ABUSE TRACKER

On August 14, 2021, New York and Pennsylvania will show their true colors when it comes to taking child protection seriously. New York is striding into the future of child protection while Pennsylvania is mired in toxic politics that endanger children.

New York Opens a Window and Learns About Perpetrators and Institutions Previously Off the Radar

Two years ago, to the day, the New York Child Victims Act window opened. Within days, over 4,000 cases had been filed. Then, when the pandemic shut courthouses, New York added a second year to the window, and by the time it closed nearly 10,000 complaints had been filed. These laws have a lot to offer the victims and their families: they validate survivors, create access to justice, and make it possible to shift the cost of abuse from the victim to the ones who caused it. But they also serve the interests of…

View Cache

The outing of a top administrator of the nation’s conference of Catholic bishops as a regular Grindr user was clearly a story. But what kind?

About the author: Peter Steinfels, a former editor of Commonweal and religion writer for the New York Times, is a professor emeritus at Fordham University and author of A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America.

Once, it was said that the eyes were the windows to the soul. Now the cellphone is. Consider Jeffrey Burrill, a man who regularly logged in to the gay dating app Grindr and whose cellphone emitted signals marking his visits to gay bars and a Las Vegas gay bathhouse. Hardly a story there, you might say.

Except Jeffrey Burrill was Monsignor Jeffrey Burrill, the secretary-general of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. And his July 20 resignation was forced by a newly founded Catholic online newsletter using commercially available data…

View Cache

In a fairly unusual move, Diocese of Albany Bishop Howard Hubbard has taken to the news media recently to try and rehab his image.

His latest missive comes in an op ed for the Albany Times Union. Before looking in detail at some of his claims, let’s note a glaring omission by the now-retired prelate.

He devotes more than 900 words to defending how he and his colleagues handled child sex crimes. But he doesn’t once mention that he himself is accused, in civil lawsuits, of molesting at least five kids.

https://www.bishop-accountability.org/assign/Hubbard_Howard_J.htm

Now when someone won’t admit that he’s an accused sex offender, it’s kinda hard to believe him when he says he didn’t protect other sex offenders.

So let’s dive into the claims made by Diocese of Albany Bishop Howard Hubbard.

In the 1970s and 1980s, when an allegation of sexual misconduct against a priest was received, the common…

View Cache

If you or someone you know needs resources or support related to sexual violence, contact the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault’s 24/7 hotline at 800-871-7741.

Robert Dupuis was part of a group of five boys who did chores around St. Joseph Catholic Church in Old Town in 1961, when he was 12.

The boys mowed the lawn, shoveled snow and helped out at church banquets and suppers, working under the supervision of the Rev. John J. Curran. But when Dupuis was alone with Curran, the priest sexually abused him, he said. It began with hugs, then progressed to fondling.

Dupuis went public with the abuse he experienced in 2008 when he urged the Augusta City Council to support removing Curran’s name from a downtown bridge, which the Legislature did the following year. Richard Malone, then bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland, acknowledged the priest’s abuse and endorsed removing…

View Cache

A Rotterdam pastor is voluntarily stepping back from public ministry as he is investigated for allegations of child sexual abuse.

“In light of a single allegation of sexual abuse that was first reported in a Child Victims Act case, Father Vincent Ciotoli, pastor of Our Lady Queen of Peace in Schenectady and St. Margaret of Cortona in Rotterdam, has voluntarily withdrawn from public ministry while the independent Diocesan Review Board investigates the claim,” states a Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany release issued Saturday. 

Ciotoli is maintaining his innocence, according to the release. 

Diocesan director of communications Mary DeTurris Poust said the claim was brought via litigation.

Father James Belogi, pastor of St. Madeline Sophie in Guilderland and St. Gabriel the Archangel in Rotterdam, celebrated the 4 p.m. Mass at Our Lady Queen of Peace Saturday in Ciotoli’s absence. After Mass, Belogi read a letter from Bishop Edward Scharfenberger to the congregation addressing…

View Cache

‘Follow Your Conscience’

“Conscience” has a suggestive but also enigmatic etymology. It is “knowledge with”—but with whom? One answer is just: with ourselves. In conscience, we know inwardly, secretly, of wrongs we have done. But another answer is: with others. In conscience, knowledge that we share with others in our moral community, or perhaps with all moral agents, is brought to bear on our actions or prospective actions. A third answer is: with God. In conscience, we know God’s law, or God’s will for us in our circumstances, or, more ominously, God’s judgment of us as sinners. As that answer hints, just what we know in conscience is open to question—a second enigma suggested by its etymology. Maybe what we know in conscience is, more modestly, how an action or prospective action of ours squares with our values. In that case, a bad conscience is merely a personal sanction, rather…

View Cache

Diocese panel will review case of Father Ciotoli, who maintains innocence

ROTTERDAM – A priest has withdrawn from public ministry after being accused in “a single allegation of sexual abuse that was first reported in a Child Victims Act case,” according to a statement Saturday by the Albany Roman Catholic Diocese.

Father Vincent Ciotoli has served at 14 churches and was most recently pastor of two churches in Rotterdam. He voluntarily withdrew in response to the claim and will not publicly officiate at sacraments, wear clerical garb or present himself as a priest, the diocese said. He may return to the ministry if an investigation by the independent Diocesan Review Board exonerates him.

“Out of an abundance of caution and sensitivity to all concerned, Bishop Edward B. Scharfenberger has accepted Father Ciotoli’s decision, and asks for prayers for all involved. Father Ciotoli maintains his innocence,” the diocese stated.

The allegation…

View Cache

‘The most important step is to ensure that the special interlocutor gets truth and justice for residential school survivors’

Nunavut MP Mumilaaq Qaqqaq said the federal government’s recent appointment of a new liaison to work with Indigenous groups on residential school healing is “a major climb down” from the NDP’s call for a criminal probe.

In July, the federal New Democrats asked Ottawa to appoint a special prosecutor to investigate potential crimes committed against Indigenous people at residential schools, and their alleged perpetrators.

The demand came after weeks of revelations about unmarked graves at residential school sites throughout the country.

On Aug. 10, Lametti announced the government’s plan to appoint a “special interlocutor,” whose job it would be to work with Indigenous communities and governments “to identify needed measures and make recommendations relating to federal laws, regulations, policies and practices surrounding unmarked and undocumented graves and burial sites at residential schools.”

…

View Cache

For the first time in history, one in five victims of child sexual abuse victims in the U.S. have a chance to file civil lawsuits to seek justice and publicly expose those who committed or concealed the crimes against them.

“Never before have so many suffering survivors had an opportunity to protect others by naming child molesters and uncovering cover ups of these horrors in court,” said survivor and advocate Joelle Casteix of Orange County, Calif. 

For decades, what advocates call ‘archaic, arbitrary and predator-friendly’ statutes of limitations have prevented such litigation, because victims have been required to step forward usually in their 20s—far sooner than most are capable of, according to most research. 

But in recent years, two dozen state legislatures have reformed or repealed these statutes, opening one- or two-year ‘windows’ during which any victim can sue any person who molested them in childhood and any institution that ignored or hid the abuse, regardless of when the abuse took…

View Cache

‘The public is overwhelmingly opposed’

NORTH AVONDALE — A permit that would have enabled a group of priests, religious brothers and Catholic missionaries to live at a residence in North Avondale was rejected today.

A Cincinnati hearing examiner rejected the conditional-use permit that would have enabled up to 10 members of the Legionaries of Christ to live at 3980 Rose Hill Ave.

“The Applicant failed to meet their burden to demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that the proposed use is compatible with the neighborhood and in the public interest,” wrote David Sturkey, a hearing officer for the city of Cincinnati.

A spokesman for the Legionaries indicated the group would not appeal Sturkey’s decision.

“The Legionaries of Christ are grateful to the City of Cincinnati for considering our petition and we are examining other housing options,” Brother Ryan Carlin wrote in an email to the I-Team.

Dozens of residents…

View Cache

Analysis: there are around 400 women across the island of Ireland ministering in Christian churches as their main life choice

The decline of the Catholic Church in Ireland has included a steep drop in vocations to the priesthood. While Ireland once exported its surplus of priests across the world just 13 men began training for the priesthood here last year. Added to that, the average age of priests is 70. Many parishes are staffed by elderly men who would be enjoying retirement in other professions.

Priestly vocations have often been described as a ‘calling’. Is there something about this secularising island, including the impact of clerical abuse scandals, that makes God’s voice hard to hear? Research points to a counter-narrative, one in which some people believe that God still speaks. Anne Francis’s study of women in ministry in Ireland was simply titled Called to emphasize women’s deep conviction that they were responding to a supernatural…

View Cache

It’s the latest example of a Catholic priest downplaying or denying residential schools. Rev. Marcin Mironiuk apologized after VICE World News reached out for this story.

A Catholic priest in Canada has repeatedly called news of unmarked graves at former residential schools “lies” and said that Indigenous children who were forced to attend residential schools died of “natural causes.”

