ABUSE TRACKER

A digest of links to media coverage of clergy abuse. For recent coverage listed in this blog, read the full article in the newspaper or other media source by clicking “Read original article.” For earlier coverage, click the title to read the original article.

December 2, 2015

Bishop Peter Connors admits he had failed parishioners on paedophiles

AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald

December 2, 2015

Beau Donelly
Reporter

A former senior Catholic church official has admitted that he had no excuse for failing to escalate complaints about predator priests.

Bishop Peter Connors, who worked as secretary to archbishop of Melbourne Frank Little from 1974 to 1976, and vicar-general of the Melbourne archdiocese from 1976 to 1987, told the child abuse royal commission the former archbishop had failed to respond to complaints against clergy as late as the 1990s, despite being aware of allegations against priests decades earlier.

He agreed with Archbishop Denis Hart’s assessment earlier this week that a “paralysis” plagued Archbishop Little’s office.

On Monday, the commission heard that children were in danger of being targeted by paedophile priests for decades because of the Melbourne archdiocese’s failure to respond to complaints.
“There was a complete failure of the Archbishop and his advisors to deal with these issues,” Bishop Connors told the royal commission on Wednesday.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Duterte: I was sexually abused as a child

PHILIPPINES
The Standard

December 02, 2015

by Sara Susanne D. Fabunan and John Paolo Bencito

CATHOLIC Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines president Socrates Villegas expressed his disgust Tuesday over PDP-Laban standard bearer Rodrigo Duterte for cursing Pope Francis in a speech Monday, and denounced his adultery, killing and vulgarity as forms of corruption.

While Duterte supporters sought to do damage control, the Davao City mayor shot back at the Catholic Church, saying he was abused as a child by a Catholic priest when he was studying at the Jesuit-run Ateneo de Davao University.

“I was abused by one of you when I was young,” Duterte said, addressing himself to Church leaders who criticized him. “Priests are also corrupt.”

When pressed for details about his abuse, Duterte blurted: “The priest was holding my penis, where else?”

He said his revelations would “destroy the church and the present status of so many priests.”

“I will tell you the names of the prominent persons who were my batch mates [in the Ateneo.] All of us were victims of sexual abuses committed against minors at that time, including me. And I will tell you my story.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Duterte to CBCP: Ask me to withdraw and I will

PHILIPPINES
Rappler

Pia Ranada

MANILA, Philippines – After being slammed by the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) for cursing Pope Francis, Rodrigo Duterte said he would withdraw if the body asks, but would challenge bishops to a debate about the Catholic church’s “sordid history.”

“You priests, you bishops, you condemn me. And you suggest that I withdraw and I will withdraw, but then I will start to open my mouth. There are so many secrets that children are hiding. This religion is not so sacred,” he told reporters during an ambush interview on Tuesday, December 1.

The Church, he said, should not be quick to judge him because the institution is also not spotless.

“Bakit yung mga pari na may kaso, may asawa, may anak, bakit hanggang ngayon hindi niyo ma-criticize ang sarili niyo?” he said, visibly distressed. (How come the priests with cases, those who are married, with children, how come you can’t criticize yourselves?)

Abused by a priest?

He even hinted that he himself endured abuse in the hands of a priest during his high school years at the Ateneo de Davao.

“Kami sa Ateneo noon (We in Ateneo before), and I will tell you the abuses committed against the minors, including me, and I will tell you my story.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Bishops slam Duterte for cursing Pope Francis

PHILIPPINES
The Philippine Star

By Evelyn Macairan and Eva Visperas (The Philippine Star) | Updated December 2, 2015

MANILA, Philippines – He’s a womanizer who is worse than a dictator and does not deserve to lead the country, Catholic bishops said yesterday after Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte cursed Pope Francis in public.

The newly proclaimed presidential candidate apologized yesterday and denied cursing the pontiff.

“Is this the leadership by example that Mayor Duterte excites in us? Is this the leadership by example that makes a public official deserving of the title ‘honorable’?” Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) president and Lingayen-Dagupan Archbishop Socrates Villegas said in a statement yesterday.

“We have so many leaders in office and many more aspiring to sit in office but are they examples of good citizenship? If the leaders we choose are to be leaders for national progress they must be visionaries and exemplary,” he added.

Former CBCP president retired Lingayen-Dagupan Archbishop Oscar Cruz also warned the public that Duterte is “dangerous and worse than a dictator whom we knew once led our country.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Duterte makes sexual abuse claims vs. Church

PHILIPPINES
CNN

By Khristian Ibarrola and JC Ansis, CNN Philippines
Wed, December 2, 2015

Metro Manila (CNN Philippines) — Lingayen-Dagupan Archbishop Socrates Villegas on Tuesday (December 1) criticized Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte for supposedly cursing Pope Francis. Duterte hit back, threatening to expose alleged sexual abuse committed by members of the Church.

Duterte, a 2016 presidential aspirant, hinted that he was sexually abused by priests during his years at Ateneo de Davao High School, and said he would expose everything if the Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) continued to urge him to withdraw his candidacy.

“Kaming nasa Ateneo noon, and I will tell you the abuses committed against the minors at that time… including me,” he said.

[Translation: “When we were at Ateneo before, and I will tell you the abuses committed against the minors at that time… including me.”]

Duterte made controversial comments during his speech on Monday about the traffic jam caused by the papal visit early this year.

Villegas reacted to this, saying: “When a revered and loved and admired man like Pope Francis is cursed by a political candidate and the audience laugh, I can only bow my head and grieve in great shame.”

“Is this the leadership by example that Mayor Duterte excites in us?” he asked in his official statement.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Jesuits urge Duterte: Let’s talk about abuse

PHILIPPINES
ABS-CBN

Doris Bigornia, ABS-CBN News
Posted at 12/02/15

MANILA – The Jesuits congregation is encouraging Davao City Mayor and presidential aspirant Rodrigo Duterte to come out and talk to them about the alleged abuse perpetrated by priests against minors in Ateneo de Davao.

Fr. Nono Alfonso, spokesperson of the Jesuits, said information to be given by Duterte will be handled properly and in utmost confidentiality.

He added that the allegations of abuse against minors will be investigated. He said abuse of the clergy has no place in the congregation in line with the mandate coming from Pope Francis himself.

The priest said he does not deny the fact that there were some abuses that happened in the past that did not come out in public after victims and their families kept quiet for fear of public humiliation.

However, he also noted that the cases of abuse done by priests are not that many and are rarely recorded because the victims chose not to have them recorded.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Philippine presidential candidate alleges clergy sexual abuse

PHILIPPINES
UCA News

Joe Torres, Manila
Philippines
December 2, 2015

At least two Catholic bishops urged a Philippine presidential candidate to speak up about his allegation that he is a victim of sex abuse by priests.

“I’m begging the good mayor on bended knees to please go to the civil court, and there file a case against these priests,” said retired Archbishop Oscar Cruz of Lingayen-Dagupan.

Davao Mayor Rodrigo Duterte, a 2016 presidential aspirant, claimed that he was sexually abused by priests during his years at the Ateneo de Davao, a Jesuit-run school.

“I will tell you the abuses committed against the minors at that time … including me,” Duterte told reporters, after Catholic bishops criticized him for cursing Pope Francis in a Nov. 30 speech.

The mayor said he would expose everything if the Catholic bishops continue to criticize his candidacy.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Amazing film of how Boston Globe uncovered church pedophile scandal (VIDEOS)

UNITED STATES
IrishCentral

Niall O’Dowd @niallodowd

I was blown away by the new movie “Spotlight,” which focuses on how the Boston Globe investigative team uncovered the massive pedophile scandal within the Boston Archdiocese and how Cardinal Bernard Law led the cover-up.

The newspaper won a Pulitzer Prize for its investigation, and it was deserved recognition for uncovering a scandal that rocked the church to its foundation and identified Law as one of the most corrupt clerics in history.

Eventually the Globe’s reporting discovered 247 priests and brothers accused of abuse and over 1,000 survivors of that abuse, some as young as four or five at the time they were abused.

The investigation linked Law directly to the cover-up, after which he was spirited out of Boston by the Vatican and given a prestigious job there, probably just before he was going to be arrested.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Press Release on publication of 20 Safeguarding Review Reports – 2 December 2015

IRELAND
National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church

(Wednesday December 2nd 2015)

20 Reports Completed by the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church and Published. Penultimate Tranche Shows Progress Continuing

With only one further tranche of reviews to be completed and published it is clear that Safeguarding practice within the Church has improved and this set of 20 reviews reinforces that.

Full reviews were carried out on, The Legionaries of Christ, The Oblates of Mary Immaculate and The Mercy Sisters as all three continue to have substantial public ministry with children. The other 17 orders and congregations had a more limited review carried out as they have little or no contact with children and no allegations of sexual abuse levelled against them. All 20 reviews showed good safeguarding practice, prompt reporting of allegations to the civil authorities and to managing risk.

“What we are seeing here are a series of good habits having been created,” said Teresa Devlin, CEO, NBSCCCI (National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church in Ireland). “Reporting to the civil authorities is prompt, case files are recorded correctly and risk is properly assessed. But what is most heartening here is that child safeguarding is an engrained component of the religious life and child related activities of these Orders and Congregations. It has become a reflex and their first consideration. ”

In carrying out the full reviews of the three orders it was found that 53 allegations had been made against 44 priests, brothers or sisters between 1941 and 2009. None of them had resulted in a conviction. The 3 Orders have good liaison with the civil authority agencies who regularly advise on the management of risk and significant improvements in reporting allegations to the civil authority agencies have been noted, with no outstanding cases requiring reporting action by the Orders/Congregations.

The 17 smaller reviews included a large number of female Congregations, who are increasing in age profile, but declining in numbers along with one male order with no allegations and limited ministry with children. Among the female orders there was one allegation of emotional abuse, which has been appropriately dealt with. And those members of the orders and congregations who minister outside these congregation follow the policy and procedures of the diocese or service in which they work.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

20 Review Reports on Child Safeguarding Practice published today- 2 December 2015

IRELAND
National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church

20 Reports completed by the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the Catholic Church and published penultimate tranche shows progress continuing. With only one further tranche of reviews to be completed and published it is clear that Safeguarding practice within the Church has improved and this set of 20 reviews reinforces that.

See Review reports of congregations reviewed;

Legionaries of Christ

Mercy Sisters ( Four Provinces)

Oblates

Benedictine Monks Rostrevor

Daughters of the Sacred Heart

Dominican Nuns of St. Catherine of Siena

La Sainte Union

Little Sisters of the Assumption

Little Sisters of the Poor

Marie Madeleine Postel Missionary

Sister Servants of the Holy Spirit

Our Lady of the Cenacle

Redemptoristine Nuns – Order of the Most Holy Redeemer

Religious of Jesus and Mary

Salesian Sisters

Sisters of Perpetual Adoration

Sisters of St Clare

Sisters of the Holy Family of Emile Rodat

St Joseph of Annecy Sisters

Ursulines of the Irish Union

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

No criminal convictions in 53 allegations made against 44 members of religious orders by Catholic Church watchdog

IRELAND
Irish Independent

Sarah Mac Donald
PUBLISHED
02/12/2015

The latest tranche of audits from the Catholic Church’s safeguarding watchdog has examined 53 allegations made against 44 priests, brothers or sisters across 20 religious orders.

The allegations examined by the National Board for Safeguarding in the Catholic Church over the period between 1941 and 2009 and resulted in no criminal convictions.

The focus of the three in-depth audits were the Legionnaires of Christ, the Sisters of Mercy and the Oblates of Mary Immaculate.

Another 17 orders and congregations which have limited ministry with children and have not received allegations of child sexual abuse against their members were also examined. There was one allegation of emotional abuse, which the reviewers found had been appropriately dealt with.
The review of current practice shows considerable improvement in responding to allegations and to responding to those who come forward according to the NBSCCCI.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Cleveland pastor accused of raping children rejects plea deal

OHIO
Cleveland.com

By Cory Shaffer | cleveland.com
on December 01, 2015

CLEVELAND, Ohio — A former Cleveland pastor accused of sexually abusing four children in his parish rejected a plea deal Tuesday that would have put him in prison for nearly three decades.

Ubaldo Ocasio, 52, chose instead to fight multiple charges of rape, kidnapping, gross sexual imposition and sexual battery that could send him to prison for 205 years to life if convicted on all counts.

“He’s maintaining his innocence,” Ocasio’s attorney, Jaye Schlachet, told cleveland.com after the hearing.

His trial is scheduled to begin Tuesday afternoon.

Ocasio is accused of raping and abusing the girls, who were between the ages of 9 and 16 while he was the pastor at a small church on Clark Avenue.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Still Searching for Witches in Massachusetts

MASSACHUSETTS
Huffington Post

Dr. Anne Hendershott
Professor, Franciscan University of Steubenville

While the moral panic of Salem’s witches may be over, an equally pernicious panic continues to haunt Massachusetts — that of the pedophile priest embedded in a complicit Catholic Church determined to protect him. This narrative recently resurfaced in the Boston suburb of Revere, where a male janitor at the Immaculate Conception elementary school used a bathroom that had long been used by adults as well as students — and a student saw the janitor using the urinal. When the parent of that student complained that her child had seen the janitor in the bathroom, the hysteria began. And, although the police and Suffolk prosecutors quickly cleared the janitor of criminal wrongdoing, the Immaculate Conception School’s parish priest was removed by Cardinal Sean O’Malley, the Archbishop of Boston, and the school’s principal and second grade teacher were forced to resign.

The lawsuits have already begun. Recently, Alison Kelly, the former principal of Immaculate Conception School, filed a million dollar lawsuit against the Archdiocese. According to the Boston Globe, Kelly claims the church forced her to resign in January even though she had immediately reported the parent’s complaints to the pastor in charge of the school. Alleging that her firing was a “cold, calculated attempt by the Church to do some face-saving at the expense of innocent people,” Kelly’s attorney told reporters that the Archdiocese did not bother with a full investigation into the recent episode because “it served their own aims to appear to be taking quick and decisive action against its employees.” An attorney for the fired teacher plans to file her own lawsuit within the next weeks.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Child abuse royal commission: Senior Melbourne clergy ‘motivated to protect church’s reputation’ over abuse complaints

AUSTRALIA
ABC News

By Danny Morgan

A senior Catholic Bishop has admitted he and other leaders of the Archdiocese of Melbourne had not properly addressed child sexual abuse complaints because they wanted to protect the church’s reputation.

Appearing before the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Bishop Peter Connors also conceded senior clergy have considered whether they may be guilty of concealing a crime.

As a former Vicar-General of the Melbourne Archdiocese, Bishop Connors was aware of multiple cases of priests abusing children dating back to 1978.

He told the commission he should have done more to convince former Archbishop Frank Little to remove the priests.

It was put to the Bishop that church leaders were motivated by a desire to protect the church from scandal.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Police wrongly said priest didn’t offend when he abused girl during confession

AUSTRALIA
The Guardian

Australian Associated Press
Tuesday 1 December 2015

Police wrongly decided a Melbourne priest had committed no crime when he indecently assaulted a 10-year-old girl during confession, an inquiry has heard.

Victoria police Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana said he disagreed with the 1990 conclusion there were “nil offences disclosed”.

“I’m of the view that there certainly was an indecent assault that was committed and it should have proceeded further,” he told the royal commission into institutional responses to child sexual abuse.

Julie Stewart has told the inquiry Doveton parish priest Fr Peter Searson indecently assaulted her during confession in 1985.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Greg Kesich: Movie on revelations of priest sex abuse reminds us that victims’ pain never ends

MAINE
Portland Press Herald

Maine reporters heard the accounts of survivors too, and more may speak out in reaction to the film.

BY GREG KESICH

‘Spotlight” is a movie about journalism. If you haven’t seen it, you should.

It tells the true story of how a team of editors and reporters at the Boston Globe connected “isolated incidents” of sexual abuse by Roman Catholic priests into a 2002 series of stories that exposed an institution more concerned with protecting its reputation than it was in protecting children.

The movie shows reporters who run down leads and pore over documents. Editors have vision and guts. Stories get banged out on deadline, presses roll and the world changes.

It had to be a movie about journalism because movies are stories and stories have an ending.

It’s not that way for the survivors of child sex abuse, who can spend their whole lives trying to get back what had been stolen from them. The rest of us may get smarter and vow not to make the same mistakes, but their pain is forever.

So that’s why, I guess, when the credits filled the screen at the end of the movie, I found myself sobbing.

Back in 2002 and 2003, a big part of my life was interviewing survivors of sexual abuse by priests in Maine.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Police wrongly closed a case of child abuse against a Victorian priest in 1990

AUSTRALIA
International Business Times

By Debleena Sarkar on December 02 2015

On Wednesday, Victoria Police Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana held that the police had wrongly concluded in 1990 that a Melbourne priest had made no sexual offence against a 10-year-old girl inside a confessional. The investigation into Doveton parish priest Peter Searson was declared “nil offences disclosed” after he was accused of indecently assaulting a minor.

“I’m of the view that there certainly was an indecent assault that was committed and it should have proceeded further,” Fontana told the royal commission into institutional responses to child sexual abuse.

Julie Stewart told the inquiry that she was indecently assaulted by the priest in 1985. According to the police report in 1990, “All Searson has done is sit the child on his knee and get the child to kiss him on the cheek. Stewart stated that when she sat on his knee he dragged her up and on to his lap where she felt his erect penis rubbing on her back.”

Fontana told the commission on Wednesday that provided the evidence that was already available at that point of time, it was but quite feasible for police to at least conclude that there was some level of indecency committed.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Australia Catholic Church’s response to sex abuse was ‘a complete failure of process’, commission is to

AUSTRALIA
The Tablet (UK)

02 December 2015
by Mark Brolly

Archbishop Denis Hart of Melbourne (pictured) has acknowledged that there was “a paralysis” and “a complete failure of process” in dealing with sexual abuse allegations under one of his predecessors, Archbishop Sir Frank Little.

But he has excused his immediate predecessor, Cardinal George Pell, who governed the Melbourne church from 1996-2001 before his transfer to Sydney.

Archbishop Hart gave evidence over two days to Australia’s Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse about the Church’s handling of child sexual abuse allegations against six priests, particularly the late Fr Peter Searson, parish priest of Holy Family in Doveton, a working class suburb of Melbourne with a majority immigrant population, in the 1980s and 90s.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

December 1, 2015

Girls pregnant due to rape put in Bessborough in 1980s

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

Wednesday, December 02, 2015

By Conall Ó Fátharta
Irish Examiner Reporter

Underage girls, pregnant as a result of rape, ended up in Cork’s Bessborough Mother and Baby Home into the 1980s. The ages are revealed in maternity registers kept by the order which ran the home and released under Freedom of Information.

In 1968, a 12-year-old girl was transferred from Bessborough to St Finbarr’s Hospital in Cork, where her child was stillborn in January, as a result of “ante-partum haemorrhage”.

Maternity Record Book 40 lists a girl of 14 whose child was stillborn in 1982. The record simply states that the child “premature 33wks, gasped and died”.

In another case from 1963, a 13-year-old “private patient” gave birth to a stillborn boy. The cause of death was listed as: “Baby very poor at birth, cerebral haemorrhage”.

