Lawsuit against St. Ignatius Ursuline Academy to Proceed, Lawyers Say

By Kathryn Haake
The Missoulian
January 31, 2014

Bishop George L. Thomas speaks at a news conference Friday Jan. 31, 2014, in Helena, Mont., about steps the Diocese of Helena has taken toward bringing resolution to claims of abuse by filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

Lawyers representing victims of sexual assault that allegedly occurred for more than 40 years at the Ursuline Academy in St. Ignatius are pledging to take the case to trial this summer – even after the Catholic Diocese of Helena filed for bankruptcy Friday to settle a similar lawsuit.

The case against the Ursuline Sisters of the Western Province alleges that 10 nuns sexually abused Native American children at the Catholic boarding school from the 1930s to the 1970s, and lists 37 men and women as the victims of sexual molestation.

The lead counsel in the case, Blaine Tamaki of the Tamaki Law Offices of Yakima, Wash., is hoping to go to trial this summer and expose the alleged abuse to the public.

The 2011 lawsuit was filed in conjunction with another lawsuit against the Diocese of Helena, listing 362 victims as plaintiffs. The diocese filed for bankruptcy and pledged a settlement of $15 million Friday, to be funded by insurance and the diocese’s assets.

As part of the settlement agreement, Helena Bishop George L. Thomas issued an apology Friday, saying no child should be the victim of abuse within the Catholic Church.

“On behalf of the entire Diocese of Helena, I express my profound sorrow and sincere apologies to anyone who was abused by a priest, a sister, or a lay Church worker,” he wrote in a news release.

The diocese also vowed to publish the names of clergy members who have been “credibly” accused and contribute $2.5 million to a fund assisting victims of abuse who come forward in the future.

Diocese spokesperson Dan Bartleson said he didn’t know how many names of former clergy members, many of whom are now deceased, will be published.

“The damage done here is a real and palpable pain,” Bartleson said. “(Thomas) has spent time apologizing and participated in the healing process personally. I don’t think any of us have a sense that the $15 million fixes things.”

Individual disbursement of the $15 million will be decided upon by an independent evaluator. If it were distributed evenly, the amount per plaintiff would be $41,436.46 before attorneys’ fees.

The lead attorney for the plaintiffs against the diocese, Molly Howard, could not be reached for comment.


It is true, Tamaki said, that no amount of money will fix the damage done by clergy members, but he said the partial settlement is a significant step in the healing process.

At a news conference at the Missoula County Courthouse Friday afternoon, Tamaki said the suit is the first of its size that lists the perpetrators of sexual violence as nuns, but he claims reports of sexual abuse by nuns is prevalent nationwide.

“The Ursulines have not taken steps to acknowledge accountability for the harms that they have caused,” he said.

He said the order has been “belligerent” in its failure to acknowledge the “horrors” that took place at the school in St. Ignatius.

The Ursuline’s attorney, Thomas Q. Johnson, could not be reached for comment Friday .

The suit lists Mother Superior Loyola, who Tamaki said was one of the main perpetrators of abuse, Mother Cecelia, Sister John, Sister Marion and other Ursuline nuns.

Tamaki was accompanied by several alleged victims of abuse, who emotionally recalled the years they spent at the school and the abuse they endured at the hands of the Ursuline Sisters and priests from the Oregon Province of the Society of Jesus – commonly called Jesuits – who ran the school.

One such victim, Francis Franny Burke, said when he finally came home from the school, at the age of 8, it was like getting out of prison.

“We were beaten and raped when we were just innocent children,” Burke said. “I relive it. It’s tough to even talk about.”

Burke was joined by Thomas Lozeau Jr., 55, Jackie Trotchie, 67, and Gary Salois, 61, all of whom took turns talking about the alleged sexual abuse and the toll it has taken on their lives.

“They’re having to accept the fact that these things did happen,” Lozeau said. “And as much as they wish it would go away, it’s not going to go away.”








Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.