ABUSE TRACKER

Into Account is honored to have as colleagues, and to advocate for, a number of Plain and Amish people. And we’re especially honored to publish a Plain survivor’s story.

Plain survivors face many barriers, including people from outside their context claiming expertise and making recommendations on how to interact with survivors and their families.

Intro to Fannie Masts’s Story, Dr. Stephanie Krehbiel

In 2021, Child Welfare Journal published an article entitled “Understanding and Partnering with Amish Communities to Keep Children Safe.” The author, Dr. Jeanette Harder, writes, “Due to cultural expectations, the Amish are not often in the practice of critiquing or analyzing their own thoughts or behaviors, or thinking abstractly.”

I read that sentence, and thought of the many formerly Amish and Plain Mennonite survivors I’ve worked with, some of them as fellow advocates and collaborators, for the past four years. Their ability to think critically, to self-reflect, to…

View Cache

Oliver* will never forget the day his life changed forever.

It was the day a Catholic priest — a man he saw as God — abused his trust and allegedly set him on a path towards “shame, substance abuse and profound mental illness”, the Supreme Court of Melbourne heard.

“I was dead. He murdered me,” Oliver told the court.

“He murdered that boy, that little boy, that I used to be.”

In 1968, Oliver was sexually assaultedby Desmond Gannon — now known to be a notorious paedophile priest.

Gannon was convicted and sent to jail for Oliver’s abuse in 2009. 

Now Oliver is suing the Archdiocese of Melbourne,  arguing it breached its duty of careand knew — or ought to have known — that Gannon might sexually abuse him.

It is the first time in its 150-year-plus history than an abuse survivor has taken the Archdiocese to trial.

‘I’ve never been the same’

Oliver and his “very religious” family…

View Cache

Former residents of the Esther Foundation have alleged they were sexually abused and harassed by an employee at the facility.

This is part 13 in a series. For the rest of the series, go here.

Note: this article contains descriptions of child sexual abuse.

Serious allegations have emerged of the sexual abuse and sexual harassment of teenage girls at the Pentecostal-linked Esther Foundation. The new allegations have emerged in the wake of a weeks-long investigation by Crikey and raise questions about how much, if any, information was passed to police and child protection authorities at the time.

The Morrison government made a $4 million grant to the foundation before the 2019 election, with the prime minister making a personal visit to the Perth-based rehab facility. As a Crikey investigation has revealed, Esther has a history of using extreme religious practices as “treatment” for girls with addiction and mental health problems.

One former resident has given Crikey a…

View Cache

Document trying to paint jailed ex-priest Richard Daschbach in favorable light ‘was not meant to be made public’

A Timor-Leste court has acquitted a priest and several of his staff over writing a report in favor of a defrocked priest jailed for sexually abusing young girls.

Father Herminio Fatima Goncalves, former chairman of the Justice and Peace Commission of Dili Archdiocese, and three of his staff were on trial after being accused of authoring the controversial report that made wild and false allegations against police prosecutors, journalists and NGOs involved in the prosecution of Richard Daschbach.

However, Dili District Court acquitted all four on March 4, ruling the report “was only for internal purposes and was not published.”

Judge Evangelinho Belo said they had not violated Article 291 of the country’s Criminal Code on judicial confidentiality, which carries a penalty of up to four years in prison. Prosecutors had…

View Cache

The Philippines has raised the age of sexual consent to 16 after amending a near century-old law, a move child rights activists said Monday would help protect youngsters from rape and abuse.

The Catholic-majority nation had one of the lowest ages of consent in the world, allowing adults to have sex with children as young as 12 if they agreed.

Under the revised law signed by President Rodrigo Duterte on Friday and made public Monday, sex with a person under 16 will be illegal and carry a maximum penalty of 40 years in jail.  

Exceptions will be made for teenage couples so long as their age difference does not exceed three years and the sex is consensual.

“Having this law is a very good protective instrument for our children from sexual violence, whether or not it starts online or whether or not it also starts in…

View Cache

There is an extraordinary exhibit at the Vermont History Museum, one that I encourage you to visit. It will be there until July 30. It tells the disturbing story of St. Joseph’s Orphanage in Burlington, Vermont, and the children who were abused there.   

When the documented torture and abuse of children was taking place at St. Joseph’s Orphanage from the 1940s until it closed in 1974, most Vermonters were unaware of what was happening within those walls. Many who may have had concerns or suspicions likely felt uncomfortable questioning the Catholic Diocese, an authority that is not easily questioned. 

It was not that long ago when adults did not fully embrace and understand the responsibility that we all share. That responsibility is to protect children. 

The prevailing culture told us that no one charged with and dedicated to the care of orphaned children would ever harm them, and…

View Cache

When former Bishop Howard Hubbard penned an Op-ed in the Times Union just as the Child Victims’ Act was about to expire, his former diocese was facing more than 300 lawsuits from survivors of childhood sexual abuse.

His words offered regret for mistakes made in the past and hope for reconciliation and healing, in spite of the fact that Hubbard himself was the target of some of the abuse allegations.

Currently, the Diocese of Albany is fighting the release of internal documents that would surely shed light on how sexual predators were allowed to continue preying on innocent children.  The Times Union reported that “The diocese has quietly waged an aggressive effort in court to conceal records that may reveal more about its handling of sexual abuse cases. . . The diocese, and Hubbard’s defense attorneys, also have sought to prevent victims’ attorneys from obtaining the records of other clergy…

View Cache

Attorney General Josh Shapiro today announced that a Fayette County priest was sentenced to 2 1/2 to 5 years in state prison for repeatedly assaulting an 11-year-old altar boy starting in 2004 and continuing until the boy was 14.

“The bravery of this survivor helped us hold Andrew Kawecki accountable, and he will now go to prison for his unthinkable crimes,” said AG Shapiro. “My office will continue to seek justice and accountability for those who use their position of power and trust to prey on their communities.”

Andrew Kawecki was charged by the Office of Attorney General in August 2020 after a victim reported to investigators that Kawecki forced sexual encounters with the victim starting when he was 11 years old. The assaults continued for three years in the back room of St. Cyril and Methodius Church in Fairchance where Father Kawecki prepared for services before mass.

Kawecki was…

View Cache

Attorney General Josh Shapiro announced that a Fayette County priest was sentenced to 2 1/2 to 5 years in state prison for repeatedly assaulting an 11-year-old altar boy starting in 2004 and continuing until the boy was 14.

“The bravery of this survivor helped us hold Andrew Kawecki accountable, and he will now go to prison for his unthinkable crimes,” said AG Shapiro. “My office will continue to seek justice and accountability for those who use their position of power and trust to prey on their communities.”

Andrew Kawecki was charged by the Office of Attorney General in August 2020 after a victim reported to investigators that Kawecki forced sexual encounters with the victim starting when he was 11 years old. The assaults continued for three years in the back room of St. Cyril and Methodius Church in Fairchance where Father Kawecki prepared for services before mass.

Kawecki was identified following…

View Cache

SPRINGFIELD, Mass. (WWLP) – The Diocese of Springfield has added one name to the list of “Finding of Credibility of Allegations of Sexual Abuse of a Minor.”

According to a news release sent to 22News by the Diocese, late Father Gerard A. Lafleur is included on the list after a credible finding by the diocesan Review Board. The nature of the reported conduct was sexual abuse of a minor in 1974. Lafleur served for 58 years in the Diocese of Springfield, from 1953-2011. His assignments included:

• St. George Parish, Chicopee (1953-1959)
• Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary Parish, Chicopee (1959-1964)
• Cathedral High School (1964-1965)
• St. George Parish, Chicopee [In residence] (1964-1965)
• St. Theresa of Lisieux Parish, South Hadley (1965-1972)
• St. Joseph Parish, Springfield (1972-1987);
• Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary Parish, Chicopee (1987-2011)
• Mary’s Meadow’s at Providence Place, Holyoke (2011)

Lafleur died in 2011.

View Cache

The schools vice principal and a counselor have resigned

[VIDEO]

Months after sexual assault allegations surfaced, two additional Mount St. Mary administrators have resigned.

The school’s vice principal and a counselor have resigned. The announcement was sent to parents and students.

Last year, Mount St. Mary conducted an independent investigation into sexual assault claims from current and former students.

“At first I was really scared because, honestly, it’s just really traumatizing to have to deal with it again, it’s been a long time and I don’t like to even think about what happened,” one woman said.

Shortly after the investigation results came back in December, the longtime principal resigned. School officials said they could have done better when the allegations were first brought to their attention.

Now, in a letter, school officials say they are done reviewing that investigation, and the vice principal and counselor resigned.

“Now that the…

View Cache

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Former Anglican priest Robin Barrett’s latest trial for child pornography offences is expected to be cancelled Friday morning, March 4, as he changes his pleas to guilty.

A sentencing hearing is scheduled to take place instead for Barrett, 61, who is charged with accessing, possessing and distributing child pornography.