The Irish Examiner put a series of questions to the Sisters of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary on the subject of children in its care that were pregnant as a result of rape. These included whether or not the cases had been reported by the order to the gardaí and/or relevant authorities at the time.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Child rape victims were in Bessborough maternity registers show

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

Wednesday, December 02, 2015

By Conall Ó Fátharta
Irish Examiner Reporter

Children as young as 12, pregnant as a result of rape, were in Bessborough Mother and Baby Home into the 1980s.

Details from maternity registers, released under freedom of information, reveal between 1954 and 1987, young girls were pregnant in the institution.

The youngest child in the registers dates from 1968. The girl is listed as being just 12 and had been transferred from Bessborough to St Finbarr’s Hospital in Cork, where her child had been stillborn in January 1968, as a result of “ante-partum haemorrhage”.

However, the presence of children in Bessborough pregnant as a result of rape continued into the 1980s. For example, Maternity Record Book 40 lists a girl of 14 whose child was stillborn in 1982. The record simply states the child “premature 33wks, gasped and died”.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Ex-priest guilty of indecent assaults on pupil

IRELAND
Irish Examiner

Wednesday, December 02, 2015

Conor Kane

A former priest who wrote to the Pope asking to be laicised because of his history of “abusing young boys” has been found guilty of indecently assaulting a secondary school student in the 1980s while the priest worked as a choirmaster and music teacher.

Henry Moloney, aged 77, of Kimmage Manor, Dublin, was found guilty last night, on the unanimous verdicts of a jury, of seven counts of indecent assault, all of which took place within one school year in the 1980s.

He will be sentenced on December 15, following the preparation of a victim impact report, and has been remanded on bail.

Moloney had pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Judge upholds abuse charges against Hibbing priest

MINNESOTA
Duluth News Tribune

By Tom Olsen Today

A judge has denied a motion to dismiss the felony charges against a Hibbing priest accused of sexually abusing underage girls, setting the stage for the case to go to trial.

In an order filed Monday, 6th Judicial District Judge David Ackerson concluded that a jury should decide whether or not Brian Michael Lederer is guilty of seven sexual assault and child pornography charges.

“Considering all of the evidence in the light most favorable to the state’s position, the state has presented sufficient evidence to support a determination of probable cause to proceed to trial against the Defendant on all Counts,” Ackerson wrote in his five-page order.

With the filing of the order, not-guilty pleas were entered on Lederer’s behalf to all charges.

Lederer, 30, had challenged the sufficiency of evidence, which was based largely on the accounts of four girls who reported inappropriate touching by Lederer, who worked at Blessed Sacrament Parish and the Assumption Catholic School.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Police wrongly said priest didn’t offend

AUSTRALIA
9 News

AAP

Police wrongly decided a Melbourne priest who indecently assaulted a girl during confession had not committed an offence, an inquiry has heard.

Victoria Police Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana said the 1990 investigation concluded there were “nil offences disclosed”.

“Quite clearly there was an indecency around it and to suggest that there was none, they suggested it wasn’t a sex offence, I disagreed with. I think the whole circumstance was surrounded with indecency,” Mr Fontana told the child abuse royal commission.

“I just didn’t agree with the original assessment that there was no offence.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Priest booked for sexual assault of 13-year-old boy

INDIA
The Asian Age

A 52-year-old priest has been booked for allegedly sexually assaulting a minor boy on the premises of Christ the King church in Shivaji Nagar.

The accused has been identified as Fr Johnson Lawrence, who holds the post of a priest-in-charge at the church. On November 27, the 13-year-old victim accompanied by his parents attended the church proceedings in the evening.

After the mass ended, the boy, who was talking with his friends, stayed back on the church premises and did not leave along with his parents.

The police said after friends left the premises, the boy decided to sit on pews in the church for some time before leaving for his house, which located in the same area.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Troy priest sentenced to 27 months in fraud

MICHIGAN
The Detroit News

Candice Williams, The Detroit News December 1, 2015

Detroit — A priest who pleaded guilty to mail fraud in connection with stealing $573,000 from St. Thomas More Parish in Troy was sentenced Tuesday to 27 months in prison.

The sentence for Rev. Ed Belczak, handed down by U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Tarnow, was below sentencing guidelines and federal prosecutors’ request.

Before the sentencing, Belczak, 70, said he accepted full responsibility for his actions at St. Thomas More Parish where he was pastor for nearly 30 years.

“I was selfish,” he told the judge. “I stole money that did not belong to me.”

Belczak said he has dealt with depression and thoughts of suicide. As part of his sentence, Tarnow ordered him to undergo mental health counseling.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

**TheMediaReport.com SPECIAL REPORT** The Definitive ‘Spotlight’ Movie Review

UNITED STATES
TheMediaReport

David Pierre

Fabricated episodes. Character defamation. Devious storytelling. This is the definitive review of the new Hollywood movie Spotlight, which purports to chronicle the Boston Globe’s 2001-2002 investigation of the Catholic Church sex abuse story.

The heavily hyped Hollywood production – starring A-list actors Michael Keaton and Mark Ruffalo – professes to dramatize the paper’s pursuit of the troubling crimes committed by abusive priests in the Archdiocese of Boston.

However, after thoroughly studying the film, TheMediaReport.com’s Dave Pierre reports:

“Spotlight claims to be ‘based on actual events,’ but it does not bode well when the very first scene of the film is a complete fabrication.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Who’s Watching The Watchers?

UNITED STATES
Chicago Now

In the New Testament, Jesus calls himself the Good Shepherd. And he knows his sheep and his sheep know him. Like good sheep, they respond to the sound of his voice. They feel totally comfortable around him. More to the point, they feel safe and secure with him. He is their protector. His very presence gives them the assurance that everything is OK. This is the nature of the relationship between a shepherd and his flock.

Cardinal Bernard Law. Chicago Police Superintendent Gerald McCarthy. President Richard Nixon.

Each of these men, in their own way, were shepherds. Each of them rose to positions of great power and authority. But along with the power and authority came great responsibility. Their duty was, not unlike that of the Good Shepherd, to protect their “flock”, to make sure that each of the sheep entrusted to their care was safe and secure. Each of those men failed to live up to their responsibility. As a result, the people left in their protective custody, ended up experiencing fear, anxiety, tension, stress and betrayal.

Who can doubt we live in stressful times? There are threats both foreign and domestic, internal and external. If these threats are allowed to go unchecked, the very fabric of our society can come unraveled. That’s why any egregious shortcoming on the part of those appointed to act as our protectors is so traumatic. The failure of our leaders, whether religious or secular, represents and fundamental violation of the trust we placed in them.

What makes this betrayal so devastating is that, for the most part, the men I mentioned really didn’t do anything much themselves. No one has accused Cardinal Law of child abuse, for instance. Superintendent McCarthy didn’t shoot anyone, justified or otherwise. Richard Nixon didn’t break into the Watergate Apartment Complex. But each of them placed the defense of the reputation of an institution above their responsibility to those they were obligated to defend.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Sex abuse commission: We got it wrong on paedophile priest, say police

AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald

December 2, 2015

Beau Donelly

A paedophile priest who forced a young girl against his erect penis and made her kiss him inside a confessional had committed no offences, according to Victoria Police at the time.

Assistant Commissioner Stephen Fontana said he was surprised police closed an investigation into Doveton parish priest Peter Searson in 1990 after a victim reported being indecently assaulted by him.

Police concluded there were “nil offences disclosed” after interviewing victim Julie Stewart, then aged 15.

“All Searson has done is sit the child on his knee and get the child to kiss him on the cheek,” the police report said. “Stewart stated that when she sat on his knee he dragged her up and onto his lap where she felt his erect penis rubbing on her back.”

Mr Fontana told the child abuse royal commission on Wednesday that on the evidence available at the time police should have concluded that at least an indecent assault had been committed.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Call for victims of Tasmanian paedophile priests to come forward

AUSTRALIA
The Mercury

PATRICK BILLINGS
Mercury

THE victim of a Tasmanian paedophile priest is urging other victims to report to the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse ahead of a Hobart hearing next month.

The commission will hold a public hearing in Hobart into the Church of England Boys’ Society and the Anglican ­Dioceses of Tasmania, Adelaide, Sydney and Brisbane.

The commission wants to hear from people who have information relevant to the hearing, including allegations involving Louis Daniels, Garth Hawkins, Robert Brandenberg, Simon Jacobs and John Elliott, against whom legal action has already been taken.

One of Hawkins’s victims, Steven Fisher was ­recently interviewed by the commission’s investigators.

He was ­as a teen abused for two years in what he describes as an interstate paedophile ring.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Panel on ‘Spotlight’ film explores priest sex abuse scandal, institutional cover-up and advocacy for vict

MASSCHUSETTS
Harvard Law Today

By LEWIS RICE, December 1, 2015

The movie “Spotlight” focuses on the dogged pursuit by Boston Globe reporters to expose the Catholic Church’s cover-up of the sexual abuse of children by Boston priests. But there is much more to the story, as evidenced by a wide-ranging panel discussion of the movie last week at Harvard Law School that touched on legal issues, secrets and shame, and even a potential lawsuit against the filmmakers.

Sponsored by the Harvard Law School Library and the Dean of Students Office, the panel featured Josh Singer ’01, who co-wrote the screenplay with director Tom McCarthy; Mitchell Garabedian, who represented dozens of plaintiffs in suits against the church (and was depicted by Stanley Tucci in a prominent role in the movie); and HLS professors Jeannie Suk ’02 and Lawrence Lessig, with Professor Jonathan Zittrain ’95 moderating. In the audience were Ben Bradlee Jr. and Michael Rezendes, journalists from the Globe who were also depicted in the film, and who participated in the discussion.

Singer, whose previous credits include the television series “The West Wing” and the movie “The Fifth Estate,” described the process of creating “Spotlight,” which he began writing in 2012, and the copious research involved, including interviews with victims and Globe reporters. “We wanted to present reporting and the newsroom in a way that really hadn’t been done in many years, as accurately as possible,” he said. “We were pretty extreme in terms of hard work in trying to get the story right.”

After several clips from the movie were shown to the audience in Wasserstein Hall, Garabedian spoke of his interactions with the victims and how the cases helped validate their stories and heal some of the pain they continued to live with in adulthood. Before the victims spoke out and the Globe coverage galvanized attention around the issue, he said, “It was the worst-kept secret in Boston that these priests were molesting children. Everybody seemed to know but no one seemed to do anything about it.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Embezzling priest Edward Belczak gets 27 months

MICHIGAN
Detroit Free Press

Patricia Montemurri, Detroit Free Press December 1, 2015

The Rev. Edward Belczak was sentenced Tuesday to 27 months in prison for stealing $573,000 from the St. Thomas More Catholic Church in Troy, where he had served as pastor for almost 30 years.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Tarnow handed down the sentence.

Belczak made a lengthy plea to the judge for mercy, citing scripture and also revealing that he had suicidal thoughts because of the public humiliation.

“I have stained the reputation of being a priest,” said Belczak.

Belczak, 70, pleaded guilty Sept. 1 to one count of mail fraud in connection with the embezzlement and is paying $573,000 in restitution. Prosecutors had asked for a 37-month prison sentence. But Belczak’s supporters had sent dozens of letters to the judge asking for leniency for the charismatic priest, whose popularity had contributed to growing St. Thomas into one of the largest, most prosperous parishes in the Archdiocese of Detroit. Belczak’s attorney, Jerome Sabbota, had asked that the priest be granted probation or home detention.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Association of Catholic Priests voices ‘disquiet’ over Vatican’s selection of Irish bishops

IRELAND
National Catholic Reporter

Sarah Mac Donald | Dec. 1, 2015

The Association of Catholic Priests in Ireland is to write to the Vatican’s Congregation for Bishops expressing its 1,000 members’ “grave disquiet” over the current selection process for bishops in the Irish church.

A resolution was carried unanimously at the association’s annual meeting in Athlone Nov. 24 which criticized the “lack of any credible process of consultation” with priests and people in recent years and the Vatican’s “preference for candidates drawn from a particular mindset.”

Over 100 members of the ACP who attended the meeting backed the statement which said the choice of candidates is “out of sync with the realities of life in Ireland today” and with the openness of Pope Francis to change and reform in the church.

The priests also expressed frustration with the “apparently haphazard policy of appointments to distant dioceses that pays little regard to the traditions and heritage of a diocese.” This policy has been operated by the church in the U.S. but has only really been implemented in the Irish church under the present papal nuncio, Archbishop Charles Brown.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Darkest Taboos of Orthodox Jewish Communities Grab Spotlight at Global Convention

ISRAEL
Haaretz

Alona Ferber Dec 01, 2015

More than 1,000 ultra-Orthodox and Orthodox Jews from around the world gathered in Jerusalem this week to tackle some of their communities’ darkest taboos: sexual abuse and domestic violence. 

The three-day event they are attending, which began Monday, is the second annual conference on the subject spearheaded by the Israeli nonprofit Tahel, the Crisis Center for Religious Women and Children. Headlined “Shedding Light on the Darkness of Abuse,” the gathering offers five hands-on training tracks, including one specially tailored to rabbis and people who work at yeshivas.

That track – “Building Safe Synagogues and Yeshivas” – features sessions about high-profile abuse cases, defining offenders, abuse in marriage and other key subjects.

Tahel has organized pilot programs on these subjects in ultra-Orthodox and other institutions in Israel, Johannesburg, Sydney, Melbourne and London, director Debbie Gross told Haaretz. The idea is for this week’s trainees to implement what they learn back home, too.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

New book based on my TEDx Talk to be released Dec. 13

UNITED STATES
The Worthy Adversary

Posted by Joelle Casteix on December 1, 2015

I learned a valuable lesson from The Well-Armored Child. It doesn’t matter how important your message is if no one knows about it. So that’s why starting December 13, I will be giving away the Kindle version of THE POWER OF RESPONSIBILITY.

For the first week after its debut, you can read the book for nuthin’. And don’t worry, you don’t need to own a Kindle to read Kindle books—due to the global domination, er., I mean … universal nature of Amazon, you can read Kindle books anywhere.

Your computer and your tablet are Kindle readers. Even your smartphone can become an ebook reader …

if you are into reading books on a microscopic scale. You can also download copies for friends, neighbors, and people who need a strong push out of the trap of victimhood.

I learned that happiness and escaping victimhood (which for me was being a victim of sex abuse in the Catholic Church) boils down to six simple and easy decisions. And it’s only 58 pages.

Easy peasey.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

CBCP hits Duterte; hits back on its child abuse

PHILIPPINES
Philippine Daily Inquirer

By: Jeannette I. Andrade, Tina G. Santos
@inquirerdotnet

Archbishop Socrates Villegas didn’t think Mayor Rodrigo Duterte’s expletive against Pope Francis was funny.

“When a revered and loved and admired man like Pope Francis is cursed by a political candidate and the audience laugh, I can only bow my head and grieve in great shame. My countrymen have gone to the dregs,” said the president of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP).

In an interview with reporters on Tuesday, Duterte warned the prelates against continuing tirades against him.

“I will destroy the Church and the present status of so many priests and what they are doing,” he said. “You priests, bishops, you condemn me and suggest I withdraw, but then I will start to open my mouth. There are so many secrets that we kept as children. Do not force (me to speak) because this religion is not so sacred.”

Victim

He said he was among the victims of child abuse by priests.

“If they want, they can start it and I’ll tell everything. From my years in Ateneo [de Davao] until we grew up, and it will make them sad, very sad,” he said. “They have secrets, I have secrets.” He stressed his comment on the Pope was “inadvertence.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Broken Rites helped the Royal Commission to become aware of the Catholic cover-up

AUSTRALIA
Broken Rites

By a Broken Rites researcher, article updated 24 November 2015

Since 1993, Broken Rites has been doing research about how Melbourne’s Catholic bishops harboured a number of sexually-abusive priests. In the mid-1990s, Broken Rites began exposing these priests. Now some of these priests, from the Broken Rites list, are being investigated by Australia’s national child-abuse Royal Commission during a four-weeks public hearing in Melbourne in November-December 2015. This article will point you to the original Broken Rites research about each of these priests.

Here are some of the names from the Broken Rites list (to read a Broken Rites article on each priest, you can click on any of the following names).

* Fr Peter Searson. For many years, the Melbourne church hierarchy knew that Searson was committing sexual offences against children in parish schools but it managed to protect him from police prosecution. Obstinately the church kept him in the ministry but eventually the hierarchy was forced to put Searson on “administrative leave” to protect the public image of the church.

* Fr Wilfred (Bill) Baker. Baker worked in parishes around Melbourne — and he committed sexual crimes against children while his superiors and colleagues looked the other way.

* Fr Nazareno Fasciale (pronounced Fah-SHAH-lay). Church leaders, including George Pell, participated in a glowing tribute to this priest, who was one of the worst paedophiles in the Melbourne diocese. In 1996, when Broken Rites exposed this (and other) church cover-ups, George Pell’s diocese went into damage control, hiring a public relations firm to announce the “Melbourne Response” (a forerunner of the church’s “Towards Healing” strategy).

* Fr Kevin O’Donnell. During O’Donnell’s life of crime, his superiors and colleagues looked the other way. In his final years, he even received public praise from one of his superiors, Bishop George Pell.

* Fr Ronald Pickering. The Melbourne church authorities protected Pickering for many years while he committed crimes against children in his parishes. Eventually he fled from Australia, evading justice. The Melbourne archdiocese then began sending retirement payments to Pickering at his new address in England but they didn’t give this address to the police.

* Fr David Daniel. The church authorities kept ignoring complaints about the crimes of this priest, but eventually some of these victims spoke to Victoria Police detectives — and the police then charged Father Daniel, thus ending the church’s cover-up.

* Fr Desmond Gannon. This is another example of how the church authorities protected a criminal priest for many years until some of his victims eventually spoke to Victoria Police detectives.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Archbishop admits: I should have done more

AUSTRALIA
Sky News

Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart admits he should have done more to protect children from a paedophile priest who hit an altar boy.

A complaint that Fr Peter Searson hit the boy around the head following mass went to Archbishop Hart, then the Melbourne archdiocese vicar-general, in October 1996.

He told Searson not to go near altar servers and referred the complaint to the Melbourne Response independent commissioner, who a few days later began to handle sex abuse complaints in the archdiocese.

Child abuse royal commission chair Justice Peter McClellan said having reviewed Searson’s file, Archbishop Hart would have realised it was not only altar servers who were in danger.

– See more at: http://www.skynews.com.au/news/national/2015/12/02/archbishop-admits–i-should-have-done-more.html#sthash.AlhyPe5q.dpuf

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatican set for diplomatic clash with Italy over ‘Vatileaks’ prosecution

ROME
The Guardian

Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Rome

Tuesday 1 December 2015

Italy is facing a diplomatic collision with the Vatican over the church’s prosecution of two Italian journalists in a case that has been broadly condemned by press freedom groups.

A media watchdog that chronicles acts of intimidation against Italian journalists said Italy would have the legal right to reject any attempt by the Vatican to seek the extradition of the two journalists – Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi – if the pair are found guilty by a Vatican court of publishing classified and leaked documents.

The trial of the journalists and three former Vatican officials – who have been charged with leaking the documents – will continue next week after being adjourned on Monday. The journalists technically face up to eight years in jail if they are convicted.

