Convicted Priest Now Facing Federal Charge
Convicted Last Year of Charges from Walworth County Incident

By Mike Heine
Walworth County Week
November 2, 2007

The Rev. Donald J. McGuire was charged federally Friday with traveling to another country with a minor for the purpose of committing sex acts, according to court documents filed in the U.S. District Court-Northern District of Illinois in Chicago.

The complaint, filed Thursday and unveiled Friday, says McGuire traveled from Chicago to Switzerland and Austria and sexually molested a boy he took with in December 2000.

The Rev. Donald J. McGuire

The boy told investigators that McGuire--once the confessor to Mother Teresa and spiritual adviser to her Missionaries of Charity, a holy order of nuns--started molesting him 1999, when he was 13 years old. The repeated abuse ended in 2003 when the Chicago Province of the Society of Jesus ordered McGuire to move from the Canisius House, a Jesuit home in Evanston, Ill., to another residence in Chicago.

The assaults happened mostly in the Chicago area, but also during trips to 11 other states and two other countries, the boy told investigators, according to the complaint.

Another boy accused McGuire of molesting him when he was 9 years old in the late 1980s, according to the complaint. The first abuse that boy reported happened when McGuire was hearing his confession. Assaults continued at retreats the two attended together until the boy was 13 or 14, according to the complaint.

Starting in at least 1991, the Jesuits placed special restrictions on McGuire regarding his contact with minors, according to documents the Jesuits provided investigators.

He was ordered repeatedly not to travel or even be alone in any room with any minors, according to the complaint.

A 2002 memo from the Jesuits says six complaints were made about McGuire since 1991 that include having a young man sleep in the same room with him, having a young man wash McGuire's feet while he showered, buying underwear for a boy, talking incessantly about sex and showing a boy pornography, according to the complaint.

Under current federal law, the statute of limitations for sexual abuse of a minor extends to the life of the victim.

McGuire could face 15 years in prison or fines totaling $250,000 if convicted of the federal felony.

The charge comes one day after McGuire failed to win a motion hearing for a retrial in Walworth County.

He was convicted by jury in February 2006 of five state charges of indecent behavior with a child and sentenced to seven years in prison and 20 years probation. The charges stemmed from incidents that occurred at a Fontana residence in the late 1960s with two boys McGuire taught at a Catholic school in Wilmette, Ill.

Should he choose to continue the appeal, McGuire will need to seek a review by the Wisconsin Court of Appeals.

Moments after Walworth County Judge James Carlson denied his motions for a new trial, McGuire was arrested on for probation violations and taken to the Walworth County Jail.

He was transferred to the federal courthouse in Chicago on Friday.

McGuire was also named in a civil suit in Cook County, Ill., filed this summer.

The suit says McGuire started abusing the unnamed plaintiff, then a 13-year-old boy, in 1999 when he stayed with McGuire at the Canisius House. The suit accuses McGuire of molesting the boy in six countries and 12 states, including Wisconsin.

It is unclear if the accuser in the civil case is one of the complainants in the criminal case.

None of the accusers are named.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.