Court Reserves Ruling in Cardinal's Sexual Abuse Case

BBC News
March 12, 2020

Cardinal George Pell is serving a six-year jail sentence in Australia

Australia's top court has reserved its ruling on whether Cardinal George Pell's bid to quash his sexual abuse convictions has been successful.

The ex-Vatican treasurer is serving a six-year jail sentence after a jury found he abused two boys in a Melbourne cathedral in the 1990s.

He is the most senior Catholic globally to be jailed for such crimes, but maintains his innocence.

Pell has challenged the verdict in the High Court of Australia.

During hearings on Wednesday and Thursday, defence and prosecution teams sparred over whether the jury had fairly considered all evidence.

The seven appeal judges then reserved their decision until a later date. They did not specify when.

The long-running case has rocked the Catholic Church, where Pell had been one of the Pope's most senior advisers.

The Vatican has been under pressure to defrock the cleric, but it has maintained he deserves a full and fair legal process.

What was the original guilty finding?

In December 2018, a jury unanimously found Pell guilty of sexually abusing two 13-year-old choir boys in private rooms in St Patrick's Cathedral. Pell was archbishop of Melbourne at the time.

The convictions included one count of sexual penetration and four counts of committing indecent acts.

Pell's trial heard testimony from the only surviving victim. The abuse was not witnessed by anyone else, but the trial also heard evidence from dozens of churchgoers.

In sentencing Pell in 2019, Judge Peter Kidd said the cleric had committed "a brazen and forcible sexual attack on the two victims".

How did Pell challenge?

His central argument was that the jury and previous appeal court relied too heavily on evidence from the victim who testified.

His lawyers described that victim's testimony as "compelling" but argue it was uncorroborated. They asserted the jury did not properly consider other evidence.

"No matter how favourable a view was taken of the complainant, it was not open to the jury, acting rationally, to conclude that the prosecution had eliminated all reasonable doubt," his lawyers argued.

Prosecutors rejected these assertions.

When will there be a decision?

It's unclear, but it does not seem imminent. The judges have asked the legal teams to make additional written submissions in the coming week.

Local media reported it could even take months.

Who is George Pell?

Pell was among the highest-ranking figures in the Church's global hierarchy.

Made a cardinal in 2003, he was summoned to Rome in 2014 to help clean up the Vatican's finances.

Pope John Paul II appointed Pell a cardinal in 2003

He forged a reputation as a disciplined Church leader who held strict conservative views against same-sex marriage, abortion and contraception.

In Australia he circulated among the political elite, and even after his conviction he received public statements of support from two former prime ministers.








Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.