“We are now also in the unfolding of lies, big lies. There are those mass graves being uncovered at residential schools,” Rev. Marcin Mironiuk told his congregation during a mass on July 18 at Our Lady Queen of Poland Parish, a Polish-language church in Edmonton, Alberta. A YouTube stream from July 18 was posted online, but has since been taken down. 

The Archdiocese of Edmonton confirmed in a statement to VICE World News that it is now aware of Mironiuk’s remarks. “As soon as the Archdiocese was made aware of these…

View Cache

More than 100 people walked about 6 miles from the Onondaga Nation to Columbus Circle in downtown Syracuse to honor victims and survivors of residential schools for Indigenous children.

Many marchers, including Onondaga leaders, wore orange shirts declaring “They Were Children” and “Every Child Matters.” Participants also carried signs, flowers, stuffed animals, and children’s shoes, which they placed around the base of the Columbus Monument across from the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception.

A child-sized wooden coffin, marked with painted handprints and filled with orange flowers, stood in front of the speaker’s platform. Nearby, a sign marked E. Onondaga Street, a reminder that the city of Syracuse and the cathedral stand on the ancestral lands of the Onondaga Nation.

“I have personally been suffering great sorrow for many years, hearing these tales that were told by the people that are survivors. Very sad, heart-wrenching stories,” said Jeanne Shenandoah, a member of the Onondaga Nation,…

View Cache

[VIDEO]

A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for victims of childhood sexual abuse is about to run out. New York’s Child Victims Act expires Friday night.

The Child Victims Act has enabled thousands of adults to sue the people they claim abused them as children, an action that would have otherwise been barred by a statute of limitations.

They are predators who, the victims say, robbed them of their childhood.

More than 1,100 lawsuits have been filed under the Child Victims Act in Erie County alone, with most of them aimed at the Catholic Diocese of Buffalo.

“But in the past, people who were abused as children did not have a way to come forward. They were afraid to tell their parents, they were afraid to report this to anybody,” said Attorney for abuse victims Steve Boyd.

Steve Boyd’s law firm has filed more than 600 lawsuits on behalf of victims of childhood…

View Cache

[VIDEO]

Saturday marks the third anniversary of a landmark grand jury report that found Catholic church leaders in Pennsylvania covered up rampant sexual abuse involving hundreds of priests and at least 1,000 victims.

Thirteen states and Washington D.C. have since made it easier for victims to file civil suits.

But in Pennsylvania, many are still waiting for their day in court.

The emotion felt by Mary McHale, Juliann Bortz and Shaun Dougherty over being sexually abused by priests as children is still raw.

“They murdered something in me. Something died,” Juliann said in a 2018 interview.

Judy Deaven said her son’s accidental overdose can be traced to being raped by a priest when he was 15.

“His soul was just sucked out of him,” Judy said. “It was — it was just taken away from him. And he tried so hard to live with it.”

“I think a…

View Cache

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — For two years, New York temporarily set aside its usual time limit on civil lawsuits in order to allow victims of childhood sexual abuse to sue churches, hospitals, schools, camps, scout groups and other institutions and people they hold responsible for enabling pedophiles or turning a blind eye to wrongdoing.

That window closes Saturday, after more than 9,000 lawsuits were filed, a deluge whose impact may be felt for many years.

Four of the state’s Roman Catholic dioceses have filed for bankruptcy partly as a result of litigation unleashed by the state’s Child Victims Act. Thousands of new allegations against priests, teachers, scout leaders and other authorities have intensified the already harsh light on institutions entrusted with caring for children.

And survivors of abuse have been given an outlet for their trauma and a chance at accountability once thought long lost.

“This has, ironically, been a…

View Cache

The citizens of Ohio must once and for all rip the legislative duct tape off the mouths of countless child sexual abuse victims. As a concerned parent, it just seems that we Ohioans should finally hold our lawmakers to task and insist that they remove “Statutes of Limitations” for prosecution of sexual abuse for three very important reasons.

First, so we can finally allow all sexual abuse victims to have an opportunity for justice by being able to report their abuse on whatever timeline feels safe and right for them.  Secondly, so we can finally allow law enforcement to find and publicly expose the hidden predators that lurk among us in plain sight. Lastly, so we can finally know that our children have better and more updated protection from sexual abuse under Ohio law. 

Two years ago, this very week, a local Catholic priest was removed from St. Ignatius Catholic Church for…

View Cache

A woman who says she was molested by her pastor when she was a teen has filed a federal lawsuit against the central Pennsylvania church where he served.

Lodging of the U.S. Middle District Court complaint comes more than seven years after state police arrested the Rev. Jeffrey Winstead, formerly of the Cedar Crest Independent Baptist Church of Mount Union.

Huntingdon County Court records show Winstead, now 65, was sentenced to 8 to 16 years in prison after pleading guilty in February 2014 to charges of involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with a person under 16 and unlawful contact with a minor.

He is listed on the state’s Megan’s Law website as a sex offender who must register with police for life. Police said Winstead admitted to molesting the girl.

A phone call placed with the church Thursday morning seeking comment on the suit was not immediately…

View Cache

The Brooklyn Diocese is facing new legal action after two priests currently assigned to Queens were accused of sexually abusing young parishioners in suits filed earlier this summer.

Monsignor Ralph J. Maresca and Father Vincent M. Daly were named in separate lawsuits alleging that they engaged in sexual contact with parishioners under their tutelage from the time they were seven and eight years old, respectively.

The suit claims that the Diocese was aware of the incidents, or should have been.

“We call on Bishop DiMarzio to come clean and inform the public about what he knows about these perpetrators,” said attorney Jeff Anderson, whose firm is representing the plaintiffs. “DiMarzio is harboring some of these perpetrators right under the publics’ nose where they still have access to children, and he must remove them from ministry to protect children in the Diocese of Brooklyn.”

A spokesperson for the Diocese told the…

View Cache

More than 9,000 lawsuits in New York were filed after the state temporarily set aside the usual time limits on civil lawsuits for two years to allow victims of childhood sex abuse to sue their abusers, The Associated Press reported Friday.

Victims sued churches, camps, scout groups, schools, hospitals and other institutions. The window for filing a lawsuit closes Saturday. 

“This has, ironically, been a very healing experience for me on a personal level,” Carol DuPre, 74, told the AP. DuPre said she was molested by a priest as a young teen in the 1960s and sued the Roman Catholic diocese in Rochester.

She said the events are “in a storehouse in her mind,” but the abuse still impacted her for decades. However, filing for a lawsuit allowed her to release the hold it still has on her.

“The idea of confronting it, talking about it and dealing with it is internally…

View Cache

The Times Union recently published a story that said I had acknowledged that the Albany Diocese covered up sexual abuse by priests by sending them to nationally accredited treatment facilities rather than reporting the allegations to local law enforcement authorities. The truth, as always, is more complicated.

In the 1970s and 1980s, when an allegation of sexual misconduct against a priest was received, the common practice in the Albany Diocese and elsewhere was to remove the priest from ministry and send him for counseling and treatment. Only when a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist determined the priest was capable of returning to ministry without reoffending did we consider placing him back in ministry. While most priests who were so treated did not reoffend, it did not always work. We as a society now better understand the compulsive, addictive nature of sexual abuse of minors.

Our failure to notify the parish and…

View Cache

PITTSFIELD — This is the story of a girl’s courage and a parishioner’s resolve. The details all came back to Russell G. Powell last weekend, 44 years after his confrontation with a priest in a Pittsfield basement.

It happened on a summer evening in Pittsfield in 1977. Powell called the Rev. Daniel L. Gill, the assistant pastor of St. Charles Parish, and asked him to come to Powell’s house, a few blocks away on Lenox Avenue.

“I told him that something important had come up and we needed to talk,” Powell said.

What happened next helps explain Gill’s abrupt departure from St. Charles Borromeo Church and offers a rare inside account of how members of a Catholic parish reacted to a report of clergy sexual abuse, decades before the issue blew up around the world.

Powell says he was moved to speak out after learning of a Cheshire woman’s 19-year battle…

View Cache

In the worst months of the pandemic in California, as we all stayed locked up tight in our homes listening to the ambulances and praying for things to get better, I found the one thing you could count on was New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. While California Governor Gavin Newsom basically vanished from the scene after being caught attending a party for a lobbyist in a fancy restaurant while much of the state was in lockdown, each day Mr. Cuomo was on television encouraging people, making sensible decisions—in and of itself a precious commodity the last two years—and providing comfort simply by his willingness to be present every day. From the outside he seemed like New York’s Dad, and I think a lot of us wished we had someone like him running our state.

To discover that at the same time he was having his fireside chats he was trying…

View Cache

Our leadership has become aware of information involving credible allegations of serious sexual misconduct and abuse of a female adult from former Greenhouse Movement staff member Joel Girard during his time serving on the Cornerstone Anglican Church staff. We understand that on 7/28/21 a police report was filed regarding this matter. – ACNA, Diocese of the Upper Midwest

Another former catechist in the Anglican Church in North America, Joel Girard, faces allegations of sexual misconduct and abuse of a female victim. The allegations are in the same diocese where at least ten victims have made allegations against another former catechist. In that case, that diocese, the Diocese of the Upper Midwest, the bishop is on leave while allegations of mishandling of that case are investigated.

