N.J. pastor’s 3 daughters accuse him of abuse, say church kept it quiet for years

MOUNT LAUREL (NJ)
NJ.com [Iselin, NJ]

November 18, 2026

By Gavin Schweiger

The middle-age man called the girl his “lover.”

She called him Dad.

And most everyone else called him Pastor Mark.

For decades, Mark Willey was the heart of Fellowship Community Church. A charismatic preacher using his position at the pulpit in Mount Laurel to lead 1,000 loyal followers, many looked to him as a moral and spiritual North Star. But three of his now adult daughters say life behind the closed doors of the Willey home was anything but godly.

“We had no idea what was predatory,” said one of the sisters, who calls herself Daughter 2 in online posts about her family. “We had no idea what was appropriate.”

Mark Willey declined to comment. But in communications to his congregation obtained by NJ.com, Willey denies his daughters’ claims and insists he did his best to parent his children.

Some of them tell a different story. Two of the Willey daughters described to NJ.com an insular upbringing scarred by strict religious doctrines and behavior they say they didn’t realize was abuse. So much of what they endured, they claimed, was sexually inappropriate and physically and emotionally abusive at best, and they believe criminal at its worst.

One of Willey’s daughters, in a police report filed in 2019, described being assaulted by her father from when she was about 2 years old to 15. “The end point of the sexual assaults,” the report reads, “was…when she began to get her period.”

Her sisters described spending a lot of time alone with their dad, including times they had “purity talks.” Willey made each sign a contract saying no boy would ever touch them, unless their dad gave approval first, the daughters claimed.

One of them said even as a young child, she knew which of her body parts her dad found attractive. Her sister alleged Willey physically abused her for discipline, including “humiliation and degradation and touching of intimate areas.”

Six-and-a-half years ago, the daughter’s police report prompted an investigation by the Burlington County Prosecutor’s Office. At the time, two of her sisters said they were reluctant to make formal statements to authorities. After nine months, the case was closed, citing insufficient evidence.

But this spring, the same two sisters, using the online monikers Daughter 2 and Daughter 3, went public. They posted their sister’s police report on Reddit and Substack, a popular content creation platform. They wrote heart-wrenching essays about their lives growing up in the church, their own allegations against their dad, and the anger they feel toward the church leadership surrounding Fellowship’s founding pastor. When those leaders learned of the police report in 2019, they effectively swept it under the rug, the two daughters claimed. After a brief hiatus during the investigation, Pastor Mark was back on stage, preaching to the faithful – many of whom they say had never heard a word about the daughter’s claims.

In the years since, Daughters 2 and 3 have left the church, they said. They’ve gone to therapy. They’ve confronted their pasts. And this year, they went to the Burlington County Prosecutor, urging her to reopen the case against their dad.

In a statement to NJ.com, Prosecutor LaChia L. Bradshaw confirmed the investigation has been reopened recently “to consider additional information that was brought to our attention.”

“To date, no final decision has been made on how we will proceed with this case,” Bradshaw said. To respect privacy, she continued, she could not discuss any details of the investigation.

Willey, now 72, had already stepped back from daily duties at the church when the women’s claims went up. He had been a pastor emeritus since 2024, giving his last sermon at the church in May before the online posts. About a month after the allegations went live, the church’s then board chairman, Jon Sharp, announced that Willey retired from Fellowship Community Church, ending his 45-year career.

“To be very clear, Pastor Mark made this decision not as an act of any admission, but because he believes it’s time for his full retirement and so that this situation does not distract from the work God has called FCC to do as a community of hope in Christ,” Sharp said in June.

In response to a request for an interview, current lead pastor Mike Candy sent NJ.com a recording of an event held in August where church leaders made statements answering congregants’ pre-submitted questions about the scandal. At the event, Candy said Fellowship held a “careful” stance on the allegations.

“It would be wrong for us to make definitive conclusions when we don’t have enough information to do that,” Candy said. “It would also be inappropriate to publicly discuss their stories or speak for them.”

The church denied comment beyond the video.

Reached by phone, Willey declined to talk. The preacher has no criminal record.

But Willey and his wife, Marian denied their daughters’ allegations in a joint private letter to friends and congregants.

In it, Willey wrote he had no “regrets or shame in the area of my moral life.”

“I have never behaved improperly to another woman, never touched another person (woman, man, child) in a sexual way other than my wife.”

‘Separate fronts’

Its beginnings were very modest.

Mark Willey started Fellowship Community Church — called Fellowship Baptist Church until 2012 — as a Bible study in his Marlton living room. He gained a small following, and moved to preach in rented space at Lenape High School in 1981.

