ABUSE TRACKER

Archbishop Peter Hundt breaks deadlock by selecting St. Peter’s as church of the future in Mount Pearl

Catholics in Mount Pearl are being asked to unite and show compassion for those losing their church after a decision has been made to abandon Mary Queen of the World on Topsail Road, and make a second attempt to purchase St. Peter’s on Ashford Drive.

“This is not a happy day for anyone,” Father Wayne Dohey told parishioners at St. Peter’s during mass on Saturday, which was streamed on YouTube.

“When you close a church there’s a lot of our friends that are hurting; there’s a lot of sadness,” he added.

Dohey is the parish priest for both churches, and revealed the decision by Peter Hundt, archbishop for the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of St. John’s, during services at both parishes over the weekend.

Hundt was asked to get involved after a steering committee with equal…

View Cache

[Via Crux]

Catholic journalists face a twofold lack of trust as reporters who cover the church, a Catholic theologian reminded them July 6 at the annual Catholic Media Conference in Portland.

He urged them to find a way forward that brings Catholics together and also reaches out to the public at large with nuanced, not simply reactive, reporting and by providing necessary context, or the bigger picture, to their readers and viewers.

Put another way: “Journalists and communicators have a role to play here, to let the eucharistic mystery of the church manifest itself for the life of the world,” said Timothy O’Malley, director of education at the McGrath Institute for Church Life at the University of Notre Dame.

“The church is experiencing a crisis related to communications,” he said during his keynote address, adding that it can’t be solved by a new technique such as a better way to…

View Cache

Glenys Yarran says she was 12 years old when she was taught how to clean maggots from a sheep’s head so it could be placed in a big black pot and made into soup for lunch.

Key points:

• Ballardong woman Glenys Yarran gave evidence in New Norcia as part of a stolen wages class action against the state government
• Ms Yarran described working 50-hour weeks as a teenager at the mission for no pay
• Her sister, Gloria Bennell, said she used to steal apples from the chickens for additional nourishment

The Whadjuk Ballardong elder is now a great-grandmother of six, but this week she cast her mind back to when she spent five years living under the supervision of nuns at a Catholic Mission in the West Australian town of New Norcia.

Ms Yarran gave evidence on Friday as part of a class action against the state government over an old policy…

View Cache

A former Northwoods priest convicted of sexually assaulting boys could be released on parole this summer, after serving about 4 years of a 30-year sentence. 

Thomas Ericksen will go before the Wisconsin Parole Commission in August, according to Department of Corrections, but a date has not yet been set. 

Ericksen, 75, was sentenced to 30 years in prison in 2019 on two charges of sexually assaulting boys while stationed at St. Peter’s Catholic Church in Winter in the 1980s. He is also registered as a sex offender for life.

He was given 20 years on one charge and 10 years on the other. He was credited with 314 days of time served in jail since his arrest, both in Minnesota before he was extradited and in Wisconsin. He is currently being held in the Jackson Correctional Institution in Black River Falls. 

The sentence was…

View Cache

Formal charges against a Warren County School District teacher alleged to have had inappropriate sexual contact with a student are shocking.

There have been occasional instances of similar issues over the past several years. Those instances don’t appear to be widespread, and we hope district administrators continue dealing with any other suspected issues of sexual abuse by school staff swiftly and firmly.

But in the wake of sex abuse scandals involving the Catholic Church and the Boy Scouts of America, one has to wonder just how widespread sex abuse in America’s schools really is. In 2018, roughly one in three educational administrators said that an employee had reported a case of sexual assault or harassment to them, according to an EdWeek Research Center survey. And, a 2020 data release of the last federal Civil Rights Data Collection showed a 55% increase in total incidents of sexual violence from 2015-16 to…

View Cache

The school’s decision follows the filing of a lawsuit that claimed Father Kevin Fitzpatrick molested and sexually abused a student in the 1970s

Servite High School is removing the name of Father Kevin Fitzpatrick from the school’s aquatic center after allegations were made that Fitzpatrick molested a Servite student in the 1970s, according to a letter obtained by the Orange County Register.

The decision follows the recent filing of a lawsuit in Orange County Superior Court against Servite, the Diocese of Orange, the Archdiocese of Los Angeles and the Order of Servants of Mary by the survivor that alleges Fitzpatrick molested and sexually assaulted him more than a dozen times a year.

The man decided to file suit after coming upon the Father Kevin Fitzpatrick Aquatic Center, a $5.7 million state of the art facility completed in 2017, during a visit to the Servite campus in the summer of 2021.

The…

View Cache

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany quietly reached a $750,000 settlement agreement last month with a 47-year-old upstate man who accused a former priest of sexually abusing him as a child.

Stephen Mittler’s case – involving allegations that serial sex abuser and former Albany priest Mark Haight, 73, abused him for over a decade – had been the first Child Victims’ Act lawsuit against the Albany Diocese scheduled for trial later this month, the Albany Times Union reported.

But the Saratoga man cut his losses and settled ahead of trial after Diocese lawyer Michael Costello told Mittler the church would likely be filing for bankruptcy, the outlet reported, citing Mittler’s lawyer Matthew Kelly.

“Whether that was hyperbole or truth, my client opted to settle to avoid waiting for the bankruptcy to resolve itself, which could take years,” Kelly told the outlet.

Haight, who was ordained in 1976, was…

View Cache

“It hit me harder than I’d expected”

Tim Stier figured it was only a matter of time. Since 2005 he’s refused parish assignments as an Oakland Diocese priest over its handling of clerical sex abuse claims and spent more than a decade outside its cathedral on Sundays calling for church accountability and justice for the victims.

He had no plans to end his self-imposed exile and resume work as a parish priest. But when the Vatican finally came for his collar a few months ago, removing him from the Roman Catholic priesthood, Stier said it still felt like a blow.

“It hit me harder than I’d expected,” said Stier, 73, whose removal was disclosed this week. “I felt sad and angry. If I’d been raping kids, I wouldn’t be thrown out of the club.”

The Diocese of Oakland said in a statement Friday only that “we wish Mr. Stier all…

View Cache

Catholic Charities Fort Worth in Texas said its women’s summit would have aimed to “uplift and amplify the voices and power of women.” Sheryl Adkins-Green, the chief marketing officer of Mary Kay, was slated to be the keynote speaker.

But a clash with the local Catholic bishop, who raised questions about the event’s compatibility with Catholic social teaching, doomed the Women’s Empow[her]ment Summit, which Catholic Charities Fort Worth had scheduled for April 28 in Hurst, Texas.

The agency ended up canceling the event. Beyond that, Fort Worth Bishop Michael Olson demanded that the chief executive officer of Catholic Charities Fort Worth, Christopher Plumlee, resign. After resisting the bishop’s demand for weeks, Plumlee stepped down in late May.

“I think we were doing some incredible things,” said Plumlee, who told NCR that he still believes his former employer is “an incredible agency with incredible people…

View Cache

Saint Josemaria Escriva, founder of the Catholic organization Opus Dei, which emphasizes the dignity of everyday work, once famously told the employees of a Spanish university he founded that the dean was no more important than the people who cleaned the classrooms.

However noble-sounding that rhetoric may be, according to 43 women in Argentina, when it came to them, it didn’t ring true.

In a complaint to the Vatican, the women, who say they were recruited into Opus Dei under false promises of higher education, now claim they were instead forced to labor under “manifestly illegal conditions” including working without pay for more than 12 hours a day, without breaks except for food or prayer, without registration in the national pension system, and other violations of basic workers’ rights.

In an attempt to know what happened, and following a series of allegations in the media of labor exploitation by some…

View Cache

A former pastor from Georgia who was conducting missionary work in Uganda when he sexually assaulted a girl under his care was sentenced by a federal judge to serve above the guideline sentencing range for his crime.

Eric Tuininga, 45, of Milledgeville, was sentenced to serve 120 months in prison to be followed by a lifetime of supervised release and $20,000 in restitution to the victim by Chief U.S. District Judge Marc T. Treadwell after he previously pleaded guilty to one count of engaging in illicit sexual conduct in foreign places. In addition, Tuininga will have to register as a sex offender for life upon his release from federal prison. There is no parole in the federal system.

“I want to recognize the true bravery displayed by the Ugandan girl for speaking out when she was assaulted by a trusted person of power from another country, courageously seeking justice across…

View Cache

A jury on Thursday convicted youth pastor Colton Albury of sexually assaulting a girl whose parents welcomed him into their family at age 16.

Albury, a well-regarded pastor, bowed his head after the jury’s forewoman delivered the guilty verdicts.

His wife, Mariah, the mother of their two children, who sat through the entire trial, shook her head as he was led away in handcuffs.

Senior Justice Bernard Turner remanded the 33-year-old into custody until August 17 for the penalty phase of his trial.

Albury’s lawyer, Miranda Adderley, requested a probation report to assist the court with determining the appropriate sentence.

The majority of the jury accepted that Albury betrayed the family’s trust when he became an adult by indecently assaulting and sexually assaulting a girl, who was just a toddler when he moved into their home.

He was convicted of two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse by a count of…

View Cache

B.C. Supreme dismisses application based on jurisdiction, diplomatic immunity

The Pope’s ambassador in Canada will not be forced to hand over any records of alleged sexual abuse at the seminary school in Mission.

Instead, he will be asked to hand over records.

An application to B.C. Supreme Court was filed in March, for the Apostolic Nuncio to produce various classes of documents related to sexual abuse at the Seminary of Christ the King.

