KANSAS CITY (MO)
Kansas City Star [Kansas City MO]
November 18, 2026
By Nathan Pilling and Laura Bauer
Maelyn Gress was 14, broken and hurt, when her parents hustled her off to a boarding school in Kansas City nearly two decades ago.
A few days before she was dropped off, she had told them she was sexually assaulted by a male relative, and they wanted her to act like everything was fine, to move on. They’d had difficulties before the rape, Gress said, and her parents weren’t sure how to handle her.
They searched for an answer and found one in Kansas City, on a quiet 11-acre campus in the Brown Estates neighborhood on the city’s East Side. So in April 2008, Gress’ father drove her from their southwest Missouri home and dropped her off at the Teen Challenge program, an unlicensed faith-based boarding school that in recent years has been known as the Kansas City Girls Academy.
“They were given this promise of 24/7 therapy, of licensed therapists living on campus,” said Gress, now 34 and a mom of six. “They were given all these promises that I would be well taken care of, and that they would fix me, essentially, through God. That’s not at all what happened.”
As her father drove away, leaving her at the school, she was strip-searched.
“I was completely naked with people that I didn’t know, after being raped two weeks earlier,” Gress said, “which was traumatic.”
It was just the beginning of 17 painful months.
Gress is among a group of 25 women The Star has interviewed about their time as youths at the religious boarding school during a 15-year span from 2008 through 2022. They described similar experiences of harsh discipline, hard physical labor, medical neglect, emotional abuse, spoiled food and the weaponization of religion.
Former students recalled the strip searches, limited or unhelpful therapy sessions and other lingering problems that blossomed at the school. They described being restrained in shackles, physically demanding punishments doled out by staff in which they were forced to do wall sits or stand silently for long periods as well as having to complete lengthy writing assignments — in two cases, students remembered having to write out the Bible from the first page to the last by hand.
One former student, who is suing the school, said she was sexually assaulted by another girl and the incident was not reported to police.
Another recalled a brutal work assignment she was given in which she hauled rocks between piles for hours in the blistering summer sun as she was yelled at by a school staff member. The same student said she was malnourished and punished with a bland diet for months.
Many told The Star that while they suffered at the school, their families paid thousands of dollars each month in tuition, even as their parents and guardians were kept in the dark about what went on there. In interviews and lawsuits, former students said their calls home were monitored and could be ended if anything unfavorable was said. Letters also were read by staff to censor any negative thoughts or details about the school and life there.
Students at the boarding school initially were typically enrolled for 15 months, but more time — and additional expense — could be added for girls who staff deemed to need more immersion in the programming, several women said.
The Kansas City school is affiliated with the Assemblies of God church and the extensive network of Adult & Teen Challenge residential treatment programs, which both have headquarters in Missouri.
In a statement to The Star, attorney John Schultz, who is representing the boarding school and its leaders in three recent lawsuits, said the school strongly disputes the swath of allegations from former students.
“Every child’s safety and care is of paramount concern to the Academy,” Schultz said. “As a faith-based organization, the Academy encourages personal growth through accountability, mentorship, education, counseling, and spiritual development. Throughout the campus, it fosters an environment of safety, care, and respect.
“Students participate in a structured program designed to promote positive change and long-term success,” the statement said. “Many students and families have experienced meaningful outcomes, and former graduates continue to serve as mentors and examples of that success.”
Many of the allegations at the Kansas City Girls Academy are similar to those revealed by The Star’s previous investigations of unlicensed boarding schools. The Kansas City school, however, hasn’t drawn the widespread scrutiny other unlicensed boarding schools in the state have. Even during The Star’s reporting on faith-based boarding schools beginning in 2020, the academy flew under the radar as no concerns emerged about it.
It’s only now, after the group of recent lawsuits and years-old abuse and neglect allegations have surfaced — including in written testimony presented to a U.S. Senate committee about the school — that lawmakers and child advocates well-versed in these facilities are beginning to learn about the concerns.
“I’m horrified and angered to learn that is happening right here,” said Rep. Keri Ingle, a Lee’s Summit Democrat who co-sponsored 2021 legislation that required unlicensed boarding schools to register with the state and conduct background checks of workers and safety inspections. “But abuse happens everywhere.
