ABUSE TRACKER

The Buffalo Catholic Diocese says parishes will end up paying the majority of the money.

BUFFALO, N.Y. — Reaction continues to the lawsuit settlement plans announced by the Buffalo Catholic Diocese on Monday. The Diocese will be looking to its parishes to pay more than half of the $150-million to settle the sex abuse lawsuits.

According to the Buffalo Diocese, the parishes will be responsible for $80-million, with each paying anywhere from 10 to 80 percent of the unrestricted cash they had on hand as of last August. That’s money that wasn’t earmarked for something specific already at the parish.

Parishes that are set to close would be paying higher percentages.

On Tuesday, 2 On Your Side spoke with Philip Gray, he’s a canon lawyer and the President of the Saint Joseph Foundation, a group of lay people who help parishioners navigate church policies and canon law.

…

View Cache

Parishes across WNY are hearing directly from the Diocese of Buffalo on how much they will have to contribute to the proposed $150 million bankruptcy settlement.

[See video]

View Cache

There has been a significant increase in the number of new allegations notified to the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church in Ireland (NBSCCCI).

Last year there were 385 allegations of abuse, up from 252 the previous year.

Its latest annual report, which covers the period between April 2024 and March 2025, shows a rise of over 50% in new allegations.

It is the highest number of any reporting period since the NBSCCCI began publishing the annual figures in 2009.

The increase was predominantly from September of 2024 and coincided with the release of the Report of the Scoping Inquiry into Historical Sexual Abuse in Day and Boarding Schools run by Religious Orders.

Along with the subsequent media coverage, this appears to have enabled individuals to come forward.

As has been the pattern in recent years the vast majority of allegations relate to the period from 1960…

View Cache

(RNS) — The SBC’s Executive Committee has spent millions defending itself against former leaders accused of abuse.

DALLAS (RNS) — In early April, Jennifer Lyell, a former Christian publishing executive, sat for a deposition in a defamation lawsuit filed by her once mentor and professor David Sills.

There she detailed alleged sexual and spiritual abuse by Sills in graphic detail — and insisted he had coerced her into sexual acts without her consent, and then asked her to join him at family meals afterward.

“But he always knew that I never, ever wanted any instance,” she said in an excerpt from her April 10 deposition. “And I always, always tried to stop it.”

Lyell died Saturday (June 7) after suffering a series of strokes. She was 47. A few weeks before she died, her lawyer filed excerpts of her deposition in a federal court as part of a legal battle…

View Cache

The alleged victim’s mother notified police of the 2024 incident earlier last week. The Catholic Diocese of Cleveland says the employee has been placed on leave.

CLEVELAND — An employee at Cleveland’s St. Aloysius Catholic School has been placed on leave following an allegation of sexual misconduct with a minor in the Youngstown area.

According to a police report obtained by 3News, the mother of the alleged victim first reported the incident to Cleveland officers, who then relayed the information to Niles police in the suspect’s hometown. The woman told authorities last week that an employee abused her son in March of 2024, when her son was just 15.

The suspect, 33, faces a charge of sexual battery by a school person of authority. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Cleveland, which oversees operations at St. Aloysius, confirmed the school “immediately” put the employee on leave “pending the results…

View Cache

When Pope Leo XIV summoned the leader of Opus Dei to see him last month, in one of his first official audiences, Vatican watchers immediately began to wonder what the meeting meant.

Some said it was a clear olive branch, a peace offering from a new pope who wanted to heal relations with a group they felt had been unduly attacked by Pope Francis.

Others said the urgency of the meeting betrayed the new pope’s frustration over delays to the group’s new statutes — first requested by Francis three years ago — and a signal that reforming Opus Dei was a clear priority.

Opus Dei quickly hailed the “closeness and affection” of the discussion.

Other readouts from the meeting seemed potentially more ominous.

“The Holy Father asked about the current study of the Statutes of the Prelature and listened with great interest to the explanations…

View Cache

Three other decisions remain on the pope’s desk which will weigh heavier on his mind.

The Dicastery for Communications removed from Vatican websites artwork by the disgraced former Jesuit Fr. Marko Rupnik over the weekend.

The decision, which has not been officially acknowledged or explained by the dicastery, came as social media users highlighted again how works by the accused serial sexual abuser were displayed on the Vatican’s official website to illustrate upcoming feasts, like Monday’s memorial of Mary, Mother of the Church.

The cycle of outrage over the continued use of Rupnik’s work by official Vatican media had become a regular event, following the disclosure of the extent of allegations against the artist in 2022 — including that he sexually abused women religious as part of his creative process.

The Vatican’s continued use of the images was repeatedly cited by survivors of abuse and their advocates as a harmful…

View Cache

In short 

The ACT Greens have announced a bill that would introduce legislation aimed at holding institutions accountable for the actions of their employees. 

It follows a High Court ruling last year that found the church could not be held accountable for the actions of a priest accused of sexual assault.

What’s next? 

The party will introduce the bill later in the month.

The ACT Greens have unveiled a bill aimed at making institutions such as the Catholic Church, Scouts and sporting groups vicariously liable for the actions of those associated with them who have sexually abused children.

This includes priests, Scouts leaders, and sports coaches who may have a relationship with the organisation akin to employment, even though it is not strictly an employment relationship.

Not an employee

The move was prompted by a High Court ruling last year that found a priest, accused of child sex offences, was…

View Cache

Canon Patrick McEntee (70) denies sexual offences against five pupils at St Michael’s College, Enniskillen where he taught

The jury has retired to consider its verdict in the trial of a priest accused of historic sex assault charges against teenage schoolboys.

Canon Patrick McEntee (70) from Esker Road, Dromore denies sexual offences against five males who were pupils at St Michael’s College, Enniskillen where he taught.

There are four counts of indecently assaulting one complainant between 1988/89 and a single count of indecently assaulting another between 1980/81.

In addition, there are a further four counts of indecent assault against three males- two against one and single counts against the other two, allegedly between 1978 and 1987.

Dungannon Crown Court heard there were similarities in terms of Canon McEntee taking them to his private quarters.

Classical music was playing and he would have the boys sit on his knee “for…

View Cache

The state house of representatives yesterday passed a pair of bills to let survivors of childhood sexual abuse file lawsuits in Pennsylvania beyond the state’s current statute of limitations.

House Bill 462, which passed 122-80, would open a two-year window for survivors to file a civil lawsuit against abusers.  The other, known as House Bill 464, would start the process to amend the state constitution to enact the policy, taking it one step closer to putting it on the ballot for a referendum.  The same pair of proposals received support in the state house over two years ago, but died without action in the state senate.

State Representative Jim Struzzi voted in favor of the bills, but Representative Brian Smith voted against them.  They now head to the Senate for further consideration.

You can report news by emailing us at news@wccsradio.com.

View Cache

• The Pennsylvania House approved two measures to allow survivors of child sexual abuse to sue their abusers and involved institutions, even after the statute of limitations has expired.
• One measure is a simple change to state law, while the other is a proposed constitutional amendment requiring a future statewide vote.
• Previous attempts to amend the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse survivors have failed due to bureaucratic errors and partisan disagreements.
• Survivors and advocates have long sought this change, arguing the current laws unfairly deny them justice.

Pennsylvania lawmakers have revived a proposal that would enable survivors of decades-old child sexual abuse to sue the perpetrators, a chance victims say the state’s statute of limitations has unfairly denied them.

A pair of measures approved by the House of Representatives June 9 would open a two-year window allowing these victims to file legal claims against abusers and the institutions that covered up…

View Cache

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Proposals that would let survivors of childhood sexual abuse file lawsuits in Pennsylvania beyond the state’s current statute of limitations passed the state House on Monday, the latest development in a yearslong lobbying campaign.

One of the two bills is a common piece of legislation that now heads to the GOP-controlled Senate for consideration. It passed the House 122-80, with Democrats voting unanimously for it while a majority of Republicans were opposed.

The other piece of legislation moves the state closer to putting a constitutional amendment about the issue before voters, which would require three more legislative votes before the statewide referendum. That bill passed the House 138-64, again with unified Democrats.

“This is about a group of survivors who have been denied access to our court system,” Democratic Rep. Nate Davidson said during debate. “And we have the opportunity to…

View Cache

Truett McConnell University has placed its president on leave as the institution investigates allegations of sexual assault against the school’s former vice president. 

In a statement published on Facebook Friday, the Georgia-based Baptist university announced the additional steps it’s taken following the emergence of allegations of sexual assault against former Vice President Bradley Reynolds.

TMU’s Board of Trustees “met out of genuine concern” and “with broken hearts” last Friday as it sought to address the situation. The meeting resulted in the unanimous approval of a third-party investigation into the sexual assault allegations to be conducted by Richard Hyde of Phoenix Research LLC. Additionally, they placed Truett McConnell President Emir Caner on administrative leave until the completion of the investigation and the appointment of John Yarbrough as acting president. 

Truett McConnell requested continued prayers for the campus community as well as “all parties involved.”

The decision by the…

View Cache

Images of artwork created by a disgraced celebrity cleric accused of serial sexual and other abuse have disappeared from official Vatican Media websites without explanation, almost a year after the head of the Vatican’s communications outfit strongly defended his department’s continued use of the images even in the face of sustained public outcry.

Victims and advocates received the news with cautious favor, but the development highlights how far the Vatican and the Church have to go toward real reform of safeguarding culture and the ecclesiastical justice system.

