY
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Andrew Brown

I said there was something extraordinary and rather shocking hidden in Mgr Charles Scicluna's interview last week. It's hidden in plain sight, so obvious that it has so far been invisible: there was no Vatican conspiracy. There was no Vatican cover-up.

Instead of one centrally ordered cover-up, there were hundreds of little local ones. They didn't require special regulations. They grew quite naturally out of the clerical culture. They worked by silence and omission rather than anything more obviously sinister. The scandal is going to be much worse as a result.

Now the one thing that everybody knows about the Vatican is that it is an organisation which all priests must obey and all Catholics should, and that it has conspiracies, policies, secret orders written in Latin and so on. I don't expect anyone who believes in this to be persuaded. But here is the evidence, anyway.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:46 AM

Gran's protest interrupts Mass

IRELAND
Donegal Democrat

A grandmother who interrupted Sunday Mass at a Donegal church received a round of applause from a large section of the congregation after she spoke from the Altar condemning the church for its role in child sexual abuse.

As she left the Altar the unidentified woman was applauded by a majority of the congregation for four to five seconds. The woman said as she left that she was walking out of the Mass in protest and she asked others to follow her.

As best as this reporter could see, in the congregation of approximately 400, no one followed the woman out of the church in protest.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:42 AM

Brady should not quit, says prelate of Kerry

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Ralph Riegel

Tuesday March 23 2010

A SENIOR bishop yesterday came to the support of embattled Cardinal Sean Brady and insisted he should remain as head of the Catholic Church in Ireland.

The Bishop of Kerry, Dr Bill Murphy, also claimed there were no secrecy oaths for abuse victims in his diocese.

Dr Murphy stressed he did not believe the cardinal should resign. He said Dr Brady had worked long and hard to tackle the challenges facing the church, including the need to improve child protection.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Perpetrators, Victims, Sexual Assaults, Gang-like Behavior and Abuse

GERMANY
OpEd News

By Kevin Stoda, Wiesbaden, Germany

"Another child abuse scandal is in the German press. Frankfurter Rundschau newspaper says that up to 100 pupils at a school in Hesse may have been victims between 1971 and 1985. Odenwaldschule is an elitist, private school with famous alumni like the writer, Klaus Mann." The charges at the Odenwald School come in the midst of a major set of scandals raising the same charges against priests at catholic schools and institutions across Germany.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:36 AM

Time for reparation for the sins of the fathers

IRELAND
The Mayo News

Tuesday, 23 March 2010 11:42

Liamy MacNally

The good priests must be cringing. A hierarchy intent on saving face is dragging these fine and holy men - wounded healers – through the mire of ecclesiastical mediocrity. Why are bishops constantly back-peddling when a scandal is revealed? This only adds insult to injury for people already immersed in deep pain after being abused. Today the perception is that the bishops simply still do not get it. They appear to be immune from reality. Unfortunately for the many decent men among the hierarchy they are all being painted with the same brush. It is down to perception. The result is that they become further alienated from those who have been wounded and heap pain upon cathedral pain. They also become estranged from the faithful.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:33 AM

Zambia: The Great Shame of the Catholic Church

ZAMBIA
allAfrica

Davis Mataka
23 March 2010

AS I fiddled with the remote control last week, surfing from one news channel to the other, my favourite pastime when I find the rare opportunity to be home with my family, I couldn't help but be drawn to the Catholic sex abuse scandal which has been receiving unprecedented airtime on most major international stations and has just refused to go away.

Thanks to DStv and their revolutionary PVR I we no longer have to fight over the same remote with my three young sons as they jostle amongst themselves for supremacy over this technological invention, in my view the second best ever since the invention of toast bread.

I say so because I was saved the prodding and embarrassing questions of my teenage son asking me what the fuss was about the Catholic Church and the sex scandals, the next obvious question would have been why priests in that Church did not have wives- well like I said, the distant bickering, hardly audible from some corner of the house was about Hanna Montana or some Ben -Ten, what a relief.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:31 AM

Church Adds More Abuse Cases to Its Inquiry in Germany

GERMANY
The New York Times

By NICHOLAS KULISH
Published: March 22, 2010

MUNICH — The investigation into sexual abuse by clergy members in Germany expanded Monday to take in four more priests and two nuns in the Regensburg Diocese in Bavaria after new victims came forward there, the diocese said Monday.

The widening scandal in the Roman Catholic Church in the pope’s native Germany has cast a shadow on the Vatican, with allegations touching his former archdiocese. Hundreds of victims have come forward in Germany since reports of abuse at a Catholic school in Berlin became public in January, with others reported in Austria and the Netherlands.

The claims of sexual abuse in Regensburg have attracted particular attention because the brother of Pope Benedict XVI, Msgr. Georg Ratzinger, directed a choir there from 1964 to 1994, raising questions about whether he would have known about sexual abuse at a school linked to the choir. Monsignor Ratzinger has said that he knew nothing about the sexual abuse, and he apologized for slapping students during his tenure.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:27 AM

Benedict’s Fragile Church

GERMANY
The New York Times

By PETER SCHNEIDER
Published: March 22, 2010
Berlin

POPE BENEDICT XVI’s strongly worded apology for the child-abuse scandal in Ireland, issued last week, left Germans like myself scratching our heads.

Where is the apology for the abuses in Germany? After all, even as the number of Irish abuse cases mounts, the depth and history of abuse in Germany is just now becoming clear — more than 250 cases are known, with more appearing each day. At least 14 priests are under investigation by the authorities.

Though Germany is a secular country and Catholics make up only a third of the population, the scandal has engendered a national debate — about religious education, about single-sex institutions and, above all, about the role of celibacy in the Catholic Church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:24 AM

Mexican archdiocese notes firm condemnation of abuse by Pope Benedict

MEXICO
Catholic News Agency

Mexico City, Mexico, Mar 22, 2010 / 09:58 pm (CNA).- In a press release last week titled, “The Church, Between Trust and Mistrust,” the Archdiocese of Acapulco in Mexico underscored Pope Benedict XVI’s firm rejection of clerical sex abuse and condemned the media campaign attacking the Catholic Church.

“The cases of sexual abuse by some clergy members in different regions of world, especially in Europe and the United States, have caused much embarrassment and pain,” the statement indicated. “Pope Benedict XVI has called this repugnant conduct an atrocious crime that must always be condemned, especially when committed by clergymen.”

After acknowledging that only a few media sources have accurately covered this issue, the press release noted that “reports have maliciously magnified the actions with the intent of discrediting the Church and confusing the faithful.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

'Fr X' assaulted student priest but hierarchy took no action

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Ralph Riegel

Tuesday March 23 2010

SERIOUS concerns were raised almost 20 years ago about the suitability of a priest who was later at the centre of two separate sexual abuse allegations, the Irish Independent has learned.

The priest, who can only be named as 'Fr X' for legal reasons, was ordained despite being the subject of complaints by a fellow seminarian.

Cardinal Sean Brady admitted last week that he was also sued by a young woman who accused 'Fr X' of raping her in 1997. The case was only settled in January, with the woman receiving €50,000.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:18 AM

Bishop failed to contact gardai

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Breda Heffernan, Pat Flynn and Gordon Deegan

Tuesday March 23 2010

A SENIOR bishop has admitted he failed to contact gardai while investigating sexual abuse allegations against two priests in the Dublin archdiocese 20 years ago.

Bishop Willie Walsh was one of three 'judges' who were asked to handle the investigation into notorious serial child abuser Fr William Carney and a second, as yet unnamed, priest.

The Killaloe bishop, due to resign soon because of his age, said yesterday that although he did not contact gardai at the time, he would do so today if he was in a similar position.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:16 AM

Concerns over priest surfaced nearly 20 years ago

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Tuesday, 23 March 2010

Concerns were raised almost 20 years ago about the suitability of a priest later at the centre of two separate sexual abuse allegations, it has been learned.

The priest, who can only be named as ‘Fr X' for legal reasons, was ordained despite a complaint from a fellow seminarian in the early 1990s.

Cardinal Sean Brady last week admitted he was sued by a young woman in the South who accused the priest of raping her in 1997. The case was settled in January when she received €50,000 (£45,000).

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:13 AM

Celestine Bohlen: Sex crime cover-up exposes Vatican failings

Las Cruces Sun-News (United States)

By Celestine Bohlen / Bloomberg News
Posted: 03/23/2010

PARIS - The time is right for the Catholic Church to drop its celibacy rule for priests. As new cases of child sex abuse erupt across the globe, even church leaders are suggesting the question be examined. At the Vatican's usual pace, this might bring change by the end of this century. Marriage, of course, won't make pedophilia go away. It's well known that most cases occur within families.

Still, the vows of chastity imposed on Catholic priests since 1139 don't help, nor does the church's attitude to sexuality in general. Sex outside marriage, homosexual "practices," masturbation: The church still condemns all of it on the anachronistic, almost tribal pretext that sex should only be about procreation.

No wonder some devout Catholics seek the celibacy of the priesthood to bury "their conflict-laden sexuality," as Klaus Beier, head of the Institute for Sexology and Sexual Medicine in Berlin, put it. No wonder the ranks of the Catholic priesthood are dwindling.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:11 AM

SNAP names priest for alleged sexual abuse

GUAM
KUAM

[with video]

by Mindy Aguon

Guam - The Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests is hoping to provide a support group for individuals on Guam who have been victims of sexual abuse at the hands of members of clergy. In preparation for the support meetings that will be held over the next two days, the organization uncovered some disturbing information about clergy who have spent time on Guam in the hopes that victims of sexual abuse at the hands of priests or other church members will have the courage to come forward.

Although the Archdiocese of Agana has made it clear that no member of the clergy on Guam, has ever been convicted or charged with sexually abusing children on the island, SNAP believes there is strong evidence to support claims that abuse has happened and may still be occurring on Guam.

"I believe that Guam has been a dumping ground for priests who've had problems elsewhere because they knew that the close-knit Catholic community on Guam would not complain, and that's tragic, and it needs to stop," proclaimed SNAP Southwest Regional Director Joelle Casteix. She says as she prepared for her trip to the island, she inquired with the SNAP Network if anyone had information about clergy abusers on Guam.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:07 AM

No report on church sex abuse

TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
Triniday and Tobago's Newsday

By RHONDOR DOWLAT Tuesday, March 23 2010

POLICE sources yesterday claimed they were unaware of any official report made against any religious organisation or religious leader in this country regarding sex abuse in the church and/or among churchgoers.

Sources added that if any such report is made, it will be investigated promptly. “Providing that what we have gathered in the investigation is strong, we would then compile a report and send the file to the Director of Public Prosecutions who will determine whether any charge would be laid and what they will be charged for,” a police source said.

On Saturday last, Pope Benedict XVI issued a pastoral letter to Irish Catholics in which he apologised for the church’s handling of cases of child sex abuse in Ireland. The apology was displayed outside the Vatican walls.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:05 AM

SNAP Presents Allegations ...

GUAM
Pacific News Center

Guam- She's ruffled some feathers within the Catholic Church on Guam, calling on the Archbishop to acknowledge that sexual abuse by Guam Clergymen is very real.

And this week the Southwest Regional Director for the support group SNAP, Joelle Casteix, is on island to conduct meetings with victims, and press the Catholic Church here to offer support to victims of the alleged sexual abuses.

SNAP stands for Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. It's a group established to offer support to victims who seem to have no other recourse.

Casteix says her mission is to empower victims and let them know they are not alone, and to help them heal. She says it is also the church's responsibility to help the victims, but the local church, Castiex says, has refused to acknowledge that these cases even exist.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:02 AM

Priest: 'I cannot live this life of celibacy'

OREGON
Ashland Daily Tidings

By Nancy Haught
The Oregonian
March 23, 2010 PORTLAND — The Rev. Tom Farley looked at packed pews Sunday morning and made a promise.

"There is an elephant in the room," Farley said as Mass began at St. Clare Catholic Church in southwest Portland. "But we'll talk about it later — after Communion. "

He was referring to the letter he'd sent to the congregation last week, which detailed why these Sunday Masses would be his last as a priest.

"I leave because of a private longing in my heart and soul that I have ignored or suppressed to my detriment," he wrote in the letter. "I love priestly ministry but I cannot live this life of celibacy."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:59 AM

The pope, human rights and call centres

CANADA
The Chronicle-Herald

By PAUL SCHNEIDEREIT
Tue. Mar 23

REMEMBER the public outrage when Ontario dabbled, a few years back, with the idea of allowing Shariah law to be used to settle family disputes?

In the end, that province wisely rejected that course, holding (what should have been obvious all along) that there must be only one law — the secular law of the state.

The Vatican should now be getting the same message from every country where Catholic priests, aided by a wilful failure to act by their superiors, have been sexually abusing children for decades, if not centuries.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:57 AM

Rwanda: Time for the Vatican to Come Clean On the Genocide

RWANDA
allAfrica

editorial

Kigali — The Vatican is awash with yet another sexual scandal that has had the Pope wringing his hands, as he tries to save the dented image of the Catholic Church.

After a similar scandal broke out in the US in 2002, the church ordered an "apostolic visitation" into U.S. seminaries to douse the flames.

Now the spotlight is directed on one of the bastions of Catholicism; the Irish church, which is accused of concealing decades of abuse by its leaders.

Paedophilia in religious orders has been an open secret, and the church has gone to great lengths to sweep it under the carpet. Now it has been forced to come out in the open and seek forgiveness for the sins of its trusted elite.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:54 AM

Canadian bishops deplore Hitchens article against Pope

CANADA
Catholic Culture

March 23, 2010
The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops issued a statement on March 18 criticizing two articles on the abuse scandal.

“We strongly deplore the tone of these articles which are offensive to Canadian Catholics and imply that the Church has not responded to the problem of sexual abuse,” the bishops’ statement notes. “This is false, and the accusations are evidently influenced by prejudice.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:51 AM

Plea bargain in Kentucky priest’s abuse case

KENTUCKY
Catholic Culture

March 23, 2010
A priest of the Diocese of Lexington will likely serve one year in prison following a plea agreement in an abuse case.