“People like to think that it happens in far dark corners with strangers. … No, it looks like a facility that is right down the street from you, and that’s why it’s so important to have consistent oversight and licensure.”
Former students said they hoped people would listen to them and understand that what happened on the Kansas City campus still haunts them. Some still have nightmares about the school, years after leaving. “We would pray every night, me and our roommates,” said Taylor Molitor, who was 16 when she arrived at the school in 2012.
“We would pray every night that God would kill us in our sleep.”
The school should have been shut down decades ago, she said.
“It was one of the most traumatic events of my life,” she said. “I am angry. I am even more angry that they’re still doing this to kids. I mean, it’s ruined my life. I have horrible PTSD.”
Lawsuits filed in federal, state court
The allegations by the women come alongside a batch of new lawsuits that have been filed against the school and some leaders in recent months laying out similar allegations of neglect, poor medical care, abuse and other misconduct.
The first was filed in December in U.S. District Court for Western Missouri, by attorneys for two former students against Kansas City Girls Academy. The students attended the school between early 2009 and mid-2011.
Then, in July, attorneys for three more former students filed separate lawsuits against the school in Jackson County Circuit Court. Each woman sued Teen Challenge of Florida, Inc., doing business as Kansas City Girls Academy and named three school leaders: Alan Biggers, Carol Kemp and Stephanie Kriner.
Each sued for negligence and emotional distress for alleged mistreatment, including constant surveillance and strip searches. The three plaintiffs attended the school between 2019 and 2022.
All three lawsuits mentioned the strip searches at the school, alleging that the former students were subjected to them on multiple occasions.
“Male staff, including Defendant Biggers, would watch Plaintiff (and other girls there) while they were strip-searched, either in person or by video camera,” one suit said. “Other girls at KCGA were present when Plaintiff was strip-searched.”
Another suit, filed on behalf of the former student who said she was sexually assaulted by another girl, said that “after or as part of being placed on ‘suicide watch,’ Plaintiff was subjected to strip searches, in which she was forced to strip completely naked for evaluation by staff, with two other girls in the same room.”
Other allegations in those three lawsuits include former students being fed expired food, such as curdled chocolate milk, having staff watch girls as they undressed, and being forced to write 1,500-word essays, called “Personal Development Reports.”
The Star sent a list of questions to school leaders through Schultz, their attorney. In response, they denied allegations of abuse and neglect and said “many are simply untrue, while others lack important context or mischaracterize practices.”
“Claims that students were subjected to abuse, medical neglect, spoiled food, shackling, harsh physical punishment or other forms of mistreatment are contrary to the facts and do not reflect the reality of the program,” Schultz said. “Likewise, claims that the Academy weaponizes religion or uses faith as a substitute for necessary medical care are false.“
In the federal lawsuit, attorneys wrote that the school marketed itself as a “uniquely transformative” facility that would “lead students towards wholeness.” School leaders, they said, knew the program’s promises were false.
From the time the two former students — known as Jane Doe, K.H., and June Doe, M.H., in federal court records — arrived at the Kansas City boarding school, the lawsuit said, they “were abused, neglected, humiliated, physically assaulted, spiritually coerced, and forced to perform unpaid labor.” (The boarding school has no connection to Kansas City Girls Preparatory Academy, a public, charter middle school operating at 17th Street and Van Brunt Boulevard.)
Students could be “violently restrained,” or be punished with forced silence, long periods of standing or excessive exercise through push-ups, burpees and running to the point of vomiting, exhaustion and fainting, the suit said.
Despite the school’s promises to their parents that staff would give them their prescribed medicine, the two girls were taken off psychiatric medications as the school believed they were “an affront to God’s will,” attorneys wrote. Both went through severe withdrawal symptoms, the lawsuit said.
“Most egregiously, KCGA told (the girls) all of it was God’s will for them, that their illnesses were their own faults, and that they deserved whatever pain they felt,” attorneys for the women wrote.
In response to questions about the school sent by The Star, a spokesperson for the Assemblies of God church provided a brief statement.
“The General Council of the Assemblies of God does not control or supervise the Kansas City Girls Academy,” the statement said. “We would encourage you to contact the school or Teen Challenge USA with any questions.”
