UNITED STATES
Christian Catholicism
Jerry Slevin
As HBO airs the revealing documentary, “Mea Maxima Culpa”, all are strongly reminded that child endangerment is immoral and usually illegal. Is child endangerment, however, always “evil” for the Pope, or only if it is allegedly done by a constant USA political opponent? The Pope’s record here is most troubling.
The Pope, reportedly acting through Los Angeles Archbishop Gomez, for the first time very publicy shamed a Cardinal, Mahony, even as “evil” for alleged child endangerment misconduct. The chosen term was an ontological one, “evil”, even “brutal”, not the usual and evasive papal theological or psychological euphemisms of “sinful” or “bad judgment”. To the likely dismay of Cardinal Mahony and his criminal lawyers, LA law enforcement officials have already noticed this unprecedented papal green light and have commenced new criminal investigations, as well they should. Better late than never. No offer of “Cardinal Law-style” Vatican immunity is apparently expected for Mahony.
Cardinal Mahony may well be asking himself, why me? Why now? After all, the Pope has already, in effect, previously given “free passes” without public shaming to many Catholic hierarchs who reportedly seriously mishandled many priest child sexual abuse cases, including Cardinals Law, Bevilacqua, Brady, Rigali, Egan, Pell, et al. The Pope has not really even similarly shamed hierarchs who admitted to actually committing child endangerment related crimes, for example, in Kansas City (Finn), Palm Beach (Symons), Belgium (Vangheluwe) and Norway (Georg Mueller). Moreover, the Pope even earlier also gave “free passes” to his brother and himself on reported failures to curtail child abuse in Munich and Regensburg and to Vienna’s Cardinal Groer for reportedly abusing numerous young seminarians. Cardinal Schoenborn blamed the last failure on Cardinal Sodano, who reportedly got an apology from Schoenborn.
Of course, significantly, the Pope and his imminent hand-picked successor could still turn on and shame any of these living hierarchs, as the Pope just did to the USA’s leading clerical “liberal Democrat”, Mahoney. This prospect likely is giving some hierarchs a few sleepless nights, especially voting Cardinals thinking about the next papal election expected in the near term. These Cardinals may be waiting to see what Mahony does, since Mahony is considered by some to be scrappy, seasoned and shrewd.
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.