Bishop Emeritus Donald Trautman says, "there was no cover-up"

Your Erie
May 9, 2018

Bishop Emeritus Donald Trautman, who was head of the Diocese in the dates recently put into question by Attorney General Josh Shapiro, has released a statement.  The statement can be read in full below:

Statement from Bishop Emeritus Donald W. Trautman regarding David Poulson 
First, I wish to express my prayerful support for all victims of sexual abuse. I abhor the evil of sexual abuse.  Secondly, in relation to the arrest of David Poulson, I wish to emphasize there was no  cover-up of sexual abuse.  In 2010, I received a fourth-hand allegation about Poulson’s contact with a young adult man. There was no allegation of physical abuse or of contact with a minor. I contacted diocesan counsel.  I then immediately tried to contact the young man.  There was no response after many attempts of sending letters and telephoning.  From the time of the complaint, until I retired, the diocese received no other complaints about David Poulson.  Thirdly, I devoted a significant part of my tenure as bishop of the Diocese of Erie to the important issue of abuse within the church. 

  • I dismissed 22 priests from ministry due to sexual abuse.
  • I established the independent Diocesan Review Board to help oversee cases and ensured they were properly handled.  
  • I played a large role in the development of our policy and procedures regarding sexual abuse when the US bishops established the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People.  
  • I hired former FBI agents to review our records. 

These facts testify to my vigilance and are a clear indication that I took the problem of sexual abuse seriously and was aggressive in the removal of abusive priests from the service of God’s people. I wish to emphasize again that there was no cover-up. Finally, let us remember the words of St. Boniface that truth can be assaulted, but never defeated.


Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.