ABUSE TRACKER

• Diocese said it hopes to quickly revise bankruptcy settlement
• Judge said a revised plan must include more safeguards against invalid and inflated claims

The Catholic Diocese of Camden New Jersey said Wednesday that it was reworking an $87.5 million settlement with 300 sexual abuse victims after a U.S. bankruptcy judge said that the proposal could put insurers on the hook for inflated or invalid claims.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Jerrold Poslusny issued a decision late Tuesday which said that the proposed bankruptcy plan would create a settlement trust that was “biased” against insurers and could allow for payment of inflated, invalid or fraudulent claims, in addition to excessive attorneys’ fees.

The diocese, which serves 480,000 Catholics in six New Jersey counties, said Wednesday that it intended to submit a revised bankruptcy plan incorporating the judge’s feedback as quickly as possible.

“The Diocese remains hopeful that it will expeditiously exit the Chapter…

View Cache

The Diocese and the attorneys representing survivors of sexual abuse will renegotiate the terms of the agreement.

A federal judge rejected the Camden Diocese’s $87.5 million settlement to sexual-abuse survivors Tuesday, saying it would leave insurance companies on the hook for invalid claims and inflated attorneys’ fees.

The Catholic Diocese of Camden, bankrupted by sexual-abuse lawsuits, agreed last year to compensate more than 360 survivors as it navigates Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The plan called for some insurers to pay $30 million into a trust covering claims and expenses.

However, the Diocese’s insurers expressed concerns that loopholes in the proposal could leave them paying more than $30 million. In the coming weeks, the Diocese and the abuse survivors’ attorneys will renegotiate the settlement.

Attorneys representing the survivors said they respect the decision from Bankruptcy Judge Jerrold Poslusny Jr. and criticized the insurers.

“The Diocese paid its insurance companies millions of dollars…

View Cache

On August 31, the Cortland County Sheriff’s Office arrested 36-year-old Nathan Brooks of Lafayette for three misdemeanors surrounding multiple occasions of sexual abuse.

Back on August 22, Cortland County Sheriff’s received reports of allegations of sexual abuse by Brooks, a priest with the Diocese of Syracuse, that took place between 2019 and 2021.

Cortland County Sheriff’s Office says an undisclosed location in the Town of Homer and an undisclosed location in the City of Cortland are where the allegations stemmed from.

“The investigation revealed that the defendant, Nathan Brooks, had subjected one victim to inappropriate sexual contact on multiple occasions over several years. The victim was known to Mr. Brooks,” said the Cortland County Sheriff’s Office.

Brooks is due in Homer Town Court, Tuesday, September 5th and Cortland City Court September 6th.

In July, the Syracuse Roman Catholic Diocese agreed to pay $100 million to sex abuse victims, as part…

View Cache

A priest in the Syracuse Catholic Diocese has been charged with forcibly touching a minor over several years, deputies said.

Rev. Nathan Brooks, 36, of LaFayette, is accused of touching the minor between 2019 and 2021 in the town of Homer and in the city of Cortland, Cortland County Sheriff’s Office deputies said in a news release Friday.

Brooks is an administrator at the Church of the Nativity at St. Joseph in LaFayette, Immaculate Conception in Pompey, St. Leo in Tully and St. Patrick Mission in Otisco.

Brooks was ordained in 2019 at the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception in Syracuse. He graduated from Bishop Grimes High School in 2005 before attending St. Mary’s Seminary & University in Baltimore, according to The Catholic Sun.

Brooks has been suspended from all priest duties as the criminal investigation plays out, the diocese said in…

View Cache

Dissident Russian artist Andrei Molodkin has created a sculpture he plans to fill with blood donated by victims of abuse in the Catholic Church, which he says he will project on to the gates of the historic city – the home of the Pope.

Human blood is set to “soak” the Vatican in a protest inspired by the late singer Sinead O’Connor.

Dissident Russian artist Andrei Molodkin has created a sculpture he plans to fill with blood donated by victims of abuse in the Catholic Church, which he says he will project on to the gates of the historic city – the home of the Pope.

Molodkin – who made headlines after selling blood-soaked copies of Prince Harry’s memoir earlier this year – says he expects Catholics to be offended by his latest stunt but insists: “It doesn’t bother me.”

He believes there will be outrage similar to that caused…

View Cache

The Abuse Reform Implementation Task Force (ARITF) held an in-person meeting on Monday in Dallas, TX. This was our first in-person meeting since President Bart Barber announced changes to the ARITF on August 11. The ARITF wishes to express our gratitude to the messengers to the 2023 SBC Annual Meeting in New Orleans for granting us an additional year to fulfill our assignment and for once again demonstrating overwhelming support for the work of abuse reform.

Protecting the vulnerable and caring for the abused is at the heart of every gospel-centered ministry. Collectively, we recognize the significance and the urgency of the task entrusted to us. We are grateful to President Barber for the confidence he has placed in this task force and for his unwavering support for this cause. We also wish to thank Send Relief for its generous financial support and ongoing partnership with the ARITF.

…

View Cache

Dozens of Chicago-area residents are speaking out against a city plan to sell public land to Plymouth Brethren Christian Church (PBCC) to build a local church. Some claim the religious group will benefit from the deal at taxpayers’ expense, while others allege a pattern of abuse in the denomination.

On Wednesday, at a South Barrington Park District board meeting, residents objected to the proposed $1.7 million purchase of public land by PBCC, a Protestant denomination headquartered in Australia. The group had planned to construct a church and school on a 34-acre site in the wealthy northwest Chicago suburb.

An attorney for the park district, Scott Puma, announced at the public meeting that “The real estate closing is on hold,” according to a report in the Daily Herald. 

Several residents spoke up against the proposed land sale in the meeting and later to media. Resident Sage Fattahian  View Cache

Today a judge in Massachusetts dismissed the criminal case against former Catholic Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, saying that he was incompetent to stand trial.  The disgraced and defrocked McCarrick was being prosecuted for sexually assaulting a child decades ago. His attorneys claimed that the once-powerful 93-year-old American prelate suffered from dementia and lacked the mental capacity to stand trial.

Our hearts go out to McCarrick’s accuser. We stand in solidarity with him and commend him for his pursuit of justice. We believe a verdict of guilty would have been rendered had the case been allowed to proceed. 

There is another case on behalf of the same survivor being prosecuted in Wisconsin. We hope that the courts in that state will reach a different decision, and finally allow this brave survivor his day in court.

McCarrick is the first Catholic cardinal in the United States to face criminal…

View Cache

The former home of a notorious paedophile priest has been set alight in Co Down.

Police spotted the blaze at the vacant parochial house in Hilltown where Fr Malachy Finegan had lived early on Thursday morning.

Extensive damage was caused to the building during the blaze, which police believe was started deliberately.

Finegan, who died in 2002, was parish priest for Clonduff parish in Hilltown in the 1990s.

He has been accused of sexually abusing numerous children over several decades. He was never prosecuted.

Finegan, who also taught and worked at St Colman’s College in Newry from 1967 to 1987, is alleged to have carried out some of his abuse at the parochial house.

In 2019, the Clonduff Parish with which the building is connected launched a consultation among parishioners on the future of the building. It has lain vacant for a number of years.

A PSNI spokeswoman said: “A passing…

View Cache

Sir, — I read Canon Judith Maltby’s letter on the breaking of the seal of the confessional for confession of sexual abuse (25 August) with interest, because I consider this debate has far wider implications for the seal generally, which have either not been recognised or, if recognised, have not been articulated by either side in the debate, so far as I have seen.

This has been carried on entirely, it seems, in the context of sexual abuse by clerics and others, which is understandable, given the gravity of the offence and the Church of England’s lamentable past failure to deal with it and seeming continued inability to do so. It is consequently also understandable that there should be calls to require any confessor who receives a confession from an abuser, confessing to what they have done, to be required to break the seal and report the abuser. The…

View Cache

Sir, — In no way do I wish to minimise the ethical complexities surrounding breaking the seal of confession to those of us in the Catholic tradition of the Church of England. Any discussion, however, must take place in full acknowledgement of the catastrophic safeguarding failures of the Church and its chronic poor performance in incorporating learning from external reviews or inquiries.

I had hoped for a more substantial defence of the seal from The Society’s submission to the IICSA response unit at the Home Office (News, 16 August). Disappointingly, the submission is thin on evidence.

The Society bishops state: “[It is a] a remote contingency, and unproven concern, that perpetrators will abuse the Seal. . . We are not aware of examples of penitents in the Church of England alleging that the ‘process’ of Confession has been in some way misused by priests to cover up instances of…

View Cache

[Includes timeline.]

Former mayor calls for psychiatrist’s contract to be terminated, wants to know what policies are in place to protect patients

Former Mountain View Mayor Sally Lieber is asking the El Camino Healthcare District to terminate a psychiatrist’s contract and explain what actions it took after the hospital learned in 1988 that the doctor, who has practiced at El Camino Hospital since 1980, was accused of sexual misconduct while a priest in Southern California.