“Italy very easily should and could refuse any extradition request because we have an article in our penal code that says such a request can be refused if the alleged ‘crime’ the person has been charged with is itself against the paramount principles of Italian law,” said Alberto Spampinato, a journalist and founder of the NGO Ossigeno per l’Informazione (Oxygen for information).

Another expert, Professor Giulio Illuminati of LUISS in Rome, said there was no legal framework for the Vatican to seek the journalists’ extradition because the Vatican does not have an extradition agreement with Italy. Illuminati also noted that Italy could question the fairness of the trial since the Vatican is not a signatory to the European convention on human rights.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

„Vorwürfe sind in keiner Weise haltbar“

DEUTSCHLAND
Kirchen Zeitung

[Bishop Norbert Trelle has rejected the accusation that the Diocese of Hildesheim sought to thwart prosecutorial investigations in the case of sexual abuse of a young girl. He said the accusation is outrageious.]

Mit Nachdruck hat Bischof Norbert Trelle den Vorwurf zurückgewiesen, das Bistum Hildesheim habe staatsanwaltliche Untersuchungen im Falle des sexuellen Missbrauchs eines jungen Mädchens vereiteln wollen. Dieser Vorwurf sei ungeheuerlich, jeder Fall werde akribisch geprüft, sagte Trelle auf einer Pressekonferenz am Dienstag.

Am Montagabend hatte die ARD in der Reportage „Richter Gottes – die geheimen Prozesse der Kirche“ dem Bistum vorgeworfen, 2010 einen angezeigten Missbrauchsvorwurf zu spät an die Staatsanwaltschaft gegeben zu haben. Dabei ging es um den Geistlichen Peter Riedel, der im Zusammenhang mit den Missbräuchen im Canisus-Kolleg bundesweit für Schlagzeilen gesorgt hatte. In Hildesheim hatte er unter anderem den sozialen Mittagstisch in der Gemeinde Guter Hirt aufgebaut.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Missbrauch: Bistum wehrt sich – Pater war auch in Göttingen

DEUTSCHLAND
HNA

Göttingen/Hildesheim. Das katholische Bistum Hildesheim hat Vorwürfe zurückgewiesen, 2010 einen Missbrauchsvorwurf zu spät an die Staatsanwaltschaft weitergegeben zu haben. In einem WDR-Fernsehbericht von Montagabend waren diese Vorwürfe erhoben worden.

Konkret geht es um den vor fünf Jahren bekanntgewordenen Fall des heute 74 Jahre alten Jesuitenpaters Peter R., der auch als einer der Haupttäter am Berliner Canisius-Kolleg jahrelang sexuelle Übergriffe an Schülern vorgenommen haben soll.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vorwürfe sind in keiner Weise haltbar

DEUTSCHLAND
Bistum Hildesheim

[The Diocese of Hildesheim is committed to the full investigation of the allegations in the Father R., who is accused of abuse]

Das Bistum Hildesheim setzt sich für die vollständige Aufklärung der Vorwürfe im Fall Pater R. ein. „Wir würden es begrüßen, wenn angesichts der jüngsten Entwicklung die Staatsanwaltschaft die Ermittlungen wieder aufnehmen würde“, sagt Bischof Norbert Trelle.

In der WDR-Reportage „Richter Gottes – Die geheimen Prozesse der Kirche“ wurde dem Bistum Hildesheim vorgeworfen, 2010 einen angezeigten Missbrauchsvorwurf zu spät an die Staatsanwaltschaft weitergegeben zu haben.

„Angesichts des tatsächlichen Ablaufs der Geschehnisse sind die Vorwürfe in keiner Weise haltbar“, erklärt der stellvertretende Generalvikar Weihbischof Heinz-Günter Bongartz. Nachdem die Erziehungsberechtigten im Namen des Opfers im November 2010 eindeutige Vorwürfe erhoben hatten, hat das Bistum unmittelbar die Missbrauchsanzeige zur Ermittlung an die Staatsanwaltschaft abgegeben. Das im März 2010 stattgefundene Gespräch in Begleitung der Lehrerin der 14-Jährigen hatte keine eindeutigen Hinweise auf sexuellen Missbrauch ergeben. Da sich das Mädchen gegenüber dem Missbrauchsbeauftragten aber eher verschlossen zeigte, wurde es ermutigt, mit Personen seines Vertrauens zu sprechen. „Damit wollten wir einen Anstoß geben und helfen, dass sich das Mädchen gegebenenfalls öffnen kann. Ein solches Vorgehen wird von vielen Opferverbänden ausdrücklich empfohlen“, erklärt der Weihbischof.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

An investigation into an epidemic of abuse

UNITED STATES
The Concordian

Posted by: Elijah Bukreev

The Oscar race kicks off with Tom McCarthy’s Spotlight, an awards front-runner par excellence

Before a problem can be fixed, it must first be brought to light, which can be a painful process.

Sexual abuse of children by a number of Catholic priests was ongoing for decades, and it was only in 2001 that members of The Boston Globe’s investigative unit, the Spotlight Team, took on the Catholic Church to challenge a system that effectively covered up sex crimes and allowed sexual predators to walk free.

This investigation is the focus of Spotlight, a new film drama by Tom McCarthy which shares stories of abuse survivors while paying tribute to the journalists who fought hard to let these voices be heard.

The appointment of a new editor, Marty Baron (Liev Schreiber), signals a change at the paper. Baron is an outsider—a Jewish man from Miami in a predominantly Catholic city—which gives him a broader perspective. He sees a problem and decides to use any available resources to tackle it, even if it means suing the Catholic Church.

What starts with a single case of sexual abuse by a priest in Boston becomes an investigation into an actual epidemic, as numbers of perpetrators—and survivors—grow into the hundreds, and it becomes clear that lawyers and high-ranking clergy members were involved in a cover-up.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

A Catholic Contemplates ‘Spotlight’

UNITED STATES
WBUR

Tue, Dec 01, 2015
by Rich Barlow

For Catholics, “Spotlight” landed in theaters this holiday season like the proverbial coal in the Christmas stocking. Watching the recounting of The Boston Globe’s clergy pedophile investigation resurrected old feelings in this practicing Catholic. I seethed again at the men who committed these crimes and covered them up. (Full disclosure: In my past life, I was the Globe’s freelance religion columnist, and my wife until recently worked as a reporter for the paper.)

Yet the film is actually a Christmas gift. We Catholics bear special responsibility for pondering the lessons of the scandal, and special entitlement: Those were Catholic kids molested by priestly perverts. Some Catholics are drawing lessons from the movie that are obvious, even banal — appreciation for our free press and justice system, the need for “more, not less, holiness in the priesthood.” (I’m unaware of anyone calling for less holy priests.) I believe there’s a more fundamental and valuable wisdom to be gleaned from the movie. Catholics, split between theological traditionalists and liberals, must understand that, at least on this one, the liberals were right.

I don’t mean that traditionalists who support church teachings on priestly celibacy, non-ordination of women, and the sinfulness of homosexuality and artificial contraception are wrong (though I believe they are). It’s more uncomfortable for the traditionalists than that: Their very premise in upholding those teachings is flawed. The premise is that, when one has doubts about a moral pronouncement by the church, the hierarchy should get the benefit of the doubt. It shouldn’t.

The premise itself rests on two observations. First, this church above all others is hierarchical, with a disciplined, military-style chain of command; obedience should be part of a Catholic’s calling. Second, the church has been in the business of philosophical and ethical reflection for two millennia, producing some of history’s most formidable minds (Paul, Augustine, Aquinas), and this should count for something. And does, for those of us who, when weighing moral questions, include the church among the references we consult.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatileaks 2 defendant, husband, probed

ROME
ANSA

(ANSA) – Vatican, City, November 30 – Rome prosecutors have placed Vatileaks 2 defendant Francesca Immacolata Chaouqui and her husband Corrado Lanino under investigation for suspected irregularities in the sale of San Girolamo castle near the town of Narni, judicial sources said Monday. Chaouqui, a public relations expert, is currently on trial in the Vatican along with four others for allegedly leaking confidential documents. Chaouqui and her co-defendants, investigative journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, Monsignor Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda and his former assistant Nicola Maio, all attended Monday’s hearing.

Chaouqui, Balda and Maio are charged with leaking the confidential material and Nuzzi and Fittipaldi with using it in two recently published books – one titled Avarice, the other Merchants in the Temple – documenting Vatican waste and mismanagement and lavish spending by clergymen.

Balda, who is jailed in a Vatican prison, reportedly alleged in a written statement that he and Chaouqui were lovers and that he feared she may be a secret service agent.

“I don’t understand anything,” Chaouqui said on Monday.

“There’s no evidence against me”.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Threats on the web: “This will be the last Pope”

ITALY
Vatican Insider

Four people have been arrested in anti-terrorism blitz in Italy and Kosovo. They had been promoting the jihadist ideology. Searches have been made in Brescia, Vicenza and Perugia

VATICAN INSIDER STAFF
ROME

“Remember that there will not be another pope after this one, this is the last”. The Kosovo citizens arrested today are said to have published threatening messages against the Pope. The incident emerged in the press conference held by investigators in the Italian city of Brescia. Investigators identified Imishiti Samet as being the point of reference. He was arrested in Kosovo and thought to be affiliated to Islamic State.

Investigations were launched after the group “Me ose, pa tu, Hilafeti eshte rikthy” was identified on Facebook. – which Imishiti Samet. Samet was a member of the group, which he used to spread propaganda to internauts in the Balkans and residents in Italy.

Samet’s Italian base was in an apartment in Chiari in the province of Brescia. The man’s brother, Imishiti Ismail was found here this morning and expelled.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Duterte claims he was sexually abused by a priest when he was a kid

PHILIPPINES
Coconuts Manila

On Tue night, Dec 1, Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte — in a report on GMA News’ 24 Oras — revealed that a priest sexually abused him when he was a boy.

“Duterte, 70, made the allegation amid the flak that he had been receiving from members of the clergy for his use of an expletive when he discussed “traffic hell” during Pope Francis’ visit to the Philippines,” reports GMA News Online.

Duterte stated, “[Kami] sa Ateneo noon (We were at the Ateneo then) and I will tell you the abuses committed against the minors at that time including me and I will tell you my story. Kaming lahat dumaan kami (We all went through it).”

The report noted: “The PDP-Laban presidential candidate also reacted to Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines president Lingayen-Dagupan Archbishop Socrates Villegas’ remarks on Duterte’s use of bad words.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pope jokes about explicit details in ‘Vatileaks 2’ trial

VATICAN CITY
Irish Times

Paddy Agnew in Rome

Asked about the ongoing “Vatileaks 2” trial in the Vatican, Pope Francis on Monday joked that he was glad that 15th century femme fatale Lucrezia Borgia “is not around anymore”.

The pope was speaking during his customary post-visit press conference on the papal plane on the way back from a highly successful six-day trip to Africa during which he visited Kenya, Uganda and the Central African Republic.

Inevitably the most difficult questions faced by Pope Francis did not concern Africa but the so-called Vatileaks 2 trial in which five people stand accused of having stolen confidential Holy See documents.

In recent days the trial has made headlines because of revelations about the intimate relations between the two major defendants, Spanish monsignor Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda and Vatican lay consultant Francesca Chaoqui, who both served on COSEA, a short -term Vatican economic reform commission which operated in 2013 and 2014.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Sexual assault lawsuit filed against Fellowship Bible Church

TENNESSEE
Tennessean

Collin Czarnecki, cczarnecki@tennessean.com December 1, 2015

A local family has filed a lawsuit against a Brentwood church after their 3-year-old was sexually assaulted by a church volunteer.

According to a lawsuit filed Monday, the family’s 3-year-old son was raped by a male teenage volunteer in a bathroom of Fellowship Bible Church of Williamson County during church on August 24, 2014. The teenager pleaded guilty to aggravated sexual battery.

The family left their son at the Children’s Ministry while worshiping, but they weren’t aware of the sexual assault until the following weekend.

According to the lawsuit, the church allegedly urged the family to not pursue charges and asked them to attend another church campus.

It further states that the church “sought to hide the truth about the perpetrator pedophile and about the rape of (the 3-year-old) from other families.”

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Family Files Lawsuit After Sexual Assault of 3-Year-Old At Church

TENNESSEE
News Channel 5

[with video]

BRENTWOOD, Tenn. – A local family has filed a lawsuit to hold a Williamson County church accountable after their 3-year-old was sexually assaulted at the church.

According to the lawsuit filed Monday, a teenage volunteer at Fellowship Bible Church of Williamson County raped the child in a church bathroom on August 24, 2014.

The family of the 3-year-old had been members of the church for 12 years. They were baptized and married at the church and saw the church as a second home.

On the day the sexual assault took place, the parents dropped off their two children at the Children’s Ministry for it’s care, but while there, the 3-year-old was taken into a bathroom by a teenage volunteer and sexually assaulted, but the family didn’t find out about the situation until the next weekend.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

THE GODDARD INQUIRY: THERAPY, NOT JUSTICE

UNITED KINGDOM
Spiked

LUKE GITTOS
LAW EDITOR

This huge inquiry into child abuse has nothing to do with truth.

Last week, more details were announced about the UK’s Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (aka the Goddard Inquiry). Justice Lowell Goddard, a member of the judiciary of New Zealand who was appointed chair of the inquiry in 2014, announced what the ‘first 12 investigations’ of the inquiry would focus on.

These initial investigations will cover, among other things, the Roman Catholic and Anglican Churches and the local councils of Nottinghamshire, Rochdale and Lambeth. Goddard indicated that these investigations represented the ‘first phase’ of the inquiry’s work and were ‘by no means the total of the work we intend to conduct’. In fact, Goddard has indicated in the past that the remit of the inquiry will include both public and private institutions throughout the UK, with some investigations looking back over ‘many decades’. While Goddard herself gave assurances that the inquiry would conclude within five years, many think this is unrealistic — they estimate that it could take as long as 10 years.

The Goddard Inquiry was announced by home secretary Theresa May in 2014, in the wake of the Jimmy Savile scandal. It aims to expose institutions’ past failures and make recommendations for how to improve child-protection mechanisms in the present. Of course, Goddard is going to have to work hard to surpass the litany of child-protection measures that have been introduced in recent decades. CRB (now DBS) checks and a vast array of powers enabling the criminal courts to disbar people from working with children are just some features of the contemporary framework of anti-abuse law.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Paolo Berlusconi probed for Chaouqui

ITALY
ANSA

(ANSA) – Rome, December 1 – Silvio Berluscon’s brother Paolo is under investigation by Rome prosecutors for suspected embezzlement in a Terni probe involving Vatileaks 2 defendant Francesca Chaouqui and her husband Corrado Lanino in connection with the sale of San Girolamo castle at Narni, judicial sources said Tuesday. According to Corriere della Sera, Chaouqui allegedly promised the younger Berlusconi to act on judicial requests to the Vatican regarding Silvio Berlusconi. Chaouqui is among five defendants in the Vatileaks 2 trial in the Vatican.

Earlier Tuesday a lawyer acting for Silvio Berlusconi denied newspaper reports that Chaouqui had contacted the former premier or Paolo in relation to the case.

“Premier Berlusconi has never had any contact with Francesca Chaouqui, or indications from anyone, of requests made by her,” Niccolò Ghedini said in a statement. “Besides, it would have been impossible to make demands since there is no possible link between Premier Berlusconi and ‘Vatican affairs’ or the Vatican bank,” he continued. In regards to Paolo Berlusconi, Ghedini acknowledged that he had met Chaouqui “occasionally” in social situations, but said the reports of contacts in relation to Vatileaks 2 were “unfounded”. Chaouqui, a PR expert, is on trial alongside investigative journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, Monsignor Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda and his former assistant Nicola Maio for allegedly leaking confidential Holy See documents.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Other Pontifical Acts

VATICAN CITY
Vatican Information Service

Vatican City, 1 December 2015 (VIS) – The Holy Father has:

– accepted the resignation from the pastoral care of the diocese of Nueve de Julio, Argentina, presented by Bishop Martin de Elizalde, O.S.B., upon reaching the age limit. He is succeeded by Bishop Ariel Edgardo Torrado Mosconi, currently coadjutor of the same diocese.

– appointed Fr. J. Victor Alejandro Aguilar Ledesma and Fr. Herculano Medina Garfias as auxiliaries of the archdiocese of Morelia (area 18,000, population 2,612,300, Catholics 2,455,618, priests 565, religious 1,268), Mexico.

Bishop-elect Aguilar Ledesma was born in San Guillermo, Mexico in 1965 and was ordained a priest in 1989. He holds a licentiate in family pastoral ministry from the Pontifical Lateran University and has served in a number of pastoral roles, including parish vicar, chaplain of the Clarissian Sisters and diocesan coordinator of family pastoral ministry. He is currently parish priest, episcopal vicar, member of the college of consultors and professor at the major seminary of Morelia.

Bishop-elect Medina Garfias was born in Rincon de Cedenos, Mexico in 1967, and was ordained a priest in 1996. He holds a licentiate in social doctrine of the Church from the Padre Alberto Hurtado University in Santiago, Chile. He has served in a number of roles, including spiritual director and professor in the archdiocesan seminary and chaplain of various religious communities. He is currently bursar of the major seminary of Morelia.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pope Francis orders unprecedented audit of Vatican wealth

VATICAN CITY
Irish Times

Pope Francis, galvanised by a scandal over Vatican finances, has ordered the most powerful bodies in the city-state to launch an unprecedented audit of its wealth and crack down on runaway spending.

At the suggestion of his economic chief, Cardinal George Pell, Francis has set up a “Working-Party for the Economic Future” which brings together the Secretariat of State, or prime minister’s office, the Vatican Bank and other agencies. Francis has told the panel “to address the financial challenges and identify how more resources can be devoted to the many good works of the Church, especially supporting the poor and vulnerable,” Danny Casey, director of Pell’s office at the Secretariat for the Economy, said in an interview.

The pope’s initiatives come as five people stand trial in the Vatican over the leak of confidential documents in two books published last month that described corruption, mismanagement and wasteful spending by church officials. Those on trial deny wrongdoing. Francis, 78, has pushed for more openness and transparency in Vatican financial and economic agencies but he has faced resistance from the Rome bureaucracy.

Seek corruption

On the flight back to Rome on Monday after a visit to Africa, Francis told reporters that the so-called Vatileaks II scandal was an indication of the mess that he’s trying to sort out. The trial of two former Vatican employees alongside the books’ authors highlighted Church efforts “to seek out corruption, the things which aren’t right,” he said, according to a transcript provided by the Vatican. The working group, which held its first meeting last week, will study measures to cut costs and raise revenue as part of a long-term financial plan. “This will include comparing actual expenditure against budgets at a consolidated level, which is a new initiative,” Casey said.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Catholic Church Corruption: Pope Francis Orders Vatican Audit Amid Mismanagement Allegations

VATICAN CITY
International Business Times

By Lydia Tomkiw

Pope Francis has ordered an audit of the Catholic Church’s wealth in what is being described as an “unprecedented” look into wealth and high spending, Bloomberg reported Tuesday. A “Working-Party for the Economic Future” was established with the Secretariat of State, the Vatican’s Bank and other agencies to examine corruption and mismanagement.

The panel will “address the financial challenges and identify how more resources can be devoted to the many good works of the Church, especially supporting the poor and vulnerable,” said Danny Casey, a representative from the Secretariat for the Economy.