After the three lawsuits were filed in Jackson County during the summer, the school posted a message on its website saying the “safety and well-being of every student entrusted to our care is our highest responsibility, and we take any allegation to the contrary seriously.”
“We respectfully but firmly disagree with the allegations in these lawsuits,” the post said. “Because this is active litigation involving former students who were minors at the time, it would be inappropriate for us to discuss individual students or their records publicly. We will respond fully and directly through the legal process, where the facts can be presented in full.”
To The Star, Schultz said the school is “confident that the legal process will provide a full and accurate presentation of the facts, and we intend to vigorously defend against these claims.”
“We hope the community will allow that process to unfold before drawing conclusions based on one-sided allegations.”
Shackles and medical neglect
The former students interviewed by The Star were sent to the boarding school for varying reasons. They described behavioral issues, attempting suicide, self-harm and struggling with mental health issues, clashes with parents who didn’t know what to do with them, having boyfriends, dabbling with drugs or alcohol.
Some traveled long distances with their families to Kansas City. Others were picked up by school staff or other strangers and hauled off to Missouri.
Christina Moniak was 15 when she was sent from her home in a Chicago suburb to the Kansas City boarding school by her adoptive parents. She had self-harmed, gone through other therapeutic programs, and her parents weren’t sure how to deal with her, she said.
She still has vivid memories of leaving her home in April 2014. Staff from the school, she said, came to her home and woke her up at 4 a.m. She screamed for her father.
“I thought I was getting kidnapped, straight up,” Moniak said. Her parents, she recalled, were “nowhere to be found.”
Once students arrived, they quickly learned the rules and the array of possible punishments that staff could hand out for things like a runaway attempt, backtalk, a misplaced sock or uneaten food. Some required extensive writing. Others required long periods of silence or standing still in isolation. Limited phone calls or visiting time with their families could be taken away.
Soon after arriving, Moniak spotted a girl restrained by shackles in a corner. She watched a staff member pick up the girl, hold her in the air and slam her to the ground, she said. Kristi Graves, one of the school’s directors at the time, was with her and watched the scene unfold, Moniak said.
“(The girl) can’t catch herself, so she splats on the ground,” Moniak said. “Kristi’s like, ‘And if you misbehave, that’s what’s gonna happen to you.’
“That was my first night. And then I went to bed after that. They were like, ‘All right, good night, have a good night.’”
She cried the rest of the night.
Earlier this month, The Star asked Graves about that incident and other allegations. She did not respond to a message.
Eleven former students who attended between 2008 and 2015 told The Star they personally were shackled or saw others shackled by staff.
The school’s current website indicates that staff don’t use “mechanical or chemical restraints.”
“We do not believe in forcing compliance,” the site says. “Instead, we foster an environment of care that encourages participation and positive reflection of behaviors.”
The former students didn’t recall medical personnel or licensed therapeutic staff at the campus. Staff steered girls away from medications and weren’t responsive to health issues students raised, they said. Former students recalled dealing with scabies, worms, lice, bed bugs and COVID-19 outbreaks.
Brooke Koppari, who was 16 when she arrived in 2010, developed cellulitis in one of her breasts early on in her stint in Kansas City. Pus leaked from her chest, and her fever climbed, she said.
“I felt super sick, but nobody would listen to me,” she said. “They wouldn’t let me call my parents, because for the first month, you cannot call anybody. You’re just there.”
Eventually, staff members took her to urgent care and then to a hospital where she was treated. One of the staff members alerted her parents and sent them a picture, which led to her firing by the school, Koppari said.
Doug Anderson, the school’s director at the time, did not respond to messages from The Star this month asking about the situation and other allegations.
Samantha Cox, who was sent to Kansas City Girls Academy when she was 15 in 2013, remembered staff praying over a girl who was withdrawing from heroin instead of getting her medical care. She said staff responded to her own case of strep throat by praying over her and having her gargle salt water and mouthwash. The infection lingered for nine months before her parents directed staff to get her medical care from a doctor, she said. Eventually, she had to have her tonsils removed.
Molitor recalled Graves throwing her onto a bed after she told her that she couldn’t handle the medication withdrawals her body was going through. She was taking psychiatric medications that she would go on and off when her prescriptions wouldn’t be refilled by staff, she said.
