Pope Francis to Dismay Reformists with "Modern Families" Document
By Rosie Scammell
April 7, 2016
|Pope Francis is not expected to grant remarried Catholics the right to take holy communion. Photograph: Sipa/Rex/Shutterstock|
Pope Francis is likely to disappoint Catholic reformists on Friday with the publication of his views on family life, which observers predict will not change church doctrine on divorcees and gay people, despite presenting a more open approach.
The Amoris Laetitia (Joy of Love) document, known as an apostolic exhortation, follows a two-year consultation with bishops to determine how the church should address the challenges facing modern families.
Francis is expected to adopt a positive tone and welcoming approach to Catholics who do not fit the nuclear family model; but in keeping with the outcome of the bishops’ synods, there is unlikely to be a dramatic shift in church teachings.
The pontiff is not expected to grant divorced Catholics who remarry the right to take holy communion, though he is likely to acknowledge that they should play an active role in church life and not be sidelined.
A similar stance will be taken on gay Catholics, whose relationships will continue to be described as “intrinsically disordered”. The focus instead will rest on the respectful engagement between the church and gay people.
Paulinus Ozodor, a religion professor at the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, US, said it was necessary for the pontiff to reaffirm the church’s beliefs. “As a community that has firm beliefs about the human person, it does sometimes have to teach things that are contrary to what many people think is right,” he told the Guardian.
|Pope Francis meets the Croatian prime minister and his wife at the Vatican on Thursday. Photograph: Reuters|
Ozodor said the church was worried about the state of the family and how to tackle challenges such as poverty, and migration. Such areas will be addressed by the apostolic exhortation, along with violence and abuse.
The pope is also likely to touch on fertility treatment and contraception – long opposed by the church – and the key value of marital sex.
Thomas Groome, a professor at Boston College, a Jesuit Catholic university in Massachusetts, said the text would be “a major breakthrough in human consciousness” which raised difficult issues in a way never seen before.
“The fact that he’s allowing us to talk about these things is a breakthrough,” said Groome. “It was presumed it was already decided and anybody that was raising this was obviously contrary to the church.”
The pontiff’s drive for open discussion resulted in strong debate during the synods, as bishops presented very different cultural and social norms. Francis is expected to acknowledge this by advising priests to use church rules in a way to best serve their communities.
“He’s said a number of times that dogma or doctrine should be at the service of pastoral life and pastoral practice,” explained Groome. “You have to take the circumstances of people’s lives into account … There has to be mercy when people don’t do as well as they could.”
The popularity of the Argentinian pope is expected to increase the impact of the text, which will run to more than 250 pages and be printed in six languages, while its publication during the Vatican’s holy year of mercy will contribute to its tone.