VATICAN CITY
National Catholic Reporter
by John L. Allen Jr. | Feb. 13, 2013
Rome —
Repeatedly over the last three days, media agencies have asked me to comment on the following question: Did Benedict XVI really resign just because he’s old and tired, or was it really because of the sexual abuse crisis, the Vatileaks mess, and the various other meltdowns that have occurred on his watch?
My answer has been that it’s not an either/or. Benedict may not have quit “because of” the pedophilia scandals or any other specific controversy, but it’s hard to believe they didn’t play a role, at least as background.
One can certainly take Benedict at his word that he feels his strength fading and simply believes he no longer has the capacity to do the job. Yet it defies reality to believe that the various sources of turmoil in the last seven years haven’t taken a toll and that they help account for the fatigue he now feels.
It’s clear they caused him anguish. Back in 2009, when his decision to lift the excommunications of four traditionalist bishops triggered a global firestorm when it turned out one of them was a Holocaust-denier, Benedict sent a letter to all the bishops of the world to explain what had happened. He apologized for the Vatican’s handling of the situation and openly confessed his own consternation at the criticism it triggered.
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.