With advice from his economic chief Cardinal George Pell, the Pope established the working group. The audit comes at moment when five people are on trial for leaking documents about wasteful spending within the church in what has been dubbed the Vatileaks scandal. The three Vatican insiders and two Italian journalists on trial could face prison terms of up to eight years, AFP reported. All five people in the highly criticized trials have been charged with releasing documents “concerning the fundamental interests of the Vatican State.”

Speaking with reporters on a flight after his recent visits to Kenya, Uganda and the Central African Republic, Pope Francis said “an error was made” with the appointment of some Vatican employees, a press statement from the Vatican said. He also said he was not surprised by the leaked information because he was aware of corruption within the church.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pope’s handpicked priest says he had sex with PR woman

ROME
The Australian

TOM KINGTON
THE TIMES
DECEMBER 2, 2015

A Spanish priest and a PR woman who are on trial for leaking Vatican secrets are engaged in a war of words amid accusations of seduction, sex and spying for the Italian secret services.

Francesca Chaouqui, a PR ­expert who was asked by the Pope to join a committee to monitor Vatican sleaze, said she was suing Father Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda, her former fellow committee member, after he reportedly claimed she pushed him into ­having sex and boasted that she was a spy.

“Everything he has stated is false and I have sued him for ­defamation,” Ms Chaouqui said. “I doubt Father Vallejo Balda would have slept with me because he does not go for women.”

Ms Chaouqui, Father Vallejo Balda and his former assistant, Nicola Maio, face up to eight years in prison if they are convicted by a Vatican court. They are ­accused of leaking information about Vatican waste and mismanagement to two Italian investigative journalists. Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, who published the leaks, are also on trial. A hearing was adjourned for a week yesterday after Ms Chaouqui, 33, appointed a new lawyer.

The Italian newspaper La ­Repubblica published a statement from Father Vallejo Balda, 54, yesterday in which he claimed Ms Chaouqui pressured him into handing confidential documents to the journalists and that she made sexual advances.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Papa Francesco, il vescovo ciellino di Ferrara: “Bergoglio deve fare la fine dell’altro Pontefice”

ITALY
Il Fatto Quotidiano

[An Italian prelate thinks the current pope should die.]l

Monsignor Luigi Negri, intercettato il 28 ottobre scorso sul Frecciarossa partito da Roma-Termini, si è sfogato con il suo collaboratore dopo l’assegnazione di due diocesi per anni in mano a Comunione e liberazione a due preti di strada: “E’ uno scandalo. Decisione avvenuta nel disprezzo delle regole. Speriamo che la Madonna faccia il miracolo”. Raggiunto dal direttore della Nuova Ferrara non smentisce: “Qualcuno ha la registrazione?”

di Loris Mazzetti | 25 novembre 2015

“Speriamo che con Bergoglio la Madonna faccia il miracolo come aveva fatto con l’altro”. Il riferimento a papa Luciani è appena velato. La frase è dell’arcivescovo di Ferrara, Luigi Negri, alto prelato in profondo disaccordo con Francesco e punto di riferimento di Comunione e Liberazione.

Negri, allievo di don Giussani, è anche noto per aver contestato la magistratura quando incriminò Berlusconi per il caso Ruby. A chi allora gli fece notare che gran parte del mondo cattolico era indignato sulla vicenda delle Olgettine, rispose: “L’indignazione non è un atteggiamento cattolico”.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Thoughts on the frenzy over the prelate who supposedly wants Francis to die

ITALY
Crux

By John L. Allen Jr.
Associate editor December 1, 2015

“Rebranding” is all the rage today in corporate communications, and one question gurus on the subject often find themselves pondering is the following: When you get a hot new CEO who succeeds in creating an appealing narrative, what happens to older stereotypes and prejudices about the brand?

If Pope Francis is any indication, what sometimes happens is that those stereotypes are re-tasked, to use another bit of corporate jargon, to support a new storyline of internal opposition to the boss.

This comes to mind in light of a controversy that’s broken out in Italy centering on Archbishop Luigi Negri of Ferrara-Comacchio, generally seen as a leader of the conservative wing of the Italian Church.

Last Wednesday, the Italian newspaper Il Fatto Quotidiano ran a front-page story based on what it described as eyewitness accounts of a conversation Negri was alleged to have had a month ago aboard a train to Rome with his priest-secretary.

In it, the 74-year-old prelate supposedly said he hopes the Madonna will work a miracle and cause Pope Francis to die, referring to the example of Pope John Paul I, who died after just 33 days. Allegedly, Negri also had some nasty things to say about recent bishops’ appointments by Francis in the Italian dioceses of Bologna and Palermo. (In both cases, the pontiff tapped men seen as center-left.)

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

French priest admits pocketing 700,000 Euros

FRANCE
Pakistan Today

A Catholic priest will be sent to court after admitting he stole more than 700,000 Euros ($741,000) collected from churchgoers and buyers of holy candles over a quarter of a century, the French public prosecutor’s office said on Tuesday.

René Heuillet, 80, admitted pocketing proceeds of regular church collections between 1987 and retirement in early 2013, plus 100,000 Euros from votive candle sales, said a statement from the prosecutor’s office in Foix, in southwestern France.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Berlusconi lawyer denies Vatileaks link

ITALY
ANSA

(ANSA) – Rome, December 1 – A lawyer acting for Silvio Berlusconi on Tuesday denied newspaper reports that Francesca Chaouqui, one of the five defendants in the so-called Vatileaks 2 trial, had contacted the former premier or his brother Paolo in relation to the case.

“President Berlusconi has never had any contact with Francesca Chaouqui, or indications from anyone, of requests made by her,” Niccolò Ghedini said in a statement. “Besides, it would have been impossible to make demands since there is no possible link between President Berlusconi and ‘Vatican affairs’ or the Vatican bank,” he continued.

In regards to Paolo Berlusconi, Ghedini acknowledged that he had met Chaouqui “occasionally” in social situations, but said the reports of contacts in relation to Vatileaks 2 were “unfounded”.

Chaouqui, a PR expert, is on trial alongside investigative journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, Monsignor Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda and his former assistant Nicola Maio for allegedly leaking confidential Holy See documents.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pope Orders Audit of Church’s Wealth as Whistleblowers Pursued

VATICAN CITY
Bloomberg Business

December 1, 2015

John Follain

Pope Francis, galvanized by a scandal over Vatican finances, has ordered the most powerful bodies in the city-state to launch an unprecedented audit of its wealth and crack down on runaway spending.

At the suggestion of his economic chief, Cardinal George Pell, Francis has set up a “Working-Party for the Economic Future” which brings together the Secretariat of State, or prime minister’s office, the Vatican Bank and other agencies.

Francis has told the panel “to address the financial challenges and identify how more resources can be devoted to the many good works of the Church, especially supporting the poor and vulnerable,” Danny Casey, director of Pell’s office at the Secretariat for the Economy, said in an interview.

The pope’s initiatives come as five people stand trial in the Vatican over the leak of confidential documents in two books published last month that described corruption, mismanagement and wasteful spending by church officials. Those on trial deny wrongdoing.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

El Salvador continues crackdown on pedophile priests

EL SALVADOR
Latin Correspondent

by Eana Maniebo | 1st December 2015

El Salvador’s Roman Catholic Church revealed that it suspended another priest for sexual abuse after a preliminary investigation.

The Archbishop of San Salvador Jose Luis Escobar announced on Sunday that Juan Francisco Galvez, a parish priest in the town of Rosario de Mora, was relieved of ecclesiastical duties after the conclusion of a preliminary investigation carried out in October 2015. Escobar said that Galvez victimized several people, but declined to give details on the victims’ identities.

Galvez denied the charges.

“I invite all those who have experienced sexual abuse from priests to come forward and directly approach me, Bishop Gregorio Chavez, or Monsignor Rafael Urrutia,” Escobar said.

He also reiterated the Catholic church’s zero tolerance towards sexual abuse.

Galvez’ case comes less than a week after the announcement of a high-profile priest’s suspension on charges of rape.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

How the mighty have fallen…

MINNESOTA
Canonical Consultation

11/30/2015

Jennifer Haselberger

Recently, parishioners and others interested in the fate of St Peter Claver Catholic School, located in what used to be St. Paul’s Rondo neighborhood, received some interesting news (see newsletter below; n.b. the newsletter is dated Fall 2014, but the content clearly indicates that it was issued in the Fall of 2015). The longtime pastor of the parish, Father Kevin McDonough, has apparently ceded operational control of the school with Father Charles Lachowitzer, formerly the Vicar General of Archbishop John Nienstedt, taking over as ‘canonical administrator’. Father McDonough, who has been heavily implicated in the sexual abuse scandal rocking the Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, remains as pastor of St. Peter Claver parish and, presumably, Incarnation/Sagrado Corazon in Minneapolis.

If this news has you scratching your head, you are not alone. Since Father McDonough remains pastor (and therefore is the legal representative and decision maker for both the parish and school), Father Lachowitzer’s position as ‘canonical administrator’ is at best the result of a gentleman’s agreement and at worst a legal fiction. Moreover, while Lachowitzer certainly has experience with school administration, that experience is hardly without blemish. His last stint overseeing a Catholic school was at Faithful Shepherd in Eagan, where he supervised a mixed gender K-8 program along with the now-restricted Father Joseph Gallatin.

Still, you can’t fault the Archdiocese for taking steps to ensure that St. Peter Claver School is no longer subject to the creative administrative practices of Father McDonough. I have alluded in earlier posts to some of the more….interesting…means that the school has used to remain afloat, and the newsletter hints at others. And, there is certain irony to the fact that an administrator has been imposed upon Father McDonough, as that particular technique for dealing with a difficult situation was created by him as a means to deal with problem priests who he nonetheless felt should be permitted to serve in parishes (e.g. Father John Bussmann at the parishes that became Mary, Queen of Peace).

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatican must free authors

PENNSYLVANIA
The Times-Tribune

BY THE EDITORIAL BOARD
Published: December 1, 2015

Iran’s imprisonment of Washington Post reporter Jason Rezaian for espionage is a farce, the sort of thing that the West has come to expect from Tehran in the corrupt theocracy’s perpetual quest for leverage.

But, unfortunately, persecution of journalists is not confined to the Middle East.

The Vatican has decided to prosecute two Italian journalists, Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, for their books on mismanagement of Vatican finances, internal resistance to Pope Francis’s reforms and other disclosures.

Since the reporters are Italian and the Vatican is a separate state within Italy, the reporters easily could have evaded arrest simply by staying outside the Vatican’s territory. They responded to the arrest summons to further expose Vatican corruption, even though each could face up to eight years in prison. The Vaticans’ conduct has been condemned by the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe.

Also facing trial are a Spanish monsignor and two Vatican staffers who allegedly leaked information to reporters. The case was supposed to begin Monday but was delayed to Dec. 7.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

How a decision by Melbourne church leaders was revealed, after 10 years

AUSTRALIA
Broken Rites

By a Broken Rites Australia researcher.

This Broken Rites article demonstrates how three Catholic Church leaders in Australia — Archbishop Francis Little, Archbishop George Pell and Archbishop Denis Hart — allowed a Melbourne priest (Father Barry Robinson) to continue ministering after he admitted having sex with a 16-year-old boy.

According to documents filed in a United States court, Father Robinson has admitted having sex with the boy on three occasions on church premises during a visit to the Boston diocese in the United States. Father Robinson left the United States in April 1994 before U.S. civil authorities could queston him about the matter.

Church leaders managed to keep the Boston matter a secret for the next ten years. The silence was broken in January 2004, when a U.S. legal firm instigated civil action against the Boston diocese on behalf of victims of Boston clergy. The legal firm had obtained discovery of church documents, which the firm filed in court, relating to the Boston diocese’s handling of clergy sexual abuse. Among the church documents (filed in court) was some material relating to Fr Barry Robinson. The church documents regarding Robinson were reported in an article in the Boston Globe newspaper on 14 January 2004.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Sex abuse commission: Church suppressed complaints to protect its reputation, says Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart

AUSTRALIA
Sydney Morning Herald

December 1, 2015

Beau Donelly
Reporter

Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart has admitted the Catholic Church buried complaints against clergy accused of sexually abusing children and misled parishioners by allowing paedophile priests to resign for health reasons.

On Tuesday the child abuse royal commission turned its focus to paedophile priests including Nazareno Fasciale, who retired four decades after allegations of child sex abuse against him were first referred to senior church officials.

Archbishop Hart agreed the church suppressed complaints to protect its reputation and that the response by senior officials in the Fasciale case was “totally unacceptable”.

Fasciale went overseas on extended leave after a 1954 complaint that he molested two sisters, and a 1960 complaint that he indecently assaulted a third girl.

He returned to Australia and became parish priest at Yarraville in 1973, but was sent for treatment by then Archbishop James Knox after concerns were raised about his conduct with young boys.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatican Prosecutions of Journalists Generate Criticism, Questions

VATICAN CITY
National Catholic Register

BY EDWARD PENTIN 11/30/2015

VATICAN CITY — The world’s largest intergovernmental security organization, Italian media associations and members of the Italian legal profession have criticized a Vatican court for indicting two Italian journalists for publishing leaked confidential Vatican documents.

The Vatican is standing firm by its decision, and its lawyers insist it is not trampling on rights to freedom of speech.

But questions are being raised about consistency in the Vatican’s approach, as some other recent breaches in confidentiality among those in senior positions appear to have taken place in recent years with impunity.

Last Monday, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe called on the Vatican to withdraw criminal charges against two journalists, Emiliano Fittipaldi and Gianluigi Nuzzi, after they published the confidential information in two new books. “Journalists must be free to report on issues of public interest and to protect their confidential sources,” said Dunja Mijatovic, said the OSCE’s media freedom representative.

The Vienna-based organization, whose 57 member states include the Holy See, was formed during the Cold War to monitor conflicts, election observation and media rights.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Report to commission condemns Jehovah’s

AUSTRALIA
9 News

AAP

Jehovah’s Witnesses in Australia foster distrust of secular authorities and the church’s way of responding to child sex abuse falls short of best practice, it is open to the royal commission to find.

In a damning submission published on Tuesday, Angus Stewart SC, counsel to the child abuse commission, recommends 77 adverse findings against the fundamentalist church, which since 1950 has received 1066 allegations against its members and never reported any of them to police.

Mr Stewart’s recommendations arise out of a public hearing into the Jehovah’s Witnesses and its oversight body, the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Australia, in July this year.

He said the Witnesses receive approximately three and four reports of allegations of child abuse a month.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Jehovah’s Witness group caned by abuse royal commission submission

AUSTRALIA
The Australian

DECEMBER 1, 2015

Tessa Akerman
Reporter
Melbourne

Counsel assisting the child sex abuse royal commission has made damning submissions of 77 potential findings regarding the Jehovah’s Witness organisation.

They include that the policy of shunning those who leave the organisation is in conflict with the belief that Jehovah God is a compassionate god.

In submissions published today, Angus Stewart SC said the Jehovah’s Witness organisation receives three to four reports of allegations of child sexual abuse each month and since 1950 the Jehovah’s Witness organisation has received allegations of child sexual abuse against 1006 of its members relating to at least 1800 victims.

He submitted in that period, the organisation has not reported a single allegation to the police or other authorities, even though 579 of those against whom allegations were made confessed to having committed child sexual abuse.

He submitted it was open for the commission to find that it is the policy and practice of the Jehovah’s Witness organisation in Australia not to report allegations of child sexual abuse to the police or other authorities unless required by law to do so.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Church welcomes England and Wales abuse inquiry

UNITED KINGDOM
Catholic Herald

by Madeleine Teahan
posted Tuesday, 1 Dec 2015

The Catholic Church has welcomed the launch of an independent inquiry into child sex abuse in England and Wales and will also set up a council to assist with inquiries.

The national inquiry will examine 12 different institutions and locations, including the Anglican Church, Rochdale Council and Westminster and will be chaired by Judge Lowell Goddard.

Baroness Nuala O’Loan will chair the Church council assisting the national inquiry, with other representatives from the Catholics Bishops’ Conference and the Conference of Religious.

Baroness O’Loan said: “The role of the council is to facilitate and ensure the proper response to the Enquiry, which has the Church’s full support. We look forward to hearing their specific requests and will ensure full co-operation with their deliberations.”

The 12 establishments which will be investigated are Lambeth Council; Nottinghamshire councils; Rochdale Council; the Anglican Church; the Catholic Church; custodial institutions; residential schools; the internet; child exploitation by organised networks; children outside of the UK; reparations for victims and survivors and Westminster.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

‘Spotlight’ on America’s Conscience: The Church, Jameis Winston and Refugees

UNITED STATES
Huffington Post

Kevin Walsh
Creator: MyMediaDiary.com, Media Educator, Video Producer of “Digging Detroit”

Michael Keaton’s character, Walter “Robbie” Robinson, in the newly-released Spotlight, is seeking Boston Globe confirmation of the Archdiocese cover-up for 70 priests involved in child molestation. He passes the list to his longtime friend and attorney, “We all knew something was going on.”

His friend kicks him out of his house and then follows Robbie into the street and asks him why he didn’t do anything — if he knew something was going on.

Robbie pauses and can only say, “I don’t know.”

Spotlight ‘s portrayal of the 2001 investigation by the Globe’s Spotlight unit (Keaton, Mark Ruffalo, Rachel McAdams and Brian d’Arcy James) is an excellent snapshot of an entire city looking the other way. When a representative of a survivor’s group brings his box of evidence to the Globe office and is asked, “Why now? Why hasn’t this been a bigger story before?” he informs them that he had already sent the box years earlier. The collective head-hanging matches that after his earlier question, if they were Catholic (not practicing).

“I don’t know” accurately sums up America’s foggy morals as it addresses refugees, gun-violence and college sexual assault while struggling, perhaps, to re-grow its conscience.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Royal Commission to hold public hearing into Church of England Boys’ Society

AUSTRALIA
Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse

The Royal Commission will hold a public hearing commencing Wednesday 27 January 2016 at the Federal Court in Hobart.

The scope and purpose of the public hearing is to inquire into:

1. The experiences of survivors of child sexual abuse by lay people and/or clergy involved in or associated with the Church of England Boys’ Society.

2. The responses of the Church of England Boys’ Society and the Anglican Dioceses of Tasmania, Adelaide, Sydney and Brisbane to allegations of child sexual abuse made against lay people and/or clergy involved in or associated with the Church of England Boys’ Society, including Louis Daniels, Garth Hawkins, Robert Brandenberg, Simon Jacobs and John Elliott.

3. The systems, policies and procedures in place within the Church of England Boys’ Society and the Anglican Dioceses of Tasmania, Adelaide, Sydney and Brisbane in relation to:

— 1.youth camps and activities

— 2.raising and responding to concerns and complaints about child sexual abuse.

Any related matters.

Any person or institution who believes that they have a direct and substantial interest in the scope and purpose of the public hearing is invited to lodge a written application for leave to appear at the public hearing by 15 January 2016.

Applications for leave to appear should be made using the form available on the Royal Commission website.

Leave to appear will generally be granted when an applicant:

a. has been summoned to give evidence

b. is an institution, or is a representative of an institution, that is subject to the inquiry to be undertaken

c. may be the subject of an adverse allegation.

It is not essential for a person who will appear as a witness in a hearing to apply for leave to appear – witnesses may appear and give evidence without applying for leave.

