Hartford Courant
March 8, 2008
http://www.courant.com/news/politics/hc-catholicpay0308.artmar08,0,2904601.story
The Roman Catholic Church paid out more than $526 million to settle sex abuse claims against clergy last year — including at least $3.8 million to victims of Connecticut priests.
The statistics are included in a new report for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops that measures how the church is dealing with a sex abuse scandal that continues to plague parishes across the United States. Although the number of sex abuse claims dropped for the third consecutive year, payouts to victims nearly doubled, to their highest level ever.
 |
| Number Of Allgations And Costs Related To Allegations |
The report, released Friday, does not break its findings down by diocese, or even by state, but officials with the Hartford and Norwich dioceses said they paid out $1.3 million and $2.5 million respectively in 2007.
Seven new and credible claims of sexual abuse were reported to the Hartford Archdiocese last year, said its spokesman, the Rev. John Gatzak. Norwich reported no new claims.
The Bridgeport Diocese, which has reported paying out a total of roughly $34 million so far settling sex abuse claims, did not have 2007 numbers available Friday.
The Connecticut claims settled in 2007 include $550,000 from the Hartford Archdiocese for a victim of the Rev. Stephen Foley, a former longtime state police and fire chaplain. Roughly $2 million went to a victim of the Rev. Bruno Primavera, who served in the Norwich Diocese from 1978 to 1980.
Officials in the Hartford and Norwich dioceses said Friday that they have used insurance money to fund the bulk of their settlement payments. "It doesn't come from the Sunday collection basket or the annual bishop's appeal," said Michael Strammiello, spokesman for the Norwich Diocese.
In Hartford, the 2007 numbers are markedly lower than the $22 million the Archdiocese agreed to pay two years ago as part of a settlement involving 43 claims.
The two dioceses in 2007 also each spent about $200,000 on sexual abuse prevention measures — which ranged from background checks on priests and staff to educational programs.
"We were told that Hartford Archdiocese is an example of best practices," Gatzak said, referring to the audit it underwent last September in preparation for the national report.
The report shows that, nationally, the number of sex abuse claims against Roman Catholic clergy dropped for the third consecutive year, but total payouts to victims nearly doubled, to their highest level ever.
Dioceses and religious orders received 691 new allegations last year, compared with 714 in 2006. The overwhelming majority of claims date back decades.
Settlements with victims increased by 90 percent over the same period, to more than $526 million — the largest amount for one year. Total abuse-related costs, including settlements, legal fees, therapy for victims and support for offenders, surpassed $615 million for dioceses and religious orders.
Several dioceses reached massive agreements with victims in the past 12 months. The Archdiocese of Los Angeles had the biggest by far, pledging $660 million to about 500 people. But many of those settlements have yet to be fully paid. Insurance covers some of the cost.
The findings are part of an annual review the American bishops commissioned in 2002 as the abuse crisis consumed the church. A companion audit of bishops' child safety policies found that nearly every diocese was following the plan.
Still, the bishops' child protection officer cautioned against "issue fatigue."
Teresa Kettelkamp, executive director of the Office of Child and Youth Protection, said the sense of urgency surrounding the issue is easing as dioceses finish enacting the reforms and cope with the many other demands on their resources.
Auditors found that some lay-clergy review boards — created in every diocese to help bishops respond to abuse — hadn't met in more than a year because no new allegations had been made. Two archdioceses — Denver and Anchorage — hadn't reported abuse claims to civil authorities until after the lapse was discovered in the audit.
"I think this is too important an issue to tire of it," Kettelkamp said. "Just because the number of victims has decreased, don't feel that there aren't more victims out there needing encouragement to come forward."
The abuse crisis erupted in 2002, with the case of one predator priest in the Archdiocese of Boston, then spread to dioceses nationwide and beyond. The bishops responded by enacting the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, which requires dioceses to conduct background checks on workers, provide safety training to children and reach out to victims.
Nearly 14,000 molestation claims have been filed against Catholic clergy since 1950, according to tallies released by the bishops' conference. Abuse-related costs have reached at least $2.3 billion in the same period.
Of the 691 new abuse claims in 2007, five cases involved alleged victims who were under age 18 last year. Some of the accused clergy in these cases were overseas priests working in the United States.
The National Review Board, the lay panel the bishops established to monitor their policies, said dioceses should improve background checks on priests from other countries and review standards of conduct with them. American dioceses are relying increasingly on overseas priests as the number of U.S. clergy sharply declines.
Most of the new allegations were made by adults who said they had been abused about three decades ago. A large majority of the 491 clergy accused last year were dead or missing, or had either been barred from public church work or defrocked because of other molestation cases.
About 40 percent of the clergy was newly accused.
The survey of nearly all 195 U.S. dioceses and non-geographic districts called eparchies was conducted by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate at Georgetown University.
The accompanying audit was conducted by The Gavin Group Inc., a consulting firm led by a former FBI official, which completed on-site reviews at 190 dioceses and eparchies nationwide. Four eparchies and the Diocese of Lincoln, Neb., did not participate.
Advocates for victims have criticized the annual reports because the auditors and researchers must rely on information provided by the dioceses and religious orders.
"It's tempting but irresponsible to assume progress has been made at this very premature stage," said David Clohessy of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. "There always has been and always will be a lag time in reporting abuse."
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.