In a July 11 email to the five elected board members of the El Camino Healthcare District, Lieber asked for details on what policy changes, if any, were made as a result of the accusations against Dr. Thomas Havel. The allegations were first brought to light in a 1988 civil suit that accused Havel of repeatedly touching, caressing and attempting intercourse with a girl he was counseling beginning in 1968 when she was 13 and he…

View Cache

Fr Joseph Marmion SJ’s abuse of more than 60 pupils in Ireland throughout the 1960s and 1970s is detailed in a newly published report.

The newly published report “A Restorative Response to the Abuse of Children Perpetrated by Joseph Marmion SJ” interviewed 62 past pupils of the Irish priest who was a teacher in three schools in Ireland throughout the 1960s and 1970s.

The report, written by Catherine O’Connell and Barbara Walshe, cautions readers of “explicit examples of abuse” perpetrated by Marmion that can make for “difficult reading and may cause upset.”

Fr. Marmion, who died in 2000, taught at Clongowes Wood College in Kildare, Crescent College in Limerick, and Belvedere College in Dublin throughout the 1960s and ’70s.

The Irish priest was removed from school teaching in 1978 following disclosures of sexual abuse during a school trip to Vienna in 1977. He was…

View Cache

Survivors’ group say Archbishop questioned why survivor did not return to police with claims a second time

The leader of the Catholic Church in Ireland has this week denied an accusation of “victim blaming” following a meeting with a clerical sex abuse survivors group.

Primate of all-Ireland Archbishop Eamon Martin met with a group of child sex abuse survivors in the Dromore diocese earlier this year.

The Dromore Survivors group say the Archbishop questioned a man who was abused as child by the pedophile priest Fr Malachy Finegan about his failure to take his case to police for a second time, after an initial report was not followed up.

Survivor Sean Faloon, who says he was raped “at least 350 times” by the late Fr Finegan, told Belfast Live he had first reported his abuse to police in the 1990s at the age of 17.

He told Belfast Live that,…

View Cache

Ron Hunter was repeatedly assaulted and sex-trafficked as a child. At 63, he’s telling his story – to protect others and heal himself

Ron Hunter is taking us on a trip down memory lane – or more precisely, 42nd Street in Manhattan. He is showing us the spots where, half a century ago, he was repeatedly molested, sexually assaulted and raped from the age of 13.

All because of the Boy Scouts.

He leads us to the block that for four years in the early 1970s was his patch. It was here that he was brought by the Boy Scout leader who groomed him, then sex-trafficked under his street name “Angel” for five bucks a trick.

Hunter stands beneath the awning of the former Selwyn Theatre, which in 1972 was a movie house showing pornographic films like Deep Throat and The Devil in Miss Jones. That’s where in the winter…

View Cache

Faced with more than 500 lawsuits stemming from clergy sexual abuse, the San Francisco Catholic diocese last week said it had no choice but to seek Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. San Francisco Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone wrote, “the bankruptcy process is the best way to provide a compassionate and equitable solution” for abuse survivors. But victims say the bankruptcy is just a ploy to deprive them of justice and their day in court. San Francisco’s move to seek bankruptcy relief follows similar filings by the Oakland and Santa Rosa dioceses, following multiple clergy abuse lawsuits. Across the country, more than 30 dioceses have have sought bankruptcy protection. We’ll talk with experts about what it all means for the church, its faithful, and abuse survivors.

Guests:

Sophia Bollag, reporter, San Francisco Chronicle

Michael O’Loughlin, national correspnodent and associate editor, America: The Jesuit Review – O’Loughlin has covered the Catholic church for both the Boston…

View Cache

 A federal bankruptcy judge has denied a motion to proceed with victims’ settlements related to clergy abuse within the Diocese of Camden.

The diocese, in April 2022, agreed to pay $87.5 million to settle claims for roughly 300 victims of clergy sexual abuse. The money was slated to go to a trust fund set up over a four-year period from the diocese and related Catholic entities. The settlement also included maintaining or enhancing protocols to protect children.

However, Judge Jerrold Poslusny, Jr. said the court needs to hear more on the merits of the settlement reached between the diocese and a committee representing victims.

The judge also denied a motion from insurance companies to enforce a previous settlement with the church, saying it was intended to be part of a plan which ultimately never came to a vote and wasn’t approved by victims.

In a statement, the diocese said…

View Cache

An Illinois megachurch pastor, who resigned after being accused of mishandling alleged sexual misconduct by his son, a former pastor, is starting a new church.

“It is obvious that God is doing something amazing and miraculous in Song and Sword,” said Mike Baker, previous pastor of Eastview Christian Church (ECC). “Same old pastor, same old town, but a brand-new work that God is going to do in us and through us.”

Baker made the announcement during a Vision Sunday online sermon on Aug. 20 for Song and Sword, the online ministry Baker launched in April. Song and Sword also seems to be the name of the church that Baker said he will launch at the Chateau Hotel and Conference Center in Bloomington, Ill., on Sept. 10. Baker said he has signed a one-year contract with the Chateau.

Baker’s son, Caleb Baker, resigned from a pastoral position at ECC…

View Cache

Maureen Sullivan spent almost five years of her childhood in the notorious Irish institution. Now, at 71, she is speaking out, despite some defenders of the Catholic Church still wanting her to stay silent

Just after her 12th birthday in 1964, Maureen Sullivan’s teacher, Sister Cecilia, sat her down and told her to be honest about what was going on at home. Hopeful that perhaps she might be allowed to go and live with her beloved granny if she dared tell the truth, Sullivan admitted to Sister Cecilia what her stepfather had been doing to her for years.

Sullivan’s father had died suddenly when her mother was 19 and, faced with the terrible fate of being a destitute widow, her mother married a new man who she hoped would save the family from starvation. Instead, that man went on to make her children’s lives a living hell. Sullivan detailed the…

View Cache

Victims push for new abuse probe They ask DC AG to open investigation SNAP: ‘Dozens of abusers are/were here but remain hidden’ And they prod DC’s archbishop to reveal more predators

WHAT

Holding signs and childhood photos, clergy sex abuse victims and their supporters will hold a sidewalk news conference revealing the names of the “DC’s Most Dangerous Dozen Child Molesting Clerics” – 12 proven, admitted &/or credibly accused predator priests who

• are still alive and presumably a threat to children now,
• are or were working and or living in the District of Columbia BUT
• are NOT on the official DC Catholic archdiocesan ‘credibly accused’ list.They will also release copies of two letters they’re sending:
• one to DC Attorney General Brian Schwalb, urging him to launch a ‘thorough, full-scale investigation, like 25 other AGs across the US have done, into Catholic clergy sex crimes and cover ups in the Washington DC archdiocese,’…

View Cache

Congregation ought to be renamed the Cheapskate Bullies for its persistent torment of abuse survivors via the legal system

The autumn sunshine was sweltering in St Peter’s Square when Pope John Paul II beatified Edmund Rice in October 1996, but it was still not as hot as the celebrations which included an al fresco holy hooley called “the Rice rave”. This, the penultimate step to canonisation, was the answer to generations of schoolboys’ daily prayer all over Ireland since 1961 that the founder of the Christian Brothers would be declared a saint by Rome.

RTÉ beamed the ceremony live from the Vatican. It featured a procession of 23 of Ireland’s most senior Catholic churchmen and 12 Oireachtas members, led by the ministers for education and defence in the Fine Gael-Labour Party government and the deputy leader of Fianna Fáil.

None of the dignitaries raised as much as…

View Cache

The Rape Crisis organisation in Louth has been criticised by clerical sex abuse survivors campaigning to strip a former leader of the Christian Brothers of a Freedom of Drogheda award.

Local councillors awarded the honour to Brother Edmund Garvey, a Drogheda native, in 1997.

Survivors of sexual abuse by Christian Brothers want local councillors to rescind the honour because of a widely criticised legal strategy adopted under Brother Garvey’s stewardship that has frustrated victim’s attempts to claim redress in the courts.

The Louth-based Rape Crisis North East said last weekend that the decision to rescind the Freedom of Drogheda from Br Garvey was a matter for local councillors.

In contrast, the national umbrella organisation, Rape Crisis Network Ireland, has rowed in behind the survivors’ campaign, saying the issue was about holding the Christian Brothers to account for an “obstructionist” legal strategy.

The chairperson of Rape Crisis North East is a…

View Cache

McCarrick Is Believed to Be the Highest Ranked Catholic Official Accused of Child Sexual Abuse and Facing Civil Lawsuits

(Saint Paul, MN) – Today in Dedham District Court, Judge Paul J. McCallum ruled that defrocked Cardinal Theodore McCarrick cannot stand trial due to dementia. McCarrick was facing trial for allegedly abusing a minor in the 1970s during a wedding reception at Wellesley College in Massachusetts. At the time of the alleged abuse, McCarrick was assigned to and living in the rectory at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City.

“Cardinal McCarrick not being able to stand trial comes as no surprise. What is shocking is that he was given permission by the pope, cardinals, and clerical culture for so many decades and allowed to do so much harm to so many for so long,” said attorney Jeff Anderson.