It will be Barrett’s second time being sentenced for child pornography crimes. He pleaded guilty in 2010 to similar offences after police found thousands of images and videos of the material on his computer. He was sentenced to 2 ½ years in prison and ordered to register as a sex offender for life.

Barrett was arrested again in 2015 after members of a joint Royal Newfoundland Constabulary/RCMP team of investigators received information from Ontario police about Barrett’s alleged participation in downloading and sharing child pornography online. Investigators knocked on his door and got no answer before using…

View Cache

A 50-year-old priest has been arrested for allegedly uploading child pornography on social media in Tamil Nadu’s Tiruppur district. The accused has been arrested under sections of Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POSCO) 2012 and the Information Technology (IT) Act 2000. The complaint came from a US-based NGO.

The police said that the complaint was made by the National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) which is a US-based NGO. NCMEC found the content and informed the Indian authorities.

After the complaint from NCMEC, the Tiruppur Police tracked down the suspect using the IP address and phone number of the accused. The suspect was identified as V. Vaithiyanathan, a temple priest in the district. He was arrested and booked by the Tamil Nadu police.

He has been booked under section 13 which deals with “Use of child for pornographic purposes” along with section 14(2) which pertains to “punishment for…

View Cache

All victims of child sexual abuse deserve the chance to seek justice. Who could disagree? Two high-profile Nebraska public officials, that’s who.

On Feb. 9, Nebraska Attorney General Doug Peterson sent a representative to a Judiciary Committee hearing to publicly testify against LB 1200. That legislation would allow victims of child sexual abuse to sue public institutions — like public schools and juvenile detention facilities — for their careless supervision of employees who sexually abuse children.

This is the same attorney general who, a mere five months ago, publicly advocated expanding the right to sue non-governmental organizations for the exact same conduct. This did not go unnoticed by several senators on the Judiciary Committee, who rightly called out the attorney general’s brazen double-standard.

In November, Attorney General Peterson widely publicized his investigative report on sexual abuse in the Catholic Church in Nebraska. At the press conference releasing the report, the…

View Cache

An Indianapolis Catholic priest suspended amid allegations of sexual abuse involving a minor on Tuesday agreed to plead guilty to one charge filed against him.

According to the Hamilton Superior Court plea agreement, Fr. David Marcotte, 32, pleaded guilty to one count of dissemination of matter harmful to minors, a level 6 felony.

The State motioned to dismiss two charges he faced — child solicitation and vicarious sexual gratification, according to the agreement.

The Archdiocese of Indianapolis suspended Marcotte from ministry in February 2019 after its victim assistance coordinator learned of the abuse allegations. The Archdiocese alerted authorities and notified the chair of the Archdiocesan Review Board about the allegation.

According to court documents, Marcotte allegedly sent inappropriate pictures to the juvenile victim and engaged in sexual conduct via various social media platforms, including apparent attempts to recruit others to participate.

The alleged abuse took place in 2016.

Marcotte was ordained…

View Cache

The civil tort case referencing alleged abuse by the late Fr. David Holley against a John Doe while Holley was in Alamogordo in the 1970s will now be heard in February 2023.

The case was originally set to begin in July 2022.

According to court filings, more time was needed for discovery between the parties. Discovery, in the legal senses, means to exchange legal information and facts of the case between opposing attorneys so that all sides can know the facts of a case.

Mediation was ordered to be completed by mid-February but has not been completed, according to plaintiff’s attorney Paul Linnenburger.

“A mediation has not yet occurred. Due to the pandemic easing and courts reopening to a large degree, mediators’ calendars are extremely tight,” Linnenburger said.

In March 2020, Doe filed suit against defendants Servants of the Paraclete, the Dioceses of Las Cruces, View Cache

The head of Germany’s largest archdiocese has offered to resign in reaction to months of criticism of his handling of sexual abuse cases.

Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki of Cologne, who resumed his duties on Wednesday after a five-month sabbatical triggered by a Vatican investigation into his leadership, said Pope Francis was considering his offer and would make a decision “in due course”.

The German Catholic church has been shaken by recent revelations that church leaders covered up abuse by priests and neglected victims over decades. Tens of thousands of Catholics have quit the church in protest.

It is unclear whether the Pope will accept Woelki’s offer. Last year he rejected a resignation request from Cardinal Reinhard Marx of Munich who had admitted sharing responsibility for the “catastrophe of sexual abuse by clerics”.

Woelki’s move follows what critics said was a half-hearted apology last month from the former Pope Benedict, accused in…

View Cache

Rainer Maria Woelki, the controversial archbishop of Cologne, has come under fire for his handling of abuse cases in the Catholic Church.

Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, the archbishop of Cologne, has offered his resignation to Pope Francis after facing criticism for how he dealt with allegations of child abuse in the Church.

The Cologne archdiocese said Wednesday that the pope would make a decision on the matter “in due course.”

Cardinal Woelki is expected to remain in his post in the meantime.

“I placed my service and office as Archbishop of Cologne at the Holy Father’s disposal, so that he is free to decide what best serves the Church of Cologne,” he wrote in a letter to his congregation.

What is the cardinal accused of? 

Cardinal Woelki faced public backlash in 2020 for deciding not to publish the results of an expert report he himself had commissioned…

View Cache

A prominent Roman Catholic archbishop who faced strong criticism for his handling of the church’s sexual abuse scandal in Germany said Wednesday that he has offered his resignation to Pope Francis following a “spiritual timeout” granted by the pontiff.

Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, the archbishop of Cologne, marked his return to work with a lengthy letter to the faithful in which said he was “not returning unchanged, as if nothing had happened in this time.”

Woelki has become a deeply divisive figure in the German church. In September, the Vatican said that Francis had decided to leave him in office but also give the cardinal the several-month timeout after he made what it termed “major errors” of communication.

In his letter to the faithful, Woelki said he has “reflected and meditated” repeatedly about his actions and the situation in the archdiocese.

He said that he has “made my service and…

View Cache

Retired Argentine Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta, formerly a close colleague of Pope Francis, was sentenced March 4 in a sexual abuse case.

Zanchetta, retired bishop of Orán, was given a 4 1/2-year sentence for abusing students at St. John XXIII Seminary. The judges ordered that his DNA be included in a national sex offender database.

Zanchetta remained silent during the sentencing, but had denied the allegations when the trial began Feb. 21. He was detained in the courtroom.

The day prior to the sentencing, Marcio Tornina, one of former seminarians in the case, used social media to demand justice.

“All I ask for is justice,” he posted on Facebook. “I feel sorry for the priests who were complicit in their silence. They know why they did it, but they should know that there were young people who put their trust in them.”

The case dates back to 2016, when seminarians accused…

View Cache

The man in his 60s is accused of sexual offenses against two male teenagers between 2005 and 2007

A senior member of a Catholic lay order accused of sexually abusing two teenagers will plead guilty in court.

His lawyer Edmond Pereira told the State Courts of Singapore that his client will admit the offenses on April 5 when the court is scheduled to have its next hearing, Channel News Asia reported on March 3.

The man in his 60s, a former officer of a Catholic school in Singapore, is accused of sexual offenses against two males aged 14-16 some time between 2005 and 2007.

The accused faces two charges of carnal intercourse against the order of nature under Singapore’s Penal Code. He was also charged with two counts of sexual exploitation of a child or young person under the Children and Young Persons Act.

The court formally charged him on…

View Cache

A Catholic bishop accused of sexually abusing young men studying to be priests was found guilty by a court in northern Argentina on Friday, capping over a week of often graphic testimony in the latest criminal abuse case to hit the global Church.

The high-profile trial played out in the home country of Pope Francis, the former archbishop of Buenos Aires and the first Latin American pontiff of the Church.

Gustavo Zanchetta, the former bishop of Oran in Argentina’s northern province of Salta, was convicted of sexually abusing two former seminarians, which prosecutors said in a statement was aggravated due to his status as a cleric.

The court handed down a prison sentence of 4 1/2 years to begin immediately.

Zanchetta had denied all charges in the criminal trial, as well as a separate Vatican canon law investigation, insisting he had “a good and healthy relationship” with all seminarians, according…

View Cache

Bishop Zanchetta led the Diocese of Orán, located in northern Argentina, from 2013 until 2017.

Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta was sentenced to four and a half years in prison on Friday, March 4, after an Argentine court found him guilty of sexually abusing seminarians.  

Bishop Zanchetta, 58, pleaded not guilty to the charge of “aggravated continued simple sexual abuse committed by a recognized minister of religion” on Feb. 21. He was accused of abusing two seminarians, who were identified by the acronyms “G.G.F.L.” and “C.M.”  

The two victims said that Bishop Zanchetta had made “amorous proposals” and had requested “massages” from the two. 

Bishop Zanchetta led the Diocese of Orán, located in northern Argentina, from 2013 until 2017. His episcopal appointment was one of the first done by Pope Francis in his native Argentina. 