The latest allegation was announced here by the Diocese of the Upper Midwest. The victim asked the advocacy group, #ACNAtoo to repost that announcement on its…

View Cache

They served at Sacred Heart and the Mission San Juan Bautista churches.

Two former priests that operated in San Benito County are named in the Catholic Diocese of Fresno’s list of clergy credibly accused of sexual misconduct that was released on Aug. 6. 

According to the list, Rev. Fred Crowley was an assistant at Sacred Heart in 1942 and Rev. Edward Haskins served in San Juan Bautista in 1947. The list notes that Haskins was included in the Diocese of Monterey list, which states he was at Mission San Juan Bautista from 1947-50. 

Crowley died in 1972; Haskins died in 1981. 

In a statement released with the list, Bishop Joseph Brennan of the Diocese of Fresno said “some members of the family—priests, deacons, and religious in positions of trust and leadership—have behaved badly. That is putting it mildly. Let’s face it, acts of abuse upon the innocent and vulnerable are truly…

View Cache

La Iglesia echó al cura Agustín Rosa Torino, condenado por tres casos de abuso sexual en Salta

La Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe decretó la pérdida del estado clerical del ahora exsacerdote Agustín Rosa Torino, quien fue condenado el 8 de julio por la justicia salteña a la pena de 12 años de prisión por abuso sexual de tres víctimas.

Un comunicado emitido por el Arzobispado de Salta detalló que Rosa Torino, de 67 años, fue “declarado culpable de los cargos de los que se lo acusaba en el foro eclesiástico”.

“Por ello, el delegado de la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, monseñor José Luis Mollaghan ha decretado la pena máxima de la pérdida del estado clerical“, explica el documento, que detalla que este Decreto “puede ser apelado en los términos establecidos por el derecho”.

El ahora exsacerdote fue condenado el 8 de julio pasado, por los miembros de la…

View Cache

Recibió la pena de 12 años de prisión por abusar de dos exnovicios y una exmonja integrantes de la congregación que él dirigía.

El mes pasado, el sacerdote Agustín Rosa Torino fue condenado a 12 años de prisión efectiva luego de que el Tribunal lo encontrara culpable de abusar sexualmente de dos exnovicios y una exmonja integrantes de la congregación que él dirigía.

En este contexto, en las últimas horas, el Arzobispado de Salta informó que el Delegado de la Congregación para la Doctrina de la Fe, monseñor José Luis Mollaghan, decretó la “pena máxima de la pérdida del estado clerical” para Rosa Torino. De esta manera, el condenado fue expulsado de la iglesia.

Por otro lado, se indicó que en relación al juicio penal contra el presbítero José Carlos Aguilera, se aceptó el traslado “a otra sede la realización de la apelación” por lo que se le ha encargado “al Tribunal Eclesiástico Bonaerense…

View Cache

I returned yesterday from a beautiful weekend retreat with a group of five dear friends who are survivors of clergy sexual abuse. We talked, laughed, cried, prayed, and experienced so much love and healing together. Thank you to all who covered us in prayer over these last few days – We certainly felt God’s grace surrounding us.

As I get back to work today, I am happy to share a follow-up to last week’s post: Survivors’ Voices: What Has Helped Me Heal, with a few more responses from other survivors who have wisdom to share.

If you have experienced sexual abuse in the Catholic Church, I would be honored to include your perspective in this “Survivors’ Voices” series. You can find more information and express your interest here.

What is one thing that you have found helpful in your healing journey?

• It took me a very long time to…

View Cache

Recent news articles about the burial of hundreds of indigenous children neglect to mention a major player in this story: nuns. Why are they missing from this unsettling story? Nuns were also abusers, or accomplices as puppets at the hands of Bishops and priests in carrying out devastating acts.

Often their actions were covert, complicit and complacent.

Two-thirds of Canada’s 139 Indian residential schools were run by the Catholic Church.

The Kamloops Indian Reservation School in Canada, where 215 remains have been discovered is one example. In another recent example, the remains of 751 persons were found in Saskatchewan. (1)

Many of the schools were under the direction of the Oblate Fathers of Mary. The Sisters of St. Ann were the teachers and everyday managers of the schools. They were responsible for the day-to-day operation of these schools, guilty of initiating and carrying out some of the physical, emotional, sexual,…

View Cache

The head of the Jesuits in Ireland has said the order must take full responsibility for the wrongdoing of Fr Joseph Marmion, whom a number of former students say sexually, physically and psychologically abused them in the 1970s when he taught at Belvedere College in Dublin.

In a 50-page report, Joseph Marmion – The Jesuit Response, Fr Leonard Moloney SJ says that while Marmion’s actions inflicted severe trauma on individual pupils, this was “magnified by the failure of the Jesuits to recognise the danger he posed to schoolboys in our care and in later ministries or to understand and respond to your needs as his victims”. He said that the Jesuits did not grasp the destructive effects of his abuse.

The report was compiled following a request from a past pupil who alleged the priest, who died in 2000, was physically violent and sexually abused students prior to his removal from…

View Cache

DOVER, Del. (AP) — Attorneys for the Boy Scouts of America are asking a Delaware judge to approve an $850 million agreement that is the foundation of the group’s plan to emerge from bankruptcy.

The judge was to begin a hearing Thursday on whether to approve the agreement, which involves the national Boy Scouts organization, the roughly 250 local Boy Scout councils, and law firms representing some 70,000 men who claim they were molested as youngsters by Scoutmasters and others.

The Irving, Texas-based Boy Scouts sought bankruptcy protection in February 2020 amid an onslaught of lawsuits by men who said they were sexually abused as children. The filing was part of an attempt to reach a global resolution of abuse claims and create a compensation fund for victims.

The Boy Scouts have proposed contributing up to $250 million in cash and property to a fund for abuse victims. Local councils,…

View Cache

A Catholic boarding school in the Highlands was a “haven for paedophiles”, a report from the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry has said.

It said that sexual abuse by monks at Fort Augustus Abbey, which closed in 1993, was a “desecration of their vows”.

The report came after the inquiry heard evidence of physical, emotional and sexual abuse over many years.

It praised the BBC for bringing the issue into the public domain.

It was a BBC Scotland documentary in 2013 that first raised the issues of abuse perpetrated by Benedictine monks in Scotland.

The inquiry report said a number of the former pupils who provided evidence spoke positively about their involvement with the “Sins of Our Fathers” documentary by Mark Daly.

In June of this year, one former monk at the school – Fr Denis “Chrysostom” Alexander, who is now 85 – admitted two charges of lewd, indecent and libidinous practices…

View Cache

CHILD USA has created a report detailing the filings in New York under the Child Victim’s Act, which closes August 14, 2021. This report provides data on how many victims came forward, the types of institutions suits were brought against, and more.

The Child Victims Act has empowered New York’s victims and educated the public. In the last twenty years, brave individuals and reporters have exposed the worldwide epidemic of child sexual abuse. We now know that 1 in 5 girls and 1 in 13 boys are sexually abused before they turn 18 years-old. Sexual abuse has life-long, traumatic impacts on victims, and it often takes decades for victims to realize or understand they were abused and to take action. Many victims never come forward, and when they do, it has been too late to access justice because of the statutes of limitations. In fact, the average age of disclosure…

View Cache

The Diocese of Fresno has released a list of priests who have faced credible accusations of sexual abuse of a minor.

Listed were several who served in Porterville and Lindsay. All served in this area for a short time and at least nearly 40 years ago.

The Diocese released a list of 37 clergy who it determined had faced credible accusations of sexual abuse of abusing a minor while serving in the Diocese of Fresno. The list included 37 priests, deacons or members of religious orders in which 24 were incardinated priests for the Diocese of Fresno, seven were extern priests and six were members from a religions order.

In addition the diocese released 29 clergy and members of religious orders with no allegations while they served in the Diocese of Fresno but had allegations against them in other dioceses. No one on the list is still serving in the…

View Cache

Catholic Diocese of Fresno releases its list of 37 priests accused of molesting minors in the Valley, 29 others who allegedly molested children elsewhere

FRESNO – For the first time ever, the Catholic Church in Fresno revealed serious allegations of priests molesting minors going back for a century.

On Aug. 6, the Catholic Diocese of Fresno released a list of more than 60 clergy with ties to the Valley “credibly accused” of sexual abuse involving a minor. In all of these cases, the victim was a minor at the time of the abuse, the alleged perpetrator was or is a bishop, priest, deacon, or religious brother or religious sister at the time of the alleged sexual abuse, and the allegations have been determined to be “more likely than not to have occurred.” No one on the list is currently serving in the Diocese of Fresno.

Most Rev. Joseph V. Brennan,…

View Cache

When institutions like the Catholic Church try to reckon with histories of systemic abuse, survivors often relate how the difficult but necessary process of unearthing the truth is deeply retraumatizing for them. They must relive horrors no one should endure. Their most vulnerable personal history is exposed. Character, motives, credibility are questioned — all of this not because they’ve done something, but because a powerful person did something to them when they were powerless.