Jeff Anderson & Associates represents approximately 7 survivors who were abused by McCarrick while he…

View Cache

A Massachusetts judge on Wednesday dismissed a criminal charge against former high-ranking Catholic cleric Theodore McCarrick, ruling that the 93-year-old former archbishop of Washington is incompetent to stand trial for alleged child sexual abuse.

The decision underscores the fast-closing window for potential accountability for McCarrick, who once was one of the U.S. Catholic Church’s most visible and connected leaders and now is one of its most notorious figures.

McCarrick had been charged with assaulting a 16-year-old boy at a wedding in 1974, the first criminal charge since a slew of sexual misconduct accusations surfaced in 2018 and he was removed from public ministry. He still faces a second criminal sexual abuse case, involving the same alleged victim, in Wisconsin.

Judge Paul McCallum, of the Dedham District Court in Massachusetts, dismissed the case in a morning hearing, after experts for the defense and the prosecution agreed…

View Cache

The 93-year-old former prelate is the most senior cleric to face charges in the Catholic Church’s abuse crisis.

Theodore McCarrick, the highest-ranking Catholic cleric in the United States to face charges in the church’s ongoing sexual abuse crisis, is not competent to stand trial, a judge in Massachusetts ruled.

The disgraced former cardinal, who is 93, was declared unfit by a Dedham District Court judge on Wednesday.

Mr. McCarrick faced three counts of indecent assault and battery in Massachusetts, based on an accusation that he repeatedly sexually assaulted a teenage boy at a family wedding reception in 1974.

The charges in Massachusetts were seen as a milestone in victims’ efforts to hold abusers in Catholic settings accountable. Thousands of clergy members in the United States have been accused of crimes in the sprawling reckoning with sexual abuse, secrecy and cover-ups in the Catholic Church. But because most of the…

View Cache

Defrocked cardinal Theodore McCarrick, the highest-ranking Roman Catholic official in the United States to face criminal charges in the clergy sexual abuse scandal, was found not competent to stand trial Wednesday in a case alleging he had sexually assaulted a 16-year-old boy in Wellesley in the 1970s.

Dedham District Judge Paul McCallum ruled that 93-year-old McCarrick was incompetent after two medical experts found he suffered from dementia, then granted the state’s motion to drop all charges.

McCarrick, who appeared remotely via Zoom, showed no emotion when a court clerk told him the case was dismissed. Dressed in a gray sweater vest over a white shirt, he sat hunched over a table in a room at his residence, an assisted living facility in Missouri for clerics accused of molesting children.

His accuser did not attend the hearing, but sent a two-page victim impact statement to the judge…

View Cache

A Boston judge ruled Wednesday that former top US Catholic official Theodore McCarrick was cognitively unable to stand trial for sexually assaulting a teenage boy five decades ago.

Based on the testimony of a forensic psychologist that the 93-year-old has dementia, “Mr. McCarrick is not competent to stand trial,” ruled Massachusetts state judge Paul McCallum.

With that ruling, the state prosecutor withdrew the case against the former cardinal, the highest US Catholic official to face charges in the sweeping scandal over the systemic sexual abuse of minors in the Church.

“The commonwealth does not have a good-faith basis to proceed any longer with the prosecution given the testimony and the opinion of the psychologist that Mr. McCarrick is not restorable to competency,” the prosecutor said.

McCarrick, who was silent as he followed the hearing by video conference, was charged in 2021 with three counts of indecent assault and battery against…

View Cache

DEDHAM, Mass. (AP) — The once-powerful Roman Catholic Cardinal Theodore McCarrick will not stand trial on charges he sexually assaulted a teenage boy decades ago, as a Massachusetts judge dismissed the case against the 93-year-old on Wednesday because both prosecutors and defense attorneys agree he is experiencing dementia.

McCarrick, the ex-archbishop of Washington, D.C., was defrocked by Pope Francis in 2019 after an internal Vatican investigation determined he sexually molested adults as well as children. The McCarrick scandal created a crisis of credibility for the church, primarily because there was evidence Vatican and U.S. church leaders knew he slept with seminarians but turned a blind eye as McCarrick rose to the top of the U.S. church as an adept fundraiser who advised three popes.

During Wednesday’s hearing, Dr. Kerry Nelligan, a psychologist hired by the prosecution, said she found significant deficits in…

View Cache

The Bolivian Bishops’ Conference criticized the “excesses” that were committed during the successive raids carried out Aug. 28 at the offices of the provincial curia of the Society of Jesus in the city of La Paz.

In a statement issued Aug. 29 titled “For a justice system that respects the rights of all,” the Bolivian bishops questioned the excessiveness of the procedures carried out by the public prosecutor’s office “under the rationale that they sought to collect evidence” in the cases of alleged sexual abuse of minors that occurred in past decades.

In this context, the bishops noted that the legislation in force in Bolivia recognizes rights such as due process, the presumption of innocence, and that any actions taken must be legal.

The prelates therefore deplored the violation of these rights while demanding that any actions taken be “transparent and within the framework of due process” and “not exceed…

View Cache

A Christchurch man who suffered sexual abuse as a child at the hands of the Brothers of St John of God has criticised the Catholic Church for publicly offering help to survivors and then turning down his request for financial aid.

Darryl Smith was one of dozens of boys who suffered “extreme abuse and neglect” at Marylands School in Halswell between 1955 and the late 1980s.

On his first night at the school, in 1971, he was woken from his sleep, taken to an office and raped. He was 6 years old.

Now 59, Smith is raising money to go to an international summit for sexual assault survivors in Rome next month.

A beneficiary, he said he is so determined to get there that he’s been skipping meals and doctor’s appointments to save every cent possible. He said he is also trying to raise at…

View Cache

Richard Rorex Losch, an Episcopal priest canonically resident in the Episcopal Diocese of Alabama, has been indicted by a grand jury in Grafton County, New Hampshire, of a Class A Felony Aggravated Felonious Sexual Assault involving a minor under the age of 13. 

The case is State v. Richard Losch Docket: 215-2023-CR-0609 and has its genesis in conduct dating from the mid-1970s.

Glenda Curry, bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Alabama, has known of the issue for more than two years. Similarly, various church officials have known of the allegations for extended periods, including:

• Rob Morpeth, the now retired intake officer for the Diocese of Alabama.
• Todd Ousley, who resolutely refused to get involved.
• Presiding Bishop Michael Curry, who ignored myriad emails from the victim and is Ousley’s supervisor.

Anglican Watch’s investigation revealed that, in every instance, the Episcopal Church made up imaginary Title IV requirements, ignored the victim’s pleas for help, refused…

View Cache

A federal judge has dismissed an explosive lawsuit filed by several young women who accused a prominent private high school in Oklahoma City of fostering a culture of sexual abuse and harassment.

In Oklahoma City federal court, U.S. District Judge David L. Russell threw out the case against Mount St. Mary High School, which was brought by more than a dozen Jane Does who claimed breach of contract, negligence, intentional infliction of emotional distress, public nuisance and violations of Title IX.

In his ruling Russell agreed with defense attorneys that the statute of limitations had run out to file a Title IX case.

Title IX, the federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in schools — including sexual harassment and sexual assault — mandates that schools receiving federal funding have in place personnel and procedures to ensure a thorough and fair hearing for both the accuser and the accused.

Federal…

View Cache

A Georgia megachurch is facing allegations it failed to warn congregants about a former youth volunteer who’s been charged with trying to traffic a 16-year-old on the dark web.

Records obtained by The Roys Report (TRR) show that on June 30, authorities arrested Kelly Garrett Ivey—a former youth volunteer at Rock Springs Church in Milner, Ga.—and charged him with child cruelty and kidnapping. And last Monday, a grand jury indicted Ivey, 41, on first and second-degree charges of cruelty to children, trafficking, and three counts of criminal attempt to commit a felony, including kidnapping.

Yet, members of Rock Springs said they just learned of the charges against Ivey last week, when a local newspaper, The Monroe County Reporter, published a story. They added that the multi-site Rock Springs Church and its affiliated school, View Cache

A Virginia megachurch pastor appeared on stage Sunday after reports that his arrest during a prostitution sting nearly two years ago will be expunged.

John D. Blanchard, pastor of Rock Church International in Virginia Beach, was arrested in October 2021 during a sting in which an officer posed online as a teenage girl offering sex at a motel.

Authorities alleged Blanchard and 16 other men had been “soliciting sex from minors.” Blanchard has denied accusations against him.

The Chesterfield County Commonwealth’s Attorney’s office dropped the charges and agreed to expunge them about a year after Blanchard’s arrest. (Certain court records pertaining to Blanchard’s case can be viewed online.) But after uproar over that decision, the office appointed a special prosecutor in January this year to consider refiling charges.

That special prosecutor declared the evidence against Blanchard was “sound,” the Norfolk Virginian-Pilot reported in…

View Cache

It is no longer a secret that thousands of boys have suffered sexual abuse during their time spent within the Boy Scouts of America (BSA), an organization congressionally chartered in 1916. In 2020, the repercussions of the sexual abuse forced the BSA to seek bankruptcy protection, and filings against the organization topped 80,000 sexual abuse claims.