It was dismissed by Court Master John Bilawich on jurisdiction grounds.

The plaintiff seeking the documents, Mark O’Neill, alleges he was abused as a teenager in the 1970s by three priests.

Westminster Abbey and the attached seminary in Mission, B.C. and the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Vancouver are named as institutional defendants, liable for “systematic negligence” for failing to protect students.

O’Neill’s application sought all written correspondence between the institutional defendants and the nuncio regarding allegations…

View Cache

A former Union County priest who admitted to NJ Advance Media that he sexually assaulted a 15-year-old boy died by suicide in his native Ecuador after he allegedly shot three people there, killing one, according to local media reports.

Manuel Gallo Espinoza, 59, shot and killed Byron Carreño, his partner in an English language school in Loja, Ecuador, on July 2, the reports said, citing “investigators.” He also shot two other partners and his pet before turning the gun on himself after a dispute about the management of the school, the reports said.

Efforts to reach prosecutors in Ecuador were unsuccessful, and the Union County Prosecutor’s Office was not immediately able to confirm the reports of Gallo Espinoza’s death. However, several people who know Gallo Espinoza verified his identity by widely-circulated photographs.

Gallo Espinoza was indicted by a Union County grand jury in 2016 for the alleged sexual…

View Cache

Summary

• Abuse crisis exploded in Boston in 2002
• Pope introduced major legislation against abuse in 2019
• Outside abuse expert says Church cannot police itself
• Critic says real ‘zero tolerance’ does not exist
• Pope gave more clout to commission for protection of minors

Pope Francis has acknowledged that there is resistance by some national Catholic Churches on implementing measures to protect children from sexual abuse by clergy but said that there is no turning back on an “irreversible” path.

Sexual abuse in the Church and measures to combat it were among one of the many Church and international topics the 85-year-old pontiff discussed in an exclusive interview with Reuters in his Vatican residence on July 2. 

In 2019 Francis issued a papal directive ordering “public, stable and easily accessible systems for submission” of reports of sexual abuse in dioceses around the world. 

Some countries, such as the United States, established procedures, sometimes known as…

View Cache

A group of former members of Dwell Community Church (formerly known as Xenos Christian Fellowship), a megachurch located in Columbus, Ohio, has purchased ad space on a billboard hoping to warn current attendees regarding abuse happening within the church.

The billboard is located along High Street in Clintonville, less than three miles from the church, and displays large bold neon green and white lettering that reads, “Stuck in Dwell Community Church? There is hope.” The message is followed by the website address leavingwell.com and a QR code, which directs to a page titled, “There Is Life After Dwell Community Church.”

“We who have left Dwell Community Church have shared similar fears,” the site reads. “We have feared that to leave Dwell would put us outside the will of God, that we would lose community and friends, that we would lose a life of meaning and purpose….

View Cache

A recently-enacted California state law that requires additional levels of abuse prevention training and implementation complements Southern Baptists’ resolve to care for children, one state convention leader said. And, it provides a window into the future for other states.

Assembly Bill 506, passed last fall and now part of the California Business & Professions Code, mandates additional levels of training, background checks and policies from churches. The California Southern Baptist Convention (CSBC) is hosting a webinar to discuss the changes July 7 at 10:30 a.m. PDT. Registration can be accessed here.

Due to the bill, churches are for the first time included in the category “Youth Services Organizations” that appears under the Business & Professions Code.

“New California laws relating to protecting youth have made your job challenging as you work to comply with the new requirements of AB 506,” wrote CSBC Executive Director Pete Ramirez in an announcement…

View Cache

Esther Matsubuchi is 85 years old. She and her brothers grew up in Marpole, not far from the small bungalow that has become a retreat for writers.

“It is also the former home of (Kogawa’s) father, a priest pedophile who molested hundreds of children,” said Matsubuchi.

Matsubuchi is not the type to speak out about private matters, but said, “This struck a nerve.”

Four of her brothers were abused by Kogawa’s father, Gordon Goichi Nakayama.

Now she wonders why her family, and other survivors of Nakayama’s abuse, were not consulted about the heritage application, which goes before city council on July 12.

Peter Wallace, a representative for the Japanese Canadian Working Group, an organization that supports healing for survivors of Nakayama’s sexual abuse, said, “A lot of members of the community see the house as a reminder of that abuse.”

The report to council mentions the house’s…

View Cache

Analysis

Pope Francis has promised to appoint two women to the Dicastery for Bishops, the Vatican department responsible for episcopal appointments. While media attention has focused on an expanded role for women in the selection of new bishops, the most significant aspect of the  reform might be something else entirely.

In comments published Wednesday, the pope told Reuters that “two women will be appointed for the first time” to the bishop-making congregation dicastery. 

Most members of Vatican dicasteries are cardinals or bishops serving as diocesan bishops around the world. While those members tend to travel to the Vatican regularly to attend the dicastery’s meetings, they are not usually present for weekly working sessions attended by members living in Rome.

Depending on who Francis decides to name  — and where they live — it will become clearer whether the pope intends to appoint them as part of the broad consulting membership, or in…

View Cache

Churches often blame adult abuse survivors for leading a ‘holy man’ astray.

At their annual meeting last month in Anaheim, California, Southern Baptists passed a series of reforms to address sexual abuse in the nation’s largest Protestant denomination.

Local church delegates, known as messengers, also passed a resolution, calling on states to make pastoral sexual misconduct a crime. Such misconduct is “a clear abuse of authority and trust,” the resolution states, similar to the trust placed in doctors, teachers, therapists and other helping professionals.

Since many states prohibit sexual relationships between those helping professionals and their patients or clients — they should also treat sexual relationships between pastors and members of their flocks as crimes, not simply a moral failing, according to the resolution.

Many still have a hard time seeing sexual misconduct by pastors as abusive. Particularly when the one abused is an adult, Baptists and other faith groups…

View Cache

The Diocese of Trier released a summary of a report detailing allegations of abuse made in the United States against the founder of the Schonstatt movement, Father Joseph Kentenich.

According to the summary of the report, which was released by the diocese July 7, the victim, known by the alias, “John Doe,” accused Kentenich of repeatedly sexually abusing him between 1958 to 1962.

The summary stated that “circumstantial evidence reviewed as part of the report both supports and contradicts certain aspects of the allegations” and that “because of the passage of time and deaths of key witnesses, ‘conclusiveness’ could not be ascertained.”

According to the German Catholic news agency KNA, the Diocese of Trier chose to not publish the 47-page report “for data protection and privacy reasons.”

The report also looked into the Archdiocese of Milwaukee’s investigation from 1994 to 1995 into Doe’s accusations. The archdiocese concluded that the allegations made…

View Cache

The Archdiocese of Vancouver’s latest update on sexual abuse by priests says priests will start undergoing performance reviews this year. 

Priests in the Archdiocese of Vancouver will undergo regular performance reviews starting this year, the archdiocese announced in its latest update on sexual abuse by priests.

The archdiocese released its latest report on sexual abuse June 30. It’s the latest in a series of updates since 2019 when it first released a 12-page report that contained 31 recommendations. An Implementation Working Group has been working to develop solutions for the recommendations.

Recommendation 15 in the 2019 report said “all clerics – whether incardinated in the Archdiocese or in ministry in the Archdiocese – should undergo an annual, formal performance review process, similar to the process that permanent deacons currently undertake.” The review should be done “by a group of people, including lay men and women.”

Archbishop J. Michael Miller had committed…

View Cache

• Current committee to help pope select bishops is all-male
• New rules allow even lay Catholics to head most Vatican offices
• Pope has already appointed some women to high-level positions

Pope Francis said he wants to give women more top-level positions in the Holy See and disclosed that for the first time he would name women to a previously all-male Vatican committee that helps him select the world’s bishops.

The role of women in the Vatican hierarchy was one of the many Church and international topics the 85-year-old pontiff discussed in an exclusive interview with Reuters in his Vatican residence on July 2. 

A new constitution for the Holy See’s central administration that came into effect last month allows any baptised Catholic, including lay men and women, to head most Vatican departments. read more

“I am open to giving (women) an opportunity,” he said in the part of the 90-minute interview that…

View Cache

The Catholic Church in Venezuela has reopened its investigation into a priest who was convicted of sexually abusing a child but was later returned to the ministry, officials said Wednesday.

The announcement came just over two weeks after The Washington Post reported on the case of the Rev. Luis Alberto Mosquera, the priest in Venezuela’s Lara state. Mosquera, 63, was convicted in 2006 of abusing a 6-year-old boy and sentenced to more than seven years in prison, but in 2008, he was released and allowed by the church to resume his work as a priest. A photo posted on his Facebook page in 2016 and reposted in 2017 showed him surrounded by children.

Mosquera’s case was one of 10 involving allegations of child sexual abuse scrutinized by The Post for the report published in June. In half of the cases, dating from 2001 to 2022, The Post found…

View Cache

A lawsuit against the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal alleges that a woman was serially sexually assaulted by a priest of the order.

While the priest – Fr. Louis Leonelli – says he had a consenting relationship with the woman, her attorney insists that no sexual relationship between a spiritual director and his directee can be consensual, and alleges that Leonelli committed several “violent sexual assaults.”

For his part, the order’s superior general has apologized, after the order told The Pillar last year that accusations against Leonelli pertained to consensual sexual activity.

The case is the latest in recent months to raise questions about the Church’s handling of assault allegations in the context of relationships between priests and adults under their pastoral care — an issue which some experts say has not been sufficiently addressed by canon law and Vatican policies.