Truly reckoning with the clergy sexual abuse scandal demands that dioceses acknowledge and repair the grievous harm done over the years to the communities they serve. They also have a moral duty to conduct this process in a way that minimizes how much abuse victims are retraumatized for having the bravery to share their painful experiences. A Cheshire woman’s heartrending story shows that the Springfield Diocese has utterly failed to live up to that…

View Cache

Organizations are turning to bankruptcy protection to manage liabilities from mass torts arising from allegations of sexual misconduct involving children. Lowenstein Sandler attorneys assert that insurers increasingly are inserting intrusive questions in proof of claim forms to deter claimants in these cases.

In recent years, a growing number of entities, such as the Boy Scouts of America and Catholic dioceses, have sought bankruptcy protection to address liabilities arising from mass torts, the most egregious of which relate to sexual misconduct involving children. Debtors facing these claims have used the bankruptcy system to bring all the key stakeholders to the table in order to reach a global resolution.

Insurers play a critical role in these cases, as debtors look to insurance companies to fulfill their obligations and contribute meaningful amounts to survivor trusts. Insurers, however, have used (or misused) the bankruptcy system to avoid or substantially…

View Cache

Inquiry chairwoman Lady Smith found children suffered sexual and emotional abuse and noted some monks were “serial sexual predators”.

Lady Smith examined practices at both the former Fort Augusus Abbey School and Carlekemp Priory School, North Berwick, both run by the Fort Augustus order.

Witnesses gave evidence about children having been abused at both.

The inquiry also examined the systems, policies, and procedures in place, how these were applied, and whether systemic failures enabled abuse to happen.

Lady Smith said: “Children were sexually abused at both schools. A number of monks were serial sexual predators and, because of the movement of monks between Fort Augustus and Carlekemp, they were able to target victims at both schools.

“Children were cruelly beaten by sadistic monks at both schools, and some beatings had sexual overtones. Children were humiliated and punished inappropriately and excessively.

View Cache

Cape Town – Reverend June Dolley-Major and her alleged rapist were cross-examined on Tuesday at the Anglican Church Diocese of Cape Town Tribunal about her alleged rape nearly 20 years ago.

Dolley-Major recalled moments leading up to and after the incident at the Grahamstown Seminary 19 years ago by an Anglican priest during a three-day visit.

The tribunal reconvened yesterday for Day 5 of the tribunal hearing, which commenced on June 28.

Advocate for the accused Lynette Myburgh asked Dolley-Major why she had not pushed the accused off, due to his smaller size.

“I was trying to push him off and I eventually pushed him off before he ejaculated inside of me,” said Dolley-Major.

Myburgh questioned why Dolley-Major did not call out for help while staying at the home of a priest and his wife. Dolley-Major said she was unable to utter words and had gone completely numb at the…

View Cache

Rev. Eric Swearingen, a Tulare County native, rose through the church’s hierarchy to lead Visalia’s Catholics despite an allegation of sexual abuse.

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Fresno on Friday posted a list of priests who it says have faced “a credible accusation of sexual abuse.”

The list included Rev. Eric Swearingen, a Tulare County native who rose through the church’s hierarchy to lead Visalia’s Catholics despite an allegation of sexual abuse. He died in 2020 after a long illness. 

The list also includes 65 other names of San Joaquin Valley clergy who have been accused of sexual misconduct against minors and young adults. The other Tulare County area priests were credibly accused of sexual misconduct stretching back to before World War II. All have since died. 

In a statement posted by Bishop Joseph Brennan on the Diocese of Fresno’s website, the Catholic leader said the church family “is far from perfect” and “can…

View Cache

REVEREND June Major told a tribunal set up by the Anglican church to hear sexual assault allegations against one of its priests that on the night of the alleged rape, she felt that something in her died.

The tribunal which started last week came a few days before the Western Cape High Court was scheduled to finalise the application by the alleged perpetrator to interdict the Major from publicly naming him.

However, his name was made public in the tribunal, held under the church’s canon law.

The accused faces charges including sexual assault, sexual harassment, sexual immorality and violation of the Church’s Constitution.

He pleaded not guilty to all the charges.

Major told the tribunal that in 2002 she, the accused whom she regarded as a family friend and another priest, Mark Andrews drove to Grahamstown.

The trip was to find a school for her son as she was to…

View Cache

Voluntary lifelong detention in church-run houses could be the best way of dealing with priest abusers, according to Fr Hans Zollner SJ, president of the Centre for Child Protection (CCP) at the Gregorian University.

It was all-important to control and guide sex abusers and “to define exactly what they may and may not do, whom they may and may not meet and how they use the internet”, Zollner explained in an interview with ORF religion, the religious affairs programme of the Austrian state broadcasting corporation on 31 July.

The Church should therefore proffer such houses to abuser priests on a comprehensive basis. “This kind of establishment should be particularly applicable in western, highly specialised societies. In other parts of the world, where communal responsibility is more paramount, parish or spiritual communities could possibly find a way of controlling priest abusers and making it impossible for them to abuse again,” Zollner said. 

The…

View Cache

Warning: This story contains explicit details of childhood sexual assault that may be disturbing to some. Discretion is advised.

GREEN BAY – Four months into an independent investigation launched by the state’s top attorney, two cases of alleged clergy abuse have been reported and turned over to the Brown County district attorney’s office. 

The two cases are among more than 100 reports statewide alleging abuse by faith leaders made possible by Attorney General Josh Kaul’s independent review, which began in April. 

One of the Brown County cases is “current,” said Holli Fisher, program manager of the Sexual Assault Center of Family Services of Northeast Wisconsin, who was unable to disclose further details. The other one was from decades ago. 

Fisher said one of the cases already is being investigated by the Brown County DA’s office. District Attorney David Lasee said both cases are potentially prosecutable in Brown County. 

“I’ve been encouraged by the number of people…

View Cache

SUMMARY

• St. Paul’s Indian Residential School operated between 1899 to 1958, was run by the Roman Catholic Church
• No details are available about the announcement, it comes amid confirmation of unmarked graves at residential schools

NORTH VANCOUVER (NEWS 1130) — The Squamish Nation will be making an announcement Tuesday morning at the site of a former residential school in North Vancouver.

The chiefs of the Musqueam and Tsleil-Waututh First Nations, as well as a representative from the Archdiocese of Vancouver, will join members of the Squamish Nation at St. Thomas Aquinas Regional Secondary School. The Keith Road school is the site of a memorial to children who were taken from their families to the St. Paul’s Indian Residential School, which operated between 1899 to 1958. The Roman Catholic School was operated by the federal government and the Order of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate.

“In 1931, the local Indian Agent…

View Cache

The state Supreme Court ruled in July that an accuser’s claim was too late under the state’s statute of limitations.

With each passing day, Pennsylvania kids become more at risk of abuse while just across the state line, kids in New Jersey and New York are becoming dramatically safer. This may sound like hyperbole, but it’s not. A recent state Supreme Court ruling illustrates the problem and shows why.

In July, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court threw out a lawsuit from a woman seeking to recover damages from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown for allegedly facilitating sexual abuse she said she experienced at the hands of a priest in the late 1970s. The court’s ruling that her claim was too late under the state’s statute of limitations illustrates the problem with Pennsylvania law.

Kids are safest, of course, when child molesters are…

View Cache

• Scale of church’s assets revealed in string of investigations
• Discovery of unmarked graves prompts fresh reparations calls

From the 19th century until the 1990s, more than 150,000 Indigenous children were obliged to attend state-funded schools in a campaign to forcibly assimilate them into Canadian society. More than half were run by the Catholic church. Disease and hunger were rife at the schools, and survivors have described physical and sexual abuse, often at the hands of priests and Catholic laypeople.

In 2006, the landmark Indian Residential School Settlement Agreement was approved by all parties – including survivors, the federal government and religious institutions.

A recent report by the Independent Assessment Process found that nearly C$3bn had been paid out by the federal government as part of settlement, including direct compensation to survivors and funding for healing programs.

The Anglican, United and Presbyterian churches have all fully paid the agreed upon amount.

The…

View Cache

With the deadline for the New York’s Child Victims Act coming up Friday, one local man has said the ability to file a lawsuit has changed his life for the better.

Brian Delafranier filed his lawsuit against the Catholic Diocese of Rochester two years ago claiming he was sexually abused for over a year by his parish priest, Reverend Robert Gaudio.

Delafranier even inspired another person struggling with the abuse from the same priest to step forward and file a claim before the deadline.

Delafranier’s attorney, Leander James, urges anyone who wants to file a claim to come forward before the deadline is up. He also states that the deadlines are not helpful for some victims who aren’t ready yet.

James is representing 120 clients in the city of Rochester who have filed claims under the Child Victims Act.

639 people have filed within the 9 counties that make up the…

View Cache

SUMMARY

• An indigenous-led investigation into the site of a former residential school in North Vancouver has been launched
• First Nations say at least 12 children died while attending St. Paul’s residential school
• Investigation will include formal interviews with survivors

Emotional support or assistance for those who are affected by the residential school system can be found at Indian Residential School Survivors Society toll-free 1 (800) 721-0066 or 24-hr Crisis Line 1 (866) 925-4419.

