CINCINNATI (OH)
Cincinnati Enquirer
February 9, 2021
By Jack Greiner
Former altar boy Kevin DiMauro recently saw a New York state appellate court affirm the dismissal of his libel suit against a Staten Island newspaper.
DiMauro claimed that the Staten Island Advance identified DiMauro as a victim of sexual abuse by a Catholic priest. DiMauro’s case failed, however, because he couldn’t demonstrate that he was the subject of the reporting.
In October 2018 the Advance published an article reporting that allegations of sexual abuse against a pastor at Blessed Sacrament Roman Catholic Church had been substantiated.
In the print version of the article, between the headline “Longtime pastor ‘will never serve as a priest again’” and the subheading “Archdiocese affirms sex-abuse allegations against former Blessed Sacrament monsignor,” the Advance included a photograph from 2000 depicting the pastor at issue, two other priests, and three children—including DiMauro, walking in a church processional, with several parishioners in the background.
The caption to the photograph read, “Monsignor Francis Boyle, seen here at Blessed Sacrament Roman Catholic Church in West Brighton in 2000, faces sex-abuse allegations brought through the Archdiocese’s Independent Reconciliation Program.”
In granting the Advance’s motion to dismiss, the court ruled that DiMauro couldn’t establish that the article was “of and concerning” him. In a libel case, the plaintiff has to establish that the article is of and concerning him. That means the plaintiff must “prove that the statement referred to them and that a person hearing or reading the statement reasonably could have interpreted it as such.” DiMauro argued that by including the photo that depicted him in the procession with the abusive priest, the article sufficiently identified him as one of the victims.
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.