“‘Now lay there,’” Molitor recalled Graves saying. “‘Jesus will take it all away.’”
Selena Guffey, who was sent to the school in 2011 when she was in her early teens, recalled a cotton ball that she used to block out noise so she could sleep becoming lodged deep in her ear. She asked school staff for help repeatedly, and it took six months before she was allowed to see a doctor who could remove it, she said.
“A lot of times,” she said, “anything medical was, ‘You’re looking for attention. You’re just doing this to get out of the facility. It’s not that bad, you’re overreacting, this is just to get attention and get out of the facility.’ Or, ‘I know that you may think you need medical attention, but God is the answer.’”
Moldy and expired food
Nearly every woman interviewed had memories about the school’s food. They recalled moldy and expired food and having limited or bland diets enforced as punishments, despite their parents and guardians paying thousands of dollars a month in tuition.
Two former students estimated they lost around 50 pounds while enrolled at the school. Without a balanced diet, others gained weight. Several women recalled being served donated food.
“We were starving all the time,” Moniak said. “The only day that we could have a decent amount of food was on Sundays, when they had us do leftovers. If you gorged yourself so much to where you threw up, you’d have to eat your regurgitated food.
“They would force you to eat the food that you just threw up.”
Early on in their stays, girls were assigned “big sisters,” the only other people they were allowed to talk to while they learned the program’s rules. From them, they learned the ropes, both official and unofficial.
Guffey recalled receiving early guidance about navigating questionable food options at the school.
“‘If you get a blueberry muffin, be careful, because they’re the hardest ones to know if it’s mold or not,’” she said she was warned. “‘It’s difficult to tell between the blueberries and the mold. Try to maybe get a regular bagel or a different kind of bagel, because they’re easier to pick the mold off of.’”
Guffey recalled working on kitchen duty and searching for juice that wasn’t starting to ferment and didn’t have floating mold.
Sacheen Ponte, a parent of a teen who began a 15-month stretch in Kansas City in 2019, estimated her family spent about $4,500 per month on the program.
“Where’s the money going?” Ponte said. “Why are they eating donated food when we’re giving them so much? And the staff they hire does not have formal training or licensure with these girls. If I had to do it again, I absolutely would not. No, not there.”
Madison Lambson, who was sent to the first of two stints at the school starting in 2012 at age 13, described her internal conflict of being hungry but also knowing the food she was served would make her gag and throw up. She’d stuff what she was given into her clothes to dispose of later.
“If I threw it up, I would get in trouble,” she said. “So I used to shove it in my pocket and go flush it down the toilet and then be starving.”
Callie Barnfield, who went to the school in 2008 at age 16, recalled another student who refused to eat oatmeal because it had made her sick and how staff made her wear a “burden bag” — a heavy backpack filled with bricks — as a punishment.
“If you didn’t have an issue with food before,” Barnfield said, “you would when you left.”
Pain since day one
Early on in her stay, Gress attempted to run away with another student and was shackled during daytime hours for several weeks as punishment, she said. In addition, two months were added to the original 15 months students are given at the school.
“Once I found out how the program was actually run, that’s when I think we started to plan how we were going to escape,” she said. “We knew that we weren’t going to physically die, but mentally and emotionally, a part of us was going to die there.”
She said she watched as others were mistreated, too. Gress recalled a girl receiving a burden bag punishment for refusing to eat a meal of expired tuna. She was given bricks to carry for each of her burdens, and Gress estimated that the four bricks in the bag weighed 20 to 30 pounds.
“She had to wear that backpack,” Gress said, “and she was on standing (punishment), where you stand from sun up to sun down with the backpack on, no matter what you’re doing, whether you’re doing school or you’re eating. No matter what, you were on standing.
“They did that to her until the food was moldy,” she said. “She never gave in.”
Students would also struggle emotionally, Gress said. At one point, staff put her in charge of caring for a student who attempted to end her own life with a razor blade by cutting her neck and wrist.
“They had me do some weird suture thing to keep her arm together,” she said. “She never got any kind of medical care for it. I don’t even know if her parents were notified, but I was in charge of her four months after that.”
