Symphysiotomy Victims Accuse Doctors of Forcing Procedures to Fight Birth Control

By Lyndsey Telford
Irish Independent
June 13, 2012

DOCTORS who forced a brutal medical procedure on pregnant women as recently as the 1990s did it to fight the crime of birth control, it has been claimed.

Victims of symphysiotomy, a practice in which doctors broke women's pelvises to ease childbirth without their consent, have called for Dail support in their bid for justice and compensation.

Campaigner Marie O'Connor accused medical professionals of depriving women of a caesarean section, which they regarded as an artificial form of contraception.

"Doctors were using a scalpel to control women's reproductive ways, stopping them from having a much safer caesarean section," said Ms O'Connor.

"Women can have no more than around four caesareans so doctors effectively saw them as birth control - a way of capping the family number."

Women were left permanently disabled after the medieval procedure of symphysiotomy, which was carried out on some 1,500 Irish women between 1944 and 1992. It has long been banished in the developed world.

Ms O'Connor, spokeswoman for the National Membership Organisation for Survivors of Symphysiotomy, was among some 20 victims in the Dail today.

She addressed the Justice Committee, which was discussing the group's draft bill proposing to amend the statute of limitations, which could lift a bar preventing survivors from seeking redress through the courts.

"These cases go back 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 years," said Ms O'Connor, ahead of the committee meeting.

"These were covert operations. Women were given no information prior to surgery, no information after surgery. These were involuntary operations. There was no informed consent."

Women were left with permanent ailments, including incontinence, chronic pain, prolapsed organs, and neurological and psychological problems.

The symphysiotomy procedure was performed in preference to the safer and more standard caesarean section - as recently as 1994.








Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.