Two males allegedly abused in the 1980s “were willing to testify” against Father Joseph Muench, 59, “but they didn't want their identity to be made public,” said the local prosecutor. “These guys have had a lot of emotional problems; they've been in counseling; they've been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of this.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:47 AM

Report: Catholic clergy abuse claims drop in US

UNITED STATES
The Associated Press

By ERIC GORSKI (AP)

While the Roman Catholic church in Europe reels from a widening sex abuse crisis, the scandal that has plagued the U.S. church for nearly a decade is tapering off, a report released Tuesday says.

The number of abuse victims, allegations and offending clergy in the U.S. dropped in 2009 to their lowest numbers since data started being collected in 2004, the report said.

The price paid by the church has fallen, too. Dioceses and their insurers paid $104 million in settlements, attorneys' fees and other abuse-related costs in 2009, down from $376 million in 2008.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:44 AM

Catholic Church ignores lessons from Canada

CANADA
GlobalPost

By Sandro Contenta , GlobalPost
Published: March 23, 2010

TORONTO, Canada — As a kid, I had no idea how unfortunately common my experience of the Roman Catholic Church would turn out to be.

I grew up in the east end of Montreal, a member of a close-knit enclave of Italians in a French-speaking neighborhood near the shores of the St. Lawrence River.

On Sundays, we’d gather for mass in the gym of a local school. Around 1970, a parish church was built, partly with donations from every family I knew. It quickly became the cultural, recreational and, of course, religious center of our small community.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:39 AM

March 22, 2010

The Catholic church's bureaucratic lament: "It wasn't my responsibility"

UNITED STATES
Washington Post

Susan Jacoby

As I drank my coffee, read the Sunday papers and mused over Pope Benedict XVI's bureaucratic, responsibility-evading "apology" for the Irish Catholic hierarchy's long coverup of child sex abuse by priests, I felt a growing sense of familiarity with the spirit, if not the letter, of Benedict's weasely pastoral letter. Then I realized that the pope's tone resembled nothing so much as the standard formulations of Soviet newspapers in the late 1960s and early 1970s, when referring to "mistakes" made during the era of the "cult of personality"--the euphemism for Stalin's murderous tyranny. As a young journalist in Moscow during that era, I grew as habituated as Russians to sentences that acknowledged the commission of errors without any admission of who or what was responsible.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:51 PM

Berlusconi praises pope's 'humility and sincerity'

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PADDY AGNEW and EOIN BURKE KENNEDY

INTERNATIONAL REACTION: POPE BENEDICT’S pastoral letter to the Irish yesterday prompted the unexpected approval of Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi.

In a remarkable communiqué, which may or may not be influenced by forthcoming regional elections, Mr Berlusconi expressed admiration for the “humility and sincerity” shown by the pope in the letter.

“Benedict XVI, like many of his predecessors, is often called on to confront very difficult situations . . . The way in which he responds is remarkably efficient, at least for all those who are not guided by totally hostile sentiments, and it is efficient both for its humility and sincerity and for the sound reasoning of the pope,” he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 PM

Minister to get audit on child protection next month

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY

HSE REPORT: A HEALTH Service Executive audit of child protection practices in the State’s Catholic dioceses is to be ready for presentation to the Minister of State for Children Barry Andrews by the end of April.

The audit had been due to be completed on December 22nd last but was delayed when the newly appointed assistant national director, children and families social services, of the HSE, Phil Garland, sought further information from the bishops.

Mr Garland had been director of the child protection service in Dublin’s Catholic archdiocese until mid-November when he took up his current appointment with the HSE.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:44 PM

Cowen welcomes 'direct apology' from pope

IRELAND
The Irish Times

MARY MINIHAN and JAMIE SMYTH

TAOISEACH'S REACTION: TAOISEACH BRIAN Cowen has said there are “things to be welcomed” in Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter to the Catholics of Ireland. In his first public response to the letter published on Saturday, Mr Cowen said the letter was addressed to members of the Catholic Church and churchgoers and the State had “wider responsibilities” to discharge.

“The Government will discharge its responsibility and the church has to see what way it can ensure its credibility and authority is respected by its own members,” he said. Mr Cowen said he welcomed the “direct apology” from the pope as well as an acknowledgment that huge dismay was felt by many at the way the issue of clerical child sex abuse had been handled.

Asked if the State’s inquiry into clerical child sex abuse should be extended, Mr Cowen said the Government was committed to ensuring independent investigations took place where issues arose, and “that where criminal proceedings are required to be pursued that will always happen”.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 PM

Letter omits 'obsession with sex lives'

IRELAND
The Irish Times

ÁINE de PAOR

PRIEST'S RESPONSE: A LIMERICK-based priest has criticised Pope Benedict’s letter for not addressing what he said was the part played by the church in creating abusers through its teaching on sexuality.

Fr Adrian Egan, head the Redemptorist order in Limerick, added he would not welcome the proposed Apostolic Visitation if this took the form of similar Vatican probes.

“There was no recognition that the church has had a huge obsession with the sexual lives of people and no recognition of how this has contributed to the development of sexually dysfunctional people,” said Fr Egan.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 PM

Vatican inquiry most likely to be led by a cardinal

VATICAN CITY
The Irish Times

PADDY AGNEW in Rome

APOSTOLIC VISITATION: THE VATICAN inquiry into church practices in Ireland will be carried out by senior figures, most likely led by a cardinal, according to Vatican sources.

The inquiry, in the form of an Apostolic Visitation, was signposted in Pope Benedict XVI’s pastoral letter to the Catholics of Ireland at the weekend.

Although no final decisions have yet been made about the nature and the timing of the inquiry, Vatican sources yesterday confirmed that the visitation will focus primarily on the handling of sex abuse cases.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:36 PM

Bishop says he should have informed Garda about abuse trials

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY Religious Affairs Correspondent

APOLOGY: THE BISHOP of Killaloe, Willie Walsh, has apologised for not informing the Garda when, in the early 1990s, he took part in two canonical trials in the Dublin archdiocese.

They resulted in two priests being laicised because of their sexual abuse of children.

He cannot comment on one of the trials for legal reasons but of the second he said yesterday: “I was made aware that the gardaí and the diocese were already in communication about the case before the canonical process began.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:32 PM

Papal miseries due to same mistakes

ALABAMA
UAB Kaleidoscope

Ron Crumpton, Forum Editor
Published On: 03/22/2010
How is it that a person can remain loyal to a religious institution that has been responsible for the sexual abuse of more than 10,000 children? How can a person remain loyal to a religious institution whose leaders go to great lengths to hide this from the public? How can these leaders let the same people molest children repeatedly and repeatedly?

In 2002, John Jay compiled a report of on the extent of sexual maltreatment perpetrated by the Catholic priesthood. It ruled out the study of some 3300 cases because the priests involved were already dead, but they found enough evidence to substantiate allegations of sexual abuse in 6700 of the remaining 7700 cases. These cases involve 4392 different priests and these numbers are for the U.S. alone.

In the 90s, the Vatican has called it the “American problem” that it was limited to the U.S., and it was mainly due to our lack of morals. But hold the phone Leroy! Recently that has changed dramatically with new cases popping up all over the globe, people saying that a priest molested them. In Australia, Austria, Germany, France and Switzerland there are more and more abuse victims coming forward to tell their story.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:29 PM

Ireland: Why the Pope's Apology May Not Be Enough

IRELAND
TIME

By Bryan Coll / Belfast Monday, Mar. 22, 2010

To Ireland's victims of sexual abuse at the hands of Catholic clergy, Pope Benedict XVI offered an apology: "You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry." For Ireland's bishops, the pontiff had a reprimand: "Serious mistakes were made. All this has seriously undermined your credibility." Thus the highlights of an eight-page letter from Rome received at Mass around Ireland on March 21.

In an unprecedented move (the Vatican had previously commented on the Irish clerical sex scandal only in private letters), Benedict apologized to victims and accused Ireland's bishops - past and present - of "grave errors of judgment" and "failures of leadership" in their handling of sex abuse cases in the Church.

The Pope also wrote that a team of Vatican inspectors would be sent to dioceses, seminaries and religious congregations in Ireland. But victims' groups were unimpressed, charing that the papal letter had failed to address the cover-up of child abuse by the Irish Catholic authorities exposed in recent weeks. "He didn't apologize for anything the Church has done, only for the actions of pedophile priests," says Andrew Madden, who was abused as an altar boy and is a member of the victims group One in Four. "[The Church's actions] weren't just down to errors of judgment. This was a proactive covering up of the sexual abuse of children to avoid scandal for the Church. Pope Benedict completely failed to own up to this."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:26 PM

Papal apology is too little, too late

AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald

IN THE past two decades Catholic bishops in several countries have grown used to making public apologies for the sexual abuse of children by priests. On Saturday, however, the task of apologising moved up the church's hierarchy to Pope Benedict XVI, in a pastoral letter to Irish Catholics.

The letter was prompted by the revelations in Justice Sean Ryan's 2600-page report, released in May last year, which detailed the conduct of 800 abusers in more than 200 institutions during a 35-year period. The scale of the abuse, and the extent to which it was concealed by bishops and superiors of religious orders, justifies descriptions of it as systematic rather than the actions of a few individuals. The Pope did not deny this. His letter castigated Ireland's bishops for their complicity in the events, and called on them to co-operate with civil authorities. But the apology fell short of what victims' advocates had wanted, as similar utterances have so often done before.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:23 PM

The Trial of the Catholic Church: A Tale of Moral and Financial Bankruptcy

News Junkie Post

By Liam Fox
NEWS JUNKIE POST

The potential financial bankruptcy of the Catholic Church is rivaled only by the apparent moral bankruptcy reaching from parish priests all the way to the Papal offices of the Vatican. Tens of thousands of cases have emerged in dozens of countries from Asia to Europe and from Australia to the Americas. No country seems immune, and the vulnerability of the victims seems only contingent on the number of clergy.

Over the past week, stories have surfaced of sexual abuse that was actively hidden and aided by the current Pope while he was archbishop of Germany. Joseph Ratzinger, archbishop of Munich and Freising, now Pope Benedict XVI , ignored repeated warnings regarding a priest accused of sexually abusing boys. While Ratzinger was in charge, the accused priest, Peter Hullerman, was briefly transferred to Munich for therapy.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:20 PM

Media Attacks Mounting against Pope over Irish Abuse Letter

ROME
LifeSite

By Hilary White

ROME, March 22, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The secular mainstream media has reacted to the release of the letter from the pope this weekend on the Irish sexual abuse scandal, calling it a “failure,” in some cases even before it could have been read. While Pope Benedict XVI clearly stated his apology to the victims of clergy abuse and to the Irish people, headlines from nearly all major news outlets have appeared saying he has failed to assuage anger.

The letter was issued on Saturday in response the government’s Murphy Report of decades of cover-up of clerical sexual abuse of children in Dublin diocese. The pope said in the letter that he shares the “dismay and the sense of betrayal” felt by the Irish people at these “sinful and criminal acts and the way Church authorities in Ireland dealt with them.” For those clergy who abused young people, Benedict had harsh words of condemnation: “You betrayed the trust that was placed in you by innocent young people and their parents, and you must answer for it before Almighty God.”

The media, however, particularly in Britain, has pounced on the letter, calling it a “disappointment.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:17 PM

Bishop confirms role of ‘judge’ in two abuse cases

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

By Pat Flynn

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

THE Bishop of Killaloe has confirmed he was one of three ‘judges’ asked to investigate allegations of sexual abuse against two priests in a secret hearing in the Dublin Archdiocese 20 years ago.

In a statement, Bishop Willie Walsh said: "On two occasions, prior to my being appointed Bishop of Killaloe, I was asked by the then Archbishop of Dublin to act as one of three judges in a canonical process involving allegations of sexual abuse against two priests of that diocese. In the first case, that of William Carney, our judgment was that the most severe penalty in Church law namely laicisation or expulsion from priesthood be applied.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:14 PM

The Catholic Church, Toyota, Trust, and Fear

Psychology Today

David Ropeik

On the face of it, Toyota and the Catholic church seem to have little in common. But they're both suffering severe criticism lately, for the same profound reason. Both of these major global institutions ignored the important role that trust plays in the psychology of our perceptions of risk. And they're continuing to ignore the importance of trust, even as they claim to want to rebuild it, in the inadequate way they are responding to the mess they've made. They're apologizing, but they are not backing up their mea culpas with sufficient action. Because trust has such a powerful influence on our perception of risk, words alone will not be enough.

Pope Benedict has just offered a letter of contrition to Catholics in Ireland for the Church's failure to protect its members, particularly its children, from decades of sexual abuse by clergy. Speaking to the victims, he wrote "You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. I know that nothing can undo the wrong you have endured. Your trust has been betrayed and your dignity has been violated."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:38 PM

RI gov candidate confronted sex-abuse priest

PROVIDENCE (RI)
Contra Costa Times

By RAY HENRY Associated Press Writer

PROVIDENCE, R.I.—John Robitaille nearly swerved his car off Interstate 95 when he heard a Boston radio station report that his old classmates had accused a Roman Catholic priest of sexually abusing them as children.

The former paratrooper, then 43, pulled onto the highway shoulder and sat trembling, tearing up as he was assailed by memories kept buried for decades: the cigarette breath of his abuser, the Rev. James R. Porter; the rape and Porter's warnings never to tell anyone what happened. He hadn't.

"It was an emotional rush," Robitaille said. "It was—it's difficult to describe it because I've never felt it before and I've never felt it since then."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:24 PM

German nuns investigated for sex abuse

GERMANY
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

By Nick Squires in Rome
Published: 4:45PM GMT 22 Mar 2010

The two sisters, along with four priests, are at the centre of fresh allegations of the abuse of minors in the diocese of Regensburg in southern Germany.

The new investigation was announced by a spokesman for the diocese, although there were no further details of when and where the abuse took place or how many children were involved.

The latest child abuse scandal is as Irish as it is CatholicThe diocese is acting on some of the 300 claims of sexual or physical abuse at institutions run by the Church which have flooded in since Germany was swept up in a scandal which has also caused shock and anger in Ireland, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Austria and Brazil.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:16 PM

Pope's Letter 'Will Not Dispel Dark Clouds' Over Church

Spiegel

Over the weekend, Pope Benedict XVI finally issued his letter of apology relating to the sexual abuse scandal in Ireland. German commentators welcome the move, but argue it is not enough. The pope, after all, still hasn't commented on the abuse scandal in his homeland.

