‘Name him’: Clergy abuse survivors call on church to identify N.L. priest sent for treatment in 1975

(CANADA)
CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation) [Toronto, Canada]

November 17, 2026

By Ryan Cooke

Facility would have destroyed records after 2000 policy, court documents reveal

An international organization of clergy abuse survivors and advocates is calling on a Roman Catholic diocese in Newfoundland to release the name of a priest who was sent away for treatment more than 50 years ago.

Ending Clergy Abuse issued a public demand last week. The organization is led by Newfoundland and Labrador clergy abuse survivor Gemma Hickey.

This comes after the diocese’s former insurance company sought a court order forcing the Southdown Institute in Ontario to turn over its records on the priest, who was mentioned anonymously in the 1990 Winter Commission report into clergy abuse. The report said he was sent away for treatment in 1975 after parents complained about his conduct with their child.

Southdown responded to the application, telling the court it would have destroyed the records under a file management policy adopted in 2000.

Hickey said that leaves only one avenue for uncovering the truth — the Diocese of Grand Falls coming forward on its own.

“The Church knew his name in 1975. The Winter Commission knew he existed in 1990,” Hickey said. “Today, the public still doesn’t [know his name]. Every route to the truth has failed, and right now nothing requires the church to tell the public… It’s long past time to name him, and every priest like him.”

Southdown has treated clergy for a wide range of issues since 1965. The Winter Commission report mentioned at least five priests from Newfoundland who were sent away for treatment, including four who were accused of having inappropriate relationships with minors.

Guardian Insurance applied for an order to compel the institute to hand over records on Father Leonard Joseph Kelly and the unnamed priest, seeking to establish what the Diocese of Grand Falls knew about abusive priests before entering into an insurance policy in the 1980s.

The court action was discontinued when Southdown revealed its policy on destroying files after 12 years.

Ending Clergy Abuse is also calling on the Diocese of Grand Falls to name every priest credibly accused of sexual abuse, as determined by an independent review, who was sent for assessment or treatment, and to disclose what happened to each of them.

While Southdown insists it doesn’t have the relevant records, Ending Clergy Abuse says there’s reason to believe the church does.

In Kelly’s case, for example, Guardian Insurance was able to unearth correspondence between the bishop of Grand Falls and the director of Southdown, showing Kelly was sent there in 1970 under a cloud of suspicion. While the reason for his departure was never explicitly stated, there was mention of him falling to exercise “restraint” in his “relationships with the boys in question.”

Ending Clergy Abuse also called for Southdown to preserve what records it does have left on priests who were sent for treatment after abuse allegations, and for the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops to direct every diocese in Canada to do the same.

The goal, Hickey said, would be to have those records examined in an open and transparent fashion.

“From Grand Falls to Southdown, this was never limited to one diocese or one province,” Hickey said. “We need an independent inquiry with the power to compel records, here and across Canada.”

Ryan Cooke is a justice affairs reporter based in St. John’s. He can be reached at ryan.cooke@cbc.ca.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/southdown-institute-winter-commission-report-priest-9.7423514