Alleged Molesters Fall through Cracks
Legislation Aims to Fix Situation

By Jim Provance
Toledo Blade
October 7, 2006

Last of two parts

Columbus — Most have never been charged with a crime, let alone convicted of one.

Their names are not on Ohio's so-called "Megan's Law" list of sex offenders checked by the state, school districts, nonprofit organizations, and others when it comes to deciding whom to license, hire, or take on as coaches or volunteers.

They may have been named in civil lawsuits, in newspapers, and, in some cases, by their own bishops, but current and former priests who have admitted to molesting children or whose dioceses have decided that they were most likely guilty of child sex abuse have fallen through the cracks of Ohio's efforts to track sex offenders.

Last of two parts

Nothing in state law authorizes the Department of Education to routinely run background checks on teachers they've already licensed, something that would probably have flagged two of 10 people the department is now investigating after they were recently brought to its attention by The Blade.

And while the Diocese of Toledo and the Archdiocese of Cincinnati have publicly listed on their own online registries the names of seven disciplined former teachers and administrators, nothing in Ohio law required the diocese or its schools to tell the Department of Education what it knew or believed to have occurred.

"It cheapens the whole licensure process when a child molester can hold a license," said Claudia Vercellotti, Toledo coordinator for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. "It gives the appearance of a more well-rounded candidate. It's hard for the average person to reconcile that someone who is licensed by the state as a teacher or counselor could also be a sex offender."

House Bill 79, pending a joint House-Senate conference committee, would require public and private schools that suspect abuse by a teacher, school counselor, or administrator licensed by the department to report their suspicions.

"The problem is these cases haven't been brought to [the state's] attention," said Rep. Tom Raga (R., Mason), the bill's sponsor and Ken Blackwell's running mate in the Nov. 7 gubernatorial election.

Priests and religious educators whose teaching certifi cates are under scrutiny:

• Stephen G. Rogers, 58, former religion teacher/associate pastor at Toledoís Central Catholic High School. Convicted of possessing child pornography in 2003. Registered sex offender. Suspended by Diocese of Toledo. State Board of Education to revoke certifi cate to teach in private and religious schools Tuesday.

• George J. Cooley, 58, defrocked priest in Archdiocese of Cincinnati. Convicted of child molestation. Holds certifi cate to teach in private and religious schools.

• Robert J. Yeager, 68, principal of Cardinal Stritch High School in Oregon in 1990s. Suspended by Diocese of Toledo following allegation of abuse 30 years ago. Will voluntarily surrender permanent high school principal, superintendent, and school counselor certificates.

• Joseph M. Schmelzer, 58, served as superintendent of St. Mary of the Assumption School in Van Wert. Suspended by Diocese of Toledo after allegation of abuse 30 years ago. Will voluntarily surrender certificate to teach in private and religious schools.

• David J. Kelley, 58, suspended by Archdiocese of Cincinnati after multiple allegations. Hamilton County prosecutor has petitioned court to make him the fi rst man placed on new civil registry of sex offenders. Holds certificate to teach in private and parochial schools.

• Samuel E. Ritchey, 63, suspended by Diocese of Columbus after allegation last year of abuse in 1977 at Fisher Catholic High School in Columbus. Has certifi cate for private and religious schools.

• Bernard A. Kokocinski, 68, suspended by Diocese of Toledo. Church settled 2002 lawsuit alleging rape in Fremont rectory in 1975. Holds certificate for private and religious schools.

• Richard M. Unwin, 53, former principal suspended by Archdiocese of Cincinnati for allegation of sexual misconduct dating back 18 years. Holds certificate for private and religious schools.

• James G. Kiffmeyer, 49, priest with eight-year certificate to teach biology and chemistry in public high school and certificate for private and religious schools. Archdiocese of Cincinnati settled complaint alleging incident with 18-year-old student in 1980s. Has taken a leave of absence.

• Victor Whiting, 50, nonpriest teacher and coach. Diocese of Toledo reached settlement over allegation he sexually touched and harassed 15-year-old female student on repeated occasions in 1990 while at St. Johnís High School in Delphos. Teaches and coaches at Northwest High School at Canal Fulton. Holds high school teaching license and certificate for nonpublic schools.

Senate Bill 17 became law in August, making Ohio the first state with a civil registry. The concept was presented by Catholic bishops as an alternative to suspending the statute of limitations to allow the filing of civil lawsuits for abuse that occurred up to 35 years ago.

Adrian Allison, director of the department's Office of Professional Conduct and Education Licensure, said he would welcome another source of information. "The bottom line for me is our goal to educate students, and in order for students to get a good education, they need a safe and secure environment," he said. "If there are individuals who are in any way a threat or impediment to that environment, we need to know about it."

The department had lobbied for the bill and found a sponsor in Mr. Raga to address the "pass the trash" phenomenon.

"Back in Warren and Montgomery counties, we had a couple of situations where teachers made an agreement to leave a school district in exchange for the school agreeing not to talk about the issue that led to the resignation," said Mr. Raga.

On Tuesday, the State Board of Education is slated to permanently revoke the teaching certificate held by suspended priest Stephen G. Rogers, a former religion teacher at Toledo's Central Catholic High School who was convicted of child pornography possession. He is voluntarily surrendering his certificate to teach in private and religious schools.

Two other priests suspended by the Diocese of Toledo, Robert J. Yeager and Joseph M. Schmelzer, have also agreed to not to fight the state's revocation of their educator certificates, according to their attorney.

The state continues to gather information on certificates held by six other current and former priests who have been convicted of crimes, permanently removed or suspended from the priesthood, or have seen their dioceses reach financial settlements with their alleged victims. A 10th case involves a nonpriest teacher and coach.

Attorney General Jim Petro, whose office oversees the statewide sex-offender registry and has written the rules for the new civil registry, said background checks come with a price. The proposed checks that would be mandated under House Bill 79 would be born by the license applicant, but many school districts and organizations have picked up the tab in the past.

The fee for a state-only background check is $15. A national check via the FBI costs $24.

Mr. Petro suggested that it may make sense to put the onus of reporting to a licensing board on the licensee, making it a crime to lie about past records on license renewal forms.

"If they attest under oath that they don't have a record, and they do, then you're got a perjury charge," he said. "A person who failed to disclose a record is now in a position of being charged with a felony."

Contact Jim Provance at: or 614-221-0496.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.