The SBC’s Abuse Helpline Is Hogwash

NASHVILLE (TN)
In Solidarity with Christa Brown [Substack]

November 14, 2026

By Christa Brown

It’s about helping the institutional image, not helping survivors

“Abuse helpline provides support for victims.”

Grrrrr.

When I saw that headline on a Baptist Press1 article last week, I nearly gagged up my coffee.

The Southern Baptist Convention Executive Committee is claiming that its abuse “helpline” provides support for clergy sex abuse survivors.

“Hogwash,” I say. It’s phony baloney.

Survivors should beware.

That’s my opinion. And it’s the gist of what I hear from other survivors: “Spare us the gaslighting.”

For Southern Baptist leaders to claim they support Baptist clergy sex abuse survivors is akin to Speaker Mike Johnson claiming House Republicans support transparency for the Epstein files.

Sounds good, but it’s not what’s happening in the real. And we all know it.

In the real, SBC leaders characterize the SBC’s abuse crisis as a hoax and call it a “snipe hunt.” So, why should survivors expect “help” from leaders like that?

In the real, the SBC Executive Committee has a decades-long documented history of deplorable conduct toward clergy sex abuse survivors – conduct for which they’ve made no amends. So again, why should survivors expect “help” from leaders like that?

What that Baptist Press headline is trying to do is to dissimulate reality behind a performative display. It’s theater.

And it’s the same old con: promoting an image of care that is untethered from actual care.

As Stephanie Krehbiel once noted, in the #ChurchToo arena, when religious leaders act “benevolent,” it’s often just a brick wall that’s been painted to look like a door. In other words, it’s illusion.

The Guidepost report highlighted a secret list maintained by the SBC Executive Committee that had over 700 entries of credibly accused abusers, many of whom had multiple victims. If SBC leaders really want to support survivors, why don’t they help the many hundreds of already-known survivors?

So why do SBC leaders spew such propaganda, given how little of any meaningful care they’ve ever actually demonstrated?

I think it’s because they understand that ordinary people in the pews – i.e., the people who donate money – hold a core desire to be seen as part of something good. So, SBC leaders placate them with an illusion to latch onto. In other words, it’s about caring for the institutional image; it’s not about caring for survivors.

Imagine if Southern Baptist leaders just came right out and said with their words what their deeds – and lack of deeds – have made plain: “We don’t really give a flip about caring for clergy sex abuse survivors.”

That would be truthful, but it’s not a truth that would sit well with a lot of people in the pews. So, it’s a truth that SBC leaders try to obscure by touching up the brick wall with ever-better door-paint.

But of course, no matter how good the paint job, a brick wall is still a brick wall. And you don’t get help from a brick wall.

Here are some excerpts from what I wrote more than a year ago about the SBC’s abuse “helpline,” and I have no reason to think anything about it has changed. What a ruse!

According to the Executive Committee’s press release, the new “helpline” will provide referrals to “Christian counseling” for survivors who report clergy sex abuse. I guess that means they’ll be directing survivors to some of their cronies. (And I’d bet some of those survivors will get “counseled” on forgiveness.) 🙄

What it almost certainly does NOT mean is that the SBC Executive Committee will expose reported abusive pastors.

We know this because, even with at least 674 clergy sex abuse reports made to the prior “hotline,” not a single one of those reported pastors has been publicly named by the Executive Committee, and the promised mechanism for imposing such minimal accountability – an institutional database – has been completely sidelined.

The new “helpline” will not only take calls from survivors — and it’s worth noting that the “calls are recorded” — but also from church leaders. It will provide ministry leaders with “coaching” on how to deal with abuse reports.

“Coaching.” 🙄

Interestingly, in the same email that the Evangelical Council of Abuse Prevention sent out announcing its partnership on the SBC “helpline,” it also directed its readers to an article on “How Churches Can Pre-Game a PR Crisis” … “even if the allegations are false.”

So, given their juxtaposition of “coaching” with “PR crisis”, it appears to me that the “coaching” is more likely to be about how churches should handle public relations than it is about how to best protect others or help survivors. And the fact that they immediately leaped to plant in people’s minds the possibility of false allegations tells a lot about where their heads are….

Suffice it to say that I see no reason for any optimism on what they mean by their offer of “coaching” for church leaders, and the SBC has earned zero trust on this. I don’t expect that the “coaching” will work to the benefit of survivors and, more likely, it will work to the benefit of churches in their typical image-management and liability avoidance efforts. What it almost certainly does NOT mean is that there will be any public outing of sexually abusive pastors in a way that informs congregants and prevents pastors from church-hopping to new prey.

Of course, per their typical “all PR all the time” approach, the SBC is hyping their new “helpline” as reflective of their commitment to “pursue justice” and “extend grace.” 🙄

Nice words, but let’s just remember the history here. If the SBC Executive Committee had any interest in pursuing justice, they never would have filed that awful anti-survivor amicus brief, urging in court that survivors should be shut out from pursuing justice. And as for “grace,” I don’t know any clergy sex abuse survivors who’ve seen much of that within the SBC. The “grace” seems always extended to the abusive pastors and their enabling colleagues rather than to the wounded survivors.

https://christabrown.substack.com/p/the-sbcs-abuse-helpline-is-hogwash