Three years later, the BSA has emerged from its Chapter 11 status. While officials overseeing the settlement process have begun directing claimants on how to receive their payout, questions remain.

While many are not clear on how much compensation they will receive and have been directed to follow up on an online portal instead of a courtroom, for others, there are concerns that those who should be held accountable for the abuse will not be. On top of all of this, a recent decision by the Supreme Court concerning another much-watched bankruptcy brings to…

View Cache

Tara Yellen graduated from Brighton High School in 1990. She said it took her decades to process the sexual abuse she suffered at the hands of a former teacher.

In 2020, Yellen filed a lawsuit against the district under the Child Victims Act (CVA), which extended the statute of limitations for survivors of child sexual abuse, resulting in more than 10,000 cases filed in New York State.

Yellen was awarded what is believed to be the single biggest CVA settlement in Monroe County history.

MORE | Former Rochester priest ordered to pay $95 million to sexual abuse victim | Rochester’s Catholic diocese sex abuse settlement includes $20.6 million from insurers

“It’s not just about the money, but money does have a lot of power in our society, and it sends a major message about what is OK, not OK, and what is…

View Cache

At Marylands School, sexual and physical abuse by Catholic brothers was brutal, prevalent and normalised. Survivors were so traumatised that, after they left, they found it difficult to understand the boundaries between right and wrong. 

This article is part of The Quarter Million, exploring the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in State Care. Read the introduction here and the rest of the series here.

Content warning: This feature describes physical, sexual and emotional violence, child abuse and neglect. If this is difficult for you and you would like some help, these services offer support and information: Auckland specialist service Help, 0800 623 1700; specialist men’s service Male Survivors Aotearoa, 0800 044 334; and Snap (Survivors network of those abused by priests). Please take care.

At the frayed edge of Christchurch, the city dissolving into large fields…

View Cache

Survivor demands resignation of Archbishop over Cardinal invite

A clerical child sex abuse survivor has called for the leader of the Catholic Church in Ireland to resign.

Several survivors of child sex abuse at the hands of Catholic clergy have spoken out against the Archbishop Eamon Martin, primate of All Ireland, after he invited a top American Cardinal – criticised for his handling of child sex abuse allegations – to celebrate a special anniversary Mass in Armagh at the weekend.

Cardinal Timothy Dolan was invited to celebrate the Mass at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Armagh on Sunday, to commemorate 150 years since the cathedral’s dedication.

Also present at the special Mass on Sunday was Archbishop Martin’s predecessor as primate of all-Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, who has faced significant criticism over his handling of child sex abuse allegations.

In 2010, Cardinal Brady denied accusations of a “cover up” when it…

View Cache

English River First Nation updates graves search

A chief in Saskatchewan says her heart is broken after ground-penetrating radar located 93 areas of interest at the site of a former residential school.

English River First Nation Chief Jenny Wolverine said it’s believed 79 of the areas of interest at the Beauval Indian Residential School could be the size of possible children’s graves and 14 could be the size of ones for infants.

“It breaks my heart that there’s likely more, or even that there’s even one,” Wolverine said Tuesday in Saskatoon.

“The experience of residential school is horrific.”

Earlier this month, 83 areas of interest were located at the site and the additional 10 were confirmed as archeological flags were being placed in the area.

Wolverine said the community is saddened at the discovery of more possible graves and it’s clear their work is not over yet.

The First Nation…

View Cache

Lawmakers say they will explore reopening a lookback window for survivors of childhood sexual assault to file civil suits when they return to Albany next session.

Friday’s funeral services for Albany Bishop Emeritus Howard Hubbard, who admitted to covering up sex abuse allegations within the diocese and faced multiple allegations himself, spurred strong emotions from survivors and conversation about future legislative action.

Sen. Brad Hoylman-Sigal sponsored both the Child Victims and Adult Survivors acts that waived the statute of limitations to allow survivors of sexual assault to file lawsuits against their abusers. Survivors can continue to file under the Adult Survivors Act until Nov. 23, but the senator said Friday the Legislature’s work isn’t finished.

“My heart goes out to all survivors, adults, who were abused as children and those who are covered by the Adult Survivors Act,” Hoylman-Sigal said. “In both instances, the state Legislature saw the wisdom of opening…

View Cache

NEW YORK – At the funeral Mass for Bishop Emeritus Howard Hubbard, Bishop Edward Scharfenberger of Albany said that there is “much to be celebrated,” from Hubbard’s life, while also acknowledging that his predecessor “was not an uncontroversial figure at times.”

Scharfenberger made the comments during his homily at the funeral Mass, held at the parish of St. Pius X in the diocese on Aug. 25. Throughout his approximately 17-minute address, Scharfenberger kept his mentions of Hubbard brief, instead highlighting the pure intentions priests have to serve, including those who fall victim to “their own sinfulness and brokenness.”

“There will be many, many times, as we say, to celebrate the life of the decedent, and [there] is much to be celebrated, and much to be contemplated on, even as we recognize by no stretch of the imagination was Bishop Hubbard … not an uncontroversial figure at times,” Scharfenberger said. “But…

View Cache

Bishop Edward Scharfenberger of Albany praised his late predecessor, Bishop Howard Hubbard, in a funeral homily Friday. 

Scharfenberger focused his homily on Christian hope and the blessing of priests, though he also  acknowledged that controversy surrounded the retired bishop, who announced a few weeks ago that he had civilly married a woman, prompting a correction from Scharfenberger.

“God wants all of us to be saved, without exception,” he said.

Scharfenberger delivered the homily Friday at a funeral Mass for Albany’s retired Bishop Hubbard, who died Aug. 19, a few days after suffering a stroke. 

“The theme of our reflection today is not so much the past but the present and the future,” Scharfenberger said in his homily for Hubbard, whose tenure was marred by numerous allegations of sexual abuse and an acknowledgement that he knowingly reassigned abusive priests.

Hubbard’s life “is much to be celebrated,” Scharfenberger said, while acknowledging that…

View Cache

With very little pomp and circumstance, Albany Bishop Emeritus Howard Hubbard was laid to rest on Friday.

“Where by life and not death have the final say, where that even when our days are over on this earth, our eternity is only beginning, and it is that eternity that we accompany our brother Howard towards, as we pray for him today, not only remembering, but hoping,” said Albany Bishop Edward Sharfenberger, who celebrated the Mass of Christian burial at St. Pius X in Loudonville.

Many of the funeral details had been kept private since Hubbard’s passing following a stroke last weekend at the age of 84.

Hubbard had asked the Vatican to be returned to the lay state before his death, but that was denied due to outstanding lawsuits against him regarding sexual abuse cases.

Hubbard made headlines again recently, when he announced he had married a woman in a civil…

View Cache

LOUDONVILLE — A collection of memories on poster boards greeted those arriving for Bishop Emeritus Howard J. Hubbard’s funeral on Friday, held at St. Pius X Church in Loudonville.

Sepia-tinged 1940s family photographs featuring the retired bishop alongside his sister Joan and recent snaps with friends dotted the boards outside of the chapel. Some cried, some took in all 84 years represented by the photos.

The pews at the church in Loudonville were packed with community members there to pay their respects.

“It was just wonderful,” said Randall Patterson, Senior Priest at St. Clement’s Roman Catholic Church in Saratoga Springs. “He was a simple man, he’d probably be a bit embarrassed by it.” he joked.

Patterson worked with Hubbard as chancellor of the diocese, calling their friendship a “tremendous gift.”

“He was for me, the most righteous man you ever wanted to meet,” Patterson said.

Righteousness was a repeated theme of the morning. After…

View Cache

Karen Bergman reported allegations of abuse to church leader in Manitoba in early 1990s; charges weren’t laid until 1998

One of the first people to inform the Roman Catholic Church of allegations of sexual abuse by Rev. Johannes Rivoire has spoken to a safeguarding commission looking into the church’s handling of those complaints.

Karen Bergman spoke to retired Quebec Superior Court judge André Denis in Winnipeg on Aug. 24. Denis was appointed by the Oblates of Mary Immaculate to lead the commission.

Rivoire worked as a parish priest in Rankin Inlet, Igloolik and Arviat as a member of the Oblates, a religious order in the Roman Catholic Church. He remains a member today.

Bergman lives in eastern British Columbia, so the commission flew her to Winnipeg to speak to Denis.

In an interview with Nunatsiaq News, Bergman said she first heard allegations against Rivoire while living in Arviat sometime in the early…

View Cache

COLUMBUS – A young Athens County woman who is suing her parents, her uncle and her uncle’s church, over sexual abuse she suffered as a minor, has asked a federal court to grant default judgment against the church on the issue of its liability for money damages.

