37 Accused in This Diocese
- Post and Courier 06.21.96
- Post and Courier 07.11.96
- Post and Courier 04.10.98
- Post and Courier 04.28.02
- Dallas Morning News 06.12.02
- Post and Courier 02.28.04
- Post and Courier 01.24.06
- Post and Courier 02.19.06
- Post and Courier 02.07.09
- Renew America 04.19.11
- Post and Courier 04.25.14
- ABC News 4 WCIV 05.30.14
- Post and Courier 05.30.14
- Diocese of Charleston List 03.29.19
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 05.27.02
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 05.29.02
- Post and Courier 05.30.02
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 05.30.02
- Post and Courier 05.31.02
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 05.31.02
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 06.18.02
- Augusta Chronicle (GA) 07.19.03
- Catholic Miscellany 07.24.03
- Diocese of Charleston List 03.29.19
- Post and Courier 06.01.95
- Patriot Ledger 12.27.95
- Post and Courier 12.27.95
- Post and Courier 06.21.96
- Post and Courier 04.28.02
- Post and Courier 02.28.04
- Renew America 08.18.06
- Post and Courier 03.11.07
- Post and Courier 09.15.07
- Post and Courier 09.15.07
- Renew America 04.19.11
- Post and Courier 01.26.16
- Diocese of Charleston List 04.05.19
- Atlanta Journal-Constitution 12.30.93
- Post and Courier 06.21.96
- Wanderer 06.18.98
- Charlotte (NC) Observer 03.17.02
- Post & Courier 04.28.02
- Post and Courier 02.28.04
- Renew America 08.18.06
- Renew America 04.19.11
- Post and Courier 04.26.14
- Post and Courier 05.12.17
- Diocese of Charleston List 03.29.19
- WCSC 01.11.21
- Catholic Miscellany 08.18.11
- Fox Carolina 03.10.13
- Greenville Online 03.10.13
- WYFF 03.10.13
- WSPA 03.10.13
- WMBF 03.10.13
- GWD Today 03.10.13
- Simpsonville Patch 03.10.13
- Independent Mail 03.10.13
- Myrtle Beach Online 03.11.13
- West Ashley Patch 03.11.13
- WYFF 04.23.13
- The Item (AP) 04.23.13
- Index-Journal 04.23.13
- Fox Carolina 04.24.13
- Greenville News 02.28.19
- Diocese of Charleston List 04.19.19
Fr. Roy Francis Aiken
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 7/4/06.
Fr. John F. Bench
Ordained for the Pittsburgh diocese. Relocated to Charleston diocese in 1980. Resigned from Holy Cross Parish in Pickens at request of Bishop in 12/93 after accusations that he had molested a girl. In 2000 he asked to be reinstated and transferred to FL. Child's parents were consulted and strenuously objected. Bishop then denied request. Died 6/6/09 in FL. On diocese's list 3/29/19.
Fr. Peter Berberich
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 3/20/97.
Sources:
Fr. William Burn
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 5/29/09.
Sources:
Fr. Juan Carlos Castano-Mejia
Priest of The Congregation of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri in Ipiales, Colombia. Arrived in the U.S. in 1999; investigated before being granted visiting priest status. Arrested and indicted in 4/02 on charges that he abused a 4-year-old girl in 2000. She told her brother who told another relative. Incident was not reported to the diocese until 2002. In 4/03, he admitted fondling the child and was sentenced to 2 years in jail, 2 years probation, and required to pay restitution. There may have been similar allegations in South America. On Charleston diocese's list 3/29/19. Deported after release from prison. On the Charlotte diocese's list 12/29/19.
Assignments:
Sources:
Fr. Roger Collerett
Priest of the Missionaries of Africa (White Fathers) - Canada. On Charleston diocese's list 3/29/19. Believed to have returned to Canada.
Sources:
Fr. Eugene L. Condon
Indicted in 7/96 on charges of 1970s abuse of minor. Resigned immediately after Diocese learned of charges and allowed "early retirement" without privileges. Ordered not to be alone with minors. Police also found child porn in his possession. In 4/98 he received 5 years probation for committing lewd acts with boys in 1970s. Arrested again in 1/06 on similar charges. Retired in 2006. Charges dropped in 2/09 because victim's extensive legal, mental and sobriety issues did not allow him to testify. Died 5/24/14. Buried 05/28/14. On diocese's list 3/29/19.
