When accused Bishop Howard Hubbard requested the Vatican remove his status as a priest, among those caught by surprise were his alleged abuse victims and their civil attorneys, along with canon lawyers. Read letters to the editor from NCR readers responding to our reporting below. The letters have been edited for length and clarity.
The title of this article is false. This article isn’t about “victim’s lawyers” but about the lawyers of alleged victims. Both the repeated use of “alleged” and references to “allegations” in the body of the article are implicitly, and I’d imagine purposely, undermined by the inaccurate title.
Ultimately, the blurring of the distinction between alleged and proven victims is a reminder that irrationalism is not only rising on the right, but is sharply increasing in the Anglosphere more generally.
The issue here is epistemology. How do we evaluate truth claims? One side suggests that we…
View Cache