He stepped down in 2017, claiming “health reasons,” and was subsequently appointed as an assessor…

View Cache

The Argentine Bishops’ Conference expressed closeness to the victims of Bishop Gustavo Oscar Zanchetta. Argentine media have reported that the bishop was first accused of sexually inappropriate behavior as early as 2015.

On Friday the Argentine Bishops’ Conference expressed closeness to the victims of Bishop Gustavo Oscar Zanchetta, sentenced to prison for sexually abusing seminarians, and renewed their commitment to eradicate these abusive behaviors.

“Having learned of the court ruling in which Gustavo Zanchetta, bishop emeritus of the Diocese of San Ramón de la Nueva Orán, has been convicted, we want to express our closeness to the victims and express a strong and sincere request for forgiveness on behalf of the entire Church,” the bishops said in a March 4 statement.

The Argentine bishops noted that “these painful events renew us in the committed and urgent task of eradicating this type of abusive behavior.”

They also expressed their commitment to…

View Cache

Gustavo Zanchetta convicted by court in a major blow to Pope Francis, who had initially defended the bishop

A court in Argentina has sentenced a Roman Catholic bishop to four and a half years in prison for sexual abuse of two former seminarians in a major blow to Pope Francis, who had initially defended the bishop.

Gustavo Zanchetta, 57, was convicted on Friday of “simple, continued and aggravated sexual abuse”, with his offense aggravated by his role as a religious minster.

A court in the north-western town of Orán, where Zanchetta, 57, was bishop from 2013 to 2017, ordered his immediate detention.

The conviction in the pope’s homeland hits at Francis’s personal credibility since he had initially rejected accusations against Zanchetta, and created a job for him at the Vatican that got him out of Argentina.

Francis has defended his handling of the case, insisting that Zanchetta “defended himself…

View Cache

Analysis

The criminal conviction of Bishop Gustavo Oscar Zanchetta for the sexual abuse of seminarians has sent shock waves through the Argentine Catholic Church, and the Vatican. 

The conviction also raises questions about the credibility of Pope Francis, a close friend of Zanchetta, on handling abuse allegations. It could well cast a shadow over the pope’s signature reform effort, Vos estis lux mundi, promulgated in the wake of the Theodore McCarrick scandal.

Bishop Zanchetta was sentenced to four years and six months in prison on Friday after he was found guilty of sexually assaulting two former adult seminarians. If he serves his full prison term, the bishop will have spent longer in jail than he did as Bishop of Oran.

While the court focused on his brief tenure leading the diocese, scrutiny is now likely to fall on the years Zanchetta spent in Rome, under the patronage of Pope Francis, who…

View Cache

Argentinian Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta was found guilty by an Argentinian court and sentenced to four years and six months of effective imprisonment for aggravated continuous sexual abuse of two former seminarians.

His immediate detention was ordered by the court in Oran, Salta, on Friday morning local time.

“We cannot determine the extent of the damage suffered by the victims, but we do have the obligation to give them an answer from justice and give an answer to society,” said prosecutor Pablo Rivero on Thursday, before requesting the conviction and immediate detention.

Zanchetta, the former bishop of the diocese of Oran, in northern Argentina, would boast of his friendship with Pope Francis, who believed the bishop’s claim he was being set up when the allegations were first made against him.

Zanchetta was made a bishop and appointed to Oran by Francis in 2013. He resigned at the age of 53 in…

View Cache

The former Bishop of Oran, Argentina, was sentenced Friday to four and a half years in prison for the sexual abuse of two former seminarians. Bishop Gustavo Oscar Zanchetta was convicted of simple sexual abuse aggravated by his position as a minister of religion, in a decision handed down by judges in his former diocese.

The bishop returned to Argentina in the summer of 2021 to face the charges, after he spent years living and working in the Vatican. After Zanchetta resigned from diocesan leadership in scandal, Pope Francis created a special post for the bishop in APSA, the Holy See’s sovereign asset manager and reserve bank. 

After he was sentenced Friday, Zanchetta was remanded directly to the custody of corrections officials; he will be immediately held in a regional facility and transferred within days to the Argentine prison where he will serve his sentence.

Zanchetta’s trial took place over…

View Cache

Allegations over Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta’s conduct raised questions over pope’s handling of abuse cases

Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta, a longtime associate of Pope Francis, was convicted by an Argentine court Friday of sexually assaulting young men in a case that has raised questions about the pope’s handling of sexual abuse at the highest level of the Catholic hierarchy.

A court in Orán, located in Argentina’s northern province of Salta, where Bishop Zanchetta served from 2013 to 2017, sentenced him to four years and six months in prison for the assault on two former seminarians there.

The bishop’s lawyer, Javier Belda, said he would appeal.

Several men said they communicated their accusations to the Vatican before the pope assigned Bishop Zanchetta to a high post there in 2017. Bishop Zanchetta remained in his Vatican post for more than two years after the accusations became public. In 2019, he was tried…

View Cache

An advocacy group on Thursday said they filed a complaint against St. Louis Archbishop Mitchell Rozanski over his handling of a priest accused in lawsuits of sexual abuse.

David Clohessy of Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, or SNAP, said the group filed a “lengthy, detailed” complaint with the Vatican office, commonly known as “Vos Estis,” that investigates abuse or cover-ups by bishops.

Clohessy said Rozanski should have suspended a De Soto priest, the Rev. Alexander Anderson, who was facing one lawsuit when he was sued again last month.

Clohessy said that Anderson has been accused five times. The archdiocese, in a statement in response to the most recent lawsuit, said other allegations were either retracted or shown to be false. 

Clohessy said church officials can encourage or discourage victims from coming forward, and were discouraging them by failing to act against Anderson.

Last month’s lawsuit, filed by Christian Hornbeck, said Anderson…

View Cache

A former Fayette County priest was sentenced up to five years in prison Thursday for the sexual abuse of a minor nearly two decades ago.

Fayette County Judge Linda Cordaro sentenced Andrew Kawecki, 66, of Greensburg, to serve 2 1/2 to 5 years in a state prison on the single charge of indecent assault to a person less than 13 years of age.

In October, Kawecki pleaded no contest to that charge as a result of a plea agreement between the defense and the state attorney general’s office.

Kawecki served in several churches in the region between 1981 and 2016, including St. John the Baptist in Perryopolis, St. Sebastian in Belle Vernon, St. James in Maxwell, St. Julian in Isabella, Our Lady of Perpetual Help in Leckrone, St. Hubert in Point Marion, St. John the Baptist in Scottdale and St. Joseph in Everson.

Kawecki abused Skyler Moncheck beginning in 2004…

View Cache

A top administrator and a counselor at Mount St. Mary Catholic High School have resigned after an independent investigation into allegations of sexual assault among students, The Oklahoman has learned. 

Vice Principal Whitney Faires and school counselor Mallory Tecmire have each resigned. 

In a letter to parents and students obtained by The Oklahoman, interim Principal Diane Floyd said she accepted the resignations March 1. 

“We expect all school administrators, faculty and staff at The Mount to follow the Safe Environment protocol and school policy to appropriately report suspected abuse or harassment of minors,” Floyd wrote in her letter. “Now that the review is concluded, we are moving forward with our focus on the Voices of Human Dignity Task Force to ensure our words, actions and policies reflect our mission and Catholic social teachings.”

The resignations followed a months-long independent investigation by Mount St. Mary, after…

View Cache

Shortly after Archbishop Donald Bolen was installed to serve as Archbishop of Regina, I and other victims reached out and requested to meet with him. We learned he was unaware of the area’s deep legacy of clergy sexual abuse. At the initial and subsequent meetings, he learned of the deep legacy of abuse and the painful, retraumatizing and broken process that myself and other victims were subjected to when they came to the church to report abuse. Those initial conversations resulted in an understanding and willingness on his part to walk with and work with victims. Over the next five years, through difficult but collaborative conversations with all parties, we have made significant changes both to prevent future abuse and to accompany victims. We continue to take steps to help the institution to listen to, learn from and walk with victims and survivors of clergy sexual abuse.

At the time,…

View Cache

A Spanish law firm has been tasked by the country’s bishops with an independent investigation into sexual abuse by clergy.

The investigation will be conducted by a team of 18 people, including former high-ranking judges, but also specialists in psychology and representatives from the world of culture. 

Heading the commission will be Javier Cremades, a lawyer who is also a member of Opus Dei. Cremades has vowed to liaise closely with the government during the investigation and rejects accusations of bias. “I am a Catholic and a member of Opus Dei, yet I am fully convinced that the Church should get to the bottom, investigate, ask for forgiveness and rectify whatever necessary,” he said, during a press conference with the head of the Spanish Bishops Conference Cardinal Juan José Omella, Archbishop of Barcelona. 