“Rape Art”

The offending images were digital reproductions of works created by Father Marko Rupnik – a former Jesuit accused of spiritually, psychologically, and sexually abusing dozens of victims over a period of thirty years – for much of which time Rupnik was based in Rome.

For decades, Rupnik enjoyed the favor of popes, Vatican officials, and his erstwhile superiors in the Society…

View Cache

“It was a night of bravery. A night of people finally standing up and saying, ‘Enough,’” shares Mary Caplan, a resident at Coterie Hudson Yards.

It was June of 1969, and Mary stood outside the Stonewall Inn. She was out with friends – a group of people with mixed backgrounds and orientations who often gathered in the neighborhood. After a spat with her boyfriend, she stepped outside for a smoke. That’s when four police wagons rolled up as part of a raid.

“It was like being slammed into a wall. I thought, ‘This can’t be happening.’ Most of the people arrested weren’t even from New York. They were kids from Jersey or Long Island who had come in just to be themselves. They thought they were in a safe place.” The protest that followed would become known as the Stonewall Uprising – a turning point in the fight for LGBTQ+ rights…

View Cache

The crisis at Bétharram exposes the fault lines of France’s response to clergy sexual abuse, leading to further politicization of the issue.

The Church’s weak response leaves the survivors of abuse at Bétharram at the mercy of French politics, revictimizing them on a daily basis.

Despite French secularism and prior efforts from the Catholic Bishops to acknowledge the depth of crisis in their country, François Bayrou’s response to the crisis at Bétharram is verbose and inefficient.

Whoever follows French news these days would notice how many stories are associated, one way or the other, to issues of sexual abuse and violence. Last year, France, Europe and the world were in shock after knowing the details of Giséle Pelicot’s quest for justice.

More recently, France experienced a similar collective shock when a trial revealed details of how Joël Le Scouarnec, a surgeon, abused at least 300 of his patients. If that was not…

View Cache

In “Medicine River,” Mary Annette Pember examines a national shame — and the trauma it wrought in her own family.

MEDICINE RIVER: A Story of Survival and the Legacy of Indian Boarding Schools, by Mary Annette Pember

In 1892, Richard Henry Pratt, the founder of one of the country’s first Native American boarding schools, told an audience, “A great general has said that the only good Indian is a dead one,” referring to George Armstrong Custer’s bloody massacres. “In a sense, I agree with the sentiment, but only in this: that all the Indian there is in the race should be dead. Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.”

Before establishing the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, Pratt participated in the forced removal of tribes from the southern plains while a U.S. calvary officer. The school was another act of genocide: Upon entering, children were given…

View Cache

As the Newsboys continue to respond to allegations of drug abuse and inappropriate sexual actions by former lead singer Michael Tait, one band member admitted the mega-popular band wasn’t surprised by the news.

“We have obviously heard rumors over the years and each time something would come up we would try to find the source and no one would tell us,” lead singer Adam Agee wrote in a Facebook group.

“We asked Tait each time something would come up and he would deny it emphatically.”

According to Agee, Tait called a band meeting in January to make the announcement that he was leaving, just days before their first show of 2025.

“He had always said we would be doing this until we were 70 years old, and that’s truth whether you believe it or not,” he said.

After a June 4 story in The Roys Report (TRR) about Tait ricocheted around the world,…

View Cache

DEERFIELD — Deerfield Academy has reached a “low six-figure settlement” with another sexual abuse victim of longtime teacher Peter G. Hindle.

The settlement was announced outside the school Tuesday morning by Mitchell Garabedian, a Boston-based attorney representing victims of sexual abuse, after the 63-year-old victim finally came forward in 2024 while meeting with his primary care physician. Hindle taught at Deerfield Academy for more than 40 years and died in 2017.

Hindle, who Garabedian described as a “serial pedophile,” allegedly sexually abused the victim approximately 15 times between 1977 and 1979, when the victim was 15 to 17 years old. Garabedian said Hindle endeared himself to the victim by connecting with him through the school’s soccer team, before the teacher allegedly lured him to the residence and began engaging in sexual abuse.

“The victim is 63 years old, he revealed for the first time in his life that he was…

View Cache

Lyell was once one of the highest-ranking women in the Southern Baptist Convention, but her life fell apart after she reported alleged abuse by a former SBC seminary professor.

Jennifer Lyell, an editor and author whose promising career in Christian publishing was derailed when she accused a former Southern Baptist leader of abuse, died Saturday (June 7). She was 47.

“Jennifer passed gently into the arms of her Redeemer, surrounded by loved ones,” said her friend Rachael Denhollander, who said Lyell had suffered “a series of massive strokes, leading to her becoming unconscious sometime Monday afternoon. She was found Thursday evening after missing a medical appointment.”

For much of her adult life, Lyell had been a Southern Baptist success story. She came to faith at 20 at a Billy Graham crusade, went to seminary, dreamed of becoming a missionary, taught the Bible to young women and children and became a vice president…

View Cache

In memory of Jennifer Lyell

Jennifer Lyell died yesterday.

Three years ago, she told me she didn’t think she would live.

She had survived alleged sexual abuse at the hands of her seminary professor. For a time, she survived being viciously attacked, over and over again, by those who sought to make her out as the villain, the temptress, the whore. But she told me she didn’t think she could survive what was being done to her much longer.

Yesterday, her body gave out. The stated cause was a series of massive strokes. She was 47.

Her death follows that of SBC survivor Duane Rollins last month. Rollins was the alleged victim of SBC leader and conservative takeover architect Paul Pressler. The SBC is meeting this week in Dallas, Texas, at its annual convention. These deaths ought to cast a pall over the gathering, but if history serves as a…

View Cache

In support of the National Day of Prayer for Survivors of Abuse, the Catholic Diocese of Northampton, in collaboration with Churches Together, held a LOUDfence event under the theme “Hope for Survivors – A Journey Towards Healing Where There Has Been Pain”. This important event offered an opportunity for communities to come together in solidarity and compassion for all those affected by abuse, recognising the lasting impact and the need for healing.

LOUDfence is a survivor-led initiative that encourages people to tie colourful ribbons and written messages to a fence, symbolising solidarity and hope for survivors of abuse. It is a simple yet powerful act of public witness, compassion, and commitment to justice.

The Luton LOUDfence – Hope for Survivors event offered a safe, sacred space for survivors to share their stories and find spiritual and emotional support from the lay and clergy volunteers.

View Cache

The Catholic bishops of Washington state asked a federal court to block a new law requiring clergy to report child abuse or neglect without exceptions for clergy-penitent privilege.

The bishops on June 5 asked the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington in Tacoma to issue a preliminary injunction to block enforcement of the law, scheduled to take effect on July 27.

Mark Rienzi, president and CEO of Becket, a religious liberty law firm in Washington, D.C., that is representing the bishops, said in a statement, “Washington state has no business intruding into the confessional — particularly when they give a free pass to lawyers who have legally protected confidential relationships with clients.”

“Punishing priests for following the Catholic Church’s millennia-old faith traditions isn’t just wrong, it’s unconstitutional,” Rienzi said.

The bishops previously filed a lawsuit with the District Court in response to Democratic Gov. View Cache

Pope Leo XIV met with the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors (PCPM) on Thursday of last week, in what was arguably the most significant meeting of Leo’s pontificate to date and almost certainly the most sensitive.

Leo met with the Commission for a full hour – twice as much time as had been allotted for the meeting in the pope’s busy Thursday schedule – and pushed back a meeting with the Secretariat of State.

The meeting with the PCPM was behind closed doors. No copy or transcript of the pope’s remarks was circulated. The founding president of the PCPM, Cardinal Seán Patrick O’Malley, emeritus of Boston, gave an interview to Vatican News in which he said there has been evolution in the Commission’s work over the years.

“Our main purpose was to be advisors to the Holy Father in the area of safeguarding,” O’Malley said.

“We have also…

View Cache

The Catholic Bishops of Washington on Thursday asked a federal court to block a new state law requiring priests to report instances of child abuse or neglect – even when it’s disclosed in confession – before the law takes effect this summer.

Senate Bill 5375 makes members of the clergy mandatory reporters of child abuse and neglect, meaning religious leaders – ministers, priests, rabbis and others – would be required to report suspected child abuse and neglect. That means priests would be required to break the sacred seal of confession or face fines and jail time.

First Liberty Institute is one of the groups representing Archbishop Paul Etienne, Bishop Thomas Daly, and Bishop Joseph Tyson, who filed an initial lawsuit in federal court last week to block the law from taking effect on July 27.

First Liberty Institute Attorney Hiram Sasser told The Center Square that his clients’ focus is on protecting…

View Cache

The U.S. Catholic bishops’ latest annual report on child and youth protection shows abuse allegations continue to decline — but authors warned of the dangers of complacency among dioceses and the laity in upholding key aspects of bishops’ safe environment protocols.

In particular, said the report, lack of functioning diocesan review boards to review protocols and allegations, along with an increase in parents opting their children out of safe environment training, could erode progress in addressing and preventing abuse.

On June 6, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Secretariat of Child and Youth Protection released the “2024 Annual Report — Findings and Recommendations on the Implementation of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People.”

The 2024 report is the 22nd since the charter was established by the U.S. Catholic bishops in 2002 as a number of clerical abuse scandals emerged. Commonly…

View Cache

The Center for Southwest Research and Special Collections (CSWR), part of the University Libraries, has announced the public release of the first portion of the Archdiocese of Santa Fe Institutional Abuse Collection. This important digital archive provides public access to previously sealed legal documents related to clergy sexual abuse cases in New Mexico.

