IRELAND
Slugger O’Toole
Mick Fealty, Mon 9 June 2014
Whenever a society attempts to impose without exception an impossible abstraction on fallible human beings, such cruelty will always be necessary.
Andrew Sullivan on the Tuam Mother and Baby home…
Now we understand that the high mortality rates at Tuam may have been the norm for such homes across the post independence state. A few years back similarly high rates at the evangelical Protestant Bethany Homes were reported in detail.
And there was (to our modern eyes) a remarkable consensus on the pretty awful way unwed mothers should be treated. Shane Harrison reporting one remembered experience:
“I grew up with starvation, was treated more or less as a dog,” he said.
“I was that hungry that I remember going into a farmer’s field and picking spuds so that we could have a meal and putting the roots back in. Well-off people in the area knew the state we were in but they walked around as if it never happened.”
Tuam closed in 1960 or 61, around about the time contraception became available in the UK. Although it didn’t arrive in the Republic till much later, it was technological change that killed the force of the abstraction Sullivan cites above rather than some spiritual sea change.
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.