NEW YORK (NY)
Crain's New York Business [New York, NY]
November 19, 2026
By Maya King and Jeffery C. Mays
The New York Archdiocese recently agreed to pay more than $800 million to 1,300 people who say they were sexually abused by clergy.
The Archdiocese of New York will mortgage churches and other properties at six Manhattan parishes to help fund its $800 million settlement with the 1,300 people who said they were sexually abused by its clergy and lay leaders.
The parish properties will serve as collateral for $160 million in loans secured through the six mortgages, according to city records. The agreement was signed by Bishop Edmund Whalen, the vicar general of the Archdiocese of New York.
Joseph Zwilling, a spokesman for the archdiocese, confirmed that the six properties were mortgaged to fund the settlement. He pointed to past comments from Archbishop Ronald Hicks, who said that money for the settlement would come from “various sources” across the archdiocese.
“This is one of those sources,” he said.
Most of the properties being mortgaged are not in active parishes. The mortgages include not only the church structures but the parking lots, schools and other buildings that the parish encompasses.
The parishes, which include the Roman Catholic Church of St. Brigid and St. Emeric on Avenue B in the East Village; Our Lady of Guadalupe on West 14th Street; and the Church of St. Veronica on Christopher Street in the West Village are all in Manhattan, most in affluent neighborhoods.
One parish, the Church of St. Michael on West 34th Street near Pennsylvania Station and Hudson Yards, was mortgaged for $58.5 million.
A law firm representing the lender, Madison Investor I, LLC, did not respond to a request for comment.
The archdiocese has already sold much of its portfolio of valuable Manhattan properties to fund the settlement, one of the largest in church history. Previously, the archdiocese sold the land it owns beneath the Palace Hotel in Midtown Manhattan and its First Avenue headquarters while cutting its operating budget by 10 percent. Archdiocese leaders have also asked parishes to contribute to the settlement.
The mortgages were first reported by the real estate news outlet Pincus Co.
Under the terms of the settlement, the archdiocese must make a payment of $638.75 million immediately into a trust. The balance must be deposited next year.
Jeff Herman, whose law firm represents 260 plaintiffs, said it was only appropriate for the archdiocese to use its valuable properties to fund the settlement.
“They have a lot of real estate, and they should either mortgage it or sell it to compensate these victims,” Mr. Herman said in an interview. “The church should not be able to walk away and feel nothing because my clients, who were victimized by the church, have been feeling this all their lives.”
The plaintiffs in the lawsuit have the option of taking a $250,000 quick payout, and a third have agreed to do so, according to their attorneys. The remainder could receive a larger payment after an examination of the extent of the abuse they suffered.
The mortgage comes as a handful of churches and schools in the archdiocese have been closed or may soon close their doors. In early November, the pastor and principal of the Epiphany School informed parents that the archdiocese would not renew its lease beyond June 2028, according to an email to parents.
The settlement has left other parishes concerned about their future. Archbishop Hicks has sought to address these concerns in a letter to parishioners of the archdiocese after the settlement became final. Some churchgoers, he said, “may be wondering what impact this settlement will have on your parish.”
“Life in your parish should continue uninterrupted,” he added.
Maya King is a Times reporter who writes about the intersection of politics, religion and ritual in New York City.
Jeffery C. Mays is a Times reporter covering politics with a focus on New York City Hall.