Over and over, she said, the program emphasized how students were disappointing God and faced eternal damnation. Anderson, the school’s executive director, she said, insisted that she take responsibility for the assault by her grandfather.
“There was nobody there that should have been there with children that had behavior issues or trauma,” she said. “They were not trauma-informed at all.”
Kansas City Girls Academy
Unlike many unlicensed boarding schools that have existed in Missouri, the Kansas City facility has gone through leadership and name changes through the years.
Names that have been attached to the school include Teen Challenge, Highland Girls Academy, the Kansas City Girls Home and in recent years, the Kansas City Girls Academy. This summer, new signs went up around the campus rebranding the facility as Heartland Girls Academy Missouri.
Over the years the former students were at the school, leadership transitioned through a series of executive directors, first Anderson, then Kristi and Richard Graves, and most recently to the school’s current leader, Alan Biggers.
Biggers is a defendant in three of the four lawsuits and is named in the federal suit, though he is not being individually sued. The school’s website touts the facility as being “like a therapeutic boarding school” and as offering a “nurturing environment where students can explore and strengthen their faith while receiving the help they need to overcome emotional and behavioral issues.”
At Kansas City Girls Academy, the website notes, “we provide a Christ-centered, structured environment that fosters personal growth, emotional resilience, and spiritual development for girls ages 12–17.” The school’s site further says it helps students “get back on track spiritually, behaviorally and academically.”
“If your girl is self-destructing or failing in school, this program and year-round school is just for her,” large text on the website reads, just above endorsements from conservatives like former presidents George W. Bush and Ronald Reagan, former Missouri Gov. John Ashcroft, Focus on the Family founder James Dobson and Chick-fil-A chairman Dan Cathy. The same endorsements appear on the websites for other Teen Challenge facilities.
School leaders did not respond to a question from The Star about the program’s current tuition rates. The school’s website invites prospective families to contact the school for rates and notes that some families “may need help handling the tuition cost for Kansas City Girls Academy, even though our tuition rate is much less than therapeutic boarding schools….”
The school’s website suggests families consider paying for tuition through options like home equity or behavioral health loans, selling a car, cashing in a retirement fund, creating a GoFundMe or asking loved ones, a church or an employer for help.
The statement posted on the school’s website in July, which denied allegations spelled out in the three recent lawsuits, said KCGA is “registered with the state of Missouri, and our academic program is accredited by Cognia.”
“We regularly engage an independent third party to review our student care and supervision practices,” it said, “and consistently implement their recommendations to improve best practice.”
‘They hid behind Jesus’
Religion, the former students said, was central to the program.
Students worked through religious material to advance toward graduation and could also be given long religious writing assignments as punishments, they said. The women also recalled being toted around to area churches to fundraise for the school.
Scrutiny of KCGA comes six years after The Star first investigated unlicensed boarding schools and how they flocked to the Show-Me State for decades because of its lack of regulations. A 1982 law permits religious organizations to claim an exemption from the state’s licensing requirement.
Former students, child welfare advocates and some lawmakers have argued for years that these boarding schools should never have been allowed to operate without licensure in Missouri.
Despite repeated attempts over the years to remove the religious exemption, that loophole has remained sacred for four decades because of intense pressure from opponents who argue that it would interfere with religious freedom.
After The Star’s investigation and subsequent reporting, which exposed years of abuse and neglect allegations, several schools in southwest and southern Missouri closed.
Former students at Kansas City Girls Academy said they hope state leaders and lawmakers turn their attention to yet one more boarding school.
“Everybody called it ‘Jesus Jail,’ because they hid behind Jesus, and they used fear to control you like a jail,” said Taylor Brown, a former student who said she still has nightmares about the school about once a month. “You didn’t have any rights, you were told when to eat, when to sleep, when to stand, when to sit, when you could go to the bathroom.”
Brown was developmentally delayed as a child, and her parents sent her to the school in 2008, when she was 11, after her severe physical meltdowns overwhelmed them, and they ran out of options, she said. Years later, she was diagnosed with autism.
Her time at the school, she said recently, “feels like a blur, and sometimes it feels like it never happened, because it was just so not normal, not healthy.”