NORTH VANCOUVER (NEWS 1130) – Three B.C. First Nations are coming together to launch an investigation into the disappearance of several children at the site of a former residential school in North Vancouver.

The Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Úxwumixw (Squamish Nation), as well as the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) and səl̓ilw̓ətaʔɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations, say they have begun the initiative at the former St. Paul’s residential school to find answers about children who went there, but never made it home. They say over 2,000…

View Cache

The Archdiocese of Santa Fe is set to auction off hundreds of plots of land all over the area. The Catholic church is being forced to liquidate its properties, as part of a bankruptcy settlement following a run of child sex abuse lawsuits. The auction is broken up into different phases. This first phase includes about 138 pieces of land in Bernalillo, Sandoval and Valencia counties. 

“Most of these are vacant parcels of land, whether they are a recorded lot in a subdivision or some of these lots I’ll be honest with you are in locations where there are no existing infrastructure presently,” explains Louis B. Fisher III, the National Director of SVN Auction Services, LLC. “But they are plotted lots and there are some that you know are sizable acreage.”

Some will be sold individually — while others will be packaged into several…

View Cache

Next year will mark the 50th anniversary of a then-secret crime: Fr. Gilbert Gauthe molested a boy in Louisiana in 1972.

Over a decade later, that crime — and dozens of others Gauthe committed — became national news. (Thanks, in part, to NCR). Thus began an unprecedented and at times overwhelming deluge of abuse and cover up reports which eventually led to over 7,000 U.S. priests being publicly accused of sexually violating children.

If you’re a Catholic, chances are you’re tired of this seemingly endless stream of allegations of clerical corruption (though the flow of abuse reports has slowed in recent years). And at least a few times over the past two decades, you have likely worried, “I wonder if kids in my parish are safe?”

I hope you’ve also asked yourself, several times, “What might I do to help prevent abuse in the church?”

Well, if…

View Cache

The window to file lawsuits under New York State’s Child Victims Act will come to a close later this month, but until a few weeks ago, David Ferrick didn’t know that the law enabling victims of sexual assault to sue even existed.

Ferrick, 52, learned about it last month in Fresno, California — thousands of miles away from his childhood home in Brooklyn, where he attended St. Cecilia’s Roman Catholic Church in Greenpoint and where he says in a newly filed lawsuit that a priest there molested him when he was just a 10-year-old altar boy.

The priest, Father Patrick Sexton, was already the subject of another victim’s accusations when Ferrick was contacted by a private eye working for the law firm handling those claims.

“I was shocked,” Ferrick said of the moment he learned he could still seek justice. “I thought the statute of limitations had come to a…

View Cache

Argentine Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta is set to stand trial this October on charges of sexual abuse against two unnamed former seminarians, aggrevated by his status as a religious minister. 

The former executive head of the Argentine bishops’ conference and bishop of the Diocese of Oran, Zanchetta has spent the last several years living in Rome, working in a Vatican post created for him by the pope. 

Because Zanchetta is known to be a close friend of Pope Francis, his trial, set to begin October 12, will likely capture media attention across Argentina as well from the Vatican. So, to catch you up on the case, here’s what we know so far:

Who is Bishop Zanchetta?

Born in 1964, Zanchetta was ordained a priest for the Diocese of Quilmes in 1991. He later served as executive undersecretary of the Argentine bishops’ conference, and in that role he worked closely with then-Cardinal…

View Cache

Former cardinal Theodore McCarrick was charged in Massachusetts Wednesday with three counts of indecent assault and battery on a person over 14. McCarrick, 91, is summoned to appear in a Massachusetts courtroom Aug. 26. 

The story was first reported Thursday by the Boston Globe.

Here’s what you need to know:

What is McCarrick alleged to have done?

According to court filings obtained by the Boston Globe, McCarrick is alleged to have sexually molested a 16-year-old-boy during a 1974 wedding reception at Wellesley College in Wellesley, Massachusetts.

The alleged molestation was not reported as a singular occurrence. Rather, the alleged victim, who has not been named, says McCarrick was a family friend, and that McCarrick had molested him frequently, on family trips to several states. The alleged abuse in Massachusetts reportedly took place at the victim’s brother’s wedding reception.

The alleged victim claims that McCarrick molested him subsequently at hotels in…

View Cache

FRESNO, Calif. (KFSN) — The Fresno Catholic Diocese has released a list of those who have been credibly accused of sexual abuse of minors and young people in the Diocese of Fresno.

It’s something the Diocese has promised to do for several years.

There are 66 names on the list with details on all of the places the individual worked within the Diocese of Fresno.

Victim advocates say they are grateful the list was released, but say it’s not as comprehensive as it should be and it took far too long for it to be completed.

“What the list and the release of it. it does is give us a little peak into the dark closet, the dark corner,” said Attorney Jeff Anderson ,who represents abuse victims.

According to the Fresno Catholic Diocese website, the list includes those who were accused while working within the Diocese…

View Cache

Fr. Anthony Atter facing multiple allegations from single complainant

A provincial court judge in Humboldt, Sask., will hear the evidence today against a local Catholic priest charged with sexual assault.

The preliminary hearing will determine whether Father Anthony Atter will stand trial on the allegations. The 45-year-old faces charges of sexual assault, sexual exploitation and sexual interference.

The assaults allegedly took place from September to November 2020 and involved one complainant.

“I can tell you that Father Atter is is very interested in being able to testify and be able to give his version of the events,” said Atter’s lawyer, Brian Pfefferle.

“He feels very confident that when the light gets shone on this unfortunate allegation, that he will be exonerated because he completely denies any thing other than completely appropriate behaviour with anyone he has contact with in that community.” 

Sexual interference is a charge laid when the alleged victim…

View Cache

Rampant child sex abuse and cover-up. The crusades. The Inquisitions. Convincing children they will go to hell or purgatory if they don’t follow instructions. Teaching that condoms are worse than AIDS. Castrating boys for choir singing. The Index of Forbidden Books. The pope’s ridiculous hat. The Catholic Church has a rich history (literally — the Vatican has hoarded vast wealth since its inception) of giving its adherents reasons to quit. For those hanging on, the past few days have delivered yet another.

It turns out that 10 individuals within the church, including a cardinal, have allegedly (https:/ www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-57981508) defrauded the Vatican in several ways. In one scheme, almost half a billion dollars worth of church assets, largely consisting of worshippers’ tithes and donations, were reportedly used to buy property that was supposed to be turned into luxury apartments in an affiuent part of London. In another double-dealing project, the cardinal…

View Cache

‘On Aug. 14, the New York Child Victims Act’s two-year civil sexual abuse statute of limitations “window” will close, and older victims whose claims had previously been time-barred will be foreclosed from seeking justice.’

The opportunity to hold child sexual abuse perpetrators—and the institutions that enabled them—accountable is about to expire for many suffering survivors who were assaulted in New York. On Aug. 14, the New York Child Victims Act’s two-year civil sexual abuse statute of limitations “window” will close, and older victims whose claims had previously been time-barred will be foreclosed from seeking justice. This legislation also extends the statute of limitations to age 55 for child sex abuse survivors whose claims have not previously been time-barred. We urge our leaders to take immediate action to reform the current law to ensure that victims, no matter their age, have continuing access to the courts.   

Statute of limitations reform must acknowledge…

View Cache

President of the Council of the Bishops’ Conferences of Europe looked into allegations that Stanislaw Dziwisz, during his term as archbishop of Krakow, covered up cases of clergy sex abuse

The president of the Council of the Bishops’ Conferences of Europe has spent ten days in Poland investigating John Paul II’s former secretary over alleged covering up cases of clergy sex abuse of minors.

The aim was to verify signals, also made in public, of negligence by Cardinal Stanislaw Dziwisz during his term as the archbishop of Krakow,” the Vatican nunciature in Poland said in a statement.

Retired Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco visited Poland June 17-26 where he held a number of meetings and reviewed documents regarding allegations against Cardinal Stanislaw Dziwisz, the late Polish pope’s private secretary for nearly 40 years.

Cardinal Dziwisz, 82, who has long been respected in his homeland for his proximity to the late pope, was…

View Cache

A Minneapolis-area school run by the Christian group People of Praise mishandled a student’s allegation of sexual abuse against a teacher, the school board president acknowledged in a recent email to teachers and parents.

People of Praise began investigating reports of abuse within the close-knit community last year. The Aug. 6 email also acknowledged an ongoing investigation into similar reports involving the same teacher.

Katie Logan told The Washington Post she was molested by Dave Beskar two weeks after her graduation from Trinity School at River Ridge in 2001, when she was 17.She also told The Post about her report to police in December 2020.

At the time of the alleged incident, Beskar was a 35-year-old teacher and girls’ basketball coach who lived in a People of Praise home for celibate men. Logan reported the alleged incident to a school official in 2006, but Beskar remained on staff until 2011, when…

View Cache

It began on the afternoon of her first Communion, the day Sheri A. Biasin, a reedy child of 7 or 8, dressed in the shiny white dress her grandmother made.