In an opinion and order filed on Tuesday, Aug. 22, U.S. District Judge Edmund Sargus denied that request from plaintiff Serah Bellar – despite the fact that the Waverly, Ohio-based Dove Outreach Church has already been found in default by the court’s clerk for failing to properly answer Bellar’s lawsuit, and is no longer allowed to take part in court proceedings in the case. (Bellar, who has changed her name, is suing under the pseudonym Jane Doe to keep her new name out of the public eye.)

In April 2020 Serah Bellar, then 16 years old, ran away from her home in Amesville….

View Cache

An Episcopal priest whose name was blacked out in the Maryland attorney general’s report on sexual abuse in the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Baltimore has resigned his position as priest-in-charge of a parish in Western Maryland.

The Rev. Thomas Hudson, onetime spiritual leader of St. George’s Episcopal Church in Allegany County, left the position between May 26, when the bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Maryland ordered him to take a leave of absence, and July 31, according to Carrie Graves, a spokeswoman for the diocese.

The bishop, the Right Rev. Eugene Taylor Sutton, was to meet with Hudson in July and issue a pastoral directive — a formal written ruling — about the alleged act of sexual abuse by Hudson described in the report that came out in April. The directive could have restricted or terminated Hudson’s ministry.

But the priest, 75, resigned from the job…

View Cache

Paix Liturgique consacre une nouvelle lettre au cardinal Ouellet, assigné en justice à Lorient, mais aussi mis en cause par un nombre croissant de personnes au Canada. Comme pour ses agissements à Pontcallec – notamment son rôle dans le renvoi de l’état clérical de mère Marie Ferréol, la justice canonique a été dévoyée afin de couvrir le cardinal…

Trois témoignages plus que troublants contre le cardinal Ouellet

Après « Mme F », qui est sortie de l’anonymat début 2023 en accusant le cardinal d’inconduite sexuelle entre fin 2008 et 2010, et a rendu public son nom (Pamela Groleau) lorsqu’elle a été attaquée en diffamation par le cardinal Ouellet, deux autres victimes, que le cardinal Ouellet s’est bien gardé d’attaquer, l’accusent aussi de comportements inappropriés… voire plus grave.

Comme le rappelle début 2023 Radio Canada, « Paméla Groleau était stagiaire au sein du diocèse de Québec entre 2008 et 2010 au moment où…

View Cache

Instalação dos grupos foi determinada pelo Papa Francisco em 2019. Nas últimas duas décadas, pelo menos 108 sacerdotes foram acusados ou condenados por crimes sexuais

Dioceses em pelo menos três estados brasileiros instalaram ou preveem a instalação, este ano, de comissões para receber denúncias sobre casos de abuso sexual praticados por membros do clero contra crianças e adolescentes. A criação desses departamentos, em todas as dioceses do mundo, está prevista no decreto “Vos estis lux mundi” (“Vós sois a luz do mundo”, em latim), assinado pelo Papa Francisco em maio de 2019 e marco nas mudanças da legislação interna da Igreja Católica sobre os crimes sexuais contra pessoas vulneráveis. Pelo menos uma dessas dioceses teve padres denunciados por molestar menores — nas últimas duas décadas, pelo menos 108 sacerdotes foram acusados ou condenados por esse tipo de delito.

O caso mais recente é o da Diocese de Rondonópolis-Guiratinga, em…

View Cache

For the past 22 years, Ed Gavagan has been in what he calls a race against time.

Seeking justice for the sexual abuse he suffered as a teenager and later disclosed as an adult, Gavagan watched the man he accused — a Catholic priest — grow old while evading repeated efforts to hold him accountable. He even wrote to Pope Francis asking for his help.

When he heard Joseph Hart, the former bishop for Wyoming, died Wednesday, Gavagan was left feeling like he should have done more to pursue justice, he said. At 60 years old, with decades between him and the abuse, he had to remind himself that what happened was not his fault.

When justice feels unattainable, “it’s just awful,” Gavagan said. “It’s layers of misery on top of injury on top of distrust.”

Hart, who faced multiple sexual abuse allegations found credible by the Diocese of Cheyenne,…

View Cache

Though it is mind-boggling anyone would still have to ask, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests filed a letter last week to Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost, asking the state to hold accountable those in the Catholic church who have been accused of being predators. The letter is a formal request by the organization for a statewide investigation into the history and scope of child sexual abuse it says is being covered up across the state, according to a report by the Ohio Capital Journal.

“Information developed on 49 credibly accused clerics from other attorneys general’s reports with ties to Ohio,” said Claudia Vercellotti with the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. “It makes you wonder what would Attorney General Yost uncover if he merely investigated?”

According to the Capital Journal, the Catholic Conference of Ohio declined to answer whether it would support such an investigation. Rather, a spokesperson…

View Cache

After an NBC Bay Area investigation, the president of St. Ignatius College Preparatory School in San Francisco released a letter to parents and staff

St. Ignatius College Preparatory School in San Francisco is explaining how it handled the situation involving a former drama director accused of kissing a freshman student years ago.

The prestigious Catholic prep school is being sued by an alum, who claims former teacher Peter Devine kissed him more than two decades ago in the school theatre. St. Ignatius in an email sent Monday to its community said it took quick action when it received the report last year, but not everyone agrees.

Edward Reese, the school president, said in the email the former student reported the incident to the campus’ current principal in 2022. Reese said that principal “immediately filed a report with the [San Francisco…

View Cache

BETHLEHEM, Pa. – A former teacher at the Holy Infancy School has been charged with inappropriately touching a child, court paperwork confirms. 

Glenn Morgan, 61, of Easton is accused of inappropriately touching a juvenile female who was under the age of 13 at the time of the alleged incidents. 

The investigation began in Nov. 2022. 

The student accuses Morgan of touching her while helping with work during math class. The accusations include touching her legs and private parts while she was wearing a skirt. 

The juvenile accuses Morgan of continuing to inappropriately touch her over a period of months from January 2022 – June 2022. 

The court paperwork continues to say that during an interview with police in July 2023, Morgan admitted to touching the student, but blamed the touching on his nearsightedness. 

Authorities say they questioned Morgan, asking if he believed the victim was lying. Morgan told police he…

View Cache

The youngest American to be made a bishop, he died while still defending himself against allegations of sexual abuse.

Howard J. Hubbard, a once lionized “street priest” who became the nation’s youngest bishop at 38 and presided over the Albany, N.Y., diocese longer than any of his predecessors, then acknowledged covering up sex abuse scandals and was himself sued for sexually abusing children, died on Saturday in Albany. He was 84.

His death, in a hospital, was caused by a stroke, his spokesman, Mark Behan, said.

Bishop Hubbard, whose upstate New York diocese encompassed more than 300,000 Roman Catholics in 125 parishes in 14 counties, was widely regarded as a progressive voice in the church on social issues like the death penalty and the ordination of women, though he unsuccessfully sued the state in 1984 to block the approval of two abortion clinics in the diocese.

But when he resigned in 2014…

View Cache

The bishop – who has now been banned from the priory – threatened the nuns with excommunication in a saga that has rumbled on for months and sparked an intervention from the Vatican.

Catholic nuns in Texas have mutinied against their bishop and banned him from their monastery for “spiritual safety” in the latest salvo in a religious feud.

They say they have been subjected to “aggression, humiliation and spiritual manipulation” as a result of the “attitudes and ambitions” of Bishop Michael Olson.

It comes after Bishop Olson, the bishop of Fort Worth, claimed the head of the priory had broken her vow of chastity with a priest from outside the area.

In a statement this week, the Discalced Carmelite Nuns of Arlington denied the claims about their Mother Prioress.

The last few months have seen a battle between the nuns and Bishop Olson inside and outside court, featuring claims…

View Cache

ROCHESTER, Minn. – A partial settlement has been reached in a lawsuit claiming sex abuse at Lourdes High School in the 1970s.

A plaintiff, identified only as Doe 222, claims Father Joseph Cashman had unpermitted sexual contact with him while Doe 222 attended Lourdes High School from 1972 to 1974.  The sexual contact allegedly happened when the plaintiff was between 14 and 16 years old.

Doe 222 filed a lawsuit against Lourdes High School, Rochester Catholic Schools, and the Diocese of Winona, claiming they should have known Cashman was a danger to children and did not provide a reasonable level of safety and care.

However, Lourdes High School and Rochester Catholic Schools have now been dismissed as defendants after reaching a settlement with Doe 222.  The terms of the settlement have not been released.  The lawsuit against the Diocese of Winona is continuing and a trial has been scheduled to…

View Cache

U.S. District Judge Jane Triche Milazzo ruled that a deposition given in 2020 by Father Lawrence Hecker should remain under seal.

A federal judge on Monday denied a motion to unseal sworn testimony given by a retired Catholic priest who recently admitted on camera to WWL-TV that he sexually abused several teens in the 1960s and 1970s.

U.S. District Judge Jane Triche Milazzo ruled that a deposition given in 2020 by Father Lawrence Hecker should remain under seal. She said attorneys did not follow the proper procedure to get the documents unsealed.

Aaron Hebert, who says he was 13 when Hecker fondled his and other middle school boys’ genitals in a Gretna church in 1968, was able to get Hecker, now 91, to testify because of his advanced age, even after his case had been stopped by the Archdiocese of New Orleans’ bankruptcy.