“The main thing was all about love and God’s grace, but they didn’t show us any grace,” she said.
“It was, ‘You do this, and you’re fine. You don’t do it, and you get punished.’ There was never any mercy or anything.”
One former student described her time at the Kansas City boarding school in 2024 testimony for the U.S. Senate Finance Committee, which was examining the failures of youth residential treatment facilities.
“These people thrived off the power over us helpless girls,” she wrote to the committee. The former student, who said she was still dealing with the trauma she said she endured at the Kansas City boarding school, did not want to be named in this story.
“Under their mercy we were starved, disregarded, our humanity taken, our spiritual path distorted, and our mental health never sane again,” she wrote in her testimony. “Their eyes lit up when they saw you in fear or crying, they purposely humiliated and degraded you for reasons big and small. Disregarding your past, your trauma, or even you as a person.
“They saw dollar signs and wanted to keep people there as long as possible.”
Some former students said the school turned them away from religion, something they once held close.
“I went from having a great relationship with the Lord and loving church, going every Wednesday and Sunday, to I won’t go to church now,” said Stefanie Jimenez, who arrived at the school in 2013 when she was 15. “I have severe religious trauma. I hate when people tell me that they’ll pray for me. I’m like, ‘Please don’t actually. Pick somebody else.’
“It’s really messed up that people that were supposed to protect us and advocate for us in the name of the Lord hurt us so badly.”
Learning about allegations from Kansas City Girls Academy, said Rep. Ingle, the Lee’s Summit lawmaker who co-sponsored the legislation on unlicensed boarding schools, shows that “we have a whole lot more work to do.” The 2021 law was a first step, but legislators need to focus again on these unlicensed facilities, said Ingle, who earlier this month won a seat in the Missouri Senate.
“I fully believe that none of these facilities should be allowed to exist without strict oversight and licensure by the state,” Ingle said. “No one should have access to vulnerable people in facilities in the state without being licensed, and there should not be any exemptions for that.
“If you are upstanding, and you have good intent, and you want to care for vulnerable people, get licensed,” she said. “Otherwise, get out of my state.”
Lasting trauma
Overall, their time in the program saddled them with more trauma than they entered with, the women said. Some spiraled into drugs or alcohol or were diagnosed with mental health conditions after leaving.
One former student, who was 15 when she was sent to the school in 2019, recounted being sexually assaulted by another student in a basement area of the school. The Star is not naming the woman at her request to protect her privacy.
She said she reported the assault to a staff member, who told her to detail what had happened in a letter to Biggers, the school’s executive director. She did, and the other student’s punishment was to do extra writing in a workbook, and police were never involved, she said.
The day after the assault, the other student remained in an assigned line position directly behind her. After the two were placed on a “relationship restriction,” the other girl was moved back one position in line.
“She was a predator there to us,” said the former student, who is among the women who are suing the school. “She was able to get away with this stuff and people were reporting it, and they did not kick her out, they did not give her any more of a discipline than the workbook. That was it.”
Records provided by the Kansas City Police Department identifying police calls to the school show no sex offenses were reported during the time the woman was on the campus. Capt. Jake Becchina, a police spokesperson, confirmed to The Star that the department took no reports from the school about the then-youth being assaulted.
Schultz, the attorney representing KCGA, said he and school leaders “can’t comment on individual claims while litigation is still active.”
“However, everyone at the Academy is a mandated reporter,” Schultz said. Any allegations “shared with staff are immediately reported” to the state child welfare agency.
When students called home, conversations were monitored by staff. So the former student who was assaulted said she knew better than to bring up the incident on a call with her parents. Later, when she told them what had happened in person, they didn’t believe her, the woman said.
“They thought I was just trying to get out of the program,” she said.
Lambson recounted a particularly traumatic memory of being forced to carry rocks in a pair of buckets for hours in the sun as a punishment. She’d fill the buckets at a rock pile, walk about a half mile, dump them and go back for more, she said.
Sweat soaked her clothes and deep cuts formed on her hands as the bucket handles gouged into her skin. She remembered a staff member yelling at her and denying her water for the first part of the discipline. Eventually, she was allowed water but only as he poured it into her mouth, she said.