Javier Cremades says the commission will be modelled on the German investigation, and will also incorporate best…

View Cache

While in Italy the Concordat with the Catholic Church creates a special situation, in other countries attacks against the legal protection of the confessional secret are gaining momentum.

Religious Confession and Evidential Privilege in the 21st Century (Cleveland, Queensland: Shepherd Street Press, 2021), edited by Mark Hill and A. Keith Thompson, is an important book I started reviewing in the previous article of this series. I examined how the idea that either the laws protecting the secret of confession and other similar religious practices should be abrogated altogether, or exceptions should be made for cases of child sexual abuse, originated in Australia, where the recommendation of a Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Abuse in this direction have been implemented in several states and territories. Other chapters of the Hill-Thompson book are about countries of Europe.

Marco Ferrante discusses the very special situation of Italy, where not only the secrecy of…

View Cache

Over at Crisis, Janet Smith relates the sad, scandalous story of how the Archdiocese of Detroit has treated Father Eduard Perrone. A beloved priest, whose 25 years of ministry at Assumption Grotto had made the parish a magnet for tradition-minded Catholics, he was suspended from ministry in 2019 because of a sex-abuse charge.

All the available evidence indicates that Father Perrone was innocent of the charge. Or to put it differently, there is no credible evidence against him. Father Perrone, who of course denied the accusations, voluntarily took and passed a lie-detector test—twice. Local prosecutors quickly dropped a criminal investigation, recognizing that the testimony from a single accuser was incoherent, and contradicted by other witnesses.

Determined to clear his name, Father Perrone filed a defamation suit against a police detective who had pressed the case against him, charging that she had falsified reports. He won that case, and…

View Cache

A western Pennsylvania Roman Catholic priest who sexually assaulted an altar boy for several years has been sentenced to 2 1/2 to five years in state prison.

The Rev. Andrew Mark Kawecki, of Greensburg will also have to register as a sex offender for 10 years once he’s freed from custody under the sentence imposed Thursday. He had pleaded no contest last October to indecent assault.

Prosecutors said the sexual abuse began in 2004, when the victim was an 11-year-old altar boy, and occurred in a back room of the Saints Cyril and Methodius Church in Fairchance, where Kawecki prepared for services. The repeated assaults continued for three years, until the victim was 14.

Kawecki was removed from the ministry and parishioners were notified after investigators received a tip about Kawecki in May 2019. The state attorney general’s office has said that after he was charged in 2020 another victim…

View Cache

La fiscalía de Argentina solicitó cuatro años y seis meses de prisión efectiva para el obispo Gustavo Zanchetta, uno de los administradores del patrimonio del Vaticano, en el juicio oral que enfrenta por presunto abuso sexual de dos seminaristas cuando estuvo al frente de un obispado en la provincia norteña de Salta.

En su alegato ante el tribunal, la fiscal María Soledad Filtrín Cuezzo sostuvo el jueves que durante el juicio “se pudo establecer la veracidad, verosimilitud y credibilidad de las víctimas, que presentaron en sus denuncias y durante el juicio lógica interna, contextualización de los hechos, precisión de detalles y vivencias desde lo anatómico”, según un comunicado del Ministerio Público fiscal de Salta.

El caso tomó trascendencia pública a principios de 2019 con un informe del diario El Tribuno de Salta sobre el supuesto comportamiento inadecuado del obispo durante los cuatro años que estuvo al frente del Obispado de…

View Cache

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield has announced two updates to their online list of clergy with credible accusations of sexual abuse.

On Wednesday, Father Gerard Lafleur was added to the list. He was ordained in 1953 and had assignments in Chicopee, Springfield, South Hadley, and Holyoke prior to his death in 2011. The abuse accusation involves a minor and dates back to 1974.

In addition, the listing for Father Charles Sullivan was updated to indicate that there has been more than one allegation against him. The move comes after the Diocesan Review Board looked into an allegation of sexual abuse involving a minor that dates back to 1994.

Sullivan was ordained in 1965 and had assignments in Longmeadow, Springfield, Holyoke, Westfield, Monson, Pittsfield, Lenox, Amherst, Indian Orchard, and Thorndike before he was removed from the ministry in 2002. He died in 2014.

The diocese explained that…

View Cache

A review board run by the Diocese of Springfield has upheld a new allegation of sexual abuse by a Catholic priest who served parishioners of a Pittsfield church in the mid-1980s.

The diocese said Wednesday it updated its roster of credibly accused priests to now reflect multiple allegations that Charles J. Sullivan sexually abused minors.

Sullivan, who served the diocese from 1965 to 1992, died in 2014. He was assigned to St. Mary the Morning Star Parish in Pittsfield from 1984 to 1986.

The newly confirmed allegation of sexual abuse of a minor dates to 1994, the diocese said; the previously confirmed allegation concerns abuse in 1993. Sullivan was removed from public ministry in 2002, the diocese said, and “assigned to a life of prayer and penance” in 2005.

This week, the diocese also updated its list of credibly accused priests to include, for the…

View Cache

An Auburn man has filed a negligence lawsuit accusing two now deceased priests of sexually abusing him while he was a studentat a Catholic school in Holbrook during the 1980s.

The suit, filed Tuesday in Worcester Superior Court, alleges the abuse occurred at St. Joseph School when Gerry Nee, now 46, was 6 to 12 years old.

The alleged abuse took place in confessionals and a vacant rectory, where one sexual assault left Nee in need of medical attention, according to the nine-page lawsuit.

Nee wants to set an example for his children and hopefully inspire other victims to come forward, Nee’s lawyer, John T. Martin, said Wednesday.

“It took a tremendous amount of courage for Gerry to disclose what happened and he had to overcome a lot of fears and concerns and anxieties about his privacy,” Martin said. “In many ways, it’s therapeutic for people to confront their abusers…

View Cache

Missoula Catholic Schools President Luis Hayes has been placed on immediate paid administrative leave following an investigation, the Diocese of Helena announced.

Former Loyola Sacred Heart High School Principal Kathy Schneider and former Athletic Director Jacob Alford will also remain on paid administrative leave for the remainder of the year.

None of the three administrators on leave will be offered contracts to return in the fall, according to Bishop Austin Vetter.

“This leave is for the remainder of the school year and is due to the fact that there was a failure on the part of these administrators to ensure that a necessary background check and training in safe environment policy were in place when hiring an employee,” the Diocese of Helena wrote in a statement.

Vetter’s decision to place Hayes on leave and continue Schneider’s and Alford’s leaves was received “with the full support of the Missoula Catholic Schools…

View Cache

In this age of small-group ministries, most pastors would know how to handle a crisis that affected significant numbers of believers in their pews.

“If you had 1 in 4 members of your congregation actively battling cancer, or 1 in 4 members … experiencing being widowed or losing a spouse, chances are that you would have some level of intentional ministry to those individuals,” said Rachael Denhollander at a recent Trinity Forum event focusing on how churches respond to sexual abuse. “Maybe you would have a support group or a Bible study for them. You would have meal trains to help provide for their physical needs.”

But many sexual abuse victims hesitate to speak out, she said, because churches act as if they don’t exist. Thus, they have little reason to believe the sins and crimes committed against them will be handled in a way that offers safety and healing.

…

View Cache

Starting with the pope.

At around the fifth hour of November’s “Enough Is Enough” prayer rally, hosted by the Catholic right media outlet Church Militant, event emcee and fallen alt-right star Milo Yiannopoulos bounded onstage to reveal a dramatic wardrobe change. Gone were the rock-star white suit and purple shoes he’d been wearing since morning, replaced by a black shirt, black suit, and heavy crucifix, which gleamed from the jumbotrons all the way to the back of Baltimore’s Pier Six Pavilion, where the concert venue jutted into the city harbor. The bleached-blond tips of his floppy hair—fashy-short on the sides and Donald Trump combover-long on top—had been shorn in a final makeover after his year of ostentatious renunciation.

At the podium, Yiannopoulos assumed an air of exaggerated modesty. “The path to salvation is a series of baby steps,” he told a crowd of some 1,500 predominantly white, mostly middle-aged rallygoers. “I’m glad I…

View Cache

February 18 – March 26, 2022

Lisa Kessler

Heart in the Wound

February 18 – March 26, 2022

Howard Yezerski Gallery is pleased to announce Heart in the Wound, a solo exhibition of photographs by Lisa Kessler. This year marks the twentieth anniversary of The Boston Globe’s Spotlight team releasing their groundbreaking story of clergy abuse. Heart in the wound features deeply personal images made before and after the story broke in 2002. Thanks to Kessler’s dedication of connecting herself with survivors and her ability to capture such delicate subject matter, we are able to view and hear these stories. The exhibition will also include an 8-minute audio documentary, as well as an interactive website which provides resources for those affected by these events.

***

I had been treated professionally and kindly as a freelancer for the Archdiocese of Boston through the 1990’s, and I didn’t know how to…

View Cache

The CEO of Kanakuk has released an open letter as part of an updated response from the camp to continued allegations related to the abuse of a former camp director.