The collection was established as a part of the settlement between the Archdiocese of Santa Fe and victims of sexual abuse perpetrated by its clergy members. This first batch of documents consists of deposition transcripts related to lawsuits against the Archdiocese in the 1900s, 2000s, and 2010s. Overall the collection includes depositions, personnel files, church administrative records, and other legal documents from the settlement. These documents, now available in digital format, serve as a crucial resource for survivors, researchers, journalists, and community members seeking greater transparency and accountability in institutional abuse cases.

“New Mexico was an epicenter…

View Cache

Pope Leo XIV is set to face one of his first major tests with a petition addressed to him calling for the removal of Cologne Archbishop Rainer Maria Woelki over concerns about his handling of sexual abuse allegations.

Newsweek has contacted the Vatican via email, for comment.

Why It Matters

As the newly elected pope, people will be watching how Leo handles concerns about sex abuse in the church.

How the Vatican responds to the petition, which has more than 60,000 signatures, could set the tone for Pope Leo’s leadership style and his stance on episcopal accountability worldwide.

What To Know

Woelki has long been a divisive figure in the church amid criticism of his handling of sexual abuse cases in the archdiocese of Cologne.

In September 2021, Pope Francis decided to leave Woelki in office despite massive criticism over his handling of the sexual abuse cases. The pontiff instead gave the cardinal…

View Cache

At the time Pope Francis picked Bishop Gregg Caggianelli, then-Cardinal Robert Prevost — now Pope Leo XIV — was running the Vatican office that selects and vets prospective bishops. Cardinal Blase Cupich also is part of that office.

One of Pope Francis’ last U.S. bishop appointments, who appears to be the first American bishop ordained after Pope Leo XIV’s election, was accused in lawsuits more than a decade ago of failing to sideline a volunteer minister at his Catholic parish following a complaint of inappropriate behavior with an altar boy in 2011.

The volunteer minister, Robert F. Little, later molested another boy from the same Fort Myers, Florida, parish, according to the lawsuits, which were filed by parents of the children and accused the Rev. Gregg Caggianelli and other church officials of not doing enough to keep Little away from minors.

Caggianelli, an Air Force officer long part of the Diocese…

View Cache

Sign up for TPR Today, Texas Public Radio’s newsletter that brings our top stories to your inbox each morning.

Editor’s Note: This story contains graphic descriptions of sexual violence.

The parents of a 15-year-old who was allegedly sexually assaulted on multiple occasions at Central Catholic High School say the school’s response is “too little, too late.”

In late April, the Garcia family reported that their son was physically and sexually assaulted on multiple occasions by teammates on the soccer team at the prestigious boys school.

Wednesday evening, Central Catholic released a statement saying they had investigated and disciplined five students, including two students who were forced to withdraw from the school.

The school also said they would engage a third party to conduct an independent investigation of Central Catholic and its staff, and shared a link to make anonymous reports online.

The Garcias and their attorney Jesse Guerra…

View Cache

When the news broke a year ago that a famous Dallas pastor had sexually abused a 12-year-old girl in the 1980s, church leaders across several states swore they knew nothing about it.

Now it turns out they did.

Just-released court documents show that Bible teacher Jimmy Evans and leaders at a Colorado megachurch knew all along that Gateway Church founder Robert Morris had sexually abused Cindy Clemishire.  

Despite this, Evans said in a statement last year that he was “shocked and devastated” by recent revelations of Clemishire’s abuse.  

And Brady Boyd, pastor of New Life Church—a megachurch in Colorado Springs, which reportedly had been informed of Clemishire’s abuse in 2007—acted like the abuse was news to him when it became public.

Addressing New Life’s congregation in June 2024, Boyd said it had “been a hard week” for him personally. And he urged congregants to pray for Clemishire, “who…

View Cache

Archdiocese confirms investigation is ongoing

Bishop Miege High School President Phil Baniewicz is on leave effective June 5 following concerns about his leadership abilities.

The Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas confirmed the information in a statement Friday morning.

Banewicz has been the subject of past abuse allegations that he has never been charged for.

A spokesperson for the Archdiocese told KSHB 41 News Reporter Sarah Plake that the executive committee of Bishop Miege High School’s Board of Trustees placed Baniewicz on administrative leave.

The decision was effective June 5, according to the Archdiocese spokesperson.

“Due to recent reports concerning his ability to oversee a safe environment for BMHS, a thorough investigation has been initiated,” the spokesperson said.

In March, KSHB 41 reported about the concerns of some parents, including Kelly Kincaid. You can watch that report in the video player below. Please see original article for…

View Cache

Archbishop Shawn McKnight has issued the following statement regarding the president of Bishop Miege High School, Phil Baniewicz:

“The executive committee of Bishop Miege High School’s (BMHS) Board of Trustees has placed Phil Baniewicz on administrative leave, effective June 5, 2025. I support this action of the executive committee for the well-being of the school. Due to recent reports concerning his ability to oversee a safe environment for BMHS, a thorough investigation has been initiated. 

“The executive committee of the board of BMHS has appointed Joe Schramp as interim president. 

“As this is a confidential personnel matter, no further information will be provided until the investigation is concluded.

“Our commitment is to make our schools and parishes places where every child feels safe, supported, and valued. This necessitates not only immediate action when concerns arise but also a continuous evaluation of our policies to ensure we are doing everything possible…

View Cache

Statement by David Clohessy, Volunteer director of Missouri SNAP

The head of a Kansas City Kansas Catholic school has been suspended because of “recent reports” questioning his ability to “oversee a safe environment” for kids.

It’s pathetic that Catholic officials continue to be so secretive about this man, his recent behavior and the child sex abuse report against him from New Mexico.

While his suspension is welcome, he should never have been hired in the first place.

Kids are safest when abuse allegations and concerns are reported to secular authorities like police and prosecutors, not to church officials. We hope every person who may have seen, suspected or suffered any misconduct by Phil Baniewicz or anyone at Bishop Miege High School will call law enforcement immediately. We also hope Archbishop Shawn McKnight will be more forthcoming soon and will use church resources to aggressively prod anyone with suspicions…

View Cache

The bishop has resumed serving his sentence for abusing seminarians under house arrest.

Disgraced Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta is back in his former Diocese of Orán, and will continue serving his four-year prison sentence under house arrest in a local convent, local Argentine media reported Thursday.

One of the bishop’s victims told local media this week that Zanchetta had met with Bishop Luis Scozzina of the local diocese and that Zanchetta would continue to serve his sentence under house arrest.

Zanchetta had previously been in Rome since November receiving “medical treatment.”

The bishop, who was convicted of aggravated sexual abuse of seminarians in 2022, arrived in Rome in November 2024, for cardiac treatment which his lawyers argued he could not receive in his home country, undergoing heart surgery at the Gemelli Hospital.

Under the terms of his permission to travel, issued by an Argentine court last year, Zanchetta was to return…

View Cache

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ (USCCB) Secretariat of Child and Youth Protection has released the 2024 Annual Report – Findings and Recommendations on the Implementation of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People.

The report is based on the audit findings of StoneBridge Business Partners, a consulting firm which provides forensic, internal, and compliance audit services. A survey regarding allegations of abuse of minors and costs that is annually conducted by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) at Georgetown University is also included as a part of the report. 

This is the twenty-second such report since 2002 when the U.S. bishops established and adopted the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, a comprehensive framework of procedures to address allegations of sexual abuse of minors by Catholic clergy and establish protocols to protect children and young people.

The 2024 report covers July…

View Cache

LOCAL priest Fr Brian D’Arcy recalls how he “trembled in fear” and felt “ashamed” after he was abused by a religious Brother during his childhood, as he reflects on his life on his 80th birthday.

The Bellanaleck cleric, who celebrated his 80th birthday on Sunday in Croke Park, while Fermanagh beat Wexford in the Tailteann Cup, has spoken about how his abuse ordeal impacted on his life.

“I became his lunchtime recreation. I often trembled in fear. I didn’t understand what happened to me, but I knew I was no longer an innocent boy from Bellanaleck,” he said in the ‘Irish Independent’.

“I should have told my parents, but I was too ashamed. I was hampered by needless guilt.

“When he finished with me, he dismissed me with a pat on the head. He went on to teach his class and I felt dirty, rotten and fearful.

“Even though I did nothing…

View Cache

“I’m really not OK with this. I feel like we’re paying for the sins of our church leadership who horribly mishandled this abuse scandal”

The Diocese of Buffalo is preparing to ask parishes and other Catholic affiliates to contribute to help pay a $150 million settlement with more than 800 sexual abuse survivors.

Parishes will be getting invoices next week after a series of vicariate meetings.

“We will find out next Tuesday,” Nandor Forgach told WBEN. He is an active parishioner at St. Benedict’s Church in Eggertsville. “It’s looking like a good portion of money will be coming from each parish. Some are in better standing than others. They’ll be able to survive it. But others will be hurt by it.”

Forgach says nothing is confirmed, but he has heard rumors that it’s
going to be a percentage, north of 50% of parishes’ reserve funds and weekly collections.

“I’m really not…

View Cache

Pope Leo XIV today spent an hour meeting with the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors (PCPM) at the Vatican.

The commission was established in 2014 by Pope Francis and has been part of the Dicastery of the Doctrine of the Faith since 2022.