On Sunday, the waiting for Ireland's Catholics came to an end. In a letter read aloud at weekend masses across the country, and handed out to churchgoers in printed form, Pope Benedict XVI expressed "shame and remorse" for the "sinful and criminal" sexual abuse perpetrated by members of the Catholic clergy in Ireland for decades.

Though highly anticipated, the apology was not well received. Many slammed the letter for not including a requirement that Cardinal Sean Brady, head of the Irish church, step down. Requirements that other church leaders be punished were likewise missed by victims groups. "It is one scandal on top of another," Hugh Keogh in Dublin told the New York Times. "I do not think we have seen the last of this."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:12 PM

Italy Prelate Sees Campaign Against Church Over Abuse

VATICAN CITY
The New York Times

VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - The Catholic Church is being unfairly singled out for criticism of sexual abuse of children by priests and will not tolerate campaigns to discredit it, the powerful head of Italy's bishops said on Monday.

Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco spoke as the Vatican tried to stem a scandal gripping the Church that has swept across Europe, with more revelations of sexual abuse of children by priests over several decades surfacing almost daily.

"For a long time, the phenomenon of paedophilia has been tragically widespread in different sectors and various categories of people and various places, even non-Catholic," he said in a speech to Italian bishops.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:10 PM

Priest investigated for suspected abuse

SWITZERLAND
swissinfo

A Catholic priest from a village in canton Thurgau has been arrested for the suspected abuse of children, the authorities have said.

Police said on Monday that the investigation into the 40-year-old Swiss was over “acts against the sexual integrity of minors”.

Evidence of possible wrongdoing by the man had led to his arrest on Friday, a statement said. More information has since been collected.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:06 PM

Swiss priest arraigned on suspected child abuse: police

SWITZERLAND
Expatica

A Swiss Catholic priest has been held on suspicion of sexual abuse against children, police and media said Monday, amid child sex abuse scandals at churches in several European countries.

Regional police in canton Thurgau said in a statement that a Catholic priest in the village of Aadorf had appeared before a local court last Friday on suspicion of sexual offences.

"Investigations by cantonal police found evidence of possible offences by the 40 year-old Swiss man against minors," they said, adding that local investigating magistrates had taken up the case.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:04 PM

Vatican czar Mgr Scicluna gets to grips with Church’s new crisis

MALTA
Malta Today

The “affable and polite Maltese” has the reputation of scrupulously carrying out the tasks entrusted to him “without deferring to anyone” Italian newspaper Avvenire says, as he prepares to take on the new cases rocking the Vatican

Mgr. Charles J. Scicluna, the promoter of justice of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and presently investigating allegations of sexual abuse by priests, has told Italy’s catholic newspaper l’Avvenire that the Vatican does not force bishops to report accusations of sexual abuse by priests to the police.

Scicluna has the reputation of being “tough” in his role as the Vatican’s investigator in the cases brought against sexually abusive priests and those accused of paedophilia. But the Catholic Church is systematically accused of being accommodating towards “paedophile priests,” the Catholic newspaper Avvenire says in an interview with Scicluna.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:01 PM

Germany plans ombudsman on church sex abuse, source say - Summary

GERMANY
Earth Times

Berlin - Germany's government has agreed internally to appoint a special ombudsman to review allegations that children were sexually abused in church institutions, sources in Berlin said Monday.

The independent commissioner with investigative powers would also make recommendations on how to compensate victims for attacks by paedophiles and sadists over the past half century at Catholic, Lutheran and non-religious boarding schools and in churches.

More than 200 Germans say they were molested as children by Catholic church priests, nuns and other staff. In the homeland of Pope Benedict XVI, 26 million people are officially Catholic.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:59 PM

Catholic Church in Birmingham held liable for abuse of disabled boy

UNITED KINGDOM
The Times

Ruth Gledhill

Father Christopher Clonan, who is believed to have died in Australia while on the run from the police, has cost the Catholic Church about £1 million so far in compensation. Last week he cost it another £32,500 after the Birmingham Archdiocese lost its case against a victim, a boy with learning difficulties known as Maga, who washed the priest's car for him. Financial difficulties caused by compensation payments are also besetting the Irish Church, where parishioners are being asked to bail out the Ferns diocese as part of their 'God-given responsibility.' The finances of the Roman Catholic Church in Dublin are also under severe pressure.

Abuse victim support groups were dismayed last year when Mr Justice Jack held that the church was neither vicariously liable as Father Clonan’s employer nor had the church been in breach of a duty of care to the boy, as this could not be owed by the church to individuals who were not themselves members of the congregation. Frances Gibb covered this for The Times. Read the Birmingham Post report here. The BBC also carried a story. Below is the full statement from the solicitors.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:56 PM

Time for the Church to focus on the victims

Sydney Morning Herald

CATHY KEZELMAN
March 23, 2010 - 6:19AM

The Pope's letter to 15,000 victims of Irish clergy abuse, while expressing his shame and remorse along similar lines to his apology in Australia and US in 2008, falls well short of the mark. While it rebukes Irish bishops and lower ranking officials it makes no mention of any sanctions against them over their "grave errors of judgment" in not responding to sex abuse allegations. He suggests that the church's own laws, properly applied, should lead to the expulsion of clergy who sexually abuse children. However, the scale of this scandal would suggest otherwise. The church is facing a burgeoning crisis in countries all over Europe, including in the Pope's native Germany and most recently in Brazil.

This letter also fails to address the role of senior Irish clerics, or most importantly, the Vatican's own accountability. It would appear that the Church's policy has helped to protect sex offenders in its midst while failing to prevent further crimes or appropriately care for victims. What appears to be a systematic cover-up of sexual abuse by the highest echelons of the Church is arguably the most morally reprehensible crime of all. The Church has for many lost its moral and sadly, its spiritual authority.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:54 PM

Papal letter on sex abuse emphasizes spiritual rebuilding in Ireland

VATICAN CITY
U.S. Catholic

Monday, March 22, 2010
By Catholic News S...
By John Thavis, Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Pope Benedict XVI's letter to Irish Catholics was a pastoral not a disciplinary document, aimed more at spiritual rebuilding than establishing a chain of accountability for the priestly sex abuse scandal.

Although the pope referenced several factors that led to acts of abuse and their mishandling by church authorities in the past, his main focus was on the future.

While encouraging continued vigilance over abuse, the papal letter did not unveil any new procedures or penalties. Instead, it announced a program of prayer and penitence designed to revive trust among Irish Catholics.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:51 PM

Bishop Walsh admits involvement in Carney case

IRELAND
Breaking News

22/03/2010
The Bishop of Killaloe Dr Willie Walsh has today admitted he was one of the three judges involved in the case of paedophile priest William Carney.

The case is regarded as one of the worst mentioned in the Murphy report into clerical abuse.

In a statement, Walsh also says he was also involved in a second case which was examined by the commission, but not published yet due to legal reasons.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:46 PM

Faith shaken - Faith

IRELAND
The Donegal News

By KATE HEANEY

PARISHIONERS across Donegal listened attentively yesterday morning as Pope Benedict XVI's long-awaited Pastoral letter was read out at Masses.

Priests across the county abbreviated the 20 page document. Some read the two page summary of the letter while others read what they saw as the relevant sections of the full document.

The Pastoral letter which began "Dear brothers and sisters of the Church in Ireland," did apologise to the victims of clerical sexual abuse - "to the victims of abuse and their families you have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry".

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:15 PM

Diocese did not seek secret deal - Hegarty

IRELAND
The Donegal News

THE Bishop of Derry, Most Rev. Dr Seamus Hegarty has issued a statement in response to allegations that he was part of a secret deal signed with an abuse victim in 2000.

The victim went public with her claims last week that she was abused over a 10-year period by an unnamed priest, but said she was bound to secrecy in a legal deal which involved Bishop Hegarty.

The bishop's statement provided by Fr Michael Canny reads: "On the afternoon of St. Patrick's Day, 17th March 2010, my office received an email from the Belfast Telegraph, which contained a series of questions to which responses were requested by 5pm. The issues raised were serious and required careful consideration, given the fact that the allegation referred to a period quite some time ago. For this reason a considered response could not be given by the short deadline required by the newspaper.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:12 PM

POPE SAYS SORRY

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Ulster Herald

By Conor Sharkey

SATURDAY'S papal apology to victims of clerical abuse marked a major watershed for the Catholic Church, a Strabane Parish Priest has said.

Fr Declan Boland was one of thousands of priests across Ireland to take to the pulpit yesterday (Sunday) to read aloud Pope Benedict's public apology.

The apology was the first of its kind issued anywhere in the world and in it, the Pope spoke of the betrayal and damage caused to the Church by some members of the clergy. And those responsible for the decades of sexual abuse against Ireland's young, Pope Benedict said, will one day answer for their actions before God.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:10 PM

Disgraced Coalisland priest 'defied Cardinal'

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Ulster Herald

PEOPLE who know disgraced Coalisland priest Fr Joseph Quinn have spoken of their shock on learning that he has been suspended from the ministry for a number of years, and yet continues to wear his clerical collar in public.

In the last month Fr Quinn has led prayers at the wake of a local man, attended a funeral and appeared at other public occasions wearing his priest attire.

In recent days the revelation broke that Fr Quinn had paid £45,000 compensation to a woman who made allegations of sexual abuse against him.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:05 PM

Tyrone priest speaks of 'dismay' over scandals

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Ulster Herald

By Ronan McSherry

AS the Catholic Church reels from a week of accusations regarding child abuse and secret payments to victims, Newtownstewart parish priest Fr Stephen Kearney believes it may not be the last of the "bad news."

Derry Dioceses, which includes the Newtownstewart parish, has been at the centre of one of the scandals when it was revealed that Bishop Seamus Hegarty had been accused of being involved in a £12,000 compensation deal to cover up alleged child sex abuse.

He was one of three priests named in a confidential civil settlement after an eight-year-old girl was abused over a decade from 1979.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 1:02 PM

Fight the Real Enemy

UNITED STATES
CounterPunch

By GARY LEUPP

I’ll never forget that Saturday Night Live appearance by Sinead O’Connor on October 3, 1992. It was her second performance of the evening, following the (relatively uncontroversial) title track from her recent album, “Am I Not Your Girl?” backed up by her band. This was an a capella version of Bob Marley’s “War,” an extremely powerful song that links war to racism and begins:

Until the philosophy which hold one race
Superior and another inferior
Is finally and permanently discredited and abandoned
Everywhere is war, me say war

That until there are no longer first class
And second class citizens of any nation
Until the color of a man’s skin
Is of no more significance than the color of his eyes
Me say war

Marley sang about imperialism in Africa, but the young Irish singer altered the lyrics to her own purposes. Where Marley referred to Angola, Mozambique and South Africa, Sinead surprisingly substituted “child abuse, child abuse” and where Marley referred to “the African continent” Sinead sang “children, children…” before delivering the closing lyric: “We are confident of the victory of good over evil” and producing out of nowhere a photo of Pope John Paul II and ripping it to shreds in the face of tens of millions intoning “Fight the real enemy."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:59 PM

The Vatican’s problem: abuse and renewal

AUSTRIA
Open Democracy

Michael Walsh, 22 March 2010

The Archbishop of Vienna has broken ranks. Few observers would have regarded Cardinal Christoph Schönborn as a radical – after all, he was largely responsible for the much criticised Catechism of the Catholic Church. Now, however, he is on record as suggesting that, in the light of the exposure of sex-abuse scandals in at least four European countries, the church should look again at the obligation of celibacy for Roman Catholic clergy. In the Vatican, whose corridors he frequents, such a proposal is utterly taboo. In any case, if he believes this is the panacea he is almost certainly mistaken: paedophilia afflicts married men (and some women) as well as single ones, which would indicate there was no direct link. There may, however, be an indirect link.

There are many reasons given for the imposition of celibacy on (the majority of) Catholic clergy, an obligation with a long and problematic history. Some of these reasons are practical, others ascetical, but there are good arguments for claiming that celibacy was originally imposed to mark off clergy as a separate caste within an increasingly Christian society. That was a long time ago, but the “caste” mentality survives to this day.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:52 PM

The Accountability Church

UNITED STATES
The Daily Dish

22 Mar 2010 12:02 pm

After countless of institutionally-aided and -protected child-rape, the Pope sees no reason to hold anyone in a cassock, you know, accountable or responsible. Lisa Miller sounds baffled by the pope's letter to Irish Catholics. She shouldn't have been. This is like Bush conceding error. The enormity of the error is so great, confessing it would compel the man to step down.

[T]hough the Pope did concede that the church has demonstrated “a misplaced concern for the reputation of the church and the avoidance of scandal” and said he “openly expressed the shame and remorse that we all feel,” he also continued to blame the scandal on others. No one—not bishops, priests, nuns, parents, even the faithful—themselves, escape having to bear the responsibility of this terrible burden. “I urge you,” he wrote to Catholic parents, “to play your part in ensuring the best possible care of children.” Not all parents are above reproach, of course, but this seems to me to be entirely missing the point.


Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:49 PM

Bishop Of Killaloe Admits Sense Of Shame Over Clerical Sex Abuse

IRELAND
The Clare Herald

The Bishop of Killaloe Dr. Willie Walsh today acknowledged that he once was part of an “oppressive culture of secrecy and undue deference to ecclesiastical authorities”.

Dr. Walsh was reacting to Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter in which the Pontiff apologised the Roman Catholic community in Ireland for decades of chronic child abuse by members of the clergy.

According to Bishop Walsh: “While I was not involved in any such process in our own diocese I too as a younger priest was part of that oppressive culture of secrecy and undue deference to ecclesiastical authorities. For that part and for the disastrously inadequate response of our Church to the heinous crime of child sex abuse I will always carry a sense of sadness, regret and shame. I again apologise to all victims of abuse but especially to any victim who may have suffered through any failure on my part.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:47 PM

Kirchenskandal: Schon wieder neue Missbrauchsfälle

GERMANY
Abendzeitung

REGENSBURG/WEIDEN - Die Kirchen in Bayern kommen nicht zur Ruhe: Gestern wurde in Regensburg der aktuelle Stand bei den Missbrauchsfällen bekannt gegeben. Ein neuer Fall in der evangelischen Kirche wurde bestätigt. Und die Kritik an den Äußerungen des Regensburger Bischofs Müller nimmt zu.

