New York Catholic Church Putting Properties Up for Mortgage to Cover $800 Million Abuse Settlement

NEW YORK (NY)
Globe [New York, NY]

November 20, 2026

By Mona Khalifeh

The Archdiocese of New York is turning to real estate to cover the cost of an $800 million settlement it owes to victims who were sexually abused by members of the clergy.

According to a report from the New York Post on Friday, November 20, the church is using six properties associated with Manhattan parishes as “collateral” for $160 million in loans to help fund the Global Settlement Agreement, which was approved on November 5.

A spokesperson for the diocese confirmed the arrangement in a statement to The Post, clarifying that no active churches are being mortgaged as part of the deal.

According to The New York Times, the Global Settlement Agreement is expected to resolve roughly 1,300 claims from people who were sexually abused by clergy members and other church personnel. As part of the deal, which The Times reports was signed by Bishop Edmund Whalen, the vicar general of the Archdiocese of New York, survivors can either accept a lump-sum payment of at least $250,000 or have their claims individually evaluated for a chance at a larger payout. Roughly a third of plaintiffs in the lawsuit have already decided to take the $250,000 quick payout.

The $800 million settlement will be paid through a trust, with the church and participating entities contributing $619.25 million upfront, and the remaining $185 million due within the next 15 months, per the Times.

According to the outlet, the archdiocese’s strategy for turning to property mortgages is one Jeff Herman, whose law firm represents some of the plaintiffs, approves of.

“They have a lot of real estate, and they should either mortgage it or sell it to compensate these victims,” Herman told The Times in a November 19 report.

“The church should not be able to walk away and feel nothing because my clients, who were victimized by the church, have been feeling this all their lives,” he stressed.

Only four of the six parishes associated with the properties being used as collateral for the $160 million in loans have been made public, The Times notes, including St. Brigid and St. Emeric in the East Village, Our Lady of Guadalupe in Manhattan, St. Veronica in the West Village and St. Michael near Penn Station and Hudson Yards.

https://globemagazine.com/new-york-catholic-church-putting-properties-up-for-mortgage-to-cover-800-million-abuse-settlement/