As attendance grew, so did the space. In 1985, Mark and Marian Willey built the nearby Mount Laurel gym to establish the church. In 2001, they expanded the building to fit their membership that grew into the hundreds, according to a Courier Post article from the time. There is also a satellite campus in Collingswood which opened in 2009 and serves around 150 weekly congregants.

The Mount Laurel church currently has around 1,000 weekly worshippers — about half the size of what is considered a megachurch — attending two Sunday services, according to Fellowship’s website. Church representatives did not answer NJ.com’s questions about its current membership, and financial records are not publicly available.

While large, the church maintains a reasonably quiet presence in Mount Laurel — a large town with no main street and several worship houses catering to different religions and Christian denominations. In New Jersey – a state that is about a third Catholic – evangelical protestant Christians, including Baptist and nondenominational faiths, make up a slim 9% of the state’s religions, according to a 2025 Pew Research Center report.

One annual event, however, has helped put Fellowship Community Church on the South Jersey map. For over 30 years, it’s hosted a free “Living Nativity” performance in Mount Laurel each December touting hundreds of cast and crew. According to a 1997 Courier Post article, the event saw around 8,000 people attend in its early years. It continues to be a large draw.

For some, the church is much more than a once-a-week stop. Along with traditional services, it hosts various ministries from youth to adult groups, small groups like Bible studies and recovery programs, and missions spanning places from Brazil to Papua New Guinea.

Willey was a board member for the Association of Baptists for World Evangelism from around 2009 to 2019, according to his LinkedIn page and archives of the ABWE website. He spoke at engagements including recent ones at Clarks Summit University in Pennsylvania in 2022, at a conference at the Northeast Fellowship in March 2025 and as recently as December 2025 in Brazil.

Former church members recalled Willey as a man with integrity and passion on stage. Some said that off-stage he was approachable.

Ed Cyzewski, 47, previously had Willey as a mentor. He remembered Willey as “very funny, very witty,” and “very patient and listening” even when disagreeing. But, he said, those experiences don’t make him automatically doubt Willey’s daughters.

“It’s believable because I know that people who are extremely talented can give off two separate fronts,” Cyzewski said.

Others alleged they saw the other side.

Joy Reamer, 43, a church staff member from 2017 until the end of 2020, remembered Willey as “very controlling” and prone to anger.

“If you are not on staff, you’ll never see this side,” Reamer said. “But it’s there.”

The allegations

While growing the church, Mark and Marian Willey were raising nine children, eight of whom survived into adulthood. In 1997, the couple’s youngest son, Seth, died in a drowning accident at 19 months old. Reeling from the tragedy meant “faith-based and biblical” counseling, they wrote in the letter they penned to friends and followers.

Coming from small families themselves and dealing with their son’s death, they wrote that the responsibilities of caring for their children and for the church became difficult.

“We had children that had to step in to the role of parenting, because of our own small system of support,” they wrote.

His daughters say each child got a different version of their father.

“We did not experience the same dad,” Daughter 2 said. “Mine was angry and violent.

“I was labeled a bad kid, but never broke a rule, not a single one,” she added. But it was because I would question, there were times when I would question when another sibling was getting punished.”

He would hit her in intimate places, sometimes in front of others, and threaten nude beatings, she said.

Daughter 3 said she was treated more like a spouse than a daughter, which she said felt “weird” from a young age.

“Ever since I was 5, my father leaned on me emotionally and physically to take care of him,” she wrote. “He confided in me like I was a romantic partner.”

The sisters say their upbringing created a perfect environment for the inappropriate treatment.

According to Mark and Marian Willey’s letter, the children were homeschooled. For five years they followed the Advance Training Institute model, a homeschooling curriculum by Bill Gothard.

Gothard is the founder of the Institute of Basic Life Principles, an organization made famous by its own scandals and its well-known followers, the Duggars of reality TV’s “19 Kids and Counting.” He resigned from IBLP after being placed on administrative leave in 2014 amid multiple sexual harassment allegations.

Neither Mark, Marian, nor other church leaders have explicitly stated following IBLP practices, which include controversial fundamentalist beliefs, outside of homeschooling. But the daughters and other former church members who spoke to NJ.com say their leadership’s culture was heavily influenced by Gothard’s ideas for years in the 1990s — including having many children as well as strict purity and modesty, especially for women.

Members and families who were heavily involved in the church may have been influenced similarly by Gothard’s ideas, but experiences varied.