An in-depth investigation released in March 2021 by former ACLJ and Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel and National Review author David French and his wife for the online journal The Dispatch revealed a number of victims of Kanakuk were under non-disclosure agreements which were signed as part of legal settlements. 

“Recent articles have accused Kanakuk of using Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) to hide details of abuse and silence victims,” Kanakuk Ministries President Doug Goodwin wrote in the letter. “This is simply not the case. The awful details of what transpired is part of the public record. The criminal component was equally public and local television stations and newspapers covered this for many months. Kanakuk’s focus is on supporting victims’ privacy and…

View Cache

As Mary Pat Fox described last month, Voice of the Faithful grew at an astonishing rate in the first few months. Looking back, though, the amazing thing is the speed and clarity with which the mission and goals of the organization were discerned. Centered in prayer, speaking boldly and listening attentively to one another, we were journeying together in faith 20 years before Pope Francis’ Synod. That convinces me that VOTF was and still is a movement of the Spirit.

Founder Jim Muller’s motto was “Keep the Faith – Change the Church.” When our critics asked us what that meant, we said we respected the role of the hierarchy, but all the people of God must be involved in discerning where the Spirit is leading the Church. Cardinal George of Chicago responded that “Keep the Faith, Change the Church” was problematic because any change in the Church will, “unless most carefully thought out,”…

View Cache

A HIGHLY critical report from the chair of the new Independent Safeguarding Board (ISB), Maggie Atkinson (News, 30 September 2021), sets how far the board believes that the Church of England must travel to prevent further safeguarding failures and to promote a safer culture.

In some cases, defending institutions had mattered more than the person making the disclosure, the report, which was presented to the General Synod on Wednesday morning, says. An attitude of “also-to-do” had resulted in seeing safeguarding as a secondary task; and there had been a “child-unfriendly” approach for people seeking help or redress, it says.

“We are keenly aware that the Church’s past failures, and the associated pain, shame, ongoing confusion, sometimes anger, and potentially lifelong trauma of victims and survivors, are too often still present long after the suffering concerned is brought to light,” the report says, “whether or not the Church considers it has in fact…

View Cache

The Vatican tribunal has rejected defense motions in a landmark trial concerning alleged financial crimes, ordering the process to continue, starting with the questioning of Cardinal Angelo Becciu.

At a March 1 hearing, court president Giuseppe Pignatone read aloud a 40-page ordinance responding to objections from defense lawyers lodged since the process kicked off last summer.

The three-judge panel hearing the case rejected requests to throw out evidence and charges — which some lawyers indicated they would appeal — and set the next hearing for March 17.

March 17 will mark the first day of testimony, when Becciu will be called to the stand to respond to questions about Vatican and Italian bishops’ conference funds he is accused of illicitly giving to the charitable arm of his home Diocese of Ozieri, located on the Italian island of Sardinia.

Becciu resigned as prefect of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Causes of Saints…

View Cache

The power that a seminary faculty has over students would never be accepted in a state run institution.

St Andrew’s College Drygrange was the main seminary for the east of Scotland. When I entered in 1978 it had just celebrated its 25th anniversary. It was a curious  place, a gay community in everything but name, but a self-loathing gay community.

Not everyone was gay. And the ones that were gay pretended that they weren’t. Except when they didn’t. Towards the end of my time there a student in the year below me told me that he and his pal had been working their way through the student list the night before – a common pastime back in the day – deciding who was and wasn’t gay. When they came to my name they concluded: “Brian isn’t gay, but he wishes he was.” 

I suppose Drygrange was not atypical for its …

View Cache

Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki has submitted his resignation for a second time to Pope Francis as leader of Germany’s Catholic archdiocese of Cologne.

The archdiocese announced the cardinal’s move on March 2, Ash Wednesday, the day that he returned to lead the archdiocese after a period of “prayer and reflection,” reported CNA Deutsch, CNA’s German-language news partner.

The Cologne archdiocese, which is Germany’s largest and reportedly also its richest diocese, said that the pope had instructed the 65-year-old cardinal to resume his ministry on Wednesday, pending a decision on his resignation.

Woelki began his sabbatical at the end of September 2021 “at his own request,” after he was confirmed in office by Pope Francis, who had ordered an apostolic visitation amid fierce criticism of the archdiocese’s handling of abuse cases.

In a Lenten pastoral letter published on…

View Cache

St. Kevin’s to retain church and hall as part of out-of-court settlement

A settlement has been reached involving millions of dollars raised in a Chase the Ace fundraiser for a St. John’s-area parish nearly five years ago.

The cash got tangled up in ongoing insolvency proceedings involving the Roman Catholic church in eastern Newfoundland and efforts to compensate victims of historic abuse at the Mount Cashel orphanage.

An out-of-court settlement was reached Sunday night. The matter had been due to go before a Newfoundland and Labrador Supreme Court judge Monday morning.

“It’s a result we’re pleased with, and the parish council, it’s a result I understand that they are satisfied with,” said Geoff Budden, a St. John’s lawyer who represents 70 people who suffered abuse at Mount Cashel.

“So it’s a compromise, but it is one that will see a significant sum of money put forward to be used to compensate…

View Cache

Germany’s ‘synodal way’ charts its own course to reform.

Germany’s Synodale Weg (“synodal way”), led by the German conference of bishops and the national committee of lay German Catholics (ZdK), assembled for the third time in February; it was likely a watershed moment in the German Church’s synodal process. Some 230 delegates, lay and clergy, debated and voted on over a dozen documents produced by working groups in four areas: power in the Church; the model of priesthood; women and ministries; and sexual morality in Church teaching. Each of the documents won the approval of well over two-thirds of all delegates (ranging from 74 percent to 92 percent), and just over two-thirds of the bishops. In addition to voting, some bishops even made bold interventions in favor of doctrinal change. (If they had talked like that when they were still priests, they would never have become bishops in the first place.) A separate…

View Cache

The Vermont History Museum is hosting a multi-media exhibit about the experiences of people who once lived at St. Joseph’s Orphanage in Burlington

The newest exhibit at the Vermont History Museum documents a painful legacy, but it’s one survivors of childhood abuse and trauma say needs to be heard as part of their healing process.

“This cannot be allowed to happen again,” said Katelin Hoffman, referring to the abuse she experienced at the now-defunct St. Joseph’s Orphanage in Burlington when she was in her early teens.

Hoffman and others have reported they were routinely harmed at the facility that closed in 1974. Some said, as a particularly shocking example, they were even forced by staff to eat their own vomit when they were sick.

“At night, they’d come in after the kids were asleep and pull them out of bed and beat them,” Hoffman recalled of orphanage staffers in an…

View Cache

A very important book critically addresses proposals that statutes protecting the confidentiality of religious confession should be abolished.

Religious Confession and Evidential Privilege in the 21st Century (Cleveland, Queensland: Shepherd Street Press, an imprint of Connor Court Publishing and The School of Law, The University of Notre Dame Australia, 2021), edited by Mark Hill, a distinguished British barrister, and A. Keith Thompson, professor and associate dean at the University of Notre Dame Australia School of Law, with a foreword by former Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, may well be one of the most important books on religion of 2022 (the year when it has been in fact released, although it bears a copyright date 2021). I will review it in a series of subsequent articles, divided by geographical focus. In this first article, I will concentrate on Australia.

The subject matter of the book is the claim, originated by horrific cases of…

View Cache

Prince Andrew could face more sex abuse lawsuits in the US due to a potential change in the law – including from a woman who claims she was groped by the disgraced royal. 

The Duke of York, 62, settled the rape case brought against him by accuser Virginia Giuffre, 38, for an undisclosed amount thought to be up to $15 million. 

Ms Giuffre’s case was allowed by a New York law which gave victims of historic child sex abuse a year to sue their alleged abusers despite the statute of limitations.   

Florida hair salon owner Johanna Sjoberg, 42, has repeatedly claimed that Andrew touched her breast in 2001 when she was 21.

So far she would have been able to sue the prince for the alleged sex assault because the child sex abuse law did not apply to her and too much time has gone by. 

But new bill…

View Cache

Batavia – A longtime area priest who became the one of the most notorious in the Buffalo Diocese’s sex abuse scandal has died.

The Rev. Donald W. Becker, 79, died Feb. 15 in Fort Myers, Fla. He was accused of molesting children in 30 lawsuits under the state’s Child Victims Act.

Becker always denied the allegations, but the sheer number of lawsuits made him the most-accused priest in the diocese.

Becker was ordained in 1968 and the lawsuits against him allege incidents dating back to at least that time. One such lawsuit accused him of getting a 15-year-old male drunk and then raping him during a 1975 incident in North Java.