“These are violent sexual assaults, and if they had been reported…

View Cache

Further to my recent article about how the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Court Bill will expand the law which makes it illegal for those in a position of trust to engage in sexual activity to now also include sport coaches, it is important to note that the new law will also cover religious leaders.

Abuse happens in every area of society and can take many forms to include sexual, physical, emotional and also spiritual.

There are numerous reasons why victims and survivors of child abuse are unable to disclose their abuse for decades, if at all.

One of the most common barriers is the fear of being believed and this is worsened when the abuser has a position of trust in a religious setting.

There has been and continues to be coverage in the media of sexual abuse by priests within the Roman Catholic Church and the Church…

View Cache

Taking steps to address racism and abuse, the Catholic Church in Australia has officially endorsed the Uluru Statement from the Heart, which calls for a First Nations voice to Parliament to be enshrined in the nation’s constitution.

In a separate action, the Plenary Council apologized formally to victims, survivors and families of child abuse and committed to a further investigation into the systemic factors that facilitated it within the church.

Members of the Plenary Council’s Second Assembly, which endorsed the Uluru Statement, also committed to acknowledging “in a prominent and appropriate manner the traditional custodians of the land” in each diocese and eparchy.

The bishops’ Commission for Liturgy and the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Catholic Council will consider Indigenous “symbols and rituals” for Catholic liturgies.

The assembly also apologized to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples for “the part played by the church in the harms they have…

View Cache

[The Secret History: Uncovering Marist sex abuse

The Marist Brothers and Fathers have educated prime ministers, judges, cardinals and All Blacks at their Catholic high schools. But their record of sexual abuse is horrific.

The Marist Brothers and Fathers have educated prime ministers, judges, cardinals and All Blacks at their prestigious Catholic high schools. But their record of sexual abuse is horrific. Worse still was their handling of the abuse when it was exposed. In this series, The Secret History, Steve Kilgallon investigates the power, abuse and cover-ups at the heart of two highly-influential and wealthy religious groups.

This is Part 3. The remaining chapters will be published in the coming weeks.]

Warning: This story may be upsetting to some.

When Rupene Amato sat with his schoolfriends at lunchtime one day in the early 1980s, they began discussing what happened when they were called for individual ‘sex education’ lessons with…

View Cache

Officials insist the association was shut down due to dysfunction, not abuse.

Mission Thérésienne, a French canonical association of the faithful active in about 20 countries, has been shut down by the bishop of Bayeux-Lisieux for “substantial dysfunctions” in its management.

The association, named after Saint Thérèse of Lisieux, encourages children and their families to pray for vocations and for about 6,500 priests and religious they have adopted. It promptly closed its website and its five magazines for young Catholics, promising to refund the subscriptions.

The shutdown was the latest community closure or diocesan inspection in France, where Church management has come under increasing scrutiny after the country’s two top archbishops, in Paris and Lyon, quit over the past two years. 

New communities in France, often charismatic or traditional groups that have grown in recent decades as vocations to the diocesan clergy fall, have received special attention. Pope Francis announced in…

View Cache

The Catholic Church presence in St. John’s, Nfld., is set to shrink significantly come autumn after at least four parish communities had their churches sold from underneath them to compensate Mount Cashel abuse victims, with possibly more to close.

The congregations of St. Patrick’s, St. Francis of Assisi, St. Pius X and Mary, Queen of Peace were informed recently that their churches have been sold at auction to help the Archdiocese of St. John’s compensate the victims of abuse at the Mount Cashel Orphanage in the 1940s, ’50s and ’60s.

Eighteen of 34 St. John’s parishes were put on the auction block June 2 as the archdiocese was forced into bankruptcy by a Supreme Court ruling that held the archdiocese “vicariously liable” for claims of abuse at the now-closed Mount Cashel Orphanage, operated by the Christian Brothers of Ireland. The brothers went bankrupt and were unable to compensate the more…

View Cache

La agresión contra las menores fue hace siete años, una en septiembre de 2015, cuando la víctima de 7 años se encontraba sentada en una de las bancas de la iglesia cuando el ahora imputado aprovechó para agredirla sexualmente.

MORELIA, Mich. (apro).- Casi siete años después de los hechos, fue detenido el pastor religioso Faustino “N”, acusado de haber violado a dos niñas, de 7 y 8 años, en el municipio de Paracho, informó la Fiscalía General del Estado (FGE).

De acuerdo con informes que forman parte de la investigación, en septiembre de 2015 la víctima de 7 años se encontraba sentada en una de las bancas de la iglesia cuando el ahora imputado aprovechó para agredirla sexualmente.

Posteriormente, en ese mismo mes y año, Faustino “N” se encontraba en su domicilio cuando vio pasar a la víctima de 8 años de edad, a quien llamó y después la introdujo…

View Cache

The Catholic Church in Venezuela has reopened its investigation into a priest who was convicted of sexually abusing a child but was later returned to the ministry, officials said Wednesday.

The announcement came just over two weeks after The Washington Post reported on the case of the Rev. Luis Alberto Mosquera, the priest in Venezuela’s Lara state. Mosquera, 63, was convicted in 2006 of abusing a 6-year-old boy and sentenced to more than seven years in prison, but in 2008, he was released and allowed by the church to resume his work as a priest. A photo posted on his Facebook page in 2016 and reposted in 2017 showed him surrounded by children.

Mosquera’s case was one of 10 involving allegations of child sexual abuse scrutinized by The Post for the report published in June. In half of the cases, dating from 2001 to 2022, The Post found…

View Cache

Settlement, involving former priest who was an alleged serial child sex abuser, was reached as diocese warned victim it would file for bankruptcy

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany recently paid $750,000 to a 47-year-old Saratoga County man who was allegedly sexually abused as a child by a former priest, marking the organization’s first settlement in the hundreds of pending lawsuits that were filed under New York’s Child Victims Act.

The unannounced settlement was reached in early June during negotiations in which the diocese’s attorney, Michael L. Costello, had warned the alleged victim, Stephen J. Mittler, that if his case remained on track for its July 25 trial date the diocese would file for bankruptcy before a jury was picked, according to Matthew J. Kelly, Mittler’s attorney.

“Whether that was hyperbole or truth, my client opted to settle to avoid waiting for the bankruptcy to resolve itself, which could take…

View Cache

An independent commission that is to conduct Spain’s first official probe into suspected sexual abuse of minors within the Catholic Church met for the first time Tuesday.

Unlike in many other nations where the government or the Church itself has opened an investigation into such abuses, Spain has only recently made moves to follow suit with lawmakers in March backing the creation of an independent commission.

The independent panel is made up of 20 people, mostly experts, but does not include representatives of the Church.

Spain’s ombudsman, Angel Gabilondo, who is in charge of the probe, on Tuesday “presided over the first constitutive meeting” of the commission, his office said in a statement.

The aim is to “prepare a report on sexual violence within the Catholic Church and the role of the public authorities”, it said, indicating that the panel included 17 experts “with experience in victimology, in the care…

View Cache

The Vatican said Friday it had finalized the sale of a London property that is the focus of a criminal trial in the Vatican courts, offloading the former Harrods warehouse for 186 million pounds (215 million euros, US$223 million).

The Vatican secretariat of state had poured some 350 million euros into the building and related fees and commissions paid to brokers — losses that are at the heart of the accusations of fraud, embezzlement and extortion against 10 people on trial.

The Vatican said it sold the warehouse on 60 Sloane Ave. in Chelsea to Bain Capital, the Boston-based private investment firm co-founded by Republican U.S. Senator Mitt Romney, after a bidding process that involved 16 preliminary offers and relied on the expertise of property advisers Savills.

The scandal over the London property has convulsed the Vatican for three years and prompted Pope Francis to strip the secretariat of state of…

View Cache

A list released by the Southern Baptist Convention of more than 700 pastors and church personnel who have allegedly abused people includes 12 Ohio pastors and two others with connections to the state.

Here is information about each individual and the allegations involving them, as provided by public records, news reports and the list itself.

‘Scourge of sexual abuse’: Southern Baptists respond to list of accused Ohio pastors

Lonny ‘Joe’ Aleshire Jr. 

Church: Licking Baptist Church in Hebron

Accusation: Sexually assaulting two teenaged girls — sisters — who attended the church where he was an associate pastor.

Outcome: Aleshire pleaded guilty to one count of rape, six counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor and three misdemeanor counts of sexual imposition in 2005. He served nearly seven years in prison and five years of probation.

More: A year after he pleaded guilty, Aleshire took it back, filing a motion to withdraw the plea, blaming his attorney and saying there…

View Cache

[Tim Stier served for decades as a priest in the diocese of Oakland CA. He sent this letter on May 31, 2022.]

Dear No-Longer-Fellow Priests,

This will likely be my farewell letter to most of you, which may be glad tidings to those of you who do not enjoy hearing from me.

Last week, I learned from David Staal, a canon lawyer for the Diocese of Oakland, that the Vatican had officially laicized me as of March 19th.  The grounds for my ouster from the priesthood was my persistent refusal of an assignment in 2005 after I told Allen Vigneron, then Oakland’s bishop, that I could not in good conscience accept another assignment until he was willing to open a public dialog throughout the diocese on three issues roiling the Church:  the sexual abuse of minors by clergy and its cover-up by bishops and their cronies, the refusal of the…

View Cache

Could co-production be the key to tackling clerical abuse?

“The Church as a whole must embark on a world-wide process of truth and reparation [beginning] with the acknowledgement of responsibility.”

