FALMOUTH (ME)
Patch [Falmouth, ME]
February 12, 2026
By Ted Cohen
When Will The Parish of the Holy Eucharist Pastoral Council Break Its Silence?
Try as it might, an influential organization representing priest sexual-abuse victims has heard nothing but crickets from the very body that by any measure should be all ears.
Parish of the Holy Eucharist Pastoral Council members are refusing pleas from Voice of the Faithful in Maine to lend their influence to the faithful’s efforts to set up a meeting with the Rev. Steven Cartwright of Falmouth.
Twice now Cartwright has cancelled scheduled meetings with Paul Kendrick of Freeport and Michael Sweatt of North Yarmouth, founders of the sexual-abuse support group.
“He is adding insult to injury by refusing to say why he is shutting the door on us,” Kendrick and Sweatt wrote the council. “We’ve asked each of you if you agree with Fr. Cartwright’s decision.
“Sadly, not one of you has responded,” they wrote. “So, we’re asking you one more time – do you agree with Fr. Cartwright’s outright refusal to meet with us?
“If we don’t hear from you, we will consider your answer to be in the affirmative – that you agree with Fr. Cartwright.”
The parish council includes a Falmouth town councilor who, like her fellow eight members, isn’t talking.
The Maine Wire has reached out to the state’s Catholic diocese, which said in a statement Thursday it has recommended that neither Cartwright nor any priests meet with Kendrick and Sweatt.
“The Diocese of Portland has a long-standing history of interactions with Mr. Kendrick and Mr. Sweatt,” said Molly DiLorenzo, diocese director of communications. “Given the nature of these interactions, we would not advise any of our priests or parish staff accept a meeting.”
“We will not comment further on this matter,” DiLorenzo added.
Kendrick and Sweatt say that as baptized Catholics they should be able to meet with a priest.
They want to meet with Cartwright to ask him whether he recognizes parishioners as instrumental in leading the church.
“In addition, there are other matters we wish to discuss with Fr. Cartwright in private,” they said.
Cartwright , a Boothbay Harbor native who has been pastor of Parish of the Holy Eucharist since 2022, has declined to respond to The Maine Wire’s questions about the meeting controversy.
Meanwhile he is claiming to be open to meetings on a schedule he posted online. “Welcome to my scheduling page,” he says. “If the times offered below are not conducive with your schedule, then please email me.”
The sexual-abuse victims’ advocates describe Sacred Heart Catholic Church in Yarmouth, part of the parish council, as “ground zero in our diocese for the sexual abuse of minors by Catholic clergy.”