Becker was pastor from 1992 to 2002 at the former St. Mary’s Church in Batavia. He was removed from his duties in 2002 on a “medical leave of absence” and named by the diocese in 2018 among the dozens…

View Cache

The Archdiocese of Santa Fe, in the throes of Chapter 11 bankruptcy, sued four insurance companies this week, claiming they haven’t fulfilled their contracts to provide liability coverage for sexual abuse complaints.

The archdiocese hopes to raise enough money, including through insurance payouts, to settle the bankruptcy case involving more than 400 people who allege they were victims of clergy sexual abuse, with some claims dating back decades.

At least one attorney sees the archdiocese’s lawsuit as a step toward a resolution in the case, which has stretched over more than three years and is on its third mediator. While it was clear the archdiocese and its insurance companies haven’t reached deals on payouts, the lawsuit reveals the severity of the disagreements between them.

The defendants named in the suit are Great American Insurance Co., Arrowood Indemnity Co., St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co. and United States Fire Insurance…

View Cache

One of the oldest Roman Catholic dioceses in the U.S. is suing four insurance companies over claims that they haven’t fulfilled contracts to provide liability coverage for sexual abuse complaints.

The Archdiocese of Santa Fe filed the lawsuit this week as it deals with a bankruptcy case involving more than 400 people who allege they were victims of clergy sexual abuse. Some of the claims date back decades.

The archdiocese hopes to raise enough money, including through insurance payouts, to settle the bankruptcy case, which has stretched over more than three years and is on its third mediator.

At least one attorney sees the archdiocese’s lawsuit as a step toward a resolution in the case, the Santa Fe New Mexican reported.

The defendants named in the lawsuit are Great American Insurance Co., Arrowood Indemnity Co., St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co. and United States Fire…

View Cache

[Google translation followed by German text]

Judgment in the trial of a Catholic priest: A 70-year-old has been imprisoned for twelve years for sexual abuse. He had molested several girls over the years. 

The trial against a 70-year-old priest before the Cologne Regional Court ended with a sentence of twelve years in prison. He worked in the Voreifel, in Gummersbach, Wuppertal and Zülpich. After the testimonies of the witnesses had become overwhelming, he himself admitted that he had sexually abused girls in all these places on numerous occasions.

“You were not the luminary that you were perceived as, but a pedophile serial offender who has abused for decades,” said judge Christoph Kaufmann to the 70-year-old priest, who on Friday before the 2nd major criminal chamber of the Cologne district court was sentenced to twelve years imprisonment. He has committed 110 cases of sexual abuse, of which 23 are classified as serious and 15 as…

View Cache

A New Jersey doctor [Hoatson is a Ph.D.] is protesting against a late Bridgeport priest who is accused of sexually abusing a child.

Bob Hoatson stood in Bridgeport Sunday outside of St. Michael the Archangel Church with a sign reading: “Abuser of minor children – Father George Maslar.”

This comes after an unidentified woman claimed she was abused twice by the priest when she was young.

Hoatson is the co-founder of a non-profit in New Jersey, Road to Recovery, that assists victims of sexual abuse and their families.

We’re told Maslar moved around at least 25 times to different churches. According to Maslar’s assignment record, the late priest began his career in 1965 at St. Michael’s Church. He moved to several different churches throughout Connecticut, Maryland, New York, and Pennsylvania before ending at St. Maximilian Kolbe Friary in Hamburg, New York.

Hoatson said Father Maslar’s name has not appeared in…

View Cache

Last August, former Bishop Howard J. Hubbard reflected on his handling of decades of child abuse allegations in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany, noting that his “most fervent prayer each day is that victims … and their families will find healing, reconciliation and peace in God’s love and that we as a church and a society will learn from this tragedy.”

The remarks by the bishop emeritus, who headed the diocese from 1977 to 2014, were made in an extraordinary opinion piece that was published in the Times Union on Aug. 13 — the final day that alleged victims of childhood sexual abuse could file claims under New York’s Child Victims Act, which had lifted the statute of limitations for two years.

Hubbard, who is among numerous clergy facing allegations of sexually abusing children, wrote in his op-ed that the diocese’s response “fell short,” and he admitted church officials had…

View Cache

A priest who abused children and adolescents over many years has been handed a 12-year jail sentence by a Cologne court. The archdiocese where he worked has denied any responsibility.

The Catholic Church has been facing a wave of abuse allegations against many priests

A  court in the western German city of Cologne on Friday convicted a Catholic priest of sexually abusing children in cases spanning many years, sentencing him to 12 years in prison.

The priest was also ordered to pay three co-plaintiffs in the cases damages totaling €50,000 ($56,000).

The conviction comes as the German Catholic Church is under intense scrutiny after revelations of decades of sexual abuse of children and misconduct toward minors by church employees, including in the Cologne Archdiocese. 

The church is seen by many to have abused its position of power by covering up abuse by priests

What was the priest convicted…

View Cache

To organize a National Eucharistic Congress in 2024, the Catholic bishops in the United States have partnered with an event planner who was accused of charging exorbitant rates during the preparations for Donald Trump’s presidential inauguration in January 2017.

The bishops are also relying on conservative Catholic organizations to provide funding and create catechetical and promotional materials for a multiyear National Eucharistic Revival that will lead up to the four-day congress in July 2024. The bishops intend to set up a nonprofit organization to handle logistics and raise $28 million over the next two years to hold the event in downtown Indianapolis.

Some Catholic observers, including experts in financial planning and church management, say the bishops’ plan is sound and consistent with other large religious events in recent years, including the 2015 World Meeting of Families in Philadelphia.

Also linking belief in the real presence of Jesus in the Eucharist…

View Cache

The Bishop of Knoxville says he will fight a lawsuit which claims he both covered up a rape allegation against a former diocesan seminarian, and defamed the alleged rape victim.

“I am taking this matter seriously and my plan is to vigorously challenge these allegations,” Bishop Rick Stika wrote in a Feb. 25 letter, distributed to priests and other personnel within the Tennessee diocese. 

“We know that the legal system works deliberately, and with good reason. I welcome a thorough examination of these allegations, but this will take some time,” Stika wrote.

The bishops’ letter came after a Feb. 22 lawsuit against Stika and the Knoxville diocese, filed by a former cathedral organist, who charges that he was raped and sexually harassed by seminarian Wojciech Sobczuk in February 2019, and that Stika did not take seriously the allegation — and in fact, tried to pressure him to keep silent. 

Stika…

View Cache

Handing a key legal victory to survivors of clergy sexual abuse, U.S. District Court Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood on Saturday ruled the assets of Catholic parishes and schools belong to the Archdiocese of Agana as a whole – and could therefore be used to help pay abuse claimants.

The judge’s ruling capped a three-year-old request from hundreds of survivors, represented by Leo Tudela, 78.

“I will stay a Catholic,” Tudela told the court after the ruling, while also urging other survivors to come forward for “healing” and to put aside differences within the Catholic Church.

Millions of dollars worth of buildings, parking lots, vehicles, cemeteries, bank accounts and other parish and school property are now part of the archdiocese’s bankruptcy estate, which could be liquidated.

But the judge and the creditors committee, along with the archdiocese, said the end goal is to justly compensate the abuse survivors while keeping the…

View Cache

District Court of Guam Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood ruled on Saturday that funds from the Archdiocese of Agaña’s Catholic parishes and schools could be used to help pay survivors of sexual abuse.

In January 2019, the Archdiocese filed for Chapter 11 reorganization bankruptcy to allow it to restructure its finances to pay the plaintiffs in about 202 clergy sex abuse claims.

The church listed $22.96 million in assets, with $45.66 million in liabilities, according to PDN news files.

Attorney Edwin Caldie, who represented some of the survivors and other creditors, said that the parties currently are trying to agree on a settlement between what the claimants are asking and what the church can pay without losing its entire community.

“It’s complicated. The church chose to file for bankruptcy and so the bankruptcy code, all of the laws, federal laws, relating to bankruptcy, they’ll guide and they’ll help us figure out…

View Cache

The new Archbishop of Glasgow yesterday said the Catholic Church should feel ashamed over the child abuse scandal while praising survivors for speaking out.

William Nolan also insisted the Church must “change our ways to ensure what happened in the past does not happen again”.

His comments came as he was installed as the new leader of Scotland’s largest Catholic community at a mass in the city’s St Andrew’s Cathedral. Pope Francis had nominated the former Bishop of Galloway for the role after the former archbishop, Philip Tartaglia, died following contracting Covid-19 last year.

As he was welcomed into his new role, Nolan spoke about “scandals” that have impacted the Church in recent years and “in particular the child abuse scandal”.

He praised those who had been abused and who had gone on to speak out for ­having “taken what happened in the dark and brought it to light”.

He…

View Cache

An extraordinary claim appeared in a column by Matthew Syed in the Sunday Times yesterday, namely that up to a million Italian children have been abused by Italian priests since 1950. No-one can fail to have been shocked by such a figure, but from where does it originate? The answer is that it comes from a member of ‘The Abuse Network’ which is calling on the Church in Italy to investigate clerical sex abuse as has happened recently in France and Germany. Speaking to The Times, Francesco Zanardi (pictured above), himself an abuse victim and member of ‘The Abuse Network’, said: “I believe the number of victims could be as high as a million here”.