Hebert’s attorney, Richard Trahant, says Hecker admitted…

View Cache

A former U.S. bishop cleared by the Vatican of multiple allegations he sexually abused minors and teenagers, after a review board under his diocese in Wyoming found that allegations against him were credible, has died.

Retired Wyoming Bishop Joseph Hart, of Cheyenne, died Wednesday, according to the Diocese of Cheyenne. He was 91.

Hart long maintained his innocence, denying all allegations of misconduct. In 2021, the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith cleared him of seven accusations of abuse and determined that five others couldn’t be proven with certainty.

Two other cases involving boys who were 16 and 17 couldn’t be prosecuted because the Catholic Church didn’t consider them minors at the time of the alleged abuse. The Vatican decree didn’t address another alleged victim.

Hart’s attorney, Thomas Jubin, at the time called some of the allegations “specious,” based on second- and third-hand information and some accusers emphasizing…

View Cache

The passing of Joseph Hart reflects a time of sorrow. Undoubtedly his death elicits painful memories for
many, especially those who sought accountability and justice.

The Scripture readings and the liturgy itself proclaim the mystery of God’s love and the mystery of Jesus’
victorious death and resurrection – mysteries that apply to the deceased and to our lives. At death, we
remember that final healing, reconciliation, and judgment rests in the hands of God. We entrust the
brokenness of humanity to the Lord, who alone has the power to restore us.

So, during this time of anguish, my message to those survivors remains, I support and believe you and will
continue to work and pray for healing for all involved in this profoundly painful time.

I also want to express my condolences to the family members of Joseph Hart and assure them of my prayers.
The funeral liturgies remind us of the compassionate love of God…

View Cache

A new lawsuit alleges local public school, private school and Catholic Church officials turned a blind eye for years to predatory behavior by former school health aide Robert Apodaca, who is accused in several child sex crimes cases and has pleaded guilty to three counts of molestation in one of them.

The 70-page complaint filed Tuesday in state District Court seeks an unspecified amount of damages from multiple defendants, including Santa Fe Public Schools, the Archdiocese of Santa Fe and Santo Niño Regional Catholic School.

It was filed by attorney Paul Linnenburger on behalf of a teen who alleges he was groomed and sexually assaulted by Apodaca in the 2018-19 school year, when he attended Gonzales Community School. The boy was one of four children Apodaca is accused sexually assaulting.

“Apodaca’s outward behavior was textbook sexual grooming,” the lawsuit alleges. “Administrators in the schools where he worked were warned of…

View Cache

The Victorian Court of Appeal has allowed a lawsuit against the Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne to proceed.

The Victorian Court of Appeal has ruled that the Catholic Church can be sued by the father of a choirboy allegedly sexually abused by Cardinal George Pell, who was acquitted of child sexual assault charges by the High Court in 2020.

The father of one of the alleged victims, referred to under the pseudonym ‘RWQ,’ sought damages, or compensation, for the mental harm and psychiatric shock he suffered as a result of his son overdosing on heroin as a result of the alleged sexual assault and from learning about the alleged sexual assault of his son.

The father brought the case against the Archdiocese of Melbourne, a branch of the Catholic Church, and Cardinal George Pell, and the case has continued despite the death of Cardinal Pell.

Before…

View Cache

The Catholic Church has lost a bid to restrict the family members of victims of child abuse by clergy from bringing civil cases against the institution.

The Court of Appeal on Friday rejected the church’s attempt to overturn a decision made by the Supreme Court in August last year that the father of a former choirboy who prosecutors had alleged was sexually abused by George Pell is entitled to sue the church.

The decision paves the way for affected family members of other victims to sue the church over the impact of their abuse.

The father alleged he had endured harm and suffering as a result of his son’s death, which he attributes to the actions of Pell.

Shine Lawyers senior associate Gabrielle Verhagen said the Catholic Church had sought to limit those who could bring actions against it to only those who had experienced the abuse themselves. She encouraged…

View Cache

In brief

The NSW Supreme Court has granted a permanent stay of proceedings in CM v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Armidale; EM v Trustees for the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Armidale [2023] NSWSC 1000 (23 August 2023).

Background

The plaintiffs are brothers who commenced proceedings against the Diocese claiming damages arising from sexual abuse perpetrated by Father Perrett in December 1976. Father Perrett, who died in July 2020, was the parish priest in Armidale and the alleged abuse took place on a camping trip he organised for children living on the Armidale Mission. 

The plaintiffs asserted that the Diocese was directly liable (in negligence) and vicariously liable for the conduct of Father Perrett. The plaintiffs also claimed that the Diocese was vicariously liable for the negligence of Sister Rita, a nun who died in 2003 and may have attended the camp and allegedly failed to…

View Cache

American prelate, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, ignored calls from Irish survivors of clerical abuse to step back from a mass yesterday to mark the 150th anniversary of St Patrick’s Cathedral in Armagh.

Cardinal Dolan, who is the Catholic archbishop of New York, was the chief celebrant at the mass in Armagh.

However, survivors of clerical abuse in the diocese of Dromore, including victims of Fr Malachy Finegan, wrote to Archbishop Eamon Martin of Armagh ahead of the liturgy, describing themselves as “appalled” by the decision to invite the 73-year-old American prelate to the mass and “the role afforded to him as chief celebrant”.

The American cardinal has been criticised for his role in transferring $57m into a special trust, when he was Archbishop of Milwaukee, in order to protect it from legal claims by clerical abuse victims. Other criticisms centre on a leaked 2017 transcript which suggested he sought to block…

View Cache

“This isn’t a prison,” a nun in the new BBC drama The Woman in the Wall says. “You can leave anytime you want. But where would you go? Who would have you? No one wants you. You’re a sinner.”

Set in the fictional town of Kilkinure in 20th-century Ireland, the show captures the story of Lorna Brady (Ruth Wilson), an unmarried mother who was formerly detained in a Magdalene Laundry. Established in the 18th century, the laundries catered for so-called “fallen women” who had engaged in sex work or had a child outside of wedlock. Ten of these institutions operated in post-independence Ireland between 1922 and 1996 and at least 10,000 women spent time in them.

Laundries were just one of many mechanisms by which the Catholic Church and the Irish state regulated behaviour that was perceived as deviant. The official investigation into Mother and Baby Homes (institutions similar to laundries where women…

View Cache

Bishop Michael Olson of Fort Worth, Texas, says the nun at the center of a dispute over allegedly broken vows may be excommunicated, along with the rest of the nuns in Arlington, Texas, where she is mother superior.

On Aug. 18, the Discalced Carmelite nuns of the Monastery of the Most Holy Trinity posted a statement on their website stating that due to the bishop’s alleged treatment of them, they “no longer recognize the authority of, and can have no further relations with, the current Bishop of Fort Worth or his officials, and forbid him or any of his officials or representatives to enter our monastery property or to have any contact or relations with the monastery or any of its nuns or novices.”

“No one who abuses us as has the current Bishop of Fort Worth, has any right to our cooperation or…

View Cache

I don’t know how to heal religious trauma. How do you begin to piece through decades of devotion? When the house of your belief is burned to the ground, the work of turning over the rubble, looking for valuables is tedious and painful. You might find treasures intact in the ash, but some things you felt were sacred have been caught in the fire and will never be what they once were. I turned to religion for an answer to my own pain, looking for a novena or a portrait of Our Lady that would heal the deep wounds inflicted by Christians, but while religion claims it can save you from anything it has a hard time saving you from itself.

I first heard about Hayden Anhedönia — better known by her alter ego, Ethel Cain – on TikTok from raving teens spellbound by the artist. They testified that her…

View Cache

Bishop Joseph Hart, who led the Diocese of Cheyenne, Wyoming, from 1978 until his 70th birthday in 2001, died Wednesday at age 91.

Hart was accused on multiple occasions of sexual abuse of minors, charges that he fervently denied. The Vatican’s doctrinal dicastery cleared him of several of the charges in 2021 while ruling that five other accusations “could not be proven with moral certitude” one way or another.

The Diocese of Cheyenne — which encompasses the entire state of Wyoming — said in a statement to CNA that Hart’s funeral services and burial will be held at the convenience of the family. The diocesan communications director told CNA on Friday that a formal statement on Hart from the diocese is pending.

Hart was accused of sexually abusing children in the mid-1970s, and numerous accusations were levied against him in 1989, 1992, 2002, and 2004. Hart was additionally accused of…

View Cache

A civil trial scheduled in December for a priest accused of molesting an altar boy at St. Mary Catholic Church in Aspen was canceled last month after parties agreed to dismiss the case, according to court records.

Father Michael O’Brien was set to stand a five-day jury trial in Denver County District Court beginning Dec. 4. District Court Judge David Goldberg approved the dismissal of the lawsuit on July 14. O’Brien, who was ordained in 2000, was the pastor at St. Mary from 2002-11.