[summary]

A new case of sexual abuse yesterday was confirmed in Regensburg.In the Catholic diocese at Regensburg there are currently allegations against four priests and two nuns. One of the priests is said to have been a student assistant at the boarding school of the Regensburg cathedral choir about 40 years ago. All allegations are now being investigated by the prosecutor.

The Protesant Church confirmed that one of its ministers was accused of abusing a 14-year-old in the 1980s.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:13 PM

Bischof Fischer: Ohrfeigen im Einzelfall "hilfreich"

AUSTRIA
Die Presse

Der Feldkircher Bischof Fischer weist Vorwürfe zurück, wonach er in den 1960ern Jugendliche mit Ohrfeigen niedergestreckt habe. Er räumt aber ein, dass "solche Aktionen für junge Menschen hilfreich sein können".

[summary]

The Feldkirk Bishop Fischer has rejected allegations that he slapped young people during the 1960s but conceded that be believes such actions may be helpful for young people. Not to be treated differently than others, he has asked the ombudsman's office for the diocese to clarify the allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 12:06 PM

Bistum beurlaubt zwei Priester nach Missbrauch

GERMANY
Bild

Montag, 22. März 2010, 16:40 Uhr
Hildesheim (dpa/lni) - Das Bistum Hildesheim hat zwei Pfarrer beurlaubt, die nach Missbrauchsfällen in die Krankenhausseelsorge versetzt worden waren. Dies sei vorsorglich geschehen, obwohl es keinerlei Hinweise auf neue Vergehen der Geistlichen gebe, teilte das Bistum am Montag mit.

[summary]

The Hildesheim diocese has placed two pastors on leave. This was done as a precaution although there is no evidence of new abuse allegations. One of the two had been accused in the 1980s of abusing a teenager. The other had faced an allegation in 2001.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:59 AM

The pope's letter to Ireland: Two steps forward and one back?

UNITED STATES
U.S. Catholic

Monday, March 22, 2010
By Bryan Cones

Though its reception has been uneven--with some applauding and some shrugging--the pope's letter to the church of Ireland is definitely worthy of praise--with reservations.

First, it actually contains an apology: "You [victims] have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. I know that nothing can undo the wrong you have endured."

Second, it has harsh words for abusers: "You betrayed the trust that was placed in you by innocent young people and their parents, and you must answer for it before Almighty God. . . . Openly acknowledge your guilt, submit yourselves to the demands of justice, but do not despair of God’s mercy."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:54 AM

Pope's letter was a blatant and disgraceful deceit

IRELAND
Herald

By Colm O'Gorman

Monday March 22 2010

Pope Benedict XVI published his letter to the Irish Church on the issue of child abuse on Saturday. What was necessary seemed clear. He had to acknowledge the cover-up of the rape and abuse of children by priests, to take responsibility for it, and to show how he'd ensure it never happened again.

But the letter failed to do any of that. There was no acceptance of responsibility for the now-established cover-up, no plan to ensure that children will be properly protected around the global Church, and no assurance that those who rape and abuse will be reported to the civil authorities.

The letter is clearly an effort to restore the credibility of a Church rocked by the publication of three State investigations into clerical crimes and church over ups in Ireland. The Pope has seen all three reports.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:51 AM

SNAP president Barbara Blaine speaks out in Germany

GERMANY
Voice from the Desert

Statement by Barbara Blaine, president and founder of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAPnetwork.org) 312 399 4747

We are leaders of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAPnetwork.org). We’re here for one simple reason – because we believe it’s our moral duty. We are here for two simple purposes – to protect the vulnerable and heal the wounded.

Sadly, we have plenty of hard work and vulnerable kids and wounded adults in the US. There are far too many predatory ministers, priests, nuns, rabbis, bishops, seminarians and preachers still in church jobs or walking free among unsuspecting neighbors and families. Many, if not most, church officials of all denominations still instinctively and consistently protect themselves, their reputations and their colleagues, instead of protecting their flock.

There has, however, been some progress in the US with this ongoing crisis. It’s primarily happened because of brave victims and concerned Catholics and secular forces, like police, prosecutors, lawmakers and journalists. It’s happened in spite of, not because of church officials.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 11:10 AM

John Cooney: Papal letter has fanned flames of worldwide fury

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney

Monday March 22 2010

POPE Benedict has let down victims in his flawed Pastoral Letter to the Catholics of Ireland. He has fanned the flames of worldwide fury among church members at his failure to admit and apologise for his own culpability in covering up rapes of children by clergy.

Nor did the German Pontiff, who remains rigidly silent about media reports that he approved the transfer of a paedophile priest for therapy rather than reporting him to the police when he was Archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982, acknowledge the Vatican's leading role, as the command headquarters of more than one billion members, in a massive global cover-up.

However, in the first papal bull on the clerical abuse issue that is written plainly in readable language, Benedict lacerated the Irish bishops, his branch managers, for grave errors of judgement, "sometimes grievously", for failing to apply the secretive canon law requiring rapist priests to be defrocked.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:17 AM

Priests and nuns accused in Bavarian abuse inquiry

GERMANY
Ireland Online

22/03/2010

A diocese in the Pope's native Bavaria said today four priests and two nuns are to be investigated in connection with sexual abuse allegations.

A Regensburg Diocese spokesman said that since allegations surfaced earlier this month, the church has been pursuing the cases with the goals of achieving justice and help for the victims, punishing the offenders and preventing future crimes.

"The work of the last 14 days has shown us that serious wrongdoing was committed by spiritual leaders and members of the church," he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:08 AM

New church abuse allegations surface in Germany

GERMANY
CNN

Four Catholic priests and two nuns have been accused of sexually abusing children in Germany's diocese of Regensburg, the diocese confirmed Monday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:00 AM

Ruth Dudley Edwards: Scandal shows how prone we are to hypocrisy and hysteria

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Ruth Dudley Edwards

Sunday March 21 2010

I had a struggle to feel proud to be Irish this St Patrick's Day. Normally I would have smiled tolerantly at the ubiquitous shamrock-bespattered leprechaun hats and orange beards infesting central London. But I was afflicted by an attack of existential gloom, brought on by listening to Morning Ireland in full cry over Cardinal Sean Brady.

It wasn't so much that we are at our least attractive when in sanctimonious lynch-mob mode: it was because this was RTE at its worst.

It was bad listening to Charlie Bird in Washington trying to persuade Brian Cowen to call for Brady's resignation and order a police investigation of his behaviour in the Seventies, but at least the Taoiseach firmly dismissed any idea that he should interfere in Church matters or the operational independence of the gardai.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:57 AM

Our politicians take to the skies as church leaders sink below the waves

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

By Ryle Dwyer

Saturday, March 20, 2010

WHY would the future Cardinal Seán Brady ask an eight-year-old girl and a 10-year-old boy to swear on oath that they would not divulge that Fr Brendan Smyth had sexually abused them? The main aim was certainly not to protect other boys from that predator. Fr Brady was apparently more interested in protecting the Catholic Church as an institution from criticism.

The cardinal says he should not be judged by the standards of today — 35 years on. The only difference is the clergy were less likely to be held accountable then. Everybody makes mistakes in life, but anyone who covers up such activities should be removed from any position of authority — not out of vengeance but in order to protect other children by demonstrating that any cover-up is intolerable.

The same standard should apply to the nun who used to deliver the young girl to Brendan Smyth in the Belfast orphanage where he used to lock himself in a room with his unfortunate victim. If the nun was so naive as not to realise there was something grossly suspicious about this, she was not fit to mind children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:54 AM

Cardinal Sean Brady must go

IRELAND
Telegraph (United Kingdom)

Cristina Odone

Pope Benedict’s letter was a beautiful, lengthy and heartfelt mea culpa. He sounded genuine in his condemnation of abusive priests. He sounded properly contrite in his pastoral address to the victims and their parents. He held out hope that trust could once again be rebuilt between the Catholic clergy and the community they are to serve. And if Benedict XVI himself had read out his letter, I am sure I would have been moved to tears. But I wasn’t, because the unprecedented apology was read out by Cardinal Sean Brady.

The Primate of All Ireland has been clearly and publicly implicated in the paedophile scandal: he accepted the suppression of the truth, and did nothing to help two young boys who were forcibly silenced by the Church. Having indicated that he might resign when his scandalous behaviour first came to light a few months ago, here he was, still in his Cardinal’s hat and robes, reading the Pope’s letter as if he were worthy to lead his Irish flock.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:50 AM

Irish response to the pope's letter

IRELAND
Guardian (United Kingdom)

Breda O'Brien guardian.co.uk, Monday 22 March 2010

Last week, it was revealed that the head of the Irish Roman Catholic church, Cardinal Sean Brady, had as a young priest taken statements from two boys abused by notorious paedophile priest Brendan Smyth. While Brady acted swiftly, and within weeks his bishop had removed the right to practise as a priest from Smyth, the fact that Brady had not reported the case to the police, and had demanded an oath of secrecy from the boys, was seen as a possible case for resignation 35 years later.

In that atmosphere, expectations for the pope's pastoral letter to Ireland were low. Some abuse survivors, notably Christine Buckley of the Aislinn Centre, had written it off before it appeared. Somewhat surprisingly, the pope's letter was welcomed by some survivors as an "overdue but emotional apology", and in general, was received reasonably well by church-going Catholics.

Extracts from the pope's letter were read at all masses. The first group addressed in the letter was the victims of abuse and their families. "You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. Your trust has been betrayed and your dignity violated." Pope Benedict acknowledged that when many survivors spoke out about what happened to them, no one would listen. He said it was understandable if they find it hard to even to cross the door of the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:47 AM

WE ARE in GERMANY

GERMANY
National Survivor Advocates Coalition (United States)

The National Survivor Advocates Coalition (NSAC) arrived in Munich Germany Sunday to stand in solidarity with the German survivors. Mike Sweatt, one of the founders of NSAC, is our voice in Pope Benedict’s home diocese.

Please spread the NSAC News far and wide today and in the coming days that the silence may be broken, the wounded and suffering found as the good fight to protect children and provide access to justice continues.

We know you are with us in this effort. We are grateful for all of your support.

– Kristine Ward and all of NSAC

WHAT: Press Conferences
WHEN: Sunday, March 21, 2010 and Monday, March 22
WHERE: Frauenkirche – Dom zu unserer lieben Frau — Cathedral of Our Lady, Munich, Germany

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 AM

It’s Catholicism Itself, Stupid

Newser

Mar 22, 10 | 7:44 AM by Michael Wolff

In an age when all religions must be treated by right-thinking people with the greatest tolerance and respect, much of the reaction to the sexual abuse story in Europe and the Pope’s involvement with it, is, nevertheless, deeply and specifically anti-Catholic.

This is not just a story about individual priests and instances of malfeasance; it is, instead, a focused and concerted argument against a host of precepts and behaviors and theological positions fundamental to the Roman Catholic Church. The issue isn’t just sex abuse, it’s the Church.

What is under attack is the infallibility of the pope, the nature of priest-supplicant relationship, the cultivated secrecy of the Church, the nature and orientation of the priesthood, and the very power—spiritual, political, and cultural—of the Church itself.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 AM

ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER GETS THE MESSAGE

ORANGE COUNTY (CA)
Catholic League

March 19, 2010

Yesterday, the Catholic League protested the blog site of the Orange County Register which showed the silhouette of a priest in a Q & A section on sexual abuse. Bill Donohue, the league's president, is pleased with the outcome:

Thanks to our members who pounded the newspaper with e-mails, the president and publisher of the Orange County Register, Terry Horne, released a letter of apology to complainants. "Singling out one group, especially in such a recognizable way, was unfair and inappropriate." He ended his letter by saying, "We hope you will forgive the lapse in judgment. And I hope you will accept my personal apology."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:36 AM

OC Register Editor Weakly Capitulates to Pedo-Priest Apologists

ORANGE COUNTY (CA)
Orange County Weekly

By Gustavo Arellano, Monday, Mar. 22 2010

​I've been away for a bit, so am late to this story: last week, Orange County Register reporter Teri Sforza did an innocuous-enough post titled, "Think you can spot the sex offender in the crowd?" that dealt with some California Attorney General report or other about perverts. The original post apparently had an illustration of a Catholic priest to accompany the post--I say "apparently," because Register editor Ken Brusic ordered it taken down after a bunch of pedo-priest apologist Catholics wrote in to complain at the behest of the reprehensible Bill Donahue of the Catholic League.

Poor Sforza was reduced to writing she "certainly did not mean to suggest that all clergymen are abusers" by using the priest illustration, a rare retreat for the otherwise-fearless reporter. Oh, Teri: The only people who claim anti-Catholic bias when it comes to the sex-abuse scandal or get offended at pedo-priest jokes or insinuations are the same ones who feel sodomized kids wanted it; they deserve the fires of Gehenna for siding against the children of Christ and with the snakes called the Catholic hierarchy. They deserve no apologies, only scorn and ridicule.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:34 AM

Ex-orphanage resident heckles bishop during Mass

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Anne Lucey

Monday March 22 2010

A MAN who was escorted from St Mary's Cathedral in Killarney, Co Kerry, after he interrupted Mass called for the bishop to "acknowledge" that abuse had taken place in a local orphanage.

Raymond Foley (48) from Moyderwell, Tralee, strode up to the pulpit just before the reading of the Pope's letter.

Mr Foley is a former resident of St Joseph's Orphanage in Killarney, which had been run by the Mercy Order.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:30 AM

Danish Catholic Church will probe sexual abuse of children

DENMARK
The Swedish Wire

COPENHAGEN (AFP) - Following pressure from its members, the Danish Catholic Church will probe a number of cases involving sexual abuse of children, it said in a statement Sunday.

"The Catholic Church in Denmark has recently been criticised by its members for not investigating and reporting to the police cases of sexual abuse which date back 100 years," the statement said.

"Bishop Czeslaw Kozon now addresses this criticism by, as soon as he comes back from an official visit to the pope on March 27, setting up a group of competent people to investigate these cases."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:28 AM

Minister lauds Bavarian church for taking sex abuse to the law

GERMANY
The Local

Published: 22 Mar 10 09:00 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/national/20100322-26029.html

German Justice Minister Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger praised Bavaria’s Catholic conference of bishops on Monday for their commitment to work with law enforcement to clarify accusations of child sex abuse at Church institutions.