Today, she doesn’t remember the particular lesson she was supposed to learn over those hours, but thinks it was related to the Biblical story of Jesus carrying his cross on the way to his crucifixion.
“I remember crying at one point, just begging for water, and (the staffer) just refused,” she said. “He said, ‘Jesus didn’t get water.’”
School leaders, according to many students, wanted to break them down. As Olivia Holcomb, who was sent to the school in 2017 when she was 15, put it: “Their goal is compliance and obedience. They’re trying to break a wild horse, I think is what they view it as. They see, ‘These kids are just crazy and wild, and we need to get them in line so that they’ll obey and listen and do as we say.’”
Cox recalled joking while in the program that she would end up with carpal tunnel syndrome because of the amount of writing she was forced to do. After leaving, she began to feel numbness and tingling in her hands. The feelings worsened, and she eventually had to have carpal tunnel surgery on both of her hands at age 20.
“I know that it was caused because of that place,” she said. “You would spend hours and hours and hours and hours every single day, for days on end, weeks on end, sometimes months on end, writing in your free time because you were on punishment.”
What she needed was mental health care from licensed professionals, love and acceptance — things she received almost none of through the Teen Challenge program, she said.
“Jail would have been better for me,” she said. “Prison would have better for me as a 15-year-old. I’m so sincere when I say that.”
Several of the women who spoke to The Star said they now had children of their own. They recoiled at the idea of sending them off to a similar program.
Said Olivia Stevens, who arrived in Kansas City on New Year’s Eve in 2012 at age 15: “As a daughter, I can respect my parents feeling that they were lost and didn’t know what to do with me. I just don’t think that was where any of us should have gone.
“As a parent, now, I would never, ever even imagine sending my kid off to something like that,” she said. “Overall, I look back on it as something pretty defining and traumatizing for me, but I don’t think it made me better or fixed me or anything like that.”
Once broken, she now fixes things
Down a quiet gravel road outside Springfield, Missouri, Gress now lives with her family and puts a bit of love back into the world.
On a recent morning, she walked from her home to a nearby building where three juvenile raccoons — fluffy acrobats all — scrambled up the inside of a holding pen, each eager for her attention. A few moments later, inside a dark, air-conditioned room in a nearby outbuilding, tiny opossum eyes peered out at her from a protected pouch as she walked in.
“I feel this innate need to take care of things,” she said. “I’m a fixer, I love to fix things. So when I get something that’s broken, and I can make it new again or better, then that’s what I want to do.”
She was bitter and angry when she was first dropped off in Kansas City. She hated her family for what they had done to her. As the months stretched on, she built bonds forged in shared trauma with other girls.
During her time at the boarding school, an urge to help others developed. Now, the compassion that formed and grew at the Teen Challenge program — perhaps in spite of that place — comes flowing out in waves through the animal refuge she founded at her home in southwest Missouri.
She’s long had a soft spot for animals and has rescued dogs and cats for years. She set to adding raccoons, opossums, squirrels, armadillos, deer and rabbits to her list, with the goal of sending rehabilitated animals back out into the countryside. Her operation, a labor of love, is funded out of her own pocket and donations she receives.
Recently, she picked up a trio of raccoons — tiny, 2-week-old babies in need of care — at 2:30 a.m. after an early morning call. She’ll always answer.
“I think I just have so much love that it literally oozes out of me,” she said. “And if I don’t have an outlet for it, then I could explode. That’s what it feels like.”
How we did this story
- For this story, Star reporters interviewed 25 former students who attended Teen Challenge’s Kansas City Girls Academy over a 15-year span from 2008 through 2022. All of the women spoke at length about their experiences in Kansas City.
- Reporters reviewed dozens of pages of court documents, state information regarding unlicensed boarding schools and police records regarding calls for service at the facility.
- The Star also reached out to current and former leaders at the program to allow them to respond to the allegations raised by former students.
Nathan Pilling is a breaking news reporter for The Kansas City Star. He previously worked in newsrooms in Washington state and Ohio and grew up in eastern Iowa.
Laura Bauer, who came to The Kansas City Star in 2005, focuses on investigative and watchdog journalism. In her 30-year career, Laura has won numerous national awards for coverage of human trafficking, child welfare, crime and government secrecy.