In a statement about the meeting on 5 June, the commission said it updated Pope Leo on progress in the Memorare Initiative, a capacity-building program designed to support local churches – particularly in the Global South – in their efforts to protect minors and care for victims of abuse.

The Memorare Initiative works through four pillars: establishing safeguarding infrastructure, promoting prevention through education, establishing global collaboration, and creating strategic communication that empowers local churches to communicate effectively and foster transparency.

“The Memorare Initiative is tailored to each ecclesial context. It respects local autonomy while offering essential support to ensure that all churches, regardless of resources,…

View Cache

Pope Leo XIV Thursday met with members of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors to get an update about their activities, while facing a clear litmus test on just how seriously he will take the abuse issue as pontiff.

The pope met the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, his first official appointment with the safeguarding body, June 5 for a meeting that lasted an hour and was an occasion for the commission to offer the pope an overview of their work and various initiatives.

Among these initiatives, according to a statement from the commission, were the Universal Guidelines Framework for Safeguarding that they are finalizing, as well as the Memorare Initiative aimed at supporting safeguarding efforts in the global south, and its 2024 global report on safeguarding.

The commission in its statement reiterated its “commitment to the unity and collegiality of all its members” and also…

View Cache

Archbishop Emeritus George Frendo on Wednesday evening apologised for “inadvertently” suggesting that victims of clerical abuse should forgive their abusers before filing a police report — a statement that has sparked outrage, with the Lisa Maria Foundation calling for him to be “kicked out of the Church”.

Frendo was reacting to a Times of Malta report about his comments on a live television programme where he encouraged victims of clerical abuse to forgive their perpetrators first before going to the police.

In a statement, Frendo insisted that he condemned the clerical abuse of minors “in all its forms”.

He said that forgiveness should not be an alternative to reporting such cases to the authorities.

“I apologise if, even inadvertently, I could have been perceived as conveying an alternative impression,” Frendo said.

The retired bishop was part of a panel of four people – three of them priests – on…

View Cache

The former bishop of Durham was one of several clergy criticised in a report on the church’s failure to stop the abuser John Smyth, which led to Justin Welby’s downfall

A bishop who served as an assistant to the King during the coronation is one of seven priests facing church disciplinary charges over the scandal that led to the downfall of Justin Welby, the former Archbishop of Canterbury.

The Right Rev Paul Butler, who retired last year as Bishop of Durham, the church’s fourth most senior role, will face disciplinary proceedings alongside six other members of the clergy.

Lord Carey of Clifton, a former Archbishop of Canterbury, will not face legal action. Carey, who served as archbishop from 1991 to 2002, had been named in February among ten priests who could face disciplinary charges under the clergy discipline measure (CDM).

They all faced some degree of criticism within a…

View Cache

[The original article includes a two-minute video excerpt, a transcript, and a 12-minute recording of the interview.]

In this interview with Vatican News, Cardinal Seán O’Malley talks about the work of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors; raising awareness in the Church about clerical abuse; and the Church’s priorities, especially the need to put victims and their families first.

The Church’s priorities with regard to the prevention of child abuse “are the same as ever” says Cardinal Seán O’Malley: “We’re trying to put the victims and their families first.”

The Cardinal was speaking on the eve of an audience with Pope Leo XIV on Thursday with members of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors.

Following that audience on Thursday morning, the Commission issued a statement noting that the audience, its first with Pope Leo,  lasted an hour and marked a significant moment of reflection, dialogue,…

View Cache

Pope Leo XIV met with members of the Vatican’s child protection advisory commission on Thursday for the first time amid questions about his past handling of clergy sex abuse cases and demands from survivors that he enact a true policy of zero tolerance for abuse across the Catholic Church.

The Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, which is made up of religious and lay experts in fighting abuse as well as survivors, called the hourlong audience a “significant moment of reflection, dialogue, and renewal of the church’s unwavering commitment to the safeguarding of children and vulnerable people.” The group said it updated history’s first American pope on its activities, including an initiative to help church communities in poorer parts of the world prevent abuse and care for victims.

The Vatican did not provide the text of Leo’s remarks or make the audio of the audience available to reporters.

Pope Francis created…

View Cache

In short: 

Former Victoria Police detective Denis Ryan has died in Mildura, aged 93.

Mr Ryan was driven from the police force in 1972 after his superiors stopped him from charging paedophile Catholic priest Monsignor John Day in the 1970s.

Child abuse victims, friends and social welfare advocates have remembered Mr Ryan for the four decades he spent fighting for justice for the children abused by Monsignor Day.

Former Victorian police officer Denis Ryan has been remembered for his courage in attempting to prosecute paedophile Catholic priest Monsignor John Day in the 1970s.

Mr Ryan died on Tuesday at the age of 93.

He was a detective based in Mildura in north-west Victoria when he was forced out of Victoria Police in 1972 for attempting to prosecute Monsignor Day.

A year earlier, he had learned of multiple allegations against the priest for child sexual abuse and began his investigation, but was…

View Cache

A victim advocacy group launched an ad campaign urging New York Gov. Kathy Hochul to force insurance companies to pay millions of dollars in abuse claims, slamming the governor for allegedly “stand[ing] with her big insurance buddies” instead of abuse victims.

The Coalition for Just and Compassionate Compensation, which started in 2023 to pressure insurance companies to pay abuse claims under the state’s Child Victims Act, began running ads in upstate New York markets this week.

“Who turns their back on over 14,000 survivors of child sex abuse? Gov. Kathy Hochul,” an ad states, claiming the Democratic governor “stands with her big insurance buddies [who are] denying responsibility while donating to her campaign.”

The ad features headlines from news stories of abuse scandals, including one that references the Diocese of Buffalo, which earlier this year said it would pay out a massive $150 million sum as part of…

View Cache

Protests, petitions, and cover-up accusations have roiled Truett McConnell University (TMU) in Cleveland, Georgia, after The Roys Report (TRR) exposed sexual assault allegations against former academic VP Bradley Reynolds.

Reynolds — dismissed in 2024 after the local sheriff’s office began an investigation into the abuse charges — allegedly inappropriately touched and digitally raped Hayle Swinson, a former student and soccer coach.

TMU President Emir Caner, who hired Reynolds in 2009, is among those accused of ignoring the misconduct. Trustees are set to meet Thursday or Friday. Student and alumni protests are slated to coincide with that meeting.

As of June 3, more than 2,000 people have signed a petition posted at change.org by “Concerned Truett Alumni” demanding action. (TMU had 2,612 students — mostly online — enrolled in fall 2023 according to U.S. News & World Report.)

The signers want a review of “all reports of alleged abuse…

View Cache

“Why do we have to pay this?”

The Diocese of Buffalo has started to ask affiliates to help pay for its $150 million settlement with more than 800 survivors of sexual abuse.

The settlement involves parishes and schools connected to decades of abuse by clergy, lay employees, religious and volunteers within the eight counties of Western New York.

We have learned the diocese has been meeting with affiliates and is expected to meet with priests and parishes next week to explain the percentages parishes would be responsible for paying.

“Why do we have to pay this. We’re not the ones at fault here,” said Nandor Forgach, a parishioner at St. Benedict Church.

The diocese sent me a statement saying it is working on a plan to satisfy the settlement and that it has “begun the process of internally communicating that plan to our clergy, parishes, and affiliates.”

You can read…

View Cache

‘Did the priest use our parish computer to look at pornography?’ a parishioner of Our Lady of Visitation asked the Archdiocese of Cincinnati’s chancellor

Green Township police removed a parishioner from Saturday afternoon Mass at Our Lady of Visitation after he questioned whether a priest had viewed pornography on a parish computer.

Two officers escorted parishioner Jake McQuaide, who is an NFL long snapper, out of the church during the 4 p.m. Mass, after he stood up in his pew to loudly ask Archdiocese of Cincinnati Chancellor Jason Williams for answers.

Williams had just finished reading a letter from Archbishop Robert Casey about controversy at the parish, and that Fr. Martin Bachman would be taking a “previously planned sabbatical.”

“Several concerns have been brought to the attention of the archdiocese. These have been investigated, and no wrongdoing — either criminally or ecclesiastically — has been substantiated … consequently, like gossip,…

View Cache

The arrest warrant for a Holliday pastor arrested Friday sheds more light on the details of the alleged relationship he had with a teenage girl.

Texas Rangers arrested Nathan Roach, 31, on May 30 for an alleged relationship he had with a child under 18. He is charged with child grooming. Roach bonded out of jail after his arrest on a $100,000 bond.

According to his arrest warrant, Roach was in a relationship with a now-17-year-old girl that began in 2022, when the girl was 15.

When the relationship began, Roach was the youth pastor at First Baptist Church in Holliday. He became the lead pastor in June 2024.

Court documents revealed that in December 2023, the girl’s parents found messages between her and Roach. The next month, the parents confronted him and asked him to stop communicating with their daughter privately. However, in an April 2025 interview, police said he admitted…

View Cache

A former Wisconsin Rapids youth pastor will spend 10 years in prison and 5 years on extended supervision for sexually assaulting a child while working as a youth pastor in 2003.

James Lane, 53, pleaded guilty to the charge in April and was convicted as a result. Attorney General Josh Kaul and Wood County District Attorney Jonathan Barnett said the case was reported through the Wisconsin Department of Justice Clergy and Faith Leader Abuse Initiative.

“As this conviction shows, the Clergy and Faith Leader Abuse Initiative is continuing to have an impact,” Kaul previously said. “Thank you to the courageous survivor whose decision to make a report has led to accountability for the defendant.”