The form should be lodged with the Royal Commission via:

Email: solicitor@childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au; or Mail: GPO Box 5283, Sydney NSW 2001.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Submissions for Jehovah’s Witnesses public hearing published

AUSTRALIA
Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse

1 December, 2015

The Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse has published the written submissions for the Jehovah’s Witnesses public hearing on its website.

The hearing, which commenced on 27 July this year in Sydney, inquired into Jehovah’s Witnesses and Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Australia Ltd.

It heard from survivors of child sexual abuse within the Jehovah’s Witnesses Church in Australia.

The submissions can be found on Case Study 29 page.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Jehovah’s Witnesses ‘fostered distrust’ of secular authority – royal commission counsel

AUSTRALIA
The Guardian

Australian Associated Press
Tuesday 1 December 2015

A damning submission to the royal commission on child sexual abuse has recommended 77 adverse findings against the Jehovah’s Witnesses in Australia.

It was open to the commission to find the church fostered distrust of secular authorities and its response to child sexual abuse fell short of best practice, counsel to the commission Angus Stewart QC found in his submission, published on Tuesday.

Since 1950 the church has received 1,066 allegations against its members and did not report any of them to police.

Stewart’s recommendations arise out of a public hearing into the Jehovah’s Witnesses and its oversight body, the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Australia, in July.

He said the Witnesses received about three or four reports of allegations of child abuse a month.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Sodalitium Christianae Vitae forms ethics commission amid investigation of founder

PERU
Catholic World Report

December 1, 2015

Lima, Peru, Dec 1, 2015 / 12:08 am (CNA).- The superior general of the Sodalitium Christianae Vitae has announced the creation of an Ethics Commission for Justice and Reconciliation to assist and offer proposals amid investigations following accusations against its founder.

“In the last few weeks, we have seen with pain and shame the disclosure of credible accusations about the grave misconduct and abuse committed by Luis Fernando Figari and other members of the Sodalitium of Christian Life. These accusations need to be clarified,” said Alessandro Moroni Llabrés, superior general of the group, in a Nov. 25 statement.

“To ensure the highest level of rigor and impartiality in this task we have called together a group of professionals, recognized for their quality and independence, to be part of an Ethics Commission for Justice and Reconciliation. Its aim will be to review what has happened, offer the highest level of assistance possible for victims and to propose the necessary (actions).”

The new commission includes Manuel Sánchez-Palacios Paiva, former president of the National Jury of Elections and spokesman for the Peruvian Supreme Court; Rosario Fernández Figueroa, a lawyer and former president of the Peruvian Justice Council; Bishop Carlos Enrique García Camader of Lurin; Maíta García Trovato, a surgeon with a specialization in psychiatry, former general director of the Peruvian National Institute of Mental Health; and Miguel Humberto Aguirre, a journalist and director of content for the RPP Group.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Spotlight shines brightest at NY’s Gotham Awards

UNITED STATES
RTE (Ireland)

Best Film.

Spotlight also took the award for Best Screenplay (Tom McCarthy and Josh Singer), with its cast, which includes Michael Keaton, Rachel McAdams, Stanley Tucci and Mark Ruffalo, sharing the previously announced Special Jury Prize for Best Ensemble.

The film tells the true story of US newspaper The Boston Globe’s Spotlight team and their work in exposing the global cover-up of clerical sexual abuse by the Catholic Church. Directed by Tom McCarthy (The Visitor, The Station Agent), Spotlight will be released in Irish cinemas on January 29.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Diocese of Camden continues to focus on protection of Children

NEW JERSEY
Catholic Star Herald

From the Office of Child and Youth Protection

The children of South Jersey have always been and will always be among the primary concerns of the Diocese of Camden. Throughout our Catholic schools, religious education programs, and various diocesan and parish ministries, we remain committed and vigilant to protecting the children and youth that we serve.

Through the years, the diocese has actively engaged and improved our policies and procedures regarding the safety of all children. Efforts in this area were further strengthened by the publication of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People in 2002.

Using the charter as a guideline, the Diocese of Camden has been active in ensuring the safest possible environment for those entrusted to its care. Criminal history background checks based on the fingerprints of all those who have regular contact with children, child abuse prevention (CAP) training to both alert children to be watchful of potential abuse and adults to be on the lookout for it, and a Memorandum of Understanding with the New Jersey Attorney General to facilitate the immediate reporting of any abuse, are among the steps that have been taken to protect the young and the vulnerable.

Rod J. Herrera, a licensed clinical social worker and the director of the Office of Child and Youth Protection, has headed this office since it was established in 2004. “The protection of children is a group effort. It is not just this office, but parish safe environment coordinators, youth ministers, school principals and others, all working together with the guidance of this office to ensure the children entrusted to our care are safe,” he said.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Unholy secrets tumble out in sex abuse commission

AUSTRALIA
International Business Times

By Ritwik Roy @ritwikroy
December 01 2015

The royal commission has heard that a “paralysis” plagued the Catholic Church’s response to abuse allegation for decades and that made innocent children vulnerable to the dangers from paedophile priests. Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart appeared before the child abuse royal commission and blamed top church officials including Archbishop Frank Little for the situation. However, he did not criticize his predecessor Cardinal George Pell.

According to The Sydney Morning Herald, Archbishop Hart described processes followed by Melbourne Archdiocese as a “complete failure” when it came to dealing with paedophile issues. He also described the allegations referred to Doveton parish Catholic education officials as “just a horror story.”

“What is now apparent to me is that there was knowledge and a failure to act. I have just been totally appalled by the extent and the depravity of the offenders and the suffering and ruination of lives of the survivors,” he said.

In another shocking revelation, the commission has heard that in 1968, paedophile priest Father Wilfred “Bill” Baker had no qualms disclosing heartlessly the confessions of a 13-year-old altar boy BTU. He was an assistant priest at St Mary’s Parish and chaplain of St Mary’s Boys School in St Kilda East. Baker disclosed the child’s confessions to notorious paedophile priest Ronald Pickering so that he was abused more by the latter, reports The Guardian.

“By mentioning it to Fr Pickering, Fr Baker clearly had no hesitation in breaking the seal of my confession to him and also Fr Pickering appeared to be agitated and was clearly concerned about this,” said BTU.

BTU revealed that the abuse made him tremendously confused as a child as he was always taught how holy priests are and how they are just next to God. However, whatever Father Pickering was doing to him was not at all in line with Christian teachings. BTU was abused by Pickering till the age of 23 which broke him completely.

In 1976, predator priest Baker started sexually abusing a 12-year-old BTO while his parents were asleep in another room. He ultimately told his mother, an assistant priest in 1978. Forty years later, BTO is overwhelmed to see that someone (the royal commission) cares.

In 1999, Baker was convicted for sexually abusing BTO and seven other boys between 1960 and 1979. Although BTO’s family received $35,000 as compensation from archdiocese’s Melbourne Response scheme, it made him feel dirty.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Child abuse royal commission: Archbishop Denis Hart admits he was aware of complaints against abusive priest

AUSTRALIA
ABC News

By Danny Morgan

The Archbishop of Melbourne has admitted he should have done more to remove a violent priest who was alleged to have sexually abused children.

In 1996 Denis Hart received a complaint that Father Peter Searson, a parish priest, had hit a boy in the head.

Archbishop Hart told the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse that at the time, he would have checked Searson’s file and been aware of a long list of other complaints, including child sexual abuse.

However, he let Searson remain as parish priest in charge of a local primary school for another four months, only restricting his contact with altar boys.

Archbishop Hart told the hearing that in hindsight, more should have been done at the time.

Commission chair Justice Peter McClellan: You would have realised from the file it wasn’t just that group that was in danger, it was everyone?

Archbishop Denis Hart: I’d have to say that now, your honour, yes.

Justice McClellan: You didn’t realise that then?

Archbishop Hart: Well, I was relying very much on proper advice because there were a number of matters coming across the desk and I think I did what I thought at the time. On reflection, of course I’d have to say more should have been done.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Church cover-up of abuse wrong: Hart

AUSTRALIA
SBS

AAP

The Catholic Church buried child sex abuse complaints and engaged in a cover-up to protect its reputation, Melbourne’s archbishop says.

Archbishop Denis Hart says the church missed numerous chances to stop predatory pedophile priests.

He says his predecessor Frank Little endangered children by failing to act on credible information about abuse by Fr Wilfred Baker, Fr Nazareno Fasciale and Fr Ronald Pickering.

“(Baker is) an utterly appalling case of terrible sexual abuse and an example, along with Fasciale and Pickering, of the archbishop failing to act on credible information about criminal abuse by a priest,” Archbishop Hart said.

Priests were moved to another parish after abuse complaints and parishioners were not told the real reason they left, the child abuse royal commission heard.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

November 30, 2015

EL PARAÍSO DE LOS LEGIONARIOS

MéRIDA (MEXICO)
Corta Mortaja [Tehuantepec, Oaxaca, Mexico]

November 30, 2015

By Emiliano Ruiz Parra

Read original article

La Legión de Cristo goza de un poder desmedido en Cancún y varias poblaciones de Quintana Roo. La prelatura Cancún-Chetumal, a cargo de los legionarios desde 1970, ha servido a la congregación religiosa para refugiar a sacerdotes acusados de pederastia o para desterrar a algunas voces críticas dentro de su comunidad. También se han apropiado de terrenos públicos y proyectan construir una basílica que podría tener un fuerte impacto ecológico. Todo esto ocurre con la complicidad del Estado y bajo la siniestra presencia de su fundador, el fallecido Marcial Maciel. 

“Lo difícil es encontrar una iglesia en Cancún que no sea una invasión…” 

Los Legionarios de Cristo siempre cuentan dos historias: una versión oficial —cargada de designios divinos— y una verdad disidente. Durante sesenta años la Legión sostuvo, por ejemplo, que Marcial Maciel —su fundador— era un santo en vida. Pero después tuvo que reconocer lo irrefutable: que había sido un pederasta, drogadicto, mitómano y había abusado hasta de sus hijos.? 

En la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal, a cargo de los Legionarios de Cristo desde 1970, también se cuentan dos historias.[1] La versión oficial retrata la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal como la abnegada evangelización del pueblo maya y de los cientos de miles de inmigrantes que poblaron el Caribe mexicano con el auge del turismo. Llegaron cinco sacerdotes legionarios y, 45 años después, se multiplicaron a 75. Encontraron siete parroquias y en menos de cinco décadas construyeron más de cincuenta. Y se adaptaron a uno de los crecimientos demográficos más acelerados del país, pues Quintana Roo pasó de menos de 90 mil habitantes a un millón 600 mil entre 1970 y 2015. 

Sin duda, una parte de esa versión es cierta. Los números son reales y los legionarios gozan de influencia en la entidad. Algunos de sus sacerdotes se han entregado con convicción a sus labores religiosas, ya sea en comunidades indígenas o en barrios de trabajadores. Pero esa verdad oficial convive con la versión de los críticos de la Legión de Cristo, algunos de ellos, ex legionarios que conocieron las entrañas de la congregación y se han convertido en sus denunciantes más elocuentes. 

Según la versión de los críticos, la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal ha funcionado como una “Siberia tropical” para relegar a los elementos indeseables, ya fueran sacerdotes acusados de pederastia o elementos críticos con la línea oficial de la Legión de Cristo. Según ellos la prelatura se ha usado como un gran negocio, al ser explotada como un polo de bodas en hoteles de lujo.? 

En la historia oficial, el Vaticano les pidió a los legionarios encargarse de Quintana Roo en 1970 y “ni el profeta más santo […] se iba a imaginar la explosión demográfica”. Según la versión alternativa, que cuenta el ex legionario Pablo Pérez Guajardo, Maciel cabildeó la prelatura para los legionarios porque poseía información —debido a su cercanía con el secretario de Gobernación, y luego presidente, Luis Echeverría— de que el Estado mexicano invertiría grandes sumas de dinero para desarrollar un gran centro turístico en el Caribe.? 

La región ha vivido, según la versión oficial, “una frenética cruzada por dotar a la prelatura de templos dignos para el culto”.[2] La versión alternativa acepta este hecho, pero acusa a los legionarios de invadir áreas verdes y apropiarse de espacios públicos para construir iglesias. En su expansión, la prelatura contó con el apoyo de un empresario hotelero, Fernando García Zalvidea, que estuvo preso trece meses por lavado de dinero del Cártel de Juárez, y luego fue absuelto. 

Este 21 de noviembre, la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal cumple 45 años, todos ellos bajo el control de los Legionarios de Cristo, la congregación que fundara Marcial Maciel el 3 de enero de 1941 en un sótano de la colonia Juárez de la Ciudad de México. Los legionarios, ahora, emprenden dos obras monumentales: la construcción de la basílica de Santa María Guadalupe del Mar, un templo de 110 metros de altura que pretenden convertir en el ícono de Cancún, con un costo anunciado de unos doce millones de? dólares; y un seminario de 57 millones? de pesos con alberca olímpica y canchas de futbol y basquetbol y capacidad para cien seminaristas. 

Los pederastas 
Cuatro seminaristas se acercaron al sacerdote Juan José Vaca, director espiritual del seminario de Ontaneda, España. Le revelaron que el rector, el padre Jesús Martínez Penilla, se los había llevado a la cama y los había masturbado. Por las confesiones de los niños se deducía que los abusos llevaban ya dos o tres meses. Vaca de inmediato le informó a Marcial Maciel por teléfono. 
—No te preocupes, habla con los apostólicos [las víctimas] y procura tranquilizarlos. Pídeles que no les digan nada a sus papás—, le dijo Maciel. 

En tres horas, Martínez Penilla había tomado el tren a Madrid. De ahí abordó un avión a la ciudad de México y de inmediato salió a Chetumal, en donde se puso a las órdenes de Jorge Bernal, el legionario de Cristo que era administrador apostólico de la prelatura, designado por Maciel Degollado.[3] Corría el año de 1970 y el papa Pablo VI acababa de encargarles la prelatura de Chetumal a los Legionarios de Cristo. 

A miles de kilómetros de sus víctimas, Martínez Penilla apareció en la primera fila de las más importantes ceremonias de la prelatura. El 19 de marzo de 1974 flanqueó a Jorge Bernal por las calles de Chetumal durante la consagración de éste último como obispo prelado. En una fotografía se aprecia a cuatro mitrados que los siguen en procesión.[4] 

Martínez Penilla desarrolló una carrera como párroco en la prelatura. El directorio eclesiástico de 1991 lo registra al frente del templo de la Inmaculada Concepción, en Bacalar. En el mismo directorio, pero de 2007, aparece como responsable de la parroquia de Nuestra Señora del Perpetuo Socorro en el municipio de José María Morelos.? 

Para 2010 había cambiado nuevamente de adscripción. En la página 43 de Una Iglesia de corazón misionero hay dos imágenes del sacerdote: en una de ellas se le ve leyendo un libro, quizá los evangelios, en una banca; en la segunda fotografía lo flanquean 18 personas. Son parte de su comunidad en el templo de la Inmaculada Concepción de María de Isla Mujeres. 

Cuando Juan José Vaca estaba a punto de salir de la Legión de Cristo le escribió una extensa carta a Marcial Maciel fechada el 20 de octubre de 1976. En ella le reprochaba una década de abusos sexuales que habían empezado en 1949. Vaca revelaba los nombres de veinte legionarios que habían pasado por situaciones similares a la suya. Entre ellos había tres sacerdotes que trabajaban en la prelatura: Javier Orozco, Ángel de la Torre y Jesús Martínez Penilla. 

La prelatura, sin embargo, albergó un caso más grave que el de Martínez Penilla. En el capítulo “El caso del Instituto Cumbres, 1983” de?Marcial Maciel, el historiador Fernando M. González detalla la primera historia de abuso sexual de la Legión contenida en expedientes judiciales.? 

Una madre de familia (a quien González identifica como Elsa N) denunció los abusos sexuales sufridos por su hijo a manos del prefecto de disciplina, un laico de nombre Eduardo Enrique Villafuerte Casas Alatriste. La justicia mexicana atrapó a Villafuerte y lo condenó a 18 años de cárcel. El examen médico comprobó las violaciones sexuales. En ese entonces, el director del Instituto Cumbres (una preparatoria de los Legionarios de Cristo) era el sacerdote Eduardo Lucatero Álvarez.? 
En su declaración ministerial, consignada en la averiguación previa 163/83, del 7 de junio de 1985, Villafuerte acusa que Lucatero “tuvo conocimiento de los hechos, y se concretó únicamente a despedirlo de su empleo, y a avisarle a su familia, aconsejándole que abandonara el país porque iba a tener problemas”. Villafuerte relata que no era el único abusador de niños en el colegio. Identifica a Guillermo Romo, Francisco Rivas y Alfonso NJ como otros empleados del Cumbres que tocaban a los niños.? 

“Que también sabe y vio en ocasiones al subdirector [sic] confesando a los menores, y que dicho [sujeto] se llamaba Eduardo Lucatero (LC), el cual también se llevaba a las niñas, hermanas de los menores y les acariciaba sus partes nobles obscenamente”, continúa. Sin embargo, al sacerdote Lucatero sólo se le impuso una multa por encubrimiento. 

Antes de acudir a las autoridades ministeriales, una de las madres de las víctimas acudió a las del plantel. Fue un error. “Mi vida cambió totalmente. Perdí el trabajo por culpa de los legionarios, perdí mis amistades de toda la vida, mi dinero, mi condominio, y de la noche a la mañana haga de cuenta que se me abrió un hoyo. Son gente muy poderosa. Me amenazaron, me trataron de sacar del periférico varias veces con un auto Mustang para que no fuera a juicio”, le contó a González.? 

Lucatero Álvarez terminó en la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal, que nunca disimuló su presencia en el Caribe. En la tercera de forros de?Una Iglesia de corazón misionero?se le ve en segunda fila entre el clero de Quintana Roo, con ornamentos sacerdotales y en oración. El grupo lo encabeza el obispo Pedro Pablo Elizondo.? 

El mismo volumen lo registra como sacerdote adscrito a la catedral de la Santísima Trinidad, en Cancún. En una fotografía (página 85) aparece en el extremo derecho de un grupo de veinte personas que posan delante de la fachada de la catedral. Alto, de lentes, guayabera y crucifijo al hombro, posa con una sonrisa.? 

En el?Directorio eclesiástico 2 014?de la prelatura se le consigna como sacerdote del clero religioso. El directorio lo identifica como titular de la Dimensión de la Doctrina de la Fe en la Pastoral Profética. Es decir, era el “guardián” de la disciplina y el cumplimiento de los dogmas en la Iglesia de Quintana Roo. 

El perro, el vino y el psiquiatra 
Pablo Pérez Guajardo se pasaba el día adormilado. Su depresión no desaparecía a pesar de la ingesta de pastillas. Hasta que decidió dejar de tomar su dosis de diazepam y dárselas al perro de raza pastor alemán, una de la mascotas en la casa de Vía Aurelia 677. Pablo poco a poco perdió la somnolencia. En cambio, el perro dormitaba todo el día ya sin ganas de jugar. “Los superiores se preocuparon por el perro que estaba muy mal. El perro sí les alarmaba y yo no”, recuerda con rabia. 

