Jury awards $14.3 million to victim of East Bay priest

OAKLAND (CA)
San Francisco Chronicle [San Francisco CA]

November 17, 2026

By Aldo Toledo

An Alameda County jury on Tuesday awarded $14.3 million in damages to a person who was allegedly sexually abused in the 1970s by an East Bay Catholic priest, according to the survivor’s attorneys. 

The jury’s decision is the second time jurors have ordered the Diocese of Oakland to pay out a multimillion-dollar settlement related to allegations against Father Stephen Kiesle. Jurors in April awarded $16 million to another survivor for past and future pain and suffering.

Tuesday’s decision is related to a lawsuit against the East Bay diocese filed under the 2020 California Child Victims Act, which made it easier to bring litigation in old child sexual assault claims.

“This is a victory for truth, courage and accountability,” Jeff Anderson, an attorney for the victim, said. “Survivors who were silenced by the Catholic Bishop of Oakland are seeing continued breakthroughs in their fight for justice.”

The civil case alleges that Kiesle, a convicted child predator who was removed from the priesthood in 1987, abused a child. Kiesle wasn’t defrocked until a decade after he was arrested on suspicion of molesting children. 

Ordained in 1972, Kiesle has been accused of abusing at least 15 children and is named in 60 lawsuits filed under the 2020 California law, according to Anderson & Associates.

The Diocese of Oakland filed for bankruptcy in 2023 while facing more than 330 lawsuits alleging priests sexually abused children over decades. In 2005, the diocese,which includes Contra Costa County, reached a $56 million settlement with 56 survivors of clergy sexual abuse.

In 2024, Bishop Michael Barber issued a public apology to the survivors of child sexual abuse in the Oakland Diocese, saying at the time: “I see the pain and destruction that was perpetrated by representatives of the Church.”

The diocese said in a statement Wednesday that while they “acknowledge the jury’s verdict, the Oakland Diocese is committed to providing fair and just compensation to all victims/survivors, and continues to work towards that goal in the bankruptcy process.”

The Oakland Diocese is one of many dioceses across the U.S. that have filed for bankruptcy while facing potential hefty settlements for alleged abuses by clergy dating back decades.

Kiesle had previously worked in parishes around the East Bay, including at St. Joseph’s in Pinole, Our Lady of Rosary in Union City and St. Columba’s in Oakland. He was arrested in 1978 for molesting two boys at his parish, allegedly tying them up to abuse them. He received counseling and three years of probation for the alleged abuse.

He was later asked to leave the priesthood in 1981, and the Vatican approved his defrocking in 1987. Kiesle then worked as a youth minister in Pinole for many years until 2002, when he was charged with molesting five children in the 1960s and 70s while he was a priest in Fremont. 

But the charges were dropped because the statute of limitations had passed. 

Two years later, Kiesle pleaded no contest to abusing a young girl at his home in Truckee in 1995, and he was sentenced to six years in prison. He was released in 2010. 

After his release, Kiesle moved into the gated retirement community of Rossmoor near Walnut Creek, where he struck and killed a 64-year-old pedestrian in a drunken driving incident in 2022.

He was found guilty of gross vehicular manslaughter. He is now serving a six-year sentence at the California Medical Facility in Vacaville. 

He is expected to be eligible for parole in February 2028.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/oakland-diocese-verdict-22536797.php