In 2002, the U.S. Catholic Church promised it would protect victims of clergy sex abuse. Part of the protection included a ban on settlement agreements that prevent victims from sharing their experiences.
Not only has the Diocese of Knoxville since used those types of agreements at least twice, Knox News has learned, but in one case the late Bishop Richard Stika covered it up.
The diocese settled a very public lawsuit by former altar boy Michael Boyd out of court in 2019. What was hidden from the public, however, was the diocese’s requirement that Boyd, 44, sign a nondisparagement clause, effectively silencing him. A nondisparagement agreement is less restrictive than a nondisclosure agreement, under which nothing can ever be said about a case, but it prohibits “disparaging remarks” without defining what would or would not be disparaging.
Stika signed off on the agreement and a diocesan attorney argued…
View Cache
Vargas’ Cases (Alachua County Court Records)