By Janet Patterson
AMDG / Roman Catholic Faithful
[See Janet Patterson's other essays Driven from the Flock and Sexual
Abuse—the Church's Millstone.]
I stood there, rooted to the spot, stroking my son’s hair, gently
touching his cold face, gazing at my precious child. “Eric,”
I thought, “oh, Eric.” Then I turned to walk down the church
aisle as the funeral attendants closed the casket. Numb from shock, I
joined the rest of my family, clutching my husband’s hand tightly,
feeling his arm caressing my shoulder.
Now, three years later, I am sitting at Eric’s computer, the one
on which he typed his suicide note, painfully recalling the series of
events that culminated in his death. Slowly, painstakingly, our family
grapples with the awful truth—our son was sexually abused at the
age of twelve by our parish priest. How could this be? Sexual abuse happens
to someone else’s child, in someone else’s family, not ours.
Then reality hits.
My mind constantly reconstructs the details of Eric’s life; sifting
and sorting through memories, wondering what clues I missed, what behavior
I didn’t understand at the time. Why, during high school, did he
refuse to be confirmed? When I questioned him about his decision, he replied
that he didn’t even know if he believed in God. He could not receive
this sacrament, he felt, unless he was making a heart-felt commitment.
Why, the night of his junior-senior prom, did he drive for hours on the
interstate, not arriving home until seven the next morning? Tearfully,
he told us that he had wanted to keep driving forever. When asked what
was troubling him, he couldn’t tell us. I sensed he was in distress,
but felt powerless. As he continued his junior year, he seemed better,
so I relaxed, believing that this episode was one of many crises most
adolescents go through.
Why, his junior year in college, did he wreck his car as he rounded a
curve too fast, hitting some trees? I drove to meet Eric that morning,
and we talked for hours in a park close by. Slowly, painfully, Eric revealed
that he couldn’t eat, couldn’t sleep, that his life seemed
out of control. Realizing he was suicidal, I immediately made him an appointment
with a psychiatrist for evaluation. After being placed on an anti-depressant,
Eric seemed confident and focused.
Shortly after this, he did a complete turnabout, embracing Catholicism
fervently. Daily holy hours, weekly visits to a nursing home, teaching
5th grade CCD, writing to a prisoner in Texas, continuing his pro-life
activities, attending a weekly Bible study group on campus, getting confirmed—all
these actions filled him with hope and enthusiasm.
Easter weekend, he proudly announced to us that he wanted to become a
priest. In my heart I knew he would be a good priest, caring, intelligent,
and faithful to our Lord’s teachings. After graduation, he headed
to the East coast as a candidate for a seminary program. He wrote letters
telling of his feeling that this was truly where he belonged. The night
before he was to fly home for a short visit, the director asked him to
wait in a room, that he needed to talk to him. After waiting three hours,
shortly before midnight, Eric was told that he was not being accepted,
that he was to take everything with him the next day, and not to tell
anyone there that he would not be returning.
On the way home from the airport, Eric stunned us by saying, “They
didn’t want me.” My heart lurched, my mind reeled, alternating
between anger and disbelief. He was given no explanation, he said, but
told us that God must want him somewhere else. Over the next few days,
I watched as parishioners asked Eric where he would be studying for the
priesthood. Bravely, he told each one, “They didn’t want me,”
leaving them puzzled and surprised. After Eric’s death, while going
through a box containing his papers, I found a paper dated a few days
before his departure from the seminary. At the top of a detailed set of
notes in blue ink, he had his perpetrator’s name written in red.
Evidently he had revealed his sexual abuse, leading to his rejection by
the seminary. How much pain he must have gone through, finally confiding
his painful secret, only to be turned away so callously. But he continued
trusting in the Lord, continued teaching CCD, and making holy hours.
A few months later, Eric took a teaching position at Catholic preparatory
school two hundred miles from home. Fluent in Spanish, he taught English
as a Second Language, Spanish, and religion. After over a year teaching,
he had begun fasting, unknown to us, evidently trying to please God and
to have a sense of control over his life. By the time we realized that
Eric was in trouble physically and mentally, he weighed only about 170
pounds, far too thin for his 6 feet 8 inch height. Entering a hospital
psychiatric unit, he attempted to combat his anorexic condition and battle
with his psychotic depression. Asked if he had ever been sexually abused,
he denied that he had. His psychiatrist was troubled by Eric’s illness,
sensing that the root cause had yet to be discovered. Over a month later,
Eric returned home, where we cajoled him to eat and to drink, as he had
no desire to do so. Eventually,with medication, he grew stronger and healthier.
For the next three years, he was a successful computer salesperson, receiving
gratitude from his many customers for his courteous, professional help.
Once more, however, his weight began to plummet. Fearing hospitalization,
he attempted to regain control of his life by going back on his medication.
Deeply troubled, he sobbed uncontrollably one night in our living room,
his best friend beside him. He dreaded hospitalization, but we succeeded
in getting him admitted for treatment. At a different hospital this time,
he had the good fortune of having the same psychiatrist. She was convinced
there was a missing link, that some unknown cause lay at the root of his
Two days later, when Becky, Eric’s older sister, visited him in
the ward, she told him that we hated his idea of God, a vengeful God Who
could never be pleased. We viewed Him as a loving and merciful God. Asking
him if he always felt that way about God, she was surprised at his answer,
“No, it all changed when I was twelve.” Then he revealed his
molestation but didn’t wish to talk about it in detail. Becky consulted
with his nurse, sensing that this revelation was crucial to her brother’s
recovery. Later, the nurse found Eric in his room, beating his head on
the floor and against the sink. After putting him in full-body restraint,
the staff heavily sedated him and placed him on suicide watch. A sexual-abuse
therapist began sessions with Eric, and we were hopeful that healing could
begin with his long-buried secret finally exposed. He returned home about
six weeks later, eventually resumed his job, and decided to move in with
a friend from work. A little more than eight months after he disclosed
his sexual abuse, Eric left work one Friday with no explanation, sat on
the porch of his friend’s house smoking a cigarette, and then sometime
that afternoon placed a gun to his head. When his friend arrived home
from work, he was faced with a nightmarish scene. The police could find
no suicide note, but acting on a hunch, Eric’s friend went to his
computer, searched among his files, and discovered one entitled “Hope.”
Dated six days before his death, the note revealed Eric’s intense
struggle to please God, yet always falling short of His expectations.
With that, our handsome, intelligent, compassionate son was gone.
Now, three years later, I feel compelled to tell his story. As a grieving
mother, I beseech those who read this to risk facing the true brutality
of clergy sexual abuse. Abuse victims are all around us—they are
our sons, daughters, grandchildren, fathers, mothers, sisters, brothers,
husbands, wives, and friends. Please pray fervently that survivors may
be treated with understanding, acceptance, and love. Let your diocese
know how you feel about the clergy sexual abuse scandal. Be willing to
support survivors in their difficult task of recovery. Hold diocesan church
officials accountable for allowing perpetrators to continue molesting
in parish after parish, excusing these actions by saying they received
“poor medical advice.” First and foremost should come the
needs and safety of children and adolescents. If our Church fails to safeguard
our children, where is its moral credibility?
As agonizingly painful as this tragedy has been, we cherish every day
we had with our son. If avoiding this pain would require never having
had Eric in our lives, then I gladly embrace the pain for the honor of
being Eric’s mother.
ERIC ANTHONY PATTERSON, R.I.P.
Sept. 5, 1970
Oct. 29, 1999