The justice minister said the Bavarian bishops were an example to other regions, as an increasing number of cases of sexual abuse continued to be uncovered across the country.

“The decision by the Bavarian bishop’s conference opens a new way for all German dioceses,” Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger told daily Berliner Zeitung on Monday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:24 AM

Danish Catholic church to investigate abuse cases

DENMARK
The Copenhagen Post

Monday, 22 March 2010

A ‘competent’ group will be set up by the bishop to look into old abuse cases involving clergy and children

The Danish Catholic church has said it will investigate a number of sex abuse cases after its leading bishop came under heavy fire for his comments in recent weeks.

Bishop Czeslaw Kozon previously said that he was under no legal obligation to immediately report knowledge of sexual abuse cases involving children and clergy to the police.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:22 AM

Pope's words of remorse fall flat for abuse victims

IRELAND
The Age (Australia)

JOHN BURNS, DUBLIN
March 23, 2010

POPE Benedict XVI's weekend apology to sufferers of sexual abuse at the hands of Catholic clergy in Ireland has drawn a deeply sceptical and angry response from many Catholics.

In the apology - a pastoral letter read aloud at all weekend Masses across Ireland's 26 Catholic dioceses and handed out in printed form to thousands of churchgoers - Benedict ex-pressed ''shame and remorse'' to victims and their families for what he called ''sinful and criminal'' acts by members of the clergy. But in the apology, the Pope did not require that Cardinal Sean Brady, the head of the Irish church, or any other church leaders be disciplined for their mistakes, as some victims had hoped.

Nor did he clarify what critics in Ireland and elsewhere have said are contradictory Vatican rules about the procedures for investigating abuse cases and church leaders' responsibility to inform civil authorities about offences they uncover, a duty the Pope reiterated strongly in his letter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:19 AM

Archbishop urges full accountability

IRELAND
The Irish Times

IRISH TIMES REPORTERS

The Catholic Archbishop of Dublin has given his strongest indication yet that the State’s inquiry into clerical child sex abuse in Ireland should be extended.

“Without accountability for the past there will no healing and no trust for the future,” Archbishop Diarmuid Martin said.

He was responding to the publication of Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter to the Catholics of Ireland, details of which were read at all Masses over the weekend. In it the pope apologised for the deep hurt caused to abuse victims and their families. “You have suffered grievously, and I am truly sorry,” he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:14 AM

Six facing Bavaria abuse allegations

GERMANY
The Irish Times

The Regensburg diocese in the pope's native Bavaria says six people there face sexual abuse allegations, many of them dating back decades.

Diocese spokesman Clemens Neck said today that church officials "regret deeply" what employees did to children and "we ask for forgiveness."

Mr Neck says seven people have come forward so far with accusations of sexual abuse against six people who are still alive. He didn't identify them.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:11 AM

Editor's Viewpoint: Full inquiry into abuse still needed

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Monday, 22 March 2010

The Pope’s response to the crisis facing the Catholic Church in Ireland over the decades of sexual abuse by priests and other religious figures can only be seen as inadequate.

His eight-page letter read out at many Masses yesterday was long on expressions of sorrow and remorse, but short in actual concrete proposals to help those who were so grievously abused.

Even the acknowledgement of what went wrong in the past — when the paedophilia of priests and others was covered up — was merely a statement of the blindingly obvious. The Church authorities, according to the Pope, had a misplaced concern for its reputation, and the avoidance of scandal. Failing to spell it out, in precise and simple terms, that the bishops covered up crimes was a serious omission.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:08 AM

Readers react to pope's apology

Deutsche Welle

The pope's apology for child abuses mollifies some but other readers demand more action in the aftermath of scandals in the Catholic Church across Europe.

Pope's apology also a warning for Germany: archbishop

Maybe he should address one to himself! -- Robyn White, Australia

Time and again, clergy of all levels have admitted the cover-ups of the church in sexual abuse of children. They should practice what they preach; offenders should publicly confess their crimes and be made available for punishment by the courts. All sex-offending members of the Church should be expelled or imprisoned by the church and never allowed to interact with the public again. Whether you banish celibacy or not will not stop the problem. Many sex-offenders are also married with children of their own. To regain the trust of the people, the Catholic Church and as its leader the pope should stop trying to hide from the facts. The pope encouraged the lay-workers to confess and take their punishment from the courts, but neglected to hold the clergy to the same standard. Hypocrisy, thy name is the Catholic Church. -- Penny, US

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:05 AM

Prelate hopes survivors will recognise pope's effort

IRELAND
The Irish Times

BARRY ROCHE and ÁINE de PAOR

BISHOP OF CORK AND ROSS: BISHOP OF Cork and Ross John Buckley has expressed hope that groups representing survivors of clerical child-sexual abuse would recognise that Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter was a genuine attempt to address the issue.

“I’ve heard some criticism of the letter. I think that was a very immediate response. I think it’s a very comprehensive letter and when the pope spoke to us after Christmas, he said that he was preparing it in prayer and great reflection . . . the Holy Father made a special effort to reach out to those who are hurt and that he has acknowledged the things were dealt with inadequately in the past.”

Speaking to The Irish Times Bishop Buckley said: “Great hurt was caused to young people . . . and we’re all saddened by what has happened but our suffering bears no comparison to the hurt and damage and distress of the victims themselves.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:02 AM

Former Lexington pastor enters plea in sex abuse case

KENTUCKY
Lexington Herald-Leader

By Jim Warren - jwarren@herald-leader.com

The former pastor of Lexington's Mary Queen of the Holy Rosary parish entered an Alford plea to amended charges in a sexual abuse case and will be sentenced in May, according to Franklin County Commonwealth's Attorney Larry Cleveland.

The Rev. Joseph Muench entered the plea Thursday in Franklin Circuit Court to amended charges of first-degree unlawful imprisonment and criminal attempt to commit sexual abuse in the first degree, Cleveland said Sunday night. An Alford plea is not an admission of guilt, but it acknowledges there is enough evidence for a conviction.

In July, Muench was suspended from ministerial duties after an internal investigation by the Diocese of Lexington, prompted by a letter from a Louisville attorney representing three men who made allegations against Muench. The diocese forwarded its findings in a letter to the Franklin County Commonwealth's Attorney.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:59 AM

Pope-victims gap is tip of iceberg of incomprehension in Catholic Church

Reuters

The wide gap between Pope Benedict’s letter to the Irish and the reaction it received from victims — the subject of my analysis today on the Reuters wire — is the tip of an iceberg of incomprehension. The frank letter went further than any previous papal condemnation of clerical sex abuse of children, an aspect that Benedict’s defenders promptly highlighted, and went so far as to say some bishops had committed “grave errors of judgment” and undermined their own credibility. This is strong stuff indeed, especially from a man like Joseph Ratzinger who has a far loftier image of the Church and its servants (more on that later).

But what was bold for Benedict was still cowardly for his critics, who saw these “grave errors of judgment” as only the starting point and wanted to hear what the pope would do about them. “The smallest steps that are obvious for any reasonable person are made painfully slowly, which ruins the Church’s reputation radically,” the German group Initiative Kirche von Unten (Church from Below Initiative). This and other victims’ groups, backed up in several countries by the media, some politicians and apparently quite a few Catholics in the pews, appreciate the apologies but want to go beyond them. They want to go up the chain of command and hold those bishops responsible who hushed up abuse cases, moved predator priests around and extracted secrecy deals from frightened victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:57 AM

Catholics in Bavaria Shaken

GERMANY
The Wall Street Journal

By VANESSA FUHRMANS
REGENSBURG, Germany—Europe's widening sexual-abuse scandal has shaken Catholics across Pope Benedict XVI's native Germany, but perhaps nowhere as much as in Bavaria, the country's Catholic heartland where some of the most sensitive allegations have emerged.

.In Germany, where hundreds of allegations of decades-old abuse have come to light since January and engulfed 22 of 27 Roman Catholic dioceses, the Catholic Church faces its worst crisis in post-World War II history. Polls show a majority of Germans believe the scandal has undermined the church's credibility, and recent government data suggest the revelations have sparked an increase in Germans leaving the church, whose membership, like that of Protestant churches, has long been declining.

In Germany's southeastern stretches along the Danube, where the Catholic church remains a mighty social and economic force, Germans are confronting the scandal with a mix of anger and conflicted loyalty to a church that plays such a big role in social services, education and other facets of daily life.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:54 AM

An apology won't end the abuse

CANADA
The Globe and Mail

Pope Benedict XVI's apology this weekend to Ireland's victims of sexual and physical assault is a welcome first step in taking responsibility for past wrongs. However, the Pope did not go far enough to restore the credibility of the Roman Catholic Church over this issue, and to reassure victims that a new strategy is in place to prevent future abuse. He should require that predatory and pedophilic clergy be disciplined for past actions, and should clarify contradictory Vatican rules that some fear continue to allow abuse to go unpunished.

In his eight-page pastoral letter, the Pope acknowledged that “serious sins committed against defenceless children” had opened up a “grievous wound.” He said he was sorry for those who have suffered in Ireland and had their trust betrayed and their dignity violated. He criticized bishops for failing to apply canon law to the crime of child abuse, and announced that a special apostolic delegation will be sent to Ireland to investigate abuse in dioceses there.

But the letter did not spell out changes in Vatican policy that would turn back a long-entrenched culture of secrecy, and did not outline new regulations that will force bishops to be held accountable for covering up incidents of clerical abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:50 AM

Chicago SNAP activists head to Europe to help priest sex abuse victims

UNITED STATES
Chicago Tribune

By Erika Slife, Tribune reporter

March 22, 2010

A day after the pope issued an apology to victims of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Ireland, two leaders from a Chicago-based group for survivors of church sexual abuse left for Europe to meet with victims, criticize Vatican officials and urge independent investigations into church sex crimes.

"That's why we're going now. We're extremely concerned about what's coming out of Rome," said Barbara Blaine, president of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, before she left for Munich on Sunday. "We've been hearing from so many victims from across the globe. We're going to be meeting with some of the survivors and advocates. We're hoping to possibly meet with government officials as well."

The group made their hasty arrangements on Friday in anticipation of Pope Benedict XVI's apology on Saturday to Irish Catholics for what he called sinful and criminal acts committed by priests and the failure of church authorities to respond to them. But the pontiff's letter has been criticized by victims' groups for not going far enough to discipline Catholic leaders for inaction.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:47 AM

SNAP...

GUAM
Pacific Daily News

10:30 a.m. — A national support group for victims of child sexual abuse will host two confidential support meetings on Guam this week.

There is no charge for either event, according to a press release from the Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests, or SNAP.

“Nothing discussed in the meeting is disclosed or shared with others once the meeting is over,” a SNAP press release states.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:43 AM

Archdiocese tightens rules for staff dealing with youth

CANADA
Metro News

PAUL MCLEOD
METRO HALIFAX
March 22, 2010

The Archdiocese of Halifax is toughening up its rules on priests and staff members dealing with children.

Mandatory police checks, banning of corporal punishment and avoiding one-on-one scenarios are all being introduced.

The new rules for Halifax and the diocese of Yarmouth were drafted by Archbishop Anthony Mancini in response to the sex-abuse scandals that have arisen across the province. Some changes were required by the church’s insurance company.

Some new clauses state the obvious (“all physical contact between staff or volunteers and children, youth or vulnerable adults is to be completely non-sexual”), while others mark new developments for the church.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:41 AM

An apocryphal apology

UNITED STATES
Indiana Daily Student

This Saturday, Pope Benedict XVI offered a public apology in Ireland to those who have suffered abuse by members of the clergy.

He waxed poetic about how sinful and criminal these actions were and expounded on the shame and remorse it has brought to the Catholic Church.

The words seemed sincere, but the Vatican has had a lot of practice with apology. In fact, the church is no stranger to scandal — it dealt with a public relations nightmare in 2002 after a slew of sexual abuse incidents surfaced.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:39 AM

Church got it spectacularly wrong, says Martin

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Monday March 22 2010

ARCHBISHOP of Dublin Diarmuid Martin said children were abused to an enormous extent and the church authorities "got it spectacularly wrong".

Welcoming the pastoral letter to Irish Catholics from Pope Benedict XVI, he said he was glad there was no sign of "revisionism" in what he had to say.

Appealing to the public to read and reflect on the letter, he said the church had tragically failed many of its children.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:37 AM

The Pope's words

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Monday March 22 2010

The following are edited extracts from the Pastoral Letter of the Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI to the Catholics of Ireland:

DEAR BROTHERS AND SISTERS OF THE CHURCH IN IRELAND, it is with great concern that I write to you as pastor of the universal church. Like yourselves, I have been deeply disturbed by the information which has come to light regarding the abuse of children and vulnerable young people by members of the church in Ireland, particularly by priests and religious.

I can only share in the dismay and the sense of betrayal that so many of you have experienced on learning of these sinful and criminal acts and the way church authorities in Ireland dealt with them.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:34 AM

'Overdue' apology to pave the way for healing

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Fergus Black

Monday March 22 2010

SOME abuse victims appeared ready yesterday to seek closure for the suffering of victims of clerical and institutional abuse.

Irish Survivors of Child Abuse (SOCA), the organisation representing people who were in industrial schools, said the pastoral letter represented a long- overdue apology from the Pope and the Vatican.

"Victims desperately need closure for what happened to them. We are fed up being victims and don't want to remain victims," said SOCA co-ordinator John Kelly.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:32 AM

Papal letter is just a start

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Monday March 22 2010

CRITICS of the Pope's pastoral letter to Irish Catholics have made many valid points about what they see as its inadequacies. But there are at least two positive sides to the event: its unique nature, and the graciousness and humility of Benedict XVI's apology to victims of clerical sex abuse.

These are matched by the strong terms in which he denounces the failings of the Irish bishops. After all those decades of cover-up and equivocation, they fully deserve his harsh words. And there are, at least potentially, practical implications of an encouraging kind.

The recent Rome meeting between Pope Benedict and the bishops disappointed most Irish Catholics. It appeared Archbishop Diarmuid Martin had been sidelined and the Pope had failed to endorse the firm actions he had taken against those involved in the "culture of concealment". Presumably the archbishop can take it that he now enjoys the support of the Vatican.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:29 AM

Cardinal asks flock to read letter 'with open heart'

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Anne Palmer

Monday March 22 2010

UNDER-pressure Primate of All Ireland Cardinal Sean Brady asked Catholics to read the Pope's pastoral letter on child abuse with an open heart as he addressed Mass-goers at the weekend.

