Disgraced Order in Spotlight Again As New Horrors Emerge

By Brian McDonald
Irish Independent
August 15, 2011

FRESH questions have been raised about the extent of child abuse by the Brothers of Charity after the emergence of new evidence of horrific conditions at a home in Cork run by the order.

The Irish Independent has obtained hundreds of pages of documents about the dreadful living conditions of vulnerable children in the care of the congregation at Lota residential facility in Glanmire, Co Cork.

But it is understood that the documents were not made available to the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, which condemned the Brothers of Charity in the 2009 Ryan Report.

It begs serious questions about how many other documents detailing horrific abuse may have slipped under the commission's radar.

Lota has hit the headlines over the past 15 years as a result of shocking sexual abuse perpetrated on dozens of pupils there.

Two men came to typify the brutal exploitation of youngsters in the 1950s and '60s who were entrusted to Lota's care.

Brother Ambrose, also known as James Kelly; and Brother Eunan, also known as James Redmond, were both convicted of a horrific catalogue of abuses against children as young as 10.

Br Ambrose (85) was described as "an evil monster". He later admitted he lost count of the number of youngsters he had abused over more than 20 years. One victim said that they had been subjected to "a reign of sexual terror" in the facility.

But the voices of mentally handicapped youngsters who were resident there have never been heard.

The Ryan Report devoted an entire chapter to the home, but lamented the lack of documentation available about living conditions at the facility.

However, the Irish Independent has now seen almost a decade of daily records kept by staff, outlining the distressing details of life in Lota in the 1970s and '80s.


These reveal institutional abuse as well as a litany of other problems such as vermin, flooding, lack of heating and chronic sickness.

This poses serious questions about the Brothers of Charity's disclosure of documentation to the commission.

In reply to specific questions about the disclosure, the religious order said that the public sessions of the commission were on public record, and it would be inappropriate for them to reveal the nature or detail of private, confidential sessions involving individual applicants.

The commission was unable to explain why the records were apparently not obtained prior to the publication of the Ryan Report.

While institutions such as industrial schools were inspected and the reports left contemporary evidence about diet and living conditions, the Ryan Report said that "no such documentation exists for Lota".

Lota management was contacted last week seeking a response to the content of the records and whether they were disclosed to the commission.

The Congregation of the Brothers of Charity was condemned in the strongest terms in the Ryan Report.

It concluded that the Brothers of Charity had put the reputation of the congregation above the safety and care of vulnerable children.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.