That was the day one of the most trusted people in Biasin’s life, the family’s priest, the Rev. Daniel L. Gill, followed her into a bathroom at her house in West Stockbridge, declared she was “the chosen one,” and put his tongue in her mouth.

Over the next four years, until she was able, at age 12, to fend him off, Biasin says, Gill groped and fondled her sexually at family picnics, sleepovers and beach outings in Pittsfield, West Stockbridge, Sandisfield and in the Franklin County town of Ashfield. Biasin says she grew up feeling different, alone, unlovable, dirty. She cried into her pillow and worried about the next weekend outing with the handsy priest so adored by her parents.

…

View Cache

(RNS) — When the news broke on Thursday (July 29) that the former cardinal Theodore McCarrick had been criminally charged with sexual abuse of a minor, many Catholics likely felt justice was one step closer to being served. Others may have wondered anew how the former archbishop of Washington had been allowed to abuse seminarians and minors for decades.

But a new survey shows that perhaps the likeliest response to the McCarrick news among Catholics was: Who?

McCarrick, who was laicized in 2019, is the highest ranking individual in the Catholic Church to be charged in the abuse crisis. His alleged abuse spanned decades and has received national attention since it became public in the summer of 2018. But a recent survey commissioned by America Media and conducted by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate found that only 38% of Catholics surveyed had heard of McCarrick.

Even when respondents…

View Cache

JACKSON, Mich. — A former Catholic school teacher will spend 12 to 30 years in prison for sexually abusing children during his tenure at a southern Michigan school in the 1970s.

Joseph Comperchio, 67, was sentenced Wednesday in Jackson County Circuit Court, Attorney General Dana Nessel’s office announced.

He also must register as a sex offender.

Comperchio pleaded guilty in June to three counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct and one count of first-degree criminal sexual conduct.

Nessel’s office charged Comperchio in September with six counts of criminal sexual conduct for sexually abusing two children and added five new counts in October related to two other individuals.

At the time of his arraignment, Comperchio was living in Fort Myers, Florida, but the charges stem from his work as a drama and music teacher at St. John Catholic School in Jackson, where he taught between 1974-77.

The victims said the assaults…

View Cache

Gov. Andrew Cuomo sexually harassed 11 women in his workplace through nonconsensual touching and inappropriate comments, according to a report published by the office of New York Attorney General Letitia James after an extensive investigation into harassment accusations.

During the monthlong investigation, 179 witnesses were interviewed and 74,000 pieces of evidence were reviewed. The report details the women’s testimonies of suggestive remarks made by the governor and his unwanted hugging, kissing and groping.

As a civil probe rather than a criminal trial, the investigation did not find Cuomo guilty by law and cannot mandate a punishment. Allies within his own political party, however, are calling for Cuomo’s resignation, including President Joe Biden, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and both U.S. senators for New York.

When the accusations were first made, Cuomo asked New Yorkers not to unfairly judge him until after an official investigation. It is now after an official investigation, but Cuomo…

View Cache

GREENVILLE, S.C. (AP) — A Catholic priest in South Carolina has been placed on leave after he was sued by a woman who said the pastor manipulated her into a sexual relationship.

Father Wilbroad Mwape was removed at least temporarily as the pastor at St. Anthony of Padua Catholic Church in Greenville by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston, The Greenville News reported.

Diocese spokesperson Maria Aselage said the church is reviewing the lawsuit and will respond later.

Both Mwape and the diocese are named in the lawsuit, filed in Orangeburg County.

Before coming to Greenville in 2020, Mwape was pastor at Holy Trinity Church in Orangeburg. It was there that the woman said Mwape started grooming her into a sexual relationship, growing her knowledge in the Catholic faith while also using her confessions about trouble in her marriage to prey on her vulnerabilities, according to…

View Cache

Researchers weigh in on apologies from premier, cabinet minister, archbishop after controversial comments

Manitobans have heard a number of apologies from public officials in recent weeks.

On Tuesday, Premier Brian Pallister said he felt sorry for the misunderstanding caused by his comments on July 7 — after protesters toppled statues of Queen Victoria and Queen Elizabeth at the legislature — that settlers in Canada “didn’t come here to destroy anything, they came here to build.”               

On the same day as Pallister’s apology, newly appointed Indigenous Reconciliation Minister Alan Lagimodiere came out and labelled residential schools a tool of genocide, after initially defending the people who ran them.

And the archbishop of St. Boniface apologized on behalf of the Catholic Church after a priest accused residential school survivors of lying about abuse.

The public response to recent apologies from Manitoba political and religious figures has varied. Judging the value of an apology…

View Cache

Readers discuss the papacy of Francis and the internal politics of liberals versus traditionalists.

To the Editor:

Re “The Ungovernable Catholic Church,” by Ross Douthat (column, July 29):

On reading the column, I was struck that the church is well positioned to respond to the challenges facing modern Catholicism. But does it have the courage to strike the balance needed to make the necessary modifications?

Pope Francis showed great promise early on, and managing in conjunction with the traditional Vatican machine has controversy at its very core. But he is the man at the helm.

A recent declaration on the “sinfulness” of gay Catholics and the efforts to weaponize the Holy Eucharist only make the schism wider.

The church is a global institution and as such must flex its muscles or it will falter or, worse, fail to exist.

Read the room. Like it or not, the young people…

View Cache

Trigger warning: nonconsensual sexual activity and abuse of minors

Nearly nine months after the Vatican released a report detailing the abuse of power and authority and abuse of minors and priests by ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, Fordham College ’54, the former cardinal has now been charged with the sexual assault of a minor in 1974. 

McCarrick was charged in a Massachusetts court on three counts of indecent assault and battery on a person over 14, according to documents filed in the Dedham, Massachusetts, District Court. 

The charges were first reported by The Boston Globe on Thursday, July 29.

McCarrick is the highest-ranking Roman Catholic official in the U.S. to be criminally charged with a sexual crime against a minor, according to Mitchell Garabedian, the lawyer for the man alleging the abuse. Garabedian is a well-known lawyer representing church sexual abuse victims.

Although the incident occurred nearly 50 years ago, because McCarrick was not…

View Cache

After surgery and a series of missteps, Francis must steel himself for a case that will shed light on allegations of embezzlement, extortion and predatory property deals at the highest levels of the church

Eight years after he was handed the job as head of the Catholic Church with a mandate to clean up the Vatican’s sleazy finances, Pope Francis’s final report card will be written this autumn in a makeshift courtroom hastily set up inside the Vatican’s museum.

Following years of stuttering financial reforms, the biggest criminal trial in the Vatican’s recent history is under way, tackling allegations of extortion and embezzlement, as well as tales of prostitutes, spies and millions of euros in donations from the faithful frittered away on a luxury London property. In their 487-page indictment, prosecutors denounced the ten defendants including prelates and bankers as “actors in a rotten, predatory and lucrative system” that allegedly…

View Cache

It was a lovely Saturday evening inside Our Lady of Mount Virgin Catholic Church. Light filtered through arched stained glass windows imprinted with dedications to Italian Americans who populated the Mount Baker church after its founding in 1911. Some were open to let in a breeze for the 5 o’clock Mass, normally in Vietnamese for one of several groups of immigrants the church has since attracted.

An English-speaking guest, Auxiliary Bishop Daniel Mueggenborg, helped conduct Mass on this July night — the prelude to a fateful parish meeting. “Tonight is going to be a difficult evening,” Mueggenborg told the crowd of 150 or so. “There is no way around it.”

The bishop, and a handful of others from the Seattle Archdiocese, came to tell parishioners their church would close.

Two other Seattle churches, St. Mary’s in the Central District andSt. Patrick in North Capitol Hill, are also slated to do…

View Cache

A South Carolina churchgoer said a Catholic priest used his position of power to groom her for sex.

The priest knew the woman was having marital problems and “exploited this knowledge” when he engaged in “sexual behavior” in 2020 and 2021, according to a lawsuit the churchgoer filed Wednesday.

Now, the priest is on administrative leave as leadership shifts in his Greenville congregation, according to Maria Aselage, a Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston spokesperson.

“We have received a copy of the lawsuit and are currently reviewing it,” Aselage said in a written statement.“We will respond to the pleading in due time.”

A Facebook user believed to be the priest didn’t immediately respond to McClatchy News’ request for comment Friday.

The woman — who McClatchy News isn’t identifying due to the sensitive nature of the allegations — in her lawsuit said she is a devout Catholic who attended churches in Greenville…

View Cache

Argentine Catholic Bishop Gustavo Zanchetta will go on trial on sexual abuse charges in October.

The public prosecutor’s office of the Argentine province of Salta announced on Aug. 6 that the trial would take place on Oct. 12-15.

Zanchetta was given a Vatican post by Pope Francis after he resigned as bishop of Orán, northwest Argentina, in 2017.

The 57-year-old bishop is charged with simple sexual abuse, aggravated by being committed by an officially recognized minister of religion, against two men identified only by their initials, G.G.F.L. and C.M.

Zanchetta has denied the allegations.

“The former bishop [of Orán] was summoned under penalty of law and at least 39 witnesses are expected to testify during the hearing,” the public prosecutor’s office said.

