AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald
November 16, 2012
Waleed Aly
Who says politicians can’t sing in unison? This week we’ve seen the full array of politicians – Green, Labor, Liberal and independent – lining up to dismantle the Catholic Church’s institution of sealed confession. The idea that a priest could hear another priest’s confession of child sex abuse, and fail to report it to the authorities is, says the Attorney-General, Nicola Roxon, “really abhorrent”. The NSW Premier, Barry O’Farrell, “just can’t fathom” it. The independent MP Nick Xenophon just slams it as “a medieval law that needs to change in the 21st century”.
No freedom of religion argument can succeed against this. The secular liberalism that defines our public culture simply won’t accept it for one simple reason: religious freedom ends where harm to other people begins. And it’s a rare kind of harm that is more horrific than children being raped. The church can argue all it likes that the confessional seal is “inviolable”. But what obligation does the secular state have to canon law? What interest does the state have in ensuring people can receive absolution? The church simply has no answer to this. Hence the spectacle of practising Catholics like Tony Abbott and Christopher Pyne jumping on the anti-confessional bandwagon. There’s just no politically viable alternative.
But here’s the problem: the whole issue of the confessional seal is a monstrous red herring. This becomes clear once you pay attention to the way politicians are talking about it. Xenophon recounts the story of a 10-year-old boy who told his story of being abused to a priest at a confessional, only to be told that he’s the sinner and he needs to repent. If that’s the full story, then Xenophon’s right to call it “sickening”, but it simply has nothing to do with the confessional seal. There’s no confession from the abuser to reveal. The child is perfectly entitled to take his story to the police and the priest is perfectly entitled to help him do it. This case isn’t about confidentiality. It’s about a priest with a septic morality. I’d want that priest fired. I’d want the church to apologise, help prosecute the abuser, compensate the victim and make sure it never happens again. And breaking the seal of confession doesn’t help any of that.
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.