Bishop Accountability


Accused Priests (Including Deacons): 63
Total Priests and Deacons: 3,267
Victims: 116
Cost: $1,377,000 (number from press release; Grossman number is slightly less)
Sources of Funds: $601,500 from insurers; $775,500 from a self-insurance fund

See Cathy Lynn Grossman, Survey: More Clergy Abuse Cases Than Previously Thought (2/10/04) with AP table of data for 80 dioceses.

See press release Cardinal Maida Reports.

See the Dallas Morning News database entry on Cardinal Adam Maida. The June 2002 database examined the records of bishops and identified those who had allowed accused priests to continue working or had otherwise protected priests accused of sexual abuse. The database is relevant to the bishops' "Nature and Scope" study because the bishops who prepared the surveys for the study are in many cases responsible for the "scope" of the problem.

Maida: 116 victims of sex abuse since 1950

By Jim Schaefer 313-223-4542 or
Detroit Free Press
February 5, 2004

An internal review of the Detroit Catholic Archdiocese has found 63 clergy were credibly accused of sexually abusing 116 victims since 1950, Cardinal Adam Maida said Thursday.

Church officials said the number of clerics represented about 2 percent of the 3,267 priests and deacons known to have served in the archdiocese during that time.

Maida said at a news conference that he believed the vast majority of priests served faithfully during the studied period, but that even one case of abuse was too many.

``I again offer my apologies to those who have been victimized for our failures to address this matter appropriately over the years,'' Maida said. ``I call on my fellow priests, all my brothers and sisters in the archdiocese, to join me in prayer and penance for our past failures, for the grace and determination to continue our efforts to heal and to protect.''

The review represented the first comprehensive and public effort within the archdiocese to report on the history of sexual abuse in its ranks. The archdiocese culled the information as part of a larger national study on accused priests and their victims, the results of which are to be announced Feb. 27.

Detroit church officials also disclosed that the archdiocese spent nearly $1.4 million over those years for counseling and settlements with victims. Outside insurance carriers paid a little more than $600,000 of those costs, officials said.

The archdiocese reported that of the 63 accused clergy, 42 are archdiocesan priests (15 of whom are dead), 18 are members of religious orders and two are deacons (one of whom is dead).

Maida said that all living clergy with credible allegations against them have been removed from public ministry.

Also, the arcdiocese turned over all allegations to prosecutors in the six counties of the archdiocese.

Four men who worked as priests in Wayne County were convicted in 2002 and 2003 for abuse that happened long ago. In January, the Vatican also laicized a Detroit area priest, Joseph Sito, who was convicted of assaulting a boy in 1999.

State dioceses report abuses by 89 priests
Dioceses announce sexual abuse cases against minors before national report's release

Associated Press, carried in the Holland Sentinel
February 15, 2004

DETROIT (AP) -- Four of Michigan's Roman Catholic dioceses, representing more than 500 parishes and more than 1.8 million registered Catholics, have released reports of known sexual abuse by clergy.

Numbers have been released from the dioceses of Grand Rapids and Kalamazoo in western Michigan, the Diocese of Marquette in and the Upper Peninsula and the Archdiocese of Detroit in the southeastern part of the state.

Catholic churches in Allegan County are part of the Kalamazoo Diocese. Those in Ottawa County are in the Grand Rapids Diocese.

The reports from individual dioceses have trickled out ahead of a national report on sexual abuse of minors commissioned by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops to be released Feb. 27.

A total of 89 priests from the four dioceses have faced credible accusations of sexual misconduct since 1950, according to the reports released since the beginning of the year.

The Lansing and Saginaw dioceses are expected to release their reports to the public prior the national report, but the Gaylord Diocese and the Eparchy of St. Thomas the Apostle are waiting for the national disclosure. An eparchy is a geographic district for Catholics who accept the authority of the pope, but follow different rituals.

The amount of detail in the reports already released varied by diocese; some did not say how many minors were abused, others didn't say how much money was paid out to victims.

Those details, however, should be available in the national report.

Bishop James A. Murray of the Diocese of Kalamazoo apologized to victims in a letter published in the February edition of The Good News, the diocesan newspaper.

"I am deeply sorry for, and ashamed of, what was done to you," he said. "While no human can see perfectly into the psyche of another, I can only assure you that no priest, religious, volunteer or employee known to have committed sexual abuse has been allowed to continue in public ministry."

The Diocese of Kalamazoo, with 46 parishes serving 118,452 registered Catholics, is one of the newer dioceses in Michigan. Numbers released this week show two priests with "credible" accusations against them since the diocese's creation in 1971. Murray's letter said the diocese had not paid any legal damages, but had spent $5,000 on counseling assistance for families.

The Diocese of Marquette, with 74 parishes serving 69,500 registered Catholics, in January reported that 16 priests out of 534 serving the parish had credible allegations made against them by 34 victims since 1950.

The Diocese of Grand Rapids, consisting of 90 parishes and 162,670 registered Catholics, reported eight priests abusing 35 victims since 1950. One priest abused 14 minors and another abused nine, according to numbers released in January.

Payouts from the latter two were not available.

The Archdiocese of Detroit, which disclosed its numbers Feb. 5, had accusations leveled against 63 of the archdiocese's priests and deacons since 1950. Cardinal Adam Maida has said the archdiocese paid nearly $1.38 million in settlements and counseling to 116 victims.

Victims of priest abuse, represented by the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, have looked askance at these reports.

For one thing, they don't name the priests, and for another, they rely entirely on the willingness of bishops to disclose the abuses -- the very thing that put the Catholic Church in the situation of paying out millions in damages from victim lawsuits.

Most dioceses already have implemented training programs and new abuse reporting methods to help head-off further problems.




Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.