|2 Sue Priest, Alleging Sex Abuse
By Joe Nawrozki and Robert A. Erlandson
The Baltimore Sun
August 25, 1994
In lawsuits seeking $ 40 million in damages, a Baltimore priest was
accused yesterday of sexually abusing two former students at a Catholic
girls high school more than 20 years ago.
The Rev. A. Joseph Maskell, 55, is accused of a series of assaults — some
involving bizarre sex practices — spelled out in graphic terms in the
The alleged attacks occurred when the plaintiffs were students during the
late 1960s and early 1970s at Archbishop Keough High School in Southwest
A now-retired gynecologist who accepted Archbishop Keough students as
patients on referral from Father Maskell also is named in one of the suits.
The suit says the doctor allowed Father Maskell into the examining room
where both men sexually assaulted the teen-age girl.
More than 30 men and women are prepared to testify to first-hand knowledge
about other alleged acts of sexual abuse by the priest — one of which
allegedly occurred on the Keough chapel altar, another in the chapel
sacristy and others in rectories and the priest's private school office,
said Beverly A. Wallace, a lawyer for the women.
Father Maskell also is the subject of a criminal investigation by the
Baltimore state's attorney's office involving sexual abuse allegations.
In addition, a high-ranking Baltimore County police official said this
summer that the priest's name has surfaced in a reopened investigation of
the 1969 slaying of Sister Catherine Ann Cesnik, who had worked with him at
Father Maskell, who was chaplain and psychological counselor at the school
but most most recently was pastor at a Howard County parish, engaged in
various acts of intercourse, the suits charge, and in one incident, is said
to have placed a gun in the mouth of one of the plaintiffs.
The suits allege that Father Maskell used various tactics to persuade or
coerce the victims, including hypnosis, threats of physical violence and
assault. The suits also claim Father Maskell forced the teen-agers to
perform sexual acts with a police officer when the priest was chaplain for
the Baltimore County Police Department.
Father Maskell, who holds a master's degree in psychology and a
certificate in advanced study in counseling from the Johns Hopkins
University, degraded and humiliated the plaintiffs, the suits allege.
In interviews with police and The Sun, Father Maskell has denied all
allegations that he sexually abused students at Keough or elsewhere.
J. Michael Lehane, an attorney for Father Maskell, said he would not
comment until he reads the suits.
Thomas C. Dame, a lawyer for the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Baltimore
who was present when the suits were filed, referred inquiries to William
Blaul, spokesman for the archdiocese.
Mr. Blaul said he would not comment on the suits because he has not had an
opportunity to review them.
He said Father Maskell is at a "well-regarded, out-of-state facility where
he is receiving treatment."
Independently, The Sun conducted taped interviews with the two plaintiffs
months before yesterday's legal action.
Both alleged that Father Maskell occasionally used the sacraments of the
church as a vehicle for sex practices.
They, and other women and men on the witness list, told The Sun that
Father Maskell persuaded the girls to confess in church whether they were
sexually active or had experimented with drugs and then used their
indiscretions to force them to do his will. If they were not sexually
active, Father Maskell told them they were "frigid" and would "counsel"
them, usually involving sexual acts and implements, the women said.
"He told me he would tell my parents I was having sex with my boyfriend,"
said one woman on the witness list. "In those days, in a strict Roman
Catholic family, that was like the world was going to end."
Another woman on the witness list, now a professional in the health care
field, said the priest conducted an "internal pelvic examination of me on a
table in the sacristy of the chapel at the high school."
"He would tell me he was medically trained, that it was for our own good,"
she said. "Combined with the fact that he was one of the closest
representatives to God in the Catholic religion, how were we as teen-agers
to know what to do?"
Other women have alleged that Father Maskell made inappropriate comments
"I was only 13 years old; I didn't even know what petting was. It was the
only time I ever had a priest suggest what my sins might be," said a 1972
Keough graduate, also on the witness list, who said the priest asked what
she did with her boyfriend and made suggestive comments.
She said she did not attend confession for 25 years after the encounter
with Father Maskell early in her freshman year.