Pérez Guajardo se ha convertido en una de las voces más críticas de la Legión. Sin ser nunca un directivo de la orden, durante veinte años estuvo cerca de la cúpula legionaria y del propio fundador Marcial Maciel. Entre 1986 y 2006 perteneció a la comunidad de seminaristas y sacerdotes que residía en Vía Aurelia, Roma, en la sede de la dirección general de los Legionarios de Cristo. 
Lo encuentro en fotografías antiguas: la del 3 de enero de 1991 en la basílica de San Pedro. Para celebrar los 50 años de la Legión de Cristo, Marcial Maciel dispuso que sesenta legionarios fueran ordenados por el papa Juan Pablo II. Con las manos en oración, se le ve a escasas tres personas del pontífice. Ese día recibió la ordenación sacerdotal después de quince años en la congregación. 

Lo vuelvo a ver en?Una Iglesia de corazón misionero, libro de nuestra historia, el libro que los legionarios editaron para celebrar los cuarenta años de la prelatura. Aparece tres veces: en la tercera de forros (con el resto de los curas del estado) y en las páginas 132 y 133. Una fotografía en gran angular lo retrata en medio de un centenar de personas, la mayoría niños: su comunidad de la capilla San José en la colonia Guadalupana, un barrio proletario en la periferia de Playa del Carmen. En la página impar tiene un micrófono en la mano y se lo acerca a un niño.? 

En esas imágenes quedó su época de cercanía legionaria. Pero el 29 de septiembre de 2011 envió al entonces director general de los legionarios, Álvaro Corcuera, una “Carta de Fuego”, en donde exigía a la congregación un deslinde de su fundador Marcial Maciel.? 

“Fue amortajado con vestiduras sacerdotales un maricón, drogo, borracho y mujeriego […] No sólo él se rió de Dios, de la Iglesia y de nosotros, también usted y buen número de superiores mayores se han burlado de la autoridad del Papa al acompañar a nuestro pedófilo fundador en sus viajes con la concubina y la hija sacrílega […] Sus labios han besado el cadáver de un falso profeta que usted y los superiores mayores nos han presentado como Alter Christus siendo un ?Anti-Cristo”, le escribió.? 

A esa carta siguieron una decena de cartas más en donde denunciaba el lavado de dinero, el encubrimiento sistemático de pederastas, el culto a la memoria de Maciel, la explotación financiera de los colegios y otras presuntas desviaciones de la Legión de Cristo. 

Delgado, de ojos verdes, orejas puntiagudas y cabello escaso, Pablo Pérez Guajardo fue expulsado de la Legión de Cristo en mayo de 2015, pero desde septiembre de 2012 lo echaron de la capellanía de San José. Cuando lo entrevisté, en septiembre pasado, acondicionaba la cochera de una casa como capilla. Se dice vetado: “el obispo (Pedro Pablo Elizondo) me prohibió que entrara a las escuelas católicas y a los hospitales”.? 

Conversamos durante tres horas. De su vida, el capítulo más vivo, y el más desgarrador también transcurría en Roma: en 1986 fue asignado a la dirección general de los legionarios, el centro de mando de la congregación religiosa. Ahí convivió con Maciel y Luis Garza Medina, “número” dos de la orden religiosa y cerebro financiero de ésta. 

La vida legionaria afectó las emociones del padre Pérez Guajardo. Se deprimió. Garza Medina le pidió atenderse con Francisco López Ibor, hijo del célebre psiquiatra español Juan José López Ibor. Se negó. Pero después fue el propio Maciel quien le pidió consultar al psiquiatra. Las sugerencias de?Nuestro Padre?eran órdenes. Pérez Guajardo desconocía entonces que era una práctica de Maciel enviar a los sacerdotes problemáticos a la clínica madrileña. Cada cuatro meses viajaba a Madrid a surtirse de dosis de medicamentos psiquiátricos que lo mantenían dormido o sonámbulo, sin ganas de rechistar.? 
Su computadora tenía acceso a internet. Navegando, se dio cuenta de que su dosis de antidepresivos era mayor a la necesaria, y que su tristeza obedecía a su vida de religioso: soledad, alejamiento de su familia desde los 18 años, falta de estímulos. Empezó a darle sus medicamentos al perro pastor alemán que cuidaba con celo otro sacerdote legionario, Juan Manuel Dueñas Rojas. 

Al quitarse los medicamentos volvió a estar despierto, pero pagó un precio. Tenía estallidos de ira y simas de tristeza. Sus padres estaban enfermos y deseaba ir a pasar con ellos sus últimos años. Con su padre no lo logró: cuando aterrizó en México ya lo estaban velando.? 

Una escena retrata su furia: a los curas sólo les estaba permitido beber un vaso de vino con la cena. Los superiores se servían dos o tres “porque tenían permiso del padre Maciel”. Enojado y con ganas de venganza, Pablo se robaba las botellas aflojando el triplay detrás de la repisa. Las ocultaba en el baño o en los ductos de aire acondicionado. 

Una tarde, uno de los superiores lo llamó para regañarlo. Pablo Pérez Guajardo, que ya se la esperaba, traía una de las botellas de vino, ya descorchada. La sacó de entre sus ropas y la derramó sobre el escritorio. 

—¿Cómo se atreve? ¡Aquí hay cartas de Nuestro Padre! —le reprendió el sacerdote (¿Y qué que hubiera esas cartas?, se preguntaría años después Pablo: si la mayoría de las cartas de Maciel eran plagios o escritos de otros autores, todo lo que ofreció Maciel fue un fraude). 

Hartos de su indisciplina, le autorizaron que se trasladara a la Ciudad de México, a una casa de legionarios en la que pudiera estar más cerca de su madre, enferma de cáncer. 

Derramar el vino fue la primera de? sus indisciplinas. Ahora la recuerda como un acto calculado de rebeldía para conseguir su traslado. Vista a la distancia era una travesura. Su auténtico desafío vino después, con sus denuncias públicas escritas en cientos de cuartillas de cartas y en sus confesiones, la catarata de recuerdos que iban reconstruyendo el rompecabezas de una congregación en donde campeaban el fraude y el abuso. La tarde que conversamos, algunas de esas escenas vinieron a su cabeza: la noche anterior a la profesión de votos, Marcial Maciel llamó a uno de sus compañeros y pasó la noche con él. Ese cura fue enviado a la prelatura. Cuando se hizo público que Maciel había tenido una hija, el sacerdote abusado (ya de 50 años) contaba compulsivamente su historia; o de la vez que el cardenal Angelo Sodano, secretario de Estado del Vaticano, les dijo a él y otro grupo de legionarios: “Dichosos ustedes porque obispos y cardenales hay muchos, pero fundador [Marcial Maciel] uno solo”; o de cuando se enteró de que Luis Garza Medina —hermano de Dionisio Garza Medina, presidente de Grupo Alfa y uno de los hombres más ricos de México— había urdido un plan para controlar a la Legión de Cristo: hizo seguir a Maciel por detectives privados, recabó la información sobre su doble vida y le hizo un chantaje: su silencio a cambio del control financiero de la congregación religiosa. 

Tras cuarenta años en la Legión, Pablo Pérez Guajardo observó y escuchó cientos de historias, pero guardaba fidelidad a sus votos privados.[5] Después de su regreso, lo destinaron a una casa de religiosos en el Estado de México y, al final, la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal. Según su relato, estuvo asignado a la catedral de Chetumal en donde reactivó las misas matutinas y salió a las calles a ofrecer bautizos gratuitos a los niños. El obispo Pedro Pablo Elizondo, al ver su energía, lo mandó a una encomienda más difícil: una colonia proletaria en Playa del Carmen.? 
De su paso por la colonia Guadalupana se puede contar su historia como cura de barrio marginal (él la llama?zona atolera?en contraste con la zona hotelera) pero resultan más pertinentes para este artículo sus impresiones sobre la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal, contenidas en una carta que le escribió a su obispo Pedro Pablo Elizondo el 24 de septiembre de 2012. Allí le dice, por ejemplo, que la prelatura ha sido, desde su creación, el destino de los indeseables: aquellos que no cuadraban con la línea de Maciel, ya fuera porque se habían negado a trabajar en colegios para niños ricos, como un grupo de curas irlandeses que se sentían frustrados de hacer pastoral sólo para clases acomodadas.? 

La prelatura se había hecho de tres buenos negocios, acusaba Pablo Pérez: las bodasglamour?celebradas en las capillas de los hoteles de lujo. Los curas legionarios habían sido reducidos a un servicio de?escort: un apuesto sacerdote impecable, bien vestido, con la raya del cabello perfecta, para adornar las ceremonias de los ricos. A esas bodas, por cierto, se les negaba el acceso a los trabajadores de los hoteles.? 

El segundo negocio, la Ciudad de la Alegría: un complejo de casas-hogar para niños, ancianos y enfermos terminales “es, en buena medida, la confeccionadora de recibos deducibles de impuestos para los hoteles y empresas (Best Day) de Fernando García Zalvidea”.? 

Y una tercera fuente de ingresos: los donativos que los legionarios recababan en Estados Unidos y Europa con el argumento de destinarlos a la evangelización de los pueblos mayas, a los cuales “nunca [les] ha llegado dinero: la inmensa mayoría de las regiones o colonias pobres carecen de dispensarios católicos, escuelas parroquiales, templos y servicios sociales”. 

Pérez Guajardo se fue de la prelatura. Buscó lugar en Saltillo, con el obispo Raúl Vera López, promotor de derechos humanos, y antagónico a los legionarios. Apenas estuvo unos ocho meses e hicieron cortocircuito. Pérez Guajardo lo acusó de usar a los pobres para su beneficio, y Vera respondió calificándolo de espía.? 

“¿A dónde voy a mis casi 60 años?”, se preguntó el sacerdote. Y regresó a Playa del Carmen, a la zona obrera, a instalar una capilla en el garaje de una vivienda en obra negra. Cuando lo visité, se movía en un automóvil Chevy viejo y sucio, sin asientos, y vivía con una familia, rodeado de costales de cemento y cortinas de polvo. En 2015 la Legión lo había expulsado de sus filas: “En términos canónicos no tengo licencias ministeriales, quedando firme que no hay ninguna sanción o pena canónica ya que no existe ningún delito (ni pederastia, pareja sexual, fraude, problemas doctrinales o enseñanzas morales erróneas)”, me dijo. 

Cuando conversamos se le notaba el cansancio tras cuatro años de denuncia sin que nada hubiera cambiado. Estaba irascible y resignado a su trabajo pastoral: dar catecismo, celebrar bautizos, avanzar en la construcción de su capilla. Le pregunté por qué había invertido tanta energía en las cientos de cuartillas de denuncia. Tenía esperanza: su esperanza era que lo escucharan en el Vaticano y le retiraran la prelatura a los legionarios. A Quintana Roo, me dijo, le faltaba un obispo franciscano, jesuita o diocesano que usara morral, huaraches y mezclilla, y se mezclara con los obreros y los indígenas de tierra adentro, y ya no con los magnates de la zona hotelera.? 

La leyenda del santo lavador 
Fernando García Zalvidea fue uno de los miles de inmigrantes que atrajo el auge turístico de Cancún. A bordo de una limusina, ofrecía excursiones a los gringos fascinados por el paraíso caribeño. Uno de ellos le dijo un día:?This is my best day. Le gustó la frase y la hizo suya. Cancún estaba en permanente expansión y era territorio fértil para los emprendedores como García Zalvidea que, al paso de su fulgurante ascenso como hotelero, tejió una red de relaciones políticas, religiosas y empresariales con la élite de Quintana Roo. Sus negocios fructificaron hasta que llegó a ser dueño de una cadena de hoteles a la que llamó Real Caribe y de la empresa Best Day, que fue pionera en ofrecer viajes todo pagado por internet.? 

Pero su emporio se tambaleó en 1998. La Procuraduría General de la República (PGR) lo relacionó con el “maxiproceso”: una investigación sobre narcotráfico y lavado de dinero del Cártel de Juárez en Quintana Roo. Se acusaba al gobernador Mario Villanueva Madrid,?El Chueco, de haber puesto la Procuraduría de Justicia local al servicio del capo Ramón Alcides Magaña,?El Metro. Fernando García Zalvidea fue acusado de lavar dinero del cártel en la compra del hotel Gran Caribe Real. Lo detuvieron y lo internaron en el Reclusorio Sur de la Ciudad de México. 
Los resultados del maxiproceso fueron ambiguos. El ex gobernador Villanueva Madrid fue detenido, encarcelado y extraditado a los Estados Unidos (en donde sigue preso) pero su caso fue excepcional. La mayoría de los indiciados fueron absueltos, entre ellos el propio García Zalvidea, que obtuvo su libertad el 4 de marzo de 2000 tras catorce meses preso en el Reclusorio Sur de la Ciudad de México.? 

Tres años después, en marzo de 2004, la revista?Contralínea?publicó diversas conversaciones telefónicas entre el ex procurador Antonio Lozano Gracia, el ex candidato presidencial del PAN, Diego Fernández de Cevallos y el abogado de García Zalvidea, Germán Rangel. Lozano y Fernández de Cevallos, ambos panistas, hablan de las “gestiones políticas” para liberar al hotelero y luego para que la PGR cerrara el caso. 

Fernando García Zalvidea se convirtió en el benefactor más visible de los Legionarios de Cristo en Quintana Roo. En el año 2000 auspició la construcción de la Ciudad de la Alegría, la mayor obra social de la prelatura en Quintana Roo: un centro que concentra escuelas, casas de ancianos, niños y enfermos terminales, y tratamiento de adicciones.? 

Pero Fernando García Zalvidea extendió sus redes a la política a través de su hermano Juan Ignacio,?El Chacho, quien fue diputado federal del PAN en el 2000 y luego brincó al Partido Verde. Con las siglas ecologistas ganó la alcaldía de Benito Juárez (Cancún está adentro de Benito Juárez) en febrero de 2002. Fue el primer alcalde de oposición en la ciudad. En 2004?El Chacho?se acercó a quien encabezaba las encuestas para la elección presidencial, el izquierdista Andrés Manuel López Obrador.? 

Juan Ignacio hizo saber que quería ser candidato de un frente opositor a la gubernatura de Quintana Roo. Y meses después de hacer públicas sus aspiraciones, fue destituido por el congreso y, ya fuera del cargo, encarcelado por quebranto del erario municipal. Estuvo preso más de un año, hasta que su hermano Fernando garantizó una fianza de 71 millones de pesos.? 

Los García Zalvidea eran de las familias más poderosas del estado.?El Chacho?ya había mandado señales de disciplina con el PRI al apersonarse, en 2010, a los actos de campaña del ahora gobernador Roberto Borge. Y en otra pista, Fernando se congraciaba con el PAN: en 2012 le organizaba actos a su candidata presidencial Josefina Vázquez Mota con hoteleros. A uno de esos encuentros invitó también al obispo Pedro Pablo Elizondo.? 

Los invasores? 
En la Supermanzana 30, los Legionarios de Cristo se quedaron con un pedazo del parque. Se metieron poco a poco. Los vecinos tenían siete mil metros cuadrados para espacios públicos. Lo partieron en cuatro: un pedazo para el kínder, otro para la primaria, otro para el kiosco y uno más para área verde. En ese pedazo levantaron una capilla pequeña. Cuando el padre —legionario de Cristo— iba a celebrar la misa, uno de los vecinos le abría y le cerraba la puerta.? 

Un día, ese vecino, Mario Cortés, salió de viaje y le dejó las llaves al cura. Estaba claro que estaban prestadas hasta su regreso. Pero nunca las volvió a ver. A partir de entonces la prelatura se quedó con la capilla y, años después, con mil metros cuadrados del parque.? 
La céntrica ubicación de la capilla atrajo a cientos de vecinos de otras supermanzanas. Rodeada de parque, se convirtió en un espacio ideal para bodas y bautizos. Cuando Juan Ignacio El Chacho García Zalvidea era alcalde de Cancún, trató de legalizar la invasión de la Supermanzana 30. Le dio a la prelatura una “orden de ocupación” del parque.? 

A partir de entonces empezó una larga batalla. Dos de sus protagonistas me cuentan su historia, Herminia Peña y Luz María Elguero, que residen en el perímetro del parque. Con el aval del?Chacho?García Zalvidea, la prelatura levantaba bardas alrededor del terreno; los vecinos acudían a derribar los castillos. La prelatura metía maquinaria para hacer socavones; los vecinos boqueaban el paso de los camiones con sus vehículos. 

No fue una lucha fácil. La prelatura actuaba de noche y daba sabadazo: las obras siempre empezaban en Semana Santa para pillar a los vecinos de vacaciones y tenían de su lado a la fuerza pública. Un miércoles de Semana Santa dos vecinos hacían guardia para impedir la instalación de castillos: llegó la policía y se los llevó a declarar (salieron libres unas horas después). Y había una presencia frecuente en torno de la Supermanzana: Fernando García Zalvidea. Los vecinos se acostumbraron a ver su camioneta Porsche blanca recorriendo las obras.? 

Durante el gobierno del?Chacho?García Zalvidea la prelatura quiso comerse cuatro mil metros cuadrados del parque. Presumieron una maqueta que tenía templo, guardería, recámaras y criptas. El entonces presidente de la colonia estampó su firma en los planos y, con ese aval, la prelatura empezó las obras de bardeado y cimentación.? 

Pero cayó?El Chacho?cuando amenazó con irse a la filas de Obrador, y los alcaldes que lo sucedieron ya no estaban tan entregados a la causa de los legionarios. Un perredista, Gregorio Sánchez, buscó una solución intermedia. Canceló la orden de ocupación que había regalado?El Chacho?pero le dejó a la prelatura mil metros cuadrados del parque.? 

Estos años de historia se cuentan en unas líneas. Para las vecinas —en su mayoría mujeres— de la Supermanzana 30, representó cientos de horas de tocar puertas, acudir a ventanillas, redactar quejas, hacer antesalas, revisar pilas de documentos, aprender leyes y reglamentos, cruzar llamadas, hacer reuniones, con su dosis desagradable de soportar las caras de los curas que, desde el púlpito, las acusaban de tener el corazón endemoniado y de conspirar para quemar la iglesia.? 

El ayuntamiento cedió de nuevo. El 17 de mayo de 2013, el director de obras arquitectónicas y civiles, Humberto Aguilera, expidió la licencia de construcción de obra nueva 66 231 para la parroquia de la Sagrada Familia. Le daba a la prelatura del 16 de mayo hasta el 16 de noviembre para terminar la obra en una superficie de mil 12 metros cuadrados.? 

Desesperados, los vecinos inconformes fueron a levantar una denuncia penal. Acusaron al obispo Elizondo, al empresario Fernando García Zalvidea y al sacerdote Luis Alberto Chavarría LC (representante legal de la prelatura) de despojo y delitos contra el desarrollo urbano. La procuraduría admitió la denuncia y abrió la averiguación previa 4819/13 el 17 de septiembre de 2013. A partir de entonces la demanda durmió el sueño de los justos (o de los injustos) y no pasó nada.? 
Pero la prelatura se impuso. Ahora se aprecia una iglesia a todo lujo: dos niveles, altar en mosaico dorado, dos pantallas planas y doce ventiladores. Las banquetas se ampliaron (a costa de derribar árboles) para convertirlas en estacionamientos. Una de ellas ostenta un letrero: “exclusivo sacerdote”. 

