BishopAccountability.org

EDITORIAL: Pennsylvania grand jury report spurs nationwide action

Observer-Reporter
January 13, 2019

https://bit.ly/2MbXxQU

The Observer-Reporter building in Washington

The grand jury report that was released last summer detailing decades of child sexual abuse by priests in six of Pennsylvania’s eight Roman Catholic dioceses was shocking, to be sure, but it was also a necessary spur for justice to be delivered to hundreds of victims around the commonwealth, and a victory for openness and transparency – one area where the hierarchy of the Catholic Church has decidedly fallen short for many years.

The grand jury investigation has been beneficial to Pennsylvania and, as a report earlier this month by the Associated Press found, it has had a salutary effect across the United States. In the five months since the grand jury findings came to light, 105 of the nation’s 187 dioceses have said that they will identify priests who have been accused of sexually abusing children. In addition, close to 20 civil or criminal investigations have been set in motion.

Alas, in some cases it is far too late for justice to be rendered. The AP found that more than 60 percent of the accused priests have died, and the statute of limitations has run out in many of the cases where priests are still alive. This largely repeats the state of play in Pennsylvania, where only two of the 301 priests identified have been charged, and some of the incidents that filled the grand jury report happened decades ago.

Still, victim advocates point to many positive outcomes, even if a guilty verdict against an abuser is not one of them. Dioceses either have set up compensation funds or will face increasing demands to do so. Priests who had been removed from the ministry but were allowed to take on other jobs where they could have contact with children could now lose those positions.

Perhaps most importantly, however, the efforts by law-enforcement officials to investigate and hear the stories of victims offer a sense of resolution and vindication for many victims, following decades of shame, silence or skepticism.

Joe McLean, a victim from St. Paul, Minn., told the AP, “This is a milestone. We are getting closer and closer to what this ought to be, the true coming to terms that would have to be at a national level.”

Following in the footsteps of Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, attorneys general in several states are now talking about or launching similar grand jury investigations on their home turf, and prosecutors in some cities are examining individual cases. As a result of the publicity surrounding the grand jury report and its fallout, there has been a sharp increase in the number of people who say they were victimized coming forward. Of course, all those accused should be accorded the presumption of innocence, and some investigations will surely lead to nothing more than dead ends. But this reckoning with past misconduct has been long overdue.

Shapiro told the Associated Press that even as the church has sought to atone for its mistakes, he does not believe it is capable of policing itself.

“They need outside forces, ideally law enforcement, to hold them accountable.”

It appears, at long last, that is happening.

 




.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.