Both sides agreed to pay their legal costs and attorneys’ fees, according to filings in the lawsuit. They also agreed to dismiss the case with prejudice, which means the plaintiff cannot refile the same claims against O’Brien. 

Neither side, however, backed off of their positions. 

The plaintiff’s lawyers said they agreed to the dismissal because of a recent Colorado Supreme Court opinion issued in an unrelated…

View Cache

An independent non-profit organisation has been employed by the scoping inquiry to assist it in interviewing survivors of abuse at private fee-paying schools about their experiences

The inquiry was set up last March following extensive revelations over previous months of historical clerical child sex abuse at private fee-paying schools run by religious congregations.

It is to make recommendations to the Government by November as to what form of inquiry might be set up to investigate such abuse.

In a letter to survivors, the inquiry said it had brought in Quality Matters, “a not-for-profit organisation with extensive experience of facilitating interviews with people who have experienced trauma and with survivors of institutional abuse,” to assist them in interviewing survivors. Those interviews have been taking place in recent weeks and will continue until September 30th.

Survivors who have agreed to take part in the process have been sent two booklets:…

View Cache

A group representing victims of clerical abuse has criticised the decision to invite a prominent US cardinal to Northern Ireland.

Timothy Dolan, the Archbishop of New York, is visiting Armagh on Sunday.

He will celebrate Mass at St Patrick’s Cathedral to mark 150 years since its dedication in August 1873.

However, abuse victims have expressed dismay at the invite.

Previously Cardinal Dolan has been criticised for authorising payments to abuser priests in exchange for their departure.

In the US, survivors of clerical sexual abuse have also raised concerns over Cardinal Timothy Dolan’s cover up of sexual abuse of children by Catholic clergy.

The Dromore Group said it was “appalled” at the decision.

It comprises survivors of Ireland’s most predatory paedophile priest, Fr Malachy Finegan, and their families.

The group has written to Archbishop Eamon Martin criticising the invite.

Its letter states: “The Dromore Group sees Dolan’s participation and role in…

View Cache

The Catholic Church on Friday suffered a loss in an Australian appeals court after a panel of judges said an abuse case brought by the father of an alleged victim of Cardinal George Pell could proceed. 

The cardinal allegedly abused the boy in the 1990s; his father brought suit against the Catholic Church and Pell in 2022, shortly before Pell’s death in January of this year. The alleged victim himself died of a heroin overdose in 2014. 

Church officials responded to the filing by arguing that the father was not the direct victim of the alleged abuse and therefore lacked standing to sue. 

The Victoria Supreme Court ruled last year that the lawsuit could proceed. On Aug. 25 the Court of Appeal agreed with the Supreme Court’s ruling from last year, ordering that the father could continue with his suit. 

Brisbane-based Shine Lawyers confirmed the decision in…

View Cache

An Australian court on Friday allowed a civil case to proceed against a Catholic archdiocese involving child sex abuse allegations against late Cardinal George Pell.

The Victoria state Court of Appeal in Melbourne refused to hear the church’s challenge to a judge’s ruling that a father, identified in court documents as RWQ, was entitled to sue for damages for the nervous shock he suffered when he learned of allegations his son had been abused.

Pell was the third highest-ranking cleric in the Vatican when he was convicted in 2018 of sexually abusing two 13-year-old choirboys in a Melbourne cathedral in 1996 when Pell was an archbishop.

Pell spent 13 months in prison before the convictions were overturned on appeal. He maintained his innocence until his death in Rome in January.

Victoria law prohibits media from identifying alleged victims of sexual offenses or any reporting that could identify…

View Cache

The children’s pastor of a church in rural North Carolina, who also taught elementary-age children at a local charter school, has been arrested and charged with child sex crimes. 

On Tuesday, Aaron Mirtsching, 41, of Morganton, N.C., was arrested “without incident” according to a statement from Burke County Sheriff’s Office. He was charged with three felony counts of third-degree sexual exploitation of a minor. Mirtsching bonded out the same day, paying $20,000 in fees. 

Mirtsching had served on staff as children’s director at Thrive Church in Morganton. According to a church statement, he was “immediately relieved of his duties.” (The church also referred to Mirtsching as “children’s pastor” in a now-deleted social post.)

The investigation was prompted by a cyber-tip from the state’s Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force, a collaboration of more than 200 law enforcement agencies. 

According to a law…

View Cache

The second-in-command of an historic community of U.S. Catholic priests that operates popular ministries across the country has resigned after he confirmed a woman’s report in early August that he made an unwelcome sexual advance toward her.

Fr. Frank Desiderio, vice president of the Paulist Fathers, corroborated the woman’s description of the incident to Paulist President Fr. René Constanza, whom the victim contacted on Aug. 10. The victim told Constanza that the sexual misconduct, which included inappropriate touching, had occurred a few days prior.

Desiderio —- a former parish priest, campus minister and seminary rector — has also been suspended from priestly ministry.

In a letter Constanza wrote to the Paulist communities where Desiderio served, which NCR obtained, Constanza said Desiderio “expressed his great remorse at his lapse in judgment.” 

“Fr. Frank profoundly regrets the harm he has caused the victim as well as…

View Cache

In 2018, “Sarah” was a 20-year-old college student and aspiring singer-songwriter—and “Andre” was a popular worship artist whose song had recently gone viral.

But that year, Sarah says Andre sexually assaulted her. And when she reported the alleged assault to the church where they both served on the worship team, the church kicked Sarah off the worship team, while Andre remained, she said.

The church where Sarah and Andre served is Churchome—a West Coast megachurch led by pastors Judah and Chelsea Smith and attended by celebrities Justin Bieber and Kourtney Kardashian. We’re not using Sarah’s real name because The Roys Report (TRR) does not report the names of alleged sexual assault victims unless they request it. Andre is a pseudonym, as well. We’re using it because Andre was never charged with a crime.

However, Phillip Ferrell, who served as the music curator at Churchome from 2016-2020, confirmed to TRR that Sarah…

View Cache

Father Alex Crow was warned by officials in the Archdiocese of Mobile about his conduct toward a teenager, The Pillar has confirmed, and was permitted to attend a trip for teens organized by an archdiocesan official — before he absconded to Europe last month with an 18-year-old who recently graduated from a Mobile high school.

The news raises questions about how much archdiocesan officials knew about Crow’s misconduct, and about whether his departure to Europe could have been prevented.

The Mobile archdiocese made national headlines July 28, when the archdiocese reported that Fr. Alex Crow, 31, had “abandoned his assignment in the archdiocese,” adding that his “behavior is totally unbecoming of a priest,” and that “he may no longer exercise ministry as a priest, nor tell people he is a priest, nor dress as a priest.”

It emerged quickly in media reports that Crow and an 18-year-old girl, a recent graduate of…

View Cache

A federal lawsuit accusing the Vatican of covering up clergy sex abuse was dismissed this week in U.S. District Court.

The suit, filed in 2019, was filed on behalf of five men who claim they were victims of sexual abuse by priests within the  Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis and the Archdiocese of Los Angeles between 1979 and 1984.

One of the accusers alleged Thomas Adamson abused him in 1981 while Adamson was a priest in Apple Valley.

In a 2014 deposition for a separate sex abuse lawsuit, Adamson admitted sexually abusing ten boys during his time in the priesthood between the 1960s and 1980s. He worked at churches and Catholic schools across Southeastern Minnesota and the Twin Cities including Rochester, Winona, Harmony, Caledonia, and Albert Lea.

It was cases against Adamson that exposed a sex abuse scandal involving dozens of priests in Minnesota and a historic $210 million…

View Cache

A sheriff said Tuesday that authorities have subpoenaed phone records of an Alabama priest and an 18-year-old woman — who fled to Europe together — to see if there is evidence of an illegal relationship when she was a student.

Alex Crow, a Catholic priest in south Alabama, left the country in late July with an 18-year-old woman who is a recent graduate of McGill-Toolen High School, authorities in south Alabama said. Crow did not teach at the school but visited theology classes and heard confession there, news outlets reported.

“We want to get the truth. If there has been a crime, we want to pursue it,” Mobile County Sheriff Paul Burch told The Associated Press. The sheriff said they are seeking text messages and other information contained in the phones.

Alabama law prohibits sexual contact between a school employee and a student 19 or younger. “As…

View Cache

The Catholic Archdiocese of San Francisco has filed for bankruptcy protection, joining two other dioceses in the state. The moves come after legislators opened a special window for sex abuse claims.

Transcript:

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

This week the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of San Francisco filed for bankruptcy protection. Here in California, it joins the Diocese of Oakland and the Diocese of Santa Rosa, which also filed for Chapter 11 protection earlier this year. And the Diocese of San Diego says it plans to file later this year. The church says these moves are because of an overwhelming number of claims of clergy sex abuse. Joining me now is NPR religion correspondent Jason DeRose. Hi, Jason.

JASON DEROSE, BYLINE: Hello.

CHANG: OK, so three bankruptcy filings here in California alone within just a few months, another one likely on the way. What is going on here?