La Supermanzana 30 no es la única que fue invadida por la prelatura. El 22 de septiembre pasado estuve en la colonia Hacienda Real del Caribe de la Región 200. Los vecinos me enseñaron un predio que era una de las áreas verdes de su barrio: un predio con árboles de donde colgaron llantas para que se columpiaran los niños.? 

Primero apareció una cruz. Después vino la barda y un letrero que anunciaba la capilla del Señor de la Divina Misericordia. “Si los niños se cuelan a jugar, al rato llega a sacarlos la gente de la iglesia”, me contó una chilanga que se mudó a esa colonia popular de Cancún. 

No lejos de ahí, en la Supermanzana 117, la prelatura también consumó un acto de invasión. El mismo método: primero una cruz, luego cuatro palos y un techo de nylon, y al final ladrillos: la capilla de Santiago Apóstol se comía el jardín que estaba frente a la primaria La Raza de Bronce. 

La invasión provocó reacciones encontradas en la comunidad. Lourdes Ibarra y Alicia Vázquez encabezaron el bando que se oponía al agandalle. Otras vecinas apoyaban a los legionarios. Las primeras eran cristianas evangélicas y las segundas, católicas. Lo cierto es que ambas estaban de acuerdo en una cosa: había sido una invasión de un área pública. Si acaso la justificaban porque ahora el parque estaba desmontado y limpio.? 

En estas páginas cuento tres ejemplos. Acaso sean muchos más. Cuando el perredista Julián Ricalde era alcalde de Cancún se contabilizaron trece invasiones. Y, según Tulio Arroyo, lo difícil es encontrar una iglesia en Cancún que no sea una invasión. Los legionarios lo han adoptado como?modus operandi: identificar un lote vacío y apropiárselo a golpe de misas y bardas.? 

Tulio Arroyo transpira una obsesión: defender las áreas verdes de Cancún. Y ese propósito lo ha puesto en el punto de colisión con los legionarios, acostumbrados a hacer su voluntad en Quintana Roo. Tulio Arroyo es un ingeniero especializado en energías alternativas. Chilango con estudios en Nueva York, se convirtió en defensor del medio ambiente cuando el ayuntamiento pretendió deforestar la última reserva ambiental del centro de Cancún, un parque conocido como el Ombligo Verde. La alcaldesa priista Magali Achach pretendía entregarle un lote a la prelatura para que hiciera una catedral. 

Arroyo Marroquín y su esposa Bettina Cetto, encabezaron el movimiento?En defensa del Ombligo Verde. Se convirtieron en expertos en derecho administrativo y acompañaron los brotes de protesta que surgían aquí y allá a las invasiones de la Iglesia. Arroyo les ayudaba a convocar ruedas de prensa, redactar comunicados y orientar los intrincados caminos de los tribunales; y consiguió salvar el Ombligo Verde de su deforestación total. Pero no pudo impedir que los legionarios construyeran ahí la catedral de Cancún. Arroyo y Cetto vivían enfrente del parque. Justo frente a su ventana se levantó la catedral.? 

Notre Dame del Sureste 
Los Legionarios de Cristo apuestan a la monumentalidad. Su red de colegios se llama Semper Altius (siempre más alto) y sus escuelas aluden a las alturas: Cumbres, Himalaya, Everest, Alpes, Highlands. En la prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal se han propuesto erigir el mayor símbolo religioso del sureste: la basílica de Santa María de Guadalupe del Mar, un edificio con una cruz de 110 metros de altura, con capacidad para mil 500 personas y con un costo estimado de 12 millones de dólares. 

Pero los planes de la prelatura se han topado con la resistencia de ecologistas. Se asentaría frente a la laguna Nichupté, una zona de manglares y especies protegidas. Uno de ellos es Pedro Canché. Indígena maya, Canché pasó nueve meses en la cárcel acusado de sabotaje. Su encarcelamiento era, en realidad, una manera de callarlo. El gobierno de Quintana Roo tuvo que soltarlo tras la presión internacional y ahora se le ve como un emblema de la libertad de expresión. 

Según Canché —en un escrito dirigido al ayuntamiento— el proyecto Tajamar (del que la basílica es una parte), representará un “inminente ecocidio que devastará la flora, fauna y humedales […]. De llevarse a cabo la construcción, se devastaría totalmente uno de los ‘pulmones’ naturales que posee Cancún y que son invaluables”.? 

Como en otras historias de legionarios, de la megabasílica de Cancún se cuentan dos historias. La historia oficial dice que Fonatur le regaló los 10 mil metros a la prelatura. Y surge la pregunta: ¿Por qué un órgano del Estado mexicano tendría que donar un terreno público a la Iglesia católica?, ¿por qué no cederle también un predio a los cristianos, adventistas, mormones, Testigos de Jehová o a los ateos de Cancún?? 

La historia extraoficial la ofrece el padre Pablo Pérez Guajardo: esos 10 mil metros fueron el pago del presidente Vicente Fox a Marcial Maciel por facilitar su divorcio religioso ante el Vaticano. Por su calidad de jefe de Estado, su solicitud de nulidad debía pasar por la Rota Romana, un tribunal de la curia pontificia. Ya divorciado de Lilian de la Concha, el sacerdote Alejandro Latapí, legionario de Cristo, celebró su boda religiosa con Marta Sahagún.? 

Encuentro con el obispo 
Detrás de su escritorio colgaba el cuadro?Head of Christ?del pintor estadounidense Warner Sallman, que se conoce también como “El Cristo legionario” porque el fundador de la congregación, Marcial Maciel Degollado, la introdujo como la imagen oficial en seminarios, casas y escuelas de la Legión de Cristo. En tres cuartos de perfil, representa a Cristo de rasgos afilados, cabello ondulado y túnica blanca.? 

Entrevisté al obispo Pedro Pablo Elizondo el 23 de septiembre de 2015 en las oficinas de la curia, a un lado de la catedral de Cancún, en el Ombligo Verde. En 40 minutos, surgieron en la conversación algunos rasgos que han hecho célebres a los Legionarios de Cristo: el éxito como insignia; el énfasis en el carácter emprendedor de la Legión y la abundancia de sus frutos materiales; la molestia ante las preguntas incómodas (pederastas, la doble vida de Marcial Maciel) y, al final, la advertencia de llevarme a tribunales si no era fiel a sus palabras. Acá una versión resumida de nuestra conversación:? 

—¿Cómo ha sido en términos de complejidad, de reto, atender una población que creció diez veces en 45 años? 
—El crecimiento explosivo que trae grandísimos retos para la evangelización. Como destino turístico y belleza ambiental es sumamente atractivo y agradable vivir aquí, como el paraíso. La gente viene de paseo y se queda. Son muy atractivas la playas, la arena, [el mar] turquesa, el sol, la brisa que sopla. 
—¿Cuál era el?manpower?cuando se fundó la prelatura? 
—Llegamos cinco sacerdotes y había cinco parroquias. Ahora son 115 sacerdotes y 53 parroquias. Ha habido dos periodos, el obispo anterior, monseñor [Jorge] Bernal. Cuando me hicieron obispo, en 2004, recibí 52 sacerdotes y ahora son lo doble y lo mismo las parroquias, se han duplicado. ¿Cómo le haces para doblar las parroquias, cuando no hay nada, cuando es selva, cuando es monte? Llegar a chapear, a desmontar, a hacer iglesita de palitos. Así fue la zona hotelera, cuando yo llegué así estaba. Y poco a poco llegar a hacer una iglesia digna, grande, sagrada, acogedora y ése es el carisma que han traído los Legionarios de Cristo: el espíritu emprendedor y misionero que logró construir muchas iglesias. Todavía están en construcción la catedral, la basílica, nuestro seminario.? 

—De estos 115 de ahora, ¿cuántos son diocesanos?, ¿cuántos legionarios? 
—Setenta legionarios, 35 diocesanos, y el resto de otras congregaciones. Tenemos una gran necesidad [de sacerdotes].? 

—Llama mucho la atención la basílica, por los 110 metros. Supongo que será la construcción más alta de Cancún, ¿por qué tan monumental? 
—Inicialmente se tuvo un encuentro con el presidente Vicente Fox y con los presidentes de la república después. Y hay un lugar que se llama Malecón Tajamar que se ha convertido en el centro social más importante de Cancún. Y providencialmente ese terreno se ha donado por Fonatur a la Iglesia católica. Este proyecto sale de la ubicación tan preciosa para ser el centro religioso de Cancún y que al mismo tiempo se convierta en un ícono y atractivo turístico para todos los turistas. Que sea un lugar como la [catedral] de Colonia o la Sagrada Familia de Barcelona o Notre Dame de París donde la gente va, reza y los turistas se encuentran con una ventana al evento guadalupano. Y podemos hacerlo con la máxima tecnología audiovisual e interactiva para presentar Guadalupe a los 14 millones de turistas. Es un proyecto de turismo religioso. Es un proyecto turístico. 

—Tiempos y presupuestos para la basílica… 
—Primero los permisos. Llevamos años y años gestionando. El día de mañana voy a tener una entrevista con el secretario de turismo para ver si ya sale.? 

—Quisiera tener la versión institucional del obispo, de la prelatura, el caso ya muy publicado en la prensa de dos sacerdotes, Eduardo Lucatero y Jesús Martínez, que han estado aquí y que fueron en algún momento señalados o acusados en algún abuso. Se dijo que la prelatura servía como para encubrir o proteger o resguardar.? 
—Son casos de 20, 30 o 40 años. Casos sobreseídos que podían estar aquí o en cualquier otra parte. Son sacerdotes que ya están retirados. Uno de ellos está enfermo, en silla de ruedas, atendido muy caritativamente, que no tiene nada pendiente, que tiene un ministerio muy reducido o nulo, que es Lucatero, de 75, 76 años. Y el otro [Martínez Penilla] es de 80 años, ya pasó la edad, no está en ningún ejercicio de su ministerio y [se le trata] con toda la caridad cristiana que se merecen personas que han trabajado por la Iglesia, y la Legión tiene la obligación de no tirarlos como trapos sucios, inútiles, sino hacer que se les dé un trato digno y respetuoso como seres humanos y servidores. Eso es todo, ¿qué más? 

—¿Cómo se vivió la etapa crítica, la revelación de que el fundador de la congregación, Marcial Maciel, tenía una hija? 
—Desde luego que lo vivimos con mucha pena, con mucha tristeza y con mucho respeto para no juzgar, condenar lo que solamente le toca a Dios. Nosotros creemos que Jesucristo es el único juez de todos, también de los que juzgamos a los otros, superficial y ligeramente, sin estar enterados. Respeto porque es un misterio, misterio cómo una persona con una vida desordenada crea una congregación tan ordenada. Es lo que dijo Benedicto XVI. Dijo: Es un misterio para mí. Frente al misterio lo menos que puedes hacer es ser respetuoso si es que estás ubicado, si no estás ubicado dices todo lo que puedas decir para sacar provecho, pa vender el periódico. Pues sí, cada uno tiene derecho a hacer su luchita, ¿no?, pues qué bueno. Aquí [en Quintana Roo] la confianza no se perdió.? 

—De la invasión en la Supermanzana 30, [y] de una escuela primaria en donde se construyen iglesias que son terrenos públicos, son parques… 
—La última es en Playa del Carmen, se llama Villas del Sol. Está metido en el monte. Los fieles católicos insisten que les den un espacio como en todas partes del mundo, que es terreno de equipamiento. Este terreno de equipamiento está señalado que es el 15 por ciento del desarrollo para que hicieran escuela, iglesia, hospital, mercado, bomberos, policía, servicios públicos. En el municipio el encargado de Asuntos Religiosos les dice: ‘si quieren la Semana Santa ahí, limpien su terrenito y celebren las ceremonias religiosas de la Semana Santa’. Limpiaron, pusieron la cruz y pues llegaron los periódicos: ‘Que el obispo está invadiendo, que es el más rico del mundo’. Yo ni sabía, yo no tenía ni idea. Aquí [en Cancún] es enormemente mucho más grande y ha habido lugares sin que se entere nadie. Los fieles han dicho: ‘Aquí vamos a hacer nuestra iglesita’. ¿Y por qué no? Y comienzan, y ponen su tingladito, y al rato llaman a un padre, y al rato están rezando el rosario debajo de un árbol, y se juntan. Digo, ¿no tienen derecho a tener un espacio donde puedan alabar a Dios, crecer en las virtudes, en fin, ser hermanos, construir comunidad, que están solos, que vienen uno de Tabasco, otro de Campeche, otro de Veracruz y quieren los vecinos juntarse para tener un ratito de convivencia…? 

—Con este crecimiento de Quintana Roo, demográfico y de infraestructura, ¿todavía se justifica una prelatura? 
—Esa es la gran pregunta que me hacen todos los obispos. La razón por la que todavía tenga que ser prelatura, es el crecimiento exagerado de la población, que no ha dado tiempo para que vayan creciendo los sacerdotes nativos. 

El paraíso intocable 
La Legión de Cristo no es sólo una congregación religiosa, sino un?holdingreligioso, empresarial y financiero: una hiedra que se extiende en asociaciones de miles de laicos agrupados en el Regnum Christi —algunas de sus integrantes, sobre todo mujeres, trabajan de tiempo completo para la Legión—, un emporio educativo con colegios y universidades en más de veinte países; el banco Compartamos; sociedades para la recaudación de recursos como Kilo de ayuda y Teletón, además de una red de alianzas con los empresarios más ricos de México, como Carlos Slim —a quien casó Maciel— y Emilio Azcárraga Jean —Maciel celebró las exequias de su padre, a pesar de que ya se le había señalado como abusador de niños.? 

Benedicto XVI dimitió al gobierno de la Iglesia en febrero de 2013. Su sucesor, el jesuita argentino Jorge Mario Bergoglio, llamado Francisco, labró una pastoral popular y progresista, en las antípodas de la Legión de Cristo, pero no se atrevió a tocar el imperio que había fundado Maciel. Incluso permitió que la congregación regresara a la normalidad, ya sin interventores pontificios encima.? 

El Vaticano tampoco ha castigado uno de los desempeños más ineficientes en México. En Quintana Roo, según el censo de 2010, los católicos representan 63 por ciento de la población. Esa cifra está muy por debajo del 82 por ciento nacional. Mientras los legionarios construyen iglesias con fervor, 14 por ciento de los quintanarroenses se declara cristiano no católico, y otro 13 por ciento se dice sin religión. 

En Quintana Roo, la Legión ha gozado de un ambiente propicio para hacer lo que ha querido: albergar a pederastas —y a encubridores de pederastas— y apropiarse de terrenos públicos sin que existan consecuencias. Desde 1970 el estado de Quintana Roo ha sido un paraíso para los Legionarios de Cristo. 

NOTAS 
1. De manera habitual, la Iglesia católica se divide en diócesis: porciones territoriales bajo el mando de un obispo. Sólo en casos excepcionales se crean “prelaturas”: zonas en donde la Iglesia tiene una estructura tan débil que es incapaz de atender a la población local y, por lo tanto, la delega a una congregación religiosa. Suelen ser zonas indígenas con pobreza extrema y de difícil acceso. En México, a los franciscanos se les han cedido las prelaturas de El Nayar (Nayarit) y El Salto (Durango), y a los salesianos, la prelatura de Mixes, en Oaxaca. Entre 1958 y 1992, los jesuitas se encargaron de la Tarahumara, en Chihuahua. La prelatura de Cancún-Chetumal comprende el estado de Quintana Roo. 
2. Hasta aquí, las citas textuales provienen de?Una Iglesia de corazón misionero, libro de nuestra historia, que la prelatura editó en 2010 para celebrar su 40 aniversario, páginas 34 y 39, respectivamente.? 
3. La historia del abuso y la fuga de Martínez Penilla la cuenta el historiador Fernando M. González en Marcial Maciel, los legionarios de Cristo: testimonios y documentos inéditos, pp. 365-366.? 
4.?Una Iglesia de corazón misionero, p. 28. 
5. En diversas congregaciones religiosas se toman tres votos: castidad, pobreza y obediencia. Maciel inventó dos votos más: el de caridad y el de humildad. El voto de caridad prohibía a los legionarios criticar a sus superiores, y el de humildad les impedía buscar puestos directivos en la organización. A través de ambos votos, el fundador consiguió que, durante décadas, ningún legionario denunciara sus crímenes. 
Con información de Gatopardo

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

NEW YORK TIMES DOET OPROEP TOT VATICAANSTAD

BELGIE
KerkNet

[The New York Times has called on the Vatican prosecutor to drop all charges against two Italian journalists – Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fattipaldi.]

BRUSSEL (KerkNet/Catholic Herald) – De bekende Amerikaanse krant ‘New York Times’ heeft de openbare aanklager van het Vaticaan opgeroepen om alle klachten tegen de twee Italiaanse journalisten Gianluigi Nuzzi en Emiliano Fittipaldi, die allebei recent een boek publiceerden over de weerstand van sommige leden van de Romeinse Curie tegen de financiële hervormingen van paus Franciscus.

De krant benadrukt dat beiden worden vervolgd op basis van een wet uit 2013, die werd goedgekeurd om seksueel misbruik van minderjarigen en kinderporno te bestrijden. Emiliano Fittipaldi noemde het proces kafkaiaans. De Organisatie voor Veiligheid en Samenwerking in Europa (OVSE), evenals beroepsorganisaties van journalisten vroegen het Vaticaan om het proces tegen de journalisten stop te zetten.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Accuser of sex abuse at Aurora church drops anonymity

ILLINOIS
Daily Herald

Susan Sarkauskas

Members of two groups critical of the Catholic Church’s handling of sexual abuse by priests are calling for parishioners to withhold financial donations to an Aurora church.

And the man who sued that church, St. Rita of Cascia, under the name “John Doe” has revealed his identity. He is John Plaschke, who now lives in Maryland, and said he revealed himself to encourage other possible victims to come forward.

Plaschke’s suit, filed in September in Winnebago County, names the church, the Rockford Diocese and John Holdren, a priest at St. Rita of Cascia in the early 1970s.

In a phone interview, Plaschke said the recent news about sexual assault allegations against comedian Bill Cosby prompted him to investigate his own abuse. The shame and the fear of not being believed expressed by Cosby’s accusers resonated with Plaschke and brought out suppressed memories, he said. Plaschke said he filed the suit after being unsatisfied with the responses of the parish and the diocese to his questions.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Prestigious MN prep school/Uni in violation of Title IX for housing sex offending monks

MINNESOTA
The Worthy Adversary

Posted by Joelle Casteix on November 30, 2015

Newly released documents show how St. John’s Prep in Collegeville, MN is in direct violation of Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 and created a hostile environment where students can reasonably believe they are risk of sexual assault.

At least 10 sex-offending monks—who have only been publicly exposed due to child sex abuse civil lawsuits and criminal complaints— live at the monastic residence (noted in the photo of the school above) mere yards from the dorms of St. John’s Prep.

Students must pass the home where the offenders live to go to the cafeteria or attend church services. Because of the real risk these monks pose, students are unable to study, work, or perform in sport activities because out of genuine and real fear of sexual assault.

According to Campus Safety Magazine:

Sexual violence is viewed under the law as an extreme form of hostile environment/sexual harassment and must be addressed. When an institution “knows or reasonably should know” about a hostile environment, they are required “to take immediate action to eliminate the harassment, prevent its recurrence and address its effects.”