This assertion by the Independent Commission on Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church (CIASE) in France is the starting point for this article.

We all want a Church that is safe for everyone: free from physical, spiritual, emotional, institutional and reputational abuse. We want healing in all its complexity for the victims, both the abused and the abusers.

And we want fit-for-purpose procedures to prevent abuse, and to deal with it, whenever and wherever it occurs.

Yet sadly, there seems to be a huge distance between what we say we want and what we are prepared to make happen. And there is genuine disagreement about whether the truth is liberating.

I am one of the small core team of Root…

View Cache

More people have come forward with stories of abuse by a now-deceased Catholic priest.

Stuff previously reported about six complaints of sexual abuse against Father George William Harrison, who coached schoolboy rugby and served in many parishes in Christchurch and on the West Coast from 1935 until he retired in 1981.

Since then several people contacted Stuff with stories of their own, with one describing Harrison as a “mega-abuser”.ADVERTISING

A man who was an altar boy in Christchurch in the early 1950s said he was groped by Harrison, who was known as Doc.

“Doc was a hard case character who liked to get you in a corner and feint boxing. During this ’bout’ it was not uncommon for him to go for your genitals,” he said.

He knew of other altar boys who told him the same thing had happened to them.

Another man now in his 80s, who grew up in Greymouth,…

View Cache

This article was originally published by The Daily Hampshire Gazette.

With the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade, American women and girls have lost their full citizenship rights. Women, transgender men and nonbinary people who can get pregnant no longer have bodily autonomy during pregnancy, or sexual freedom. The government now controls their bodies and behaviors. Politicians can force people to carry pregnancies against their will—a form of involuntary servitude that should be prohibited by the 13th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, but which the current Supreme Court now allows.

The six right-wing Catholics on the Supreme Court reversed long-standing U.S. law as part of a campaign to establish in its place the Catholic belief that abortion at any stage of pregnancy is a sin. The original instigator of the anti-abortion movement was the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, and they remain one of its biggest funders.

Shortly after the…

View Cache

A B.C. court acquitted Fr. Placidus Sander in 1993, but he admitted to a single sexual encounter with “an older seminarian” and to kissing one student twice.

Vancouver’s Roman Catholic Archdiocese has added another name to its reportedly sexually abusive priests list.

On June 30, the diocese released an update on its activities to combat priest sexual abuse in which it released Father Placidus Sander’s name.

Sander, who was born in Oregon in 1927 and ordained in 1952, occupied several positions at Mission’s Christ the King Seminary between 1954 and 1988. He died in 2021.

He was acquitted in a sexual assault case in 1993 but remains the subject of current accusations in civil suits brought against him and others.

The diocese’s abuse report notes that the papal nuncio — or the pope’s ambassador to Canada, received an anonymous letter in May of 1987 signed by “Former Seminarians.” The anonymous note…

View Cache

In appointing him to a parish, Bishop William Callahan of La Crosse, Wisconsin, disclosed little about the priest’s alleged use of the Grindr ‘hook-up’ app, what treatment he might have received or what safeguards have been put into place.

A decision to restore Msgr. Jeffrey Burrill to active ministry in his home diocese in Wisconsin, less than a year after a scandal involving his alleged use of the “hook-up” app Grindr, has raised questions about the prudence of the move and the way in which it was implemented. 

Bishop William Callahan of La Crosse told members of St. Teresa of Kolkata parish June 11-12 that Msgr. Burrill would be their new parochial administrator. He further expressed confidence in his ability to accompany them in their journey toward Christ.

However, although he said in a brief statement published on the parish website that Msgr. Burrill had most recently served the U.S. Conference…

View Cache

Benedict’s exit changed expectations that the papacy would always be a lifetime assignment, fueling speculation the current pope has tried to push away.

Over the last few weeks, close watchers of the Roman Catholic Church have carefully studied shadows on the Vatican walls for proof that Pope Francis is about to retire.

They pointed at an unexpected move to create new cardinals in August as a sign that Francis, 85, was stacking the college that will pick his successor before an early exit. They read deep into his planned visit to an Italian town with a connection to a medieval pope who called it quits. They saw the pope’s use of a wheelchair and his cancellation of a trip to Africa as evidence of his papacy’s premature ending, despite Vatican explanations about a healing right knee.

But in an interview published on Monday, Francis dispelled the rumors, calling the supposed…

View Cache

Polscy biskupi, którzy przed laty tuszowali przypadki pedofilii w Kościele, mogą zostać postawieni przed sądem – orzekł w piątek Sąd Najwyższy. Chodzi o interpretację art. 240 Kodeksu karnego, który od lipca 2017 r. nakazuje wszystkim obywatelom informować śledczych o podobnych przestępstwach. Stanowisko SN jest przełomowe, bo do tej pory prokuratorzy z reguły unikali wszczynania śledztw w stosunku do hierarchów.

• Do polskich prokuratur trafiło już co najmniej kilkadziesiąt zawiadomień dot. możliwego popełnienia przestępstwa przez hierarchów kościelnych. Śledczy do tej pory z reguły odmawiali wszczęcia postępowania
• Niepodejmowanie tych spraw zalecała im Prokuratura Krajowa, uważając, że nie można rozliczać biskupów, którzy wiedzę o pedofilii nabyli przed karnym obowiązkiem denuncjacji, czyli przed 13 lipca 2017 r.
• Wątpliwości w tej sprawie rozwiewa piątkowa uchwała Sądu Najwyższego, której interpretacja idzie wbrew wykładni prokuratury
• Przez lata nasze społeczeństwo żyło w przeświadczeniu, że osoba duchowna nie może podlegać odpowiedzialności karnej. Otóż okazuje się, że może – uważa przewodniczący Komisji ds….

View Cache

Poland’s Supreme Court has ruled that a person can be held criminally liable for failing to report cases of child sexual abuse even if they occurred before July 2017, when a law making it obligatory to inform the authorities of such crimes came into force.

The state commission on sexual crimes against minors has hailed the “landmark ruling” as a boost for victims of abuse seeking justice. One liberal media outlet, meanwhile, describes it as “bad news for bishops”, some of whom have been accused of covering up cases of abuse within Poland’s Catholic church.

On Friday, the Supreme Court issued a response to questions submitted by lower courts in the cities of Kalisz and Wrocław, who asked if people could be held legally responsible for failing to report cases of child sex abuse that took place before the 2017 change in the law, reports the Polish Press Agency (PAP).

The…

View Cache

Analysis

In Liechtenstein, a country smaller than Washington, D.C., the Catholic Church is going through a moment of serious upheaval – with real questions about whether or not its entire structure might be folded back into the Swiss diocese to which it once belonged. 

The local archdiocese has been embroiled in controversy over the global synodal process, Church-state relations, and clerical abuse allegations.

Those topics are relevant to the entire Church — That’s why it’s worth digging into what’s happening in Liechtenstein.

A singular nation

Many people have heard of Liechtenstein, but perhaps only a small percentage could place it on a world map.  The German-speaking country, officially known as the Principality of Liechtenstein and founded in 1719, covers just 62 square miles and has a population of around 38,000 people, 73% of whom are Catholic. 

The wealthy tax haven has the distinction of being “doubly landlocked,” meaning that its neighboring…

View Cache

Solicitors for alleged victims criticise organisation for fighting cases ‘tooth and nail’

Scouting Ireland has been accused of trying to rely on a “legal technicality” to avoid paying compensation to survivors of historical child sexual abuse in its legacy scouting bodies.

Recent legal filings responding to claims taken by alleged victims of child sex abuse argue that the High Court has “no jurisdiction to hear and determine” the cases due to a relatively little know clause in charities law.

A law firm representing nearly 30 alleged victims has criticised the organisation for trying to use a “legal technicality” to avoid its liability to those who were sexually abused by scout leaders in the past.

In recent filings, Sheehan & Co LPP Solicitors, which represents Scouting Ireland, state that under a 1961 law anyone seeking to sue a charity must first notify the Charities Regulator. The filings argue that as…

View Cache

The pope’s ambassador to Canada won’t have to hand over records pertaining to B.C. priest sexual abuse allegations unless he agrees to a request from the defendants in the case, B.C. Supreme Court ruled July 4.

A man who alleges he was sexually abused by Mission Roman Catholic priests and a seminary employee may not get relevant records in possession of the pope’s envoy to Canada — but there’s a chance he could get them from the defendants.

Mark O’Neill is seeking damages for sexual abuse he alleges he suffered as a teen during his time at a Mission Roman Catholic seminary from 1974 to 1978. He was 13- to 17-years-old at the time.

The defendants listed in the suit are the Seminary of Christ the King; Westminster Abbey Ltd.; the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Vancouver, a Corporation Sole; Emerick Lazar; Harold Vincent Sander, a.k.a. Dom Placidus…

View Cache

As a teenager, the victim was subjected to attacks at a Scottish priest college.

Scotland’s Catholic Bishops’ Conference has been ordered to pay more than £450,000 to a former priest who was sexually abused while at a school for boys wanting to enter the clergy.

While a teenager in the 1970s, the ex-priest suffered “vile” child abuse at the hands of the “spiritual director” of a Scottish seminary.

Between the ages of 14 and 16 years old, he was assaulted in his dormitory bed two or three times a month.

At the age of 18, he left the college and attended a seminary in Rome and was later ordained as a Roman Catholic priest in Scotland.

In 1996, his abuser was convicted and sentenced for separate unrelated offences.

