Former Passionist Priest, Who Once Served in Pittsburgh, Gets Probation for ‘unnatural Acts’ on a Minor

Associated Press via Tribune-Review
January 6, 2020

BOSTON — A Catholic priest has pleaded guilty to two counts of “unnatural acts” with a minor for accusations of sexual abuse dating back to the 1970s.

James Randall Gillette was sentenced to five years of probation in Suffolk Superior Court in Boston on Jan. 2, according to court records. More serious charges of child rape and indecent assault and battery on a minor were dismissed, but he still has to register as a sex offender.

Gillette is affiliated with Congregation of the Passion of Jesus Christ, a religious order commonly known as the Passionists. Dan Flynn, director of health and social service at Congregation of the Passion of Jesus Christ, said Gillette has not been defrocked but has been on restrictions that ban him from identifying as a priest or serving in church functions since the 1990s. Flynn said Gillette is currently living privately in Massachusetts. He declined to comment further.

Gillette was briefly in Pittsburgh. According to, Gillette served in 1993 and 1994 at St. Paul of the Cross Monastery in the South Side. As a religious order, it is not part of the Diocese of Pittsburgh.

Mitchell Garabedian, a lawyer for Anthony Sgherza, one of Gillette’s two accusers, said Monday that his client feels “validated” by the guilty plea.

Sgherza filed a civil complaint against Gillette in 2014, saying he was repeatedly abused by Gillette starting when he was 9 years old and until he was 13. The case was dismissed after Sgherza reached a settlement with the church, according to Garabedian.

Sgherza, who splits his time between Vermont and New York, now helps other survivors cope with the trauma of abuse, Garabedian added.

Gillette had been assigned to St. Michael’s Parish in Union City, N.J., and St. Gabriel’s Parish in Boston during the time Sgherza was abused. He also worked in parishes in New York City and Mexico City and also served as a missionary in Honduras, according to Garabedian.








Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.