Pope Francis named Zanchetta as bishop of Orán on July 23, 2013, in one of his first episcopal appointments in his homeland of Argentina.

After resigning as the head…

View Cache

FRESNO, Calif. (KFSN) — The Diocese of Fresno has finished a lengthy investigation reviewing claims of sexual assault involving clergy members within the Diocese.

The investigation began in May of 2019, reviewing more than 2,800 files to identify any priest, deacon, or other member of the church facing allegations of sexual abuse involving a minor within the Diocese.

The files listed accusations that went back as early as the 1900s to the present.

Diocese officials looked into the allegations and determined credible allegations against 37 priests, deacons, or members of a religious order of which 24 are incardinated priests for the Diocese of Fresno, 7 extern priests, and 6 members from a religious order

A separate list of 29 clerics and members of religious orders are also named who have no allegations of sexual abuse of a minor while serving in the Diocese of Fresno, but were determined to have allegations against them…

View Cache

FRESNO, Calif. (KGET) — Former Bakersfield priest Craig Harrison is on a list of clergy credibly accused of sexual abuse of a minor released Friday by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Fresno, the culmination of a two-year review of 2,800 clergy files.

Defense lawyer Kyle J. Humphrey, one of several attorneys who have spoken on Harrison’s behalf since allegations first surfaced in 2019, said from their standpoint the ex-priest’s inclusion was inevitable.

“They’ve never done a legitimate investigation,” Humphrey said of diocesan officials. “They’ve never interviewed (Harrison), allowed us to present witnesses or cross-examine accusers.”

The list contains information about 37 priests, deacons or members of a religious order credibly accused while serving in the Diocese of Fresno, officials said in a news release.

An additional 27 clerics and members of religious order are named who had no allegations brought against them while in the Fresno diocese but were credibly…

View Cache

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Fresno posted a list of priests who it says have faced “a credible accusation of sexual abuse” to its website Friday.

The lists includes more than 60 names of clergy who have been accused of sexual misconduct against minors and young adults.

The revelations come more than two years after the Fresno Diocese had vowed to release such a list. In early 2019, the diocese said it would release a list after reviewing records dating to 1922 — similar to what other dioceses did.

The Diocese of Fresno is one of the last in California to release a list of credibly accused priests to the public.

Almost all dioceses in the state released their lists in 2018 and 2019. Advocates in 2020 told The Bee that the Diocese of Fresno was stalling the release…

View Cache

GREENVILLE — A former parishioner has accused the pastor of St. Anthony of Padua Catholic Church in West Greenville of using his position to manipulate her into a sexual relationship, according to a lawsuit filed this week.

Following the allegations, the Diocese of Charleston placed Fr. Wilbroad Mwape on leave, according to a statement from the Support Network for those Abused by Priests (SNAP), which has expressed support for the plaintiff. 

The lawsuit states that Mwape met the plaintiff while he was a priest at Holy Trinity in Orangeburg, where he served for about five years, and where she was a member. Mwape provided the plaintiff with counseling during that time, the complaint said.

Mwape, who the complaint states was aware of the plaintiff’s marital issues through his position as her priest, was transferred to St. Anthony’s in the summer of 2020. According to the lawsuit, he invited the former…

View Cache

A survivor of abuse in a faith-based institution is appalled at what she calls the Catholic church’s mishandling of victims’ stories of abuse.

Frances Tagaloa has called out the Catholic church to change their processes when dealing with survivors, following the recent Abuse in Care Royal Commission of Inquiry Pacific investigation hearing.

This comes after a couple of Pacific survivors gave their testimony at the recent Abuse in Care Royal Commission of Inquiry Pacific investigation hearing in South Auckland, including from a spokesperson named Ms CU.

Tagaloa said as a survivor she sought to emphasise how appalled she was at the Catholic church’s attempts to silence Ms CU, through a lack of communication, support and information along with protecting the perpetrator and not providing adequate monitoring or safeguarding over Fr Sosefo Sateki Raas whose conduct was under the spotlight at the inquiry.

“It illustrates a pattern that is not unique,”…

View Cache

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican is investigating about a dozen founders of congregations of consecrated or religious life, and the most common allegations involve abuse of power or conscience, financial corruption or problems associated with “affectivity,” said a top official.

Spanish Archbishop José Rodríguez Carballo, secretary of the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, spoke about his office’s work overseeing religious congregations in an interview July 30 with “Vida Nueva,” a Spanish weekly magazine on religion.

He said the church has very “clear and precise criteria” when it comes to discerning the authenticity of a religious charism when determining whether to approve a new congregation or religious order.

Among these criteria, he underlined: “communion with the church; the presence of spiritual fruits; the social dimension of evangelization; high regard for other forms of consecrated life in the church; and the profession of the Catholic faith,” referring to the doctrinal congregation’s 2016 letter “Iuvenescit Ecclesia” to…

View Cache

At the height of his career, former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick was one of the most influential leaders of the Catholic Church in the U.S., heading the Archdiocese of Washington, D.C. Last week, he became the first U.S. Cardinal to be criminally charged with a sexual crime against a minor, making the 91-year-old the highest-ranking Catholic Church official in the country to face criminal charges for clergy sexual abuse.

The fact that McCarrick sexually molested adults and children was already known: A Vatican investigation confirmed the abuse. He’d been defrocked in 2019.

Mitchell Garabedian has settled more than 2,000 clergy sex abuse cases over the past 20-plus years and is the lawyer representing an abuse survivor in a current civil case against McCarrick.

“Cardinal McCarrick was one of the most powerful and influential cardinals in the world. He hobnobbed with presidents: George W. Bush, President Ford, President Carter, President Clinton,” Garabedian…

View Cache

An online auction will start Sept. 21 to sell hundreds of “nonessential” properties belonging to the Archdiocese of Santa Fe.

A Florida-based executive with the auction company involved said Friday the auction — aimed to raise money to help settle a bankruptcy case — will be divided into two sales, one ending Sept. 28 and the second starting sometime in November.

The archdiocese originally proposed offering 732 properties in Northern New Mexico, but Louis B. Fisher III said there will be fewer in the two batches. Fisher, national director of SVN Auction Services, headquartered in Florida and Louisiana, said there will be about 140 in the first sale and about 500 in the second.

The properties tend to be small, and many were donated by parishioners to the archdiocese. Fisher said some of the parcels will be “challenging, quite honestly,” to sell. But some are “desirable.”

“I’m not going to…

View Cache

[Via National Catholic Register]

A former New York seminary professor pleaded guilty this week to charges of stalking a local news reporter, after a criminal complaint accused him of making a death threat and other threats over the phone. 

Paul Lubienecki, a former adjunct professor at the now-closed Christ the King Seminary in East Aurora, New York, pleaded guilty on Tuesday to stalking local investigative reporter Charlie Specht with the outlet WKBW. The charge carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Lubienecki will face sentencing on Nov. 9 at 12:30 p.m.

On six separate occasions, Lubienecki left harassing voicemails for Specht during the reporter’s investigation into allegations of clerical sex abuse in the Buffalo diocese and at Christ the King seminary.

“I know where you live in [TOWN],” the Feb. 11, 2020 complaint accused Paul Lubienecki of telling Specht in a voicemail. “I‘m going to…

View Cache

The pastor of a Catholic church in Greenville has been placed on administrative leave after he was accused of using his position of authority to have a secret sexual relationship with one of his parishioners, according to a lawsuit filed in Orangeburg County this week.

Father Wilbroad Mwape was placed on temporary administrative leave and the local dean, Father Jay Scott Newman, will be the parish administrator in his absence, Maria Aselage, spokesperson for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston, told The Greenville News in a statement Wednesday.

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit.

“This case stems from the Catholic Church’s continued failure to police their priests,” the lawsuit states in its opening page.

The diocese is reviewing the lawsuit and will respond in due time, Aselage said.

Mwape did not return calls or emails for comment.

Phil Allen and Steve Olson, two…

View Cache

Father Louis Gigante is the brother of late mobster Vincent Gigante aka ‘The Chin’, who was the head of the Genovese crime family

Retired priest Louis Gigante, who is best recognized as the brother of late mobster Vincent Gigante of the Genovese crime family, has now been accused of sexual abuse of a minor boy. A lawsuit was filed in May 2021 against Father Gigante, on the allegation that he molested a nine-year-old boy at St. Athanasius Church in 1976-77. The retired priest reportedly subjected the unnamed victim to “endure prolific and profound abuse” during bible study sessions. 

According to the court documents, “[The] plaintiff would attend bible study at the church with Father Gigante and (he) would find ways to get plaintiff alone … and repeatedly performed oral sex on him.” The suit further alleges that Gigante’s Bronx parish as well as the Archdiocese of…

View Cache

Priest abuse has been a steady and disturbing pattern across the U.S. for decades. Currently, cases are pouring in, and the list of clergy credibly accused of abuse continues to grow in New York state. Four dioceses in New York have filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, prompting claims deadlines. The dates for Syracuse and Rochester have already passed, but it’s not too late for some.