DEROSE: Well, the short answer…

View Cache

Hearing dates:14-16 August 2023Date of orders:23 August 2023Decision date:23 August 2023Jurisdiction:Common LawBefore:Cavanagh JDecision:

The proceedings be permanently stayed pursuant to s 67 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW).Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE — Stay of proceedings – historical child sexual abuse – claims of negligence and vicarious liability on two different bases – delay – absence of critical witnesses and documents – whether the defendant’s own conduct caused prejudice – whether the defendant can have a fair trialLegislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 67

Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 63

Limitation Amendment (Child Abuse) Act 2016 (NSW), ss 6A(1), 6A(6)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 13.4(1)(c), 14.28Cases Cited:

Abdulla v Birmingham City Council [2012] UKSC 47; [2013] 1 All ER 649

Connellan v Murphy [2017] VSCA 116

Council of Trinity Grammar School v Anderson (2019) 101 NSWLR 762; [2019] NSWCA 292

DP (a pseudonym) v Bird [2021] VSC 850

…

View Cache

I knew telling my story would be costly. I didn’t know that it would be this costly.

I published my story in Anabaptist World because I saw institutions related to the Mennonite Church USA ignore and minimize abusive behavior again and again. I wanted to share my first-hand experience with one of those institutions–Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary (AMBS)–and acknowledge the ways that AMBS employees both helped me and pushed me toward danger. Through the process of my separation and divorce, I received many gestures of care from the AMBS community, along with harmful admonitions about forgiveness and reconciliation. Both happened. I thought, and still think, that I wrote a piece that exposed the damaging patterns at AMBS while also expressing gratitude for tremendous support and generosity.

A few weeks after the publication of my Anabaptist World piece, I had a…

View Cache

The Magdalene Laundries were back in the spotlight recently following the death of Irish singer Sinead O’Connor, who spent time in one of the former asylums as a teenager. A new BBC drama examines the impact of the abuse which took place at some of these notorious institutions.

Many of the obituaries published following O’Connor’s death last month noted the time she spent as a young woman in Dublin’s An Grianan Training Centre, a Catholic-run institution which used to be the High Park Magdalene Laundry, where children and teenagers were routinely treated badly.

The laundries had been theoretically set up to house “fallen women” – a blanket term which included unmarried mothers, women deemed to have been badly behaved, promiscuous or sexually abused, or who were considered uncooperative or burdens on their families.

Shoplifting and truancy led to O’Connor being placed in the institution for 18 months in her teens.  View Cache

Police in California are calling on victims to come forward to assist a child pornography investigation into a San Jose Christian school system facility worker arrested for allegedly giving students money to send him explicit images and videos.   

Todd Baldwin, a 43-year-old employee at the Valley Christian Schools, was arrested last week and charged with felony possession and distribution of child sexual material.

On Aug. 16, the Silicon Valley Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force’s Child Exploit Detail was notified that a member of the facilities department at Valley Christian Schools was “in possession of explicit digital media of juveniles,” according to a public notice from the San Jose Police Department. 

Investigators identified Baldwin as the staff member who “allegedly paid students for providing the explicit images and video.” The task force arrested Baldwin the next day and served a search warrant for his campus office and San…

View Cache

Timothy Crowley, a former priest at St. Thomas Rectory in Ann Arbor, has pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct. Crowley was arrested in 2019 in Tempe, Arizona, and his case was dismissed after a preliminary examination. However, the Attorney General’s office prevailed in an appeal to the Court of Appeals, and criminal charges were reinstated in 2022.

Crowley pleaded guilty in Washtenaw County Circuit Court to four felony counts of first-degree Criminal Sexual Conduct and four felony counts of second-degree Criminal Sexual Conduct related to his abuse three decades ago of a minor. This marks the ninth conviction secured by Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel and her team of investigators since the inquiries began in 2018. It is important to note that criminal charges have been levied in 11 cases, and two defendants remain in India awaiting extradition.

We are glad that Crowley is facing consequences…

View Cache

A Native-led coalition plans to digitize and share thousands of archival pages about schools that forcibly enrolled Native children and erased their culture.

It’s no secret that the church played a major role in imposing colonial rule in North America. But if you grew up under the American education system like me, you might’ve never learned about the Christian-run boarding schools that forcibly enrolled Native American children and then attempted to wipe out their culture. In the past few years, thankfully, the ugly truth about these schools has been coming to light — mostly in Canada, but now in the U.S., too.

Recently, the National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition, or NABS, said it will digitize 20,000 archival pages related to Quaker-run boarding schools, according to The Associated Press. Much like Canada’s now-infamous residential schools, the Quakers — or members of the Religious Society of Friends — separated Native American children from their families to…

View Cache

Joseph Hart’s accusers grieve lack of accountability despite church officials substantiating their allegations.

For the past 22 years, Ed Gavagan has been in what he calls a race against time. 

Seeking justice for the sexual abuse he suffered as a teenager and later disclosed as an adult, Gavagan watched the man he accused — a Catholic priest — grow old while evading repeated efforts to hold him accountable. He even wrote to Pope Francis asking for his help. 

When he heard Joseph Hart, the former bishop for Wyoming, died Wednesday, Gavagan was left feeling like he should have done more to pursue justice, he said. At 60 years old, with decades between him and the abuse, he had to remind himself that what happened was not his fault. 

When justice feels unattainable, “it’s just awful,” Gavagan said. “It’s layers of misery on top of injury on top of distrust.”  

Hart, who…

View Cache

The Rev. Stanley Begnaud’s more than two-decade career as an ordained priest in the Diocese of Lafayette is proving problematic for those he left behind.

Begnaud, born in Lafayette in 1921, ordained in 1958, retired in 1982 and deceased three years later, is a key though largely missing figure in a continuing lawsuit against the Diocese of Lafayette filed by a plaintiff, known in court only as “Sam Doe,” who says the priest sexually abused him more than 60 years ago. The plaintiff would be in his late 70s now.

Sam Doe charges that he was a parishioner at St. Stephen Catholic Church in Berwick, near Morgan City, in the early 1960s when Begnaud, then a parish priest who was giving the 16-year-old a ride home from a social event, attempted to molest him — first in the moving vehicle and then by the side of the road. St. Stephen’s was…

View Cache

When a city judge called for “more transparency, not less,” it was in reference to his decision to reveal 43 blacked-out names in a Maryland attorney general’s report on the history of child sexual abuse in the Catholic Archdiocese of Baltimore.

But it also applies to the inclusion in his opinion of some of the arguments those individuals made against being named publicly. Their contentions provide for the first time, in some cases, their comments on the allegations made against them.

The nearly four dozen names still concealed in the public version of the report include those of five high-ranking clerics who had a central role in handling abuse allegations over nearly half a century, as well as 10 of the people accused of abusing children.

While their names were redacted in the report released in April, The…

View Cache

[See also the report.]

Former pupils at three Jesuit schools in Ireland who were abused by the late Fr Joseph Marmion have described the devastating impact on them and their families of “the extreme physical punishment, sexual grooming, wrongful accusation, and expulsion or threat of expulsion” they suffered at his hands.

In testimony to a restorative justice process, the men spoke of ongoing “feelings of panic, disgust, anger and upset” as well as “self criticism and self-loathing that they didn’t challenge him at the time”.

They recalled being “shocked and traumatised on witnessing the violence, and emotional and psychological abuse being inflicted on others in their class and in their presence” by the priest, while several men recalled “incidents of severe violence being inflicted on certain students that impacts them to this day”.

These were among recollections of 62 Jesuit past pupils alleging abuse by Fr…

View Cache

Joseph Hart, a former Kansas City priest and retired Wyoming bishop whose tenure was clouded by a string of sexual abuse allegations deemed credible by two U.S. bishops but dismissed by the Vatican, died Wednesday. He was 91.

His death was confirmed late Wednesday afternoon by the Diocese of Cheyenne. Hart had been dealing with health issues for years and had recently entered hospice care.

Hart had been the subject of abuse allegations spanning more than three decades and was the target of two criminal investigations in Wyoming that both ended without charges being filed. He also was one of several priests featured in “Procession,” a highly acclaimed 2021 Netflix documentary about clergy sexual abuse.

News of Hart’s death evoked a strong reaction from sexual abuse survivors and their families.

“May his victims know that they are believed,” said Ed Gavagan, of New York City, who grew up in Cheyenne…

View Cache

Key points:

• A Supreme Court decision has left Christopher Moran without any legal avenue to seek compensation for abuse he allegedly suffered as a child
• The court ruled that the church would be subject to an unfair trial because the alleged perpetrator – a paedophile priest – is dead, as are others linked to the diocese
• Lawyers say the legal tactic used in Mr Moran’s case is increasingly common and “devastating” for victims

Christopher Moran has been waiting a lifetime to have his day in court.

When he was nine his father suddenly died and he went to stay on an Aboriginal mission in northern New South Wales.

The Taungurung man alleges it was during this vulnerable time that he was sexually abused by Catholic priest David Perrett while on a camping trip to Georges Creek in 1976.

The convicted paedophile died in 2020, but Mr Moran’s trauma lives on.

“I carried this,…

View Cache