But what does he base that figure on? What he has done is extrapolate from a number that appears in the recent French report that was commissioned by the French hierarchy.

Based on a survey, that…

View Cache

In this age of small-group ministries, most pastors would know how to handle a crisis that affected significant numbers of believers in their pews.

“If you had 1 in 4 members of your congregation actively battling cancer, or 1 in 4 members … experiencing being widowed or losing a spouse, chances are that you would have some level of intentional ministry to those individuals,” said Rachael Denhollander at a recent Trinity Forum event focusing on how churches respond to sexual abuse. “Maybe you would have a support group or a Bible study for them. You would have meal trains to help provide for their physical needs.”

But many sexual abuse survivors hesitate to speak out, she said, because churches act as if they don’t exist. Thus, they have little reason to believe the sins and crimes committed against them will be handled in a way that offers safety and healing.

…

View Cache

We must now accept that such evil is not an aberration but part of a duality central to institutional religion

The most dangerous moment in any scandal is when anger shades into indifference, when revelations that once had the power to shock become so normalised that they scarcely register. I wonder if we have reached such a tipping point in one of the most disturbing stories of our age: the sexual abuse of children by Roman Catholic priests.

If so, this should trouble us all.

On Wednesday a Vatican insider estimated that up to a million Italian children had been abused over seven decades. We do not know the true number because the clergy enjoy various immunities in Italy and the nation has never confronted, let alone fully investigated, the evil that has taken place within its borders. This should have led the news worldwide but scarcely merited a mention on…

View Cache

Religion should carry a health warning

I applaud Matthew Syed’s piece “A million children abused by Italian priests, and it barely makes the news” (Comment, last week). In my work as a psychotherapist, I witnessed the lifelong psychological damage experienced by survivors of abuse. It leads me to wonder: should all religious belief systems carry a mental health warning?
Tony Warren, Burgess Hill, West Sussex

Priests unfairly damned
The Catholic church is an easy target in countries with a long tradition of anti-Catholic bigotry such as Britain. A comprehensive survey of sexual abuse by priests in the US by John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York found that about 4 per cent were accused (but not all found guilty). That means 96 per cent had no accusations against them. This is comparable with many other organisations and churches.
Professor John Loughlin, fellow, Blackfriars Hall, Oxford

Fallibility must be acknowledged
It is difficult…

View Cache

A German court on Friday convicted a Catholic priest of sexual abuse of children in cases that spanned many years and sentenced him to 12 years in prison.

The Cologne state court also ordered the 70-year-old to pay three co-plaintiffs in the cases damages totaling 50,000 euros ($56,000), news agency dpa reported.

The priest was identified by local media only as Hans U.

According to the indictment, the case against the priest covered 118 counts and the youngest victim was a 9-year-old girl. The priest was taken into custody during the trial because more victims came forward and the court saw a danger of him reoffending.

The court heard that the suspect’s victims included a girl who complained of homesickness at a holiday camp and a girl to whom he was supposedly giving anger therapy.

The priest continued to have opportunities to be alone with children although the officials with…

View Cache

“We’re very let down by this open letter from Joe White,” said a 34-year-old Branson man who says he was abused by a former Kanakuk counselor now in state prison serving two life sentences.

Kanakuk camp near Branson went public late Friday with a new statement aiming to redefine its relationship with people who say they are survivors of sexual abuse that took place at the Christian summer camp.

For more than a decade, the camp has been under scrutiny for reports of sexual abuse. As the News-Leader reported in 2010, a charismatic former camp counselor, Peter Newman, pleaded guilty to sexually abusing boys and is now serving two life sentences in Missouri prisons, plus 30 years.

Eleven months ago, Kanakuk was again in the spotlight due to new reporting by journalists Nancy French and David French published by The Dispatch, a conservative-leaning news site. Much…

View Cache

Pennsylvania Bishop Daniel Gutiérrez issued the following message to his diocese on Feb. 25 outlining an investigation of child sex abuse claims against a New Jersey lay employee who previously had served for 20 years at a parish in Philadelphia. The employee, Thomas Whittemore, was terminated from parish ministry this week as the two dioceses’ investigation continues.

My Siblings in Christ,

It grieves me to tell you that several months ago, we were contacted by someone who reported that he had been sexually abused as a child by Mr. Thomas Whittemore during the time Mr. Whittemore served as the director of music at St. Peter’s Church, Pine St., Philadelphia. Mr. Whittemore was employed by St. Peter’s from 1984 to 2004 and employed from 1980 to 1983 at All Saints, Wynnewood. At the time we received the report, Mr. Whittemore was employed by a parish in the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey.

We…

View Cache

The Southern Baptist Convention’s Executive Committee has offered a public apology and a confidential monetary settlement to sexual abuse survivor Jennifer Lyell, who was mischaracterized by the denomination’s in-house news service when she decided to go public with her story in March 2019.

The committee, which acts on behalf of the SBC between its annual national meetings, announced the resolution during their Tuesday meeting in Nashville, the latest chapter in a saga that has raised questions about the handling of sexual abuse in the nation’s largest Protestant denomination. In addition to a public apology, Lyell also received a financial settlement of an undisclosed amount, according to Gene R. Besen, the committee’s interim legal counsel.

Lyell publicly disclosed she was a sexual abuse survivor after learning the man she accused of abuse, a former Southern Baptist seminary professor, had recently returned to ministry. She said she came forward with her story…

View Cache

A youth church leader in north Alabama has been arrested after authorities said she sexually abused a 15-year-old high school student.

Allison Brianna Cookston Stone, 26, of Albertville, was arrested Wednesday and charged with second-degree sodomy and second-degree sexual abuse, Marshall County Sheriff Phil Sims said.

Stone is a youth leader at the Church of God of Union Assembly in Albertville, Sims told reporters Thursday.

“That’s a position of trust in our community,” the sheriff said, according to al.com.

Stone was released after posting $60,000 bond. It was unknown if she has an attorney who could comment on her behalf.

The alleged victim in the case was identified as a teenaged boy from Boaz High School.

Authorities believe the boy’s parents “were unaware of the sexual nature” of the relationship between him and Stone, Sims said. The alleged abuse had been going on “for some time,”…

View Cache

One of the oldest Roman Catholic dioceses in the U.S. is suing four insurance companies over claims that they haven’t fulfilled contracts to provide liability coverage for sexual abuse complaints.

The Archdiocese of Santa Fe filed the lawsuit this week as it deals with a bankruptcy case involving more than 400 people who allege they were victims of clergy sexual abuse. Some of the claims date back decades.

The archdiocese hopes to raise enough money, including through insurance payouts, to settle the bankruptcy case, which has stretched over more than three years and is on its third mediator.

At least one attorney sees the archdiocese’s lawsuit as a step toward a resolution in the case, the Santa Fe New Mexican reported.

The defendants named in the lawsuit are Great American Insurance Co., Arrowood Indemnity Co., St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co. and United States Fire Insurance Co. Representatives of…

View Cache

Michael Vanderburgh is a lot of things. He is a husband, and a father. He’s a college graduate, and a former cop. He is the executive director of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul in Dayton, Ohio. He is also a survivor of clerical sexual abuse when he was a child. 

Like a lot of survivors of abuse, Michael never told anyone what he went through at the hands of a priest and family friend. He first came forward in the aftermath of the Spotlight scandals which rocked the Church in the early 2000s.

Coming forward meant that Michael, like a lot of victim-survivors, had to come to terms with what he’d been through all over again. 

Michael thought the process of coming forward ended with his home Archdiocese of Cincinnati offering him $21,000 in compensation, while acknowledging that “no amount of money can sufficiently compensate a victim of…

View Cache

A German Catholic priest was sentenced to 12 years in prison for child sexual abuse, a German court said on Friday, the latest in a string of cases that have shaken the German Catholic Church.

The Cologne district court found the man, identified in court documents as Hans Ue., guilty in a total of 110 cases between 1993 and 2018, including 23 cases of serious sexual abuse of children.

The court ordered the defendant to pay compensation to three of the nine plaintiffs for their pain and suffering.

German newspaper Sueddeutsche Zeiting said the youngest victim was 9 years old at the time of the crime, adding that three plaintiffs were nieces of the 70-year-old priest.

Court hearings in the case, underway since November last year, revealed additional potential victims and led to the priest’s detention in January, the Cologne court said.

The lawsuit is the latest case in a…

View Cache

A long-awaited public apology is to be offered by five Stormont ministers to victims of historical institutional abuse.

The compromise move comes as the offices of the First and deputy First Minister remain empty following the resignation of Paul Givan, which also forced Michelle O’Neill out of the role.

The public apology was recommended in the final report of the Historical Institutional Abuse Inquiry (HIAI), which was published five years ago.