Dr Brady, who has said he would take a period of time to reflect on his future, said: "In the name of the church, Pope Benedict openly expresses the shame and remorse that we all feel about the abuse that has occurred."

"He expresses the depth of the pain that has been caused and acknowledges that some people find it difficult even to go inside the doors of a church after all that has occurred."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:27 AM

Bishop admits involvement in secrecy oath for abuse victims

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Fergus Black

Monday March 22 2010

ANOTHER Irish bishop has admitted being involved in an investigation into clerical abuse claims in which victims were made to sign oaths of secrecy.

The Bishop of Clogher, Joseph Duffy, said in a statement that he had been been party to at least one civil settlement involving a claim made against the diocese in which a non-disclosure agreement was signed between the diocese and the claimant.

He told a Sunday newspaper that it was to his "regret" he did not pass on the abuse claims to police when he first became aware of the allegations in 1989.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:24 AM

Prelates urged to come clean on role in cover-up

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By John Cooney

Monday March 22 2010

BISHOPS have been urged to "come clean" on any role in covering up child sex abuse allegations as two major investigations loom over Irish dioceses.

Pope Benedict said bishops committed "grave errors of judgment" as he called for honesty and transparency in his historic pastoral letter.

Senior clergy and religious will come under renewed scrutiny as the Pope announced an Apostolic Visitation -- an inquisition into what the Vatican considers unorthodox practice or laxity of moral life.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:22 AM

Abuse inquiry is not the first for Vatican

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Fergus Black

Monday March 22 2010

POPE Benedict's promise to hold an apostolic visitation of certain dioceses in Ireland is not the first time the Vatican has sent in prelates to investigate the workings of the church.

Last year five bishops appointed by the Vatican carried out an intensive investigation into the Mexico-based Legionaries of Christ following allegations of sexual abuse against the order's founder.

And in the US an intensive investigation was ordered into hundreds of religious communities representing more than 67,000 sisters.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:19 AM

Victims want bishops to quit as Pope 'ducks issue'

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By Fergus Black

Monday March 22 2010

ABUSE victims and campaigners say they will go on demanding the resignations of bishops after the Pope ducked the issue in his pastoral letter.

Clerical abuse victim Andrew Madden said the letter had failed to address the issue of clerical sexual abuse of children.

He was given a standing ovation when he addressed delegates at Fine Gael's national conference at the weekend.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:17 AM

Pope and Pedophilia—the Plain Truth

The Trumpet

Ron Fraser

Currently there’s a great hue and cry emanating from the world press in relation to Pope Benedict xvi’s reaction—or rather perceived lack of reaction—to the publicity being given to pedophilia charges brought against certain priests in Europe. The loudest clamor surrounds cases in Germany, particularly in Benedict’s old diocese of Freiburg, Bavaria.

Nothing justifies anything but absolute condemnation of the abuse of priestly office. But what is really behind this latest outcry against the Catholic Church and its spiritual leader?

Dig behind the headlines and you see an agenda. It’s an agenda driven by fear of the rising power of the papacy—a power that, in tandem with the elites in Berlin, has succeeded in imposing on Europe an imperialist constitution against the will of much of its electorate. Given its history, this power combine of Rome and Berlin is greatly feared by two movements in Europe: pan-Islamism and the secularists.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:12 AM

Training God’s Rottweiler: Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Must End

Religion Dispatches

By Anthea Butler
March 22, 2010

A passionate call for reform from a scholar of religion and cradle Catholic. When does an institutional theology become so rotten that it needs to be taken out at the roots? It's time for a new reformation, with justice for victims of sexual abuse.

Time to clear the air? Back in 2002, the Boston Globe first embarked on its Pulitzer Prize-winning series that would shock Catholics in America and around the world. The sexual abuse scandal the Globe uncovered in the Boston Archdiocese, which sparked similar exposes around the country, would rock the American Catholic Church, bankrupt dioceses, and even resulted in the murder of a notorious pedophile priest. The reporting shined a bright light on travesties the Vatican wanted kept in the dark: suicides, abuse, and shattered lives of children and adults who suffered the abuse — the product of malfeasance at all levels of the Church hierarchy, which tried to blame it on “America,” "homosexuality” and “a few bad priests.”

The story is repeating itself, with a vengeance. Its stench now reaches all the way to the seat of Peter in Vatican City, and the late Pope John Paul II's "Rottweiler," Pope Benedict XVI.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:09 AM

For crying out loud, let's not get emotional

NEW ZEALAND
3 News

Mon, 22 Mar 2010
By Philip Patston

Catholic priests have been at it again, this time in Ireland, which of course begs for a joke:

What do you call an Irish Catholic priest? No better than the rest.

Not funny in any sense of the word, but you would think the Pope could harden up (ahem...) when it comes to admonishing the sin and the sinner.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:05 AM

Pope accused for not crediting secular groups

IRELAND
RTE News

Monday, 22 March 2010
A Catholic support-group for victims of clerical sexual abuse has criticised Pope Benedict XVI for failing to give credit to secular agencies for uncovering abuse hidden by the church.

Voice of the Faithful Ireland says in the pope's weekend pastoral letter, he also ignored that, by giving excessive powers to bishops, the church had caused too many victims to be intimidated.

Voice of the Faithful's international network grew out of a meeting of 30 Bostonians in their parish during the abuse crisis in their diocese. Members describe themselves as mainstream Catholics.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:01 AM

The sins of the fathers

CANADA
Montreal Gazette

CHERYL CORNACCHIA, The Gazette
March 22, 2010

A woman who says she was raped and impregnated by a Quebec priest 45 years ago characterized this weekend's apology by Pope Benedict XVI to victims of pedophile priests in Ireland as an empty gesture.

While unprecedented in its recognition of pedophilia in the Catholic Church and the damage done, France Bédard complained that no mention was made of measures that would hold priests accountable or that could prevent future abuse.

"You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry," was the pope's message communicated to Irish Catholics through a letter read during weekend masses. "I know that nothing can undo the wrong that you have endured."

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:58 AM

Bishop of Clogher did not report abuse claim

IRELAND
BBC News

Another senior Irish Catholic cerlgyman has admitted failing to tell police about a paedophile priest.

The Bishop of Clogher admitted he knew of abuse allegations against a priest in his diocese in 1989, six years before the cleric appeared in court.

Bishop Joseph Duffy was told Enniskillen priest Fr John McCabe had abused a young boy in his car.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:56 AM

Pope's letter disappoints Dutch abuse victims

NETHERLANDS
Dutch News

Monday 22 March 2010

Pope Benedict's letter to Irish Catholics apologising for the sexual abuse scandal has been greeted with disappointment by Dutch victims, the NRC reports.

In the letter, the pope apologised to the people of Ireland and to thousands of victims of sexual abuse in past decades by Roman Catholic priests there.

And he criticised Irish bishops for 'grave errors of judgement' in dealing with the problem.

But the pope did not mention any sanctions against the bishops, and said simply that those who are guilty will have to answer to god for their crimes.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:53 AM

RC CHURCH DEALING WITH SEX ABUSE CLAIMS

TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
Trinidad and Tobago's Newsday

By ANDRE BAGOO Monday, March 22 2010

ON THE SUNDAY after Pope Benedict XVI issued a pastoral letter to Irish Catholics in which he apologised for the church’s handling of cases of child sex abuse in Ireland, local priest Fr Garfield Rochard revealed there have been unproven reports of child sex abuse at the hands of priests in this country.

As pressure continued to mount on the church internationally in the wake of Pope Benedict’s apology, which was displayed outside of the Vatican walls on Saturday, Fr Rochard also revealed that the local church has “a mechanism” for dealing with reports of child sex abuse at the hands of priests which does not necessarily involve the report being referred to the police at the soonest opportunity.

Asked if there have been reports of priests sexually abusing children, Rochard said, “There have been reports but they have not been substantiated...There have always been reports.”

Were such reports ever referred to the police?

“I am not aware of that,” Fr Rochard said. “When I say there are reports, it’s alleged. If there have been reports you have to investigate. That is the process. You determine how you deal with it if it is substantiated and how you deal with it if it is not substantiated.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:50 AM

Guam sex abuse support group

GUAM
Kuam

by Mindy Aguon

Guam - The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) will be on Guam holding support group meetings this week as they attempt to begin a thoughtful healing process and start a vibrant support network on the island. Their visit comes at the same time the organization is heading to Europe to provide a support network for numerous victims of sexual abuse by clergy in Ireland.

SNAP Southwest Regional Administrator Joelle Casteix will hold several meetings this week locally in an effort to begin a support group for individuals who claim they've been victims of sexual abuse at the hands of clergy on the island. Casteix, who arrives on Guam late tonight, said in October of last year she received phone calls from two individuals who said they were victims of sexual abuse and knew of several others who had similar allegations.

The Archdiocese of Agana and Archbishop Anthony Apuron have said that they have not received any such complaints and no clergy have been convicted of sexual abuse. SNAP, however, has written two letters to the archbishop, calling on full disclosure of the complaints of sexual abuse.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:48 AM

Abbot proposes Rome registry for religious sex offenders

SWITZERLAND
Earth Times

Geneva - A Swiss abbot has proposed that Rome establish a registry of clergy members who committed sexual abuses, local media reported Monday.

Martin Werlen, the abbot of Einsiedeln in Switzerland, told media that opening such a depot of information would allow for greater transparency.

If a member of the clergy was moved from one diocese to another, the database could be accessed to see if the priest had been accused of sexual or other abuses in previous positions.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:45 AM

Catholic sex abuse scandal: time to sack trendy bishops and restore the faith

UNITED KINGDOM
Telegraph

By Gerald Warner

It has become fashionable to claim that the sex abuse scandal currently afflicting the Catholic Church is “its biggest crisis since the Reformation”. Oh, really? Tell me about it. The abuse issue is just a small part of the much larger crisis that has engulfed the Church since the Second Vatican Catastrophe and which is more serious than the Reformation.

Abolish clerical celibacy? The last thing a priest abusing altar boys needs or wants is a wife. There is no compulsory celibacy in the Church of England, but that has not prevented vicars and boy scouts furnishing gratifying amounts of copy to the tabloid Sunday papers for the past century. Celibacy goes against the grain of today’s “unrepressed”, “non-judgemental”, let-it-all-hang-out attitude to sex; its continued existence is a reproach to the hedonist Western world; so Rome must be persuaded to abolish it – likewise its condemnation of divorce, abortion, contraception, homosexuality and all the other fetishes of liberal society. Dream on, secularists.

“Irish abuse victims disappointed by Pope’s letter.” Of course they are. They were disappointed by it before they had read it, before it was even written. Any other response would diminish the power they find themselves wielding against the Church. Have they a legitimate grievance? In most cases, yes. They have a ferocious grievance against the “filth” (Benedict XVI’s term, long before he came under public pressure) who defiled them and treated them like animals.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:42 AM

Finnish priests to stay celibate

FINLAND
Ice News

The spate of recent child abuse sex scandals across the United States and Europe will not prompt the Finnish Catholic Church to review its stance on compulsory celibacy, the church has said.

Last weekend, the head of the German Catholic association, Alois Gluck, said that the time had come to put an end to celibacy vows for Catholic priests. His demands stemmed from continued sex scandals that have plagued the Catholic Church.

“The media have exaggerated the issue,” said the Bishop of the Roman Catholic Church in Finland, Teemo Sippo, adding that Finland’s Catholic priest community had not discussed the latest European scandals. Sippo also claimed that no case of sexual child abuse towards children had ever been reported inside the Finnish Catholic church and that recent paedophilia discussions were cathartic. “The problem has been that people have tried to hide it. The whole atmosphere will improve now that it’s taken seriously,” said Sippo.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:34 AM

March 21, 2010

'Acknowledges no quick-fix solution' - Bishop Drennan

IRELAND
The Iirsh Times

LORNA SIGGINS and MICHAEL PARSONS

GALWAY AND CARLOW: THE POPE’S pastoral letter needs to be read in a spirit of “faith and openness”, Bishop of Galway Dr Martin Drennan said in Galway Cathedral at the weekend.

The letter is at times “very direct”, refers to “courage and resolve” and also acknowledges that there is “no quick-fix solution”, Dr Drennan said, when he read extracts from the text at 6pm Mass on Saturday.

Although it clashed with the Six Nations rugby tournament, several hundred people attended the service. A Galway diocesan spokesman said Dr Drennan had opted for Saturday evening as he had confirmations to attend on Sunday.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:33 PM

Police to advise closing sex crimes case against Moti Elon

ISRAEL
Haaretz

By Tomer Zarchin and Yair Ettinger

The police are expected to announce that there is no basis for a criminal investigation against Mordechai (Moti) Elon, a prominent religious Zionist rabbi who last month was accused of committing sex-related crimes.

Police said a preliminary probe indicates that while Elon did engage in sexual activity with young men, he did not violate any laws because they were of legal age and gave their consent.

After the completion of the preliminary probe, investigators will present their findings to Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein. Last month, Weinstein ordered the head of the police intelligence branch, Maj. Gen. Yoav Segalovich, to follow up on allegations aired against Elon by members of Takana, an umbrella group of religious Zionist organizations aimed at preventing and dealing with sexual harassment by religious leaders.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:29 PM

As apology is read, Pope’s homeland is named and shamed

IRELAND
Belfast Telegraph

Monday, 22 March 2010

Ireland's Catholics listened to the Pope's apology for the conduct of the Church throughout a long-running paedophilia scandal at Mass yesterday.

But any hope the extraordinary gesture would draw a line under abuse claims was dashed when a senior German cleric was the first to admit the church in the Pope's native Germany had “hidden for years” assaults by priests on young children.

Robert Zollitsch, archbishop of Freiburg, told a German newspaper that the “assaults that took place in such numbers within our institutions shame and frighten me”. His remarks came even as senior Vatican figures claimed that Pope Benedict's pastoral letter on the Irish abuse cases was the last word on the scandal.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:26 PM

Colm O'Gorman: Papal letter was a disgraceful deceit

IRELAND
The Independent (United Kingdom)

Monday, 22 March 2010

Pope Benedict XVI published his letter to the Irish church on the issue of child abuse on Saturday. What was necessary seemed clear. He had to acknowledge the cover up of the rape and abuse of children by priests, to take responsibility for it, and to show how he would ensure it never happened again.