Sources:
Fr. Raymond DuMouchel
Retired in 1999. In 11/02, Charleston police charged the 78-year-old with sexually molesting two girls while working at city churches and a local hospital in the1950s. Third accuser came forward 2/03. Charges dropped in 2005 because of DuMouchel's dementia and inability to contribute to his own defense. Died 9/10/06. On diocese's list 3/29/19. Named in a lawsuit against the diocese filed by a man who claimed that the diocese knew DuMouchel was abusing children. A judge ruled against the plaintiff, who was also a victim of convicted priest Wayland Brown, in 12/21.
Fr. Thomas A. Evatt
Placed on leave in 5/02 after accused of performing a lewd act on a boy, age 9, during a rectory overnight stay in 1977. The alleged victim told his father in 1991 and informed police and Diocese in 2002. Evatt said the 1977 incident was a "singular horrible event" that never happened again. Trial pending in 7/03 when Evatt was found dead in his home 7/18/03. Death ruled accidental, due to massive blood loss when Evatt cut his leg on a piece of furniture. Alcohol abuse contributed to his death. On diocese's list 3/29/19.
Sources:
Fr. Jaime Gonzalez-Farias
Visiting priest of the Diocese of San Bernardo in Chile. Arrived in SC in 2015. Named publicly as credibly accused by the Diocese of Charleston SC on its list in 8/2021. The Diocese received a report in 12/2020 that Gonzalez-Farias sexually abused a boy, age 11, in late 2020, including during a trip to FL. Gonzalez-Farias had returned to Chile. He was arrested in Miami FL 11/29/2022 by the U.S. Marshall Service. Pleaded not guilty in 1/2023.
Fr. Justin L. Goodwin
Arrested 1994 on charges of abusing four brothers in the late 1970s. Released on personal recognizance. In 1995 he entered an Alford plea (did not admit to wrongdoing but felt evidence would result in conviction) and was sentenced to 10 years prison, suspended upon service of 5 years probation. Died 12/25/95. Plaintiffs settled for $200K total but were denied permission to participate in 2007 settlement.
Sources:
Fr. Frederick J. Hopwood
Accused of abusing multiple people. Resigned in 12/93 after accusations became public. Criminal charges filed in 1994. Pled guilty. Sentenced to three years probation, treatment and 250 hours public service. Hopwood's roommate at seminary and later was future Cardinal Bernardin. Ordained by Bishop Russell of Charleston who made him Chancellor immediately after ordination. Died 4/30/17. On diocese's list 3/29/19. Lawsuit filed in 1/21 claims abuse of a boy for two years in the mid-1970s, beginning when the boy was age 13 and a St. John's Church and Cathedral School student.
Sources:
Fr. Leon Joseph Hubacz
Named publicly as accused by the Charleston diocese on its list 3/29/19. Subject of a settlement. Died 6/28/99.
Sources:
Fr. Robert J. Kelly
Monsignor. Accused in a lawsuit filed in 11/3/21 of sexually abusing a young altar boy in the early 1990s, at St. Andrew's in Myrtle Beach. Kelly's accuser said the priest also abused other altar boysl. Kelly died in 2004.
Fr. Ernest Eugene Kennedy
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Noted to be the subject of a settlement. Died 6/9/17.
Fr. Walter Pringle Lee
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Left the priesthood after 10 years, married and raised a family. Died in 4/81.
Fr. James McElroy
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Abuse allegedly occurred in the 1940s. Subject of a settlement. Died 7/5/71.
Sources:
Fr. Frederick Austin McLean
Named publicly as credibly accused by the Charleston diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 8/26/10. Included in a 10/19 report commissioned by the Diocese of Bridgeport, with an allegation deemed not credible. McLean was accused of sexually abusing a 17-year-old girl in 1962. He had been transferred to the Charleston diocese in 1956 from Bridgeport, and incardinated into the Charleston diocese in 1959. He is thought to have left ministry in 1964. Accused in a lawsuit filed in 1/21 of abusing a girl and her sister 1961-66 while assigned to St. John's Church and School.
Assignments:
Sources:
Fr. George Frederick Moynihan
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 8/30/04.
Fr. Daniel Francis Murphy
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 7/21/80.
Fr. Joseph J. Murphy
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 8/24/98.
