LUBBOCK (TX)
Baptist News Global [Jacksonville FL]
December 3, 2025
By David Bumgardner
The trial for a former youth pastor at four Texas churches has been reset to April 20, 2026, granting both the prosecution and defense more time to prepare for what is expected to be a contentious case.
Luke Cunningham, 43, of Lubbock, Texas, faces charges that include 16 counts of sexual assault of a child. These charges carry a first-degree felony enhancement known as “bigamy” following a grand jury reindictment that superseded previous charges and added penal enhancements.
The statute under which Cunningham has been reindicted escalates sexual assault charges to first-degree felonies when the offender is accused of assaulting a person “whom the actor was prohibited from marrying or living with under the appearance of marriage,” as defined by Texas bigamy laws.
Prosecutors based these charges on Cunningham’s alleged promises to marry his underage victims — teenagers in his youth group at Turning Point Community Church in Lubbock — once they turned 18. At the time of the alleged offenses, Cunningham was married and had several children with his then-spouse.
Cunningham’s case drew national attention when BNG first reported in June 2024 that he had been arrested by U.S. marshals on child sexual assault charges. He also was reportedly under federal investigation by the FBI for possible international and interstate sex trafficking, as the alleged abuse reportedly took place overseas during mission trips.
BNG has learned through multiple sources close to the case, including advocates and law enforcement officials speaking on background, that Cunningham’s reindictment occurred after a prospective plea deal fell through.
Sources allege that prosecutors initially offered Cunningham a plea deal of 50 years in prison. Had he accepted, Cunningham would have been released at age 93, assuming he survived the full sentence. Cunningham allegedly refused this deal and countered with a prospective term of five years, which was summarily rejected by the prosecution.
Soon thereafter, the grand jury returned the reindictment of Cunningham with the bigamy enhancement.
Requests for comment on the plea deal and subsequent reindictment were not immediately returned by the Lubbock County District Attorney’s Office or Cunningham’s defense attorney, Michael King.