For many years, the victim carried out his role as a priest in an “effective and wellrespected” manner.

However, the trauma of…

View Cache

Archbishop John C. Wester is speaking about the decision to mortgage an iconic Santa Fe cathedral to meet a settlement agreement tied to church sex abuse victims.

The action was a last resort because “we pretty much sold everything we can, including my residency,” Wester told the Santa Fe New Mexican on Thursday.

The archbishop sent letters to parishes last month informing them they would collectively need to borrow $12 million to pay for the settlements. That’s when he broke the news about the cathedral. The archdiocese has to remit $65 million by Sept. 30 and a final $10 million by March 31 of next year, Wester wrote.

Still, the decision to use the Cathedral Basilica of St. Francis of Assisi, the heart of the diocese, shocked many New Mexico Catholics. Wester believes the love for the cathedral actually was a factor in the property being accepted…

View Cache

• Summary

• Unsubstantiated rumours fuelled reports of imminent resignation
• Pope laughs off rumours of cancer: “Doctors didn’t tell me”
• Trips to Moscow, Kyiv appear more likely; possibly in September
• On U.S. court decision, pope says abortion is ‘hiring a hit man’

Pope Francis has dismissed reports that he plans to resign in the near future, saying he is on track to visit Canada this month and hopes to be able to go to Moscow and Kyiv as soon as possible after that.

In an exclusive interview in his Vatican residence, Francis also denied rumours that he had cancer, joking that his doctors “didn’t tell me anything about it”, and for the first time gave details of the knee condition that has prevented him carrying out some duties.

In a 90-minute conversation on Saturday afternoon, conducted in Italian, with no aides present, the 85-year-old pontiff also repeated his condemnation of abortion following the…

View Cache

ROME – In 1992, two boys attending minor seminary in Parana, in northeastern Argentina, reported that Father Justo Ilarraz, spiritual director for the seminarians, had sexually abused them.

The then-prefect of the seminary, Juan Alberto Piuggari, today archbishop of Parana, led them to the office of the then-head of the diocese, Archbishop Estanislao Esteban Karlic.

(Karlic, now 96, led the Argentine bishops’ conference between 1996 and 2002, and was created a cardinal in 2007.)

Estimates indicate that between 1984 and 1992, Ilarraz abused at least 50 children. In 1992, he confessed to having “amorous and abusive relationships with minor seminarians.”

To this day, he remains a priest, despite a 25-year prison sentence that came after his case led to the revision of the statutes of limitations for sexual abuse in Argentina.

“No one wanted to walk with us,” said Hernan Rausch, one of Ilaraz’s survivors who spoke out in a…

View Cache

Around this time last year, the Washington Post printed a front-page story detailing allegations of sexual and physical abuse within the South Bend-based People of Praise and its affiliated Trinity Schools. Shortly after this, four of us mentioned in the article wrote a Viewpoint in The Tribune suggesting reforms for the group.

One year later, these reforms have not been met. Most significantly, the People of Praise have not publicly named all who have been credibly accused of abuse or concealing abuse. The public has no information about whether wrongdoers have been removed from the organization.

And earlier this month, another newspaper reported on allegations against People of Praise co-founder Kevin Ranaghan and his wife, Dorothy. The allegations came in the form of sworn affidavits, filed in the 1990s, by three women who had lived within the Ranaghan household. The allegations described what many would consider to be…

View Cache

The North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church has agreed to pay $448,216 to help pay sexual abuse claims against the Boy Scouts of America as part of the scouting organization’s federal Chapter 11 bankruptcy settlement.

The United Methodist Church nationally agreed to pay $30 million over a three-year period as one of the largest church sponsors of Boy Scout troops.

“This is good news that we have reached a settlement,” said Lynn Hare, chancellor for the North Alabama Conference, in a report on June 23 at the conference’s annual meeting.

The North Alabama Conference, which represents 638 congregations and 118,963 church members in North Alabama, was assigned an amount as part of the plan to spread out the payments among all United Methodist conferences.

“The conference has pledged to pay that money within a year,” Hare said.

As part of its bankruptcy…

View Cache

Raimundos Oki calls tests’ on child abuse victims a violation of human rights

Police in Timor-Leste have charged a journalist for allegedly violating judicial secrecy by publishing reports that question the virginity tests of some underage girls, who were sexually abused by a convicted former priest.

The Criminal Investigation Scientific Police launched an investigation against Raimundos Oki, editor-in-chief of news portal Oekusipost.com, on June 30, local media reports say. He was questioned for about an hour.

Oki came under fire for his reports which, among other things, questioned the virginity tests by the public prosecutor on inmates of the Topu Honis Shelter in Kutet, Oecusse.

Richard Daschbach, 84, a US citizen, was jailed for 12 years last December for sexually abusing young orphaned and underprivileged girls in his care at the shelter he founded in 1993.

Oki’s articles argued that the virginity tests were “forced” on…

View Cache

As former pastor Bruxy Cavey appears in an Ontario court, the reckoning continues at The Meeting House.

Reeling from the arrest of their former teaching pastor, Bruxy Cavey, for sexual assault, and a growing number of sexual misconduct allegations against other previous pastors, leaders at The Meeting House are looking for ways to move forward.

“We are deeply sorry for the abuse and harm that has occurred, be it sexual, emotional, or spiritual in our church family,” Jennifer Hryniw, cochair of the board of overseers, recently told the congregation, which operates in 20 locations across Ontario. “We are deeply sorry for how many of these stories have been handled in the past. We continue to be humbled to now be the stewards of these stories.”

The Meeting House was supposed to be a humble kind of church. The Canadian Anabaptist congregation was built around movie theater venues…

View Cache

A papal apology on Indigenous land in Canada is not irrelevant south of the border.

When Pope Francis visits Canada July 24-29, Oneida First Nation activist Daisee Francour and her colleagues at the U.S.-based international Indigenous nongovernmental organization Cultural Survival will be paying close attention.

“An apology for one nation, in a way it’s a win for all of our nations,” said Francour. “When I say nation, I mean that as an Indigenous community — not necessarily the nation state or colonial state.

“There’s a huge opportunity, because the Catholic Church is just such an influential institution globally. There’s a huge opportunity to leverage, influence and push nation states like the U.S. government to join this collective process for justice, toward truth and toward healing.”

Francour and her colleagues, Indigenous media across the United States and American religious orders and dioceses have been watching closely what has happened in Canada…

View Cache

Criminal cases that are too old under state law could be revitalized under federal law.

The FBI has an open investigation of decades-old claims of child sexual abuse by Catholic priests, according to attorneys who confirmed several of their clients have been interviewed by federal agents in recent months.

Bill Arata, whose clients include the alleged victim of Patrick Wattigny, a Slidell priest and high school chaplain who was arrested on state child molestation charges last year, said his clients have been questioned by FBI agents.

Other attorneys representing dozens of other victims also said federal investigators have been interviewing their clients and focusing on potential violations of the Mann Act, which gives federal jurisdiction to prosecute sex crimes if a perpetrator took a victim across state lines for illicit sex, even if the alleged crime took place decades ago.

That means that allegations of crimes such…

View Cache

Freshly planted pink lilies adorn the sculpture of a young Jesus on the west side of Santa Fe’s Santuario de Nuestra Señora, one of the oldest churches in the country.

The inscription at the statue’s base — ”Dejen que los niños vengan a mi,” (“Let the children come to me”) — urges the Roman Catholic faithful to encourage their children to seek the company of Christ.

The words pack an irony that cannot be ignored as the Archdiocese of Santa Fe and its parishes begin to dig their way out of debt stemming from a bankruptcy spurred by a $121.5 million settlement with 375 people who say they were sexually abused — most as children — by Roman Catholic priests.

In a letter issued last month, the archdiocese asked its churches to contribute a combined $12 million to help bridge the gap between what insurers will pay and the $75 million the…

View Cache

For the first time in the history of Germany, less than half the German population registered as members of one of the two large churches: Catholic and Protestant.

New figures on church membership resignations have come as a shock to many, reported the German Catholic news agency KNA.

“The figures for 2021 show the profound crisis in which we find ourselves as the Catholic Church in Germany. There is no way to sugarcoat it,” said Bishop Georg Bätzing, president of the German bishops’ conference.

The Catholic Church counted 21.6 million members last year, according to its statistics published June 27. That corresponds to about 26 percent of the population. The Protestant, or Evangelical Church in Germany, has 19.7 million members, which corresponds to 23.5 percent. Christians in Germany remain by far the largest religious community, but the membership exodus has skyrocketed.

In Germany, church membership is registered…

View Cache

The Marist Brothers and Fathers have educated prime ministers, judges, cardinals and All Blacks at their prestigious Catholic high schools. But their record of sexual abuse is horrific. Worse still was their handling of the abuse when it was exposed. In this series, The Secret History, Steve Kilgallon investigates the power, abuse and cover-ups at the heart of two highly-influential and wealthy religious groups.

This is Part 2. The remaining chapters will be published in the coming weeks.

Warning: This story may be upsetting to some.

Waiheke Island, 2002. Robbie West* isn’t in a good way. He’s taking a lot of methamphetamine and drinking heavily, but making a valiant effort to tidy his life up.