Lane was a youth pastor at Faith Reformed Church in Wisconsin Rapids and had been living in Colorado. Lane admitted to assaulting the victim in his vehicle when he was driving the victim home.

…

View Cache

A Siler City pastor accused of watching and distributing child pornography faces child sexual exploitation charges, according to the police.

A Siler City pastor accused of possessing child pornography faces multiple charges, according to police.

Nelson Chay, 57, is charged with 10 counts of second-degree sexual exploitation of a minor.

According to the Siler City Police Department, in April, the department received an online tip about Chay, a pastor at Casa de Dios. Chay is accused of using the messaging app Kik to watch and distribute child pornography.

Investigators used a warrant to search Chay’s Siler City home on May 29, finding multiple electronic devices with child pornography.

The Siler City Police Department is concerned there could be victims who haven’t come forward.

“Due to his position in the church and that trust was bestowed upon him by our community, Chay has had access to juveniles indicating that there might…

View Cache

The Trump administration has launched an investigation into the law, calling it “anti-Catholic.” The bishops say it would force them to break their oaths.

Catholic leaders in Washington have sued the state over a new law requiring clergy to report suspected child abuse, including details potentially revealed during confession.

The lawsuit, filed last week on behalf of the bishops, alleges Senate Bill 5375, which was signed into law on May 2, violates the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. The law “puts Roman Catholic priests to an impossible choice: violate 2,000 years of Church teaching and incur automatic excommunication, or refuse to comply with Washington law and be subject to imprisonment, fine, and civil liability,” the lawsuit states.

The law’s text doesn’t target Catholics specifically. In fact, it upholds the mandatory reporting requirement for ministers, priests, rabbis, imams, elders…

View Cache

In a deeply unsettling development from Kerala, six nuns of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church, who bravely spoke out against former Bishop Franco Mulakkal—later acquitted in a high-profile rape case have faced serious consequences for their stand. Once active members of religious life, they now find themselves ostracised, unsupported by Church administration, and under mounting pressure to leave their convents. Half of them have already stepped away from their religious vocations.

Back in 2018, these six nuns from the Jalandhar Diocese courageously supported a fellow nun who accused Bishop Franco of sexually assaulting her multiple times between 2014 and 2016. Despite filing a police complaint, initial inaction led them to protest publicly, demanding justice. Their actions, however, came at great personal cost.

Although Bishop Franco was arrested and later acquitted by a trial court in 2022—a verdict now under appeal in the Kerala High Court—his accuser and her supporters continue to face…

View Cache

A Catholic nun from Zambia has called on African Christian leaders to take decisive action against the abuse of women in the Church.

Sister Linah Siabana, a mental health specialist with the Missionary Sisters of Our Lady of Africa, delivered her message during the recent Symposium and Annual General Meeting of the Conference of Major Superiors of Africa and Madagascar (COMSAM), in South Africa.

Sister Siabana called out a “persuasive culture of silence” in the church, saying it “hinders justice and healing for those impacted”.

She shared accounts of religious women who have suffered at the hands of priests or fellow sisters, including a case where a sister attempted suicide multiple times following abuse. “She felt dirty, and felt that whoever looked at her was seeing what [had been] had done,” recounted Siabana.

She emphasised the power imbalance that plays into church abuse, leaving an “incalculable” physical and psychological toll…

View Cache

The court ruled that Church confidentiality was less important than the right of journalists to investigate, ‘especially as regards matters of particular relevance to society’.

Colombia’s Constitutional Court ruled that the Catholic Church must release information about priests accused of sexual abuse.

The ruling was a victory for two journalists, Juan Pablo Barrientos and Miguel Ángel Estupiñán, resolving a dispute that began in 2020 when the Archdiocese of Medellín refused to release information to Barrientos about 105 priests. 

The Church had argued that the information was covered by the canon law rule of “the pontifical secret”, or confidentiality. The court ruled that this was less important than the right of journalists to investigate, “especially as regards matters of particular relevance to society”.

One of the cases Barrientos investigated concerned the Bogotá priest Luis Ángel Cuenca Serrano, reported to have abused at least 12 children. Although the Archbishop of Bogotá Cardinal…

View Cache

Not long after I arrived in town as the National Catholic Reporter’s Vatican correspondent, I attended a farewell dinner for a Roman Curia official who had served here for almost a decade. 

It was the priest’s last night in Rome and I asked him how he had spent his day. There were a few meetups with old colleagues, some final packing and then he noted that on his way to the dinner he walked by the Penitenzieri one final time.

“I figured if I didn’t see anyone there I knew, my time here could be summarized as a complete failure,” he joked. 

Il Wine Bar De’ Penitenzieri, or the “Penitenzieri” — or even “the Jesuit bar” — as everyone calls it for short, is steps from the Vatican and built into the side of the Jesuits’ global headquarters. It’s a cozy, if sometimes cramped space that offers more seating outside than indoors. 

…

View Cache

An ad campaign is pressuring Gov. Kathy Hochul to force insurance companies to pay claims to thousands of alleged sexual assault victims on behalf of churches, hospitals, schools, Boy Scouts troops and other employers they represent under the Child Victims Act.

The victims who were allegedly abused as children decades ago sued the various organizations they claimed allowed the abuse to happen decades later under the New York State Child Victims Act of 2019.

But many cases are tied up in court, with insurers of the defendants refusing to make payments on behalf of their clients, including the Catholic Church and other defendants, according to the group behind the ads, The Coalition for Just and Compassionate Compensation.

The group is bankrolled by allies of the Catholic Church, among others.

Hochul’s Department of Financial Services is supposed to help enforce the law, advocates said.

“Who turns their back on…

View Cache

In a powerful press conference, a survivor of child sexual abuse courageously shared his story and detailed new evidence against the late Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner, who served for nearly two decades at St. Joseph Catholic Church in Palm Bay, Florida. The evidence was presented by Jeff Herman and his team at Herman Law, as part of a new civil lawsuit filed in the Circuit Court of the Ninth Judicial Circuit in and for Orange County, Florida.

The complaint, filed on behalf of 26-year-old Shawn Teuber, alleges that Father Hoeffner sexually abused him on multiple occasions from 2012 to 2014, during his time as a student at St. Joseph Catholic School and parishioner at St. Joseph Catholic Church. It names the Diocese of Orlando, St. Joseph Catholic Church Palm Bay, St. Joseph Catholic School and St. Joseph Catholic Parish as defendants, accusing them of negligence, reckless disregard and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

“I’ve carried this pain for…

View Cache

Washington state removes an exemption protecting the seal of confession

On Thursday, a group of Roman Catholic priests in the state of Washington announced it is suing the state over a new law requiring religious clergy to report all instances of child abuse—even those mentioned during the act of confession.

While advocates for abuse victims cheered the new legislation, high-ranking priests said they would rather go to jail than violate church doctrine by breaking the confidentiality of confession.

The law, which Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson signed on May 2, adds religious clergy to the list of professions required to report child abuse. The list already includes doctors, counselors, and teachers. The law takes effect on July 27.

At least 24 states make clergy members mandatory reporters, but most include an exemption for any knowledge gained during a private confession of sin. Washington’s new law does not include this exemption, causing a stir…

View Cache

Bishop Michael Martin of Charlotte has indicated that he will assess whether to return to ministry a priest who has been accused of both boundary violations and sexual abuse of a minor.

The priest – Fr. Patrick Hoare – was removed from his role as pastor after the diocesan lay review board found boundary violation allegations against him to be credible.

Hoare has also been accused of sexually abusing minors decades ago in Pennsylvania – allegations which the Pennsylvania police determined to be credible, according to Martin’s predecessor.

Martin said the priest’s future ministry in the diocese will depend, in part, on his completion of an “assessment and training” program.

In a May 29 letter to parishioners of St. Matthew’s Parish, where Fr. Hoare had previously been pastor, Martin announced that the Apostolic Signatura – the Church’s supreme tribunal – has sided with the diocese in its decision to remove…

View Cache

A former Catholic priest in Jersey has been jailed for five years for sexually abusing a child.

Piotr Antoni Glas committed the 11 sexual abuse offences between 2004 and 2007 while he was a priest in the island.

Jersey’s Royal Court also gave Glas, 61, a lifelong restraining order, preventing contact with the victim, and ordered him to pay more than £12,000 towards the cost of the victim’s ongoing therapy.

In April, Glas was found guilty of three counts of gross indecency with a child.

The court heard how Glas progressively groomed his victim before abusing his position of trust to satisfy his sexual desires.

In delivering the sentence, the Deputy Bailiff Robert MacRae said it was “difficult to think of a more serious breach of trust than your offending in this case”.

‘Planned and deliberate’

On Monday, Crown Advocate Carla Carvalho, prosecuting, described Glas’s “planned and deliberate” grooming.

She…

View Cache

The victim of a former Catholic priest and self-proclaimed exorcist who was yesterday jailed for five years for sexual grooming has been praised for their “bravery in speaking out”.

Piotr Glas was also banned from any contact with the victim for the rest of his life following his sentencing in the Royal Court yesterday for what was described as “a gross and flagrant breach of trust” in using his position to abuse the child.

The Superior Number of the Royal Court – which convenes for only the most serious cases – heard that 61-year-old Glas was working as a priest and youth worker in Jersey 20 years ago when the abuse took place.

Crown Advocate Carla Carvalho, prosecuting, said Glas had “showered [the victim] with gifts and generosity” and invited the child to his home.

