Pedophile priest released from prison, living in facility tied to the diocese

NEW IBERIA (LA)
Arcadian News First [Lafayette, LA]

November 17, 2026

By Jim Hummel

Father Michael Guidry has served his seven-year prison sentence for molesting a teenage boy. Guidry, 83, has now registered as a sex offender in Iberia Parish, where he’s living in a nursing home with ties to the Diocese of Lafayette.

According to that sex offender registry, Guidry’s new home is the Consolata Rehab and Wellness Center on the Teche. Records show the Diocese of Lafayette maintains a mortgage interest in the property; it’s owned by Consolata Nursing Home Incorporated, which is registered to the Diocese of Lafayette. ANF Investigates has also learned the facility is home to at least five retired priests from the diocese.

Guidry’s case– through his arrest, trial, conviction, and now release– has continued to raise concerns about the church’s handling of the clergy sex abuse crisis.

Guidry molested the son of a deacon he served alongside at St. Peter Catholic Church in Morrow. The victim’s father, Scott Peyton, later resigned from the diaconate and left the church, citing the clergy sex abuse crisis. Peyton made international headlines when he was excommunicated by Lafayette Bishop J. Douglas Deshotel. The Vatican recently upheld Peyton’s excommunication, citing public statements he made about joining an Anglican church.

While Guidry was permanently removed from ministry, the Diocese of Lafayette has never responded to inquiries if he was excommunicated or defrocked. Dawn Eden Goldstein, a canon lawyer for the Peyton family, recently claimed in an interview on Acadiana News First that Bishop Deshotel allowed Guidry to remain in the priesthood out of compassion for his age. The diocese did not respond to requests for comment on that claim.

“…it was extremely important to Bishop Deshotel that Guidry remain in the priesthood, precisely for this reason: so Deshotel could assure the diocese’s priests that the diocese will care for them in their old age just as it cares for Guidry,” said Goldstein in a statement to ANF Investigates. “…this is what it has come down to—that the diocese under Bishop Deshotel is more concerned to prove its fidelity to priests than to show the faithful that it has no place for sex abusers—[it] says everything about how little the Diocese of Lafayette has learned in the forty years since Gilbert Gauthe’s first conviction.”

We reached out to the Diocese about Guidry’s living arrangements, and they declined comment.

https://www.acadiananewsfirst.com/2026/11/17/pedophile-priest-released-prison-living-facility-tied-diocese/