After nearly three decades, he’s realised that the recurring nightmares that keep pushing him back to drink and drugs are actually painful memories he’s been working hard to bury. Having tried police and lawyers to…

View Cache

• Two of the alleged victims accused Jeremiah Lowe, 39, of molesting them when they were youngsters
• Lowe’s ex-wife, Abbey Plummer, claims he forced her to have sex with him, choked and beat her
• It comes after Lowe’s father John Lowe II, 65, was forced to step down from New Life Christian Church in Warsaw, Indiana, in May after admitting he had previously had an affair with a 16-year-old girl 
• The girl – Bobi Gephart, who is now 43 – stormed onto the stage during a service, grabbed a microphone and claimed he groomed her as a teenager, took her virginity, and sexually abused her

[PHOTO: Jeremiah Lowe, 39, has been accused of molesting two women when they were youngsters. His ex-wife has also raised claims of abuse during their turbulent marriage]

Three women have claimed they were abused by the son of an Indiana pastor who was ousted after being accused of grooming…

View Cache

The Southern Baptist Convention recently released a major report, from an independent investigation by Guidestone Solutions, exposing years of sexual abuse cover-up and mishandling by its leaders.

When Southern Baptists passed resolutions responding to sexual abuse at their annual meeting June 14, I held my breath and reluctantly celebrated. I know how much these actions mean to survivors — I talk to survivors every day. I, too, am a survivor of sexual abuse at a Southern Baptist seminary in North Carolina.

Since I came forward with my story four years ago, I have continually spoken with fellow survivors and leaders of SBC institutions about necessary changes. I often felt my suggestions were not acted upon quickly enough. Even now, there is tremendous work left to be done. Yet, I am encouraged by the reforms the SBC approved.

My joy does not come without words of caution for SBC pastors and…

View Cache

Marshall Blalock, pastor of First Baptist Church, Charleston, S.C., said one of the spiritual lessons he learned through serving on the Sexual Abuse Task Force was how to “think and act with more compassion.”

Blalock was one of the eight members selected by immediate-past president Ed Litton to serve on the Task Force, and was also named vice chairman.

The Task Force began their work this fall by signing a contract with independent firm Guidepost Solutions, who conducted an investigation into allegations of mishandling of sexual abuse claims by the SBC Executive Committee.

Guidepost released their full report in May, and the Task Force later released recommendations for reform based upon the findings of the report. Those recommendations were subsequently overwhelming approved by messengers at the 2022 SBC Annual Meeting in Anaheim, Calif.

Blalock said the whole experience greatly impacted his understanding regarding ministering in…

View Cache

Analysis

The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith updated this month its handbook on handling allegations of clerical sexual abuse of minors. While it harmonizes the standing guidance with revised canon law, it also highlights the distance still remaining between the Vatican’s preferred legal praxis and the methods used by U.S. dioceses.

The DDF’s update to its 2020 vademecum, or handbook, on Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela — the special law on sexual abuse cases — is dated June 5, though the text only came into wide canonical circulation this week.

The revisions largely amount to a tidying-up exercise, reconciling 2020 policies with the new Book VI of the Code of Canon Law promulgated by Pope Francis this time last year. 

But, while the revised vademecum doesn’t offer much in the way of new guidance on how to handle accusations of clerical sexual abuse of minors, there remains a sizable gap…

View Cache

Pope Pius XII was a slender, ascetic pope who dined alone most nights in the Apostolic Palace, attended by nuns, a pet canary at hand; he then spent hours writing statements and speeches during the long darkness of World War II. 

Pius’ words had repercussions he probably never imagined, a language so scripted as not to offend Adolf Hitler and Italy’s fascist dictator Benito Mussolini in the grisly buildup to World War II. The pope made no great outcry as Polish Jews were slaughtered in 1939 and Polish priests went to prison. In 1941, when Hitler invaded Russia, the pope singled out “the great courage shown in defending the bases of Christian civilization and confident hope in their triumph.”

And yet Pius knew the rotten underbelly. When a Roman military chaplain briefed him on Germans dynamiting synagogues in Ukraine and horrific Nazi massacres of Jews and Catholics,…

View Cache

The Bishop of Albany is proposing an alternative plan to settle hundreds of claims of sexual abuse against the New York diocese, a proposal the bishops hopes would avoid litigation over abuse claims and a diocesan filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

The diocese is proposing a court-approved mediation process and a fund for survivors created by the diocese, its affiliated institutions and its insurers, to compensate victims.

But Bishop Scharfenberger told The Pillar that the reason he is making the proposal, which he described as “another path forward for survivors,” isn’t to save the diocese money. Instead, he said, he hopes the mediation process could ensure all victims receive some compensation from available diocesan resources. 

“The thing, I think, that’s not been understood is that there is a limited amount of money,” the bishop told The Pillar. “I don’t want any hidden corners whereby we say we’ve got this pot over there saving…

View Cache

The federal probe could pave the way for further revelations and further lawsuits against the New Orleans archdiocese.

Federal authorities are investigating alleged sex abuse of minors by New Orleans-area Catholic clergy, sometimes going back decades, on the grounds that the accused men could have violated a federal anti-sex trafficking law by crossing state lines. The investigation could provide another means for abuse victims to make their case against their abusers, and possibly file sex abuse lawsuits against Catholic dioceses and other organizations.

The FBI is probing whether accused priests can be prosecuted under various charges including the Mann Act, which bars taking anyone across state lines for illicit sex. Though some criminal claims may date back to the 1970s, the Mann Act has no statute of limitations. The Louisiana State Police is aiding the inquiry.

Federal prosecutors have used the Mann Act to help convict Ghislaine Maxwell, a leading…

View Cache

The Secret History: Uncovering Marist sex abuse

The Marist Brothers and Fathers have educated prime ministers, judges, cardinals and All Blacks at their Catholic high schools. But their record of sexual abuse is horrific. Worse still was their handling of the abuse when it was exposed. In this series The Secret History, Steve Kilgallon investigates the power, abuse and cover-ups at the heart of two highly influential and wealthy religious groups.

This is Part 1. The remaining parts will be published over the coming weeks.

Warning: This story may be upsetting to some.

When John Wilson* was 12 years old, he was repeatedly raped and sexually abused by his school principal, Kevin Waters.

Over two years at Christchurch’s Xavier Intermediate, John was groomed, then threatened, beaten, and even burned with a cigarette lighter. He was an altar server, and Waters would trick John by summoning him to the city’s Catholic cathedral…

View Cache

Ahead of America’s July 4th celebrations, Claire Cronin talks about her faith, her frustration at the lack of political action on US gun violence, and how she expects President Biden to visit Ireland soon

Claire Cronin likes to tell story of John F Kennedy, brother of Jean Kennedy Smith, the last female US ambassador to serve before her in Dublin.

During his 1963 visit, the then US president stood at a window in Deerfield, the ambassador’s Phoenix Park residence in Dublin, and looked across the park.

“The story goes that one of his aides said to him: ‘When you’re not president, what Democrat are you going to support to follow you?’ And he said: ‘I’m going to support whatever Democrat makes me ambassador to Ireland,’” she says.

Cronin (62), almost five months in her job as President Joe Biden’s envoy to Ireland, is equally taken by the view towards the…

View Cache

When representatives of The Episcopal Church gather in Baltimore for the denomination’s General Convention taking place from July 8-11, they’ll be asked to consider a proposed overhaul to the church’s sexual violence prevention policy.

Currently, Episcopal canon law requires those preparing for ordination to demonstrate competencies in the “prevention of sexual misconduct.” The proposed changes would strike that requirement. Instead, ordinands would need to demonstrate the loftier-sounding, but more nebulous, ability to “form communities that understand and welcome diverse experiences of gender and sexuality, manifest safe and appropriate boundaries, and implement strategies to prevent sexual misconduct.”

The intent is to underscore “the importance of providing places for inclusion and support for those who have experienced rejection, shaming, and violence”—in particular, members of the LGBTQ+ community—which sounds like a welcome and refreshing change. 

But there’s a problem.

Gender and sexual minorities don’t just experience rejection, shaming, and violence outside Episcopal churches—they experience…

View Cache

Diocese proposes court-supervised effort to compensate more than 400 victims of sexual abuse who have filed claims.

The city’s Roman Catholic Diocese on Wednesday announced an initial proposal to use a court-supervised mediation plan to compensate the more than 400 victims of sexual abuse who have filed claims against the diocese, individual clergy and others under the state Child Victims Act.

The proposal, which must be approved by a state Supreme Court justice, would seek to “maximize the monetary recovery for victim/survivors on a fair and equitable basis and to accelerate the payments,” according to a release distributed to dozens of attorneys on behalf of the diocese by Michael L. Costello, the diocese’s longtime attorney.

“The diocese seeks to avoid the costly expenses and prolonged delays that would otherwise be associated with continued litigation with plaintiffs and their…

View Cache

The list of priests credibly accused of child sexual abuse who have served in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Columbus now totals 53, with one additional priest awaiting a judgment.

In May, the diocese added a Newark priest to the list of those who had been credibly accused after he was put on leave in January.

The Rev. Dean A. Mathewson, 77, remains on leave after he was accused of sexually abusing a minor while serving at St. Francis de Sales Parish in Newark in the early 1990s.

The list, originally with 34 clergy named, came out in March 2019 on the heels of the Pennsylvania grand jury report that revealed more than 1,000 victims of alleged abuse by more than 300 priests over 70 years. The report’s release spurred public pressure for dioceses across the country to release such lists telling people which priests…

View Cache

With the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade, American women and girls have lost their full citizenship rights. Women, transgender men and nonbinary people who can get pregnant no longer have bodily autonomy during pregnancy or sexual freedom. The government now controls their bodies and behaviors.