She said Glas had a foot fetish and would encourage…

View Cache

A Mass for the late Michael J. Byrnes, Roman Catholic archbishop emeritus of Guam, is scheduled for Saturday at the Dulce Nombre de Maria Cathedral-Basilica in Hagatña.

“All are invited to join in praying for the repose of the soul of our dear former shepherd of the church on Guam and for (the) consolation of his family,” according to an announcement Monday by the Archdiocese of Agana,  

The Office for the Dead will be prayed at 9:30 am., followed by the Mass at 10 a.m.

In the event of an overflow crowd, “the cathedral makes provisions not only with the cry room to the side but opens the smaller chapels and incorporates a widescreen. They have speakers outdoors with tents at times,” Tony Diaz, communications director for the archdiocese, said. 

The former archbishop of Agaña died on Saturday morning, Guam time, at the age of 66, while in hospice care…

View Cache

After Pope Leo XIV’s election on May 8, a new survey shows the percentage of Catholics continues to decrease in Peru. It was conducted by the Peruvian Studies Institute (known as IEP in Spanish), an independent social science think tank.

In its previous research, carried out in November of 2024, IEP had shown that 63.5 percent of the Peruvian people declared to be Catholic. Six months later – and after Cardinal Robert Prevost, a U.S.-born Peruvian national, was elected as the new pontiff – the percentage of Catholics fell to 60.2 percent.

In the same period, the proportion of Evangelicals grew from 8.4 percent in 2024 to 11.3 percent in 2025. The percentage of Peruvians who declared they don’t have any religion increased from 11.1 percent in 2024 to 11.9 percent in 2025.

Peruvians were also questioned about the feeling generated by the election of the first pontiff from Peru….

View Cache

For the outside world, it’s perhaps Pope Leo’s pleas for cease-fires in Gaza and Ukraine that have attracted the most attention since his election just over three weeks ago. For Catholic insiders, all manner of papal acts have generated reaction, from his sartorial touches, his use of sung Latin in public prayer, and even his few personnel moves.

For Italians, however, one moment above all from the new pontiff’s agenda has raised eyebrows: His May 27 audience with Cardinal Angelo Becciu, whose vicissitudes over the past five years, including his grudging withdrawal from the recent papal conclave, have formed the Vatican’s most riveting prime-time domestic soap opera.

Though the audience has been of interest here mostly in terms of what it might augur about Becciu’s personal fate, it also points to a decision about a key structural reform with deep historical roots.

It was Becciu, of course, whom Francis compelled…

View Cache

[See also the text of the lawsuit.]

The Brief

• A man is suing the Diocese of Orlando for $25 million and demanding a trial by jury after allegations of a pastor sexually abusing him and potentially others “for years.”
• The lawsuit also alleges that the church, school, parish and Diocese did nothing to stop it, even “commit[ing] willful acts of disregard and concealing” it.
• Police believe the alleged sexual abuse by the pastor may be linked to a deadly triple shooting in Palm Bay one year ago.

A man is suing the Diocese of Orlando for $25 million and demanding a trial by jury after allegations of a pastor sexually abusing him and potentially others “for years.”

Police believe the alleged sexual abuse by the pastor may be linked to a deadly triple shooting in Palm Bay one year ago. 

What happened?

What we know:

In a…

View Cache

[See also the text of the lawsuit. The original article includes video of previous WKMG reports.]

Over a year after a Florida priest was shot and killed in Palm Bay, a law firm has announced a lawsuit against the Diocese of Orlando.

A January 2025 report suggests Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner may have abused the gunman, but plenty of questions remain.

Below is a timeline of events:

JAN. 28, 2024

Palm Bay police responded to the 400 block of Forgal Avenue NE for a domestic disturbance.

Police said two officers were wounded in a standoff with 24-year-old Brandon Kapas, who had shot and killed two people in the home.

JAN. 29, 2024

The Diocese of Orlando announced that Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner and his sister, Sally, were both “tragically murdered” in the shooting.

Police Chief Mariano Augello confirmed that one…

View Cache

Since the first sexual abuse allegations surfaced in 1991 against the founder of Fondacio, the lay community—now marking its 50th anniversary—has yet to fully confront its past. In 2024, current leaders launched an independent review commission, which is expected to release its findings in June 2026.

A “cloak of silence.” As Fondacio prepares to mark its 50th anniversary May 30, that’s the phrase current leaders use to describe the long-standing hush surrounding the early history of their Christian lay community.

To understand the silence surrounding allegations of sexual and spiritual abuse by the movement’s founder, one must go back half a century. The story begins in 1974 in Poitiers. Jean-Michel Rousseau, a newly converted Catholic in his thirties and a Ph.D. in economics, launched what he called the “Christian Community for Formation.” He had returned from the United States a few years earlier, deeply changed by his encounter with the…

View Cache

(OSV News) — As the Italian bishops’ conference released its latest figures of abuse victims over the last five years, one survivor who recently met with the Vatican’s abuse commission is calling for concrete action against a bishop accused of covering up his abuse — showing that the accountability battle is, for survivors, far from over.

In a telephone interview with OSV News May 23, Antonio Messina said he hoped to also meet with Pope Leo XIV and “ensure that my story, which I already reported to Pope Francis and (several) dicasteries, can actually be pursued and not ignored.”

“I hoped that my willingness to meet — because no one can give me back what was taken from me — will be useful both to the church and to victims who have suffered, to prevent others from suffering and that those who have suffered have the tools to move forward with a…

View Cache

A woman who is now an adult has reached a tentative settlement with the Archdiocese of Los Angeles in her lawsuit alleging she was sexually abused by two clergy members and a nun while she was a minor attending a Catholic church and school two decades ago.

Attorneys for the plaintiff, identified only as L.G., filed court papers Thursday with Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Tiana Murillo notifying her of a “conditional” resolution of the case with the expectation a request for dismissal will be filed by Sept. 1.

No terms were divulged.

The archdiocese released a statement regarding the accord, saying it was part of a global settlement of multiple cases.

“In this particular matter, claims regarding the individuals have not been found to be credible,” the statement read. “There is no Archdiocesan record of the named woman … at all. The matter remains under internal review while the…

View Cache

Roman Catholic bishops from the state of Washington have filed a lawsuit challenging a new law that forces them to violate the confessional seal, calling it “a blatant intrusion” on their First Amendment rights. 

The bishops of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Seattle and the Dioceses of Spokane and Yakima in Washington, along with Catholic priests in the state, filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington at Tacoma on Thursday.

The lawsuit, which names Washington’s Democratic Gov. Bob Ferguson, Democratic Attorney General Nicholas Brown and every county prosecuting attorney in the state as defendants, alleges that Senate Bill 5375 is unconstitutional. 

The measure, signed into law by Ferguson earlier this month, adds members of the clergy to a list of professionals who are required to report instances of child abuse or neglect to law enforcement. Under the legislation,…

View Cache

Barely two weeks before Southern Baptists gather in Dallas for their annual meeting, another alleged sexual abuse case — this time involving a former student at a Georgia Baptist university — has surfaced.

The story includes the alleged grooming of Hayle Swinson of Americus, Ga., by Bradley Reynolds, then vice president of student services at Truett McConnell University. Her story began with innocent home basement Bible studies and mentoring that slowly progressed to holding hands during prayer and eventually placing his hands on her leg, caressing her back and later moving to her breasts and placing his hands in her pants, she says.

But it didn’t end there. Reynolds tried to convince Swinson that God had showed him in dreams that his wife was going to die and it was in God’s divine plan for them to marry and raise his children together, according to published accounts.

Reynolds, about 20 years…

View Cache

Lawsuit alleges murdered Palm Bay priest sexually abused children The murder of a Palm Bay priest has led to a new sexual abuse lawsuit against the Diocese of Orlando.

PALM BAY, Fla. — The murder of a Palm Bay priest has led to a new sexual abuse lawsuit against the Diocese of Orlando.

The victim in the lawsuit said he came forward after learning the Rev. Bob Hoeffner was murdered in January 2024.

According to police, the gunman, Brandon Kapas, killed Hoeffner and two others before Palm Bay police shot and killed Kapas.

On Friday, attorneys for Shawn Teuber filed a suit that claimed the diocese was aware Hoeffner was abusing children and engaged in a coverup.

Teuber said he was abused by Hoeffner and believes Kapas was also a victim of sexual abuse.

According to the lawsuit, Teuber was groomed by Hoeffner while he was a seventh…

View Cache

Prominent British Catholics have voiced grave concern about new government-backed legislation that will require Christian clergy to report information obtained during confessions about sexual abuse.

“Priests always try to comply with the law — but this won’t happen if that law contradicts Catholic teaching,” said Timothy Guile, chairman of the English Catholic History Association.

“No priest is going to risk excommunication by breaking the confessional seal — they’d sooner go to prison than bow to such demands. Once again, we face ministers and politicians with no knowledge or understanding of religious faith,” he said.

No Exceptions to Disclosure Obligation

The Catholic historian was reacting to confirmation by Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s government that “no exceptions” would be made to disclosure obligations under a major new Crime and Policing Bill.

In an OSV News interview, Guile said the bill amounted to “anti-Catholic legislation” and recalled repressive measures against the church dating…

View Cache

YAOUNDÉ, Cameroon – In the face of histories of abuse and cover-up by the Church, a Catholic nun in Zambia has challenged Church leaders to stem the tide of abuse against women religious wherever and whenever it happens.