But the letter failed to do any of that. There was no acceptance of responsibility for the now-established cover up, no plan to ensure that children will be properly protected around the global church, and no assurance that those who rape and abuse will be reported to the civil authorities.

The letter is clearly an effort to restore the credibility of a church rocked by the publication of three state investigations into clerical crimes and church over ups in Ireland. The Pope has seen all three of these reports.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:24 PM

Bruce Anderson: Only a different leadership can save the Irish church

IRELAND
The Independent (United Kingdom)

Monday, 22 March 2010

There is no reason to doubt the sincerity of Pope Benedict's feelings. His letter was powerful, reading as if it had been written from the heart. So it should have been. Nothing less would suffice. The word "abuse" does not begin to describe the miseries which some of those Irish children endured.

Go back 50 years to rural Ireland. The past is another country? More like another world. The pace of life is as gentle as the regular showers of light rain, as unhurried as the immaculate pouring of a glass of Guinness – and everything seems as harmonious as that pint when it finally arrives. True, there is not much sign of energy. It is some years since the last person with any get-up-and-go got up and went. But there is always good craic to be had, sometimes on serious subjects. The tourist would be reminded that twelve hundred years ago, when Western Christianity was struggling to survive, some of the most successful struggles took place in the West of Ireland, where the monasteries were among the few points of light in the Dark Ages.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:21 PM

Leading article: A landmark for Ireland, if not yet for Catholicism

IRELAND
The Independent (United Kingdom)

Monday, 22 March 2010

Pope Benedict's pastoral letter to Irish Catholics, extracts from which were read out in churches across Ireland yesterday, is a landmark for the Vatican and for the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland. It is the first time that the Vatican has given a statement of this kind on the issue of sexual abuse of children by priests, which the church had long been complicit in concealing. The Pope deserves credit for this and for acknowledging publicly the harm that has been done – not just the damage to the Church as an institution, but the profound hurt to very many individuals who were abused by adults in a special position of trust.

There will be those, understandably, for whom the Pope's apology is nowhere near enough. While his contrition was heartfelt and far-reaching, he offered no specific apology for the elaborate ways in which the Church had sought to cast a veil of silence over the fact, and the extent, of paedophilia within its ranks. He referred only to "serious mistakes" among bishops in the way they had responded to the allegations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:18 PM

Two group leaders leave for Europe to meet with church sex-abuse victims

UNITED STATES
The Plain Dealer

ERIKA SLIFE, Chicago Tribune

CHICAGO -- A day after the pope issued an apology to victims of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Ireland, two leaders from a Chicago-based group for survivors of church sexual abuse left for Europe to meet with victims, criticize Vatican officials and urge independent investigations into church sex crimes.

"That's why we're going now. We're extremely concerned about what's coming out of Rome," said Barbara Blaine, president of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, before she left for Munich on Sunday. "We've been hearing from so many victims from across the globe. We're going to be meeting with some of the survivors and advocates. We're hoping to possibly meet with government officials as well."

The group made their hasty arrangements on Friday in anticipation of Pope Benedict XVI's apology on Saturday to Irish Catholics for what he called sinful and criminal acts committed by priests and the failure of Church authorities to respond to them. But the pontiff's letter has been criticized by victims' groups for not going far enough to discipline Catholic leaders for inaction.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:15 PM

Pastoral letter: readers' reaction

IRELAND
The Irish Times

Among the online responses to the pastoral letter on irishtimes.com were:

Vincent Xavier: Everybody speaks about victims and for the victims and nobody wants speak about the victims of this media frenzy. Why don’t you speak for the innocent priests and religious who suffer humiliation because some criminals in the church did criminal activities. You are victimising the innocent people and don’t you think what you are doing is wrong.

Patrick Brennan: What appears to be an apology is in reality an opportunity for more Catholic Church propaganda. As soon as I read the opening lines where the pope makes it sound like all this information is new to him, frankly I switched off. Does anyone really believe that this is the first time he’s heard of this type of behaviour?

Ivan: The pope carefully distances the Vatican from the criminal cover-up. According to teachings a confession should be full and open for absolution. This is not. The pope also has this carefully worded so as to maintain primacy of canon law over civil law. So, we have two issues: the Vatican response – ignored; and the issue of the paedophiles. Neither are satisfactorily addressed.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:12 PM

‘I am truly sorry’

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

By Noel Baker

Monday, March 22, 2010

BISHOPS criticised in the Pope’s pastoral letter could come under renewed pressure to resign after the message to Irish Catholics sparked anger among some victims’ groups.

There was a mixed response to the contents of the letter, with some survivors of abuse welcoming Pope Benedict’s apology for clerical child sex abuse, while others said it did not go far enough.

In extraordinary scenes, Bishop of Kerry Bill Murphy was verbally attacked as he read the Gospel at Mass at St Mary’s Cathedral in Killarney yesterday, while at Dublin’s Pro-Cathedral protesters staged a walkout demonstration.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:09 PM

Critics slam Pope's apology for glaring omissions

IRELAND
The Globe and Mail (Canada)

Eric Reguly

Rev. Donal Collins was known as “The Slinker” or “Paws.” That's because he would prowl the dormitory at St. Peter's College in Wexford, Ireland, at night, looking for boys to indulge his perverted sexual desires.

The Diocese of Ferns received the first complaints of abuse against Father Collins in 1966. The bishop treated the case as a moral failure and sent the teacher-priest away, but he returned two years later and the abuse resumed. Some boys complained about demands for mutual masturbation and oral sex, but officials did nothing and Father Collins kept being promoted. The wave of complaints did not force his resignation until 1991. Two years later, he admitted to the abuses. He served one year in jail and was not defrocked until 2004 – 38 years after his sexual crimes began.

Father Collins was just one of many Irish priests who got away with abusing children for many years, even decades, as the Catholic church in Ireland protected its own or failed to understand the severity of the allegations. Eventually, three state investigations were launched, two of them last year, each a damning chronicle of sexual horror. The Vatican refused to co-operate in those probes. But this weekend, Pope Benedict XVI apologized for the trauma inflicted on the victims and their families.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:06 PM

Pope’s Letter Does Little to Assuage Irish Anger

IRELAND
The New York Times

By JOHN F. BURNS and EAMON QUINN
Published: March 21, 2010

DUBLIN — Pope Benedict XVI’s weekend apology to sufferers of sexual abuse at the hands of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland met with a deeply skeptical and often angry response from many Catholics here on Sunday, with one prominent victim calling it ineffectual and demanding that the pope forcibly remove the head of the Irish church if he does not resign.

In the apology, Benedict expressed “shame and remorse” to victims and their families for “sinful and criminal” acts committed by members of the clergy. His apology, a pastoral letter, was read aloud at all weekend Masses in the 26 Catholic dioceses spread across the Irish Republic and the six British-governed counties of the north, and handed out in printed form to thousands of churchgoers.

But in the apology, issued on Saturday, the pope did not require that Cardinal Sean Brady, who is the head of the Irish church, or any other church leaders be disciplined for their mistakes, as some victims had hoped. Nor did he clarify what critics in Ireland and elsewhere have said are contradictory Vatican rules about the procedures for investigating abuse cases within the church and church leaders’ responsibility to inform civil authorities about offenses they uncover, a duty the pope reiterated strongly in his letter.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:03 PM

Bishop of Clogher failure to report abuse allegations

IRELAND
The Irish Times

THE BISHOP of Clogher, Joseph Duffy, failed to report allegations of clerical child sex abuse against a priest to the civil authorities.

He was also party to at least one civil settlement involving a claim made against the diocese, in which a non-disclosure agreement was signed between the diocese and the claimant of sexual abuse.

Dr Duffy was told in 1989 that Fr John McCabe, who was a teacher at St Michael’s College, Enniskillen, had abused a boy in his care. He did not report the allegations to the police, according to a Sunday newspaper.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:01 PM

Fine Gael applauds survivor's speech

IRELAND
The Irish Times

MICHAEL O'REGAN

POLITICAL REACTION: ABUSE SURVIVOR Andrew Madden received a standing ovation from Fine Gael delegates in Killarney on Saturday when he criticised Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter. Mr Madden had been invited to the national conference to speak on children’s rights.

After studying the document, Mr Madden said it represented, “not an inability to do the right thing, but an unwillingness to do the right thing”.

He repeated his call for the resignation of the pope and Cardinal Seán Brady, arguing that the pastoral letter had changed nothing. A major problem, he said, was the pope’s failure to accept the cover-up of clerical sex abuse in Ireland.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:58 PM

Church 'steering a different course'

GERMANY
The Irish Times

DEREK SCALLY in Berlin

GERMANY: THE PRESIDENT of the German Bishops’ Conference, Archbishop Robert Zollitsch, has said Pope Benedict’s letter to Irish Catholics can be applied to the church in the pontiff’s homeland.

As it faces its own abuse scandal, the German Catholic Church had been characterised by a “culture of cover-up”, the German prelate said, but was now “steering a different course”.

“What the Pope says has relevance for the entire church and is clearly a message to us in Germany,” said Archbishop Zollitsch. “We know that mistakes were made here in Germany, we German bishops have recognised these mistakes . . . and cannot allow these mistakes to be repeated. Therefore I understand the pope’s admonition of the bishops in Ireland as an admonition of us. The scandal of sexual abuse is no mere Irish problem. It is a problem of the church in many places and it is a scandal of the church in Germany.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:56 PM

Recognition of victims' suffering welcomed

IRELAND
The Irish Times

ALISON HEALY

CORI REACTION: THE CONFERENCE of Religious in Ireland (Cori) said the pastoral letter was an important part of the process of confronting the mistakes of the past, encouraging healing and ensuring that the safeguarding of children was an absolute priority.

Cori represents 135 religious congregations and has circulated the letter to all its members. Its director general Sr Marianne O’Connor said Cori particularly welcomed the pope’s acknowledgement that abuse victims and their families had suffered grievously. She said the pope had recognised that all religious were suffering as a result of the sins of their predecessors. They had “betrayed a sacred trust or failed to deal justly and responsibly with allegations of abuse”, she said.

Sr Marianne noted the pope’s commitment to conducting an apostolic visitation to certain dioceses in Ireland, as well as seminaries and religious congregations. “It is unclear as to how many religious congregations will be part of this process and we await the detail on this as referred to in the letter,” she said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:53 PM

'Pope fails to mention role played by Vatican'

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PAMELA NEWENHAM

CHILDREN'S SAFETY1: POPE BENEDICT’S pastoral letter neglected to apportion any responsibility for clerical sex abuse to the Vatican, a group representing abuse survivors said.

The pope speaks only of the failures in the Irish church, and neglects to mention the role played by the Vatican, Maeve Lewis, executive director of One in Four, said at a press conference after the letter was issued.

“If the church cannot acknowledge this fundamental truth, it is still in denial,” she said. “We are astounded at the pope’s assertion that the roots of clerical sexual abuse lie in the secularisation of Irish society, the falling off of religious devotion and failures to adhere to canon law.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:48 PM

Fr Lombardi pre-empts criticism and defends pope

VATICAN CITY
The Irish times

PADDY AGNEW in Rome

VATICAN BRIEFING: SENIOR VATICAN spokesman Federico Lombardi got his retaliation in first. Asked for a reflection on Pope Benedict’s “Pastoral Letter To The Catholics Of Ireland”, he was quick to both pre-empt criticism and defend the pope, underlining the “unprecedented” nature of the letter.

Facing the massed ranks of the world’s press in the Vatican press office on Saturday, he disagreed with those who argued that the Holy See continues to underestimate the entire clerical sex abuse problem.

“Frankly, this does not seem such a small response to me . . . There has never been a letter like this from the pope, this is a response that should not be underestimated . . .

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:46 PM

Dismay at 'sinful criminal' deeds - Cardinal Brady

NORTHERN IRELAND
The Irish Times

GERRY MORIARTY Northern Editor

PONTIFF'S MESSAGE: IT WAS evident from Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter to Irish Catholics that the pope was “deeply dismayed” by what he described as the “sinful and criminal acts and the way church authorities in Ireland dealt with them”, Cardinal Seán Brady said in St Patrick’s Cathedral, Armagh, on Saturday.

After 10.15am Mass Dr Brady delivered a summary of the pope’s pastoral letter. Cardinal Daly said he was “deeply grateful to the Holy Father for his profound kindness and concern”.

The cardinal added: “My dear people, as Pope Benedict said at his general audience this week on St Patrick’s Day, I ask you that you read this letter with an open heart and in a spirit of faith.”

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:42 PM

Pastoral letter strays far from facts but has merit

IRELAND
The Irish Times

OPINION: Confronted with the greatest tragedy in Irish Catholicism, the pope ignores the reality of decades of abuse to blame secularism and moral relativism, writes PATSY MCGARRY

WE WERE so much younger then. That year’s student drama festival was in Galway and the production of the evening was UCD Drama Society’s take on the Greek tragedy Oedipus Rex. Loud and declamatory, it was directed by Jim Sheridan in an adaptation by Neil Jordan and staged in the long-since disappeared Hanger ballroom in Salthill.

The audience sat in scaffolding arranged in a square around the ballroom floor, as the walls of Thebes. Festival adjudicator was playwright John Arden, then in a Stalinist/Marxist state of mind.

Very early on a weary predictability became characteristic of his post-performance adjudications. He saw all plays through particularly red eyes, beginning with a Belfast production of Sheridan’s School for Scandal which opened the festival. It was another example of class warfare.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:39 PM

Full accountability is only way forward - archbishop

IRELAND
The Irish Times

PATSY McGARRY and JAMIE SMYTH

THE CATHOLIC Archbishop of Dublin has given his strongest indication yet that the State’s inquiry into clerical child sex abuse in Ireland should be extended.

“Without accountability for the past there will no healing and no trust for the future,” Archbishop Diarmuid Martin said.