Fr. James Robert Owens-Howard
Former Bishop England High School teacher. Retired. Arrested on charges related to fondling an 8-year-old boy in a pool. Convicted in 2/93. Apparently sentenced to 5 years prison. Released in 4/98. Absent on sick leave per 1993 and 1998 Catholic Directories. Not indexed in the 2002 Directory. Registered sex offender in SC as of 6/10. Conviction information found on that website. On diocese's list 3/29/19. Died 12/01/15.
Fr. Cesare Palatore Belfiore
Named publicly as accused by the Charleston diocese on its list 3/29/19. Visiting priest from the Diocese of San Jose in Costa Rica. Believed to have returned to Costa Rica.
Fr. Anthony Plikunas
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 11/28/73. Subject of a settlement.
Sources:
Fr. William Richardson
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Noted to have left the Catholic priesthood in 6/83. Subject of a settlement.
Sources:
Fr. Gerald J. Ryfinski
Arrested in 6/01 after a computer repairman found child pornography on Ryfinski's computer. Pleaded guilty in 3/02 to one count of third-degree sexual exploitation of a minor. Received a five year suspended sentence with three years probation. Laicized in 4/07. On SC Sex Offender Registry as of 1/3/10. On diocese's list 3/29/19.
Fr. Paul F. Seitz
Removed in 11/94 after allegations that he was involved in sexual misconduct with a minor 30 years prior. Denied allegations. Allowed to return to work prior to 2002. Assigned to a smaller parish and ordered not to be alone with children. Per a 6/02 article, Seitz resigned "for health reasons." On diocese's list 3/29/19. Noted to have retired 6/1/02 and to be "under restrictions."
Fr. James Sharples
Priest of the Oratory of St. Philip Neri in Rock Hill, SC. Died 11/28/74. Named publicly as accused by the Charleston diocese on its list 3/29/19.
Sources:
Fr. Charles L. Sheedy
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 7/6/89.
Sources:
Fr. Lawrence Sheedy
Status: Settled
Diocese: Diocese of Charleston SC
A man filed a civil suit in 2004 naming Sheedy as his abuser. The man said the abuse occurred at a Catholic orphanage in 1967-68 until the Mother Superior found out. Sheedy was transferred to Arizona and later died. The suit settled in 6/06 at mediation. The man and others accusing Rev. James Nyhan filed another suit against the church for loss of consortium.
Fr. John Simonin
Monsignor. Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 7/15/10.
Fr. Gabriel Smith
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Retired from active ministry 12/31/18. Allegation noted to have occurred eight years prior to ordination and "did not involve touching the minor." Returned to ministry in 3/04 after the Vatican determined that he was not a risk to minors.
Fr. Frederick H. Suggs
Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 8/26/98. Subject of a settlement.
Fr. Creston J. Tawes
Named as accused by the diocese on its list 3/29/19. Died 8/4/80. Subject of a settlement.
Sources:
Fr. Hayden Vaverek
Privileges removed in 3/13 after allegations of sexual misconduct involving a minor more than 15 years prior, when he was pastor of Our Lady of Lourdes in Greenwood. In 1/11, with permission of the bishop, he began working for Catholic Near East Welfare Association, a papal agency based in NY City. Apparently in Rome when allegations were made public. As of 4/23/13 accuser waived further criminal investigation, saying church punishment was enough. Diocese was continuing investigation. Laicized in 5/16. In 2017 Vaverek created a nonprofit for supporting priests "at a vocational crossroads" called Pax Bonum. Included on the diocese's 3/19 list of credibly accused.
Sources:
Fr. Freddy Washington
Pastor of St. Mark the Evangelist parish in Harlem in the NY archdiocese when arrested in 6/17 for sexual abuse in 1982-84 of two boys, ages 10 and 11-14, at St. Patrick's church in Charleston. Washington was an 18-year-old lay person and volunteer at the time of the alleged abuse. The boys were in training to be altar servers. Abuse was said to have included fondling and oral copulation. The Charleston diocese learned of the allegations in 2/16 and contacted the Rockville Centre diocese. The Charleston diocese contacted Charleston police in 9/16. Former pastor of two Chicago parishes. Listed on Xavier University in New Orleans' website in 6/17 as associate professor of pastoral theology. Included in 10/22 on the Chicago archdiocese's list of credibly accused.
Fr. Louis Williamson
Named publicly as credibly accused by the diocese on its list updated 12/31/19. Died 6/20/62.