Due to bankruptcy filings, the Diocese of Buffalo and Diocese of Rockville Centre have a deadline for clergy abuse claims of August 14, 2021. This date coincides with the extended look-back window date in the Child Victims Act (CVA), which has led to an even greater influx of clergy abuse lawsuits. Since the New York CVA was enacted, thousands of child sex abuse cases by clergy have been reported by survivors who were previously unable to make claims due to their age and when the abuse occurred.

…

View Cache

Two sisters abused by the same priest have said it was “heartbreaking” to discover the other had gone through the same thing.

Former priest Con Cunningham pleaded guilty to eight counts of indecent assaults between 1971 and 1975.

Now 86, he abused sisters Paula and Margaret Martin, who were between nine and 12, and 11 and 13 years old when it happened. 

The abuse took place at a number of locations in Donegal, including at the girls’ home, at the parochial house in Fanavolty in Fanad and also at the Loreto College buildings in Letterkenny.

Speaking publicly for the first time today, Paula said they waived their right to anonymity after staying silent during her childhood “brought much pain.”

She said: “All through my teenage years and my twenties I put huge energy into hiding this part of me because I was so ashamed.

“During this process, the legal process, and…

View Cache

A new civil sex-abuse lawsuit has been filed against former cardinal Theodore McCarrick, also naming Opus Dei priest Father Michael Barrett, who is currently a pastor in the Archdiocese of New York.

Jeffrey Anderson, a prominent attorney who represents sex-abuse victims, announced the allegations against Father Barrett and McCarrick on Wednesday in a news conference that was broadcast online.

“My youth, my childhood was robbed from me,” said the plaintiff, who filed the lawsuit anonymously, in the case during the online press conference. He said he was “abused by two people involved in the Catholic Church, and this is Father Michael Barrett and Cardinal McCarrick, who wasn’t a cardinal then, and he should have never become one.”

According to Anderson, the plaintiff was abused by Father Barrett beginning at age 12, and the abuse continued for “three to four years.”

Neither the Archdiocese of New York nor Opus Dei immediately…

View Cache

A former Catholic school music teacher in Jackson will serve more than a decade in prison as the fourth person convicted in the Michigan attorney general’s ongoing clergy abuse investigation.

Joseph Comperchio, 67, of Fort Myers, Florida, was charged last September for sexually abusing two children. In those cases, he faced two counts of first-degree criminal sexual conduct and four counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct.

Then in October, five new counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct involving two new individuals were added.

In June, Comperchio pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct and one count of first-degree criminal sexual conduct.

The charges stemmed from Comperchio’s time as the drama and music teacher at St. John Catholic School in Jackson in the 1970s.

Jackson County Circuit Court Judge Susan. B. Jordan sentenced Comperchio on Wednesday to 12 to 30 years in prison. He must also register as a…

View Cache

[Via National Catholic Reporter]

Msgr. Robert T. Richie, rector of St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City, told cathedral parishioners in an Aug. 3 letter he has been named in a civil lawsuit alleging he “sexually abused a child on one occasion” nearly 50 years ago.

“I completely and without reservation deny this allegation,” he wrote. “Nothing like this has ever occurred during my 50 years as a priest, or at any other time in my life. I am confident that once this matter is litigated in court, the allegation will be found to be absolutely false.”

The suit was filed under New York state’s Child Victims Act, which went into effect in 2020. Gov. Andrew Cuomo recently signed into law a bill to extended the deadline for filing suits under the law to Aug. 14. The law lifted the statute of limitations on abuse cases to allow victims to file claims…

View Cache

It is with sadness that we inform you that an allegation of sexual abuse of a minor has been made against Father Paul Butler, Parochial Vicar at St. Margaret of Scotland Church in Selden, in a recently filed Child Victims Act lawsuit. The alleged abuse is reported to have occurred in the 1980s, when Fr. Butler was a seminarian.

The Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People establishes specific guidelines when an allegation is made against a clergy member. An investigation is begun when an accusation is made. In accordance with the processes and procedures outlined in the Diocesan Child Protection Policy, the matter has been reported to the civil authorities. Father Butler has voluntarily stepped away from ministry and will not present himself as a priest while the required processes and procedures are undertaken.

The Office for the Protection of Children and Young People of the Diocese…

View Cache

Two lawsuits have been filed under a new Louisiana law that gives child abuse victims a chance to file suits for old claims.

The bill took effect Sunday, and allows victims of sex abuse to file suits against anyone involved for the next three years. If someone was convicted in connection with the abuse, there is no limit on filing suits. Previous law allowed people to file suit for ten years after their 18th birthday.

According to a release, the Lamothe firm has filed two lawsuits under the new law this week; the firm believes these are among the first filed in Louisiana under the new law.

“Given that most survivors do not come forward until much later in life, usually in their 50s, this law provides a much-needed path to justice,” said Frank E. Lamothe, III, who has spent his career representing sexual…

View Cache

A priest accused of sexually abusing a child had historic links to two Wellington Anglican schools, with parents at one – Chilton Saint James in Lower Hutt – informed of the links on Monday.

During her testimony to the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care two weeks ago, Joanna Oldham accused Reverend Ray Oppenheim of sexually abusing her when she was a young girl. She said that, when she was nine years old, Oppenheim molested her and took indecent photos of her three times before an uncle found out and put a stop to it.

Anglican bishop Justin Duckworth on Monday said those allegations were the first he had heard about Oppenheim, who died in 2001.

Oppenheim worked at St Mark’s Parish in Wellington from 1987 to 1990, which has since closed. That school had close links to St Mark’s School beside the Basin Reserve.

He then worked at…

View Cache

[With a video report.]

The new account of a state trooper bolsters a meticulous new report on Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s misdeeds — and how his inner circle allowed such conduct to fester.

The governor placed his finger on the back of the trooper’s neck, standing behind her in an elevator at his Manhattan office, tracing the path of her spine with a two-word narration: “Hey, you.”

Sometimes, he asked questions — Why didn’t she wear a dress? Why pursue marriage when “your sex drive goes down” afterward? Could he kiss her? — and sometimes, he made statements: He remarked that his ideal girlfriend could “handle pain.” He said that the trooper, in her late 20s, was “too old” for him. He directed her to say nothing of their conversations.

The trooper was perhaps most unsettled after an event on Long Island in 2019. As she held a door open…

View Cache

[Includes eight-minute video interview with Mitchell Garabedian]

Defrocked ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick last week became the highest-ranking Catholic church official to be criminally charged for sexual abuse, for assault and battery on a 16-year-old boy in Wellesley in the 1970s. Meanwhile, in unrelated cases, the archdiocese of Boston settled six lawsuits last week with former leaders accused of assaults across the state ranging from 1966 to 1990. Jim Braude was joined on Greater Boston by attorney Mitchell Garabedian, who has represented hundreds of victims of church abuse to talk about the church’s longstanding problem with sexual abuse in its ranks.

Garabedian said the McCarrick case could represent “a new era” for going after powerful leaders in the church, as more victims keep coming forward.

“He wanted to take the weight off his shoulders — the emotional weight that many victims have and carry through their lives after being sexually abused as children,” Garabedian…

View Cache

Two months after one of its priests admitted in court to pocketing $516,000 in parish funds, a New Jersey Catholic diocese is introducing a multi-step system that will allow people to anonymously report financial misconduct in their parishes.

The Diocese of Metuchen — which includes churches in Middlesex, Somerset, Hunterdon and Warren counties — is partnering with an ethics consulting company to set up a telephone and online system to gather reports of ethics violations in its parishes, schools and cemeteries, church officials said.

The diocese already has systems in place for people to confidentially report allegations of clergy sexual abuse, but it has become clear parishes also needs a way for people to report theft, fraud and other financial problems, said Anthony P. Kearns 3rd, chancellor of the Diocese of Metuchen.

“Day after day in the news, we are reminded…

View Cache

[Includes eight-minute audio interview.]

Next month, a former Catholic Cardinal will face criminal charges in Massachusetts for alleged sexual molestation.

Theodore McCarrick is the highest ranking member of the U.S. Catholic clergy to be criminally charged with sex abuse. The charges stem from an alleged incident involving a teenage boy that happened more than 45 years ago.

Many of the sex abuse cases involving boys and young men are not reported until the victims are adults, and in the past many such reports have been disbelieved.

Allen Ruyle is a psychotherapist in San Diego who works with male survivors of sexual abuse.

He joined Midday Edition on Monday to talk about why it sometimes takes male sex abuse victims many years to come forward.

View Cache

The priesthood of the Catholic Church has always lived with the trappings of a kind of mystique, perhaps because of the celibacy. When the sexual abuse crisis in the church arose, that mystique was tarnished or even eroded. Parishioners no longer put priests on pedestals, and there may be something very good in that. I keep reminding myself that we’ve been called to walk with the people rather than to lead from on high. The result has become remembering why it was that I became a priest.

Most priests I know do not see themselves as holy, not in the way most people think of being holy, and surely not any more holy than the people they see each Sunday. All too often, it seems to most priests that we are far less holy than many of those folks in the pews.

Because parishioners see priests doing holy things and…

View Cache