It’s a question I’ve fielded my whole adult life. “How can you remain part of a religion when you disagree with so much of it?” my secular friends ask. “How can you stay in an institution that doesn’t let women participate fully? A church that has covered for child abusers?”
I usually come back to the same answer: I love Jesus and want to follow him, and the best way for me to do so is to remain in the church that raised me, flawed as it is. In Struck Down, Not Destroyed, America’s Vatican correspondent Colleen Dulle offers a powerful testament to her own commitment to the church—a commitment where scrutiny and critique go hand in hand with reverence.
“It’s impossible to be a Catholic these days without experiencing some cognitive dissonance,” Dulle states. Recalling the Genesis story of Jacob wrestling with God, she goes on: “We wrestle with the teachings…
View Cache