Some 660 alleged survivors have claims against the New Orleans Archdiocese in its long bankruptcy. Attorneys Frank Lamothe III and Kristi Schubert have 75 clients. Twenty-three of them are prisoners; most allege abuse at two long-shuttered orphanages, Hope Haven and Madonna Manor.
Two of these men had a different path to prison.
Bernard Joseph, 57, and Marcus Hamilton, 65, half-brothers, are serving life terms in Angola, the Louisiana State Penitentiary, for murdering a priest.
Their stories, revealed here in full for the first time, cite their lawsuits against the New Orleans Archdiocese, voluminous documents in a death penalty appeal, and NCR’s Zoom interviews with each man at an office with attorney Schubert present. Prison officials refused permission for in-person interviews.
This story also involves two Josephite priests. One was murdered. The other has testified that he was trying to help the brothers, who say both religious men abused…
View Cache