"I Feel Physically Ill
at the Behaviour of My Clerical Colleagues"
Fr Brian D'Arcy tells Eamon Keane on Newstalk that the State must
step in to protect children
November 29, 2009
[For links to related articles, see Martin:
Is there a paedophile ring? by Maeve Sheehan, Irish Independent, November
I must have read about a dozen reports from all over the world, from Boston
right through to the Ryan report, the Ferns report, the Dublin report
and reports from Australia, and they seem just the same.
Yesterday, I just felt physically sick. This morning I have to get up
and I try to read it again and I still felt physically sick and I still
am physically sick having read the kind of abuse that was perpetrated
on innocent children by people who, in a sense were colleagues of mine,
because I did spend quite a number of years working within the Dublin
Archdiocese in Mount Argus.
Later in the 80s I began writing about this in the Sunday World and it
was not believed, nobody believed that it was true. It began to seep through
that things were happening because I knew about it from American contacts
and I wrote about them and they were denied. And the way in which the
institution of the Church resisted any hint of anything being less than
perfect within the institution to me is horrifying and degrading, and
as I read it today I cannot but agree with the man who said "There
is no future for that particular church".
You take Archbishop Dermot Ryan, for all the work that he did in Dublin,
his reward for covering up was that he was made a cardinal. Sadly he didn't
live to see it, but he was posthumously made a cardinal. Desmond Connell,
for all his work, he was also made a cardinal. Cardinal Law in Boston,
who had an equal cover-up to all of this in Dublin -- and the reports
of that are really as horrifying -- was held responsible for what had
happened in Boston. Where is he now? He was promoted to an office in Rome.
So don't tell me that this protection of the institution is not more important
than the protection of children that is at the heart of the matter. It
is when something that is supposed to be set up for the promotion of Christian
values becomes more concerned about its own self preservation that the
Christian values can go wherever they like as long as the preservation
is maintained and anyone who steps out of line is hit over the head. And
if somebody had come and said they would have had no trouble at all removing
that priest from office and silencing him, yet where a bishop comes in
and says "we have three paedophiles we're covering it up" he
becomes a cardinal.
Anyone who tried to bring it up to the surface at community meetings,
or wherever, it was always marginalised, it was always fought against.
And here's a very simple thing for you, every religious order, every diocese
has a certain amount of paedophiles within them at the moment not working
and not working as priests, but there's a very simple way the Vatican
could easily say, as Canon Law does actively say, that all priests who
have been involved in paedophilia activity should immediately be laicised,
defrocked, call it what you like, so that they can never possibly act
or go out into the shadow of being holy again.
If a priest left and wanted to get married to a woman they have no problem
at all getting rid of a guy like that you know. So there's this sinister
thing where, if you're in a diocese or an order where these guys are,
they will resist everything that is done and they will pontificate and
they will try to tell the rest of us how to lead our lives. I've experienced
this at first hand and it is the most sickening, awful thing that you
First of all, as a child, I was sexually abused by a priest. And at school,
as a first year student, I was sexually abused by a priest of the order
of which I now belong, and I've also been a superior in the order for
a long time and every time you try to remove these guys from ministries
you are met with the sternest opposition and there seems to be this idea
that people should be given a second chance. There is a false sense of
forgiveness, a false sense of loyalty.
My strongest argument in all of this is my only motto in life, is to protect
the child from abuse and protect the family from abuse and protect the
people that have been harmed by this -- in my life as a priest I've had
to deal with a number of suicides which were absolutely related to abuse
by a priest or a brother as a youngster.
I've seen the devastation in people's lives, it is a horrendous crime
and you know only somebody who has been through it at a deep level can
understand -- and the bravery of the likes of Andrew Madden and Marie
Collins and many, many others who have stood up to this institution is
I want to make sure that not only can this never happen again, but I want
to make sure that the State takes control of the protection of children.
It shouldn't be left to any institution or a sports club, or a church.
It's the State's job to protect it and nothing should stop the State from
We have a better system of protection for children at the moment -- Dr
Diarmuid Martin needs to be encouraged, Eamonn Walsh needs to be encouraged,
but believe you me, it has been the victims who have pushed this and the
State who have been taking control.
Eamon Keane's 'Lunchtime' programme is broadcast Monday to Friday, 12.00-14.00,
on Newstalk 106-108fm