Yesterday's suits were filed in Baltimore Circuit Court by Towson lawyers
Phillip G. Dantes, James G. Maggio and Ms. Wallace.
The two women plaintiffs, identified only as Jane Roe and Jane Doe, now
are in their early 40s.
Additional suits will be filed, Ms. Wallace said.
Mr. Dantes, lead lawyer in the case, said there are only two plaintiffs
because a three-year civil statute of limitations precluded others from
joining the suit.
With the two plaintiffs, he said, the three-year period began from the
time they recovered their memories of the alleged abuse, as allowed under
Other people who alleged Father Maskell abused them said they never had
lost the memory but had no one to report to.
Mr. Dantes said their testimony will show a pattern to corroborate the
Also named as a defendant in one of the suits is Dr. Christian Richter,
79, of Ruxton, a retired gynecologist. "During the course of multiple
examinations . . . in Maskell's presence, both Richter and Maskell sexually
battered plaintiff, including engaging in vaginal penetration," the suit
Dr. Richter told The Sun last March and April that he accepted referrals
from Father Maskell at his private office on St. Paul Street.
Although he first denied the priest was present during examinations, Dr.
Richter later said, "It's possible he may have been in the examining room,
in the absence of parents, I don't know, to calm the girl. It's very
possible he might have come in the examining room. She was 16. She probably
had a good deal of faith in him."
Dr. Richter said Father Maskell showed a great interest in medicine,
particularly in gynecology. "He seemed to be more acclimated to the OB
obstetrics and GYN part of it."
"All I can say is, he's a man. And I guess it was his opportunity . . . ,"
Dr. Richter replied.
Asked what he meant by "opportunity," he said, "To be inclined to favor
women in any way, I guess."
During the interviews, Dr. Richter denied sexually abusing the woman. He
reiterated that denial yesterday when he was shown a copy of the lawsuit.
Dr. Richter declined to comment on the suit other than to say it lacks
"details on what we're supposed to have done."
The city state's attorney's office also is looking into other purported
sexual attacks on children and young adults at parishes where Father Maskell
was assigned after his ordination in 1965.
Two weeks ago, city detectives dug up a vanload of confidential records
the priest had ordered buried four years ago in Holy Cross Cemetery in
Sharon A. H. May, chief of the Sex Abuse Unit in the city state's
attorney's office, this week continued to refuse comment on the
City police were accompanied at the exhumation of the records by the two
Baltimore County homicide detectives assigned to the revived investigation
of the slaying of Sister Catherine.
The detectives were there because Father Maskell's name had come up during
their investigation, said Capt. Rustin E. Price, commander of the county
"We are still actively investigating leads," Captain Price said yesterday.
Sister Catherine was also on the faculty of Archbishop Keough. The priest
has denied any knowledge of the slaying.
On July 31, Father Maskell stepped down as pastor of St. Augustine's
Church in Elkridge and went into treatment.
On Aug. 2, he resigned from the Maryland Air National Guard, where he was
senior chaplain of the 135th Air Transport Group, based at Martin State
He also was dropped from the advisory board of Operation Challenge, a
Guard-sponsored program at Aberdeen Proving Ground for high school dropouts.
After he left St. Augustine's, archdiocesan officials said he had
requested time off to seek in-patient therapy for anxiety and stress brought
on by "the prospect of civil litigation and a criminal investigation."
The suits also name as defendants the archdiocese, Archbishop William H.
Keeler, the School Sisters of Notre Dame and Seton-Keough High School, which
previously was known as Archbishop Keough.
The lawyers for the plaintiffs said the order of teaching nuns is named as
a defendant because it was Father Maskell's immediate supervisor while he
was at Archbishop Keough.
The high school is named because of administrative responsibility, and the
archdiocese and Archbishop Keeler because they are the direct employers of
"Defendants breached their duties by negligently failing to investigate
and monitor the background and activities of Maskell and, upon notice of
such propensities, negligently placing Maskell at Keough, and thereafter
negligently failing to adequately supervise and monitor his behavior," the
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.