He was responding to the publication of Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter to the Catholics of Ireland, details of which were read at all Masses over the weekend. In it the pope apologised for the deep hurt caused to abuse victims and their families. “You have suffered grievously, and I am truly sorry,” he said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:37 PM

Sunday, March 21, 2010

UNITED STATES
outpatient clinic

Skip Shea

In spite of the recent bad publicity, the Catholic Church is still flexing it's moral muscle. No not that one. Apparently the US Bishops are telling the faithful to press their Congressmen to vote against the Senate Health Care bill because of Federal Funding of abortions. It's nice that the church wants to use a woman's Constitutional Right as a bargaining chip. ...

It looks like the Vatican sent out a form letter of apology to Ireland yesterday. In it the Vatican apologized to the Irish, but in a statement said it could be read as applying to other countries. It's their new green policy. Saving trees and money. They are going to need it for legal fees.

In the letter the Pope describes the Bishops' response to the abuse as "botched." Obviously. They got caught. Just like he botched things in Germany.

It should be clear to everyone now that the Bishops worldwide used the same MO with the abusers. Keep them in ministry, move them to another parish and don't report the crime to authorities. They could not have been acting individually and independently from each other. They were behaving as directed.

From people like the Pope.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:33 PM

W.Va. Predator Watch site tracks sex offender cases

WEST VIRGINIA
Sunday Gazette-Mail

By Kathryn Gregory
Staff writer

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- Nearly 800 accused sex offenders are awaiting trial in West Virginia, and one local organization is hoping to make it easier for the public to find out who those people are.

West Virginia Predator Watch, a watchdog service operated by Warriors Actively Against Sexual Predators, hopes to raise community awareness about those accused but not yet convicted of sexual crimes with online postings of published news stories and public court documents.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:28 PM

Bishop of Clogher ‘sorry’ for failing to report paedophile priest

IRELAND
The Times (United Kingdom)

David Sharrock, Richard Owen

Bishop Duffy is the third clergyman in Ireland to admit to a cover-up of abuse cases
Pressure for more resignations among Ireland’s Roman Catholic hierarchy continued to grow yesterday when a bishop admitted that he had failed to report a paedophile priest to the police.

The admission by the Bishop of Clogher came as Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter — containing an unprecedented apology for the sex abuse scandals in Ireland involving churchmen — was read out to the faithful at Sunday Mass across the country.

The Most Rev Joseph Duffy admitted that he had known about allegations of abuse against a priest in his diocese in Enniskillen, Co Fermanagh, in 1989, but failed to tell the police or civil authorities. He had been informed that Father John McCabe had abused a young boy in his care, but he failed to report the incident to the police or social services in Northern Ireland. In spite of complaints from the boy’s mother, the Enniskillen school at which McCabe taught wrote him a reference to help him to get a job at an integrated, non-denominational school in Belfast. Six years later McCabe was jailed for 20 months on abuse charges.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:24 PM

More now needed after Pope’s apology

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

21 March 2010

A ‘‘further step’’ in a process of healing was how Archbishop Diarmuid Martin greeted the letter from Pope Benedict XVI, which is being read at Masses this weekend.

Indeed, it is clear that the depth of the crisis facing the Roman Catholic Church, not only in Ireland but internationally, as new revelations of child sexual abuse and its cover up emerge by the day, will not be dealt with quickly or easily. The scale of child abuse has been becoming slowly clear in recent years, as one shocking revelation has followed another.

It has also been evident that the Church was criminally negligent in dealing with it, choosing to cover it up and silence victims again and again over the years. What we learnt more recently,via the Ryan report into abuse in residential institutions and the Murphy report on the Dublin diocese - and subsequent revelations here and elsewhere in Europe - is the institutionalised and organised nature of this cover-up.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:21 PM

Seanie Fitz is just a symptom of the national disease

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

21 March 2010 By Vincent Browne

The Pope’s pastoral letter has forced Sean FitzPatrick off the front pages. For the cardinal in Armagh,Sean Brady, the timing must be disappointing. FitzPatrick had shifted the spotlight from him but now the focus is right back on the Catholic Church.

Brady was ashamed of his handling of the victims of Brendan Smyth in 1975 but, curiously, he discovered his shame - or at least acknowledged it - only when he was found out. The expression of his shame contained no mention of how he himself contributed to the abuse of the two children he had interviewed, by requiring them to take an oath that must have seemed deeply menacing to them; this in the immediate aftermath of them being questioned about the details of their abuse.

That oath requirement was a shocking act, quite aside from the form of the oath that required the boys to keep secret about their ordeal, even in the face of the ‘‘common good’’. How anybody back in 1975 thought this was not itself an outrage is incomprehensible. To add further insult to further insult to further insult to a mountain of injuries, the head of the Catholic Church, Pope Benedict XVI - himself hugely compromised because of his own handling of sex abuse cases while a bishop in Germany - fails to acknowledge his own role and that of the Vatican in the abuse of children here.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:19 PM

New probe central to Pope’s message

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

21 March 2010 By Kieron Wood

Pope Benedict’s proposal for an Apostolic visitation of some dioceses, seminaries and religious congregations shows the gravity with which the Vatican regards the situation in Ireland.

An Apostolic visitation is a formal process whereby the Pope nominates specific individuals, probably from outside Ireland, to examine particular aspects of the Church’s life. In December 2008, the Vatican announced a visitation of women’s religious orders in the United States. This was followed last April by an announcement that the US

Leadership Conference of Women Religious was also under scrutiny because of its support for causes such as the ordination of women. The New York Times reported that the visitation had ‘‘startled and dismayed nuns, who fear they are the targets of a doctrinal inquisition’’. The same may happen in Ireland. The Apostolic visitors will have the full backing of the Pope to investigate whatever they consider necessary.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:16 PM

Victims’ groups react angrily to Pope’s letter

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

21 March 2010 By Nicola Cooke

Victims’ groups yesterday reacted angrily to Pope Benedict’s pastoral letter on clerical child abuse in Ireland, and said it fell far short of addressing their claims.

Maeve Lewis, executive director of victims’ group One in Four, said the letter had too narrow a focus on lower-ranked Irish priests and did not acknowledge the responsibility of the Vatican in the cover up of clerical sex abuse in Ireland. ‘‘While we welcome some parts of the letter - such as a willingness for the church to cooperate with the civil authorities, we find other parts of it astounding. It does not call for the resignation of Cardinal Sean Brady, which victims’ groups have demanded," she said.

Abuse victim Andrew Madden, author of the Altar Boy, said the pastoral letter failed to address any of the issues raised by himself and others, in an open letter to the Pope last month. ‘‘There has been no owning up of the Catholic Church’s part in causingt he sexual abuse of so many children by protecting paedophile priests. The Catholic Church did not fail to act - it acted very clearly to protect itself and leave other children to pay the price," Madden said.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:14 PM

Some Upset Pope Letter Not Mentioned During Mass

BOSTON (MA)
WBZ

Jim Smith, WBZ Reporter

It was the pope's first public address since his letter apologizing to the victims of priest sex abuse in Ireland.

Pope Benedict avoided any direct mention of the abuse scandal on Sunday, but focused on acknowledging sin and seeking forgiveness. "Trusting in his great mercy toward us, we humbly beg his forgiveness for our own failings and we ask for the strength to grow in holiness." ...

At St. Brigid Church in South Boston, parishioners said there was no mention of it during Sunday mass. "They should have mentioned it," said one churchgoer. "Maybe it should have been brought to the attention of everyone."

Most of the people at St. Brigid have at least a passing knowledge of the papal letter, and they also acknowledge there is much pain in the United States because of the priest abuse crisis.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:10 PM

Victims advocacy group criticizes Pope's comments on clergy sex abuse, travels to Europe

UNITED STATES
Fox 59

By Associated Press
4:40 PM EST, March 21, 2010

CHICAGO (AP) — A national advocacy group says Pope Benedict XVI's apology on sexual abuse by clergy doesn't go far enough.

Members of the Chicago-based Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests left Sunday for Europe.

President Barbara Blaine says members are concerned and the goal is to encourage those who have been abused to speak out and lobby for independent investigations.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:07 PM

Pope-victims gap is tip of iceberg of incomprehension in Catholic Church

Ethopian Review

Tom Heneghan | March 21st, 2010

The wide gap between Pope Benedict’s letter to the Irish and the reaction it received from victims — the subject of my analysis today on the Reuters wire — is the tip of an iceberg of incomprehension. The frank letter went further than any previous papal condemnation of clerical sex abuse of children, an aspect that Benedict’s defenders promptly highlighted, and went so far as to say some bishops had committed “grave errors of judgment” and undermined their own credibility. This is strong stuff indeed, especially from a man like Joseph Ratzinger who has a far loftier image of the Church and its servants (more on that later).

But what was bold for Benedict was still cowardly for his critics, who saw these “grave errors of judgment” as only the starting point and wanted to hear what the pope would do about them. “The smallest steps that are obvious for any reasonable person are made painfully slowly, which ruins the Church’s reputation radically,” the German group Initiative Kirche von Unten (Church from Below Initiative). This and other victims’ groups, backed up in several countries by the media, some politicians and apparently quite a few Catholics in the pews, appreciate the apologies but want to go beyond them. They want to go up the chain of command and hold those bishops responsible who hushed up abuse cases, moved predator priests around and extracted secrecy deals from frightened victims.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 6:00 PM

Bruce Arnold: Politicians share blame for turning blind eye to abuse

IRELAND
Irish Independent

By BRUCE ARNOLD

Saturday March 20 2010

The silence of our politicians is as shameful as Cardinal Brady professes himself to be. They have had nothing whatever to say about their part in the abuse of children and their responsibility for the inadequacies in the law, or for the failure of the law to be implemented.

This has happened time and time again, and has been referred to, time and time again, without lifting the pall of silence in which politicians look the other way.

We have been lectured to by the media on the punishment of abuse and questioned over what to do about the criminal concealment of abuse by senior clerics. Yet, with a few commendable exceptions, both personal and party, the politicians have generally subscribed to that ultimate piece of hypocrisy -- hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:51 PM

CARDINAL SINS

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

21 March 2010 By John Burke, Public Affairs Correspondent

The most senior Catholic cleric in Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, stands accused of playing a key role in enforcing a code of silence which allowed the activities of paedophile priest Brendan Smyth to go undetected by civil authorities for almost 20 years.

The secrecy with which Brady handled the allegations against one of the country’s most notorious paedophiles 35 years ago suggests that fellow Churchmen may soon be implicated in similar handling of child abuse allegations. As recently as last October, the Murphy Commission, which examined child abuse in the Dublin archdiocese as far back as the mid-1970s, found that oaths of secrecy were a common feature in canonical investigations into child abuse.

Brady’s admission that he acted as a functionary in a canonical investigation which probed abuse allegations made against Smyth in 1975 is expected to be followed by similar admissions from other senior clerics. The Bishop of Clogher in Monaghan, Joseph Duffy, has confirmed to The Sunday Business Post that he was party to similar canonical investigations in which parents and children involved were required to sign an oath of non-disclosure as part of an internal Church probe into abuse claim made against a cleric.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:48 PM

Lost in a moral maze

IRELAND
Sunday Business Post

In the late 1960s, the Catholic Church positioned sexual morality at the heart of its authority - a decision that is now coming back to haunt it, writes Padraic Conway.

There are few who could have been left unmoved by the events of the past week pertaining to Cardinal Sean Brady’s conversations of 1975 with children abused by the late Fr Brendan Smyth. What is striking about this case, compared even to the equally heartfelt reaction to the Ryan and Murphy reports, is the level of disappointment and anger expressed by what we might call ‘‘mainstream’’ or ‘‘silent majority’’ Catholics.

Yesterday’s Pastoral Letter of Pope Benedict XVI to the Catholics of Ireland is of undoubted significance, the fullness of which may take some time to emerge. His call for ‘‘decisive action carried out with complete honesty and transparency’’ as the only way to ‘‘restore the respect and good will of the Irish people towards the Church’’ has the ring of accuracy and truth. One hopes that this letter will indeed be a spur to action and not, as with so many other Roman interventions, a de facto disempowering of the local church. To discover the source of much of our current distress, it is necessary to recall an earlier Papal initiative. For many such people, whose access to ecclesial pulpit or media microphone is slim to none, last week was a watershed - but a watershed with a history.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 5:45 PM

A cover-up beyond forgiveness

SCOTLAND
Herald Scotland

Ian Bell

Pope Benedict has called it “the child abuse crisis”.

Crisis of what, exactly, and for whom? In his general audience at the Vatican last week the pontiff also spoke of “this painful situation”. Is it still possible to hope that something important was lost in the translation of those miserable words?

One by one, even the defences of the well-meaning are being stripped away. The hopes of the remaining faithful, still attempting to live their lives in Christ, are being shattered. All those who have done no harm, who love their church, whose anger and horror are a match for any secular cynic, have less and less to offer.

What remains? The claim, as though in excuse, that there will always be an inescapable few who are tainted and twisted? It no longer holds.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:24 PM

CONTEST…If I were Pope Benedict, I would…

Voice from the Desert

Frank Douglas

I am sick and tired of words, words, words, and more words–some of them my own–about the Catholic clergy sex abuse scandal and its cover up by bishops, religious superiors, and the pope. Which leads me to run a contest to identify the most realistic and likely actions the real pope could take to protect the innocent, heal the wounded, and begin the long process of church reform.

Suppose you were Pope Benedict XVI for a day. Suppose, as Archbishop of Munich, you covered up, i.e., kept silent about, clergy sex abuse in the archdiocese. Suppose, as the leader of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, you promoted a document that all clergy sex abuse cases were to be kept secret. Keep these facts in mind as you prepare your contest entry. These are the baggage items with with you are burdened.

Suppose further, as part of the contest, that the following ground rules apply:

1.You, as pope for a day, are to recommend one, or two, but no more than three initial, concrete actions, not words, not apologies, not a papal letter, that the real pope could or might implement.

Posted by Kathy Shaw at 4:18 PM

Clergy sex abuse victims' group leaders head to Europe

UNITED STATES/EUROPE
Chicago Breaking News

March 21, 2010

A day after the pope issued an apology to victims of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Ireland, two leaders from a Chicago-based group for survivors of church sexual abuse left for Europe today to meet with victims, criticize Vatican officials and urge independent investigations into church sex crimes.

"That's why we're going now. We're extremely concerned about what's coming out of Rome," said Barbara Blaine, pres