Politicians can force people to carry pregnancies against their will — a form of involuntary servitude that should be prohibited by the 13th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, but which the current Supreme Court now allows.

The six right-wing Catholics on the Supreme Court reversed long-standing U.S. law as part of a campaign to establish in its place the Catholic belief that abortion at any stage of pregnancy is a sin. The original instigator of the anti-abortion movement was the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and they remain one of its biggest funders.

Shortly after Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion leaked in May, a…

View Cache

The Catholic Church also said that it had asked the Attorney General’s Chambers to partially lift the gag order on the case in relation to the identity of the offender, but AGC said it was unable to accede to the request. 

SINGAPORE: The two teenage boys who were sexually abused by a prominent member of the local Catholic community “refused” to make police reports after the incidents came to light in 2009, the Catholic religious order said in a statement on Sunday (Jun 5).

The boys were repeatedly told that they could make a police report and would be accompanied to the police station to do so, but they were insistent in wanting to keep the matter private.

As such, the superior of the Catholic order, who initiated investigations on the case, did not make a police report at the time “out of respect for the stated wishes and requested privacy…

View Cache

A former priest who was sexually abused as a teenager by a senior cleric has been awarded £455,000 damages against the Catholic Church.

The man, who cannot be named, was abused while he attended a residential school in Scotland in the 1970s.

His attacker had been his “spiritual director” between the ages of 14 and 16.

The victim went on the join the priesthood but became a “tortured soul”, the Court of Session heard.

He later went through the formal procedure of leaving the priesthood and was married for a while.

The man sued The Bishop’s Conference of Scotland for £2.25m.

It admitted the sexual abuse occurred and accepted liability for any loss or damage caused by the abuse.

Lord Clark, who heard the case, said: “For many years the pursuer (the ex-priest) carried out his role as a priest in an effective and well-respected manner.

“However, as a teenager…

View Cache

Why isn’t the crisis part of the synodal conversation?

The year 2018 was a turning point in the modern history of the Catholic Church’s response to the global abuse crisis, and once again incidents in the United States played a major role. The McCarrick scandal exploded in the spring and summer of that year, following an investigation that determined the former archbishop of Washington D.C. had sexually abused a minor. McCarrick was the highest-ranking cleric in Church history to be accused of, investigated for, and removed from the college of cardinals, not for covering up someone else’s abuse but for the abuse itself; about seven months later, he was defrocked. The case spurred a number of significant developments in the Vatican: the February 2019 summit convening Curia leaders and the presidents of all the bishops’ conferences; the promulgation of the May 2019 motu proprio Vos estis; and the release of the…

View Cache

The FBI has opened a widening investigation into sex abuse in the Roman Catholic Church in New Orleans going back decades, a rare federal foray into such cases looking specifically at whether priests took children across state lines to molest them, officials and others familiar with the inquiry told The Associated Press.

More than a dozen alleged abuse victims have been interviewed this year as part of the probe that’s exploring among other charges whether predator priests can be prosecuted under the Mann Act, a more than century-old, anti-sex trafficking law that prohibits taking anyone across state lines for illicit sex.

Some of the New Orleans cases under review allege abuse by clergy during trips to Mississippi camps or amusement parks in Texas and Florida. And while some claims are decades old, Mann Act violations notably have no statute of limitations.

“It’s been a long road and just the…

View Cache

(For Immediate Release June 29, 2022) 

We are encouraged by news that the FBI is looking into sexual abuse and cover-up within the Archdiocese of New Orleans. We have no doubt that this probe will reveal far more truths to the public than we have gotten from church officials in New Orleans. A probe like this is absolutely critical, especially when considering the move by church hierarchs in New Orleans to pre-emptively declare bankruptcy, a move that we believe was designed to shield assets, protect secrets, and prevent information about the cover-up from making it into the public eye.

As we see it, the best justice that victims and the unsuspecting faithful can hope for lies with a secular law enforcement investigation. SNAP has long argued that true reform and change will come from the involvement of secular authorities and believe that what is happening in New Orleans is a…

View Cache

The FBI is investigating sex abuse allegations in the Catholic Church in New Orleans that goes back decades, according to the Associated Press.

And people who say they were subjected to abuse by priests welcome the federal investigation.

Shaun Dougherty is Board President of SNAP, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests.

“Anytime an organization such as the Roman Catholic Church self-polices itself, you know, you’re not going to get a true look into the window of what is actually going on within that organization, this case being the Roman Catholic diocese in New Orleans, so the FBI has the tools and the manpower and the resources,” said Dougherty.

According to the AP, the FBI opened a “widening investigation into sex abuse” stretching back decades. The feds reportedly are looking at whether priests took children across state lines to molest them and according to AP more than a dozen…

View Cache

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany on Wednesday proposed mediated financial settlements for survivors of clergy sex abuse as an alternative to court battles or the diocese declaring bankruptcy.

The diocese is facing a potentially huge cost from the more than 400 claims pending against it in court, both in legal bills and judgments. In an open letter, it said mediation would result in a more equitable distribution of the finite pot of funds it has available for the purpose.Report Adabout:blank

But a law firm representing two dozen people who claim to have been molested by Albany Diocese clergy decades ago called it a bogus and cynical maneuver to avoid transparency and accountability.

Three years ago in New York, the long-running clergy pedophilia scandal took a sharp turn from a shocking revelation about one of society’s most respected institutions to a major financial threat: The state Child Victims Act briefly…

View Cache

As former pastor Bruxy Cavey appears in an Ontario court, the reckoning continues at The Meeting House.

Reeling from the arrest of their former teaching pastor, Bruxy Cavey, for sexual assault, and a growing number of sexual misconduct allegations against other previous pastors, leaders at The Meeting House are looking for ways to move forward.

“We are deeply sorry for the abuse and harm that has occurred, be it sexual, emotional, or spiritual in our church family,” Jennifer Hryniw, cochair of the board of overseers, recently told the congregation, which operates in 20 locations across Ontario. “We are deeply sorry for how many of these stories have been handled in the past. We continue to be humbled to now be the stewards of these stories.”

The Meeting House was supposed to be a humble kind of church. The Canadian Anabaptist congregation was built around movie theater venues…

View Cache

The FBI has opened a widening investigation into sex abuse in the Roman Catholic Church in New Orleans going back decades, a rare federal foray into such cases looking specifically at whether priests took children across state lines to molest them, officials and others familiar with the inquiry told The Associated Press.

More than a dozen alleged abuse victims have been interviewed this year as part of the probe that’s exploring among other charges whether predator priests can be prosecuted under the Mann Act, a more than century-old, anti-sex trafficking law that prohibits taking anyone across state lines for illicit sex.

Some of the New Orleans cases under review allege abuse by clergy during trips to Mississippi camps or amusement parks in Texas and Florida. And while some claims are decades old, Mann Act violations notably have no statute of limitations.

“It’s been a long road and just the fact…

View Cache

Having learned so much from survivors, their friends and family members, and their stories of abuse, I feel deeply for all those who have painfully spoken and patiently awaited the justice promised by the New York State Child Victims Act (CVA). Many suffer in silence with no one to share their story with. While I will continue to do all in my power to assist and accompany survivors and loved ones in recovery, including in their spiritual healing, I understand that my efforts are naturally difficult to trust. It will be hard for many to believe that I am acting or speaking from my heart, or that what I do or say is credible. I still believe it is worth reaching out to survivors and their loved ones at this juncture to describe a path to justice for all survivors under the CVA.

Currently, two divergent courses of action are…

View Cache

Bishop Edward Scharfenberger of Albany is proposing a new plan for victims/survivors of clergy sexual abuse in the diocese that he argues maximizes the monetary recovery of victims/survivors on a fair and equitable basis, accelerates those payments, and allows the diocese to avoid litigation or bankruptcy.

The concept for the “Victims/Survivors Path Forward Plan” was publicized by Scharfenberger in a June 29 news release. The plan was formulated under the supervision of the New York Supreme Court, where the diocese currently has more than 400 victim/survivor cases pending.

“Having learned so much from survivors, their friends and family members, and their stories of abuse, I feel deeply for all those who have painfully spoken and patiently awaited the justice promised by the New York State Child Victims Act,” Scharfenberger said.

The Child Victims Act is a New York law passed in 2019 that allows prosecutors to bring criminal charges in…

View Cache

The contrasting recent handling by the Vatican of two bishops has highlighted concerns about discrepancies in the disciplining of bishops, with no explanation available why one of the two bishop was dismissed while the other has been allowed to remain in office.

The two cases involve Bishop Daniel Fernández Torres of Arecibo, Puerto Rico, whom Francis relieved from his episcopal duties in March, and Bishop Richard Stika of Knoxville, Tennessee, who has not been sanctioned despite an array of allegations including the mishandling of a case of sexual misconduct by a diocesan seminarian. 

“The treatment of such cases has seemed quite arbitrary to me,” one cardinal told the Register on condition of anonymity, adding that this approach raises “serious and justifiable questions.” 

The Vatican did not give a reason for dismissing 57-year-old Bishop Fernández, who in a March 9 declaration protested against the decision, calling it “totally unjust.”

“No process…

View Cache

Like Meggie Ochoa, we all need to be child rights advocates and give support to the cries for help of abused children

Pope Francis is an avid football fan and uses sport to protect children. He follows San Lorenzo football club. He hosted an international interreligious charity football game in Rome in 2014 to support children in need of help and protection. There he met famous players such as Lionel Messi. The late Diego Maradona, also from Argentina, gave Pope Francis a football jersey emblazoned with “Francis.”