Mr Givan and Ms O’Neill announced last month that the apology would be given in Parliament Buildings in Stormont on behalf of the powersharing executive on March 11.

However, since then the DUP has resigned the first minister role, in protest at the workings of the post-Brexit Northern Ireland Protocol, leading to doubt over whether the apology would go ahead.

It was confirmed on Thursday morning that the public apology will be offered by ministers Michelle McIlveen, Conor Murphy, Nichola…

View Cache

Survivors are calling for the remains of a Catholic priest to be exhumed from church grounds after they allege he sexually abused children.

The First Nation of Kahnawake south of Montreal will vote next month in a referendum on whether the remains of a Jesuit priest alleged to have committed sexual abuse should be exhumed and removed from the community.

Exhumation “was an idea proposed by community members, alleged victims and supporters,” Tonya Perron, one of the Mohawk Council’s elected chiefs, said in an interview this week.

“They proposed having him removed from the territory, and it started a dialogue in the community about his remains being here in the first place. We don’t have any precedent to go by.”

After the discovery last summer of what are believed to be 215 unmarked graves at a former residential school in Kamloops, B.C., several Kahnawake residents came forward with allegations that…

View Cache

Senators Melissa Agard (D-Madison) and Lena Taylor (D-Milwaukee), joined by Rep. Kristina Shelton (D-Green Bay), on Thursday, Feb. 24 released LRB-6112.

The bill requires members of clergy, like other professionals interacting with children, to report all instances of child abuse and neglect, including sexual abuse, of which they become aware in their professional capacity.

Peter Isley, Program Director of Nate’s Mission, joined Agard in support of the bill. Nate’s Mission is committed to “dismantling the structural mechanisms that allow abuse” within churches.

Agard and Isley released the following statements:

Agard: “For far too long, secrecy has clouded justice and healing for victims. It is time to put an end to keeping the known abuse of children in the shadows. This bill will hold accountable clergy and faith leaders who sexually abuse children, as well as those who have worked to hide this abuse. These are heinous crimes and an abuse…

View Cache

A disclosure by the Diocese of Bridgeport about Fr. George Maslar has us infuriated, but not surprised. A brave survivor, identified only as “Jane Doe,’” has stepped up and shared publicly about the abuse she suffered as a child at the hands of Fr. Maslar. The woman received a settlement from the Diocese last year, after notifying Church officials in Bridgeport in 2017 that she was assaulted by the priest in 1971 when she was just 15 years of age. She met the cleric when both attended prayer meetings at the Cathedral of Saint Augustine in Bridgeport.

The Diocese of Bridgeport said in response to the woman’s public disclosure of the abuse, “It is important to note that when the Diocese first became aware of the allegations in November 2017, it immediately reported them to the Connecticut State Department of Children and Family, Child Abuse and…

View Cache

Today’s sentencing of Fr. Jean Claude Jean-Philippe, CM,  a member of the Vincentian religious order, hopefully will bring closure to his victim, and we pray that she and her family, hurt by this betrayal of trust, can begin to heal. The Archdiocese of Miami deeply regrets the harm perpetrated by this priest which extends not only to the survivor of this assault and her family but to the parishioners, to priests of integrity, and to the entire community of faith. 

It is over twenty years since the leaders of the United States Catholic Church established a charter to protect children and those who are vulnerable. One hundred ninety-five dioceses in the country now have very clear and mandatory policies along with educational tools to maintain the safety of children and vulnerable adults. 

Along with proactive directives, the Archdiocese of Miami’s policy dictates immediately reporting allegations of abuse by clergy or…

View Cache

The woman claims she was abused by a priest while attending a church-run school in 1970

Editor’s note: This story contains graphic subject matter that may be upsetting to some

An Okanagan Indian Band member has sued the Catholic Church, alleging she was sexually assaulted by a priest more than 50 years ago at a Vernon elementary school that was run by the church.

The woman filed a statement of claim Feb. 22 in B.C. Supreme Court against the Roman Catholic Bishop of the Diocese of Kamloops. According to the court documents, the woman does not know the identity of the priest who assaulted her but claims the diocese does. The priest is listed as defendant John Doe.

The statement of claim states that the woman attended St. James Catholic School from 1968 to 1972. She was allegedly molested in 1970.

“In or around the spring of 1970, when the…

View Cache

A federal judge found sufficient claims of fraud allegations exist against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Harrisburg and ruled that attorneys representing sexual abuse survivors can seek a judgment to have an estimated $95 million in assets the Diocese transferred behind two different trusts moved to its bankruptcy estate.

According to the Feb. 17 ruling by Chief Bankruptcy Judge Henry W. Van Eck, the assets include $50 million in real estate like the Diocesan Campus, bishop’s residence and a retirement home for priests, all in Harrisburg, along with eight cemeteries including All Saints Cemetery in Elysburg and seven high schools including Our Lady of Lourdes Regional in Coal Township.

Also at risk of being returned to the bankruptcy estate is $45 million in furniture and appliances, cash and securities, religious artifacts and objects, vehicles, notes, records and books, according to filings with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District…

View Cache

The woman was a student at St. James School from 1968 to 1972 and was allegedly molested in 1970

Another lawsuit alleging sexual abuse has been filed against St. James Catholic Church in Vernon.

A member of the Okanagan Indian Band is claiming she was sexually abused at a church-run elementary school in Vernon when she was a child.

The woman filed a claim in B.C. Supreme Court Feb. 22 against the Roman Catholic Bishop of the Diocese of Kamloops and John Doe.

Court document state the woman does not know the name of the priest who allegedly molested her, but claims his identity is known by the diocese.about:blank

According to court documents, the woman was a student at St. James School from 1968 to 1972 and was allegedly molested in 1970.

“In or around the spring of 1970, when the plaintiff was seven years old…

View Cache

he Roman Catholic Diocese of Knoxville and its bishop have been named in a lawsuit alleging that sexual abuse allegations against a former employee weren’t investigated properly.

The complaint filed Tuesday in Knox County Circuit Court details multiple allegations of sexual harassment and abuse that a then-employee of The Cathedral of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus in Knoxville lodged against a then-assistant to Bishop Knoxville Bishop Richard Stika, news outlets reported.

The lawsuit claims that Stika overreached in his response to the abuse complaint. It says the diocese hired an outside consultant to investigate the claims, but the bishop replaced the initial investigator with someone who only interviewed the former assistant and not the employee who made the allegation, according to the lawsuit.

Stika was notified Tuesday evening of the lawsuit and attorneys are reviewing the claims, diocesan spokesperson Jim Wogan said in a statement.

“The diocese expects the…

View Cache

The number of 300,000+ mentioned in a 2021 report, now seems uncertain and is hotly debated. But the problems for the Catholic Church remains huge.

In October 2021, the Commission indépendante sur les abus sexuels dans l’Église (CIASE, Independent Commission on Sexual Abuse in the [Catholic] Church) released its report. The CIASE studied sexual abuse in a Catholic context rather than sexual abuse by the Catholic clergy only, as it also included abuse perpetrated by laypersons associated with Catholic institutions. Although the detail was overlooked by some foreign media, the CIASE was “independent” in the sense that the Catholic Church did not control its work and results, but it was appointed and funded by the French Catholic Bishops, not by the government or by any other secular institution.

The report concluded that between 1950 and 2020 the victims of sexual abuse in a Catholic context in France had been 330,000, of…

View Cache

Reports of clergy sex abuse in the Catholic Church have become so routine — and the scale of victimization and coverup so vast — that the effect is to dull the impact of each new revelation. It appears that over the course of decades, practically every higher-up in the institution knew, or should have known, what was going on.

Yet even the apparent sameness of so many disclosures and admissions, over so many years, should not blunt the importance of a recent report that Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, as archbishop of the German cities of Munich and Freising from 1977 to 1982, failed to discipline abusive priests and enabled them to maintain their roles in ministry.

Similar allegations have been leveled, and often documented, regarding many bishops. But the German report, two years in the making, implicates a future pope, who at the time was known as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger.

…

View Cache

Ellen Gable Hrkach explains how she has kept her faith even after learning that her father was a victim of abuse by a priest.

He heals the brokenhearted,  and binds up their wounds. (Psalm 147:3, Revised Catholic Edition)

 Almost four years ago, the revelations about the now-defrocked Theodore McCarrick and the Pennsylvania Grand Jury report were disturbing, especially to the most devout Catholics. Since then, many members of the Church have left in disgust. 

In the years that followed, revelations that homosexual networks exist within seminaries and dioceses have caused some Catholics to have a crisis of faith. Numerous seminarians have tried to alert higher-up prelates to no avail. It’s unacceptable that a bishop – or as in the case of McCarrick, a cardinal – would not only be complicit but also participate in the abuse. 

For every abuse reported, there are likely hundreds, perhaps thousands over the past 70-plus…

View Cache