46 years after a nun was killed inside Mercy Hospital’s chapel, the case still shapes Toledo’s reckoning with its past.
On a cool, sunny February morning, Claudia Vercellotti and Lee Pahl walk side by side down North St. Clair Street, past the brick walls of Fifth Third Field, home of the Toledo Mud Hens. They stop at a street sign.
It reads: Msgr Jerome Schmit Way.
For Vercellotti, the founder of Ohio’s Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, the sign is a provocation. For Lee Pahl, whose aunt was murdered more than four decades ago, it is something closer to a wound that never closes. Monsignor Jerome Schmit, revered by many for his decades of service to the Toledo Diocese and his prominent role with the Catholic Youth Organization, is remembered very differently by those who know what happened in a hospital sacristy in 1980.
“Toledo has…
View Cache