Athletes are admired and imitated by millions of fans around the world. They have influence because of their willpower to succeed, to overcome hardship and achieve near-impossible goals. That is the way it is for many great Philippine athletes since almost all of them come from very poor families and have unique sporting ability. However, they have few sponsors to enable them to…

View Cache

Father Mullapally was suspended from public ministry in Kerala two years ago following a sex scandal

A Catholic priest has been suspended in southern India after he reportedly married a Hindu woman following her temple rituals.

Officials of Tellicherry Archdiocese in Kerala state announced the withdrawal of the priestly faculties of Father Mathew Mullapally on June 28, soon after pictures of the newly married couple flooded social media.

Mullapally has informed the archdiocese of his “definitive and non-retractable decision for personal reasons to leave the priesthood and to return to secular life,” said the letter, jointly signed by Archbishop Joseph Pamplany of Tellicherry and his chancellor Father Joseph Muttathukunnel.

The letter made no reference to the marriage but said Mullapally informed the archbishop of his “desire to get dispensation from all his clerical obligations and consequently of clerical rights as well.”

The archbishop after “mature consideration and…

View Cache

Two years after launching “Version 1.0” of guidelines for how bishops, religious superiors, and canon lawyers are expected to handle complaints of alleged abuse by clergy, the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has released an update. In a disappointing fashion, this update does not strengthen any existing requirements because the update is a mere suggestion without any teeth to enforce it. We are frustrated that “reforms” from the Vatican continue to lack the very clear and direct asks that survivors have been making for years.

The update to the “Vademecum on Certain Points of Procedure in Treating Cases of Sexual Abuse of Minors Committed by Clerics” “does not have the power of law,” according to a dicastery statement released on June 27; rather, it ” is intended to respond to a growing need for knowledge” regarding the processes to be followed when allegations of abuse…

View Cache

A papal apology on Indigenous land in Canada is not irrelevant south of the border.

When Pope Francis visits Canada July 24-29, Oneida First Nation activist Daisee Francour and her colleagues at the U.S.-based international Indigenous nongovernmental organization Cultural Survival will be paying close attention.

“An apology for one nation, in a way it’s a win for all of our nations,” said Francour. “When I say nation, I mean that as an Indigenous community — not necessarily the nation state or colonial state.

“There’s a huge opportunity, because the Catholic Church is just such an influential institution globally. There’s a huge opportunity to leverage, influence and push nation states like the U.S. government to join this collective process for justice, toward truth and toward healing.”

Francour and her colleagues, Indigenous media across the United States and American religious orders and dioceses have been watching closely what has happened in Canada…

View Cache

A former North Carolina pastor and Christian school administrator was convicted of eight sex offenses this month, local media reported. A woman reportedly told police that the man had sex with her multiple times when she was a student at his school.

Jason Wesley Keller, 42, is in jail after a jury convicted him of six felony counts of sex with a student and two counts of indecency with a student. He is set to spend four to five years in prison followed by 30 months’ probation, according to local news reports.

Keller initially faced 10 charges related to sexual activity with a student. Police said the charges stemmed from incidents during the 2008-2009 school year at Union Grove Christian School, in a suburb southwest of Greensboro. The student was reportedly 17 at the time, and Keller was the assistant principal…

View Cache

Disgraced socialite Ghislaine Maxwell was sentenced to 20 years in prison for the sex-trafficking ring of young teens she helped financier Jeffrey Epstein run for a decade.

The punishment doled out by U.S. District Judge Alison J. Nathan on Tuesday marks the most concrete punishment yet for the years of abuse Maxwell and Epstein imposed on young girls.

Several of those girls, now adults, testified during the trial, bravely pulling the curtain back on years of abuse they suffered after Maxwell and Epstein tugged them into their orbit. The two often used the allure of wealth and their connections to powerful people such as Prince Andrew, Bill Clinton and Donald Trump.

“Today’s sentence holds Ghislaine Maxwell accountable for perpetrating heinous crimes against children,” U.S. Attorney Damian Williams said in a statement tweeted by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York. “This sentence sends a strong message that no…

View Cache

New lawsuits are flooding into the Catholic Church, now that the U.S. Supreme Court has rejected a challenge to a California state law that allows victims to sue, even decades after clergy sexual abuse.

The I-Team’s Dan Noyes spent years investigating these cases, exposing how church officials allowed known abusers to move from parish to parish. The church is facing new lawsuits because of the actions of priests we first uncovered in the 1990s.

Over the years, we’ve heard stories of abuse at the Catholic Church’s “Camp St. Michael” in Mendocino County from more than two dozen victims. Now, a new plaintiff is coming forward telling the I-Team, “Every morning, we were supposed to do polar bears, which is all the boys stripped down to nothing and jump in the river naked.”

He doesn’t want to show his face or use his name, but he is the latest to sue the…

View Cache

(For Immediate Release June 27, 2022) 

SNAP raises concern over former high-ranking priest employee, now current parish pastor

This past week, NBC Bay Area News (Part 1 and Part 2)  revealed that at least four prominent Catholic priests in the San Francisco Bay Area were accused of child sexual abuse in lawsuits filed under California’s look-back window. Yet contrary to the promises of the 2002 Dallas Charter, all four are still working. 

While all four clerics are a serious concern to us, it appears that Msgr. James Pulskamp of the Diocese of Santa Rosa — accused in a current suit of sexually abusing a child at the Hanna Boys Center — was in the best position to also cover up accusations of abuse, including perhaps any against him. As we have come to expect, Catholic officials attempt to minimize the gravity of the allegations…

View Cache

A Quebec Superior Court judge has authorized a class action lawsuit against the Trois-Rivières Diocese for alleged sexual assaults from 1940 to the present day.

Lawyers with Arsenault Dufresne Wee Avocats presented arguments on June 15 at the Trois-Rivières courthouse and published a news release Monday saying the diocese did not oppose the class action.

Dominic Maurais is slated to represent victims who “have been sexually assaulted by a member of the diocesan clergy (bishop, deacon), by a religious person, a member of the lay pastoral staff, an employee or a lay or religious volunteer under the responsibility of the Catholic Bishopric of Trois-Rivières,” the release reads.

The Trois-Rivières Diocese covers a large area in Quebec’s Mauricie region.

The release reads all alleged crimes will need to be proven in court unless an out-of-court settlement is reached.

More than 25 victims have contacted the law firm with their accusations.

The…

View Cache

Two years after posting online a step-by-step guide for how bishops, religious superiors and canon lawyers are supposed to handle accusations of alleged abuse by clerics and labeling it “Version 1.0,” the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has published an update.

“Version 2.0” of the dicastery’s “Vademecum on certain points of procedure in treating cases of sexual abuse of minors committed by clerics” was necessary mainly because of Pope Francis’ promulgation of a new section of the Code of Canon Law dealing with crimes and punishments in the church.

“Book VI: Penal Sanctions in the Church” went into effect Dec. 8 and was the result of almost two decades of work updating, adding, clarifying and strengthening the code’s list of crimes and provisions available for sanctioning the guilty.

As a step-by-step guide, the vademecum was updated to include references to the revised canons.

A statement published by the…

View Cache

The Supreme Court has ordered the Catholic Archdiocese of Melbourne to pay $1.9 million to a man who was sexually abused as a child by a priest in Kilmore between 1968 and 1970.

Catholic priest Desmond Gannon was convicted and jailed in 2009 for abusing the primary school-aged boy on three occasions.

The victim later lodged a civil action case, the result of which was handed down earlier this month.

The case was lodged against current Melbourne Archbishop Peter Comonsoli, claiming damages for the injuries and resulting losses he suffered as a result of the abuse.

Supreme Court judge Andrew Keogh ordered the church to pay a total of $1,908,647 – $525,000 for general damages; $15,000 for future treatment expenses; $1.5 million for economic loss damages, less $131,353 for a payment from the Melbourne Response, set up by the Catholic Church to respond to complaints of abuse committed by priests…

View Cache

A months-long NBC Bay Area investigation into a wave of new clergy abuse lawsuits has uncovered a series of allegations against dozens of Northern California priests and church employees accused for the first time of sexually abusing children. Some of them continue to work here.

Two Bay Area Catholic dioceses are allowing priests they employ to remain in ministry despite lawsuits now accusing the men of sexually abusing children earlier in their careers, NBC Bay Area has confirmed.

The findings come amid an ongoing NBC Bay Area investigation into a flood of new child sex abuse claims hitting Catholic institutions across the state. The civil lawsuits are the result of a 2019 California law that opened a three-year “lookback” window allowing new child sex abuse lawsuits based on claims typically barred by the statute of limitations.

Click…

View Cache

A new initiative by a group representing U.S. Catholic priests to inform clerics of their canonical rights when they are accused of misconduct, including sexual abuse, is attracting criticism from survivor advocates, who say it could help cast accused priests in an overly sympathetic light.

But the clergy behind the effort by the Association of U.S. Catholic Priests, or AUSCP, argue it is necessary. Over the last 20 years, they say, diocesan leaders have failed to respect priests’ rights under canon law — in some cases allowing accused clerics to languish in administrative “limbo” for several years while civil and church authorities investigate allegations made against them.

“And in so many cases it’s virtually impossible to prove their innocence, because it’s pretty hard to prove a negative,” Fr. Mike Sullivan, a parish priest in Minnesota who is a canon lawyer and a member of the association’s Mutual…

View Cache