“You have a spectrum of people who believe (for example) that drums were evil, and you have other people who were, like, listening to secular music,” Cyzewski said of his experience in the church at the time.

Daughters 2 and 3 said it all left them without sex education and heavily influenced by their father’s religious beliefs.

“We didn’t know what normal was,” Daughter 2 said.

The two women said of all their siblings, Daughter 1, who filed the police report in 2019, was their dad’s favorite.

“We knew that she was special to him and that they spent a lot of alone time together,” Daughter 2 said.

Though both daughters said they weren’t aware of each others’ individual experiences with their dad, “I knew she was alone with him the most,” Daughter 2 said.

Her sisters said Daughter 1 started distancing herself from them and other family members in 2014 and cut ties entirely in following years. She has not spoken to them since, the sisters said, and their attempts to reach her have not been successful. She did not respond to multiple attempts from NJ.com to contact her, including a certified letter.

Reverberating through the church

The daughters’ posts are clear: As much as there’s good in the church, they cannot forgive its leadership for the secrets they knew.

After the investigation started in 2019, Willey brought the news to the other church pastors, including his son, Ben Willey, board members have said.

Mark Walton, a board member at the time, said the board took the allegations seriously but did not independently investigate Daughter 1’s claims, concerned about an investigation further disturbing the family, and seeming biased in favor of Willey.

The board announced the allegations to members that attended its annual business meeting on Zoom. Reamer, on staff at the time, said that these meetings are not well attended, as not all congregants are members, and not all members attend the meetings.

The main body of congregants did not hear about the allegations officially, which Walton said was to protect the confidential nature of the investigation, and because it would not have been appropriate for the church to disclose.

Of the former churchgoers who spoke to NJ.com other than Reamer, some heard about the allegations, while others didn’t know until the Reddit post this year.

As the investigation went on in 2019, Willey took a short leave of absence. Between June 16 and Sept. 29, 2019, he did not preach at Sunday services, according to archived sermons.

At the time, Daughter 2 said she didn’t speak up for her estranged sister, partially because of the impact she saw the allegations had on her family. Daughters 2 and 3 watched as the investigation ended, their father returned to preaching, and their sister was “smeared” in hushed conversations in some corners of the community, they said.

Daughters 2 and 3 both said they’ve never spoken to their sister about why she filed the police report. Still, they said she inspired them in part to come forward this year.

“I think we both credit our sister, and she was destroyed,” Daughter 2 said of her sister’s reputation. “Destroyed by this f—— church.”

It took Daughter 2 about a year to craft the language in the letter that she eventually posted on Substack. She sent it to church leadership, too. In it, and in her subsequent writings, she accused the church of protecting Willey and not doing enough to handle the allegations.

“I loved this church, but you have failed to respond to the many warning signs you received about the problems within the Mark Willey family,” she wrote. “The board, pastoral staff, and elders have consistently turned a blind eye to the pain, secrets, lies, and deception in order to preserve the influence of a popular and charismatic speaker who abused and neglected his family.”

Since the letters were posted in May, many have showed support for the daughters online — including around a dozen people who have added to the Substack page. It now has more than 780 subscribers, Daughter 2 said.

Others have denounced the posts and supported Willey and the church.

Though they had previously left the church, going public has been anything but easy, Daughters 2 and 3 said.

“Even friends who knew about this and supported us going public have since changed their mind,” Daughter 2 said. “It’s intense.”

The church’s first response to the daughters’ Substack was a statement to the congregation in June by now-former board chairman Sharp.

“As I’ve reflected over the past several weeks, God continually reminded me that when his kingdom is thriving, the enemy is lurking, and we must draw on his strength,” Sharp said in the statement.

The address drew criticism, with some saying he suggested Willey’s accusing daughters were enemies of the church. He later apologized “for the words that hurt people” in a statement to congregants.

Sharp did not answer requests for comment.

Since June, Sharp; Mike Candy, the current lead pastor; Willey’s preacher son, Ben and others have made statements in response, culminating with an event in August where they answered others congregants’ questions.

The church also created a new “listening team,” a volunteer group of licensed psychologists and counselors “intentionally not tied in any way to our church leadership, staff, or church board.” The chairman of the listening team is a former Army chaplain and licensed social worker, Candy said in a statement.

Daughters 2 and 3 have stopped posting on the Substack, now called Children of Fellowship. But it lives on through other members, who have continued to write of their experiences in the church.

https://www.nj.com/burlington/2026/11/nj-pastors-3-daughters-accuse-him-of-abuse-say-church-kept-it-quiet-for-years.html