Sister Linah Siabana was speaking during the Symposium and 6th Annual General Meeting of the Conference of Major Superiors of Africa and Madagascar (COMSAM) in South Africa that ended May 30.

Sexual violence, she explained, encompasses a range of actions that coerce and pressures individuals into engaging in unwanted sexual activities.

“These can manifest in various forms including physical violence, emotional manipulation, or overarching power dynamics that inhibit a person’s capacity to give informed consent,” she said.

She said the tactics used may involve intimidation, threats or grooming behaviors that further complicate the victim’s ability to resist or report the abuse.

“Understanding the peculiarity of sexual abuse is crucial for recognizing the…

View Cache

According to a report released May 28, Italian dioceses recorded 69 cases of abuse involving minors or vulnerable adults in 2023 and 2024—a rise compared to 2022. The Italian bishops’ conference said the increase reflects “the emergence of incidents that had previously remained hidden.”

Italian dioceses reported 69 cases of abuse involving minors or vulnerable adults in 2023 and 2024, most occurring in parish settings, according to a report released Wednesday, May 28, by the Italian bishops’ conference.

The 98-page document, which reviews efforts to combat sexual abuse in the Italian Church, details 69 cases involving 118 alleged victims—one-third of whom were between the ages of 10 and 14.

By comparison, a 2022 report recorded 32 cases and 54 potential victims. Of the 69 recent cases, 11 involved sexual relations, 19 involved sexual assault, and 25 involved inappropriate touching.

Further reading: Sexual abuse in the Catholic Church: the Italian exception

…

View Cache

A lawsuit seeks “not less than $25 million” in damages from the Diocese or Orlando for alleged negligence.

A New York man filed a lawsuit Friday against the Diocese of Orlando alleging he was molested by a priest while a student at a Catholic school in Brevard County — the same priest who was killed last year by his childhood friend.

The lawsuit seeks “not less than $25 million” in damages from the diocese for alleged negligence “arising from the sexual abuse of a child” by Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner, 76, who was shot to death Jan. 28, 2024, in his Palm Bay home.

Hoeffner had spent 25 years in Orlando parishes, including a stint as a teacher at Bishop Moore Catholic High School, before taking a post in Brevard. He retired in 2016.

The lawsuit claims the diocese was warned of Hoeffner’s inappropriate behavior with young…

View Cache

• The lawsuit alleges that priest Father Robert Hoeffner sexually abused boys.
• One of the alleged victims, Shawn Teuber, is now suing the diocese and claims Hoeffner used confession to coerce him into sexual acts.
• Brandon Kapas killed Hoeffner, Hoeffner’s sister, and his own grandfather before being killed in a shootout with police in January 2024.

A lawsuit against the Orlando Diocese of the Catholic Church was filed by a Boca Raton law firm on May 30, alleging negligence was committed by a Brevard County priest who was murdered in January 2024.

Jeff Herman of Herman Law firm, which represents sexual abuse survivors, announced at a press conference in Orlando that he is filing the suit on behalf of an alleged survivor who was childhood friends with Brandon Kapas, the man who killed Robert “Father Bob” Hoeffner.

The lawsuit alleges negligence by the Diocese of Orlando and St. Joseph Catholic Church and…

View Cache

NCTR, May 29 2025

TREATY 1 TERRITORY, WINNIPEG, May 29, 2025 – The National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation (NCTR) and the Oblates of OMI Lacombe Canada (the Oblates) continue their collaborative efforts to ensure residential school Survivors, their families, and communities have access to critical historical Oblate documents.

For several years, the NCTR has worked in collaboration with OMI Lacombe to acquire Oblate residential school records from various archival sources and expedite access to critical historical documents, including personnel files of Oblate members who worked in residential schools in Canada. These records are vital for families and communities as they continue their research on residential school Survivors and the children who never made it home.

Through research, agreements and dialogue with the Oblates of OMI Lacombe, the NCTR has created a list of Oblate priests and brothers who participated in the administration and/or operations of these schools. Many of the…

View Cache

Today, Herman Law held a press conference to announce our lawsuit against the Diocese of Orlando and associated institutions, highlighting the institutional failures that allowed Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner to abuse our client. Attorney Jeff Herman stood alongside our courageous client as he bravely shared his story and called for accountability. 

Read the full press release below.

ORLANDO, FL — May 30, 2025 — In a powerful press conference today, a survivor of child sexual abuse courageously shared his story and detailed new evidence against the late Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner, who served for nearly two decades at St. Joseph’s Catholic Church in Palm Bay, Florida. The evidence was presented by Jeff Herman and his team at Herman Law, as part of a new civil lawsuit filed in the Circuit Court of the Ninth Judicial Circuit in and for Orange County, Florida.

The complaint, filed on behalf of 26-year-old Shawn Teuber,…

View Cache

Canadian researchers and advocates have published a list of more than 100 priests and religious workers who served in the country’s controversial Indigenous “residential schools” that operated there for more than a century. 

The National Center for Truth and Reconciliation — a nonprofit that collects and publishes information on the Indigenous school system — said in a Thursday press release that it had created “a list of Oblate priests and brothers who participated in the administration and/or operations” of the schools. 

The list was live on the group’s website as of Friday, complete with “personnel profiles and links to the schools where the Oblate members served,” the group said. 

Long a source of historical tension in Canada, the residential schools — the last of which closed in the 1990s — have been criticized for their aim of turning Native American children away from Indigenous…

View Cache

PORTLAND, Maine (AP) — James Talbot, a former Catholic priest convicted of sexually assaulting boys in Maine and Massachusetts after he was exposed by the investigation highlighted in the movie “Spotlight,” has died. He was 87.

Talbot, a former Jesuit, appeared on a list provided by the religious order of northeastern Jesuits who faced credible allegations of sexual abuse of a minor. Talbot died on Feb. 28 at a hospice center in St. Louis, said Mike Gabriele, a spokesperson for Jesuits USA East.

Talbot was one of the subjects of The Boston Globe’s investigation into priest sexual abuse that won a Pulitzer Prize in 2003 and was adapted into the 2015 movie “Spotlight.” The investigation revealed widespread sexual abuse, and coverup of that abuse, within the Catholic Church. Jesuits USA East did not offer a comment about Talbot’s death.

He pleaded guilty in 2018 to gross sexual assault and unlawful sexual…

View Cache

Victims of the abusive priest James Talbot want it known far and wide what the Jesuits did not tell them: he’s dead.

When Jim Scanlan heard that the priest who raped him and so many others had died, he was surprised at his own reaction.

It wasn’t relief or anger or a fist-shaking “Yes!”

It was indifference.

James Talbot, who as a priest raped Scanlan and other boys when he taught at Boston College High School, then raped more boys after he was quietly shipped from Boston to Maine, was not worthy of an emotion so intense, so draining, so overwhelming, as hate; that Talbot simply is not deserving of Jim Scanlan’s deepest feelings.

“There’s an old saying, and I didn’t know what it meant until now. ‘The opposite of love is not hate, it’s indifference,’ ” Scanlan said.

Nonetheless that anger, that sense of enduring grievance, did eventually well…

View Cache

The Vatican confirms the Diocese of Charlotte’s decision to remove Father Patrick Hoare for alleged boundary violations with minors.

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — The Vatican has upheld the Diocese of Charlotte’s decision to remove a priest from his pastoral role following allegations of violations with minors, ending a years-long appeals process, Bishop Michael T. Martin announced.

Father Patrick Hoare was removed as pastor of St. Matthew Parish in 2020 after the diocese’s Lay Review Board concluded that claims of boundary violations with minors had “a semblance of truth.” Hoare appealed the decision to the Holy See in Rome, which has now ruled that his removal was in accordance with canon law.

Martin said he will appoint a new pastor for St. Matthew Parish in the coming days, ending a period during which Father John Allen has served as interim administrator since 2019.

The review board examined three complaints…

View Cache

Shares outcome of canonical proceedings involving Father Patrick Hoare

CHARLOTTE — Bishop Michael Martin, OFM Conv., issued the following statement May 29 to members of St. Matthew Parish about their former pastor, Father Patrick Hoare, who has been on administrative leave since December 2019:

Dear St. Matthew parishioners,

I am writing to share news about Father Patrick Hoare and the pastoral leadership of St. Matthew Parish.

As Bishop Peter Jugis shared with you in 2020, Father Hoare was removed as your pastor after the diocese’s Lay Review Board (LRB) reviewed specific claims of boundary violations with minors by Father Hoare and concluded that they had a semblance of truth. The LRB is an advisory group mandated by particular ecclesiastical law and its members are appointed by the diocesan bishop. The LRB is to independently evaluate claims of misconduct by clergy and other diocesan employees and to make recommendations to the…

View Cache

The Rev. Patrick Hoare’s removal as pastor of St. Matthew Catholic Church amid accusations of misconduct involving youth was justified under church law, the Vatican City-based government of the Roman Catholic Church has ruled.

St. Matthew in Ballantyne is the largest Catholic parish in Charlotte and among the biggest in the U.S.

Charlotte Catholic Bishop Michael Martin revealed the Holy See’s ruling in a statement to St. Matthew parishioners published Thursday in the diocesan newspaper, Catholic News Herald.

The Holy See ruled on Hoare’s appeal of his removal in 2020 by then-Charlotte Catholic Bishop Peter Jugis.

Allegations against popular priest

Hoare’s removal followed a review by the diocese’s Lay Review Board of “specific claims of boundary violations with minors.” The board found “a semblance of truth” to the allegations, Martin wrote.

