BishopAccountability.org

Clerical Abuse Victims' Compensation Case Begins

By John Cordina
Malta Independent
October 9, 2013

http://www.independent.com.mt/articles/2013-10-09/news/clerical-abuse-victims-compensation-case-begins-2838986753/


The request for compensation by 10 victims of clerical abuse at the St Joseph Home in Santa Venera is time-barred, according to the lawyer of the religious order – the Missionary Society of Saint Paul – that runs the home.

The first hearing in the case filed by the 10 men against the two former priests convicted of abuse – Charles Pulis and Godwin Scerri – the MSSP, the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Malta and the government was held this morning in front of Judge Lino Farrugia Sacco.

The MSSP’s lawyer, Ray Zammit, filed a request for the entire proceedings to be held behind closed doors, a request which was backed by lawyers representing the Malta Archdiocese and the government. The two former priests, who are currently serving prison terms, had no lawyer representing them, prompting Mr Justice Farrugia Sacco to warn that this was a serious case and that legal assistance was very much required.

But the lawyers representing the 10 abuse victims, Franco Vassallo and Patrick Valentino, objected to the request, with the former stating that it was not in the interest of justice. He added that if anything, it should be the victims who should make such a request, and not the perpetrators.

Dr Vassallo also noted that he was open to having witnesses heard in private, but pointed out that the legal arguments being made – particularly that the request for compensation is time-barred – deserved scrutiny.

In response, Dr Zammit said that his request was based on three main points, including that the ensuing media reports and public debate would be damaging to justice, and that issues of a very sensitive and private nature would be brought up.

He also said that the case would be damaging to the nineteen children at St Joseph Home, stating that the criminal trial against the two former priests already had a negative impact.

“I do not want them to pass through that again,” he said.

Mr Justice Farrugia Sacco ultimately ruled that witnesses should be heard behind closed doors, but insisted that at this stage, any debates of a legal nature should be public.

The case continues on 16 December. Lawyers Joe Brincat and Dominic Cassar are appearing for the Malta Archdiocese, while Victoria Buttigieg is representing the office of the Attorney General.




.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.