We aren’t talking about frat parties. We are talking about men who engaged in child sex trafficking in South East Asia, men who evaded charges of child sex abuse, men who took numerous children to cabins in order to sexually abuse them, men who sexually abused the high school and college students they counseled, and men who abused altar boys in their care.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Spotlight & Philippines Jesuit sex crimes. Jesuit abused young man “a few hundred times” starting when he was 15 in Ateneo de Zamboanga, Arvisu House, Loyola House of Studies

UNITED STATES
PopeCrimes& Vatican Evils.

Paris Arrow

The Jesuits are among the most notorious sexual predators on earth.

Jesuits are infamous members of the JP2 Army – John Paul II Pedophile Priests Army.

END Statute of Limitation for pedophilia

This “Jesuit sex crimes” from the Philippines prove that the statute of limitation must be removed for pedophilia and pederast sex crimes because it takes about three decades before victims can speak about their shameful past. Lucas, (not his real name) comes out only now at the age of 46 and he was sexually assaulted “hundreds of times” starting at the age of 15. It took him three decades to reveal his shameful past and in the Philippines, that shame belongs not to him alone – but to his entire family as well. Read our article, — New York Catholic bishops fight new Statute of Limitation bill for it would cause the church “catastrophic financial harm”.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Case Study 35, November 2015, Melbourne – Live hearing

AUSTRALIA
Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse

[live stream]

The Royal Commission will hold a public hearing in Melbourne from Tuesday 24 November 2015 commencing at 10:00am AEDT.

The public hearing will inquire into the response of the Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne to allegations of child sexual abuse.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Priest accused of stealing told bishop he was playing ‘hardball’ with unauthorized fees

CANADA
Windsor Star

TREVOR WILHELM, WINDSOR STAR

The bishop of the London diocese testified Monday that a priest charged with stealing claimed he was charging unauthorized wedding fees to play “hardball” with people wanting to use the church.

Bishop Ronald Fabbro took the witness stand as week two of the trial against Robert Couture began.

“He should not be including a fee for himself,” said Fabbro.

“This idea of playing hardball I thought was not a good pastoral approach.”

Robert Couture, the former pastor of Ste. Anne Parish in Tecumseh, is charged with theft over $5,000. A forensic accountant told court last week Couture stole between $170,000 and $234,000 from 2002 to 2010.

Fabbro said Monday he received a complaint in 2004 from the parents of a couple who got married at Ste. Anne. He said the complaint from the family, referred to in court as the Majors, was about fees that Couture required.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Obispo Barros asegura que “se enteró por la prensa” de abusos de Karadima

CHILE
El Dinamo

[Bishop Barros said he learned of the abuses by Karadima from the press.]

Barros mostró su molestia por ser relacionado con los abusos de Karadima, recalcando que “he señalado en más de una ocasión que en este proceso se ha faltado gravemente a la verdad, y he visto en algunos medios de comunicación algunas alusiones al respecto, las que niego rotundamente”.

En el marco de la demanda civil que interpusieron tres de las víctimas de los abusos cometidos por Fernando Karadima en contra del Arzobispado de Santiago, el pasado 20 de noviembre prestó declaración el cuestionado obispo Juan Barros.

Es que Barros es sindicado por parte de los querellantes y de la comunidad de Osorno de ser uno de los encubridores de los delitos realizados por el ex párroco de El Bosque, lo cual ha sido negado en innumerables ocasiones por el prelado.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

‘VatiLeaks’ trial rescheduled for Dec. 7

VATICAN CITY
National Catholic Reporter

Junno Arocho Esteves Catholic News Service | Nov. 30, 2015

VATICAN CITY
A Vatican trial against two Italian journalists, a Spanish monsignor and two others was postponed for one week after the court allowed one of the defendants to change lawyers.

On what was to be the criminal trial’s first day of testimonies by the defendants Monday, the Vatican court granted a request by one of the accused to have a new lawyer and receive more time to prepare for the case.

The proceedings began with the presiding judge, Giuseppe Dalla Torre, stating the request by Francesca Chaouqui, a member of the former Pontifical Commission for Reference on the Organization of the Economic-Administrative Structure of the Holy See.

Dalla Torre, along with three other Vatican judges, deliberated for 10 minutes before granting her request and announcing the trial would resume Dec. 7.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pope acknowledges criticism over speed of leaks trial, admits ‘error’ in naming commission

PAPAL PLANE
Star Tribune

By NICOLE WINFIELD and FRANCES D’EMILIO Associated Press NOVEMBER 30, 2015 —

ABOARD THE PAPAL PLANE — Pope Francis has acknowledged criticism that the Vatican’s trial over leaked documents has been rushed, saying the defendants and their lawyers must have time to mount a proper defense.

Francis spoke to reporters en route home from Africa after a Vatican judge on Tuesday adjourned the trial until Dec. 7 to give one of the defendants time to prepare after she engaged a new attorney late last week. Several of the suspects had complained that they hadn’t had time to find lawyers, much less study the case file before the trial began Nov. 24.

In a startling acknowlegment of his involvement in the process, Francis said he had wanted the trial to be finished before the Dec. 8 start of his Jubilee Year of Mercy.

“But I think this can’t be done now, because I want all the defense lawyers to have time to defend, that there is the freedom of defense,” he said.

Three members of a papal reform commission are accused of leaking documents to two reporters who published blockbuster books detailing Vatican waste, mismanagement and greed among some cardinals and bishops. The two reporters are also on trial for having published the material — accusations that have drawn scorn from media rights groups around the world.

The groups have urged the Vatican to drop the charges against reporters Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, who face eight years in prison if convicted.

Francis acknowledged that journalists have an important role to play in uncovering injustice and corruption.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Caught on video – priest in cake fetish sex romp with married goddaughter

NEW YORK
The Sun (UK)

A KINKY priest has been kicked out of the church after he was caught on video engaging in a ‘cake-crushing’ fetish with his married goddaughter.

Footage shows The Rev. George Passias, 67, looking on as Ethel Bouzalas, 45, sat and stomped on pieces of banana bread – while wearing sexy lingerie.

Passias has been relieved of his priestly duties at St. Spyridon Church in New York after a unanimous vote, church officials tell the New York Post.

Bouzalas, 45, who was principal of the St. Spyridon Parochial School, is now five months’ pregnant — and she claims the horny holy man is the father, according to The National Herald, a Greek-American daily newspaper.

Bouzalas has alleged that Passias urged her to get an abortion, despite that being against the teachings of the Greek Orthodox church.

The priest has denied that claim.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatican leaks trial postponed after defendant changes lawyer

VATICAN CITY
Irish Times

A Vatican trial into the theft of confidential Holy See documents was postponed on Monday until December 7th, dashing church hopes of wrapping up the case before the start of the Roman Catholic Holy Year.

The trial of five defendants, including a senior Spanish priest and two Italian reporters, was due to hear the first testimony on Monday, with the court looking to reach verdicts before December 8th, when the Holy Year starts.

However, the panel of three judges agreed to adjourn the hearing because one of the accused, lay consultant Francesca Chaouqui, had changed her lawyer, who requested more time to prepare the defence.

Two defendants, journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, had books based on leaked documents published this month that depict a Vatican plagued by greed and graft and where Pope Francis faces stiff resistance to his reform agenda.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Missbrauch in der Katholischen Kirche: Geheime Paralleljustiz

DEUTSCHLAND
Spiegel

[Father R., considered a major abuser in the instances of sexual abuse at Caniusiu College in Berlin, but he never faced charged in criminal and civil law because the actions were said to be time-barred. It turns out that a girl raised in the church has made serious allegations against the priest which are not time-barred. It remains to be seen whether the priest will be charged.]

Von Peter Wensierski

Ein Mädchen meldet einen nicht verjährten Missbrauch, der in Verbindung mit dem Berliner Canisius-Kolleg steht. Doch die Kirche informiert erst zehn Monate später die Staatsanwaltschaft.

Pater R. gilt als ein Haupttäter im Fall des jahrelangen sexuellen Missbrauchs am Canisius-Kolleg in Berlin. Vor Gericht musste sich der katholische Geistliche jedoch nie verantworten, straf- und zivilrechtlich waren die Taten verjährt. Nun stellt sich heraus: Ein Mädchen erhob bei der Kirche auch schwere Vorwürfe gegen den Pater, die nicht verjährt waren. Doch das Bistum Hildesheim, bei dem sich die Jugendliche gemeldet hatte, verschleppte die Aufklärung, wie die WDR-Dokumentation “Richter Gottes” zeigt.

Das Mädchen hatte sich in Begleitung seiner Religionslehrerin im März 2010 an das Bistum gewandt und von einem Besuch bei dem Pater vier Jahre zuvor in Berlin erzählt. Erst habe der Geistliche mit ihr ein Straßenfest besucht und ihr eine Panflöte geschenkt. Dann gingen sie in seine kleine Wohnung und aßen gemeinsam Abendbrot. Später habe sie sich im selben Raum schlafen gelegt, schließlich sei der Pater mit ihrer Familie in Hildesheim befreundet gewesen. Sie war ihren Angaben zufolge noch nicht ganz eingeschlafen, da sei Pater R. wieder aufgestanden, habe sich auf sie gelegt und begonnen, sie zu küssen und zu befummeln.

Als das Mädchen dies berichtete, kannte die Bistumsleitung Pater R. schon bestens, nicht nur als mutmaßlichen Serientäter vom Berliner Canisius-Kolleg. Auch auf einer eigenen Pressekonferenz, nur vier Wochen zuvor, hatte das Bistum zwei andere Missbrauchsfälle von Pater R. im Bereich des eigenen Bistums zugegeben, denen man “leider nicht nachgegangen sei”.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Sexueller Missbrauch Canisius Kolleg – Katholische Kirche behinderte Ermittlungsbehörden

DEUTSCHLAND
Hannover Zeitung

Die katholische Kirche hat die Aufklärung der Straftaten des Haupttäters Pfarrer Peter R. im Missbrauchsskandal am Berliner Gymnasium Canisius Kolleg 2010 aktiv behindert. Das zeigt erstmals die ARD/WDR-Dokumentation “Richter Gottes” von Eva Müller aus der Sendereihe “Die Story im Ersten” am Montag, 30. November um 22.45 Uhr. Darin äußert sich der Täter zum ersten Mal öffentlich. Die Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin prüft nun die Aufnahme neuer Ermittlungen.

Anfang 2010 berichteten ehemalige Schüler von Pfarrer Peter R. am Berliner Gymnasium Canisius Kolleg, dass er sie nackt fotografiert, angefasst und zur Selbstbefriedigung genötigt habe. Sie lösten damit den Missbrauchsskandal der katholischen Kirche in Deutschland aus. Die Rede ist von mehr als 100 Opfern. Bereits im Februar 2010 meldete die Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin, dass Peter R.’s Taten verjährt seien und deshalb keine strafrechtlichen Konsequenzen hätten.

Vier Wochen später, Anfang März 2010, meldete sich jedoch im Bistum Hildesheim ein 14-jähriges Mädchen, das dort angibt, Peter R. habe auch sie bedrängt. Die Kirche veröffentlicht diese Meldung nicht, informiert die Familie der 14-Jährigen und die Behörden nicht, vernimmt aber den Täter selbst dazu und leitet durch den Hildesheimer Bischof Norbert Trelle eine interne, kirchenrechtliche Voruntersuchung zu diesem Fall ein. Zur selben Zeit sagt der damalige Vorsitzende der Deutschen Bischofskonferenz, Erzbischof Zollitsch, öffentlich eine umfassende, “ehrliche Aufklärung” und bessere Zusammenarbeit mit den staatlichen Behörden zu.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Church’s ‘terrible failure’ on abuse

AUSTRALIA
9 News

AAP

Melbourne Archbishop Denis Hart insists he has not tried to blame dead church figures for the archdiocese’s “terrible failure” to act on abuse complaints.

Archbishop Hart says his predecessors failed to act, but excluded 1996-2001 Melbourne archbishop Cardinal George Pell from his criticism.

Archbishop Hart says former archbishop Frank Little put children in danger by not acting on complaints about Fr Peter Searson, one of a succession of pedophile priests in the Doveton parish.

“It’s just a horror story,” Archbishop Hart said of Doveton.

“These things were being presented again and again and again, and nothing was happening.”

During his evidence to the child abuse royal commission, senior counsel Gail Furness SC said some of the criticisms were levelled primarily at Archbishop Little and one of his vicar-generals, Monsignor Gerald Cudmore.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Pokin Around: Cardinal Law, portrayed as protector of pedophile priests, once worked here

MISSOURI
Springfield News-Leader

Steve Pokin, spokin@news-leader.com November 30, 2015

On Thanksgiving I went to the Moxie Cinema and watched “Spotlight,” the best movie I’ve ever seen on journalism, including “All the President’s Men.”

The film, based on real events, has a strong local connection: Cardinal Bernard Francis Law, who is the villain.

The film chronicles the Boston Globe’s Pulitzer-Prize winning coverage of how the Boston Diocese protected pedophile priests and moved them from parish to parish. The man behind these decisions was Law, who became a Cardinal while archbishop of the Boston Diocese, the third largest in the nation.

Before going to Boston, Law, now 84, was bishop of the Springfield-Cape Girardeau Diocese from October 1973 to January 1984.

As a result of the Globe’s dogged reporting, Law became a sort of poster boy, representing how the Catholic Church initially covered up of the misdeeds of pedophile priests.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

“Spotlight” shows journalism at its best, Catholic Church at its worst

UNITED STATES
Saint Peters Blog

By Tom Ohara – Nov 30, 2015

If you want to be simultaneously appalled and inspired, go see the movie “Spotlight.”

It’s about the Boston Globe’s 2001-2002 Pulitzer Prize-winning investigation into the Boston archdiocese’s decades-long cover-up of child sex abuse by its priests and brothers.

The film is unusual because it portrays people doing actual journalism. There are no gaggles of goofballs with microphones shouting stupid questions in a hallway.

“Spotlight,” the name of the newspaper’s investigative team, shows that quality journalism is usually the result of a dogged slog.

One of the heroes is Marty Baron, a Tampa-born guy who as the Globe’s new editor in 2001 asked some unpleasant questions about the paper’s coverage of the scandal.

The investigative team found the disturbing answers: that the archdiocese knew about the extent of the abuse for decades and used its considerable money and power to cover it up.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Archdiocese shows ownership title for former hotel

GUAM
Pacific Daily News

The group Concerned Catholics of Guam has argued that Archbishop Anthony Apuron gave control of the Yona seminary to the Neocatechumenal Way, but the church has released land documents to dispute that claim.

The archbishop of the Archdiocese of Agana, as the “corporation sole,” holds the title to the former Accion Hotel, which is currently being used as a seminary, according to a document released by the Archdiocese of Agana last weekend.

“The archbishop of Agana is the legal and sole owner of the Redemptoris Mater Seminary of Guam in Yona — (formerly) Hotel Accion property,” a statement from the archdiocese, approved by Msgr. David Quitugua, the archdiocesan vicar general, states. The statement was released in the Nov. 29 edition of the Umatuna Si Yu’os, the archdiocese’s newspaper.

The archdiocese released the property’s certificate of title, which was issued by the Department of Land Management on Oct. 30, 2015, following publicly expressed concerns from Concerned Catholics of Guam that Apuron may have signed a document that might have placed the property under the control of the leaders of the Neocatechumenal Way.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatileaks 2 trial continues

VATICAN CITY
ANSA

(ANSA) – Vatican City, November 30 – The second hearing in the so-called Vatileaks 2 trial against five people for allegedly leaking confidential Holy See documents ended after less than 15 minutes on Monday after the court decided to grant five days to the new lawyer representing defendant Francesca Chaouqui to prepare her defence. “I don’t understand a thing, there’s no proof against me,” Chaouqui said after the hearing.

“In the next five days we must discover why I’m here,” the PR expert added. Chaouqui’s co-defendants, investigative journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi, Monsignor Lucio Angel Vallejo Balda and his former assistant Nicola Maio, all attended Monday’s hearing. Chaouqui, Balda and Maio are charged with leaking the confidential material and Nuzzi and Fittipaldi of using it in books published recently documenting Vatican waste and mismanagement and lavish spending by clergymen.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

Vatileaks: “Sesso, bugie e padrini politici, io e la Chaouqui amanti e nemici”

ROME
La Repubblica

di MARCO ANSALDO e CORRADO ZUNINO

ROMA – Nel memoriale che monsignor Lucio Vallejo Balda ha consegnato al primo avvocato (poi sostituito) l’8 novembre scorso c’è la confessione dei suoi rapporti, anche carnali, con Francesca Immacolata Chaouqui. Ci sono le sue convinzioni preoccupate: “Lei era dei servizi segreti, aveva dietro Bisignani”. E c’è il racconto di tutti gli amici importanti della pierre assurta a commissario delle finanze del Vaticano per volontà di Papa Bergoglio.

I GIORNI DELLA TENTAZIONE
“Io non potevo cedere… Avevo sempre il Papa davanti agli occhi che parlava della sacralità delle donne sposate e del matrimonio “, si tormenta monsignore. È il momento più drammatico della confessione a proposito del suo rapporto con la Chaouqui, uno dei commissari alle finanze della Santa Sede.

Sono trascorsi sei giorni dal suo arresto e monsignore detta il suo memoriale sulla diffusione delle carte segrete della Prefettura economica di cui era il segretario. “Repubblica” presenta questo documento mentre oggi, al processo sul caso Vatileaks, sia il monsignore spagnolo sia la pierre cosentina saranno interrogati dalla Corte. Sul tavolo, una prima importante decisione presa nei giorni scorsi: il rifiuto da parte della corte della richiesta avanzata dal legale d’ufficio di Balda (tutti gli imputati di questo processo presso la Santa Sede non hanno avvocati di fiducia) di sottoporre il suo assistito a una perizia psichiatrica.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.

VatiLeaks trial postponed, main suspects exchange low blows

VATICAN CITY
Wichita Eagle

dpa

VATICAN CITY
A key hearing in the VatiLeaks 2 trial over leaks related to alleged financial scandals in the Vatican was Monday postponed by a week to give a new defense lawyer time to study the case.

Main suspects Monsignor Lucio Vallejo Balda and Francesca Chaouqui were to be questioned, but presiding judge Giuseppe Dalla Torre at the Vatican court rescheduled the hearing for Dec. 7 after Chaouqui showed up with a new counsel.

Laura Sgro replaced Agnese Camilli, who was a court-appointed lawyer, the Vatican said in a statement.

Vallejo Balda, a Spanish member of the conservative Catholic movement Opus Dei, and Chaouqui, an Italian public relations consultant, were members of a now-disbanded committee that advised Pope Francis on financial and administrative reforms.

They are accused, along with an aide of the monsignor, of passing on information to journalists Gianluigi Nuzzi and Emiliano Fittipaldi.

Former friends Vallejo Balda and Chaouqui are now in the midst of a fierce spat.

In a written statement to the court, leaked to Italian newspaper La Repubblica on Monday, Vallejo Balda confesses to having had sex with Chaouqui.

He describes her as a dangerous social climber with friends in high places, including former Italian premier Silvio Berlusconi.

Several Italian newspapers last week quoted confidential prosecution papers containing lewd and foul text messages between the two. Chaouqui claims they were edited to tarnish her reputation.

Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.