Jugis placed Hoare on administrative leave in December 2019 based on decades-old allegations of sexual abuse of a minor…

View Cache

Claudine*,a retired nurse who was raped by a chaplain when she was young, is one of the pioneers. “In 2019, after the publication of an article about abuse at our lycée, we got together as victims. We were scattered all over France. We organized a meeting, which was very warm and involved a lot of listening. Our group of ten people was received by CIASE in February 2020. I was in Lourdes when the bishops acknowledged the Church had done wrong, and I went to Paris when CIASE issued its report. So I saw the birth of the INIRR, to which I decided to take my case in January 2022.

Michel* was abused at a very young age by a nun. He worked as a psychotherapist and was also one of the pioneers. “When I first heard about the Sauvé Commission [named…

View Cache

Former members of a suppressed scandal-plagued Peruvian lay group, along with peasants who claim to have been routinely harassed by the same group, have issued a joint call for justice, reparation and a meeting with Pope Leo XIV.

On May 29, members of the Castillo and Catacaos peasant farming commune in Piura, Peru, stood side-by-side with former members of the Soldalitium Christianae Vitae (SCV), to decry abuses and alleged financial corruption of the outfit, and to advocate for civil and ecclesial action.

The SCV, founded by Peruvian layman Luis Fernando Figari in 1971, was once one of the most powerful ecclesial movements in Latin America, with consecrated and lay members, before scandals erupted in 2015 involving decades of various abuses inside the group, including the sexual abuse of minors.

Figari was sanctioned by the Vatican in 2017, and papally-mandated leadership was appointed to reform the group. Pope Francis in July 2023 sent…

View Cache

Victim to testify against Father Robert Hoeffner, attorney says

On Friday, Herman Law is set to hold a news conference to announce a lawsuit against the Diocese of Orlando amid new child sexual abuse allegations against a late priest.

Palm Bay Police said 24-year-old Brandon Kapas shot and killed Father Robert “Bob” Hoeffner, 76, and his sister, Sally Hoeffner, 69, inside their home in January 2024.

A year later, a report revealed that sexual abuse may have led to the shooting, including a folder with notes about abuse that was found at the crime scene.

Hoeffner served for nearly two decades at St. Joseph’s Catholic Church in Palm Bay.

According to a news release, a victim will share their story during Friday’s news conference, alongside statements from Jeff Herman, a nationally-recognized attorney and advocate for survivors of sexual abuse.

The news conference is set…

View Cache

A now former New Jersey high school teacher is accused of secretly recording girls at two different malls, and at least one student at the Catholic school where he worked.

Axel Palomares, 50, was arrested on Tuesday following the execution of a search warrant at his home in Morristown, authorities announced. He’s facing multiple charges including creating and possessing child sex abuse material.

Prior to his arrest, Palomares taught Spanish and coached the girls soccer team at St. Thomas Aquinas High School in Edison, according to NJ.com.

An investigation into Palomares began in December after authorities received a tip regarding a user on the Kik chat app talking about his illicit recordings and having fantasies of abusing kids.

Amid their investigation, law enforcement learned that Palomares had been seen on surveillance video “spending a considerable amount of time” in bathrooms at the Bridgewater Commons, according…

View Cache

The “quiet revival” in Britain, especially among younger men, may well be occurring in the Republic of Ireland as well, with new research suggesting increasingly favourable attitudes towards Christianity in the country, albeit with a fair amount of suspicion towards the Roman Catholic Church.

A poll of a 1,000 people commissioned by The Iona Institute, and carried out by Amarach Research, discovered that Gen Z (18 to 24 years-old) are more open to faith than Millennials (25 to 34 years old).

A majority of people in Ireland (61 per cent) described themselves as religious or spiritual in some way. The vast majority of the Irish population still identifies as Roman Catholic, however only about 16 per cent said they went to mass regularly.

Just over a fifth of respondents said they were not Catholic, with a quarter said they would not object if the Catholic Church were…

View Cache

A 74-year-old pedophile and former surgeon was given a maximum 20-year prison sentence on Wednesday by a French court for the sexual assault of hundreds of patients, mostly children, over more than two decades. Joël Le Scouarnec was sentenced after admitting raping and sexually assaulting 299 victims.

A 74-year-old former surgeon was given a maximum 20-year prison sentence Wednesday by a French court for the rape and sexual assault of hundreds of patients, mostly children, over more than two decades.

Joël Le Scouarnec was sentenced after admitting molesting nearly 300 victims in one of the country’s largest-ever child sex abuse cases, which has raised questions about how he was able to abuse so many, for so long.

Judges followed the public prosecutor’s recommendations regarding the length of the sentence, and the criminal court of Morbihan, in western France, ordered that Le Scouarnec should serve at least two-thirds of the punishment…

View Cache

Archbishop Emeritus John Vlazny, who led the Archdiocese of Portland, Oregon, through some of its most turbulent years, died at his home in Beaverton May 23. He was 88.

Public visitation for Archbishop Vlazny will take place June 5 at St. Mary’s Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception in Portland, with a vigil service that evening, Hillsboro News Times reported. A funeral Mass will be held June 6 and livestreamed on the archdiocese’s website.

Born in Chicago and ordained a priest in 1961, Archbishop Vlazny spent over five decades in active ministry, serving in key leadership roles across the country. His assignments took him from auxiliary bishop in his native Archdiocese of Chicago, to the Diocese of Winona in Minnesota, and ultimately to Oregon, where he became Portland’s archbishop in 1997.Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

His 16-year tenure in Portland was defined by conducting pastoral outreach and responding to…

View Cache

Groups alleging enduring multiple abuses from the former Catholic organization Sodalitium Christian Vitae, joined efforts on Thursday asking the church to make public it’s investigation.

Speaking in the Peruvian capital Lima, they called on Pope Leo XIV and the Peruvian government to hear their plea and continue a serious investigation of their accusations.

They are also demanding that the Peruvian government liaise with the U.S. authorities, as the Sodalitium is also based in Denver.

These groups already have a history with Pope Leo XIV, who acting as priest and bishop Robert Prevost during his decades in Peru, heard their cases and took them to Pope Francis.

Francis sided with the victims and along with Prevost, investigated the cases and dissolved the Sodalitium Christian Vitae.

The groups are now requesting Pope Leo make public the decree to dissolve the Sodalitium.

The Sodalitium is a lay group that runs schools and spiritual…

View Cache

Since the first sexual abuse allegations surfaced in 1991 against the founder of Fondacio, the lay community—now marking its 50th anniversary—has yet to fully confront its past. In 2024, current leaders launched an independent review commission, which is expected to release its findings in June 2026.

A “cloak of silence.” As Fondacio prepares to mark its 50th anniversary May 30, that’s the phrase current leaders use to describe the long-standing hush surrounding the early history of their Christian lay community.

To understand the silence surrounding allegations of sexual and spiritual abuse by the movement’s founder, one must go back half a century. The story begins in 1974 in Poitiers. Jean-Michel Rousseau, a newly converted Catholic in his thirties and a Ph.D. in economics, launched what he called the “Christian Community for Formation.” He had returned from the United States a few years earlier, deeply changed by his encounter with the…

View Cache

Washington’s Catholic leaders sued state leaders and county prosecutors Thursday, alleging that a controversial new law requiring priests to break the confessional seal to report suspected child abuse is “a brazen act of religious discrimination.”

The new law adds clergy to a list of other professions, such as health care workers and school personnel, who are mandatory reporters of abuse. But the church’s lawsuit pushes back on a provision of the law that does not allow carve-outs for things said during confession, and exposes priests to potential arrest. 

That decision by lawmakers violates the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, alleges the lawsuit filed in Tacoma’s federal court by leaders and priests in Washington’s three archdioceses, including Seattle archbishop Paul Etienne. It names Gov. Bob Ferguson, Attorney General Nick Brown and a host of local law enforcement officials, who could…

View Cache

They argue it is unconstitutional to force Catholic priests to divulge information learned in confession.

Washington’s leading Catholic bishops filed a lawsuit Thursday contending the new state law requiring religious leaders to report child abuse or neglect, even when it is disclosed in confession, is unconstitutional and should be invalidated.

They argue the law violates their First Amendment right to practice religion free of government interference, and is religious discrimination because it will force priests to violate their sacred vows or face punishment by the state.

It also violates a provision of the state constitution guaranteeing “freedom of conscience in all matters of religious sentiment, belief and worship,” they assert.

They want the law set aside and an injunction barring criminal investigations or prosecution of Roman Catholic clergy for not divulging information learned in confession.

The new law “puts Roman Catholic priests to an impossible choice: violate 2,000 years of…

View Cache

‘The sacramental seal is inviolable’

The bishops of Washington filed a lawsuit Thursday challenging a new state law that requires priests to violate the seal of confession if they suspect the abuse of minors.

The May 29 lawsuit argues that the new law violates First Amendment religious freedom protections, as well as the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment and the Washington constitution.

“Confession offers the faithful a confidential space to seek God’s mercy and guidance. This trust is sacred, and any law that jeopardizes it risks discouraging those who recognize the harm they have caused from seeking moral guidance,” said Jean Hill, executive director of the Washington Catholic Conference, in a statement.

The suit argues that the law constitutes religious discrimination, because it demands that priests violate the norms of the Catholic Church to adhere to the reporting requirements, while at the same time explicitly exempting multiple other groups…

View Cache